“Please God. Please make it stop.”

I have been forced to leave Cairo prematurely following a horrific sexual and physical attack in Tahrir Square.

The atmosphere was one of jubilation, excitement, and happiness as I walked, accompanied by two male companions for safety along Kasr El Nil bridge. I had had an awful day, caused by problems in personal relationships, so I was so happy to be in such a wonderful environment, getting such amazing footage. Women, children and fathers smiled, waved, and cheered happily at the camera, calling out the widely used phrase “welcome to Egypt! Welcome!”. Fireworks lit up the sky. It was a moving and captivating experience.

Just as I realised I had reached the end of the bridge, I noticed the crowd became thicker, and decided immediately to turn around to avoid Tahrir Square. My friends and I tried to leave. I tried to put my camera back in my rucksack.

But in a split second, everything changed. Men had been groping me for a while, but suddenly, something shifted. I found myself being dragged from my male friend, groped all over, with increasing force and aggression. I screamed. I could see what was happening and I saw that I was powerless to stop it. I couldn’t believe I had got into this situation.

My friend did everything he could to hold onto me. But hundreds of men were dragging me away, kicking and screaming. I was pushed onto a small platform as the crowd surged, where I was hunched over, determined to protect my camera. But it was no use. My camera was snatched from my grasp. My rucksack was torn from my back – it was so crowded that I didn’t even feel it. The mob stumbled off the platform – I twisted my ankle.

Men began to rip off my clothes. I was stripped naked. Their insatiable appetite to hurt me heightened. These men, hundreds of them, had turned from humans to animals.

Hundreds of men pulled my limbs apart and threw me around. They were scratching and clenching my breasts and forcing their fingers inside me in every possible way. So many men. All I could see was leering faces, more and more faces sneering and jeering as I was tossed around like fresh meat among starving lions.

I shouted “salam! Salam! Allah! Allah!”. In my desperate state I also shouted “ma’is salaama!” which actually means “goodbye” – just about the worst possible thing to say to a horde of men trying to ruin me. I might as well have yelled “goodbye cruel world! Down I go!”

A small minority of men, just a couple at first, tried to protect me and guide me to a tent. The tent was crushed, its contents scattered into shards all over the ground. I was barefoot as they stole my nice new shoes. I was tossed around once more, being violated every second. I was dragged naked across the dirty ground. Men pulled my blonde hair.

The men trying to protect me tried to guide me into another tent. I was able to scramble onto the ground.I sat with my back against a chair and surveyed the surging mob. Although a few men tried to form a human shield around me, offering me rags to cover my bruised body, men were still able to touch me. There were just too many.

I felt surprisingly calm. I understood what was happening and just transcended into a detached state of mind. I gazed around at the bared teeth and raging eyes. The tent began to collapse and I was cloaked in a huge sheet. I was struggling to breathe. One man lifted a tent pole and attempted to strike me with it.

At this point, I said aloud to myself, calmly, over and over, “please God. Please make it stop. Please God. Please make it stop.”

I’m not religious. But at times of desperation, we all feel compelled to appeal to some higher power to save us. It’s human nature. The need to feel safe and loved is what compels many to reach for religion in the first place.

An ambulance forced its way through the crowd. It opened its doors, and was invaded by tens of men. It closed up and drove away.

I began to think, “maybe this is just it. Maybe this is how I go, how I die. I’ve had a good life. Whether I live or die, this will all be over soon. Maybe this is my punishment for some of the emotional pain I’ve caused others through some foolish mistakes and poor judgement recently. I hope it’s quick. I hope I die before they rape me.”

I looked up and saw a couple of women in burkas scattered around. They looked at me blankly, then looked away.

After 5-10 minutes, my friend managed to convince people inside a medical tent to form a pathway through the crowd to guide me into the tent. During transit I was mauled and invaded.

I reached the tent and saw my friend Callum. Muslim women surrounded me and frantically tried to cover my naked body. I fell to the ground and apparently temporarily lost consciousness.

The women told me the attack was motivated by rumours spread by trouble-making thugs that I was a foreign spy, following a national advertising campaign warning of the dangers of foreigners. But if that was the cause, it was only really used as a pretext, an excuse.

The men outside remained thirsty for blood; their prey had been cruelly snatched from their grasp. They peered in, so I had to duck down and hide. They attempted to attack the tent, and those inside began making a barricade out of chairs. They wanted my blood.

Women were crying and telling me “this is not Egypt! This is not Islam! Please, please do not think this is what Egypt is!” I reassured her that I knew that was the case, that I loved Egypt and its culture and people, and the innate peacefulness of moderate Islam. She appeared stunned. But I’m not really a vengeful person and I could see through the situation. This vicious act was not representative of the place I had come to know and love.

After much heated debate, it was decided that Callum and I would leave separately to avoid attracting attention. I was disguised in a burka and men’s clothes and ordered to hold the hand of an Egyptian stranger who would pretend to be my husband. I was terrified but I could see it was the only way out, and had to decide to trust him.

He pulled me through the crowds out of the back of the tent. He told me: “don’t cry. Do not cry. Look normal.”

I was barefoot, dodging broken glass and debris, trawling through mud and dirt. My inner reserves of strength kicked in, and I stopped crying and just thought “keep calm and carry on.”

My trousers had clearly belonged to someone much fatter, and were falling down.

I thought I was being led to an ambulance, or to hospital. The man sat me down by the side of the road, still ordering me not to cry. Eventually, his friends turned up, with Callum. They explained that they couldn’t take us to hospital since they might be arrested if they were seen with us.

One man helpfully suggested: “you want to go to McDonalds? Get some food?” I declined this generous offer of culinary compensation for the evening’s events. Surprisingly, I wasn’t really in the mood for a Big Mac.

Callum and I went on our way. We eventually hailed a taxi. Upon reaching a government hospital downtown, we tried to explain the situation. People stared at us blankly, sloping around the corridors. We were turned away and told to go to a nearby hospital instead. Nobody would take us; we just had to walk there.

Upon arrival, I was eventually ushered into a small cubicle. Two men asked “are you pregnant? Married? A virgin?” They seemed displeased by my response of “no”.

They led me back outside to sit with Callum. I was refused examination and treatment. Eventually I decided I’d just have to check for damage myself. I went to the bathroom and couldn’t believe the reflection. I was dirty, wounded, with hair like a tramp and eyes wide with shock.

For 2-3 hours, people strolled past us, a couple of them making vague attempts at phonecalls to the embassy. At every stage, Callum did everything in his power to speed up the process and talk sense into everyone. It was thanks to him that the people in the medical tent saved me. He effectively saved my life.

Somehow, we ended up with the embassy thinking we were at the police station, the hospital staff not realising we were still at the hospital, and the police thinking we were…god knows where.

I was sat in a room full of men. One of them seemed to be taking a photo of me. I’m not sure why, as I wasn’t exactly looking glamorous. It all made my heart race.

It was Callum’s phonecalls (he had to use other people’s phones as both of ours had been stolen) that bore fruit. Finally our friends turned up with a lady from the embassy. I was taken to a private hospital where a doctor’s first question was “are you married?”, which is of course the most important question to be asking a victim of mass sexual abuse.

He and a female nurse (who only reluctantly kept me covered up) looked briefly at the damage and just wandered off, saying that because I didn’t have internal bleeding, they couldn’t do anything. A useful trip, that was.

Finally, I was taken home by my friends, and put to bed. I didn’t want to tell my family right away, as I knew it would destroy them.

Yesterday, I had a proper examination and darted around sorting things out, spending an eternity giving a police report. People with me were reduced to tears, but I didn’t real feel like crying. People kept telling me “you’re being so brave”, but I just felt like getting on with it. Maybe it’ll catch up with me in a few days, I don’t know.

A few things yesterday made me realise the impact this has had on me. During the examination, which was carried out by a woman, I was crying and shaking. To have someone touch me so soon after the event was terrifying.

Later, I couldn’t bear to be around groups of Egyptian men. And when it got dark, I panicked, and couldn’t bear to look any man in the eye. I clung to Callum all day. As we drove around Cairo, I couldn’t help but think “of all the people we’ve driven past today, one of them must have been in that crowd of hundreds last night. Just one.”

I am determined to continue with my documentary at some point. I have no equipment, (not even any of my photos) am nervous about the possibility of not getting my insurance to cover all the equipment and everything taken from me, and no money to resume the process. But I’ll get there. I have to find a silver lining to this experience. I have to spread awareness; it is my duty to do so. I have to do this; I will not be driven into submission. I will overcome this and come back stronger and wiser. My documentary will be fuelled by my passion to help make people aware of just how serious this issue is, and that it’s not just a passing news story that briefly gets people’s attention then is forgotten. This is a consistent trend and it has to stop. Arab women, western women – there are so many sufferers.

I am determined to return to this wonderful country and city that I love, and meet its people once again. I am determined to challenge the stereotypes and preconceptions that people have of Arab women back in the UK and the US. I have so much to say, and I will say it, in time.

So, to anyone taking risks, whether in the UK or worldwide, please, take care, and don’t make the same mistakes. Don’t be swept up in a wave of euphoria. Don’t let anything cloud your judgement. I was not focused enough because I was distracted by the wonderful atmosphere which was cheering me up after a difficult day.

But don’t let yourself become a victim. Don’t let bad experiences ruin your life and determine your future. One of the worst things two nights ago was that I had never felt so powerless. I had no control and I was violated. But now I can take control and rebuild my confidence, and learn from my experience.

Nothing, and nobody, will hold me back. When I’m ready, I’ll finish this. The show must go on.

Thank you very much for reading.

2,436 thoughts on ““Please God. Please make it stop.”

  1. Pingback: Today’s Bookmarks « xris.net.nz

  2. It’s been eight years since all this happened,have you been back to Egypt? How is your relationship with Egyptian men now?
    Do the events of Tahrir Square still haunt you?

  3. Please let me know if you’re looking for a author for your site.
    You have some really great articles and I feel I would be a good asset.
    If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d love
    to write some articles for your blog in exchange for
    a link back to mine. Please shoot me an email if interested.
    Regards!

  4. If these men genuinely believed you to be foreign enemies they would feel justified in punishing you. I feel the sexual assault to be going too far, but the beating was perhaps justified in most local people’s eyes because Western women behave badly at home and try and do the same when they come to Egypt.
    They dress provocatively, have filthy tongues and drink themselves unconscious.

  5. Pingback: North Africa Exports Rape Culture to Germany – Word Wide News

  6. Pingback: Om att “män förklarar saker för mig”… | reflektioner och speglingar - Alice Miller II...

  7. Pingback: Taharrush or group rape of European women by Muslim refugees shocks Continent | Kimberlydvorak's Blog

    • This is totally untrue. Western women come to Egypt and dress and behave like the sluts they are. They have filthy mouths and skimpy clothes
      and they wonder why they Egyptian men look
      on them with disgust. If I saw a Western woman
      being beaten by group of men I would help them
      to beat this one. Western woman have many sex
      affairs from their teenage years. The men have a duty to punish so our own girls do not follow
      the way of the White sluts.

      • You are disgusting, no one has the right to touch another, whatever you think of them. It’s ludicrous to think all white woman are sluts who sleep around? Are all Muslims terrorists? Of course not. Seriously, grow up, do some research on the damage sexual assaults cause, hint promiscuity can sometimes be the consequence.

      • To Kate
        You are totally delusional. White women are disgusting in their dress and speech. They behave like pigs and are proud of their behavior. I have seen them staggering along the street, falling down, vomiting and displaying their bodies to everyone.
        They should be permanently excluded from Egypt, after receiving a public flogging. White women experience sex from their mid teens.
        They have the morals of alley cats.
        They have no concept of honor

  8. Pingback: What does Morsi’s presidency mean for Egyptian women? | altM

  9. Pingback: El infierno de ser mujer en Egipto | Verdades que ofenden..

  10. Pingback: Too much information - Papierkorb - Lesezeichen

  11. India and middle eastern men are disgusting. I met an Indian man who is a Hindu who already had a girlfriend in America. I am in Germany. His name is “Anmol Chandon” or “Nikka Anmol”. He cheats lies and is a lying piece of shite. He took photos of our visit to show his friends and used me. He uses online dating sites to find women all over the world and con them. He uses them to stay with or have sex usually until they see him in person……. He is disgusting with bad hygiene and clogged pores all over, very short, and dirty. He is doesn’t deserve any woman and all need to beware. He preys on innocent white women, filipinos, and anything with fair skin…. spreading herpes and worse. He is a coward and swine.

    • These kind of men should be castrated for what they did just like any man who abuses women and rapes them. If men continue to treat women this way or the way they do, no woman will want to mix with them, let alone marry them and more and more women are staying clear of men for all good reasons : health (hiv and other diseases), exploitation (at home at the work place), unequal pay and career promotions. I too have had horrible experience with men and there is one thing that is sure, i wil never date a muslim but even more i do not want to have anything to do with men or sexist religions like islam or any other religion that gives men all rights, powers and privileges.

      We have all had it with the way men treat women and it is even worse when in the name of religions or their maleness, they do the kind of things they did to you or to me or to anyone including my sister whom these b..; ards killed ….

      It is about time women of the world demonstrate in the street and organise themselves to put an end to this and many other things they suffer because of men.

      Women are going to rebel loudly or silently but we will put an end to this kind of horrors one way or another

    • Way to stereotype!
      All white men are kkk
      All african men are thugs

      Stereotyping, racism, and most of all ignorance.

    • “India and middle eastern men are disgusting.”

      The only scums in this world are you racist, stereotyping white bastards. From your comment – it is not clear what he does to ‘force’ women in any way. Does he blackmail them? Does he use physical force (because that would be rape)?

      All you say is – he uses dating sites to find women – like that’s a crime (of course he is a brown man – how dare he use dating sites to find women of the ‘superior’ white race.

      I could show you a million examples of WHITE MEN who ar perverts who prey on women and use them. Who are child molesters. Who groom young girls. Who misuse their privilege and power to get force sex. Of white men who con. Of white men who are disgusting scums. And yet you would never use the same words for the entire race like that. Why?

      You say the following – again to stereotype indians: “He is disgusting with bad hygiene and clogged pores all over, very short, and dirty. He is doesn’t deserve any woman and all need to beware. ”

      There’s no worse human scum than the white race.

  12. Pingback: Natasha Smith: Is This Egypt? | Fair Observer

  13. Pingback: Letter from the Editor-in-Chief | Fair Observer

  14. Pingback: Egypte : les viols et agressions de femmes se multiplient place Tahrir | Actualité des Comores

  15. Pingback: El infierno de ser mujer en Egipto | Dossier33

  16. Pingback: Ce qu'on ne vous dit pas sur l'Egypte - voyagecast

  17. Pingback: Abusos sexuales, la cara más siniestra de la Plaza Tahrir. | La República del Shawarma (en Español).

  18. I do not drop a lot of responses, however I browsed a ton of remarks here Please God.

    Please make it stop. | Natasha Smith. I do have a couple of questions for you if it’s okay. Is it only me or does it seem like a few of the remarks come across like they are coming from brain dead people? 😛 And, if you are writing on other sites, I would like to follow everything new you have to post. Could you make a list of all of your shared sites like your linkedin profile, Facebook page or twitter feed?

  19. Pingback: La cara més sinistra de la Plaça Tahrir. | La República del Shawarma.

  20. Pingback: Yasmine y el Acoso Sexual en Egipto | Mariposas en la Tormenta

  21. Pingback: “With a Smile on His Face”: New Account of Sexual Assault in Tahrir Square | Wronging Rights

  22. Total shock over here. Hope you’re getting better real soon.
    If you ask me, you should open up an account so we can collect money for you to buy new equipment for you documentary, in case the insurance isn’t working. You’ll receive the first payment from me!

  23. Pingback: Too much information - Papierkorb - Lesezeichen

  24. Pingback: Martha Colmenares | El infierno de ser mujer en Egipto

  25. I just don’t understand the minds of these people, and I’m not just talking about the Egyptians, but also the people behind these comments. Why is it that no one seems to be able to do the simple thing and sympathize, and support. She posted this to share her story and to spread awareness, not to have it spiraled into a debate or be criticized. And all of these ignorant off-topic comments! If you feel as though you shouldn’t write it then use common sense and DON’T! It’s totally inappropriate. I’m sure many of you have opinions and yeah the assault of women in Egypt IS the topic, but this is not the place to debate; just support.

    And I thank the women and men who have actually shown their support. Natasha, I hope that this horrific experience hasn’t changed you for the worse. I hope that you found the strength to persevere, move forward, and make a difference.

    p.s. As my nerdy side demands it, “Live long and Prosper”.

    • Right on …. I know how bad men are in many places and in other places worse than others and sometimes the women trap other unsuspecting women to have a relationship with these guys who abuse them, cheat on them and rip them off. I was such a girl and i have been harassed and still am for complaining out loud and denouncing what they schemed…. harassed and labeled… So i know the feelings… I think women should create association with lawyers and shelters and support group to help women who have been victimised by similar men but do not know where to get support.

      I also think that in the contect of the HIV pendemic and other STD’s, laws should be passed so that honesty and sexual safety should be compulsory in any marriage or other relationship and that abuse and rape should be far more criminalised and punished (including financial compensation to deter people from repeating the offense) than they actually are.

      I have had bad things happened to me and some from my own family or colleagues which may have been related to my family any way. It is time we create association to protect women and save their lives …. and get support especially for those who do not know where to turned to for help and whose culture allow men all the abuse sexual and otherwise they can do, making the women responsible in every case for what they go through when in many cases it is men ‘s fault.

      This should be a primary concern in this world and for future generations so that women can live safe, happy life and are no longer afraid to have relationships or to marry and are safe from all harm including but not limited to abuse, contamination by hiv or other std’s, finanacial poverty, lack of support from peers … Let’s all unite to make it happen everywhere in the world and let’s put an end to the abuse and double standard, polygamy and other treasons condoned by religions that are ruled and run by men with a view not to protecting women as they should but allowing men to continue their sexual predating and other abuse as they have since the beginning of time.

      Women need to be informed and protected from such threats and abuse and help when they have to sue somehow for the damage they suffer as a result. They have to be informed of their rights and obligations but we must build a world where women are safer from all abuse and dangers for their life, their health and their financial survival as well as those of their children or other family they cherish.

  26. Pingback: Not Again « selfBESIDE

  27. natasha, wanted to tell you how many girls are with you. I would like you to know that we will not leave it blank, we will go to all people and we critar possible for all companions who are following heavy fighting in Egypt. hope you can understand the translation

  28. Pingback: Mulheres sofrem com estupros na Praça Tahrir dois anos após revolução egípcia | Mundo Como Ideia

  29. Pingback: The Daily Beast – Wenn die Bestie entfesselt wird | diesiebtesichel

  30. Pingback: Egitto. In piazza contro la violenza sulle donne | Wild Italy

  31. Pingback: The True Nature of the “Arab Spring.” | Citizen Times

  32. Pingback: Israël et les dessous du moyen Orient

  33. Pingback: Sexual Harassment and Rape in Morsi’s Egypt | Missing Peace | missingpeace.eu | EN

  34. You’re brave to post this but it’s important to expose it to the light.
    I’m afraid this horror has been a common experience recently for Egyptian women, and not unheard of in the past before Mubarak’s fall. Islam takes root from the ancient fertility cults of the Middle East. http://www.strateias.org/niqab.htm

  35. Pingback: The ‘Epidemic’ of Sexual Harassment—and Rape—in Morsi’s Egypt | Raymond Ibrahim

  36. Pingback: ‘Ik blijf weg van Tahrir’ – vrouwelijke journalisten voorzichtiger door seksueel geweld | De Buitenlandredactie

  37. Pingback: The ‘Epidemic’ of Sexual Harassment—and Rape—in Morsi’s Egypt » Choosing Life - God's Gift To The Unborn

  38. Pingback: Sexual assault during protests at the Tahrirplein | Women of the world

  39. You are alive Congratulations Multiculturality is exactly this give occidental women to then for free as objects exactly like objects Probably nobody wish understand cause probaly must be a deep part of masculin people , even in occident prefer rape a women instead conquer her in an apropiate an occidental way Occidental way is hard for man Muslin way, is harder for women bat easy for men Sharia admit 4 women for each man So them thy work jus to pruchase four poor women-slaves for his own use Each of the 4 had as mani child as Allath wish For big families for one single man!! wath man in earth can mantaein such a bunch os children? Nobody The results —criminal a society with no education and in some cases even starving The Sharia , the loo of Coran destroy the contries where had been impossed by slaverin the women Such way its just the working of arab imperialism
    Just now we all are in the way to be muslim
    As said: You are alive Congratulations

  40. Pingback: L’Egitto tra violenza e diritti. All’ombra di piazza Tahrir. « Lo ZibalDonne

  41. Hey Natasha
    Thanx for sharing your experience something that must be difficult to do. Lets hope the bastards who where involved suffer some serious guilt when they realise what they did. Lets hope too (even less likely) that sexual abuse, sexism and patriarchy in all forms eventually dies out across the world but it would seem from many of the posts here that religious fanaticism of all varieties will help keep such backward behaviour alive for some time to come. In the meantime I hope you can continue your work and life and enjoy it, stronger for being a survivor, a crass cliche it may be given your extreme experience, but try not to let the bastards grind you down.

    p.s I rather scarily came across your blog link whilst researching a very nasty nazi website!

  42. Pingback: I’m so disgusted’: How Egypt’s protesters are fighting sexual assaults | egyptnewswire.org

  43. Pingback: I'm so disgusted': How Egypt's protesters are fighting sexual assaults Pakistan wiki Pages — Non-Stop Information Blogging epage.pk Pakistan wiki pages

  44. Pingback: ‘I’m so disgusted’: How Egypt’s protesters are fighting sexual assaults

  45. wow…. so much attack against religion here…and blame shifting too…
    The important thing we would all have to know is that no one makes the perfect mark in morality, Honestly!!! The only reason why I am a christian is because I know God forgives me when i sin and ask him for forgiveness. And He helps me to live upright too. Its amazing! Even inexplicable sometimes! I have peace. I have freedom in Christ too and I recommend same for you.
    This whole world will phase out. Christ WILL come again to take his own unto himself and destroy those who reject Him (being a God who hates sin). I know i can’t possibly make the mark on my own account so I’ve surrendered all unto him. Its simple.

    Just say:
    Dear Jesus, I thank you for life and more especially for eternal life. Pls forgive me of my sins and wash me with your precious blood. Pls come and become the lord of my life so i can be wih you eternally. In Jesus’ name, Amen!

    That’s it. You’ve made it!!! There is rejoicing in Heaven because of you!! Wow…
    Now, you will have to contact any Bible-believing church and introduce yourself to the pastor so he teaches you more. You’ll also need a Bible so you can understand what you’ve just done. I recommend you start reading from the book of Romans and the gospels. There is so much more in store for you!!! I’m excited for you!!! love you bunches
    To skeptics who think life end when you die or that your living a ‘good life’ will send you to Heaven, it isn’t true! No Jesus. No eternal life. Think it through and please reconsider…

    • Yes, as an ex Christian I can confirm this message
      The ever merciful and peace loving god will throw you into the pits of hell if you don’t sign up and become a Christian. yes this peace loving religion who’s practitioners conquered over half the globe and all (apart from Ethiopia) of Africa is a brilliant and worthy religion. The bible which was written 50 years after the death of Christ and revised hundreds of times since is the true and accurate word of god and best of all this holy church now denies half of what’s written in its holly scriptures (all that making the world in 7 days thing)

      • hi Thomas. i cant really slash back because I’m not too good at arguing. But the truth is that although God is a fierce judge who wouldn’t go against his very essence- HOLINESS, he gives an escape route for those willing to accept it and that is accepting Jesus. I don’t think i should be such a big deal saying a little prayer which will secure your life after death. Even logically, its totally worth the risk seeing that there’s absolutely NOTHING TO LOOSE!!! Remember neither i nor you has died before. 🙂 but i have taken an insurance policy covering that already.Pls rethink your withdrawal, Tom.
        The universe has not always existed. It had a start…what caused that? Scientists have no explanation for the sudden explosion of light and matter.
        How is it that we can identify laws of nature that never change? Why is the universe so orderly, so reliable?
        Even the greatest scientists have been struck by how strange this is. There is no logical necessity for a universe that obeys rules, let alone one that abides by the rules of mathematics. it really doesn’t to behave this way! Especially if it came to being after AN EXPLOSION… There are may religious settings that profess to be ‘christian’ but really aren’t. we need a bible- believing church to know and understand the faith.
        Thanks so much for sharing your view. i appreciate it.
        By the way the Bible WAS NOT written 50 yrs after the death of Christ. You just may be talking about collating and compiling the various books. The miraculous thing about that is: though these scripts may have been found near and far the speak about the very same thing! The bible does not once contradict itself. In some cases the same stories are even repeated. Its Amazing!!! I believe it in its entirety.
        Shalom

  46. wow…. so much attack against religion here…and blame shifting too…
    The important thing we would all have to know is that no one makes the perfect mark in morality, Honestly!!! The only reason why I am a christian is because I know God forgives me when i sin and ask him for forgiveness. And He helps me to live upright too. Its amazing! Even inexplicable sometimes! I have peace. I have freedom in Christ too and I recommend same for you.
    This whole world will phase out. Christ WILL come again to take his own unto himself and destroy those who reject Him (being a God who hates sin). I know i can’t possibly make the mark on my own account so I’ve surrendered all unto him. Its simple.

    Just say:
    Dear Jesus, I thank you for life and more especially for eternal life. Pls forgive me of my sins and wash me with your precious blood. Pls come and become the lord of my life so i can be wih you eternally. In Jesus’ name, Amen!

    That’s it. You’ve made it!!! There is rejoicing in Heaven because of you!! Wow…
    Now, you will have to contact any Bible-believing church and introduce yourself to the pastor so he teaches you more. You’ll also need a Bible so you can understand what you’ve just done. I recommend you start reading from the book of Romans and the gospels. There is so much more in store for you!!! I’m excited for you!!! love you bunches
    To skeptics who think life end when you die or that your living a ‘good life’ will send you to Heaven, it isn’t true! No Jesus. No eternal life. Think it through and reconsider…

    • Oh, what are you doing on this site? Go away and annoy someone less intelligent than yourself who you can probably convince, teach them about the tooth fairy and santa claus at the same time.

      • I’m so tired of you obsessive fucks bashing religion all the time like you getting payed for it. It’s always CHRISTIANITY too, or ISLAM when you’re feeling more radical and the Politically Correct police aren’t looking.

        Secular Atheists obsessed with bashing religion are as bad as Islamists who want to force their Allah down everyone’s throats.

        You both are a cancer. I hope you know this.

  47. Natasha i am a 15 year old boy and when i read this i felt the most sincere hurt about what happened to you i am extremely sorry for what happened to you. im am praying for you OK now i am going to tell you that i am a christian and that all of the Muslims are ridiculous Jesus Christ is the one and only god and he was your savior that day and i praise you that you prayed to him and he saved you from getting killed and i hope you see this comment please respond to me if you go to church because i would love to pray with you and GOD has condemned those men that did that to you and he has rewarded the men that helped you and saved you i believe your story a hundred percent i am fifteen year old that does not use derogatory comments people you say stuff on the internet that you would never say in person so you should all be ashamed of your self’s AMEN in the LORD GOD almighty Jesus Christ GOD i s going to be with you always Natasha love john.N

  48. After being shocked about what happened to you, I now am in shock about some of the comments above.
    People’s abilities in cruelty, denial and stupidity are absolutely mindblowing..

    I wish you all the best with your recovery.
    Stay strong and keep up the good work, you’ll get there.

  49. I am from Egypt i feel ashamed from what these animals have done , I am so sorry about that i hope u don’t think all egyptians are like that , u r strong and u will go on insh’Allah

  50. We live in a society that tells victims to be careful, not to get raped and not rapists to not rape. And you including, why are you blaming yourself and saying you made a mistake, you didn’t. The problem comes from a religion, that is often misinturpreted. I think muslims should not raise their children in muslim religion, because this deprives those children from thruly understanding their own religion. Believing in a particular religion should be conscience choice made in adult age, because only if you choose this religion yourself, without pressure of the society, you will know why you believe in it and then you will never misiterpret it like many people do. And if you think muslim religion is not the cause of what happened to you, then ask yourself has something like that happened in 21 century in a country where islam is not a primary religion.

    • If you want to know the true mind of Islam, you need to learn how to read Arabic (apparently this is the only language their god understands as they all must pray in Arabic regardless of a persons race. The English version has the most important issues wiped out) and then read the two books: the Quran and the Haddis. Only then will you understand why such things happen to women and what they really think of non-muslims:)

  51. Why complain about losing your “expensive shoes” when all these FAR more important things were happening to you? I just don’t understand..

    • It’s a recounting of what was going through her head at the time of an extremely traumatic event – it is perfectly understandable if you have ever been subject to a criminal assault.

      The brave soul is possibly dealing with symptoms of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder or the precursors thereof.

      She was attacked by a raging mob in a strange land, totally violated, in fear of her life – I don’t think it could have got much more traumatic.

      It is a horrific incident but she is incredibly brave for posting this and I admire her tenacity.

  52. Warm Regards to all that has lost there job, lost there lovers, the ones that are battling with examination to pass, you need to win a lotto, you need to do death spell for your enemy, you want to get what your heart desire without working nor doing anything to get it, With the help of Dr Ajayi Ololo, Theses problems are solved.. Cos over here in this great temple that is know world wide as the best and greatest spell caster temple, There is no problem that do not have a solution when you come to this temple OF OLOLO. I will also want all of you to know that there are so many swindlers / scammers that has claim to be spell caster, Just to get money from those that need help. I also come to tell you to beware of these so called temples online that can never help you solve your problem. I Dr Ajayi Ololo will want to tell you all that there iS no spell caster online that can ever be like us, Cos we have helped so many individuals to get all there heart desire online. Anyone that require the help of our services should kindly send an email to the following email address: ajayiololo@yahoo.com .

  53. I just wanted to stop and thank Dr Atingo for his help. You have saved my relationship twice….and all that time I used your spell. I broke up twice last year with my ex……first time we got back together…lasted a short while because I had not followed your instruction completely…second time I used your methods again and he came back. Thank you so much. I was so confused how to act when he came back, but I had to follow your instruction. We are stronger than the first time or the second time……and all because I took your well meaning spell. Thank you so much. I have a life these days, after letting go of all the drama in my life. Thank you so much for your help. contact him with email atingospiritualtemple@live.com if you need is help also.

  54. Dr.upesa, and friends, I wanted to give you an update on my situation. On November 3 20011 I requested a binding love spell be cast on my boyfriend. His eyes roamed to any woman that passed us and it made me feel horrible. I am happy to report that a week after I requested the spell he proposed to me. We have been married for a year now, are expecting our first child in Nov. 20012 and he no longer has eyes for any other woman. I was greatly impressed with the fast results and the personal attention I was shown during the casting and beyond.he is real a good spell caster email dr.upesaspelltemple@yahoo.com

  55. My dear world community friends,
    believe me or not it is a manufactured story to blame Muslims and the Islam. the fact is that the whole is lie and black lie story.

    it is impossible. no human can do it and it is never and not done by any of the Egyptian. last night when 1st i saw and read this in human incident, i was shocked. whole night i remained thinking over this matter and kept asking Allah my Lord Almighty God, how why and who might have done it….

    but early in my morning prayers, it was revealed to me., that it is nothing and no one made or did it,
    it was just a blame like many and thousands of others to let down Muslims and the religion liked for mankind by HIM the Allah, the Almighty God creator of all; of us most merciful gracious and owner of all this our universe and many others more larger than ours. ..

    We all have to go back to HIM standing in rows in front of HIM and HE the supreme of all supper powers will be asking us about our deeds and deals. HE may 4give us for the violation and making negligence to HIS rights upon us, as we the human beings. BUT but not and never , HE will Never 4give for the violations we made to HIS men and women and to HIS creation. HE loves human being, male or female 70 times than a mother may love her child.
    He will ask every one of us for other rights that any one of us might have violated and engulfed/killed. harassed/raped/made sex or other things and sins.

    I request all of you plz be in patience read and study the holy books. all holy books are from Allah the God. but the last one the holy Quraan is the conclusion of all previous books and Holy {Prophet the last prophet Mohammad is the last manageress of Allah to whole of the universe.

    this holy book the Quraan addresses the whole of man kind, whether he/she is in India or China USA or Brazil or in Europe and Australia.
    Be unbiased and study this book with open eyes and brain and even the hearts and ur conscious may be Allah shows the right path to ; lead this short timed/framed of our life in the way HE lies and wants Us to pass and carry before we r changed to another state of our life in its existence next phase. .

    So our life is like a project. it has a specific time frame after which we change our states of existence and join back to our origin the clay. About next phase i will tell u in details.

    thnx
    Dr.Ghayur
    Philosopher and thinker

    • Dr. Ghayur, I am convinced that you have a learning disability! This incident certainly did happen. Most muslims are savage beasts, so this story is entirely believable. Perhaps you would find it more believable if the muslim crowd had raped a camel and then eaten its feces? I’m sure that is a common sight in Egypt!

  56. ms Natasha Smith,
    believe me i rad ur true story. it killed me it killed my inner sight and insight.well at the moment i can’t do any thing for you, but story u narrated shocked me and my conscious.had been i there i wud have bled my last drop of blood to gv u full protection.

    as a Muslim i am ashamed, of cruel act of those people. i pray for u and feel for u. indeed u r great with high level of courage.

    this is we weep on and for.
    our religion does not tell us this what these men like animals do. its wild and wild-ism, i condemn it.
    any how, plz do remember me, i will remember u and will pray My Allah to give u reward for this unhappy day u saw bxas of HIS men.the worst creature.

    May Allah put u under HIS blessings…amin

    Dr Ghayur Ahmad
    islamabad PAKISTAN
    0092-346-5391712

  57. Dear Natasha, may I offer my deepest sympathy to you and apologise on behalf of the many heartless people commenting here who’d rather say “it serves you right” than offer any understanding. You are brave and you are helping to change attitudes. In the future, people with such narrow minds like those we see polluting this thread will be seen as just as moronic as someone who thinks black people should have to sit at the back of the bus. Indeed, I, and many others already see them this way. Thanks to the bravery and determination of those like you, attitudes are changing and patronising heartless idiots will soon no longer be given the time of day by anyone for airing such bile. Good luck in everything you do.

  58. I AM DR. OLORUN ODUDUWA, I GREW UP IN SOUTH AFRICA, I HELP PEOPLE WHO ARE SERIOUSLY IN NEED OF A CHILD TO GET A SON, IT IS DEEPLY UNCONCIOUS BEEN MARRIED AND DON’T HAVE A SON AS A SOLID PROOF TO YOUR HUSBAND THAT YOU ARE A REAL WOMAN, WHAT A DIRTY ROLE, SEEK TODAY FOR A CHILD IN MY POWERFUL TEMPLE AND IT SHALL BE GRANTED TO YOU IMMEDIATELY, I HAVE HELP SO MANY PEOPLE IN THE WHOLE WIDE WORLD TO GET A CHILD IN THEIR WHOM, I CAN HELP YOU BECAUSE I INHERITED THIS POWERFUL SPELL FROM MY FATHER CALLED OLORUN, HE BLESSED ME WITH IT, JUST CONTACT ME NOW AND GET YOUR CHILD SOLUTION SOLVED NOW AT (OLORUNODUDUWASPIRITUALTEMPLE@GMAIL.COM) AND I SHALL STAY FORWARD TO HELP YOU OUT WITH MY POWERS. (OLORUNODUDUWASPIRITUALTEMPLE@GMAIL.COM)

    THANKS

  59. I’m from Iran, Islam was a religion started by a delusional paedophile who heard strange voices in a cave and thought god was talking to him, today that kind of person would be locked up in a mental home.

    What do you expect from such a backwards religion that doesn’t even recognize women as equal to men?

    I mean every offence in my statement, problem? do something.

    • You’re probably not from Iran though are you? You’re just prefixing your comment with something that you think will give it more weight. Having said that, the first part of your comment is about right. But then I think religion as a whole is nonsense, not just Islam.
      The problem I have is your next sentence. “What do you expect?” does not justify a crime. If you get shot in the head walking through an inner city area of a big British or American city on your own at night, people would offer sympathy to your family, not just basically say “It served him right for being so stupid”. That’s because most of us have empathy and understanding. Maybe you’ll suddenly learn what this means one day if something similarly horrific happens to someone in your family, Then you might get over your childish patronising attitude, one in which you value being able to say “You’re stupid for making a mistake, I’m more intelligent than you”.

      Oh and by the way I have lived in a muslim country for 2 years, alongside many other expats and have made friends male and female from here too. I’m sure there is crime like in any other place, but contrary to what your narrow mind would have you believe, in this country at least rape is not common place

      • How can you know that rape is not commonplace when women do not report it and it is not taken seriously by the authorities???You read above how Natasha was treated in hospital and this was a headlining case….How do you think the native women get treated??? They dont is the answer because if a muslim woman tells anyone she has been raped SHE is partly held responsible for aloowing it to happen…..I know this firsthand…Please realise that as a man you will have had a different experience of Islam and Islamic countries than a woman, muslim or foreign….

  60. My name is Allen Spencer I am a Canadian i want to shear my testimony, I was married to my husband for nine years before he left for another woman it was so bad that it affect my job to shorten the story it all ended when I meet with a great spiritualist who prayed for me. In relationships we need a lot of spiritual help he told me my problems and they where all true he prayed for me and after three days my husband who had abandoned me for two years already came to my door with some red rose flower asking me to take him back we talk for some time concerning his new wife, he agreed to leave her after two weeks we renewed our wedding vows and we are happy together if you want to contact the spiritualist you can contact him personally through prophetfatai@gmail.com or his temple for help on prophetfataispiritualtemple@gmail,com. he is a father figure with great powers his temple is a home of solution.

  61. Am STEPHANIE from FLORIDA i want to share my life experience to every body on this site. i was in a serious relationship with mike i love him so much we have dated for almost 6 years now. until he meant another girl called charity he told me that he is know longer interested in dating me any more. i was so confuse i don’t know what to do so i told my friend about what my love just told me and he told me that she can solve my problem i was doubting her how can that be possible so she directed me to a spell caster called DR AFILE .so i contacted him and i explain every thing to him and he told me that my problem will be solved within 2days if i believe i said OK .So he caste_ a spell for me and after 2days my love came back to me begging me on his knees on the ground asking me to forgive him. And I was surprise just like a dream and today Am so happy now. so that why i decided to share my experience with every body incase there is anyone out there that have such problem should contact him via afilewadadaspiritualtemple@yahoo.com

    • ^^And here we have yet another misogynistic, piece of shit, trolling little bitch. No one cares what you think. No one needs any advice from a fucking moron loser like you. STOP BLAMING THE VICTIM. Oh yeah, and your other comment about having the right to be raped and what more rights does she want? How about equal rights and the right to not be raped? What the fuck is wrong with you?

      • how about the equal right to enjoy raping a stupid bitch who willingly to a place where she KNOWS she is going to be groped, assaulted and raped. if she didn’t want to be raped the dopy bitch wouldn’t go there

      • Um, Lee..first, you’re a stupid bitch. Second, rape is not a right, it’s a crime. So no, you don’t have the right to rape. You’re such a piece of shit. How do you live with yourself?

    • What a despicable idiot you are. I live in the largest Muslim country in the world and this never happens. I have been here a year already and although like anywhere I’m sure the society has a few problems, sexual harassment doesn’t seem to be one of them, neither does violence, and that is not me living in a little expat bubble, it’s through mingling and socialising with many locals too. You probably don’t even know which country I am talking about anyway such is your ignorance. Oh, and another thing, if you are so convinced that such horrors only happen in muslim countries, haven’t you noticed all the allegations of sexual assault aimed at the catholic church over the years? Don’t get me wrong, I care not for Islam, or Catholicism for that matter – I am convinced that all religions are based on crazy stories and have no place in any intellectual discussion in the 21st century, but even considering this, I still believe all men and women should be treated equally and with dignity and respect. Whereas you show a shocking lack of empathy that can only come from being burdened with sheer stupidity or a complete lack of a conscience. This woman deserves the support of everyone, as do other victims. They should NEVER be blamed.

  62. WELCOME TO LORD TAMPA TEMPLE

    Am Lord Mubiso Tampa a spiritual and traditional Doctor here in South Africa.I think its time you eradicate poverty,failure,set-back,bad luck,Diseases and all forms of pains out of our life at a glance.

    Do you need spiritual help?
    Do you need Financial Stability,Success in Exams,Progress in business and other affairs,is your marital relation complicated or broken?and you want your Ex back either alone or with the kids,

    Other Solution Areas.
    Enlarging your penis that for the men and for the Females cure of unusual discharge and discouraging fat
    Decrease Of body size to normal
    Spell to bring your lover back,or get the person you are admiring,just contact Lord Tampa Temple Today and you will get the solution to whatever problem you have.

    Contact Lord Tampa Temple today for solutions to all your problems.a word is enough for the wise.

    contact Address:No Cradock Place, 1st Floor, 10 Arnold Road, off Cradock
    South Africa
    Email:lordtampalasolutionhome@yahoo.com

  63. I am really pleased with this service I am one of those people who said I ll never call a psychic or a magician or whatever to help me with my problems least of all my love problems but I reached the point where I knew I needed some guidance and I m so glad I found this website and priest Tom I never in a million years would have thought I’d be writing a letter like this but when I nearly lost Amanda in one of our stupid petty fights (usually started by yours truly) I thought I had lost everything And when I was at my most desperate you didn t take advantage of me You performed a very good service for a person in true need I don t know how you did it or how this magic works but all I know IT WORKS amanda and i will are happily back together and I ll always be grateful for priest Tom kindness sympathy and extension of services to me in a real time of need thank you priesttomspelltemple@gmail.com Sincerely posted by Kelly Best

  64. Regardless of your religion or what you believe, you treat others as you want to be treated. That is just common sense. I have never been more saddened by humanity than I have after not only reading this blog but reading the comments… I don’t want to live on this planet anymore.

    • I agree. I am staggered by the lack of empathy or moral understanding shown by those who feel they have any right to pass judgement on a victim of such an horrific crime. But for what it is worth, for every one of these dreadful idiots, there are many more good people who care, who have changed attitudes and history in some countries with their courage and determination and are fighting to do the same in others now. I believe most people are good and these dicks are in the overwhelming minority. At least I hope so

      • I hope that you are right in that there are more good people than bad. So many people filled with so much hate. I know it sounds corny but I wish that love would truly conquer all.

  65. Natasha, I just stumbled on your page, and after reading about your horrific experience, wanted to convey my sincerest apologies for the fractured and uneducated mindset of the people that ripped you of your dignity that day and made you fear for your life. No one should feel that terror – I felt it through your words. You sound like you have a stable head on your shoulders and a forgiving and understanding heart that can be reassured and uplifted through counselling, which I hope you have sought early so doubt doesn’t set in. I wish you peace and all the best in your life.

  66. Am annette
    For almost all my life I have contacted different psychics, tarot readers, on-line casters,
    etc.! Everyone gave me advice, told me that I needed a spell and guaranteed
    it! I contacted sanctus, he told me what was wrong & then I went to another spell caster
    which of course did not work! Months later with no work, major financial problems & love
    problems I came back to her! I OWE sanctus MY LIFE!! Although I got a job that I thought
    was great.

    I got fired & she told me I was getting a better one! I doubted her
    & within a month a got that FABULOUS JOB!!! My financial affairs are clearly
    up day by day & my love life is a lot better! I think that if I was not so
    stubborn & doubtful EVERYTHING would be working but I need to realize that santus is not
    like other casters! HE IS FOR REAL!! The casters in my past took my money & never heard
    from them again & sanctus answers everyone e-mails, keeps you calm & DOES GIVE
    YOU REAL RESULTS!!! Being patient, confident & letting the energies work are the success
    to his spells. Anyone who deals with him will sooner or later get their wishes come true!
    I will never doubt him or go to anyone else again! Love sanctus!!! P.S. Sorry for being
    so doubtful!a trial will CONVINCE you.
    you can contact him on sanctuspriest@yahoo.com

  67. Sorry to hear about your experience- Regarding the comments above, man’s inhumanity to man is universal, it can be found in every society regardless of color creed or religion- that being said it’s all the more tragic when men use God to justify their inhumanity- God preserve us all from fundamentalists of every stripe!!

  68. CHLOE

    Thank you thank you DR ABULU for what you have just done, for helping
    me getting my husband who left me with two kids april last year to me
    i thank you so much the great ABULU of abuluspiritualtemple@yahoo.com for
    bringing back my family i am great-full and will always be if you also
    need his help his email(abuluspiritualtemple@yahoo.com)

  69. Natasha what happened to you was horrible. Those men who assaulted you are nothing but brainless uneducated self-righteous beasts. You are a brave person, but going back there to prove that it’s just an isolated incident that won’t happen again is just too dangerous. Those men can turn into demons at the drop of a hat (or by merest fraction of a rumor). In Muslim countries there are people that try to spread hate towards westerners (infidels), their targets are the uneducated, low-income population. I know this because I’m living in one of Muslim country. Cairo , they city you’ve come to love is one example. There are many good people there but there also live many unthinking ‘believers’ that assaulted you. Please tread wisely

    • Yes and the west is just just a beautiful utopia where no one ever commits crime or gets hurt! no woman ever gets harassed in the west.Its only the evil boggy man muzzzlums with there book that tells them to rape and kill poor and defenseless innocent white woman! thank god obama sends bombs over there to blow them so they can learn to civilize like us…wait i don’t trust him either he has that black wife and a funny name!

      • albrooklani: you’re dumb guy i ever seen…blaming all muslims for a minority..religion is not responsible for a small group who do this…bible even teach more voilance and Who started the 2nd World War? Muslims?
        Who killed about 20 Million of Aborigines in Australia? Muslims?
        Who sent the Nuclear Bombs to Hiroshima and Nagasaki? Muslims?
        Who killed more than 100 Million Indians in South America? Muslims?
        Who took about 180 Millions of African people as slaves of whom 88% died and were thrown in the Atlantic Ocean? Muslims?
        No, They were not Muslims! First, you have to Define Terrorism properly. If a Non-Muslim does some thing bad, it is a crime. But if a Muslim commits the same Act. He is a Terrorist.
        First remove this double standard, and then come to the point.
        emphasized text Now its must be stop in the name of freedom.Can west allow Muslims to do the same Act on holocaust under the umbrella of freedom?. Otherwise feel slap on double standard of freedom due to this shameful and dangerous act which cause to increase the distance between East and West .

  70. what ever happened to you is unfortunate and i don’t support violence BUT we white people never seem mind our own business. sit down and ask your self was Egypt worth being molested and disgraced for, ask yourself if a foreign country is worth your dignity and life. if the answer is yes then trust me you might get molested again. proper judgment is needed here. if the Egyptians are fighting for their so called freedom how is that your business uh? it’s your feet that carried you close to the mob right? SO WHO DO YOU BLAME?

    • Here’s who you DON’T blame: THE VICTIM. Seriously, you should be ashamed of yourself. Tell men not to rape instead of blaming the victims. Don’t even come on Natasha’s page with this nauseating bullshit.

      • Precisely. I agree. This lopsided, painfully hypocritical mindset of most people in this damned world makes me laugh. AND cry. Rape a woman, grope her, strip her publicly, coz hello, thats how men are. It’s the woman’s fault coz she should know men are animals…. PATHETIC. Gary Goodman, just don’t comment if you haven’t got anything human to say. You don’t need to prove your stupidity by commenting here.

        I wonder how men still call themselves the “superior” race after behaving like jungle-beings. Hmmmm… time to think?

    • Diane Rennie Revert of 11 months
      I am a “WHITE” Scottish woman and I am also Muslima. My choice defines who I am and my choice comes from years of abuse and molestation by “WHITE” relatives both male and female Islam has brought peace and understanding to my life because I have taken some time to learn about what Islam actually means. You speak about proper judgement Are you not brown when you stay in the sun does that make you any less “White” Perhaps the white you should consider is the white of someone’s heart and actions. Men and women alike are equally able to commit evil deeds That does not come down to religion that is a personal choice from each individual to act in that way. Why should this girl trust your opinion when it is clearly uninformed, racist and very clearly give from someone who has little or zero compassion to the human race. Have you ever been to Egypt? Have you walked one mile in the shoes of these people struggling to survive. Think before you open your big mouth again because it is YOU who shows no “PROPER JUDGEMENT” in what you say May Allah bless your soul and forgive your ignorance. Praise to Allah to make sure there were people of the white hearted variety to help her out of a terrifying situation and to give the strength and courage of a Lion to stand tall again

    • your definitely the biggest asshole worldwide 🙂 you could get molested in any place on this earth so don’t talk bullshit

      • I have been forced to leave Cairo prematurely following a horrific sexual and physical attack in Tahrir Square.

        The atmosphere was one of jubilation, excitement, and happiness as I walked, accompanied by two male companions for safety along Kasr El Nil bridge. I had had an awful day, caused by problems in personal relationships, so I was so happy to be in such a wonderful environment, getting such amazing footage.

  71. Pingback: Bericht uit Egypte: Cairo made me do it | De Buitenlandredactie

  72. Dear Natasha, i was reading with tears in my Eyes not only because what these savage animals did to you but also because your good heart. you were trying to avoid any stereotyping about Egypt or Arabs or Muslims while you were hurting more than anyone from their brutality . I respect you and i believe the world needs more people with kind beautiful souls like yours. When i was reading i felt horrified and ashamed of my country and my people but the only thing i could think of is that YOU- the hurt one -are ready to get back to Egypt so I’m not going to be full of hatred and grudges. you are a Role model and whenever i face any tough situation in my life I’ll always remember your fighting soul and good heart. I’m Egyptian by the way

    • The problem is that some stereotypes are true. Some societies have culturally embedded behaviors (from religion, tradition, geography, etc) that are the norm–like a disdain for the privacy, security and liberty of women. The majority of Muslim nations are still acting under an ass-backwards third-world-style conception of women’s rights, and this is EXACTLY what you should expect to see when you go there. Pretending like rape isn’t a real threat is NOT the band-aid that will heal the problems of the religiously and culturally instituted chauvinism that causes rape to be so prevalent. The solution lies in accepting the reality that rape IS a much more markedly real threat in Muslim nations, then attacking the overarching social mechanisms that breed such a culture.

      • Oh hoo-hah! Mob violence is mob violence whether you’re Roman Catholic, Buddhist, Atheist or Moslem. I take off my hat to you Natasha, and wish you success. I too love Egypt. From Charmian, South Africa – the country with the highest rape statistics in the world.

  73. We need to educate the American people to all the crimes that are being committed to women and men in these countries. Your article I stumbled on by accident. We as human beings need to be responsible for each other and shun those who do these crimes, and all crimes against humans. Standing behind God’s name as justification to do whatever you want is sick, and very disturbing. Please have any one of these fools show me a letter from God, saying to violate you. What hateful men, weak stupid imbeciles. as to this crime is a crime against God. How could there be such a God of no forgiveness, compassion, hate. If humans could only use their brains.

  74. I am so sick of this so called religion. the more I learn about Islam the more I think it came from the evil one. The Koran is a joke. Muhammad is a fool and a pedophile,

    .

    • Well then i guess you haven’t read the Quran to the fullest. You have to read the Quran to understand this beautiful religion. Yes there are some so called muslims who do not understand the true meaning of Islam and who have not read the Quran directly, for e.g. if they don’t know how to read so therefore they don’t understand it, and play by their own rules. On the day of judgement they are going to get judged for that. But this is the only religion which makes sense and has so many evidence in the Quran which no other religion has got an answer for. The Quran is a guidance to show humans how to live and to gain knowledge of your creator and the hearafter. now i’m not comparing any religions but just saying that at least read the Quran then tell your self if this does make sense and if this is a beautiful and peaceful religion, just forget about the outer world for a second and your bad thoughts towards the religion. You will feel safe and protected and will not be scared of death as you will know Allah is hear to protect me.
      i seriously do feel sorry for you, not knowing who you are disrespecting, hope you come to know one day, but don’t leave it to late, you will definitely regret everything you said about Islam and Prophet Muhammed PBUH

      just fix up, and don’t make a fool out of your self. please!

    • Hey dave. If there are some idiots doing something it is not wise to blame mohamed allah etc. We cannot blame jesus for everything done by westerners. So leave the gods alone.

      • yawn. Your religion is just as stupid as theirs. Haven’t you heard of science? A woman has been violated in the most horrific manner and has had the courage to write about it. Don’t turn it into an irrelevant debate about which fairytale is the one you should live your life by. Horrific acts sadly happen in all countries and in all religions. The bottom line is, it was wrong, regardless of the religion of the perpetrators. And if you still think this is an Islamic problem, what about the catholic church and small boys?

  75. If islam is such a wrong and hateful religion then why is there so many people converting to islam in this 21st century? & I’ve read the quran and i understand it very well, its the only religion that makes sense and as for the haters? They will always hate because they cant take it that it is such a perfect religion. I’m blessed to be a muslim i wake up thanking allah swt because he has given me another day to worship him and be a better person than I was yesterday. However natasha I am very sorry for what happened to you, but I guess it will get better with time and those peopl who did this to you will most certainly get punished. Peace.

    • If you’ve read the Koran then you know that Mohammed was adamant that all Christians and Jews are also Muslims. Muslim means he who submits or surrenders (to the will of God). Anyone who submits to the will of God, therefore, is by definition a Muslim. All the rituals, which came later, are unimportant. All that matters is that one submits to the Will of God.

      The question, however, remains. What does it mean to submit to the Will of God? Calling oneself a Muslim means nothing if one simply follows rituals but refuses to submit to God’s Will. I see this all the time. Men who insist they are Muslims but are arrogant, cruel and proud. These men have not submitted to the Will of God. They have not even tried to do so. They may call themselves Muslims but that does not mean they are.

      Hypocrites are found in every religion. It is in the nature of all men and women to be deceitful, selfish and dishonest. Jews, Christians and those who follow the teachings of Mohammed of Mecca and Medina – most of them are not true believers. They merely claim they are.

      • I have a question about this, I am actually extremely interested in learning about Islam and I would love to ask you questions if you are willing to answer. If you’re interested please email me (I think you get my email)

  76. Hello, I think your website might be having browser compatibility
    issues. When I look at your blog site in Opera, it looks fine
    but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping.
    I just wanted to give you a quick heads up!
    Other then that, wonderful blog!

  77. God helped you. The people who’d attack you were not muslims. Islam means straight path. These are not straight people. God will punish each and every one of them.

    • I agree God helped you.

      But here is my plea to Westerners, women in particular:

      1. These are the people – they will do this repeatedly. Do not go to the Middle East for reporting etc. Drop it. They do not understand your idea of “a woman of spirit”.
      2. There is no wonderful revolution underway. Democracy does not work outside the developed Western world. Liberty is only abused by people unfit for it. Leave them in authoritarian rule, they do just fine.
      3. People do not turn from human to anmal in a moment. They never were human. The autocratic rule keeps beasts in check. That’s all. So please drop your “Western presumptions” that democracy will liberate these people.

      Enough Lara Logans please; would you women jounos please stick to familiar grounds. Please do not go to Egypt to witness the “glorious revolution”. Do not go to a Lion’s den and say eh he ate me up!!!

      • That’s not much of a solution, telling women to be scared and stay home. Tell rapists to stop raping. She did nothing wrong and she doesn’t need you to chastise her (don’t go into a lion’s den and say he ate me up).

      • what u say is true Anu… there is no “glorious revolution” underway. Those of us that are educated and in the arts or academia that have lived with Islam long enough knew this “Spring” could well for SURE be nothing in the end but an icy dead cold. because although the “rebels” that wanted CHANGE were the ones that got him and others OUT – they were not the ones that could carry the vote so they have been hijacked and now if the government and military are not careful these ppl can take everything down. They already have pushed women out of the government house… They have already took the “womans quota” away from being represented in the politics and parliament. they can now ruin everything and take us all back – into the dark ages and go down into the mud and wind up with a hideous government like Pakistan or Iran or be a puppet government to Iran like Syria has been… and no tourism either just like them also, so no good economy… it is already SO BAD!! These ppl can take us down to nothing but religious oppression and violence against religious minorities and backwards doctrines against all women. You are right Anu… perhaps autocratic rule was the best for most and we should have left it ALONE because these ppl can make it HELL for ALL… But even in the square as momentum gained they were infiltrated by these people that were backwards and “egged on” the naive young ppl… and we now have at this point, as it is said, jumped from the frying pan into the fire. all this said, I am so sorry this happened to you daughter, but be aware that these people are everywhere in all societies, but in those societies that hold no respect for woman where they can get away with this sort of behaviour – they will do these things and not even have a concious over it. This would probably not have happen in a Western country – you may have men sneaking a pinch on a girl here and there like they do so much in Italy, but NEVER THIS! And I hate to admit it but rape is mostly a serious problem in islamic countries as the culture and the religion go hand in hand with mistreatment of women and girls and do not prosecute the rapists. Its just the way it is and it will not change until muslim woman of the ummah demand it! If you proceed to do this work then please join forces with the Muslim womans that are already trying to make change happen like Mona Eltahawy. Read her story here.

        http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2012/04/23/why_do_they_hate_us

        bless you dear – your story of trial and strength is needed to show the muslim ummah woman that sexual assault is nothing to be shamed of and speak OUT and fight BACK and make the change HAPPEN!! If enough woman in the Ummah FIGHT – then the “evil lions”, those which are NOT “noble lions” and are unworthy and of low character, can indeed be driven back with a whip and a gun – and be “FORCED” to respect…..

  78. I’m saddened and sickened by all of this. I am American but fortunate (apparently) to look Egyptian. I was in Tahrir more times than I can count. I heard about many of these stories and the people who blame the women for going, they blame the Muslims because they hate the religion, and everything else you can think of. It’s ridiculous and disgusting. These men are animals, but men are animals all over the world too!! Surely when we went to Iraq to kill 1 million plus innocent people for oil you cannot tell me Christians aren’t the same type of animal!! The fact of the matter is that hate is rampant in this world, and ignorance, and THAT is a deadly combination. The Egyptian gov.t did not want to believe that their people were unhappy and they blamed the revolution on “the hidden hand” and said there were spies, and even showed them on TV. This gave the men MORE reason to harass and rape any foreigner. I live here and there is a problem with the men respecting women,(in a very patriarchal society) but the more serious problem is ignorance and intolerance. I’m so sorry this happened to you Natasha. May you find peace and find a way to help win the war on women all over the world.

    • I doubt you are American ..if you really are , so you know nothing about what ‘ s going on in Egypt now , public raping in Egypt does n’t target foreign women only ,so we can’t say it’s a revenge from ” hidden hands ” .. It happens every day to Egyptian women , the wave of looking down to women is getting stronger especially after the MB’s taking power of the country , So we( Egyptian women ) will fight for our rights and we will never be the scarifice of what so call ” Arab Spring “

    • It’s unfair to say Christians went to Iraq and killed millions for oil. To be exact it’s Americans who did it and in particular the American government. Please don’t be ignorant and just post about things if you don’t know the facts.

      • i agree – the armed forces that were in Iraq were from all over as it was an allied coalition and there were MANY different “religions” in those forces, including atheists, hindus, christians and even MUSLIMS

      • @grace I said Christians because they were also in Iraq acting like animals. and by the way, women in the American service get raped more by their fellow service men than anyone in the Middle Eastern countries which they are based. Men (bad men) are bad all over the world but people want to say this is a Muslim problem to demonize the religion so we can carry on hating them . Its not . Its a sickness of humans no matter what religion.

  79. Pingback: TomDispatch> Rebecca Solnit, The Archipelago of Arrogance « WAMMToday

  80. Pingback: Men Explain Things To Me… « UKIAH BLOG

  81. Natasha, thank you for sharing your story and for your brave stand to reveal truth. God grant you healing in mind, heart and body. Be safe and feel loved!

  82. Dear Natasha! I am so sorry than people from my faith did that to you. May Allah give them what they deserve. there are no excuses for what happened there. However, the debate that followed, especially about Islam, people need to know its not about countries or territories. being pious and righteous has noting to do with countries and boundaries. its about the submission of your will to your creator. Allah has said it in quran that no particular clan or group will be the owners of paradise. All those who submit their will to Allah, believe in hereafter and do good deeds will be rewarded with paradise whether, Muslims, Christians, Jews, or sabis or any other religion. as long as they believe in one Allah. similarly those who disobey Allah’s will they will be put to hell and these people did clearly disobeyed Allah. If they do not sincerely repent for what they did and ask Allah for forgiveness they will burn in hell forever. Natasha this act of rape is one of the most punishable acts in Islam.

    other who have been fighting over religions and countries must under stand that its devils act to make us humans fight. unfortunately most of us wont know.

    I pray for your recovery and strength.
    May Allah help you and guide you to strength.

    • This is your islam – This is the truth – There is NO peace in islam…….

      Qur’an:9:88 “The Messenger and those who believe with him, strive hard and fight with their wealth and lives in Allah’s Cause.”
      Qur’an:9:5 “Fight and kill the disbelievers wherever you find them, take them captive, harass them, lie in wait and ambush them using every stratagem of war.”
      Qur’an:9:112 “The Believers fight in Allah’s Cause, they slay and are slain, kill and are killed.”
      Qur’an:9:29 “Fight those who do not believe until they all surrender, paying the protective tax in submission.”
      Ishaq:325 “Muslims, fight in Allah’s Cause. Stand firm and you will prosper. Help the Prophet, obey him, give him your allegiance, and your religion will be victorious.”
      Qur’an:8:39 “Fight them until all opposition ends and all submit to Allah.”
      Qur’an:8:39 “So fight them until there is no more Fitnah (disbelief [non-Muslims]) and all submit to the religion of Allah alone (in the whole world).”
      Ishaq:324 “He said, ‘Fight them so that there is no more rebellion, and religion, all of it, is for Allah only. Allah must have no rivals.'”
      Qur’an:9:14 “Fight them and Allah will punish them by your hands, lay them low, and cover them with shame. He will help you over them.”
      Ishaq:300 “I am fighting in Allah’s service. This is piety and a good deed. In Allah’s war I do not fear as others should. For this fighting is righteous, true, and good.”
      Ishaq:587 “Our onslaught will not be a weak faltering affair. We shall fight as long as we live. We will fight until you turn to Islam, humbly seeking refuge. We will fight not caring whom we meet. We will fight whether we destroy ancient holdings or newly gotten gains. We have mutilated every opponent. We have driven them violently before us at the command of Allah and Islam. We will fight until our religion is established. And we will plunder them, for they must suffer disgrace.”
      Qur’an:8:65 “O Prophet, urge the faithful to fight. If there are twenty among you with determination they will vanquish two hundred; if there are a hundred then they will slaughter a thousand unbelievers, for the infidels are a people devoid of understanding.”
      Ishaq:326 “Prophet exhort the believers to fight. If there are twenty good fighters they will defeat two hundred for they are a senseless people. They do not fight with good intentions nor for truth.”
      Bukhari:V4B52N63 “A man whose face was covered with an iron mask came to the Prophet and said, ‘Allah’s Apostle! Shall I fight or embrace Islam first?’ The Prophet said, ‘Embrace Islam first and then fight.’ So he embraced Islam, and was martyred. Allah’s Apostle said, ‘A Little work, but a great reward.'”
      Bukhari:V4B53N386 “Our Prophet, the Messenger of our Lord, ordered us to fight you till you worship Allah alone or pay us the Jizyah tribute tax in submission. Our Prophet has informed us that our Lord says: ‘Whoever amongst us is killed as a martyr shall go to Paradise to lead such a luxurious life as he has never seen, and whoever survives shall become your master.'”
      Muslim:C34B20N4668 “The Messenger said: ‘Anybody who equips a warrior going to fight in the Way of Allah is like one who actually fights. And anybody who looks after his family in his absence is also like one who actually fights.”
      Qur’an:9:38 “Believers, what is the matter with you, that when you are asked to go forth and fight in Allah’s Cause you cling to the earth? Do you prefer the life of this world to the Hereafter? Unless you go forth, He will afflict and punish you with a painful doom, and put others in your place.”
      Qur’an:9:123 “Fight the unbelievers around you, and let them find harshness in you.”
      Qur’an:8:72 “Those who accepted Islam and left their homes to fight in Allah’s Cause with their possessions and persons, and those who gave (them) asylum, aid, and shelter, those who harbored them – these are allies of one another. You are not responsible for protecting those who embraced Islam but did not leave their homes [to fight] until they do so.” [Another translation reads:] “You are only called to protect Muslims who fight.”
      Muslim:C9B1N31 “I have been commanded to fight against people till they testify to the fact that there is no god but Allah, and believe in me (that) I am the Messenger and in all that I have brought.”
      Bukhari:V9B84N59 “Whoever says this will save his property and life from me.'”
      Qur’an:8:73 “The unbelieving infidels are allies. Unless you (Muslims) aid each other (fighting as one united block to make Allah’s religion victorious), there will be confusion and mischief. Those who accepted Islam, left their homes to fight in Allah’s Cause (al-Jihad), as well as those who give them asylum, shelter, and aid – these are (all) Believers: for them is pardon and bountiful provision (in Paradise).”
      Tabari IX:69 “Arabs are the most noble people in lineage, the most prominent, and the best in deeds. We were the first to respond to the call of the Prophet. We are Allah’s helpers and the viziers of His Messenger. We fight people until they believe in Allah. He who believes in Allah and His Messenger has protected his life and possessions from us. As for one who disbelieves, we will fight him forever in the Cause of Allah. Killing him is a small matter to us.”
      Qur’an:48:16 “Say (Muhammad) to the wandering desert Arabs who lagged behind: ‘You shall be invited to fight against a people given to war with mighty prowess. You shall fight them until they surrender and submit. If you obey, Allah will grant you a reward, but if you turn back, as you did before, He will punish you with a grievous torture.”
      Qur’an:48:22 “If the unbelieving infidels fight against you, they will retreat. (Such has been) the practice (approved) of Allah in the past: no change will you find in the ways of Allah.”
      Qur’an:47:4 “When you clash with the unbelieving Infidels in battle (fighting Jihad in Allah’s Cause), smite their necks until you overpower them, killing and wounding many of them. At length, when you have thoroughly subdued them, bind them firmly, making (them) captives. Thereafter either generosity or ransom (them based upon what benefits Islam) until the war lays down its burdens. Thus are you commanded by Allah to continue carrying out Jihad against the unbelieving infidels until they submit to Islam.”
      Qur’an:47:31 “And We shall try you until We know those among you who are the fighters.”
      Tabari VI:138 “Those present at the oath of Aqabah had sworn an allegiance to Muhammad. It was a pledge of war against all men. Allah had permitted fighting.”
      Tabari VI:139 “Allah had given his Messenger permission to fight by revealing the verse ‘And fight them until persecution is no more, and religion is all for Allah.'”
      Qur’an:9:19 “Do you make the giving of drink to pilgrims, or the maintenance of the Mosque, equal to those who fight in the Cause of Allah? They are not comparable in the sight of Allah. Those who believe, and left their homes, striving with might, fighting in Allah’s Cause with their goods and their lives, have the highest rank in the sight of Allah.”
      Ishaq:550 “The Muslims met them with their swords. They cut through many arms and skulls. Only confused cries and groans could be heard over our battle roars and snarling.”
      Qur’an:5:94 “Believers, Allah will make a test for you in the form of a little game in which you reach out for your lances. Any who fails this test will have a grievous punishment.”
      Ishaq:578 “Crushing the heads of the infidels and splitting their skulls with sharp swords, we continually thrust and cut at the enemy. Blood gushed from their deep wounds as the battle wore them down. We conquered bearing the Prophet’s fluttering war banner. Our cavalry was submerged in rising dust, and our spears quivered, but by us the Prophet gained victory.”
      Tabari IX:22 “The Prophet continued to besiege the town, fighting them bitterly.”
      Tabari IX:25 “By Allah, I did not come to fight for nothing. I wanted a victory over Ta’if so that I might obtain a slave girl from them and make her pregnant.”
      Tabari IX:82 “The Messenger sent Khalid with an army of 400 to Harith [a South Arabian tribe] and ordered him to invite them to Islam for three days before he fought them. If they were to respond and submit, he was to teach them the Book of Allah, the Sunnah of His Prophet, and the requirements of Islam. If they should decline, then he was to fight them.”
      Tabari IX:88 “Abdallah Azdi came to the Messenger, embraced Islam, and became a good Muslim. Allah’s Apostle invested Azdi with the authority over those who had surrendered and ordered him to fight the infidels from the tribes of Yemen. Azdi left with an army by the Messenger’s command. The Muslims besieged them for a month. Then they withdrew, setting a trap. When the Yemenites went in pursuit, Azdi was able to inflict a heavy loss on them.”
      Ishaq:530 “Get out of his way, you infidel unbelievers. Every good thing goes with the Apostle. Lord, I believe in his word. We will fight you about its interpretations as we have fought you about its revelation with strokes that will remove heads from shoulders and make enemies of friends.”
      Muslim:C9B1N29 “Command For Fighting Against People So Long As They Do Not Profess That There Is No Ilah (God) But Allah And Muhammad Is His Messenger: When the Messenger breathed his last and Bakr was appointed Caliph, many Arabs chose to become apostates [rejected Islam]. Abu Bakr said: ‘I will definitely fight against anyone who stops paying the Zakat tax, for it is an obligation. I will fight against them even to secure the cord used for hobbling the feet of a camel which they used to pay if they withhold it now.’ Allah had justified fighting against those who refused to pay Zakat.”
      Muslim:C9B1N33 “The Prophet said: ‘I have been commanded to fight against people till they testify there is no god but Allah, that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah, and they establish prostration prayer, and pay Zakat. If they do it, their blood and property are protected.'”
      Muslim:C10B1N176 “Muhammad (may peace be upon him) sent us in a raiding party. We raided Huraqat in the morning. I caught hold of a man and he said: ‘There is no god but Allah,’ but I attacked him with a spear anyway. It once occurred to me that I should ask the Apostle about this. The Messenger said: ‘Did he profess “There is no god but Allah,” and even then you killed him?’ I said: ‘He made a profession out of the fear of the weapon I was threatening him with.’ The Prophet said: ‘Did you tear out his heart in order to find out whether it had professed truly or not?'”
      Muslim:C20B1N4597 “The Prophet said at the conquest of Mecca: ‘There is no migration now, but only Jihad, fighting for the Cause of Islam. When you are asked to set out on a Jihad expedition, you should readily do so.'”
      Muslim:C28B20N4628 “Allah has undertaken to provide for one who leaves his home to fight for His Cause and to affirm the truth of His word; Allah will either admit him to Paradise or will bring him back home with his reward and booty.”
      Muslim:C28B20N4629 “The Messenger said: ‘One who is wounded in the Way of Allah – and Allah knows best who is wounded in His Way – will appear on the Day of Judgment with his wound still bleeding. The color (of its discharge) will be blood, (but) its smell will be musk.'”
      Muslim:C34B20N4652-3 “The Merit Of Jihad And Of Keeping Vigilance Over The Enemy: A man came to the Holy Prophet and said: ‘Who is the best of men?’ He replied: ‘A man who fights staking his life and spending his wealth in Allah’s Cause.'”
      Muslim:C42B20N4684 “A desert Arab came to the Prophet and said: ‘Messenger, one man fights for the spoils of war; another fights that he may be remembered, and one fights that he may see his (high) position (achieved as a result of his valor in fighting). Which of these is fighting in the Cause of Allah?’ The Messenger of Allah said: ‘Who fights so that the word of Allah is exalted is fighting in the Way of Allah.'”
      Muslim:C53B20N4717 “The Prophet said: ‘This religion will continue to exist, and a group of people from the Muslims will continue to fight for its protection until the Hour is established.'”
      Bukhari:V5B59N288 “I witnessed a scene that was dearer to me than anything I had ever seen. Aswad came to the Prophet while Muhammad was urging the Muslims to fight the pagans. He said, ‘We shall fight on your right and on your left and in front of you and behind you.’ I saw the face of the Prophet getting bright with happiness, for that saying delighted him.”
      Bukhari:V5B59N290 “The believers who did not join the Ghazwa [Islamic raid or invasion] and those who fought are not equal in reward.”
      Qur’an:2:193 “Fight them until there is no more Fitnah (disbelief) and religion is only for Allah. But if they cease/desist, let there be no hostility except against infidel disbelievers.”
      Qur’an:2:217 “They question you concerning fighting in the sacred month. Say: ‘Fighting therein is a grave (matter); but to prevent access to Allah, to deny Him, to prevent access to the Sacred Mosque, to expel its members, and polytheism are worse than slaughter. Nor will they cease fighting you until they make you renegades from your religion. If any of you turn back and die in unbelief, your works will be lost and you will go to Hell. Surely those who believe and leave their homes to fight in Allah’s Cause have the hope of Allah’s mercy.”
      Qur’an:2:244 “Fight in Allah’s Cause, and know that Allah hears and knows all.”
      Qur’an:2:246 “He said: ‘Would you refrain from fighting if fighting were prescribed for you?’ They said: ‘How could we refuse to fight in Allah’s Cause?'”
      Ishaq:280 “The Apostle prepared for war in pursuance of Allah’s command to fight his enemies and to fight the infidels who Allah commanded him to fight.”
      Qur’an:61:2 “O Muslims, why say one thing and do another? Grievously odious and hateful is it in the sight of Allah that you say that which you do not. Truly Allah loves those who fight in His Cause in a battle array, as if they were a solid cemented structure.”
      Bukhari:V4B52N61 “Allah’s Apostle! We were absent from the first battle you fought against the pagans. If Allah gives us a chance to do battle, no doubt, He will see how bravely we fight.”
      Ishaq:398 “Ask them for their help. Thereby make the religion of Islam agreeable to them. And when you are resolved in the matter of religion concerning fighting your enemy you will have the advantage.”
      Qur’an:3:146 “How many prophets fought in Allah’s Cause? With them (fought) myriads of godly men who were slain. They never lost heart if they met with disaster in Allah’s Cause, nor did they weaken nor give in. Allah loves those who are firm and steadfast [warriors].”
      Ishaq:393 “How many prophets has death in battle befallen and how many multitudes with him? They did not show weakness toward their enemies and were not humiliated when they suffered in the fight for Allah and their religion. That is steadfastness. Allah loves the steadfast.”
      Qur’an:3:153 “Behold! You ran off precipitately, climbing up the high hill without even casting a side glance at anyone, while the Messenger in your rear is calling you from your rear, urging you to fight. Allah gave you one distress after another by way of requital, to teach you not to grieve for the booty that had escaped you and for (the ill) that had befallen you.”
      Qur’an:3:154 “Say: ‘Even if you had remained in your houses, those ordained to be slaughtered would have gone forth to the places where they were to slain.”
      Ishaq:440 “Helped by the Holy Spirit we smited Muhammad’s foes. The Apostle sent a message to them with a sharp cutting sword.”
      Ishaq:470 “We attacked them fully armed, swords in hand, cutting through heads and skulls.”
      Qur’an:61:4 “Surely Allah loves those who fight in His Cause.”
      Qur’an:61:11 “Believers, shall I lead you to a bargain or trade that will save you from a painful torment? That you believe in Allah and His Messenger (Muhammad), and that you strive and fight in Allah’s Cause with your property and your lives: That will be best for you!” Qur’an 61:12 “He will forgive you your sins, and admit you to Gardens under which rivers flow, and to beautiful mansions in Eden: that is indeed the Supreme Achievement. And another (favor) which you love: help from Allah for a speedy victory over your enemies.”
      Qur’an:8:5 “Your Lord ordered you out of your homes to fight for the true cause, even though some Muslims disliked it, and were averse (to fighting).”
      Qur’an:24:53 “They swear their strongest oaths saying that if only you would command them. They would leave their homes (and go forth fighting in Allah’s Cause). Say: ‘Swear not; Obedience is (more) reasonable.'”
      Qur’an:4:74 “Let those who fight in Allah’s Cause sell this world’s life for the hereafter. To him who fights in Allah’s Cause, whether he is slain or victorious, We shall give him a reward.”
      Qur’an:4:75 “What reason have you that you should not fight in Allah’s Cause?” [Another translation says:] “What is wrong with you that you do not fight for Allah?”
      Qur’an:4:76 “Those who believe fight in the Cause of Allah.”
      Qur’an:4:77 “Have you not seen those to whom it was said: Withhold from fighting, perform the prayer and pay the zakat. But when orders for fighting were issued, a party of them feared men as they ought to have feared Allah. They say: ‘Our Lord, why have You ordained fighting for us, why have You made war compulsory?'”
      Qur’an:4:78 “Wherever you are, death will find you, even if you are in towers strong and high! So what is wrong with these people, that they fail to understand these simple words?”
      Qur’an:4:84 “Then fight (Muhammad) in Allah’s Cause. Incite the believers to fight with you.”
      Qur’an:4:94 “Believers, when you go abroad to fight wars in Allah’s Cause, investigate carefully, and say not to anyone who greets you: ‘You are not a believer!’ Coveting the chance profits of this life (so that you may despoil him). With Allah are plenteous spoils and booty.”
      Qur’an:4:95 “Not equal are believers who sit home and receive no hurt and those who fight in Allah’s Cause with their wealth and lives. Allah has granted a grade higher to those who fight with their possessions and bodies to those who sit home. Those who fight He has distinguished with a special reward.”
      Qur’an:4:100 “He who leaves his home in Allah’s Cause finds abundant resources and many a refuge. Should he die as a refugee for Allah and His Messenger His reward becomes due and sure with Allah. When you travel through the earth there is no blame on you if you curtail your worship for fear unbelievers may attack you. In truth the disbelievers are your enemy.”
      Qur’an:4:102 “When you (Prophet) lead them in prayer, let some stand with you, taking their arms with them. When they finish their prostrations, let them take positions in the rear. And let others who have not yet prayed come – taking all precaution, and bearing arms. The Infidels wish, if you were negligent of your arms, to assault you in a rush. But there is no blame on you if you put away your arms because of the inconvenience of rain or because you are ill; but take precaution. For the Unbelieving Infidels Allah hath prepared a humiliating punishment.”
      Qur’an:4:104 “And do not relent in pursuing the enemy.”

      • Dude I’ve read the quran over and over again and I’m educated enough to tell you all those things that you have just quoted from the quran is bullshit i tell you and do you even know what jihad means? It means to strive or struggle and muslims don’t go killin people just because they dont believe in Allah swt. I’ve got mmany friends who aren’t muslims. People like you have nothing better to do than just be judgemental and talk out of your own ass. Go research the proper thing or go buy a quran that is translated in english from a proper muslim shop and then give your views.

  83. hello there and thank you for your info – I’ve certainly picked up anything new from right here. I did however expertise a few technical points using this web site, since I experienced to reload the site a lot of times previous to I could get it to load correctly. I had been wondering if your web hosting is OK? Not that I am complaining, but slow loading instances times will very frequently affect your placement in google and can damage your high-quality score if ads and marketing with Adwords. Well I am adding this RSS to my e-mail and could look out for much more of your respective exciting content. Ensure that you update this again very soon.

  84. Well, Dick, I see you live in a simple world where you play “Christian” simply to salve and justify your own self-centered godlessness. Read up a little on Jesus. You honestly think he’d endorse your absolute lack of sympathy, empathy, compassion? Not to worry, you are in the majority these days. “Christianity” in the USA these days is pretty much summed up by hordes of self-righteous bigots stuffing their faces with bird flesh at Chick-fil-a under the pretense that their hate and intolerance is a show of support for God. Might bear remembering that Christ’s example was to feed OTHERS before himsef. Love thy neighbor, all that. He would not have endorsed “Gluttony for God.”

  85. Islam is the problem, as currently practiced by 95% of the world’s Muslim population. Of *course* one can find enlightened Muslims and enlightened, progressive interpretations of Islam are *possible*. That’s not the question. Until journalists wake up and start calling it like it is, and not how the Saudis, Qataris, Emiratis, Pakistanis etc want you to portray it, Islam will not improve.

    • Well, you are wrong, your addiction to oil is behind the problem with all the countries you name. But if you must go there, you must admit that Islam is no worse than Christianity or Judaism. They have been interlocked in a death grip for millenia. Vidal got it right when he said “The great unmentionable evil at the center of our culture is monotheism.” Abraham gave birth to a line of virulently self-righteous, closed-minded brats.

      • There is no country or religion in the world that the muslims don’t have a prob with. The Quaran teaches muslims to HATE everybody, KILL everybody – until there is rule fo Islam all over the world.
        Funny – you blame the US. Down here the pakistanis blame us indians, in palestine they blame the jews & Israel. And finally – there is one country where there should e no problems ‘technically’ for the muslims: CHINA
        They are a strong ally of Pakistan. They like muslims & pakistanis too. But you muslims are bombing up that place up too. Doing jihad there as well. What’s ur explanation for that sir?
        There is absolutely no comparison between christianity, judaism or any other religion with Islam. It is hilarious if you say that. LOL… Again – you guys seem to blame everybody else except yourself. The amount of violence & bloodshed spread ALL OVER THE WORLD cause of Islam in just 1400 years – and till today is just unbelievable. Over hundred million people killed. We know what you have done in India during the 800 year muslim rule – tortured, killed, executed hindus – forced conversions, destroyed our literature, destroyed 3000 temples – it was barbaric.

        If there is any evil in this world it is ISLAM. The root cause is not ‘oil’ – it is the ‘Quaran’…

      • well Islam is not like that for God sake dont talk about anything you havent knowledge about!
        whereever the Quran says kill the non believers ”in battle, when they fight you” Islam is not senseless Quran says who ever killed an innocent human being(not definetly muslim) is like he killed the whole humanity. its the muslims who changed Islams reality not Islam.. well blacksheeps are everywhere ”dick nespo”

  86. Hi Natasha,
    My heart goes out to you for what you survived and I admire your strength in being able to write about this. I come from a part of the world (India) where such things, though rare, are not unheard of.. Recently, a similar such incident happened in my country where a minor girl fell victim to mob attack – a very similar incident. As a woman the first thing I felt was that this could have been me. And then I felt apologetic – to me India and Egypt do have one common thing – our countrymen’s need to control & own women – I am apologize to you for that. I will make sure I will do my bit, by raising any boy child I have, to be decent men who will never do what these guys did to you. I sincerely hope you overcome the pain soon.
    -Keerthana

  87. Wait… you just got mass ravaged by a bunch of Arab animals in the country’s largest public square: and you want to prove that these creatures and the stupid fucked up cult they adhere to is ‘actually very nice’? The attack, I’m afraid, has also messed with your head.

    • I would also like to declare right here that you will never find such an incident happening in the modern western world, the supposed place of “devolved morals”

      • Dude.. i hope u are aware of the fact that, during new years eve, molestation is common in France. I can talk about France cuz I have seen it personally.. Drunk men were out of control….

  88. This is one of the most disturbing things I have ever heard. Scary! And sick! because of the amount of apathy involved at every single step – even after you had suffered this horrendous attack. Sick because the people who did this – couldn’t see how small & young you were and how it didn’t once remind them of their little sisters or relatives.

    I wish you wouldn’t go back there. Plz. You don’t have to finish the documentary. You can just write about it – articles are good enough.

    May god bless you – and help you recover fully, and really soon. I hope the people around you are giving you all the love, support & respect you need to recover quickly. If not, let me know and I’ll write to you every single day until you feel better.

  89. While reading what you had to suffer, I suffered it inside me. I am an Indian woman, You are indeed brave to publish it, and I hope your grit, will help us to make, this world better and safer place for daughters of Asia, Daughters Africa, Daughters of Europe, and daughters of America.

  90. It is a horrible story; I couldn’t read it until the end because of what happened to Natasha by these animals. It is incredible and gut-wrenching to read what happened to her. I think I would have wanted to just die after such an unbelievable event! She shows incredible strength in her comments on this ordeal and I wish her all the best in her recovery from this. I ‘m feeling sick now. Things are not well in this region (N.-Africa & the Middle-East). Libya gives me some hope because they elected a non-religious government. Now they need to build on that with truth and openness. I hope that the women in these regions and everywhere else where they are subjected to wrongs like this can regain their freedom and live like equals that they are in their and our societies! There is much work to be done, not in the least by the effected women. They must group themselves against these wrongs, inequalities, attacks and rapes. Natasha, I wish you the best and a victory for your cause!

      • This article has a couple of firsts for me:
        1) I am an Indian and have read/heard about such incidents quite frequently here but realized that such incidents aren’t just India-specific
        2) Part of the reason I thought was that us Indian males are highly insensitive being of a patriarchal society but after reading John’s comment understood that this breed of animals is spread across the world.

        Natasha,
        I hope you that you are at-least on the path of recovery from this ordeal. Our thoughts and prayers are with you. FTW!

  91. Look at me .. I am a blond good looking woman and I walking arround all naieve and sorts on a square filled with especially criminals, retards, religious zealots, and all under the influence of an evil spirt.
    Mmm purely at random you get molested ?!
    Ever wondered why they put divers in a cage when let loose arround great whites in their natural habitat :S
    Better learn this lesson quick ..
    If you don’t learn to see possible dangers before they cristalize you end up dead.
    And trust me a western white female on a square filled with rif raf .. you are lucky you still have your limbs ..
    The evil spirit most Arabs are under won’t fail twice, go back home and stay away from places you don’t belong to !
    A streetsmart kid could have told you so !

    • Only someone truly EVIL would dare to imply that she could be pointed at as (even in the slightest bit) responsible or to blame. SHE didn’t commit a crime, those men did! She is the victim, so have some respect! Even she was naive, she could never be blamed, because she did nothing against the law. And you; you are discussing “evil spirits”? That shows that you’re a thousand times more ignorant than she ever was. Get educated and civilised, you savage pig.

    • Holy misogyny! So women can’t travel the world? Should stay in their place? WOW. Rapists need to stop raping. Ignorant folks need to stop blaming the victim, who did nothing wrong, and place the blame on the rapists.

  92. Sexual assaults happen every day all over the world. Women have been gang-raped here in the United States. I’m humbled by this young woman’s bravery and courage for speaking out. I hope she continues working and tells other women’s stories.

  93. Pretty section of content. I just stumbled upon your web site and in accession capital to assert
    that I acquire in fact enjoyed account your blog
    posts. Anyway I will be subscribing to your feeds
    and even I achievement you access consistently fast.

  94. This is the 3rd or 4th case of gang rape of Western women on Tahrir Square, and it has nothing to do with Islam and its culture??? pleeeese!

  95. Thank you Natasha for speaking out – so important to hear your own words rather than a newspaper report. I came across this http://awid.org/eng/News-Analysis/Women-s-Rights-in-the-News2/Egypt-May-25-the-commemoration-of-black-Wednesday which describes Egyptian security forces in civilian clothes attacking Egyptian women in a very similar way in 2005. The attacks on you were maybe one with the attacks on Egyptian women calling for revolution.

  96. I am extremely extremely shocked this happened I am not even sure this is real that’s how shocked I am. ESPECIALLY since these are Muslims its almost unbelievable but I suppose in today’s day and age it is very possible.

    I sympathise with what happened I have no idea how that must have fealt but I can tell you this is TOTALLY AGAINST Islam. 100% without a doubt no Muslim will deny that this is totally against Islam i don’t care what excuse they say about “spys” this is totally against Islam and I am a Muslim saying this.

    I don’t know why this happened and why these men are such animals, dirty pigs but I do know many non-muslims and “islamophobes” will use this as extreme biasness and propaganda against Islam when clearly this is not the teachings from Islam if ANY1 studies Islam u will find this

    Man is not perfect so do not take the view of these pigs as Islam.

  97. Hi there!
    I am sorry does not even cover what I feel after reading this. I just hope you get your justice.
    We have tried to take an initiative through #Justiceforwomen on Twitter. If you’d be interested in sharing this story on our blog, do let me know.
    Sakshi Kumar

  98. I believe you, Natasha, and I am so sorry that happened. And I’m so sorry that, in addition to going through such a horrible, dehumanizing experience, you are being harassed by misogynists. It takes a lot of courage to share your story, especially when you know a few noisy, banal people will do anything to discredit you, just because you are female. To the misogynist trolls: Can you explain what could possibly motivate Natasha to lie about something like this? I mean, seriously, what kind of benefit could she possibly be getting from making this up? (Already rolling my eyes in anticipation of more misogynistic drivel.) Can you explain why you are so sure she’s lying when you have no idea what you’re talking about and have nothing to back up your claim? Are there no women in your lives that you love and respect? And if there are, can you explain your misogynistic position to them without feeling like scum? WOW.

  99. Dear Natasha;
    There is no word can make you feel better or make you forget this horrible accident and believe me I am feel shame and every Egyptian man should feel shame when know this happened in Egypt, but I am really so sorry and please do not let this accident change you in bad way do not let it leave a deform on your soul and please forgive us because we could not protect you in our country. god bless and protect you .

    • Oh, this didn’t happen in a Muslim country? And the horrid 15-year old male wasn’t even a rabidly raving, cowardly, disgusting, retarded, ……., …………., ……, etc. etc., (fill in the blanks) Arab/Egyptian male consumed by the urge to violate that white skin, and prove to all what a macho man he is, either? British kids rape small girls they’re babysitting. Must be a tradition over there, due no doubt to their depressingly rainy climate and the economic recession. They can’t hep it. So sorry all — my apologies.

      I would be interested to hear what those on this (BTW, increasingly & tragically ludicrous thread, apparently hijacked by illiterate nitwits) sad incident involving 2 (presumably Christian) kids. I wonder how other Christians would feel if it were their daughter who was raped by the neighbors’ son. Would they be as outraged as I, over this? There must be something in the Christian faith, or the Bible, that pre-disposes their teenage boys to rape infants, no doubt. Could it be due to their extreme whiteness, that weird skin color, that makes people behave this way? Or is it that disgusting pork they eat that makes boys commit such heinous crimes before adulthood? Perhaps it’s because those awful Brits live in a democratic country, and have rights that most of us don’t, which pushes teenage boys to sexually assault small girls, because their laws encourage it.. So many questions, all unanswerable. I’m terribly confused and don’t know what to make of this rape that involves neither Muslims nor Arabs.

      The only answer I can come up with is that the boy is a Muslim/Arab/Egyptian masquerading as a bona fide British national with real British parents, and that the girl encouraged him by dressing provocatively in her cute little “Hello Kitty” pink pyjamas. Serves her right for accepting an English neighborhood boy to babysit her while her parents were gallivanting around town, leaving their child under the care of a deranged Bible-studying teenager, while they went to the pub or something, to consume alcohol and fall into a drunken stupor.

      • How disgustingly gleeful you sound! How dare you use this poor litle gir’s rape to make your gleeful little points. Sexual abuse and rape of children happens in every country on this planet. But no, I don’t see mobs of men raping lone women in England. Can you point me to repeated examples such a huge mob of white men raping and attacking and nearly murdering a woman? (because the points you seem to be making are about white English people, not black or brown English people). Hmmm… I’m betting you can’t. Why is that? Because culture does have something to do with it. And British culture would not accept such a thing happening. There would be an immediate outcry. There would be an investigation. There would be arrests. And there would a be a trial. How interesting that that has not happened in this case. How disgusting that you have to drag out the rape of a five year old to make your gleeful, inconsequential points. Until the culture in Egypt changes so that it will not tolerate mass rapes of this kind, they will continue to happen from time to time. And it is voices like yours that will continue to let it happen. It has nothing to do with skin color. It has everything to do with culture and extreme Islam.

  100. Dear Natasha,

    I am moved by your story and I wish you all the best regarding the task to cope with this experience.
    I must say that I’ve read these lines with my mouth wide open – being totally impressed by the conveyed strength and determination of yours not to let yourself be paralyzed by these traumatic events. Moreover, that you look beyond the specific situation, keeping your fundamentally positive stance towards Egypt and its people, refraining from any generalization but keeping the admittedly sad context in mind.
    Thank you for speaking out, for describing your personal suffering in such detail – it helped me become more aware about harrassment against woman. I hope, it will help me to intervene.
    Thank you and all the best!
    – a man
    Bremen, Germany

  101. Pingback: Farkhunda Zahra Naderi | Afghan Parliamentarian and Women Activist » Features Sexual violence rises in Egypt’s Tahrir

  102. I’m really saddened to read so many bad anecdotes about visits to Egypt. I have been to Egypt many times, alone and with others, and lived there briefly. In ANY culture that is not your own, you need to use common sense. On the other hand, if your guard is up every moment, you will miss the great warmth and generosity of most Egyptians.

    I count many, many Egyptians among my closest friends. I’ve stayed in Egyptian homes, traveled from Cairo to Luxor by car with an Egyptian friend, and wandered all over the country alone. I know Egyptians of great integrity and intellect.

    Yes, there have been some dicey moments but they were all when I was not using common sense and they could have happened ANYWHERE. In fact, I’d have been in much more danger in New York doing the kinds of things I’ve done in Egypt than I ever would have been in Egypt.

    I’ll return to Egypt again and again if possible. I miss it.

  103. I feel very sorry for your terrible ordeal and glad you survived that. May be this shows how is this society is changing fast. If Egypt changes from a civilized state into a religious one. Morals come from conscious not from following any text whatsoever but this is what islamists can’t understand. I am a coptic man and I see racism everyday.

  104. The wonderful Arab Spring has brought forth he first blossom of true muhammadanism,
    the marriage of a sheich with a sex slave. How wonderful.
    httpv://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FHrUDAVn–s&feature=related

  105. Pingback: Egitto. In piazza contro la violenza sulle donne « Resulayman blog

  106. Pingback: Sexual Harassment | Projects

  107. Hello Natasha. I saw your video reading on CNN and was compelled to come here and try to communicate with you. I feel bad for you and sorry for your ordeal. That type of evil should never be perpetrated on anyone in any country. I hope you can move on with your life and be happy. Though you can never forget, you can certainly find life a successful life in the future.

    I have followed the news on Egypt in earnest these past years. I, myself, actually lived there as a study abroad student several years back. I am sure I could share some similar stories with you about being in Egypt. Fighting with cab drivers, exploring ruins, dining in Zamelek to mention a few. I only lived there for six months, but honestly it was the nearly the worst six months of my life. I tell my friends and family that I would never live in that forsaken place again, and I would only visit to travel to the Red Sea, one of the most beautiful places on earth and great for water sports. Even then I would be afraid to go there after the bombings that took place in the area after I left.

    I think that people underestimate just how backwards Egypt really is, and how especially dumb most Egyptian guys are. Ethnocentrism causes people to lump an area or group into one big category – ‘all Asians look the same’, for example. Having traveled in Asia, obviously, each country is like apples to oranges. Chinese people are totally different from Japanese people, but most Americans have no idea about this. I could go on about why, but I don’t want to get off the point I am making. The Middle East is no exception. If you have been to Jordan, you can tell the striking difference in personality between Jordanians and Egyptians. Jordanians seem more educated and the country more developed. While I was pretty nervous traveling around the country (because of anti-Americanism, and especially in Palestinian areas), I felt much more comfortable going about my day to day business. As soon as you return to Egypt (particularly Cairo) it is nothing but endless fighting and hassles, lack of respect, manipulation, rudeness, etc. I have been to a lot of cities around the world, and I have to say that Cairo ranks pretty much at the bottom. I hate to say this, because I have never been the type of person to put other cultures or peoples down, and I would consider myself fairly ‘liberal’ in the American sense, but I must say what I feel is in my heart.

    Saying it, however, certainly doesn’t improve the situation, nor will it ensure that what happened to you in Tahir Square won’t happen to another. Action is needed. What I truly believe is needed in Egypt, before it will ever succeed at democracy or improvement, is Separation of Church and State. I have studied this issue extensively while at home and in Egypt, and know this must occur. It is unfortunate that a man with links to the Muslim Brotherhood has been chosen as the so-called president of the country. Anyone who has lived in Egypt and knows Egyptian behavior knows that most of what he says publicly is complete bullshit, especially any rhetoric about ‘representing all people, including Christians/minorities’. He ‘resigned’ from his party, a grand gesture only meant as a power play, but not realistic. Having fundamentalist Muslims in power is only a recipe for disaster. It would be the same in any country (ala G.W.B. in my own country). I am certain that the people who started the revolution had no foresight that the country would fall into the hands of fundamentalist Muslims. The ‘face bookers’ are probably very reasonable people who, like most Egyptians, want to improve the terrible conditions there. What they got now is probably completely the opposite of their intention.

    In your story you mention that you were ‘swept up’ in a sense by the events in the square, and that you should have kept up your guard. Don’t feel bad and blame yourself. Egypt, and Egyptians, have a way of doing that. Once, when I was shopping in Khan-el-Khalili (the famous Cairo market), I ventured over to the non-foreign side with my girlfriend of the time (she talked me into it). In hindsight it was such a stupid decision. On the other side we met a man, who was well dressed, a bit handsome, and friendly. He spoke decent English and started up a conversation with us. Usually when strangers in Egypt start a conversation, it is usually to get you to buy something, or to use you for their purposes. It is very rare that they actually care about you or want to have a genuine conversation. Yet, we were roped in, because you can’t keep your guard up all the time. He asked us what kind of food we liked, and pizza came up. He said there was a pizza shop nearby and he would take us there. As we followed him past the row of market tents into the back of the market, a shopkeeper looked at me (direct eye contact) and shot me a grim warning. Without saying a word, I understood what he was saying. ‘You are in danger. You shouldn’t be here. Don’t follow that man. Turn back’. Fortunately, the man we met was walking ahead of us, so he didn’t see the shopkeeper. About 15 seconds later, we were being led up a dark sloping alleyway. We are almost there, he said. I knew something wasn’t right. I turned around and looked at my girlfriend, and there was a look of complete fear on her face. We both knew it was bad. Luckily, I am not without courage. On the spot, I looked at my watch and said ‘I’m sorry but we don’t have time for this. We have to meet our friends in 15 minutes.’ The man we met protested, but I stood firm. We went back, and the man followed behind. He protested a bit more, but resigned. He knew we had changed our mind, and was prodding me about why. He offered to walk us back to the main area, where we caught a taxi. The last thing he said to us, was, ‘did one of the shopkeepers say something to you?’ I told him no, and we left. I still get nervous thinking about it to this day. I would imagine that if I had went on, my petit girlfriend might have been kidnapped or worse, after I was beaten silly, or maybe worse. I was an idiot to think I could trust someone in Egypt.

    Another strange memory was of me riding the bus between Cairo and the Red Sea, which is about a 9 hour drive. On the way back there was a woman and a baby sitting in the back. The men on the bus, meanwhile, smoked and smoked and smoked until the bus was filled with the stuff. It was totally disgusting for me, but I can’t tell Egyptians to quit in their own country, can I? I felt more sorry, however, for the woman and her baby. The men just didn’t give a shit about them. Women and children are second-class citizens there and in most middle eastern countries. I think you give the men there more credit, because a few of them tried to help you. The masses of Egypt don’t care about their own, much less western people who come there. In fact they resent us at best, at worst they hate us. We can do all the things they can’t. We can hold hands and kiss in public, we can drink alcohol and gamble in their country (ordinary Egyptians are prohibited but Western people are not), and we are automatically ‘upper-class’ even if we are struggling to get by in our own country, as soon as we step off the plane. Who wouldn’t resent us? I find it strange that people who openly profess their love of god and peace would so horribly treat others, but that is the nature of fundamentalism, is it not? Without all the black uniformed police walking around the city with kalashnikovs people there would do worse. It is not the religion that keeps those people in check. It is inequality that drives them to lose empathy. That is why they can lie to your face, and pretend to be something they are not. Nothing changes when they get permission to live in western countries. In fact, they often become worse, even the coptic christians. They can barely handle their new environment, they are still used to living in the manipulative and corrupt environment in their home country (I have experience with Egyptians in my own community in America, some of them friends). I have to admit, though, that Americans can be jerks too, in our own way. I am not ethnocentric, nor racist, by the way (and I do have my sins).

    While I was there, a french photographer was stabbed to death by her then Egyptian boyfriend. I can’t remember the details of it, but I think he was jealous of another man, or she was going to leave him. Egyptian men look at women as objects, for their pleasure. The stare them up and down as they walk down the street, and they whistle at them. They grope them whenever they get the chance. A few years ago some women started taking self-defense classes and it took off. Egyptian women are sick of it. One of my Lebanese friends was walking in Cairo and some man made a rude comment, something about her dress, or where she was going (I can’t remember). When she told him, in Egyptian Arabic, ‘It is none of your business’ the man hauled off and slapped her in the face. I asked her if she called the police, but she said no, ‘because they wouldn’t help me, in fact they might do something bad to me too.’ How humiliating for her to have to let a stranger slap her and do nothing. Another friend of mine, who a Japanese female, said a taxi driver said something strange to her in Arabic and started masturbating in the car. He never touched her, and after the drive she just simply went home. Weird. While I was in walking with my girlfriend, almost every guy in town (including the police) stared at her body like jackals. I gave them dirty looks (even the police with those damn kalashnikovs) but they simply ignored me. Most guys at home take a quick peek, because sometimes you just can’t help yourself, but these guys were just totally disrespectful and didn’t care. I could go on and on.

    The problem with spreading democracy in places like Egypt is that most people don’t understand the conditions in which democracy flourish. If you don’t know the background history and how France and America found democracy after the age of Enlightenment, then you can’t understand why it worked. After the fundamentalist dark ages, philosophy and education were not only ideal, but encouraged. Unfortunately that environment doesn’t exist in most places. The upper class who founded American and French democracy had the knowledge and support to get it done. Egypt has a lot of ‘western educated’ politicians/aristocrats, but not an educated population to support them. It is mostly poor, uneducated, fundamentalist muslims, who have no idea what democracy even means. I remember when I went to Jordan, there was a girl selling small trinkets near Petra. She spoke some broken English, and mentioned that ‘the government had forced them off their land’, but she kept saying ‘he’ after that in place of government. She actually thought ‘government’ was a person! (I don’t know til now if it was just bad English or if she really didn’t know, but I think she didn’t know). Of course, uneducated people can hardly be blamed for being ignorant. On top of it, the newspapers in Egypt are just mouthpieces for the government, and most of it is just propaganda. ‘The Cairo Times’ is the only trustworthy source of journalism in Egypt, and it is written in English. One of my friends works for them. When I was at the University of Cairo I was shocked at how naive some of the student were about their own country. The muslims there acted as if the Christian minority was treated equally. It was such a joke.

    Honestly, if you are determined to finish your documentary, I say go for it, but you best set some rules for yourself, and perhaps even get some outside help. I am sure there are many who would be totally willing to help you with your work. I wouldn’t tell you what to do because I don’t know you, but if I were in your shoes I wouldn’t go back in person. You can get someone else to do the filming and photography. You might have enemies there now, and it would be completely unsafe, especially under the current conditions. I’m sure you are used to going to places (as a journalist) that are ‘unsafe’, but your situation is more complex now. If you are still determined to travel there again, I would suggest dying your hair black, and dressing as unattractively as possible. Do you know any Egyptian Arabic? My friends suggested saying ‘Haram’ (shameful) when they treat you badly. However, I am puzzled as to why the hell you would want to go back there. Honestly I just think you are still infatuated by the ‘romantic Egypt’ and not the real Egypt. It is like that when you travel sometimes. Just like love, you get infatuated, and you lose perspective. Later you come to your senses and realize your emotions were clouding your judgement. In your video you say that you still love the country and it is a good place. Most people are good there, but I could’t say it is a great country. I would never want to live there and for me anyone who would want to live there has mental problems. An earlier poster said, ‘most Egyptians want to emigrate’, which is true. Getting a visa to America, England, or Australia is like winning the lottery.

    I know this is a long post. I hope I haven’t offended you in any way. After watching your video, I was touched, and saddened, and I wanted to reach out. Somewhere, someone in the world, is thinking about you. If I have offended the Muslims who post comments here too, again, I apologize. However, I stand by my comments and say them from my heart. I truly wish the people of Egypt the best, but remain skeptical of recent events. Natasha, the country doesn’t deserve you, and any thing else you have to give is a complete gift to them. I hope that if you do go back, that the government will meet you at the airport to apologize, and will investigate the incident properly. You are owed at least that and more. Journalists like you are what keeps the world caring about their plight, and those in the country that are suffering and truly deserve help. It is they who we must keep fighting for.

      • Such detailed and honest feelings Jeremy. Few days i saw some poster who said she wants to organize the protest against such sexual harassment, and this is the news which has come out.
        Even such protests were victimized by harassment by men of the society.
        I sincerely hope that Ms. Smith do not goes back.

      • I was the post who “said she wanted to organise a protest against SH in Tahrir”. Organised, attended, completely successful, supported by the crowd in Tahrir who chanted with us, raised debate throughout Egypt, made several newspapers here, TV coverage on the way, front page of Le Monde. Articles in Foreign Policy, Huffington post and papers in Canada, Jordan, Lebanon, India, Sweden, Spain…and probably countless other places we’re not aware of.

        And all thanks to Natasha’s bravery in speaking out (plus our own plain common sense and decency in not lumping people together based on race, country or creed). 🙂

    • I guess You are Right in many ways , but I’m sure that You didn’t see the real good way of the true good Egyptians !

      We hate most of what the people in my Country do , but it’s what You get after 40 years of nothing but bullshit ! they ruined the morals , the education , the geographicalty of the cites & the people who lives in it !

    • Egypt is the same horrible place full of horrible people no matter what kind of government they have ! So dangerous to walk around if you are a Blonde Lady .. The Same was 10 years ago in Cairo Bazaar , and the same is today in Tahrir Square !

      So many Egyptian men admit freely of their sexual harassment, and they think it is normal and/or it’s the fault of the woman they harass…. Unbelievable.

      I really do not think the unfortunate attack that happened to Natasha was motivated by political or religious reasons, but purely because of being a western looking blonde lady ! That is pretty enough reason !
      It was so hard reading through your lines Natasha, but I applaud you for your courage to share these horrible moments, so that WE ALL KNOW again !!

      God Bless…

    • Allow me to disagree almost completely with you. While it is unfortunately sometimes true what is said about many Egyptians, this is something that would happen in any country under the same circumstances. They have had for about 50 years garbage marxist/simply oppressive government rule, leaving the people with similar education and morals. And this is all thanks to america and europes wonderful support of the Egyptian people. While your words do have some truth, you cannot simplify the entire country as so, and I can easily say likewise and worse about american society. In america, every 45 seconds a women is apparently sexually assaulted, and these are old statistics I speak of, and you may simply search this up for yourself. In every country, if there is enough lawlessness, the devil will come out of a some people. I will tell you it’s very saddening, because in the Muslim world rape/sexual harassment is seen as a huge crime, and to see this done to someone in a Muslim state will bring many Muslims to tears, as Ms. Smith said of the women who helped her. Because this is such a horrendous crime for Muslims, it rarely happens. And when it does, it usually happens to women who are wearing so scarcely that for an ill-bred uneducated man all he sees is that, “she’s asking for it”.

      Of course this is not Islam. Mubarak and those before him hated Islam, and so did their best to suppress it, which is why we have such sad cases as this, and which is why they are supported by america and its like. If america and its cultured educated people loved democracy, knowledge and morals for everyone like they do for themselves, why is the US supporting all these oppressive goons? And to be frank, I’ve lived in America for a good part of my life, and I can hardly say that americans are any better than your description of Egyptians, and can recount just as many miserable cases of rape, torture, discrimination, racism, fascism, drunkenness. And if there are any who see women as a sex toy, it is americans, who get to know each other through bars and one-night stands.

      Don’t think I’m just trying to insult america, but I’ve lived in a lot of countries and can tell you that its not the place I’ve decided to live in, and honest to God, I seriously think anyone who wants to live there is truly mental.

      So please, before making such remarks know that problems and their roots are a lot deeper than they seem, and that if you look a little deeper, it’s clear who plants all of is.

      By the way, quite remarkable how she was saved by the burka.

      • You’re CLEARLY delusional. Jeremy wrote an amazing and honest account of Egypt. Like most Muslims who live in the Middle East you are delusional, Islam needs to be reformed simple as that, and the WORLD can see that. And all of my Muslim friends who live in the USA are wealthy and extremely educated Muslim American’s are wealthier that the average American, so I have NO idea what you are talking about. My Muslim American friends are well-balanced they are not EXTREME they are realist and I truly respect them.

      • Yes. Remarkable how she was saved by the burqa…
        Quite remarkable how, to be safe, she had to disappear from public view into a black cloth coffin completely. Remarkably disgusting.

        Yes, women are raped everyday all over the world but somehow… a full scale public-endorsed public-view Tahrir Gang Bang feels a little more…intense. Maybe that’s just me.

        You forget something – we’ve seen how Muslim countries regard rape. We saw it again in Libya when a woman told a room of journalists she’d been raped by Libyan forces. We saw the ordinary Muslims in that room throw a bag over her head and drag her away screaming. We heard the (female) newscaster refer to her as a whore.

        If women are only safe from rape and sexual assault in the full public view in Egypt when they’re within your “remarkable safe burqa” then — there are no men in Egypt. What they have are not men. Because quite simply, real men don’t rape. Rapists rape.

    • Hi Jeremy,

      I attended AUC in Cairo, and must admit that my 1st year there was quite harrowing. There seemed to be a lot of commentary and overtly offensive looks, every time I stepped out into the street, even though I am neither blonde nor European. I didn’t understand Arabic, and the whole combination was very difficult. I sincerely considered leaving Egypt altogether; the noise, pollution, dirty looks, snide remarks.. everything just wore me down. Perhaps I was just young and inexperienced. By the end of the year, I must have succeeded in building a protective shell of some sort, as I tuned out the men, the streets, and all that I had found disturbing. I made lots of friends, and learned how to navigate the social system (which is quite unlike that in any other country I have lived in), and began to actually enjoy and appreciate Egypt and the Egyptians.

      One cannot compare Cairo to Amman, or Egypt to Jordan, or any other Arab country. Cairo is the only Arab megapolis; an ancient and humungous town teeming with life, and all that is good and bad. Jordanians don’t live in a crammed space, on top of each other, and don’t have the same sort of poverty that exists in Egypt, that grinding, hopelessness that drives those with nothing to lose.

      A French friend of mine, blonde and blue-eyed, was planning a work-related trip to Khartoum. She asked my advice, and I said to wear a hijab, and not go out in the street, and never take a cab, and keep away from shanty towns and slums, and take a couple of good books to read as she’d be closeted in her hotel room the entire week. I also advised her to stop in Cairo on the way home to recover from Khartoum.

      To my amazement, she called to tell me that my advice had been useless as no one in Khartoum had even looked at her twice, that she had taken all the public transport (which I wouldn’t dare do), visited everything, had felt safe, and had not had to wear a headscarf even once. I was truly surprised; and even more so when she complained that no sooner had she set foot in Cairo, she was besieged by hecklers and guys hitting on her, she went straight back to the airport and flew home.

      This is not to say that Sudan is better than Egypt or anything of the sort. The reasons may be linked to the fact that Egypt is a major tourist destination, and millions of Egyptians are directly dependent upon tourism and its associated services for their livelihoods; whereas Sudan is off the tourist track. I have seen western women who came to Egypt with the intention of meeting Egyptian men; this is quite common, and the same can be said of Tunisia, Morocco, and even some African countries.

    • thanks a lot but we ain’t a camel jockeys !! :s wanna know who we are look into NASA scientists , check Dr. Ahmed Zewail & Taha Hussien & Naguieb Mahfouz & many many many more who teached your people how to think & how to use there minds !! we ain’t fouls we once was the greatest Nation in the world ! I don’t need to say any thing more than this !

      • Exactly why they don’t live or work in Egypt. Your a fool to say that your county was once the greatest, your country has been destroyed by KSA and other Arab countries promoting the Muslim Brotherhood. Now look at your poor country, you will have nothing because of the Brotherhood. I lived in Port Said and Cairo, the more Islamic the people are, the dirty they live. Sick to see how people destroyed the beaches of Port Said and throwing trash on the streets in Cario, but hell, they always gonna go pray in public so the rest of the world knows they are “Religious”. A bunch of hypocrites, this attitude of abuse comes from Mohammad anyway, he married a girl at 6 and had sex with her at 9 for God SAKE! WAKE UP.

      • I’m not gonna talk dirty as you !

        but read history & you’ll know what Ancient Egyptians teach for the whole world ! until now they made things no one can discover how did they do it !

        our country didn’t get destroyed by Ksa m it was the Turkish who fucked it !

        what you talked about the beaches & trash Dear sir that’s what You got after over 40 years of Bad Education !!! No more manners or health care !!

        Don’t tell to wake Up cause I am , You wake Up & Read !!

      • & I’m not going to talk about my Prophet ” Mohamed ” cause i don’t need to follow that Zionism shit about marring kids & what ever , i know Who I’m following !

        They even don’t respect ” Jesus ” !! how do I suppose to expect them to respect ” Mohamed ” !!

      • Dear sir, let me show you exactly what your contribution to the world of science is:

        Muslim population: 1.2 BILLION
        No of nobel prize winners: 8 (only 2 in science)

        Jewish population: 13 million
        No of nobel prize winners: 166 (121 in science)

  108. Natasha Smith, I saw the video of the attack that happened to you. and the report said that you will go back to complete your paper. PLEASE how can I reach you so that next time you’re here, I’d make my best to protect you. Its such a very sad story and I googled you to be able ot find any contact to tell you this!

  109. On behalf of theall egyptions amd mouslimes arround the world i say ” we are sorry natasha ” for what you suffered and faced in egypt , believe me it’s not egypt and it’s not islam , in any country and in any place in the world there’s bad people and good people so iwish u forgive us and visit egypt again and meet the true egyption’s …

    • Stay away from Egypt…its the worst place on earth…and yes it has to do with the culture, yes it has to do with Islam. Go back and look at photos from the 50’s, it was a normal country…today its totally screwed up.

  110. i am hear to give testimony of how i got back my husband, we got married for more than 9 years and have gotten two kids. thing were going well with us and we are always happy. until one day my husband started to behave in a way i could not understand, i was very confused by the way he treat me and the kids. later that month he did not come home again and he called me that he want a divorce, i asked him what have i done wrong to deserve this from him, all he was saying is that he want a divorce that he hate me and do not want to see me again in his life, i was mad and also frustrated do not know what to do,i was sick for more than 2 weeks because of the divorce. i love him so much he was everything to me without him my life is incomplete. i told my sister and she told me to contact a spell caster, i never believe in all this spell casting of a thing. i just want to try if something will come out of it. i contacted traditionalspelltemple for the return of my husband to me, they told me that my husband have been taken by another woman, that she cast a spell on him that is why he hate me and also want us to divorce. then they told me that they have to cast a spell on him that will make him return to me and the kids, they casted the spell and after 1 week my husband called me and he told me that i should forgive him, he started to apologize on phone and said that he still live me that he did not know what happen to him that he left me. it was the spell that he traditionalspelltemple casted on him that make him comeback to me today,me and my family are now happy again today. thank you traditionalspelltemplefor what you have done for me i would have been nothing today if not for your great spell. i want you my friends who are passing through all this kind of love problem of getting back their husband, wife , or ex boyfriend and girlfriend to contact traditionalspellhospital@gmail.com and you will see that your problem will be solved without any delay.

    • You have no reason to say that…besides there are witnesses and video footage.

      The way to deal with sexual assault here is to fight it, not deny it.

  111. Pingback: Voices of the Week (25/06 – 02/07) | Hollaback! Brussels

  112. Sorry for what happened to you. This is outrageous. Yes dear there are a lot of animals around, and more frustrated they are the more dangerous they can get. i HOPE that with the so called damned Arabic fucking spring, many animals will turn to humans. As an Arabic christian – Lebanese actually -, i can tell that : pray for those who did bad to you, and forgive them, that is what Jesus Christ taught us to do.

    • @swissindipendentpeaceworker. I’m really disgusted about your reaction and what you are writing here. I see no reason why natasha smith would make something like this up. From female friends in Cairo I’ve personally heard several stories like that, even though none this grave. Plus, who are you to call yourself swissindipedentpeaceworker? Your english writing tells me that you are not really swiss. And as a peaceworker you should know better than to write stuff like that. In any case: shame on you!

      • ja doch ich bin aus der schweiz-und als demokratisch denkender mensch darf ich hier sagen was ich denke

      • @swissindependantpeaceworker geehrte Ungläubigen demokratische Schweizer Arschloch, Es gibt auch keinen Beweis dafür, dass die Luft die Du atmest, oder dass Elektrizität, Gravitation oder Magnetismus existiert, da Du es nicht sehen kannst. Vieleicht existierst du auch nicht. ‘ ist mir eigentlich sceiss egal.

      • My bad, an Schweizer Gymnasien lernt man normalerweise besser Englisch und als Peaceworker solltest du ein bisschen auf der Welt rumgekommen sein, jedenfalls soviel, dass du nicht ganz naiv bist was alles passieren kann. Zum Thema: Das hat mit Demokratie nichts viel zu tun, höchstens mit Meinungsfreiheit, wenn du in diese Richtung gehen willst. Aber das ist absolut nicht der Punkt. Es geht vielmehr darum, dass man Opfer von Gewalt nicht noch beschimpft und nach Beweisen fordert, die gar nicht erbracht werden können und so noch ein zweites Mal einer Tortur unterzieht, die unter Umständen fast noch schlimmer ist als der Vorfall selbst. Ja, es ist möglich, sie kann die Geschichte erfunden haben, aber die Wahrscheinlichkeit ist äusserst klein und die Wahrscheinlichkeit, dass du einer Person, die schon genug leid erfahren hat noch mehr zufügst ist sehr gross. Wieso solltest du soetwas machen? Zudem kannst du dich besser informieren: Denn egal ob diese bestimmte Geschichte erfunden ist oder nicht: Es gibt sehr viele andere ähnliche Fälle von Kairo, die können gar nicht alle erfunden sein.

    • You mean the mob was inconsiderate enough to rob her of her phone so she could video it all for you?

      Lots of sand up there in that stone age desert for a country.
      Keep your head buried in it – or watch the video.

      • read the history again ,,,, coz u r blind ,, u will see the difference between a 7000 years civilization and a 250 years one ,,

  113. A lady more who lost her illusions about Islam. If all the journalists of the world would tell the truth about the Arab ‘spring’, future would be nicer, I believe. But the lies go on and on. When you listen to Belgian radio you’d think this ‘revolution’ has something to do with freedom. Of course it has something to do with freedom. It is a fight for the freedom to slaughter, plunder and rape. That’s why these shitty muslims attacked Mubarak. He wanted a civilized country. Poor naïeve fellow! he didn’t understand that you cannot embed civilization in an Islamic environment.

  114. As Natasha case demonstrates Muslim violence against Infidels and other Muslims are not isolated episodes. They are part of an ongoing process that has accompanied Islam throughout its entire history. In fact, the absolute majority of Muslims who die a violent death are not killed by “infidels”: they are slaughtered by other Muslims. Therefore, if the Western appeasers definition of peace has anything at all in common with mine, Islam, contrary to their opinion, is not about peace at all. If you disagree, I will be grateful if you share your definition of peace with me.

    Maybe it is about deep personal beliefs? Let’s see. Islam is the only religion in the modern world that accepts forced conversions. Just a few years ago, two Western journalists were abducted in Gaza and held for ransom — also a uniquely Islamic practice. While in captivity, they were given a simple choice: convert to Islam or die. They converted. Not a single person of any authority in the entire Dar el-Islam has objected against that rape. And why would they? For 14 centuries Mohammad’s followers have spread Islam by the sword. For 14 centuries that worked for them. Why stop now?

    I am no hero myself. I have to admit that if I were offered the same choice, I would, most probably, choose life and repeat the shahadah after my tormentors. But how would those foreign sounds that are utterly meaningless to me, sounds that were forced out of me by the gun at my temple or a knife at my throat, change the way I feel towards Islam and everything it stands for? You can force someone to follow your rituals; you can even force someone to fight on your side. But can you force a person to believe or not to believe something? No more than you can force an Islamic country into democracy, even if the entire military might of the United States is at your disposal. No, dear left wing peace mongers, Islam has nothing to do with personal beliefs.

      • Ms. Smith’s ordeal happened in a country which follows the “religion of piss/peace.” And, frankly, such things only happen in the Islamic hell-holes of the world. Egypt is fast approaching mass famine – couldn’t happen to a nicer group of people.

      • @Attorney
        So, you claim that the problem is about Islam itself?

        Islam doesn’t have “hell-holes” as you said ;Islam exists in all countries around the world.
        Aren’t there Muslim people in your country?
        are they doing such things in your country?
        Is this type of attack happens only in Islamic countries among all countries in the world? haven’t you heard about sexual harassment committed by non Muslim man against woman in any non Muslim country?
        note that the people attacked her were probably Muslims, but people saved her were diffidently Muslims. why have you noticed the bad thing and turned a blind eye to good deeds?
        if it is a problem about Islam itself, Muslim people weren’t to save her.
        i repeat it: it is an ethical, ethical, ethical problem.

  115. hy everybody i was travelling some times to cairo to egypt-sinai…its a very sad story but this has nothing to do with islam-islam does not learn to rape a woman-does not say to beat a woman.its so sad but humans have to go behind the facts…egypt people and specially from cairo are wonderful humans-as an traveller i can tell…all over the world there are brutal humans…i just hopr that this woman can go over it from this shock….

      • 4 (34) Men are the protectors and maintainers of women, because Allah has given the one more (strength) than the other, and because they support them from their means. Therefore the righteous women are devoutly obedient, and guard in (the husband´s) absence what Allah would have them guard. As to those women on whose part ye fear disloyalty and ill-conduct, admonish them (first), (Next), refuse to share their beds, (And last) beat them (lightly); but if they return to obedience, seek not against them Means (of annoyance): For Allah is Most High, great (above you all).

        4 (34) Alrrijalu qawwamoona AAala alnnisa-i bima faddala Allahu baAAdahum AAala baAAdin wabima anfaqoo min amwalihim faalssalihatu qanitatun hafithatun lilghaybi bima hafitha Allahu waallatee takhafoona nushoozahunna faAAithoohunna waohjuroohunna fee almadajiAAi waidriboohunna fa-in ataAAnakum fala tabghoo AAalayhinna sabeelan inna Allaha kana AAaliyyan kabeeran

        الرِّجَالُ قَوَّامُونَ عَلَى النِّسَاءِ بِمَا فَضَّلَ اللَّهُ بَعْضَهُمْ عَلَىٰ بَعْضٍ وَبِمَا أَنفَقُوا مِنْ أَمْوَالِهِمْ ۚ فَالصَّالِحَاتُ قَانِتَاتٌ حَافِظَاتٌ لِّلْغَيْبِ بِمَا حَفِظَ اللَّهُ ۚ وَاللَّاتِي تَخَافُونَ نُشُوزَهُنَّ فَعِظُوهُنَّ وَاهْجُرُوهُنَّ فِي الْمَضَاجِعِ وَاضْرِبُوهُنَّ ۖ فَإِنْ أَطَعْنَكُمْ فَلَا تَبْغُوا عَلَيْهِنَّ سَبِيلًا ۗ إِنَّ اللَّهَ كَانَ عَلِيًّا كَبِيرً
        In the English translation the adverb lightly is inserted by the translator. It is not a part of the Arabic original. A muhammadan man is sanctioned by his holy book to beat his spouse(s), and not only with a siwak.

      • Yes I agree, as a former Muslim it does state this in Quran 4:34, thus the reason I am no longer a muslim.

  116. I bet everyone now knows why a revolution happened in Egypt… A lot of things need to change around here, I really want to say sorry as an Egyptian… But I can’t, no words will ever be enough.

  117. i dont know wat to say am realy so sorry fr ths all as an egyptian girl am sorry fr ths too much if ur ths story is real bt i wounder when ths happened ???????? we heared nothing abt sexual harrassment in tahrir square i gone there befre bt ths square was full of good ethics nothing frm ths was happeneing at the time of 25th jan revoloution …..my heart is acheing since i red ths story feeling so embarssed …i say sory again to u sister …our cultur is not and never been and will never goes like ths …..if ths story is fake i ll never forgive u realy as u giving bad repution to us and to our country and to islam ………

  118. 😥 😥 😥 we r sry
    plz and dnt hate Egypt 10% only r like dogs and other 90% r good one plz plz forgive us and pray 2 jesus 2 forgive us 😦

  119. hi natasha smith …
    my name is phillippe moussa
    i am egyptian …..i just wanted to say sorry 😦
    God bless ur life

  120. Natasha .. One million Aahabibty your safety and the safety on you Lord you’re fine now .. I am Egyptian and Ruby Ahabit know you said that Egypt and its people pretty good Jaddaaa, but unfortunately just in the ads fulfilled for spies and in Egypt because of the high rate of ignorance like this happened and think Maaky Lanka spy .. I Batdhir Lekki Jaddaaa and I love Aúolk that all of Egypt was safe and I am your girl Bnzel at any time, all the time and there is no Mae never no respect for the woman has, but unfortunately the verbal events Elly got Maaky stemming from the people we want the image and shape of Egypt shaking in front of the world .. Welcome Aahabibty your safety and Becky in Egypt at any time and we all open our homes to Lekki Lord Zaalana and you may be not beyond mishap and de Tenseeha I Arefh difficult to forget that Avatar Please try again .. Kter regret at the event Meka .. : (

  121. here is a story for all those who claim Muslims are terrorists. this story is to tell u that terrorism has no religion
    1-june-2009, from 2 years ago a Muslim girl called Marwa Elsherbine was murdered by a German citizen, born in Perm, Russia but claiming German ethnic origin ,abuse at El-Sherbiny in a public playground for children in Dresden,El-Sherbiny, wearing an Islamic headscarf, was called an ‘Islamist’, ‘terrorist’ and ‘slut’. Others present tried to intervene, but Alex W. continued the verbal abuse for several minutes until the police arrived at the scene, directing epithets in Russian and German at the Russian-speaking bystanders who tried to reason with him

    Alex W. was charged with defamation, pressed by El-Sherbiny as any civilized and rational person would do, and found guilty by the district court of Dresden, issuing a fine of 780 Euro. During the trial Alex W. claimed mitigating circumstances for the act of insulting El-Sherbiny, suggesting that ‘people like her’ were not real humans and therefore cannot be insulted. The Public Prosecutor successfully appealed the verdict to achieve a higher conviction due to the openly xenophobic character of the incident. . At the appeal hearing at the regional court in Dresden, 1 July 2009, eight persons were present in the courtroom: a panel of one professional and two lay judges, the prosecutor, Alex W. as the defendant, his defense counsel, El-Sherbiny as witness for the prosecution, and her husband and son as observers. No security personnel was present and no security searches of individuals and their possessions were carried out, common in cases without anticipated security concerns and with no persons under arrest present. After El-Sherbiny had testified, Alex W. strode across the courtroom and attacked her with a knife with an 18 cm (7 in) long blade, which he had taken into the courtroom in his backpack. El-Sherbiny received multiple stab wounds to the upper body and arm (at least 16). During the attack Alex W. was allegedly shouting ‘You don’t deserve to live!’ While trying to protect his wife, El-Sherbini’s husband Elwy Ali-Okaz was also stabbed. A police officer, who was in the court building testifying in an unrelated case was called to the scene to intervene, but mistook Elwy Ali-Okaz for the attacker and shot him in the lower leg. A criminal investigation against the police officer was ongoing as of 25 August 2009. Marwa El-Sherbiny died on the scene, succumbing to her injuries. Alex W. was arrested on the scene.Elwy Ali-Okaz, Marwa’s husband, critically wounded in the stabbing attack, was in a coma for two days. He subsequently received physical therapy for several weeks in a hospital near Dresden for the stabbing and shooting injuries. Mustafa, son of Marwa was present in the court room. German officials rejected to hand over son to Egyptian embassy and set him to an orphanage after incident. Marwa’s family had known about the murder 2 days later, through a friend in Germany, and not through the Egyptian embassy in Germany. Tarek ElSherbiny Says Germany has responded poorly to his sister’s murder Alex W. was held on remand on suspicion of murder of Marwa El-Sherbiny and attempted murder of Elwy Ali Okaz. He was formally charged with murder, which carries a maximum sentence of life in prison, attempted murder and grievous bodily harm by the public prosecutor’s office on 25 August 2009. Prosecutors cited hate against non-Europeans and Muslims as the motive, perfidiousness as a qualifying feature for the murder charge, and full criminal responsibility as the result of a psychiatric evaluation. His trial has been tentatively scheduled to begin on 26 October 2009 . Elwy Ali Okaz is intending to act in the role of co-plaintiff for the trial.. As of 25 August 2009 Alex W. had made no statement to investigators. An application for a change of venue by W.’s defense lawyer was refused by the upper regional court (Oberlandesgericht).

    • I’m sorry, but one solitary incident of a German man assaulting a Muslim woman does not disprove “terrorism” (which has absolutely no bearing on this blog post, by the way) nor does it negate the horrific and systematic sexual harassment, rape, degradation, and genital mutilation suffered by Muslim women at the hands of Muslim men. It is fortunate the incident mentioned above did not feature an Egyptian man, for it is certain if it did there would never have been any criminal charges.

    • Just for a correction in your understanding , it is always better to blame the socio political cultures whose followers rule certain parts of world , justify the crimes of human beings who dare to be different.
      For proper nouns sake you may use the following.
      Sharia for all world.
      IRAN, Pakistan, etc
      Non Beleivers,
      Forced Conversions, rapes,
      Unnoticed, unpunished attacks on non believers ( Dhimmis ) or weak believers ,specially children and women by LAW of lands of Sharia..
      Now lets have example of institutionalization of such religious atrocities from non believers part of governments.

    • Did you notice something?
      You even “reported” it yourself?
      He was charged, tried, convicted and sentenced – on both counts.

    • Venting your anger or hate against poor unarmed muslims is wrong.

      But this does not prove anything. The religion of Islam is like ‘EVIL PERSONIFIED’ in this world.

      1. Quaran teaches (commands) muslims to hate all other religions: jews, christians, idol-worshippers, west. Not just in a few verses but in copious amounts. Then it goes further & commands them to KILL these non-believers – wherever you find them. If you read those verses – you would be amazed at the level of violence advocated in a holy book (THE most important holy book of the muslims). It talks about jihad in over 160 verses. And thousands of verses in the hadiths (which document the life & words of muhammad), shariya law etc.

      In fact – THE MOST IMPORTANT THING A MUSLIM CAN DO IS WAGE WAR – DO JIHAD & KILL PEOPLE. Yes, there is nothing else that would get them heaven like doing jihad. That is what Islam teaches.

      2. It clearly commands them to struggle & fight until there is the rule of Islam all over the world. So in other words – even if you want peace, try to be good to them, there is no peace possible. EVER!

      3. They can have 4 wives, are free to have sex with slave girls. After a war, they can take the women as sex-slaves. Even in 2012 – there is a woman MP (from this very hellhole of Egypt) who was pushing for a law where they can ‘buy’ female prisoners of wars from non-muslim countries. The other journalist who suffered a similar fate in Egypt – while being attacked one of the men shouted – she is a jew (probably as an attempt to justify the rape in their own minds).

      4. They say – the blood & property of a non-muslim is the right of a muslim to own.

      5. These are not my biased views – I have heard debates and the muslim response to these questions. And there was nothing to give me any hope. Not only that – you read about the life of Muhammad and the same thing. Then I heard what the mullas were preaching, what was being taught in the books – and again the same pattern. Hatred and venom against jews (especially Israel), christians, hindus, buddhists, the west. Declarations of jihad. Mob justice & death fatwas – for minor mistakes. Finally you see what the muslims are doing – and that too is consistent with what is being taught to them and how it generates some of the most brutal animals and killers.

      I am sorry, but it is truly a factory for EVIL. Simply cannot be compared with anything else in the world. I TRULY believe that Islam is the religion of satan. Watch the following videos on youtube:

      1. Islamization of Europe:

      2. Three stages of jihad:

      3. The third jihad:

  122. All of these men needs to be brutally killed and murdered, I am so sorry for what happened to you, please do not visit any arabic country ever, even ourselves arabs hate it here, everything is so corrupt.

    God, please, kill them all, make them suffer, for our sakes…Amen..

    • loooool please speak for your self, we Egyptians love our country, am married and i love my Egyptian man so much that i will die for him, he loves me and treats me like a queen and i know aloooooot of ppl the same way so speak for your self

  123. Pingback: Women’s Revolution « Buildingmydoor

  124. I really don’t know what is more creepy: The fact of being raped or the fact that you went there naively. I think the latter is more creepy. Thank you very much for reading.

  125. Let’s look at this scenario: first the countries of the OIC (the Ummah) declare war on some non muhammadan countries, the United Kingdom of Great Britain for instance. Knights of the Ummah then capture unbelieving British women and than sell them on the slave markets of the middle east. This scenario have been played in the past (the Ummayad, the Abasid, the Ottoman onslaught to mention a few). Horrifying to us kufaar people. That’s why we should be for ever vigilant less the abovementioned nightmare come true.

  126. WoW that reminded me of Michael jackson “Thriller” lol

    I really cant blv that any sane person would believe this story!

    Did you really buy this shit! you really believe that exaggerated story that if someone told me it happened in 18th century i would laugh and think of it as a joke!

    Suddenly while she was walking hundreds of men decided to get that chick and gang bang her! after she crossed that line all men became so evil but 5 seconds ago no one even looked at her!

    Well i just laugh when i read her story and i laugh even more when i find others who believe that girl! she need to get her head examined! really did you buy this crap LOL

    • We can only hope it happens to you one day (even if you’re a man, hopefully in prison, while bending over to get the soap) so all others can have a good laugh at your story.

  127. Being a true mumina ms. Rehaab wil agree with mrs. Salwa al Mutairi. It’s allright to treat kafir women as slaves.

    In the age of instant information many a truth how ugly it may be will be exposed in the harsh light of honest scrutiny.

    • The lady did not say treat Kafir women as slaves but POWs. You and your moral logic has only been the ‘norm’ over the say past 100 years or slightly more. Slaves exist even now and the biggest trader is the UN/NATO the officials working for which have been caught over and over again for running the sex slave rings with the mafia. Secondly, slaves have clearly defined rights and there are responsibilities on the master – so its not a free for all party. People like you fail to understand history/practices and define normallcy based on your limited experience which is only applicable to your lifetime. Humans have existed thousands of years before and will exist after you… some laws are made for eternity.

      • @ MIKEPeople like you has the morals of sewer rodents. Shame on you. Those officials are criminals. This “lady” USE “RELIGIOUS ” JUSTIFICATIONS TO JUSTIFY slavery. She is wright because the muhammadansm justify slavery. Muhammad himself was a wholesale slave trader.

      • “Some laws are made for eternity…??”
        Yeah… let’s re-institute the slave trade so average good Muslim men can go fuck slave girls instead of fornicating.

    • I can’t write my comment on your reply below so i’ll post my comment here.
      you asked me to prove the points you were talking about, and i’ve many.
      but first, do you understand Arabic language?

      before replying i want to say some quick notes:
      – you asked me to prove that Quraan includes parts stating that men should free some slaves if committed sins. this was stated in 13 different “ayat” in quran i will mention some of them:

      -Surat “Al Tawba” aya: 60
      إنّما الصّدقات للفقراء والمساكين والعاملين عليها والمؤلّفة قلوبهم وفي الرقاب والغارمين وفي سبيل الله وابن السبيل فريضةً من الله والله عليم حكيم ) (٢).
      the word وفي الرقاب
      -Surat “Al Nesaa2” aya:92 talking about the case if Muslim kills another Muslim by fault.
      – Surat “Al Balad” aya:13 فك رقبة
      – Surat “Muhammad” aya: 4
      -Surat “Al ma’eda (5)” aya: 89
      -surat “Al Mujadala” aya: 3
      – Hadith in “Sa7ee7 al Bokhari”, 6337 and “sa7ee7 Muslim” 1509
      – check that link
      http://sunnah.com/bukhari/49

      There are too many proofs but in Arabic language.

      Allah “not prophet Muhammad” hasn’t forbid slavery completely.but before Islam slavery has many many forms. Islam forbids them all except in Wars or “ghazwas”between Muslims and non Muslims. and that is for a reason. if you understand Arabic, i’ll post a link of “Sheikh Shaarawi” talking about why Islam doesn’t forbid slavery of non muslims in Wars.

      anyways, in the story of miss.smith, she is a visitor that came to the country in peace.not in war, so, if i assumed that you’re right and muslim treats non muslim women as slaves (In war only), the condition is not satisfied here cause she came in peace not in war.
      + these harassment are committed also from time to time by Muslim men against Muslim women here in Egypt.if they are religious, they should obey
      their Islam and stop committing that at least against Muslim women.
      therefore, it is not a religious problem.it is ethical problem and those men don’t obey Islam, if they are muslim.

      that situation rarely happens in Egypt, too many foreign tourists come to visit Egypt and spend their time in peace enjoying the country. I’ve never heard that the situation frequently happens.

      • Dear ms. Rehaab.
        Thank you for your reaction. I also apologize for my answer, but I think that your comment deserves a considerate answer.
        My proficiency in Arabic left much to be desired but I receive plenty of help from a good friend, a Semitist by profession. In general I read English translations and seek the help of a. good friend, a Semitist, for further clarification. For instance: I use the Guillaume translation of the Sira , and he takes the trouble to check passages in his Arabic copy of it.
        You’re in the right concerning manumission (the freeing of individual cases). It’s in the qur’an and ahadith.
        I’m right concerning abolition (the total repudiation of the principle and system of slavery, the ownership of one human being by another human being). Muhammadanism will never abolish slavery because it is part of the system of the religion of submission. Muhammad started his rise to power and riches by selling the women and children of Banu Qurayza into slavery.
        Slavery as an institution will be extant until the end of time:
        Q.33:50 – O Prophet! We have made lawful to you your wives and those whom your right hand possesses out of those whom Allah has given to you as prisoners of war…
        “When will the Hour be established?” Allah’s Apostle replied, “The answerer has no better knowledge than the questioner. But I will inform you about its portents. 1. When a slave (lady) gives birth to her master. 2. When the shepherds of black camels start boasting and competing with others in the construction of higher buildings. And the Hour is one of five things which nobody knows except Allah. The Prophet then recited: “Verily, with Allah (Alone) is the knowledge of the Hour–.” (31. 34)” Sahi Bukhari: 2:47
        http://www.searchtruth.com/book_display.php?book=2&translator=1&start=37&number=43

        Harassing, molesting or raping of women are not slavery of course but these phenomena come from the same mindset. Women are inferior to man. Q. 4.3, 4. 34 for instance.
        According to an imam in Australia, Sheik Taj Din al-Hilali, the nation’s most senior Muslim cleric, compared immodestly-dressed women who do not wear the Islamic headdress with meat that is left uncovered in the street and is then eaten by cats.
        Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-412697/Outrage-Muslim-cleric-likens-women-uncovered-meat.html#ixzz1zeLdrd1m
        You are right in the formal sense. In order to capture slaves the mumineen have first to call the unbelievers to convert. If they refuse, the people of the book must accept the dhimmi status and pay the jizyya with willing submission. If they refuse both alternatives they must be attacked and subjugated and taken into slavery. The rest (polytheists) must either convert or be attacked. Refusal results in destruction or slavery. Formally a war of subjugation must be declared by the caliph, a vacant position at this moment. But according to mrs. Salwa al Mutairi (after consulting ulama in Saudi Arabia and Kuwait), it is perfectly legal to buy slaves from war zones.
        Sheik Abu Ishak al Huweiny for instance longs for the day when the caliphate will be re-established, attacks can be unleashed and slaves can be taken. According to this sheik, slavery will boost the Egyptian economy no end.

      • Seems to happen rather frequently to young pretty female foreign journalists with blonde hair …. this case is not unique.

        A religion that says it’s okay to enslave women today if they’re of a different religion needs some serious reformation.

        BTW. Captured enemy soldiers are POW’s not the civilian population of the defeated side. Claiming the women as POW’s is bending language; and claiming them as “spoils of war sex slaves” shows just how backward this religion and some adherents are.

        That Kuwaiti woman is advocating the reintroduction of the slave trade so that “average good Muslim men” can go fornicate with slave girls instead of un-enslaved girls. And all because her religion doesn’t forbid it. Somehow, for her, fornication’s not fornication if the woman has no say in the act. And BTW: no say = rape.

        Christianity and Judaism at their basic levels don’t forbid slavery either – but all decent people do.

  128. @ the right honourable ms. Rehaab
    You stated: “third, to all commentators who expressed their hatred to Islam, you look like ignorant, READ ABOUT ISLAM FIRST BEFORE YOU SPEAK IN ORDER NOT TO LOOK LIKE IGNORANT”
    Here I must contradict you. I’m not ignorant in cases pertaining to muhammadanism. I’ve taken the trouble to read the qur’an, the Sirat Rasul Allah, the sahih ahadith al Bukhari and Muslim, the Muwatta of Malik ibn Annas, the Sunan of Abu Daud, fragments of Tabari, the Tafsir al Jalalayn, hadith ibn Majah, etc., etc.
    I recommend you take a look in your own copies (if you don’t have hard copies of some works you can consult on line versions) of the abovementioned works to verify if I’m ignorant and talking arrant nonsense.
    If a criminal, warlord, rapist, mass murderer, highway robber, paedophile concocted a “religion” the subsequent ethics can only be horrendous and disgusting.
    Egyptians and other Middle East people are as intelligent in the genetic sense as any people living around the world. But because of the horrible, gigantic meme of muhammadanism, the whole region has been mired in misery and ignorance for a very long time.

    • sir, i’ve been hesitated to reply as i believe that the problem is not a religious problem. Can you guarantee that all of those people were muslims? so i believe that arguing for that point is irrelevant and we shouldn’t mix moral problem with religious problem.but, what you have mentioned deserves a reply.

      seems that you’ve read alot about Islam. but have you read anything about Arab people before Islam? to know about a religion, you should know about people that this religion targets. their lifestyle before it, their traditions,etc.and why that religion targeted those people. If you don’t have knowledge about that point, let me tell you that Arabs in the era of “Jaheliya”;the era before Islam, had more and more oppressive traditions against women.
      before Islam, girls were being buried alive “female infanticide”, after Islam, It has become forbidden.

      about slavery. slavery is one of the oldest Arabic tradition, not Islamic tradition.
      It were an Arabic habit to slave foreigner men and women. it is one of their basic and daily habits.
      so, it’s not strange to be mentioned in Quraan. when “slaves” or “melk-Yameen” are mentioned in Quraan,it is because having slaves in such society is not strange, but it surely doesn’t mean that Islam gives muslims the order to have slaves.

      for example, if you’re used to doing something,say, playing a certain game. if i told you: “when you’re playing that game , do the following.”. It means that is your habit and i don’t deny or forbid it, but it also doesn’t mean that I give you an order to do it. it is not a command, but it is your habit.

      on the contrary, if you read all Quraan, you’ll find some “ayat” that tell muslims if they committed sins, they should set some slaves free so that Allah forgive them.that means that slavery is not recommended in Islam. but it is not forbidden directly in one step cause it were,in addition to wine, part of Arab commercial system and they had benefits from it, so it has been important to forbid it gradually like wine,not suddenly like female infanticide.

      nowadays, there is no slavery in Islam.

      so, slavery WERE not denied then; in the era of Muhammad. However, Abu Bakr (Muhammad’s freind) was famous for setting slaves free, he was buying them then set them free.

      another point to add to your knowledge, if you don’t know it, In Islam,in the era of Muhammad, If a muslim had sex with female slave and she gave birth, he should set her free.

      all points that i mentioned prove that slavery and having sex with female slaves were one of the ancient Arabic traditions, not Islamic. Islam put many rules to reduce and forbid slavery gradually.as they had benefits from it (from ancient Arabs point of view), Islam didn’t forbid it suddenly.

      Islam is the most Religion that respects women.

      hope you got my points.and sorry for my bad English

      • Dear ms. Rehaab
        Thank you for taking the trouble to answer me.
        You stated that the problem is not religiously based, but in your country and most countries in the region the muhammadan religion is so dominant even paramount (since 14 centuries) and the main constituent of the cultures of the region. Most problems in the ummah has a religious component to it. It is probable that the people violating ms. Smith are muslims because this is a crowd celebrating Morsi, a leading Muslim brother to the presidency. Nothing is more relevant in the muslim world than the relogion of Muhammad.
        You refer to the jahiliyya, an era depicted by muslim authors in the blackest of colours as justification for the atrocities of Muhammad. History are most times written by the victors. You stated that in the pre-muhammadan era the traditions are hostile to women. As to female infanticide, can you give me a reference as to the deficit of young women in the Arab communities? The imbalance of the male-female ratio must have been staggering.
        Slavery is the original sin of humanity and is not an invention of Muhammad. But Muhammad did not abolish it either. On the contrary. After killing between 600 and 900 men of the Jewish tribe of Banu Qurayza, the “holy prophet” sold their women and children into slavery and took one fifth (20 %) of the proceeds. One of the chapters of the “holy” qur’an is titled Al Anfaal. The Kuwaiti politician Salwa al Mutairi is right when she advocated the reintroduction of sex slavery because slavery is on of the fundamentals of Islam.
        Can you give me the sura and ayat stating that Muslims must man
        umit some slaves when they have sinned or if they have begotten children with slave women?
        Muhammad and his successors did not abolish slavery. Slavery was en still is a constituent oart of muhammadanism and is still being practiced in some part of the muslim world like Darfur or Mauritania. In the 19th century Muslim corsairs in the Mediterranean raided coasts of Christian lands to enslave the population. American president Jefferson sent warships to put and and to this form of ghazwa.
        In the Abbasid as well as in the Ottoman caliphates large harems were maintained filled robbed females and guarded by black eunuchs. A sure sign of large scale slavery.SLAVERY IS AN INTEGRAL PART OF MUHAMMADAN ISM.
        Can you refer me to the passages in the canonical scriptures were slavery had been abolished and the even forbidden?
        According to imam Abu Ishak al Huweiny and mrs. Salwa al Mutairi muhammadans will reintroduce slavery when they will reign supreme.
        Can you give me passages in the sira or ahadith stating that Atiq ibn Uthman or Abu Bakr ibn abu Quhafa (who gave his six year old daughter in marriage to his “friend” Muhammad) bought slaves for the sole purpose of manumitting them?
        I have read Mohammed Tidiane N’Diaye’s Le Génocide Voilé. It’s horrendous.
        I will be most beholden to you if you can proof using ahadith and tafsirs that slavery is forbidden. It will cure me of my advanced form of the illness of ISLAMOPHOBIA.
        You stated that Islam is the religion with the highest respect for women. Can you explain and interpret sura 4 aya 3 and 34?
        As a Grammar school teacher I like to transmit a positive image of Islam to my students.
        I thank you in advance, Al Mulhid

      • You are either wrong or blind. The problem is a religious one.
        It’s a religious one because you lot can’t get past the basic fundamentalism of your religion that allow and condones such behavior as slavery.

        That you actually spout the garbage that “Islam is the most Religion that respects women” means you’ve fallen for that ridiculous old religious propaganda line.

        Women under Islam are never the masters of their own fate – they remain forever minors under the law and in the eyes of their own people. That is not respect.
        Married Muslim women may be beaten by their husbands if they’re suspected of thinking wrong – that is not respect. (Good old 4:34)

        And if you insist that what your religion offers women “is respect” then your suspect respect is something I never want to meet – let alone ever be subject to.

  129. Pingback: Pray for Egypt - Page 2 - Christian Forums

  130. after i read your words, as an egyptian, i can only apologize to you about this sexual harassment & the physical attack that occured to you while you was in Tahrir Square , Egypt is in tough time now , people are misguided , i cant imagine myself in this situation , again accept my apology as an egyptian .
    God bless you

    • What an amazing person/thing you are. I’m sure you would feel the same way if this happened to your Wife/Husband/Brother/Sister.

  131. first of all i’d like to express my sympathy to you, if your story is true, and would like to tell you that the majority of Egyptians are not like those.

    second, I’m Egyptian Muslim girl living in Cairo and may face some of harassment but just weird words. almost all Egyptian girls face these situations daily but at most some weird words as i mentioned. there exists some special rare cases that girls are exposed to sexual harassment.

    third, to all commentators who expressed their hatred to Islam, you look like ignorant, READ ABOUT ISLAM FIRST BEFORE YOU SPEAK IN ORDER NOT TO LOOK LIKE IGNORANT. It’s not a religious problem. Islam doesn’t allow a man to touch a foreign woman unless she is her wife (foreign here means it’s not her wife). I wonder how do you link such problem to Islam?!!. It is a problem about morals. and add the following to your shallow knowledge: not all Egyptians are Muslims, not all Muslims are religious, If a Muslim’s behavior is bad, It doesn’t mean that Islam is bad.but it means that he doesn’t pursue Islamic rules of conduct. you read a part and ignored the other. who said that all of them were Muslims?!!, were they carrying labels with “hey, I’m Muslim” written on it? lol
    and have you read that people who saved her are Muslims too? Can’t you read?

    finally, It’s difficult for me to believe such story as i know many friends who visit Tahrir square daily and never faced or even witnessed such situations. but I feel pity on you, God bless you and again, don’t think that those are the Egyptians and Muslims, They are special cases who lack moral and religion.

  132. I utterly respect you and despise the behaviors of those throngs. Evil dispositions contrive to flourish in humans on all scales – from the throngs to the individual – and all over the world. Men have vast social and economic leverage over women and this is intrinsically wrong. I am so sorry.

  133. Natasha. I just wanted to let you know that I was touched by your blog post and the retelling I saw on CNN.com. As a psychologist in the US who (who now does nonprofit work around college student mental health) I was painfully reminded of so many clients I had seen in counseling when I worked at university counseling centers. Women and men who had been victimized or abused or oppressed and the pain and joy I felt in watching them try to put back the pieces after truly life-changing events. And the hope I always had for them that they would find the bravery and strength to move forward, not feel like a victim, but a survivor, and see what adventures life still held. You are a gifted writer and I look forward to seeing the documentary you complete. And lastly, there is nothing wrong with setting up a donation system — I would happily contribute and encourage others to do the same.

  134. Sorry to hear that; its too disturbing.
    For those who blame Islam, please get some education before you criticize.
    If I was there at that time; I would be protected you even if I will get killed. that what Islam tough us; to respect and protect the humanity despite the differences.
    Sorry again and hope you are well.

  135. it is Mubarak and SCAF militias they deliberately do such acts tp force women refrain from going and of course men will not go with fear that their women may be subject to these practices. It is not the first time they do this in Tahrir to drive people away. It is not a usual sexual harrasment act.

  136. I’m so, so sorry this happened to you. Whatever anyone says, it was in no way your fault. Please don’t listen to those who seek to blame anyone but those who perpetrate such abuse and who defend such actions. They are part of the problem, their disrespect one of the reasons why those that perpetrate these acts get off free.

    Please look after yourself, whatever you need to do to process and to heal, whatever help is needed. You are an incredibly strong, smart woman, and they can’t take that away from you, nor the love and respect of those who care about you. You have the well wishes of many of us, people who don’t know you but truly feel for you.

    To those who doubt her story: do you doubt those of every other female journalist who has encountered a similar situation? Do you honestly believe rape and molestation never happen? That despite all these stories, unless they meet some standard you’ve invented and the victims allow themselves to be examined by you (as if you’re some forensic expert!) that it must be false? Do you not realise that regardless of whether any one story is true, what is your excuse for disparaging victims as a whole, for ignoring the very real issue as a whole?

    And why should you not believe someone who says they’ve been hurt? Is it generally your policy to disbelieve anyone relating their experiences? Or is it only the vulnerable who have to fulfil some impossible standard? Millions of people who experience violence and abuse would not fulfil your standards: does that mean it never happened? Or that you’ve learned to defend perpetrators by rationing sympathy for victims. Sympathy for people’s experiences isn’t something to avoid giving if at all possible, it should be freely given if you really want to understand what went on. But of course, if you’re judgemental you’ll never really realise what went on, because you’re determined to tell yourself nothing could have happened. You’re lucky that you have that option: the millions of women and children who have lived through this did not have that option.

    You can’t accuse any one woman of trying to frame someone because there is no one person to frame. You can’t frame a baying mob: we all know humans are capable of anything when mob mentality takes over: we have numerous examples and even footage from history, denying that this is plausible is disingenuous.

    Do you honestly believe there are no ‘witnesses’ because none of the crazed crowd of rapists wanted to admit to abetting or perpetrating a crime that would lead to severe consequences to themselves? Do you believe someone so uncaring as to stand by and watch would come out and criticise it later? Did you go and personally hunt down everyone who was there amongst thousands of people and ask each one if they saw anything? Did you not consider that those who disapproved might risk danger to themselves if they speak out? Someone on the other side of the square may well not have known; that doesn’t mean it didn’t happen.

    This happened because of an oppressive, exploitative viewpoint of women, that whilst it might have been justified by Islam in these men’s eyes, is not the fault of any one religion, or necessarily religion at all; such attacks can and have been perpetrated by people from all backgrounds in the world. It is quite simply about exerting domination over women, and taking out their contempt on someone they saw as weaker and not worthy.

    This is real. And we need to stop it. All of us. And especially men. Especially Arab men. These rapists are co-opting your religion to spread hate. They are besmirching your country, your community, your identity. They respect you, they do not respect us. Change works from within, and Egyptian women need your help because women can’t fight sexual abuse and assault on our own: it is not a women’s problem, it is a HUMAN problem. In fact, it is a Men’s problem, because men are the majority of perpetrators. It is YOUR problem. Share these stories, talk about them in your community. Teach your boys and young men to respect women, teach each other that this behaviour is not allowed, and is not acceptable, and is not God’s will. And it is up to the rest of us from the outside to support that change.

    • Amazing, thoughtful and right on the spot Anne. I agree wholeheartedly.
      Anyone who further posts on this article should read this response before making vitriolic statements without stopping to think. The internet is a mob as well.
      Mrs. Smith, I am so amazed and proud of your dedication and your response to what happened. You represent the best of humanity in your ability to understand what has happened to you. I further apologize for the extreme comments on both sides from this article as well. Not everyone thinks this way, and I refuse to allow some lonely troubled people clacking furiously away at a keyboard to speak for the rest of us.

  137. Jackie Chan here (at least all the egyptian men here call me that name), trained martial art athlete, make sure next time you go to tahrir with me.

    • According to Leftist dogma, only white people can be racist. Muslims are considered by definition non-white. This leads to the conclusion that Muslims are worse than racists in their treatment of (other) People of Color.

  138. okay in Islam rapist are sentenced to death, so mentioning Islam in such an awful accident is offensive. if this story is true then am really sorry that such thing happened in my country and the men who did all really deserve to die. if it was me i would not hesitate for a second to get a gun and shoot them. so i cant really imagine what your feeling. but still my mind cant really grasp that this happened in Tahrir square with all these men involved. i have been to tahrir squar many times and am white with nice hair and i dress really normal pants and short sleeve shirts and nothing ever happened to me just a few words but thats it.

      • WHO IN THE WORLD ARE YOU CALLING A NIGGER??? ARABS ARE SOOOOO PREJUDICE They think they are superior they are just DESERT DOGS that the world HATES…LOOK HOW THEY TREAT THE NUBIANS AND INVADED EGYPT ARABS ARE VERY PREJUDICE!! ARABS FORCED ISLAMS ON THE AFRICANS AND WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR A SEGMENT OF THE AFRICAN SLAVE TRADE AND THEY ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR THE VIOLENCE IN SUDAN….YES PEACEFUL ISLAM AND ARABS DID THIS

    • BELIEVE IT OR NOT AM WHITE AND EGYPTIAN WITH HAZEL EYES AND BLOND HAIR =D AND I GO AROUND EGYPT AND NTHN EVER HAPPENED TO ME, I WENT TO TAHRIR SQUARE SEVERAL TIMES AND NTHN HAPPENED TO ME,
      SORRY NOEL BUT U DNT HAVE A CLUE ABT WHAT UR SAYING AND UR SOURCES ARE JUST MESSED UP, THE PROPHET PBUH FREED ALOT OF SLAVES AND DEMANDED THAT WE DO THE SAME, THE PROPHET’S LAST WORDS BEFORE HE DIE WAS “TAKECARE OF YOUR WOMEN AND TREAT THEM RIGHT, PROTECT THEM AND MAKE THEM HAPPY” I WISH EVERY MAN TREATS HIS WOMEN JUST LIKE THE PROPHET TREATED HIS. IN OTHER WORD LEAVE ISLAM OUT OF THIS EQUATION BECAUSE IF U REALLY GOT TO KNOW IT RIGHT U WILL NEVER LEAVE IT

  139. My Heart is bleeding about happened to you , since i first heard it , just wanted to tell you that the thugs of old regime whom are still free till now , they mean many times to do such stuff to Distorts the the revolution , wish soon you will come to share us – Egyptians – the happiness of fulfilling our revolution goals
    by the way – your case give me & many Egyptians males & females to do serious activities against women Harassment.
    Accept my deep apology & respect
    Aly Abugabal

  140. Islam is the most disgusting religion Mankind ever came up with. I myself am an ex-Muslim woman and I spit on the days I ever got to believe I was the piece of trash Islam made me think I was. Fucked up religion. Allah Fuckbar.

  141. هذا الفعل منافى لعادات وتقاليد الشعب المصرى ولكن ماذا تنتظرين من بعض القله اللذين عاشوا فى مستنقع الفساد فيه فى كل شى حتى اصبح الهواء الذى نتنفسه فاسد ولكن اعلمى ان هذا ليس من طبع الشعب المصرى وان فى التجمعات يندس الغوغائيين و الجهلاء وان مثل هذه الحوادث فى الايام العظيمه للثوره لاتعد على الاصابع اقبلى اعتزارى وان كنت لا ادرى ان كنتى ستقرأين رسالتى

  142. This kind of incidents can be expected in a country dominated by the religion of peace. The founder of this religion, Abu’l Qasim Muammad ibn Abdallah (A.D. 570-632) use to rape female captives of his jihad ghazwas, for instance Rayhanabint ‘Amr ibn Kunafa, or the daughter of Huyayy ibn Akhtab. And since this disgusting criminal is still considered a perfect human being (al insane al kamil) by his muhammadan adherents, whose conduct must be emulated, because he was the perfect example of conduct (uswa hasana) this appalling shenanigans will happen on a regular base. You don’t have to believe me.Read the Sirat Rasul Allah and the sahih ahadiths of Bukhari and Muslim for yourself.
    And for the rest: salaam alaikum.
    And as to the story of the Pakistani Christian family: “Good luck to you in your new home, Canada, after fleeing from that Muhammadan hellhole called Pakistan, the so called home of the pure.”

  143. Rape is a crime of power, not sexual desire, and it is not caused more frequently by uneducated or poor men than by educated, wealthy men. The latter have the money to cover it up by buying the victim’s silence or the police officer’s / prosecutor’s “cooperation.” Don’t fool yourselves into thinking rape is a product of education or income. That’s an incorrect stereotype. Rape will exist so long as a man wishes to exert power upon a woman, any education and income bracket will suffice!

  144. It is no coincidence that a society in which its majority religion and culture oppresses women to the benefit accrued to men, that sexual harassment and assault are rife. The only difference is that western women such as Natasha and Ms. Logan are willing to report it, whereas their Egyptian / Muslim counterpart victims will be raped and murdered by their own family for doing so. Such is the nature of a society that is built and depends on oppressing women and gays and lesbians. Not only is Egypt’s political system built on oppression and dictatorship, but its family structure as well. Think about how so many Egyptian men get this idea in their head that they can strip by force, rape, and murder any woman they please. Who wants to live in such a society, much less visit as a tourist? As history has shown, financial boycotts are second in effect to war. Since no war was ever waged to protect women, I urge a tourist boycott of Egypt. Hit them where it hurts, and they will change. Not because they’re enlightened enough to know right from wrong, that women have a civil right to not be touched or harassed independent of a particular man’s desire or opinion, but rather, because for such unprincipled rapists and harassers living in Egypt (probably 10 million out of population 80 million) need to earn a living as well. It is no comfort to the millions of victims of Mubarak and rapists that “most Egyptian” or “many Egyptian” men don’t rape, sexually assault, harass women. That so many Egyptian men don’t express outrage / place public pressure on the courts / dictators / society to change such immoral attitudes / lenient laws / lack of enforcement is the reason why a sufficient number of Egyptians rape, murder, and disrespect women. That the family of a victim of sexual assault would consider killing their daughter / kill her because she’s a victim shows a total lack of respect for a victim of sexual assault, a woman, and a human being. We can thank Egyptian immorality for spawning such a generation of uneducated, violent, and unthinking people. Don’t visit Egypt. Land of rape, murder, and human waste. The smart Egyptians emigrate. The rest remain in a cesspool of violence against women and children. May all you disgusting Egyptian sexual harassers (you know who you are) get what you deserve; an unhappy, short life. Shame on all of you.

  145. Nathasha, I feel much compassion with you. I hope you’ll go on and be a journalist because world need women journalists to witness what happens everywhere to women.
    I’m not religious neither … so I tell you : Humanity bless you, Natasha.
    I’m proud of you.
    Myriam, french, 40.

  146. Religion has nothing to do with this. Natasha was specifically targetted because she is a White woman. For that reason, and that reason alone.

    There’s a reason that White women have the highest standard of living of all women on earth.
    It’s time to have some respect for our own race. We have a right to exist in the future.

    • “There’s a reason that White women have the highest standard of living of all women on earth.” => so, you define standards by skin color? All white women have highest standard of living? sorry that sound somewhat ignorant and narrow-minded to me, a Taiwanese – “Yellow woman”, so to speak.

      • Firstly , i am so sorry to hear what happened to you , it is a real tragedy, but a simple word for those blaiming Islam , i need to remind you “or let you know as many of you may not be aware of this catastrophy” that 3 years ago a Muslim Woman “marwa el sherbeeny “was was killed during an appeal hearing at a court of law in Dresden, Germany. She was stabbed by Alex Wiensan ethnic German immigrant from Russia, against whom she had testified in a criminal case for verbal abuse,so don’t blame islam for anything ,it has nothing to do with the religion or country .

  147. Hi, i’m christian and i was raised in Egypt and it was hard because 90% of it was Muslim.Women there don’t get any respect and even less when your christian. I got along with most of my Muslim neighbors and the were very kind but the majority aren’t.Egyptian men love foreign women because they think they are more beautiful and powerless . I am soo sorry this happened to you . I feel ashamed about what my country has become.

  148. Thank you for sharing, it takes love for the mankind to make experiences of such kind public. I believe that something went very much wrong in education for those participated in assaulting a single woman feeling righteous to do it just because some rumors, and also those medical personals, who turned away to provide help to an injured person, being judgmental instead of professional. Something went very, very much wrong in the education system for those people, and that needs urgently to be corrected.
    I would like to express my respect for your courage for trying not to hate the entire race and making efforts to still embrace the beautiful sides of that culture, that you are still trying to be objective which is not easy. It’s easier to hate.
    I would like to express my admiration for your mental and psychological strength showing here.

  149. Pingback: Abrogation simply and succinctly explained « oogenhand

  150. Pingback: Otra periodista es violada en la Plaza Tahrir de El Cairo

  151. Reading the comments on Natasha’s report, I keep seeing the same thing over and over:

    Egyptian guy: “I’m so sorry this happened in my country, I feel so ashamed, you are so brave, I feel so bad for you, you’re welcome here, I wish I had been there to protect you”.

    Egyptian woman: “I’m so sorry this happened to you, Natasha. Sexual harassment is a dreadful problem here, I hope you recover soon, I’m praying for you, you’re so brave, my thoughts are with you.”

    Foreign weirdo Islamophobes & racists: “You should not have gone there, Egyptians are animals, it’s your own fault [misquotes or partial quotes from the Quran], you we stupid, you enjoyed it (and other hateful and disgusting things)”

    Question: if Egyptians and/or muslims are hateful and unfeeling animals (or “zombies”, one person called us), why is almost all of the hatefulness and lack of feeling coming from foreigners, most of whom suppose themselves to be good christians?

    Of course, lots of foreigners left kind and caring comments too. But all the bat-shit-howl-at-the-moon crazy, nasty, hatefulness aimed at Natasha is coming from self-styled “civilised” foreigners. #Ironic

    • I just came back from playing football (soccer) with 13 young Egyptian guys, as the only woman there, at the most basic local playing field, where about 200 guys were playing in other matches.

      By some uncanny miracle, I escaped unscathed with my life and only three attempts to give me a juice box, plus a lift home in someone’s Volkswagen Beetle.

      Some commentators here suppose all Egyptian and/or Muslim men to be ravening beasts who cant see a woman without jumping her en masse. Either the looney tunes commentators are wrong, or I am. Presenting into evidence: one box of apple juice. [Irony alert]

      • Thats fantastic! I assume you’ll now be leaving the security of White-European Civilization permanently to live with your non-White heroes?

        Feel free. Embrace ‘Diversity’. Don’t come back. Ever.

        (Of course. You would never do that. Because subconciously, not even you believe what you’re saying. You need the security that White countries, and only White countries offer.)

        Nobody likes a traitor.

        Your race has made you who you are. Your race has given you everything you have. Your White family. Everything. Try being grateful every once in awhile.

      • OMG! An actual Nazi…wow! It’s like meeting an ewok from Star Wars or something. 🙂

        Well…I’m not a “traitor to my race” since a) youre batshit crazy, and b) I live in Cairo and have for many years, it’s an awesome city, and c) I’m half-Egyptian, half-British. Yes, that’s right…I’m a product of MISCEGENATION, bwah-hah-ha-hah! Run away quickly, before I infect you with my impure blood.

        PS: Thank you so much for the laugh: much-needed at the end of a long hard day. 🙂

  152. Thank you for your brave story. These happening to people in some countries like Egypt, Afganistan, Pakistan etc. are the main reasons why I, white woman in my 40’s am definatelly not travelling to those countries and never give donations to them. This is way too horrifying to be anyway unforgiven. I really hope you manage this trauma and keep your integrity. You seem very strong and openly optimistic woman. I admire you.

    Yours, lady 49 yrs. from Finland

  153. well, I can’t find any words to express my apologies for such a behavior, also i can’t imagine how much pain you have been through. as for me I’ve never sexually abused any one and I consider these abusers beasts just sick bodies without brains. I’m really so mad about what happens to women here, I’m so sorry but I’m really speechless. I’ll try to post a comment again when I’m not that shocked. as for now accept our apology there’s still few good men here.

  154. Pingback: Jonge Britse journaliste (21) “Arabellieus” misbruikt op het Tahrirplein (+ video) | AmsterdamPost – De keerzijde van het nieuws

  155. Pingback: The Thinking Housewife › For Women Journalists in Egypt, a Rite of Passage

  156. im muslim and im Egyptian and im not very good in english i translated ur words and im very sorry and very sad for that .. and i know its not my words what will make u feel better .. buts just know if i know who did that i swear i’ll never leave him live his dam life .. im very sorry .. im very sorry .. .

  157. Dear Ms. Smith
    Your naivety is skyrocketing. Islam = MORDOR and that’s it. Millions of Muslim women suffer heavy oppression every day, because Koran says “Men stand higher than women”. Wake up!

  158. Are you really THAT stupid, Natasha?! Muslims are disgusting rapists! Egypt is full of those disgusting monkeys! Islam is a “religion” of hate! Still you protect these bearded turban wearing beasts?! And you even wanna go back to Kairo?! I’m beginning to think you enjoyed being mass raped! Don`t protect muslims! Expose them for what they are : “R-A-P-I-S-T-S!!!” Death and hate to islam, the muslims are the scum of this planet!

    • Speaking of scum… 😦 And Nazis come to that.

      Unfortunately, your “insightful” and intellectual commentary only exposes your ignorance in not knowing that muslims dont wear turbans (not that it would be relevant if we did)

      I’m so sorry for you, you sad little man.

      • if you say muslim are rapist or skank of the planet..then you dnt know anything about muslims or even islam..and may i remember you have you ever heared that in mosque any person was rapped noooo..but i have heared hundred and hundred of stories wherea pope orpriest rapped children women and men in the church..

    • I suppose the Nazis were muslims, too? And of course all rapists are muslim. Oh, wait…
      It’s not like no other religious fundamentalists believe women are a second class who don’t deserve control over their bodies (which country has a problem with religious fundamentalists murdering doctors who carry out legal procedures such as abortions? Oh, the USA!) and no other religion has caused wars and chaos and suffering in history..

      This isn’t about religion, it’s about power, control, believing others less than yourself because they are different, and dehumanising them as a result until you can justify doing ANYTHING to them because they’re not human so they don’t deserve respect.

      And you’re falling into that trap yourself.

  159. Pingback: #Day 15 & 16 & 17 – Ra’anana « Israel: Cancer Without Borders

  160. For those amongst us , with all respect to their beliefs ( including Ms. Smith ) who think that this behavior has no relation whatsoever with certain dominant community beliefs and the way it was treated in its aftermath by local institutions with reference to behavior towards “different” people, be they are amongst them or from different communities.
    PS – I am talking of the community/institutional response here ,not individual conduct.
    have a look.

    What should we expect from institutional system when some people in a community are just “different”. ?

    • You’re posting a video which seems ( according to the comments on Youtube ) to be some kind of propaganda against Islam. I’m sorry for Neeha ( as well as Natasha ). But you must know that these people are EXTREMISTS, do you think that all the Pakistani condone these acts and that ” raping children is an Islamic tradition ” (cf the video on Youtube ). Extremists as well as the polity ( in Pakistan and Afghanistan for instance) speeches meet their goals thanks to that kind of thinking. The Western’s ” look they are barbarians ” is a fuel to the ” look they hate us”. If you study the nascency of extremism in Islam, you’ll see Islamic Ideology is born when Arab Countries started what they called “Annahda” (Renaissance) in the late eighteenth early nineteenth. And has made the West his enemy because its only relation to it was through colonization so it was born to counteract colonization, certainly it has gone too far.We must also see that the “Western democracy” has been and continues to do when you see that in France for instance during the elections Nicolas Sarkozy insisted on the ” difference” between real French and French Muslims which lends credibility to the hate speech of extremists. I insist again, I do not condone this kind of practice ( also in religion a Muslim doesn’t have the right to force anybody to embrace Islam ). It’s really annoying to watch videos manipulated in this way, I’m sure a man can do the same documentary about evangelization in Africa or Muslims’ persecution in China and talk bad about Protestantism and Buddhism. But It is shameful, because instead of solving problems as the video may suggest, using it as it was on Youtube, it deepens it. Thanks for helping
      extremists, And note that the first victims of extremism are Muslims themselves

      • We all have perspectives to see the same thing, why someone posted these videos on youtube was different , why i have posted them is different.
        A drunk person can still like alcohol when doctor demonstrates that it kills germs ,thinking that drinking is good because it cleans body of germs !!
        You conveniently choose to ignore my PS note.
        what i have noted in the video is the response of the Institutions , institutions include the social political set up to victims of inhuman abuse.
        For all Victims in the video and Miss Smith here , the question I have asked is not that the individual or individuals have done is how much criminal, the question is ,”how institutional set up had chosen to respond it ?” and for its response, why did they responded the way they did, is this the same to be expected in all the countries and all socio political systems? For all who will read this ,compare for yourself ,do you see that socio-political system responds to victims of inhuman abuse better in which place ? would that be same for Ms. Smith in england and Egypt ? or would that be same for neeha in pakistan and canada ? or for the lady who was abused for not agreeing to beliefs of majority , would she met same fate in USA for her conduct as she did in Iran ?
        If not then think why.

      • I doubt this belief of yours ” also in religion a Muslim doesn’t have the right to force anybody to embrace Islam”
        It is because of 2 reasons.
        1. That the holy book tells to ignore all old verses for all new verses where ever there is a conflict of beliefs.
        2. That to make the belief propagated by holy book on all world and all world governance (sharia ) had been told to be prime objective for anyone who wants to qualify as “true believer”.
        Please correct me if i am wrong ?

      • First of all, If authorities didn’t interfere It’s because they are they are the big winners of the disorder ( particulary in Egypt wherethe military want the people feel the problem generated by their lack ), also in Pakistan, the regime is itself extremist, so saving this family will be in the opposite direction of its speech which could discredit their presence in power. So it happens in countries where people seems to have embraced the system’s speech. You can say that it is a consequence of beliefs but I think that it is a consequence of ignorance and rejection of the other. And unfortunately, It is not proper to Iran, Egypt or Pakistan…. You can find articles about Arab immigrants in France who were expelled after they complained of violence because they were illegal immigrants. We are talking abour France, land of the Free, you can be raped or anything else as soon as you have no papers you have no rights.

      • Absolutely not you can’t force anybody to embrace Islam. ‘no compulsion in religion’ (Qur’an: 2:256) Convincing maybe be, but it is up to the person ( who obviously is not Muslim) to choose.

      • You mix truth and lie. It is very true that modern, political Islam is far more Anti-Western than traditional Islam, which saw the West as Christian, and therefore somewhat to be respected. It is also true that the main enemy of an extremist Muslim is a somewhat less extreme Muslim. On the other hand, most people in history who saw themselves as Muslims, considered the verse to be abrogated, and did practice forced conversion. Compared to modern Salafists, the Ottomans were very moderate. Yet, they oppressed the Balkan Christians.

      • Ottomans oppressed all non-Muslims for POLITICAL reasons… The Ottomans’ regime was a Caliphate of divine right with no real legitimacy, that is why as the ayatollahs or the Taliban … it creates one by giving to itself a role of fighter on behalf of Islam. And note that The Ottomans’ period was successful militarily but culturally void for Muslim history.
        I still Insist ‘no compulsion in religion’ (Qur’an: 2:256).
        PS: forced conversion was also practiced during the evangelization in the late
        nineteenth and early twentieth conolisation during the course in Africa with the oppression of peoples who refused to comply with requests

      • Like all Turks, you are very intelligent. You mean, during the Ottoman Empire, true Islam almost dissappeared from the Earth? And how am I to know whether you are a “true” Muslim, or someone who will force me to “convert”? Also, Christianity is considered a Religion of the Book by Islam, and a natural ally against the “idolaters” of Black Africa, as well as against non-religious people, like in Europe.

      • Othmane.
        Its nice from you to hear that you ( as individual) is ignoring the call of sharia that says,”it is the aim of all true believers to not rest until all world is ruled by sharia” .

        Also interesting is to note that you are ignoring direct command of god to replace all older verses of holy book with later verses and hence you refuse to beleive that ” “Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book (the Jews and the Christians), until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued.” Q- 9.29
        It is equally warm to see that you refuse any command from holy book associated scriptures that it is duty of true follower to work for installation of sharia and removal of man made governments
        Perhaps all of this discussion is not related to you then, it concerns someone or groups who are acting on the verses as mentioned above regarding 9.29 and installation of sharia law on non believers , lets not defend the indefensible.

  161. Pingback: The Council Has Spoken!! Week of 6.29.12 Watcher’s Council Results | askmarion

  162. I’m so so sorry for you i really felt pain for what happened to you ….
    I’m a muslim and i’m also an Egyptian who lives in cairo and i’m a revolutionary and i can sure you that this has happened to dozens of Egyptian girls every day it has nothing to do with any religious things or political stuff or any thing .. its related to the poverty and deprivation and these people has nothing to do with Islam or the Egyptian revolutionary people or the Tahrir square …
    this is the truth and we are trying to face this catastrophe i hope that this dosen’t happen to any one else whether an Egyptian or a foreigner …
    i’m so sorry again and i hope that this acciden don’t change your idea about us

  163. Pingback: Female Journalist Sexually Assaulted in Public at Egypt’s Tahrir Square « Helios Journal

  164. Hey Tasha…first of all chin up brave girl and hope you feel better soon if you are not already !

    HERE IS A QUESTION for you Tasha:
    I never doubt what you have mentioned…..i never say that you are lying….im not even interrogating you and felt sad ready what happened to you….but just innocent question came to my mind and i was hesitated if i shall ask it or not !! you mentioned the story with it’s very tiny details,which is quite weird to me….you were shocked,scared and crying so you had no focus but reading your blog you mentioned the steps that have happened,ripping off your skirt first then underwear then shoes then top then they started….etc then to the tent,you remember the 2 ladies wearing “burqu” staring you then went away…you remember your position setting on the chair….you remember that the guys asked you if you wnna go to MAC ! and what happened when the crowd were trying to get into the tent???they have just changed their mind and went away!?it sounds like you were focusing and remembering everything with it’s tiny details and in order too,what happened first then what second which is quite weird as its a terrific sexual assault and any girl in your situation will never be focusing,she will tell the story but not in order as you did !!!!

    Again this is just innocent question,im not doubting your story and i never mean any bad background out of asking this question !

    Regards,
    MIKE

    • ” it sounds like you were focusing and remembering everything with it’s tiny details and in order too,what happened first then what second which is quite weird as its a terrific sexual assault and any girl in your situation will never be focusing,she will tell the story but not in order as you did !!!! ”

      So you make all assumptions yourself Mike,
      1 . It is “Weird” way of expression by her. It should have been according to your understanding !
      2. What should any girl do in any situation like this and in what order she ought to do it .
      3. And biggest of them all , all of your beliefs should be clarified for sake of wonderful “innocence” you proclaim .
      Come on leave at least some assumptions for qualified doctors and psychologists too, shouldn;t you ? or may be your curiosity inspires you to become one of them so you will broaden your understanding, it would be such good end.

      • Dear Anudeep,

        Sounds you didn’t get me please read what i posted again accurately….AGAIN im not against her or sayin shes lying i DO BELIEVE her,when i said “in order” i meant writing what happened to her first this happened then that in details as in such situation like “Lara Loahn” the american lady she was like “i was attacked they ripped off my clothes and started to harass me” not as Natasha mentioned in full details….as science says in such situation you feel lost you lose control and this happened to Tasha too so how come shes remembering such tiny details!!! and again still it’s just a question came by my mind,this has nothing to do with what happened…and this question doesn’t mean shes making up a story or shes lying never !!!

        “2. What should any girl do in any situation like this and in what order she ought to do it .” <<<so your question is wrong from the beginning !!! i wasn't talking about what she did or her reaction-as she has done nothing wrong,shes a victim but i meant what she wrote on the blog

        "or may be your curiosity inspires you to become one of them " what do you mean one of whom???

      • Simple Question ,
        ” as science says in such situation you feel lost you lose control and this happened to Tasha too so how come shes remembering such tiny details!! ”
        It seems lets return to dig such science and do some Phd over how reliable is that science to predict each human being’s reaction.
        I had hope that this incident and your curiosity as to why science is not followed by the person affected would lead you to more research, may be earning some degree. it would be helpful to mankind.

    • Michael,

      People often begin to hyperfocus in traumatic situations. It is the body’s attempt to localize details that can help you get out of the situation. Read Brison’s book Aftermath that in one sections exactly treats the details she noticed as she was being raped and trying with everything she had to be able to survive the experience.

  165. Pingback: Tahrir Square British Sex Assault Victim: “I Know This Is Not Islam – I Love Egypt – It’s Okay” | Here's The Right Side Of It

  166. Pingback: Egyiptom: Nők elleni erőszak a Tahrír téren · Global Voices Magyarul

  167. British government is housing thousands of radical muslims from all over the world in order to send those to a holy war in some secular country, because the british “policy” doesn´t work. These terrorists are terrorizing and killing innocent people with the approval of the british government. CNN is the biggest liar-channel of the world. Those warmongers deserve to reap what they have seeded. I do not feel pity for smith.

  168. This not happen. Western lie. Muslim man never act like this. This just make hate for Islam. All false like cutting head of videos.

    • na ja ill tel you what..actually am an egyptian woman who lives in germany..and as an egyptian girl who as in tahrir square and where here intire family lives their,..such things happen..! and it also happened to me and that happends to hundered of thousands regular egyptian women in daaily basis..!! this stuff happens everyday in all arround cairo in bus traffic ,on the street..not only in tahrir..!

      • am really sorry for what happened to you natasha..and you are really a brave women..cause as that happend to me and i even have a video of it which displayed on cairo channel but no body got interested as they said to me after i got rescued by some courage and brave young egyptian mens and brought to tent..some women in the tent even refused at first the idea of me being there as one of the said” took her out from there..she deserves what happend to her..who told her not wear a “khemar” to cover her hair” its not the covered hair that gonna protect me from this evil eyes..! and you know what even the girls with the “khemar’ get sexual herassted everyday in the public traffic..!! anyways thank you natasha bec of you i got releafed it happend to me last year but only now i got this releaf and peace bec finally i spook about it and conficed my self that it wasnt my fault and that i am the VICTIM here..!!

    • Unfortunately It is a real problem!! Muslim men never act like this but stupid men do,whether Muslim or not. And I understand your feelings Mohammed, It’s too hurtfull for us ( actualy I am Muslim ) to read such but the first step to eradicate the scourge is to admit its existence.
      I am really sorry for what happened to you Natasha.

  169. Gullible journalist goes out in the world in order to “explain” the world, as it has learned it by the education-system of the british government, and be part of the misinformation media from the west. Then the journalist experiences the media and government lies at her own person. Well, i do not feel sorry for her. She is part of this media-complex that has turned to many facts into lies and vice versa. I just hope all british people experience one day this pain this journalist had experienced that peculiar day. Girl this has happened to you, because you deserved it! Think about it!

  170. It’s so poignant that she still considers Egypt a “wonderful country” – and still has “love” for Cairo. And it’s not just a Muslim thing. Stripping female reporters in public, physically and sexually assaulting them, and attempting to kidnap them occurs every day all over the world. Allahu Akhbar!

  171. Hopefully the Army will be in control. These asses MB stole a revolution. They ARE animals. If this crap continues it will really a part of Africa that no one will ever care about again.

  172. Please God help this women to live like a good human ,and helped those who comment to let them know the truth.
    How can we know you are honest?
    And who is saving you from those ?
    But these accusations are false and reflect the hate on the Muslims..!!!

    • I so hope you are not a troll. These sentiments, if spouted in earnest, are at the same time incredibly titillating and scary. Like going to the House of horrors at a fairground. Oh, and death to people with an IQ under 30!

  173. “I find it frustrating that many commenters here are saying that hate runs in Muslims blood but what does that say about the commenter himself/herself?”

    It tells you that an increasing number of people in Western countries with exposure to Muslim minorities and their behaviour have reached the point where they are thoroughly fed up with being robbed, harassed and made foreigners in their own countries.

    “How can they not realize that they are spreading hate as well?”

    Stating opinions based on empirical evidence and personal experience is many a thing, but not hate.

    “We, as humans, will never progress if we see entire population as savages, and not realize that crimes equally and sometimes more horrendous happen IN THEIR neighborhoods and countries as well.”

    Looking back at the past two thousand years we as humans have civilizationally, socially and technologically progressed as humans exceptionally fine by living by that creed.

    “Not all Muslims are from the middle east, anyway,”

    Relevance?

    “and many Americans have converted to Islam after 9/11…”

    Relevance?

    “being Muslim is not something you are born with, it’s something one chooses to believe.”

    Sorry to burst your bubble, but according to Islamic tradition and all Islamic schhols of jurisprudence *everbody* is born as a Muslim. That’s why people of other faiths are held in such contempt by pious Muslims: because they have not reverted to their “original” ie. Muslim faith.

    “Not all Egyptians are Muslims, either.”

    No, but as sure as there’s not a pub in Saudi Arabia called “The Shoplifter’s Arms” the Egyptians Natasha “experienced” were Muslims. Because going to a mass rally of the Muslim Brotherhood as a Coptic christian is just as suicidal as going there as a young, blond western female…

    “And people saying Natasha should be punished for being “ignorant” is driving me crazy!”

    No, we say she HAS been punished for being woefully ignorant. We say she SHOULD and COULD have known better. She went there anyway.

    “YOU ARE THE SAME AS HER ATTACKERS!”

    So pointing out her obliviousness makes us rapists? Thanks. That, in turn, tells us all we need to know about you.

  174. Hello Natasha,
    I am so sorry for what happened to you. That is horrible.

    However it reflects the nature of Egyptians. If you don’t severly control them, that’s what you get.

    I am an Egyptian citizen (only by birth) as my grandparents are from another country in north africa.

    I have grown up in Egypt and I can assure you that what led Egyptians to be like that and to act like that is democracy.

    When Omar Suleiman said that the Egyptians are not ready for democracy he was right.

    Egyptians are simply too vain, not to mention arrogant, and most of all ignorant, they weren’t like that. Bur they started to be when Mubarak and his regime gave some space for democracy, as a result the islamic current played with people’s minds, and made them think that they -Egyptian muslims- are right, and the whole world is a wrong party comprised of non believers.

    Which means that harrasing, insulting, or even hurting other non muslims is allowed (according to them).

    I am ashamed that I was born in Egypt, and I hope that one day a strong regime returns, and sends all those arrognat rubbish protestors to do something more productive other than standing in Tahrir square doing harm to others and themselves.

    • I am sorry if thus really happened to u , but there is no evidence of what u claim , besides, we didn’t hear about any harassment accidents after the spy advertisement on TV . If u try to gain sympathy and fame on the shoulders of Egypt , or try to distort the appearance of Egypt and Egyptians , believe me u r a loser ,,

  175. So you asked God to save you, and God did.

    But you’re not religious?

    Maybe you should connect the dots. Or at least say “thanks God”.

    • Looks to me like god didn’t do any saving. Instead, people who risked their lives by dragging her into a tent, disguising her, and then whisking her away to safety actually did the saving.

      Did you actually see some sort of miracle happen to save her? Did you see her transported in the blink of an eye to safety? Or some sort of holy shield surround her? I didn’t.

      Maybe it’s you who should connect the dots.

  176. I find it frustrating that many commenters here are saying that hate runs in Muslims blood but what does that say about the commenter himself/herself? How can they not realize that they are spreading hate as well? We, as humans, will never progress if we see entire population as savages, and not realize that crimes equally and sometimes more horrendous happen IN THEIR neighborhoods and countries as well.

    Not all Muslims are from the middle east, anyway, and many Americans have converted to Islam after 9/11… being Muslim is not something you are born with, it’s something one chooses to believe. Not all Egyptians are Muslims, either.

    And people saying Natasha should be punished for being “ignorant” is driving me crazy! YOU ARE THE SAME AS HER ATTACKERS!

    I just can’t believe some people!!! Too many thoughts running through my mind to make them coherent…

  177. Dear Natasha,
    It always made me so angry when I see or hear about such acts against women, tried to do what I can in the surrounding community.
    But your last incident made me decide to be proactive and started this page on facebook trying to combat Sexual harassment by encouraging all celebrities in Egypt to speak out about this catastrophe.
    it will be an honer of you join our efforts so we save other women from such brutal attacks by ignorant miss leaded people.
    http://www.facebook.com/combatSH
    http://www.facebook.com/groups/combatSH/

  178. Pingback: Jarabspring latest - Page 31 - The Orange Room - forum.tayyar.org

  179. That is one hell of a story, so much stuff happens in Egypt not so much to foreginers but to Egyptians themselves, beaten up in the streets by police for not having ID e.t.c. The poor (really poor) follow religion in a stranger way to the middle and upper classs, they may not fast or most of them dont even pray, so its hard to know weather they really believe in Islam or not. Most of these comments are people talking about what they’d do themselves but I cn totally agree that your mentality and speech at the end is the best, not many people can talk if they have been in that problem and I’m now ashamed to be half Egyptian because the counrty is just plain wicked, I’m sorry Natasha for that. Hany Ellaboudy

  180. Pingback: Jarabspring latest - Page 31 - The Orange Room - forum.tayyar.org

  181. Pingback: Египет: Напади врз жени на плоштадот Тахрир · Global Voices на македонски

  182. I’m sorry for your experience, Natasha.

    There is no singular answer as to why you were attacked. It’s human nature to try to pretend that every complex situation has a singular solution. You were in the wrong place at the wrong time. Men act entitled in some situations. People in mobs obey mass psychological impulses that are not easily contained. Neither Christianity, Judaism or Islam can be described as anything but patriarchal. Women will always be targets of patriarchal religions, regardless of how well females become socially programmed to accept their inferior roles.

    I’m sure I can come up with a dozen more possible factors that weighed in on this, but my main points are that

    (1) People who blame ONLY Islam are laughably reductionist. ( I could easily point to episodes among “Christians” that I COULD twist to my political agenda and claim that it represented all Christianity in general, since I despise religions in general, including Christianity).

    (2) My other point would be that you may want to take more precautions in the future. I wish you a speedy recovery and a bright future

  183. Ah yes… the old cry. “No witnesses, it didn’t happen!” The cry men have been using for centuries to deny women’s experiences. Because in any public venue, absolutely everything is automatically documented by the Veracity Police on their super mobile phone cameras that can take a picture through a crowd of men’s backs. And, I’m sure the wannabe rapists would have paused to take a few pictures of themselves and their friends-of-the-moment for the old family album.

    Your argument is so stupid it isn’t even funny.

  184. I know you grew up in western culture and hold certain values. But in Islamic countries you need to ask the big questions all over again, and throw everything you assume is true about human nature out the window. How is it that a mass crowd of men would feel so bold as to rape you in broad day light, in front of countless witnesses. That a nurse or doctor would feel conflicted about helping you? Why is there no real law enforcement to be found that will prosecute anyone for what happened? Why will there be no follow up? And finally why was this allowed to happen? What was the underlining justification for their actions? Did you ever think that they had a reasoning behind their behavior? To them, what happened to you was good.

    The truth is that you are an infidel. You represent a nation that once subdued Islamic countries. You can be sure that those men have listened to several imams talking about you. That you are the ultimate evil. The most scary thing, is that those men believed that by destroying you they were doing God’s will. I found it very interesting that Egyptian women surrounded you declaring that this wasn’t Islam. Did you know that they were working with the men, covering for them? Did you know that by agreeing with them, parroting their “islam is peace”, you further convinced them that you are truly a naive infidel worth only of rape and death? However, I’m glad you did because it saved your life. The true and living God would never approve of this, and He surely isn’t Allah.

  185. Natasha, what a horrible, terrifying experience. I’m so sorry this happened to you and as a man I’m ashamed to share a gender with the people who assaulted you. I hope you’ll heal in every way.

    I think it’s important to recognize that Islam is a religion of deep, foundational misogyny. Try reading the Koran — it’s an inescapable conclusion.

    Though the self-described Islamic moderates have evolved past this, that was their own choice. If it were up to the Koran, they would themselves be put to death as disobedient infidels, joining the rest of us in a mass grave.

    Until the Middle East joins the middle class, this kind of thing will be utterly rampant. If we want to kill off fundamentalist Islam, we’ll need to send them more iPads and designer shoes than Hellfire missiles.

    • Um, Sorry but people like you make me sick. You say Islam is a peaceful religion after what you just experienced? Maybe you enjoyed it. The fact is, shit like this does not happen in civilized countries. Look at EVERY single ISLAMIC country. They are all complete shit holes. Gays get executed, women get executed, people who practice different religions get executed. You are a typical dumb liberal slut, you got what you deserved little Miss “Journalist” Islam is peaceful? If you honestly believe that then Why don’t you take another trip down to tahrir square.

      • You are a typical dumb liberal slut, you got what you deserved”

        Yeah, because appalling sexual assault is ABSOLUTELY deserved when a woman expresses an opinion you disagree with. You know what? You’re on the same continuum as those men Natasha describes. *Maybe* you aren’t as far along the violence continuum as them but, given your fundamental lack of respect for Natasha’s bodily integrity and your assumption that rape can be justified, I personally wouldn’t assume that. But, at base, you are no different. A woman dares to say something or do something you don’t like? Hey guys! raping this one is fine! Oh, yeah, look. That’s pretty much what happened…

        Hypocrite.

      • Happens in Amish country all the time. /sarc

        None so blind as them who will not see.

  186. I’m very sorry for what happened to this woman but despite what a few people told her, that was Egypt and that was Islam. Hell, that’s the entire Middle East.
    In Western societies you can expect equal rights and to be treated with a certain level of dignity. When you travel to a part of the world where they cut the clits off of little girls and marry female children off to relatives you cannot expect to remain safe when surrounded by the men there.
    I’m sorry but it’s true. It’s a different culture and despite the hype all cultures are not equal. There are neighborhoods in the USA that not even cops enter alone yet for some reason cute young Liberal reporters think that they can travel all over the world and they’re protected because they are carrying a camera.
    There are bad people in the world and some places most likely have more bad than good.
    I hope this young woman can eventually recover and put this behind her. I also hope that she uses better judgement in the future.

  187. Ahmed,

    You have provided a good example of Muslim’s practicing taqiyya to Infidels as they are instructed to do in the Koran. In your view, it’s OK to deceive nonbelievers. Nice work, but you don’t really expect us to believe this, do you?

  188. Oh hon’ :(. Deal with the PTSD first. Get out of survival mode and ‘I am too intelligent to let this defeat me’ mode before you go back. Wanting to go back is part of the PTSD – even though it doesn’t sound like it. Find a calming & non-judgemental therapist you can speak to. I find older women who have worked in a hospital to be the best for this, myself. It’ll take a few months. Or longer. Heal. You have that luxury.

  189. Natasha: you survived for a reason. Don’t ever doubt it…you can make this work for the greater good. But be sure you deal with your own healing of this trauma–I cannot recommend Dr. Francine Schapiro’s work on PTSD highly enough…see EMDR (Eye Motion DeSensitization Reprogramming) and find a therapist qualified to do this work when your spirit is ready.

  190. I am so very sorry you had to go through that. That you can describe it with such grace is amazing. Thank you for sharing that story.

  191. I’m shocked by the madness and the pain that you describe in such detail. The incomprehensible brutality and the deep suffering.

    But apart from that, I admire the serenity and the clarity of mind that comes out of your heartfelt narration. The reflective will to understand what was going on and the determination to survive. The bravery of the men and women who tried to help, putting themselves at risk. And the passion that leads to keep working in despite of everything and take the documentary to a good end.

    I sincerely hope all wounds will heal soon. And that aggressions against foreign and local women, in Egypt and everywhere, will one day stop.

  192. What happened is Islam in practice, whatever the muslims frantically say — who are you going to believe, your lying eyes and body, or their lying protestations?

    Accept the facts: these people, however nice they may seem in other circumstances, are utterly untrustworthy animals who do not know how to be decent.

    Egypt is sinking into an Islamic hell – it will be generations before it will be safe for civilized people to visit it again.

    • A blonde woman wandering around in a crowd of Muslim men and expecting to be left alone? That’s like expecting a pack of dogs to leave a raw steak alone. She should be very thankful to have survived. There is no need to go back. Her story already tells us all we need to know.

    • both the attackers and the saviors were muslim, so do not give me that ‘all muslims are like this or that’.

  193. Reblogged this on The Rio Norte Line and commented:
    What Natasha Smith describes is the epitome of a repressed, evil culture. I find it hard to take her at her word that this does not represent Egypt when so many had the opportunity to help her and chose not to do so.

    • Uh, yeah, because this king of thing never happens in the West, does it? No, in this sexually free Utopia women are never assaulted or gang raped and complete strangers will help any woman in trouble!

      For the iconic case I suggest you google “Kitty Genovese” before you come out with this “holier than thou” BS

      • And I suggest that you look up “logical argument”. I didn’t compare and contrast Egypt to the US or any other country, I commented on the performance of the crowd of Islamists compared to the supposed pious nature of the religion. If an assault on a woman happens in America or anywhere else, it does nothing to diminish the criminality and severity of the violation in Egypt. A wrong elsewhere in the world does not make it right in Egypt.

  194. Must say you are a very courageous young lady. To be harassed like that and yet have the heart to fight against similar crimes being perpetrated against others elsewhere is really really admirable.

    I myself am not a bigot, but a rather rational person who weighs the pros and cons of everything. While I know what you are saying and plan on doing are the right things, I can’t help but wonder if certain parts of the world are even worth discussing.

    You went there with pure intentions, but ended up assaulted, humiliated, robbed of your dignity and only but a handful came to your rescue.

    At some point in its history a star expands and explodes to form a supernova – that was the revolution in February 2011, but at a later stage stars implode and shrivel into oblivious black holes – that is what is happening out there currently.

    The story needs to be told, but are they worth it ? Or, should we just let them implode upon themselves until they get their act right ?

    • No one Saw what happened to her @ tahrir square it is all based on her story! she is saying 100’s of men were attacking her while no single person at tahrir square posted anything about this on twitter!

      The square was full of religious people and protesters waiting for the elections results and the security measures wr high and tight! checking id’s of everyone entering the square and no thugs were let in! and the place was safe and clean!

      Her story is unconfirmed and with no witness and no one saw what happened to her although she said hundreds of men were attacking her and hundreds were protecting her! As if Egypt was divided that day 2/3 to attack her and 1/3 to protect Miss Natasha! bet egyptians were so busy that day!

      • For the record I TOTALLY believe her… NO WOMAN would make something like this up. But I do find it curious why no one tweeted about this and reported this…this is just strange to me. But I know how uneducated Egyptian men are…basically animals. But the point about the tweets leaves me wondering.

  195. It seems you like it(raped by arabs)
    Try next time Libya or Tunis or Syria or Turkey for some different fuck.
    Stupidity SHOULD be punished.

  196. Stupid Idiot, what did you expect ?> did you not know about the american journalist being raped on tahir ?? Have you not noticed that muslims were PIGS ? Animals ? Now you know ..

  197. Natasha, you are a journalist . Don’t you watch the news ? This already happened in Egypt at least to a french journalist and to another too. Haven’t you heard of mass rapes perpetrated by hundreds of men in Egypt ?

    You say “I reassured her that I knew that was the case, that I loved Egypt and its culture and people, and the innate peacefulness of moderate Islam” Are you sure this religion does not generate a huge sexual frustration for men ?
    I am fed up with “this is not the true Islam” . Terrorism : “this is not Islam ” Beheadings “this is not Islam” Honor crimes “this is not Islam” Excision “this is not Islam ” women forced to wear burka “this is not Islam ” young women forced to marry a man they don’t want “this is not Islam” Call for murder because of caricatures “this is not Islam” Journalist, politicians, teachers threatened or killed ( Theo Van Gogh, Ayan Hirsi Ali…) “this is not Islam” …
    Happily, most muslims are not terrorists but they ( and you) should try to find out why “such a beautiful religion ” ( as muslims say) can generate such monsters and so horrible behaviours…and protest against this

    • Natasha is right, this horrible crime does not reflect true Islam. These acts are human corruptions of a beautiful, peaceful faith. My love and support goes our to you Natasha. You clearly have a very pure heart and don’t seek vengeance or hatred. Good luck in your doco 🙂

  198. NATASHA SMITH, AM SORRY, I wish I was there to take one simple scratch instead of you, but unfortunately I wasn’t there since I wouldn’t support Morsy (the new presd.), But I blame myself alot now !! ppl may blame on you, but Trust me it is NOT ur fault at all, it is their fault, and you have the liberty to forgive or not…
    I just knew abt that, very confused, feeling very guilty, don know how to fix that, or what to tell at all, Every man and woman from Egypt pretend to be defending everything but your situation, but I have to admit, it is our fault Natasha, If you have heard abt the good ppl of egypt; I have to tell you; it is no longer the same, we are different know, no longer those ppl with major hospitality you used to hear about..
    Leaving my mail, just contact me with any thoughts, even those simple ones that can make me feel better !

  199. I wish I could muster up more than the most basic amount of sympathy for you, Natasha, but I simply can’t. You’re a journalist. You’re sitting at the very center of the information flows.
    After all thousands upon thousands of reported cases from all over Europe of Muslim men seeing “infidel” girls and women as nothing but meat ripe for the taking (for example *all* rapes in Oslo were committed by muslims, you’ve got the pimping out of underage British girls by Pakistani gangs, you’ve got non-muslim girls being harassed as “whores” or gangraped in French banlieues etc.) and after what happened to Lara Logan you nonetheless thought it a good idea to visit Egypt, now de facto taken over by the Muslim Brotherhood. I mean, their endgame is just to establish a global caliphate and create shariah-conformist societies, but I suppose cultural-relativist media speak nowadays considers that to be “moderate”.

    You of all people should have known what might – and did – await you. And yet you chose to go anyway. The men who attacked you are guilty, plain and simple. But you are guilty, too. Guilty of naivetee and stupidity that almost earned you a Darwin Award.

    Seek counseling. Recuperate. You’re young and clever and strong. But do yourself a favour and shed the cultural relativist mindset that got you into this shit in the first place.

    • Ok, aside from the blatantly bigoted interpretation of ‘who rapes the most women’, this argument REALLY upsets me. It. Is. Never. The. Fault. Of. The. Person. Who. Was. Raped. It is the person who does the raping who is at fault. Period. Your attempt to make it Natasha’s fault for being in the wrong place at the wrong time justifies the act, which is distressing.

  200. When reading your story, I cannot help but feel rage at these people, at their culture, at their country, for doing something like this to Natasha and of course so many other women there.

    But at the same time, I cannot help but think “This is what cultural relativism of the west has brought us to”. In older times, a sane western woman would never have gone there and the colonial administration would have punished these people harschly and rightfuly so for doing this crime.

    Natasha is simply a victim of the time. A naive western woman like many other.
    I’m European and very much not naive about the reality of these countries.
    This is why I vote “far right” and prevent their immigration into my homeland.

    • …and from here, history draws a direct line to Auschwitz. where does it stop? and you defend colonialism? i am an indian, and i know the horrors my country faced under the colonial rule. i hope you can realize you are not the open-minded, forward-thinking person you think you are. conservatism is as responsible for misery as any other religion. you simply were born into your homeland, its nothing to your credit. what have you done to make it a better place for those who live there or those who like it and choose it over their countries where they suffer from religious dogmatism? oh yes, you vote far right! big help! Please, be sensitive to the suffering of this woman. Such a crime against any living organism, a woman, a child, a man or an animal is unacceptable, irrespective of which country, religion, sect, fan-club, politico-economic motivations the victim belongs to. Nataha is not a victim of time, it is a victim of people like you, who perpetrate hatred, closing constructive dialogue, keeping darker regions of the world darker with your far right convictions and eventually, sinking into darkness yourself.

      • Thank you for pointing that out. But i have to say, that the point is of relevance here. What i was targeting was the nationalism proudly touted in the previous post and it was nationalism that gave us the second world war and the associated horrors. Maybe i should’ve said world-war II, which would’ve been less radical, but also less likely to have driven the point home. The current usage of the term “Godwin’s law” is limited to using comparisons with nazis when it is inappropritate, however, “Godwin’s law itself can be abused as a distraction, diversion or even as censorship, fallaciously miscasting an opponent’s argument as hyperbole when the comparisons made by the argument are actually appropriate”. (Ref: David Weigel, “Hands Off Hitler! It’s time to repeal Godwin’s Law”)

    • Reducing the argument above, by Rational Liberal is a diversionary tactic.. it is sad that what s/he wrote is seen as referring to the argumentum ad Hitlerum. This is far from being an example of Godwin’s Law. The fact is, anondragon made the leap to blaming the victim by stating that the fault lies with time, or the naivety of the woman who should’ve known better. This person justifies her points with her xenophobia – which ends with a irrational nationalistic ‘my homeland’ note.
      One can see that a sane women would not have gone there is not a comment on the women, or the colonization – it’s a comment on the culture of that area, and while some of that culture may be deleterious to those colonizing, the culture of those colonizing can be seen in a similar light by those who are colonized. Two wrongs do not make a right.

      A multicultural, secular, humanist world is the way forward.. and Natasha IS the victim of bigoted people like anondragon and those here who are saying that Natasha lied, or she must’ve enjoyed it, or that it was her fault that she went there. This bigotry is in the form of misogyny, of racial-pride, of religious supremacy.. and especially so in an inherently violent religion like Islam, which places women lower than men in rights, by default.

      Re-evaluate your arguments. It’s riddled with flaws.

      • Dumbass racist nazi-pig… by the sight of your “emblem” in your avatar I could smell your propaganda before I read the first word of your idiotic comment. The only reason why you don’t put a swastika as image is cause you’d be banned from any website before your comments could come online.

      • That you could confuse a parody of Che Guevara with nazi-ideology goes to show the extent of your intelligence (or lack thereof). I think you’re more hurt and offended with what i wrote than with my avatar, obviously. Yet, instead of attacking my argument, you’ve attacked me. Great!.. why not type in all CAPS to make your points stronger..?!
        ..idiot.

        Let’s hear you criticize what the author here went thru’. Or criticize the ideology that allows men to turn into such demons. Let’s hear your arguments, instead of your unfounded rage.

      • ..unless of course, you’ve replied to ‘anondragon’ here.
        In that case (IFF), and i type this with mammoth regret at being too quick to respond, i apologize.. this totally exposes me to criticism for calling out ‘idiot’. Feel free to return the courtesy. 😛

        Stupid wordpress.. won’t let anyone edit their comments.

  201. What happened with Natasha Smith is not isolated episode. The reaction I am getting on my comments indicates that people do not understand how the sexual assault of Natasha’s related to what I am posting. My goal is to demonstrate that the very Arabs (brainwashed by Islam ideology in to blood-thirsty zombies) who express their sympathy and apology to Natasha would rape and tear her apart at very first opportunity as they did many times in the past with many Infidels be they Americans, Canadians, British, Russians, Israelis and many other normal people from normal countries.

    Hateful propaganda towards Infidels in general and the Jews in particular in Arab countries does not stop for a minute. One of the Al Jazeera footages describes quintessential innocent civilian a 10-year-old boy from Jenin named Abdul — shot to death by an Israeli soldier. Al Jazeera tells us that Abdul was described by his friends as the smartest kid in his class and that his dream was to become a martyr. Unfortunately for everyone, Abdul wasn’t smart enough to abstain from throwing stones at Israeli soldiers, which was exactly how he became a martyr.

    Fortunately for us, this was not the kind of martyrdom Abdul had in mind: he did not die killing infidels. I can’t help asking an ultimately cynical question: how many Israeli, British or American children would I be willing to sacrifice to allow him to grow up and fulfill his dream? Would four high school students be enough to pay for Abdul’s 77 eternal virgins, or should it be something on the scale of September 11?

    Kids’ dreams mature with age, and chances are that, instead of a mass murderer, Abdul might become a brilliant scientist or a leader who would’ve taken the Arab world from its hopeless, eternal misery towards the heights of human enlightment. Hard to imagine of course, but stranger things are known to have happened. But what about the grown up “innocent civilians” who had instilled those murderous dreams in the mind of Abdul and hundreds of thousands of children around him?

    What about his parents? What about his school teachers? What about the imam in his mosque? They are all civilians, but are they all that innocent? If we are sincere in our desire for peace, shouldn’t we admit that those people are infinitely more dangerous to us than those who are allegedly (as the al Jazeera would put it) running around with AK-47s and explosives belts?

    • So to sum up: murdering a sweet 10-year-old child for throwing stones is OK by you, provided he’s a muslim? “Normal” people, from “normal” countries?!

      I don’t know how someone…let’s be kind and say, “special” like you can even use the word normal. 😦

  202. Hi!

    I just read your story. I am so sorry, that this happend to you. I cant imagine, how you felt in this moment. Keep your head up, you can do whatever you like to do in the futur! Just reading your text, shows me, that it doesnt matter WHAT I want to do, just IF I really want to do it, I can make it. And thank you for shearing your story. It is really brave from you to talk about it in the public, but also, that you want to go back and go on. Its amazing, how much power you have just to go on and that’s the most important thing now. It happend now, you cant change anything. But the future isnt written yet and YOU can decide, how it will be. I know, I’m just seventeen years old and I maybe dont have that much experience like others. But I really thank you for your story, which shows me, how we can reach any target we want, be brave and speak up.

    Thank you and good bless you!

    Andrea,
    Switerland

    PS: You shouldnt worry about your equipment. The most important thing is that you and your friends are alive and save. And I’m sure, that this is the smallest problem. You will get it for sure 😉

  203. Hmmm.

    After reading (well, briefly — there are to many) comments here, I just can’t resist the temptation to ask simple question.
    In these dark, horrible, sinister times of Hosni Mubarak — did anybody heard about at least *one* mass rape on Tahrir square?
    *Yes* or *no*?

  204. I am a muslim and condem in all strongest words what happened to Natasha. What happened to you was awful. But, may I stress that these bunch of outlaws do not represent Egypt.

    • words are cheap. actions count. prove that these people are outlaws by hanging them as outlaws should be. I am so tired of muslims begging us not to draw conclusions from each successive muslim outrage. At some point, a rational person concludes it is Islam that’s the problem.

    • It was really them JOOS, right Amin? Jewish agents sent in to roam Tehrir Square freely, and lead poor innocent followers of Allah to assault her… and the half dozen or so other western females who’ve had this done to them since your glorious “revolution”.

      Danged Joos, behind everything.

  205. I’m from Palestine and I am really sorry that this happened to you, I hope you feel better very soon horrid experience, I really respect your strength and will to recover and continue living.ِ

    And I am ready to offer any help.

  206. Hi Natasha,

    Thank you so much for sharing your story with us. I imagine it was not easy…I really pray that you are feeling stronger and are staying positive.

    As Jenny suggested, I too would strongly recommend that you get some counseling. I am a photojournalist and suffer from PTSD and it is not easy to live with. As Jenny said, the mind can be deceptive so even if you are feeling okay it is really worth talking to a professional. Writing is also very healing and a great way of fighting PTSD.

    l lived in Cairo for 4 years and I have never felt more safe in a city, in my life – something that is never easy when you are suffering from PTSD. I agree with you that this behaviour is not reflective of Islam, but it does seem to be a trend now with the masses in Tahrir who are attacking and violating so many women. I really hope you are looking after yourself and pampering yourself. Remember always that it was not your fault and it was out of your control. There was nothing you could do about it but save yourself – and that you did. Well done. You are true survivor.

    Sending you much warmth and healing from Africa,

    Mariella

  207. @Natasha: what happened with you was an exception ,as I am a woman I am very sad for you but after the comment that have read that say that most Arab and accurately musulmins are terrorists but they are forgotten that Islam has respeted women and compare it to a pearl to protect.
    By speaking about terrorists i can tell you that the terrorists are those who kill children check days, are those who violate women and even men in Iraqi prisons , are those selling Africans as slaves, are those who wage war to steal oil, are those who consider the other as an enemy, before talking about Islam and insulting the slightest thing is to read it and you’ll soon understand why it is a war against Islam. finally I say ,you cried “Please God make it stop” you must know that no musulmin does that because he is afraid of god that you called, and that every day there are hundreds of women in Palastine and iraq screaming that god protect them from violations of soldiers. you have already seen their feelings. Finally I wish you that you do not again this accident and good luck in your work.

  208. “A Muslim woman” is right. There are “good” and “bad” people in every country and every society which is precisely why it is so disturbing to read so much hate on this thread. Is hate “good” or “bad”? How we treat others is a reflection of ourselves and that includes how we communicate with one another.

  209. أنا علاء من تونس .
    صديقتي أولئك كلاب
    أناس لا يمثلون العرب و لا الاسلام فنحن أرقى و أسمى من هذه المستويات المنحطة
    باسمي و باسم تـونس نتقدم لك اعتذارا عما صدر من أولئك الشرذمة
    و السلام

    • وانا اضم اسمي معك انا فلسطيني وانا عربي مسلم فهؤلاء مرتزقة لكل شخص فعل هذا ___ فنحن نحترم الضيوف ونحترم جميع الاديان ____فحتى المصريين و الاسلام برئ منهم وشكرا…

      And I add my name to you I am a Palestinian and I am an Arab Muslim mercenaries They each person to do this ___ We respect the guests and we respect all religions, even the Egyptians and ____ Islam is innocent of them and thank you …

  210. I am an Egyptian and sad all the sadness of what happened to you, but this behavior by some odd souls and the patient did not reflect the masses of the Egyptian people, Muslims and Christians and I Balatmar what happened to you

  211. Pingback: Trevor Loudon's New Zeal Blog

  212. Pingback: Femmes d’Egypte, Femmes en Egypte (1) « EN D'AUTRES CONTREES

  213. Pingback: Jewish Islamophobia and Muslim Anti-Semitism « oogenhand

  214. Dear Arab terrorists lovers, you stood by the Holocaust and you stood by in 1948 as seven states launched a war that the Arab League proudly compared to the Mongol massacres. You stood by in 1967 as Nasser, wildly cheered by wild mobs in every Arab capital in the world, vowed to drive the Jews into the sea. And you would stand by tomorrow if Israel were facing extinction. And since Israelis know that the Arabs-Palestinians daily dream of that extinction, they will do everything possible to remain alive.

    The poor Palestinians who today kill Jews with explosives and firebombs and stones are part of the same people who – when they had all the territories they now demand be given them for their state – attempted to drive the Jewish State into the sea. The same twisted faces, the same hate, the same cry of “idbah-al-yahud” – “Slaughter the Jews!” that we hear and see today, were seen and heard then. The same people, the same dream – destroy Israel.

    • i cant see the relationship between this event and the Palestinian and isreali struggle .
      please dont use this to express you hating opinions .

      • I can, Egypt is next door to Palestine and Israel and both cultures spawn from the same false religion started by a paedophile in the 7th Century. I’m no great lover of the Jews myself, they can be unjust and cruel at times, but they are a damned site more civilized than Muslims.

        If we have to pick the lesser of two evils I pick the Jews.

      • When you say Jews, do you mean followers of the Talmudic religion, or some supposed race? I agree that the Talmud shares some similarities with the koran/hadith, but it is not nearly as loathsome. Even if the Talmud allows cheating, robbing and killing Gentiles, that would be no worse than let’s say, the Vikings or the Huns did. Muslims, on the other hand, practice barbarities like FGM.

      • well this is your opinion , every society contains the bad and the good , in every society there are criminals like those who did to Natasha that humiliating and uncivilized deed .
        but they do not represent me or anybody else , they only represent themselves like criminals in all over the world they all represent themselves .
        read more about Islam , I’m sure you will notice another thing .

  215. Barack Hussein Obama is, essentially, a foreigner. He may (or not) be born in the United States, but the values shared by the American people, the values that made this country great and prosperous, are as foreign to him as his Arabian, Kenyan, Indonesian roots are to us. He has nothing vested in this country. All his life here, he was closely associated with its enemies.

    Obama will destroy America with no regrets. The very fact that seven years after the devastating attack visited on the United States by Arabs, the Americans placed an Arab into the White house demonstrates the depth of the crisis USA is in.

    • Off topic much. Just say what you really want to say, why don’t you (which is probably something like ‘it’s called the “White” House for a reason’).

  216. Pingback: The Council Has Spoken!! This Week’s Watcher’s Council Results 6-29-2012 | Virginia Right!

  217. Obama’s policies toward Israel, includes the unconscionable demand that Israel unilaterally retreat to indefensible 1949 borders. Notably, those borders were expanded in 1967 by capturing territory from hostile nations during a protracted, international armed conflict waged for years by Arab Muslims whose clearly stated purpose was to finish the Final Solution that Hitler began. Due to prevalent Juden Haas among the vile collection of despots and Marxist-Socialists assembled in the U.N., Israel is the only nation in the world facing constant demands that it discontinue defending its children against slaughter and its borders against incursions. It is also the only nation in the world facing constant demands to cede land rightfully captured during armed conflict in accordance with customary international law. When members of the “Peace Today” can take their family to go build a synagogue and live peacefully among their friends in Gaza, peace may be a realistic, attainable goal. Until then, the world shouldn’t demand of Israel what it doesn’t demand of the Arabs.

    In Israel there is more courage in one small square mile than in all of Eurabia. In Israel there is more courage in one soldier than in the combined and cold hearts of every bureaucrat at the United Nations

  218. Obama is the first American president that lied to the Jewish people and the American people as well, when he said that he would defend Israel, the only Democratic state in the Middle East, against all their enemies. He has done just the opposite. He has propagandized Israel, until they look like they are everyone’s enemy — and it has resonated throughout the world. He is putting Israel in harm’s way, and he has promoted anti-Semitism throughout the world.

    Obama has brought this to a people who have given the world the Ten Commandments and most laws we live by today. The Jewish people have given the world our greatest scientists and philosophers, and the cures for many diseases, and now Obama plays a very dangerous game so he can look like a true martyr to what he sees and says are the underdogs. But the underdogs he defend are murderers and criminals who raped Natasha Smith and uncounted others and who want Israel eradicated.

  219. So, here’s the question: Can we defeat Iran?

    I won’t keep you in suspense. Here is my answer: We could if we had the will, but we don’t and so we can’t. This pains me more than I can possibly tell. I keep saying that the six million defenseless, unarmed, harmless Jews would have been better off if they had died resisting the Germans in whatever tiny, totally impractical way they could. What can I say then about the most powerful country in the world that is able to smite its enemies the way God Himself wouldn’t want to top, but prefers to keep its hands clean and, as a result, perish?

  220. Despite my utmost contempt for Islam and the abysmal way of life it has generated for its followers, I still believe in the sacred right of Muslims, along with everyone else on this planet, to live the way they see fit for themselves as long as they do not interfere with other people’s right to do the same. This is how I define peace: the freedom of a nation to live according to its own ideas of right and wrong without imposing those ideas on other nations or having other nation’s ideas forced on them. I don’t approve of “honor killings”, of genital mutilations, of public executions for deeds that aren’t even considered crimes in our society. However, I don’t believe I have a right to object to them as long as I am not forced to participate. Unfortunately, Islam directs the faithful to force me into participation. It’s called jihad. It’s mandatory. And it’s upon us. And practically every armed conflict that goes on earth today is a front of jihad.

  221. For Natasha I have nothing but compassion. For so many of the responds on here who demonstrate similar bigotry, intolerance, and aggresion as her attackers I feel nothing but disgust. It is never, never, never right to violate another person whether physically or in words or attitudes, if everyone learn to treat others as they would wish to be treated themselves, this world would be a much nicer place.

    • Intolerance of what???? A very hateful, sick, cancerous religion that advocates violence? Islam is complete and total violence. Violence against Jews, violence against women, violence against “infidels” or anyone who doesn’t subscribe to its horrible tenents. Do you want tolerance from normal people who are horrified at what this culture advocates? Sorry, I don’t “tolerate” people who want to kill me. I don’t “tolerate” people who think it’s a-okay to throw acid in the faces of young girls. I don’t “tolerate” a people whose calling in life is to erradicate me from this earth. If it makes you feel better to call me a bigot because I’m horrified at what these people are apparently capable of…have at it. You can’t run from the truth that most people see. I feel sorry for this young reporter. But she seems blind to what I see. I would never, ever have gone where she went. These people are savages, barely fit to live. They’ve been steeped in such vile hatred and now they are left with a culture that is a disease. I know what I see. Trying to call me a name to blunt the truth doesn’t change the truth. Maybe one day, these people will drag themselves into modern society…but all signs point to that not happening.

      • If you went to your local mosque and asked the imam there about any of the things you just listed, you would have never posted that.

  222. Natasha:
    l am a spanish women that often goes to Egypt for diving. l feel so sorry for what happened to you and l send you all my understanding and energy to overcome this. Be strong, continue with your life, try to help others and just pay attention to your heart. l know very well how egyptian men are: repression is a very bad thing, they grow up with fear in their minds, they do not know how to think…they just follow their religion, the lessons other told them, but they will never dare to break the rules, or think by themselves because they grew up with fear and a childish mind. Maybe not all, but loads of them. Sexually repressed, they see European women as a kind of provocation to their eyes, they desire what they cannot have and would do anything to satisfy their sick minds. Islam revolution will come through the hands of women, when they realise they need no men to be happy in this world, and that there are many ways of living and decide their own lives without the permit of a man. l have experienced many things in Egypt, they are liers, have no heart and at a chance to betray you, they will do it.
    Please, keep on enjoying life, love, friends, and other cultures, do not stop your life at this point and if there is something you want to do, try to help other women to understand how wonderfull life is when you are free to decide, free to committ your own mistakes, and the joy of learning from life experiencing.

  223. Readed a comment off a Dutch father in the Volkskrant.
    His Dutch daugher (student in Nice) was also nearly raped in the middle off the street in Nice.
    She and her 2 sisters were threatened with a knive to here througt
    Algerien Islamic boys are now ruling in Nice France!!!
    Tunesie (also going in the islamitic direction) is going the same way.

    We in the West Countrys are ruled by naive and dangerous leaders, bounded by a terror regime (Saoudi Arabie which also pays their Suni- bombings in Irak today) which feels the mighty god of Oil themselves.

    How far will we fall before we put a clear line?
    It will be the common people which will change our political systems, demanding for protecting our next generations.

    • Unfortunately they already fucked us, Christians, due to fucking tolerance of European politics, who betrayed legacy of Crusades… Why we should respect Muslims here, in our homeland, when they don`t care about out laws, traditions and religion???

      • I`m not supporting Breivik`s methods, but at least I understand his motivation…

    • Just to be clear I am not defending ,but what ever happened was done by savages and there are savages everywhere and they can’t be related to Islam or any religion, because in Islam plenty to do such horrible thing is death ,so clearly they have no regards to any rules and they are simply murders and psychopaths and cant represent any religion.

      • Thank you!!!
        i’m sick of this stereotyping and racism that’s been going on for the longest period of time!
        and just to be clear as well, i’m not muslim.
        please read carefully what the girl is trying to say.
        do not turn it into a political/social/racist debate. she doesn’t need that. she’s been through too much already.

        as for you, Natasha, i know you probably wouldn’t read this, but much love darling. i’m sorry this awful thing happen to you. but thank you for telling your story. it’s very courageous and brave of you. carry on ♥

  224. Hello Natasha.

    I strongly urge you to seek appropriate counselling as soon as you are able on your return. Please take care to do this as the mind has the ability to cleverly mask the impact of seriously traumatic experiences in the initial stages and if not properly treated, the effects can lead to debilitating PTSD.

    Please take care to avoid this as it is a very shocking experience that you have been through.

    All best wishes,

    Jenny

  225. I am so so sorry for what you’ve been through. No words can describe what I am feeling right now. I am an Egyptian woman but I live abroad. I won’t attempt to defend Egypt. All I can say is that I admire your spirit so much and these people are animals and deserve to die for what they did. I hope you will be able to put this behind you one day. You and your family are in my thoughts.

  226. Some of you call me names. Let me explain something into plain English for you, the politically correct peace-mongers.

    To be Arab means to conquer every nation that can be conquered and claim its historic achievements as if they belonged to Arabs from the beginning of time. Why not? According to the teachings of Islam, Adam and Eve, Abraham and Moses, Jesus and you are Muslims.

    Yes, you too, because Islam teaches that every human being is created Muslim. The Arab civilization does bring together Christian, Jews, and an ever growing list of other peoples. It brings them together in the mass grave of their destroyed civilizations, never bothering to ask whether those people ever wanted to be brought together by Arabs or anyone else.

    The most interesting aspect of this is that Arabs sincerely believe that they save those they conquer from the darkness of eternal ignorance.

    I remember reading somewhere that Egyptian peasants living today along the shores of the Nile are still using the same primitive irrigation devices that were used by their ancestors in Egypt 5,000 years ago. I believe that people who, in the course of 5 millennia, have failed to improve primitive, prehistoric technology, upon which their survival immediately depends, can be reasonably called primitive.

    Actually, it’s worse than that. Today’s Egyptians have nothing to do with the builders of the pyramids. Today’s Egyptians are Arabs. Their ancestors did not
    live along the Nile. Arabs invaded, occupied and conquered Egypt in the middle of 7th century CE, 20 short years after the invention of Islam. They invented Islam, but Inventing or even improving the water wheel was beyond their ability to create.

    I don’t mean to say that Islam does not stimulate our own creativity. Without it, our engineers would not have had reasons to invent ways to tell baby formula
    from explosives. Without it, our ethicists would not have to decide whether profiling Muslims is morally and legally admissible. Considering that 99.99% of
    terrorists in the modern world are Muslims, I would say that we should not profile them. We shouldn’t allow Islam – the greatest danger global humanity has ever faced – on our soil either. Without Islam, we would have been as safe from terrorist attacks on our soil today as we thought we were 11 years
    ago, on the eve of 9/11.

    Here’s another question for the ethicists. When someone hates the enemies of his country and his people, does that make him a racist? And if he doesn’t hate them, then what does that make him?

  227. Pingback: Friday Sex Links! « Sex with Timaree

  228. Thank you for sharing your story, Natasha. Your experience is deeply troubling. I strongly urge you to seek appropriate counselling as soon as you are able – when you return home. It is important after such experiences because the mind cleverly masks the impact of seriously traumatic experiences initially – and if not properly treated, the effects can lead to PTSD.
    I urge you to get treatment as soon as you are able.

    Take good care,

    Jenny

    • Natasha Smith should consider this good advice from Jenny.
      “I strongly urge you to seek appropriate counselling as soon as you are able – when you return home. It is important after such experiences because the mind cleverly masks the impact of seriously traumatic experiences initially “

  229. Dear Ms Natasha Smith, I am an Egyptian woman in my mid forties. I would like to express my sincerest apologies about what happened to you in my country. I feel terrible that you had to go through this brutal, inhuman attack. I totally understand your agony. I am also a mother of a 17 year old girl so I truly empathesize.I think you are very brave to share your story. I admire your passion for your studies and profession that brought you to Cairo in the first place. I also respect the way you felt and reacted throughout the whole ordeal. I am impressed about your kind thinking towards Egyptians despite the cruelty you were exposed to from a group of them. I hope you get over this trauma very soon and I wish you all the best of luck in your future. Stay safe

    • Dear Ghada, may be you will try to explain then why same group public rapes already happened 4 times with different journalist-women? Will you agree that something wrong with your entire society?

      • I am an Egyptian and I can’t say that there are no something wrong. Many things are wrong here but some of us are really trying to fight it.

        We are sorry

      • …and Western society is so perfect that no criminal acts take place on women? you shill. pos truth is your a racists pot stirrer that only sees the inside of your empty head.

      • To reply that , I am an Egyptian girl who currently live abroad , to reply the questions about the journalist-women rapes , i would like to share with you my experience and my sisters experience living in Egypt .
        My parents and grandparents always talk about how Egypt was in the 60s and the 70s how people where all EDUCATED and polite and everyone had work and something to do . This is an Egypt i never saw , i am 20 years old and i never used public transport or even taxi , WHY is that ?because every Egyptian girl has the same fear the journalist-women been exposed i can’t tell you how many girls i know been sexually harassed and raped kidnapped but those ignorant savages , Including my sister 2 month ago coming home form her University someone tried to kidnap her one block away form my home in Heliopolis ,but thank god she had pepper spray and that'”s why my scared parents do let me and my sister go out alone and if we are only girls we always carry pepper spray or any sort of protection and we never stay out late. And that is simply because for the past 30 years there is almost 30% uneducated and 40% living under the poor line with 5 dollars a month (maybe less i am not sure of the statistics you can see it online), if you go to the farms in upper Egypt you can ask them what religion do you follow they will say Islam and if you ask what is the name of the prophet they will tell you they don’t know ! ,same with Christians in Egypt . Those men are thugs uneducated savages due to the corruption and the poverty they are living in , and they are not stopped because the police is as corrupted , Education is everything you teach people morals and religion and they will follow , so take everything from them money , food , well being and they will turn into animals . So that’s why there is revelation because all the educated brilliant minded can’t live there because they are not payed or even acknowledged . You have no idea how i love my country and thank god i was lucky enough to be in a Middle level family , my parents struggled to give me the best education possible inexpensive of a lot of things even health my father works 12 hours a day to provide for my family ,So as you see people are not lucky as you , no one chooses his life and where he was born .In this case those people are like that all because of the thieve Mubarak , who ripped out everything we have.I am not defending i am stating facts.
        Finally Though i am abroad my heart is back home where there is still good people and hope , and i cant wait to help my country bloom again as it used to.
        Something is wrong and that’s why we made the revelation. Pray for us to be better because we are sure trying !.

  230. “If we extend unlimited tolerance even to those who are intolerant, if we are not prepared to defend a tolerant society against the onslaught of the intolerant, then the tolerant will be destroyed, and tolerance with them.”
    – Karl Popper

  231. I think she was raised in a culture so different and so detached that it is hard for here to grasp the true nature of that culture. It’s hard for me to criticize her right after she experience the worst nightmare of every woman in this world. i can only hope that eventually she would be shaken from those pseudo liberal ideas she thinks she must hold on too. god i feel like getting on a plane to egypt and putting all the men there in prisons. i can’t deal with this. really. do you know the The AHA Foundation? it’s trying to fight the horrible crimes being done to women in the name of Islam and religion. I highly recommend them.

  232. Pingback: e-lending … is anyone that bothered? | Can we re-Kindle Our Love for The British Bookstore?

  233. Your words are of utmost grace. Filled my mind with such lewd pictures and made me so hard as I imagined waves of filthy Muslims violating your tender body over and over again. I printed out a picture of your angelic face and finished on it. I’ll do it again soon and post a picture of it for the whole world to see.

    • You sick, weak fucks should be shot and left to rot on the side of the road, just like the attackers. I wish you a horrible life, you wretch.

    • Seriously? You honestly think this is ok to post? This is something horrible that happened to someone in real life, and she’s had the courage to talk about it. If you’re trying to be funny, then trust me you’ve failed. If you’re not trying to be funny, then you’re just being sick and need to get your head examined.

  234. Hi, Natasha. You really are a survivor.

    I am from Brazil and I am shocked about what happened to you in Egypt. In my country sexual assalts and rape are considered heinous crime and rapers are hated in the Brazilian society (it doesn’t matter if the victim is “pregnant, married or virgin”).

    To encourage victims to fight for their rights, many Brazilians counties have a special police station for women. This special police station for women is responsible for investigate, typify crimes agaisnt woman and file police reports. The result is impressive, the number of victims looking for this assistance has increased substantially, they can count on the system.

    There is an special law to protect women against domestic violence, Maria da Penha’s Law. Maria da Penha fighted for almost two decades to put her ex-husband in prison, who tried to killed her twice, and after a public clamour and an international pressure upon the Brazilian Government, it was created this law named with her name in homage to her case.

    I believe that a Police Station for Women and a special law agaisnt domestic violence is essencial to start changings in a society dominate by male opression. Without a support, these women will be condemned to live in that cruel reality forever.

    You don’t need to come back there, you are stronger outside that country beacuse nowadays we have the world in a screen. Many Egyptians said that they reached a victory because they could fight against the ancien Government without been caught and tortured. Fight against that monsters in a place where your rights and, mainly, your body and soul will not violeted, again.

    You can use a translator software to:

    1. Maria da Penha’s Law
    http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/_ato2004-2006/2006/lei/l11340.htm

    2. Police Station for Woman
    http://www.sepm.gov.br/acesso-a-informacao/perguntas-frequentes/violencia/o-que-e-delegacia-especializada-no-atendimento-a-mulher-deam/

    I wish all the best for you!
    Good luck with your project!

  235. Natasha, I don’t think it’s your fault, but I think you’re tremendously stupid when you say you love that place and the people and what happened to you doesn’t represent Egypt or Islam. You know perfectly well what would happen to someone wearing a star of david on his or her neck, or to someone who would be perceived to be gay or lesbian. That’s Egypt and that’s Islam. When you go back there to make your politically correct statement, please take a start of david on your neck and prove us wrong.

    • Don`t worry, Romeu, she is not stupid, she just likes these BDSM games and group public rape was one of her most excited girly fantasies. That`s why she wants to feel it again and again.

    • No, “bravery” isn’t what happened there. “Bravery” is going BACK there thinking you’ll prove the innate beauty of this hateful culture/religion. I’m starting to think Ms. Smith has a thing for adrenaline rushes, not journalism. Take up bungy jumping girl!

    • I am sorry to hear you believe in a “religion” that advocates the abuse of non-muslims. How disgusting you are.

      • I am sorry but where exactly is it written In Islam that non Muslims should suffer ?? . Please don’t not state your opinion as a Fact , you want to accuse , accuse with proves. Not all how claim them selves Muslims are Muslims , Most of the terrorist just twist the words into their own perspective and act upon it and say “ya i am Muslim and i am following this and that “. BUT i want to remind you that there are psychopaths everywhere ,and there is a word called “lying” which means not saying the truth ,so never ever take what you hear for granted because people DO LIE !! . ONE more point i have traveled almost everywhere and i met a lottt of people Muslims form different countries and backgrounds and tell you what each ONE of them have their own perspective influenced by their culture , and family culture as well , not to mention the language because not everyone can read Arabic and they have the translated versions of everything …and just a brief example of translation is google translate ya it helps but never gets it completely right and the rest is for you to wonder , so if you want to accuse , accuse a murder or the person who actually did something and never generalize .

  236. I’m so, so sorry to hear this happened to you, Natasha. You’e incredibly brave and you’re a fierce, fierce woman to have been out there filming in such a mad, volatile situation that’s crying out to be recorded; and why not you? Why not a woman?

    I’m a journalist as well, and though we don’t know each other, I have nothing but pride in you and immense respect for the job you’ve been doing.

    I couldn’t continue reading all the bickering and nasty crap of different varieties in the comments here, and suggest you give that a miss, for now, too – take a break mate. Just catch your breath. Sending you all strength and power, and love,

    Claire x.

    • All strength, power and love is nothing when nothing is in head. You should wish more brains to Natasha as seems she really needs them.

    • Not in the least true. The Oklahoma City Bomber – Timothy McVeigh? Christian. The Norway Bomber and mass murderer – Anders Breivik? Christian. The IRA bombers? One and all Christian.

      • And if to compare them to quantity of Muslim terrorists? Big difference, isn`t it?

      • Keeping score are we? So, what you’re saying is: christian morons 3- muslim morons 3 billion. You’ll keep me up to speed on that development won’t you?

      • Good girl Kate, you`ve got the point Also all named Christians tool that tactics exactly from Muslim terror brigades, lets remember Munich Olympics.

      • Breivik was not a Christian, but an infidel, or have you heard as he has screaming “God Akbar” ? or “Jesus Akbar” ? he and the other, those were killer, and no religious people. in the bible is nothing written that the christians have to kill someone. but in the quran! sure 9;5 sure 9;29 sure 9;73 sure 9;123 sure 2;191 sure 2;193 sure 4;89….. do you want more? There are still lots of it

      • Lord X, have you actually read the bible? The old testament is full of bloodthirsty ‘kill the unbelievers’ rants. Deuteronomy 13 springs to mind.

      • @ Cait. and what does this have to do with braivik and the other murderers? you wanna tell me that these people has read the old testament? hitler and napoleon has also read the old testament?

  237. Islam is for idiots, never go to islam countries and fight angainst islam that is spreading all over the world : this retard religious shit is the cancer of humanity

    • You`re are not really right, people who rule the crowds of Muslims very far from idiots, they just use the religion to keep the power

  238. Islam ? nice religion full of violence and insane people … what a shame … i will never visit that kind of country, the middle ages was more safe than now

      • a rape in public, driven by hundreds of wild people, something exists only in Islamic states.

  239. That`s it, there WAS and WiLL be NO any sign of democracy in that country, especially with new pro-Muslim president and especially for western women. What kind of “culture” are you spoken? Dirty animals, nothing more. And if Natasha wants “to return to this wonderful country and city”, then all this just means she really liked treatment she got and wants to enjoy it again. Go on.

    • Congrats on being a horrible person and totally misunderstanding not only Natasha, but everything she wrote. You clearly don’t have much empathy or much emotional range, drive, or resilience yourself if this is what you’re taking from it.

      • Surely me, but I never would like to return back to place, where I was almost killed, if only with heavy weapons to revenge. And this is RIGHT. Most of those “nice people” never change and they will repeat same action next time. You don`t believe me, Laika? Come on, visit that “wonderful country” now.

        PS.This damned tolerance will kill Europe in nearest future.

  240. i think that this is a big lie that you made up. why did not you go to the authorities if you are fair..lies .lies.lies .all people in tahrir were just asking and crying to Allah to have a good president , they did not have time to bully anyone . so your story is not true.

    • Natasha is at least the FOURTH western female reporter, all blondes, raped on the tahrir square. Before her there was Lara Logan, Carolin Sinz, a danish one.
      Russians says at least twi other were.
      If you are really an egyptian woman (and not a raper in disguise), how can you defend fanatics who excise 93% of their daughters and rape whoever they want because they can. This is psychiatric.

      • four female journalists.. you said. \
        then I’m wondering why they still go there. don’t they know better?

  241. i am an egyptian

    i did not vote for MORSI nor SHAFIQ beacuse i know that the whole situation is FUCKED up and the Mercenaries are still out there walking around in religious shoes.
    there is NO kind of any justification what so ever for what happened to u
    but all i can say that just feel sorry for us due to the 30 years of corruption and minibulating the morals
    &

    I AM SORRY :(((((((

  242. Come visit Oslo and you may experience the same dear Britons. Sexual harassment of white women by Arabs and blacks is an everyday experience is this multicultural city. Police don’t give a darn about anything else than investigating white people who may be bigots. The logic from our government and their media is that we bigots are to blame for the rape epidemic we have “brought upon our self”.

  243. Islam : isn’t it the religion written by a slaver, raider, raper and pedophile maniac that makes the raped women guilty of adultery ? It drove to suicide a 16 yo Moroccan girls a few monthes ago : raped, and forced to wed her raper by her own parents, because sharia commanded it.
    Isn’t it the religion of the Rochdale serial gang-rapers, who considered english non-muslim teens were just whores (for being non-muslim) and acceptable rape-fodder ?
    Animals, the filthy lot of them.

    • And now her boyfriend is setting up an account to make it possible for her to return to the scene of the crime in order to make some “beautiful, politically correct” statement! This is the apex of delusion and horror. He should be online trying to find weapons grade plutonium to make a bomb not make excuses for her rapists! For shame….there is tolerance and there is stupidity!

      • i think her boyfriend is trying to do the right thing for his girlfriend he is showing how much he cares and how worried about the whole situation i think everyone here who has something bad to say about them should just not write anything and leave them and this site alone as your just making matters worse

  244. *sigh* the wonders of cultural relativism. Seems like Evolution is doing its work mightily fine, you were just lucky this time… yet you plan to go back. Go figure.

    You are correct in one account. This happens to women the world over but in all judeo-christian religions where women are seen as inferior to men, license to behave like this is almost culturally implicit. I truly do despair for the likes of you… regardless what happened to you is not something I would wish upon anyone, no matter how foolish and delusional. Get well soon and rethink whether it is a good idea to head back there, you can fight your fight without ‘becoming a catalyst’, or is that modern speech for secular martyr?

    • It’s not her trying to be a martyr, it’s her working to make some good out of a terrible situation. People do that. Is that so hard to understand? It’s part of life, and the way strong people often cope with hardship. It’s probably the best (if not only) way of moving forward completely.

      And FTR, Judeo-Christian cultures are far from the only ones in which this is culturally implicit. To believe that you’d have to ignore quite a bit of the rest of the world.

      • Laika, seeing as adherents of judeo-christian religions (including islam) (no I don’t capitalise these aberrations out of sheer disrespect) account for the vast majority of the population on this planet I reckon that’s pretty thorough.

        Yeah yeah you can split hairs if you like and bring up the populations of India and China and still it would not make a difference to this point.

        Also, I see that the use of the phrase ‘secular martyr’ is lost on you.

        Strong people hah! ‘perform mistake, learn, and avoid’ is the only evolutionary biology acceptable way of coping with hardship, not something that h. sapiens as a species has mastered 😉

  245. This sentence is very insightful: “that good education doesn’t make an idiot any less of an idiot, just an educated idiot that’s all”
    Muhammad Atta was well educated, coming from a well-to-do family. But he was also a muhammadan idiot, believing in the idiotic promise of 72 virgins in Janna. And he was even more of a well educated, muhammadan idiot if he believe that 72 raisins was worth the sacrifice of his own life.
    The idiotic muhammadan crowd in that “blessed place” are an impatient lot. In stead of waiting for the newly elected ikhwan caliph to proclaim jihad to the kufr people, in order to rob them of their possessions and enslave their women they just grab a kufr young woman who happens to be there.
    The land of Kemet will be a country, rich beyond belief in the future thanks to the outstanding muhammadan economist who has a brilliant solution to eradicate poverty. Poor people don’t have to resort to the described practices.:

    • That’s one big fallacy here, extremist wahabi Islamists are not representatives of Egyptian moderate conception about Islam. Those extremists like Abu-Ishak and others get paid with millions of oil gulf money to spread an extremist pro-dictator understanding of religion. I bet if you can get a single terrorist speech like this one coming out of an Azhar clerk.

      • Recep Tayyip Erdoğan: “There Is No Radical or Moderate Islam. There Is Only Islam.”
        Dear Mr. Ahmed Seddik: Why don’t you brush up your qur’an, sahih ahadiths al Bukhari and Muslim, ibn Majah, al Tirmidhi, the Muwatta of Malik ibn Annas, the Sunan of Abu Daud, the Tafsir al jalalayn, etc., etc.
        There you will find the muhammadanism of Abu al Qasim Muhammad ibn Abdallah. As a true mumin you should listen tothe “great” Turkish padishah.

  246. Natasha!
    I was horrified about your story, please forgive me if what i’m actually going to tell will seems rude to you, but please let me tell my opinion of what’s happened:
    This is just the mob of sexually disfunctional (not satisfied, not learned how 2 treat etc) young animals, i mean this could happen to anyone in this country. The truth is there most of them like you meet, this is just the result of history of the country and the society. Your only mistake was to think that your true love to country and peoples will be your shield. I wish you 2 come back home asap, there will be more violence soon, believe me.

    Zagit, Russia.

  247. Natasha,

    I am also a survivor of sexual assault. It left me scarred emotionally and mentally–I know what you are going through, and I am outraged at the morons who are blaming you for being assaulted or using your assault as an excuse to engage in naked racism and stupidity, because it reminds me of the “well it’s your fault”-type garbage that I heard after I was attacked.

    This attack was not your fault, Natasha. It was never your fault, and it will never be your fault. I applaud your decision to continue with your documentary–it sends a very clear message that your assailants do not have power over you, and it shows that you are a lot stronger than some small-minded asshats are giving you credit for.

    Thor ward you, great lady.

      • Dear Cait and AQ,
        Thank you for being one of the few sensible people here. Please, do continue posting and taking down all these nationalist, racist, religious nut-jobs. “the only thing necessary for evil to win is for good people to do nothing!”
        To Natasha,
        I would be lying if i say that i can even begin to comprehend what you have,are going through. Thank you for sharing this with us, Please, seek help, especially for PTSD. And please do continue with your documentary. I wish you a speedy recovery and may your mind never be clouded by ill judgement based on anything that is not driven by logic.
        Your fellow human,
        RL.

  248. As I said earlier, Natasha is really a brave girl and far more sensible to understand it’s not the religion responsible for what happened to her, it’s just some BAD people in the societies who create such horrific crimes. Just for example read this news : http://articles.cnn.com/2012-03-25/justice/justice_california-immigrant-death_1_iraqi-woman-el-cajon-life-support?_s=PM:JUSTICE
    now shall Muslim blame ALL Americans or Christianity responsible for the murder of 32 years old Iraqi mother of five???

    • You compare apples with oranges.There is a clear connection between islam and violence against women or violence in general.It’s clear for everyone that the muslim society has problems with sexuality and women and you comparison is a pathetic attempt to distort the true.Natasha wasn’t assaulted by some deranged criminals in a dark corner but by mob of normal, ordinary guys in broad daylight on a crowded square.That is a shame

      • Islam never allow violence against any animal, how about humans!!! Please if you don’t know about Islam, don’t judge it.
        I can’t see the ‘clear connection’ you are talking about here. Can you clarify more??
        I don’t think that you know the ‘people’ who attacked Natasha. How come did know that they are not criminals?? How do u know if they Muslims , Christians, or even atheists ??
        Why you didn’t speak about the other ‘people’ who tried to protect her?? why they can’t be Muslims??
        Religion has nothing to do with what happened to Natasha.
        if a person convicted with murder, the judge is muslim and the person is also a muslim. Why you look to the murder only??

        At last, I am terribly sorry for you, Natasha :(. Please accept my apologies for what happened to you, it was our fault, we should have protect you. I don’t know what I can say to make you feel better. I am really sorry again

      • @Ahmed
        Please don’t give me the BS they aren’t real muslims and islam doesn’t allow it.Look at muslim countries and then judge again.There aren’t any Jews anymore in the Arab countries.The Christians are being slaughtered in all muslim countries including Egypt where the Copts face a gloomy outlook for their future because of the oppression they experience by their fellow muslim country men.Pakistan,Iraq,Sudan Nigeria in all these countries Christian communities are shrinking because of islam which encourages the killing of Jews and Christans.I guess they aren’t real muslim either,are they?Look at Westbank and Gaza i know it’s not everything okay there but is that a reson to name shopping malls or sport center after suicide bomber?

  249. I thought as an Egyptian that people lacking the ability to attribute causes of a problem; sexual harassment in Egypt for example, to a compound multi-factorial cause was part of our poor education and intellectual standard.. And that low intellectual standard was why people tend to look for a single bright shiny reason to put on all the blame of their problems.

    Frankly I believe that everyone who puts all the blame only on Islam, or the barbaric cultural nature of Egyptian men without putting in consideration the extreme social injustice and poverty and social imbalance and political dictatorship and lack of freedoms people were and still are suffering in Egypt as major co-factors contributing to the ugly scene told by Natasha, those who just think its religion and only religion that made that scene take place serve to prove a point, that good education doesn’t make an idiot any less of an idiot, just an educated idiot that’s all. You people are not any different than salafists, you’re just agnostic salafists.

    I feel sorry for you Natasha, reading this post made me remember the day my sister came home from college crying because of an incident which honestly was less violent, yet not any less barbaric than the one you’ve experienced. I’m sure that a strong young lady just like you will get over this experience soon enough.

  250. Before a journalist goes to a place to report complex social phenomena he or she should make him/herself knowledgeable about the culture of that place. The place visited by ms. Smith has been under the shadow of a criminal for 14 centuries. If a culture has been dominated for this long by a highway robber, an extortionist, a paedophile, a rapist, a mass murderer, a slave trader by the name of Muhammad ibn Abdallah don’t expect humane values and practices. This mob just follow the practice of their role model (uswa hussana) who had raped many a woman during the time when he became powerful. Read the Sira and the Ahadith before you undertake to study this specific society.

  251. The story seems all too familiar. Maybe not with the same amount of violence you experienced. I have seen western women (journalists,ngo´s and people that like to be on top of everything around the world) and their “i am untouchable” attitude. They often have absolutely no respect for different cultures and point their cameras point blank into everybody´s face without having the consent of the person in front of the lense. I call your experience “totally foolish”. Just stay where you are. There they are mostly all like you.

  252. Natasha,

    first I am very sorry and accept my sympathy and sorry for this barbaric action.

    secone, DO NOT BELIEVE ANYTHING FROM WHAT IS TOLD TO YOU IN EGYPT.

    The Propaganda and sheating is spread everywhere in Egypt.
    I BELIEVE THAT THE ATTACK IS ORGANIZED !!! and not just from a couple of criminals.
    Egypt is since long time is without Law and without Order (see what is done to the copts thens of Years before)!!!!!.
    If You need to do an Experiment, complain to the new elected President and see whether he will bend the finger for You and do anything OR NOT!
    The Rvolution MUST continue till a real civilian and a real democratic fair human and civil president will be fairly elected and not throut ……….

    ALL what is published IN EGYPT NOW IS LIES LIES LIES and the Evil will distroy himself.

    Please forgive these barbaric People, but try to complain officially TO GET THE cRIMINALS BE PUNSHED: maybe the foreign minister of the UK MUST do somthing and apply pressure ON Egypt for sake of the future victims linke You.

    All the Best and may the LORD heals all Your Wounds.

    HE and only HE can heal us and repair evary thing ONLY HIM … it is like a magic biut it is true.
    And the LORD will do that FOR YOU!
    Believe it (and not, or not!).

    • “I think that the attack was organized” .. No it is not and you know well it is not ..and stop telling the world it is the last 60 years ..it is not too…it is the ideology of the Mb who is taking power now ..thanks to what so call ” Arab Spring “…please free world do n’t reelect any one who backed or contributed in creating this ” ugly spring “.. For your people ‘ s good .

  253. I happened to read upon this just out of the blue.
    I’m thoroughly disgusted by such behavior, I have a girlfriend who I’d give the world to, just to make her happy and the thought of something like this possibly happening to her because she has blond hair in a bigot filled country… it just makes me shudder. People, yes t his happens everywhere but i don’t remember the last time there was a public gang rape in the U.S., and if something like this even started up for one minute the MAJORITY of the U.S. around would probably beat to death anyone who was participating in such a foul act.
    It’s entirely appalling to know this could actually go on, and it’s justified in the end by.. religion. By a base belief like Islam. I’m all for free religious beliefs, but when your religion kills millions and causes such suffering.. then maybe things should change.

  254. Natasha ,
    I’m an Egyptian girl . I knew about wt happened to u & I;m really sorry for all wt u have been through , I hope u r better now . I want to tell u some real words u have to put in mind always no matter wt happened … Muslims , Arabs, & Egyptians … are not pigs to be shot , they are not all rapists , they are nt brutal , they are nt anything of wt’s been written above & known for them everywr cause of ignorance of their History & civilization .. We are just human beings like everybody else ,. Don’t u ever think cause u r a journalist or a forgeiner , u were sexually harrased ! No ! it happens everwr in the world Natasha , even in ur country & u know it … We are originally good , but ppl just want to focus on the awful things bad ppl do here although everyone of those critisers have dozens of issues a like in their country. If u would have been up to this in ur country , would that be their reaction?? I’m sure not … I’m really sorry for u Natasha & sorry we have such ppl between us . But wt I can assure u is that specially egyptians are the most kind, welcoming , open hearted ppl u can ever meet . Don’t let a very harsh & negative experience prevent u from seeing the whole picture .. Any of us could have been in yr place , Be strong , face yr fears , live yr life .. Egypt will always welcome u ))

  255. I am a poud Egyptian and reading your story has caused me a grat deal of sorrow sadness and despair , I am now speaking on behalf of Egyptian girls like me ; I AM DREADFULLY SORRY for horrible experience though I know it won,t compensate your pain and I appreciate that you undersatnad that this NOT the true nature of Egptians or Islam though many comments claim that such a barbaric act is encouraged by the Egyptian Islamic society but I assure you all that bybeing an Egyptian Muslim girl Islam has the utmost respect for women and such a viciose act gets up to death penalties ..

  256. I cannot say anything but just imagine what you went through. My God, you are one brave girl! Try to forget this incident as much as possible otherwise it would not let you have peace. You are lucky to be alive and God/Allah listened to your prayer. These savage men Muslim or not (does not matter) will be standing on the day of judgment when the justice will be done properly. Keep faith and feel strong. My prayers are with you…A bih hug to you!…From: a Muslim woman

  257. Pingback: Natasha Smith « ladykokoroswansong

  258. I have never read or even heard of anything that touched me as much as your incident and moreover your determination to not let this terrible experience stop you! I had tears in my eyes reading this. Hollywood should make movies about people like you instead of the avengers! You are a real life hero! Not because of what happened to you but because after all that, you can say “I will overcome this and come back stronger and wiser”. No one on earth could be stronger than that!

  259. It´s your own fault. You should know how muslims behave. I would never visit a muslim country in my life. Never.

  260. I’m So Sorry. i apologize for every moment you had in this madness
    I’m Egyptian, and i feel shameful because what happened for you.
    Thanks GOD you are safe.

  261. First of all, i’m so sorry for what happened to you and hope you’ll be ok.

    Now the question is, where have you been the last few years ? Where have you been the last few years ?

    Lara Logan, reporter from CBS, was raped there. Caroline Sinz, french journalist was raped there. Duth girl was raped there, and so many many womens from egypt and from foireign culture.

    So the questio is, where have you been the last few years to not learn from this women’s experience ?

    Are you so naive ? I’ll not say what happened is your fault BUT what happened shows that you’re not living in the same world than some of us.

    Even with 3 or 4 or 10 friends, i’ll never go to this place with my girlfriend or any female friend as i’ll not be 100% sure to give her full protection if something went wrong.

    Everybordy knows in this world what kind of treatment womens can have in this place. Everybody knows rape’s history from dutch, american, french….. journalists, turists, or womens in this place

    So what did you think before going to this place ? What happened in your mind ?

    I don’t know why but in few weeks or months, we’ll hear another same history from a female, journalist or tourist, going to the same place, be raped in the same conditions, and after that complaining for what happened.

    What the hell happen with you ladies ?????

    We all have a brain and it’s not forbidden to use it.

    • Im so sorry for what had happened to natasha but really you should propagand for this country as it a zone for rapiest its not like that and i liked that you said not even with 3,4or even 10 friends you do to aplace like that without knowing how to protect the one with you it was very shamfull of the people there but the bad thinking of natasha an# her friend especially her friend for letting hergo there know the circumstances of the situation but really this isnt islam and muslim country behaves so so sorry natashaa

    • Actually, you ARE saying that what happened is her fault. It’s called victim-blaming, and it’s wrong and sociopathic.

    • You cannot possibly excuse the conduct of the men involved by saying ‘she shouldn’t have been there in the first place’. While this hackneyed and ridiculous concept of rape exists ie ‘the person who got raped can somehow be blamed for the event’ rape will continue to happen and go unpunished and victims will continue to feel unnecessary guilt and shame for what happened to them. Rape is ALWAYS wholly the fault of the rapist. There is no such thing as ‘contributory negligence’ in this situation, NOTHING can excuse what those men did.

  262. Natasha your experience was disheartening and devastating to read, but I truly thank you for posting your experience to provide others with insight into such horrible events. I don’t want to simply tell you what I am sure you are already tired of hearing, but your are a strong and unique individual and your spirit is inspiring. I truly wish you the best of luck in your continued work in Egypt and also your continued fight against sexual abuse no matter where it takes place in the world. It is through exposing stories like your own and creating a debate that brings to light the horrible details of sexual abuse that people will truly be shown the horrible treatment of women in countries around the world. Your story is important and one that many need to hear, I hope that you never stop spreading your message and making your voice heard!

    • Criminals of all
      Origins should be shot dead ! But when u say Muslims ! That’s weird ! Don’t you have criminals of the same origin like you ? Sir , crime has no origin nor religion !!!!

    • Excuse me but you didn’t understand anything of what she explained… You just have a pathetic reaction…
      Respect to Natasha and be brave to overcome what you passed through…

      • You’re right MOB RAPE in Broad daylight is not tolerated nor is it commonplace in Christian nations!! Oh my goodness if that happened it would be on the news 24hrs. Oprah would talk about it…the police would round them up and put them all in jail for life.

        All nations and religions have issues…this is true, but the problem with Islam is that it is so archaic in mindset it never admits that there needs to be reform and never admits anything they are doing is wrong, there are always excuses being made. Unlike Christianity whose religion is based on repentance and confessions of one’s sins so that our lives can become better. I am just over the Middle East for the simple fact that the region as a whole is unable to accept that this is the 21st century. The Middle East has NO CLUE how to deal with democracy because of their mind set; again this is a systemic problem that will not change anytime soon.

  263. you cant expact a good behavoir of men if you dont demand it.
    you cant control the male’s sexuality with eliminating the female’s one.
    this is not working.
    there is no modest society when just 50% have to learn taking responsibilities.
    these men have never learnd being self responsible for their own sexuality.
    they do learn that always the woman is fault.
    im sorry but with the veil sexual harassment will growth!!! because men do not learn taking responsibilities for their own sexuality und behaviour which is very important!
    by the way sexual harassment do not happen because of the sexual lust it happens because of the sexual lust for POWER. men in patriachy have got no sexual power they are completely sexual depand on women.
    but at the same time they think the male sexuality should be superior.
    so sexual harassment is a power struggle, they are not doing it for the sex they are doing it because they are horny for the sexual self-authority
    every man has got the SAME smile when he sexual harasses
    it’s a smile for power it’s a smile of joy of humiliation!!!

  264. iam from egypt we see things like thise evry day what you wait from pepole live 60 in dark we are mouslem but alot of us did not know any thing abot islam i told u iam sorry but the most of us good pepole and we hope you come againe but thise time you will see the real egyptios the most kind pepole in the all world

  265. Dear Natascha, I was SHOCKED reading your peril…!
    You were SO lucky to escape alive. And still you want to go back to this world of madness…??? Everywhere where islam is getting in power it’s women and girls who will not be safe anymore. If ANY religious leader orders your wife/daughter to be stoned all you can do is cast the first stone and hope you kill her instantly so she doesn’t have to suffer long. They CAN and they DO so…! Because they are so AFRAID of women…!
    And then the religious idiots (followers) – who don’t think for themselves! – start killing off everyone who uses his brains and questions things and then eternal darkness falls in. It’s no coincidense that islam wears a half moon and star as it’s mark.
    It’s the realm of darkness. It’s the new fascism…
    But that’s something a lot of people in the west don’t want to see as they believe in their own vulgair stories that islam is love…
    Sleep well, Western world…

    • Obviously some random German guy. You’d hide better under an Islamic name if your English came from Arabic rather than Germanic roots, my racist friend/s.

  266. Thank you for sharing your story. It was very difficult to read it. I do comprehend the dissociation you write of having experienced during the attack fully and the terror of finding yourself powerless against madness. I had much this same experience when I was eight years old..in remote rural Australia. I agree this type of mob stupidity and mindlessness is not representative of any religion or any nationality or region and most certainly I know, is not simply a middle eastern problem. It is though, a justification problem.
    Though through the grace of the presence that protected me from the worst of my time of terror, I am much healed since my encounter.. though I will never forget its lessons. I do have to keep reminding myself on a daily basis even now, that ‘ some men’ do this..not all..or else I fear despair would take over. I pray every day that men will learn that abdication of responsibility for their own sex and emotional drives is theirs, alone…and that somehow the minds and hearts of the many good men in the world will be empowered to help the minds and hearts of these diseased men. Until that day I will continue to walk with God and carry a big stick.

  267. Natasha, please don’t go back there. At least, not soon. Give yourself some time to heal. Get counseling.

    You saw this culture at its worst — but it’s nonetheless the true Egypt and yes, representative, much as we would like to think otherwise. Much as many Egyptians would like to think otherwise. Similar things have happened time and again. If the multiple rapes (that’s what they were) are not bad enough, consider the indifference of educated Egyptians, men and women alike, in the tent and at the hospitals.

    And I beg you, don’t think for a moment that you brought this on by being less vigilant than you might have been.

    Neither should you write off the experience as something done by thugs, by hooligans. Most of your attackers probably were ordinary men taking advantage of an opportunity.

    People will do in crowds what they won’t do as individuals. Such attacks don’t always happen, but they happen with enough regularity in Egypt (and elsewhere, alas) to be predictable. In other words, violence against women is a cultural pattern we can’t wish away by saying “All Egyptians aren’t like that,” or by you going back to Egypt and successfully filming in a crowd of men. It won’t prove anything except that you’re brave, and we know that already.

    • So does that mean that when some redneck POS drags a black man behind his truck until body parts go flying off in random directions, or some racist dirtbag decides to shoot up a community center because he “hates liberals”, it’s representative of the US?

      Stupid, stupid person.

      • I believe in the US they would provide the victim with treatment when she or he arrived at the hospital, and feel some empathy for he or she. Not so in Cairo/Egypt apparently. It says a lot about the country…

      • Look again i am not defending , but as a local i NEVER ever go to a public hospital why ? , the main reason again is the corrupted regime those people are hired by family friends with higher ranks and usually the worst doctors can be ,this is not usually the case for all hospitals but sure exists , the other case is the other doctors barely take any income or money and have big families to look after taking care of her would put their family in danger !. WE HAVE SO MUCH CORRUPTION FROM THE LAST REGIME Those people do not follow morals or religion and THAT’S WHY WE MADE THE REVOLUTION and up until now the there is CORRUPTION and the old regime exists ,You have no idea the proofs that both of the elected presidents forged their ways there :S . AND THAT’S WHY THE REVOLUTION DIDN’T STOP and will not stop until a better EGYPT

    • NO EXCUSES EVER!
      NO ONE ” deserves” to be raped or assaulted EVER
      The responsibility for the CRIME is with the perpetrator!
      There is NEVER a reason to sexually assault ANYONE.
      You cannot ” bring it on”.
      STOP EXCUSING DESPICABLE CRIMES!

    • Unbelievable. They keep telling, that these people are so religious believe in Alah and in the Koran and then doing this horrible thing. Either they are hypocrites or don’t really believe in it. The other possibility ist, that someone can interpret the koran in his own way and that it says it is okay do do this. Either way this its no good. Dangerous, dangerous religion, ehere people are forced to join straight from the beginning of their lives and threathened with death if they decide to believe in something else. I hope the officials of the islam agree one day, on one interpretation of the koran where this kind of violence is against god. I people would then really believe in god, they would be the disbelievers. I also would see some of these men in jail and a demonstration of moslems against this kind of behavior – otherwise they just look away and agree with it in a passive way.

    • When do you understand that a rape victim’s blog is not the place to make shallow, useless, blaming comments? 😦

  268. Thank you for bravely recounting your story. I hope that your physical and emotional injuries are healing and that you can put this behind you. It is quite disturbing, however, to know that this is not an isolated event. I’ve never been to Egypt and am hopeful that most Egyptians are good people but it seems as though there is something truly rotten in Egyptian culture that makes it acceptable for women to be treated this way. Spy, foreigner, reporter – it does not matter. There are real issues that need to be addressed – God help the women who live with it day by day.

    • I am Egyptian and trust me such act is absolutly unacceptable and there are up to death penalties as a punishment for such a dreadfull act according to the Egyptian law and Islam . but unfortunalty the old rotten regime stood watching infront of such barbaric acts ,which has repeated many times through the past years, especially when it comes to foreign reporters in order to bolck them away from Egypt ,her story is already sreading between Egyptians amng twitter and we will not just stand and watch these animals need to be punished … We are really sorry for her dreadful ecounter and we hope you all don’t take these barbaric hooligans ,who are more of animals than humans, as representitves of the Islamic and Egyptian society

    • No it is not islam it is not egypt but it is the culture of these men , i`m very very sorry natasha , i don`t know you natasha but i like and love you please come back to egypt 🙂 forgive egypt I am really so sorry

      • “the culture of these men” – You mean the 62 % of egyptian men who admit to having sexually harassed a female. When 62 % of the population is continually doing the same thing i would say this seems to be a problem with egypt. And why is it that the more religious a people becomes, the more strict it’s intrerpretation of islam is, theless rights do females enjoy?

    • True true. And that is from an Egyptian perspective. All that was great about Egypt died with it’s pharoahs. Unfortunately the vast majority of Egyptians today are primitive, child-like and hideous. I carry such shame to be of that background. Natasha- I apologies whole-heatedly for the what happened to you at the hand of these primitive people.

    • Rapists exist in all societies and religions. I don’t think that those thugs in Tahrir were any better or worse than catholic bishops who raped schoolchildren. There are victims of sexual assault in muslim, christian, jewish, budhist societies.
      However, you can’t deny that some common sense and better judgement would have been in order in this situation especially after what happened to Lara Logan in exactly the same place a couple of months ago. Come on.. God will protect you, but you have to be careful yourself in the first place.

  269. I have two comments:

    1) To good, caring, and compassionate Egyptians: What about Natasha’s camera and film? Can’t you help her to find these important items? I hear of stolen items being found all the time now through the internet and word of mouth. Please help Natasha get her work and gear back.

    2) To Natasha, I have been researching the appalling crime of rape lately and have found very supportive, deep-thinking observations by people who are trying to make the world a better place. One blog entry could be helpful for processing the guilt women feel about being sexually assaulted: http://anytimeyoga.wordpress.com/2011/06/02/i-wouldnt-do-anything-differently/
    A comment on another site talked about the difficult juxtaposition of considering victim actions as opposed to perpetrator actions and how these pan out for women of color in ghetto areas of the USA. She alluded to several of the same dynamics that seem to be present in Egypt for women and especially for tourist women. There is too much blaming of the victim. I pray that you will please continue to reach out to others who can help you in your process of dealing with this horrible, unnecessary, and physically and emotionally oppressive event.

  270. I am an Egyptian man and would like to tell you I am sorry, I hope that I was there to spare you with my life I am really so sorry

  271. You’re an idiot if you think this isn’t what your country is like, every day. Women over there… they’re worth LESS than cattle. Hell, no one would even help you to the tent. You were abandoned by the ambulance, you were molested as they dragged you to the tent. And don’t give me this bullshit that had you paid more attention, it wouldn’t have happened or turned out differently for you. The moment they went after you, you should have started taking out eyeballs.

    Instead you collapsed, you submitted, you LET THEM take you.

    I think you’re a moron for wanting to keep doing this documentary, not just because you were RAPED, but because after that assault, the country isn’t worth defending. Hell, no one would help you in the hospitals because you didn’t meet their idiotic criteria. Let that city and it’s country rot. Move on.

  272. Do your self a favour, drive around the town and spot a few of the attackers, their bound to be nonchalantly walking around with no sense of remorse, even any sense they have done anything wrong. Get you male friend grab them one by one, take them to an alley and smash their faces in with a bat, make them beg for their lives then continue to smash their faces into goop. Leave the country the same day and never return.

    It’s saddening that you wont do the above or even feel hate towards muslims. There are some really genuinely good muslim people out there sure, but these are the 1%. The rest are idiotic, disgusting sub human creatures that hold no value in human life, their own or otherwise. Just take a step back and think that these ‘people’ think that a warmongering, racist, sexist, mass murdering, paedophile psychopath is a good person to base a religion and an entire way of life upon. Why anyone expects any less of them I cant fathom to understand yet alone except.

  273. a horrible incident – i’m glad you can maintain something of a philosophical attitude…as a former photojournalist with many years in the middle east and south asia – it seems to me that your street sense needs some honing – after the incident with l logan last year – it would seem that blondes of any sort are a fair mark among the crowds of tahrir…whether it something instigated by the mukhabarat (security services) or not is unclear…

    as traumatized as you must be, think about how lucky you! crowd violence is a terrible thing to experience, as you now well know! good luck and feel better…

    fyi – burqas are culture specific to afghanistan and the indian subcontinent…

  274. As a victim myself I completely understand especially considering the political and social circumstances you must use your strength to help others BUT please seek help when you need it honey I thought I could run a marathon for rape victims but had a relapse this from a 40 a day smoker lol lets call it PTS up and down BUT every year IS easier and my life has changed for the better 🙂 I have no doubt you will help change In the world xx much love

  275. I am and Egyptian woman and this made me cry. No apologies will ever be enough, I know that, because we get harassed everyday and it’s not like apologies make us feel any better. All I want to say that this did not just hurt you, maybe you were the “real” victim but this is a shame for all of us Egyptians. I am kinda ashamed of what I’ve read, I can’t believe how some people would be like that, like animals, and I’m very surprised at your reaction, you are very strong. Stay strong, we need more people like you.

    • I wonder if Egyptian women are treated in a similar way. The men in Egypt seem to treat women in a very violent way, as if they are 2nd class citizens. The way she was treated at the hospitals and police station is despicable. I pray for all women in Arab countries……please, God, let them matter to the men. And make the violence against women stop.

    • That’s why Arabs need a dictator with iron hand and will. Every USA interference to bring them “dermocracy” is leading them to complete chaos and Islam fanaticism. Same happened in Iraq, Libya, Egypt, and same will happen in Syria. USA don’t want Arabs to become civilized nation, they want to keep them in caves. And people like Natasha, who works in Goebbels department called “Free Western Press” are sharing responsibility for that, so it’s some kind of ironic justice.

    • why are you tolerating this male behaviour in your country?
      i mean what are you telling your sons??
      women have to fight back when sth bad happens to them.
      are there defense courses in egypt?
      and telling your son that he is responsible not the woman otherwise there will be never a change…..

  276. Natasha, I’m really sorry for this unimaginable situation …. I’ve been to Egypt recently and things were so much different…… I hope you can rebuild your life and mend your mind and heart, it’s not easy, but you can do so. Keep strong and thanks for sharing your history. Love. Juliana

    • You have to admit that western civilization with all it’s political correctness has failed. In the old good times a young lady must have stay at home and grow up children, attend church a leave her man to settle the problems. With all this sexual revolutions, gay and lesbi marriages, tolerance to other races and aggresive religions like Islam, the west is going to face soon its end. Look at abandoned gorgeous cathedrals in mega polis of Paris, Milan, Rome, there are few Christian believers! Cities and towns of Europe are overtaken by ords from africa and middle east. Feminism is leading white race to its natural death. Women must stay women and look out for troubles! I have no sympathy to natasha, she is just not doing what she had to. Western Europeans think! Stop your madness! You are about to become history, because of your self destruction!

      • Omg! Free your mind, my friend! Feminism is the best thing ever happened to this world. If more women would be president, this world would be a whole lot better off. Hopefully one day you will see that all religions were created by men to suppress/oppress his fellow-men and women. Marx was right about his opinion on religion.

      • There are two kind of Feminists – those who wants to cut off from men and those who wants to sew on to women. Seriously, feminism depleted his purpose when women get same rights as men and now degraded to complete idiocy like special device to help women to pee standing.

  277. I hope I do not create an impression that I am trying to defend myself here. I don’t think there is any need for defense. People accusing me of racism routinely greet each other with the words, “May you kill a Jew before you die”.

    They call Jews “children of apes and pigs”. They consider “infidels”, in
    general, and Jews, in particular, subhuman and don’t even try to keep that
    belief a secret. They kill us, INFIDELS, at every opportunity and without any specific reason; they believe that, as Muslims, they have a license to kill us. They adhere to ideology demanding them to destroy not just Israel with its entire population, but every culture that exists in this world except their own – even though the latter can be called a culture by anthropologists only. They openly and proudly admit their intention to Talibanize the entire world. Accusations of racism coming from them are as ludicrous as calls for abstinence coming from a retired prostitute who is now running a brothel.

    • Stop giving critics of islam a bad name. You sir, are just creepy, with your constant preaching and whining. I agree with all your main points and am not offended by anything you wrote, but you are looking ore and more like an utter asshole. Just as fanatical as an islamist, which cannot be said often about critics of islam.

    • i dont under stand who you trying to fool muslims religion doesn’t say to kill any people from other religion except to defend your country or religion and we always have the racism againt us and muslims ….any one except israel must not talk about racism because phalastine every day suffering from jewish racism and they kill them every day and even kill the childrens so please dont talk about racism we are only against the terrorist which exist in israel behavior and try to blame and accuse the arab with racism ….dont try to spread you lies

      • Yes, I’m sure that Jewish hate towards muslims is just tiny in respect to what muslims feels about jews. Where are the calls in Israel for wiping out the palestinian territories? Where are the calls for indiscriminately killing muslim children? Do Israel name plazas after terrorists whose only notable act is the senseless killing of innocents? Where is this culture of racism that you speak of? You obviously doesn’t recognize racism when it’s in front of you.

        Israel may very well harbour some resentment towards muslims, but it simply pales in comparison with the hate that muslims harbour towards jews.

        Learn the art of self-reflection and enter the 21st century.

  278. Dear Natasha,

    For my first time in my life i find my self standing speechless for a non-human actions with all of brutal behaviors.

    please accept my apology as an Egyptian citizen and if there any thing else i can do for you more than saying sorry please tell me and i am totally ready with all of my hear and my feelings for make it up for you.

    I am sorry for what ever you gone through in these situation and i hope one day you will reach peace in your heart and your mind against those animals who treated you in such way.

    God bless you and your family, and never forget that you have a great Lord who can always protect his children 🙂

    Yours
    Paul E. Grace

  279. I cried by reading your story. I know your spirit is stronger than your body, deep inside your soul you know this experience was chosen by your inner self, to grow, to learn, to forgive and to move on. Breathe each day and thank every minimum positive aspect of this experience. You are still here, and you can change the world you live in. Act.

  280. Now you know they are animals in human cloth. This is what will happen to all blond girls daily once these savages become the majority in our cities. Their so-called revolution is just a flash mob that was made possible by our technology.

  281. Now you know they are animals in human cloth. This is what will happen to all blond girls daily once these savages become the majority in our cities.

  282. Dear Sarah,

    Thank you for being such a brave young woman. You inspire me a lot and I look up to you. I feel deep sorrow for your horrible experiences, luckily you are a strong soul. Remember to take care of yourself because you´ve gone trough a lot. Much more than the most of us. You need time for yourself, I don´t want you to forget that.

    These people who have hurted you are deeply cruel. Is religion playing a part of this? I don´t know, some people are just heartless. Uneducated. Disrespectful. We must remember that world is a cold place, but people around us close to our hearts make it warmer.

    I wish you all the good things to happen in the future. Don´t stop fighting. Don´t stop being a woman you are and let those man break you in pieces.

    Warm greetings and love from Finland.

  283. Natasha, you’re very brave for telling the world about your assault and consequently the problems faced by Egyptian women and perhaps Muslim women in general throughout the Middle-East. Non-Muslims and women are treated as being inferior to Muslim men within Islamic cultures which poses two problems for non-Muslim women in Egypt as you discovered to your cost. It also perhaps reflects the spate of grooming of non-Muslim children by Muslim men in the UK over the years, but which appears to have been deliberately covered up by some politicians as not being a problem.

  284. I was sexually assaulted by a mob outside a Mosque at Khan el Khalili (think it’s the Hussein Mosque – just at the end of the main tourist cafe strip) a few years ago. I was fully clothed (long black dress, no skin showing other than neck and ankles) and hair up in a bun. I happened to be passing at exactly the time the men were leaving the mosque. There were hands touching me EVERYWHERE – trying to get inside me, despite my clothes. I was separated from my friends. Nobody took my clothes off and I was not violated as you were, nor physically attacked, but I just wanted to put it out there that this has been going on (to a lesser degree) for a LONG time.

    One man helped me get out and some ladies who ‘caught’ me at the side kept repeating, “This is not Egypt. Not all Egyptians are like this.” while I was crying.

    Later, I saw a psychiatrist (apparently a big name in Cairo medicine) who also asked me if I was married – the code for “Are you a virgin?”. Because yep, that is REALLY important!! Needless to say, I didn’t see him again.

    None of this helps you, I know, I’m sorry.

    Stay strong if you need to, but don’t be afraid of the other feelings too.

  285. So very, VERY sorry to hear what happened to you, Natasha. On the other hand, I will NEVER understand what would possess a sane white European women, a kuffar whore in their eyes, to subject herself to a crowd of sexually repressed young Muslims knowing how women in general are treated in these countries.

    You were like fresh meat in a shark tank and what ensued was totally to be expected – a sexual feeding FRENZY!

    There is a reason why a lot of women in Muslim countries choose to veil themselves – it’s their only protection from being sexually assaulted like you were!

    Be well and thank you for telling your story – let this serve as a lesson to other women!

    • In the West, we’ve only recently come to understand what the Quran and Islam teaches, since we’re generally taught from childhood that all religions are equal morally. How many people in the West have noticed that the Egyptians celebrating in the square after the elections were all men? Why are there separate polling booths for men and women? In the West we need to ditch our romantic views of Egypt and instead accept that it’s not as sophisticated a culture compared to say Turkey or even Pakistan.

      • It’s quite complicated , am Egyptian and ive been living here for like 5 years ,
        but recently things became worse and worse

        there is a state of deterioration in ppl’s manners , ppl in Egypt are apparently religious but they’re actually not !
        there is a big difference between culture and religion and all the wrong bases i found her and lived with it are based upon stupid culture ,
        Egypt wasn’t that way in 80’s , 70’s or even in 60’s .

        what Egypt has been through all those past 30 years , had completely altered its ppl ..
        and became really bad !

      • Yep, we Westerners have been brainwashed with the lie of cultural relativism and white guilt as a result of the leftist generation of ’68 permeating every facet of Western institutions, incl. education where the poisoning of minds and feeding of false information in the name of political correctness takes place.

        Reality is – Western culture is FAR superior to Islamic culture, as if that wasn’t blatantly obvious! The Islamic world is Christianity 500, 600 years ago with the technology of the 21st Century. The collective mindset is medieval at best and it’ll stay that way unless and until the absolute power of Islam has been destroyed and the Muslim world goes thru a major Age of Enlightenment similar to Europe centuries ago.

        I won’t be holding my breath.

      • Wrong answer. May I ENLIGHTEN YOU with the RIGHT ANSWER. The actions are men are preceeded by the thought to perform that action. The mind must be in a state where that action seems like the next thing to do in the moment. The minds of man are subject to many stiimulus whcih can cause them to think in a certain way in certain moments, especially on a mass level. So this is another case of mass conciousness leading to actions. We know this from psychology that it is never a RELIGIOUS problem, since religions are inherently good. There is some force or propoganda or repeated information acting on the minds of these men that makes certain actions acceptable. It is neither right nor wrong…. It is a action…. It happend before in history and it will happen again in the future under conditions that make the minds of men think in this manner. This is the ONLY CORRECT ANSWER. You need post no others,

      • am sorry but you’re information is incorrect. i am a proud egyptian and putting aside the horrible assaults of suppressed ignorant people that is made due to poverty and people gambling with religion. however, to correct you Egypt is NOT what so ever less sophisticated than pakistan and the revolution was full of women in tahrir square. my mother and i slept the whole 18 days in tahrir square till the regime falls down. there were so many women muslims and non muslims we would dress the way we’d want and half of us do not wear hijab its a personal choice. in egypt we do have night clubs and an amazing night life. we are not like pakistan. however, very similar if not alike turkey. please before writing about something look it up it is very offensive to say that the egyptian revolution was only driven by men when it was basically awakened by women.please educate yourselves ignorance is not an excuse but a disablility.
        thanks,
        th

    • This happens to women who are fully veiled as well. See above. It has to do with innate male aggression, not how women dress.

  286. It’s easy to see that the disarmament of Israel will enjoy much more enthusiastic international support than the disarmament of Iran. Nevertheless, the Iranians, I am afraid, have very few reasons to be overly optimistic right now. Hussein Obama, for example, has already announced that the United States has absolutely nothing against the people of Iran; it’s the Iranian government we don’t like.

    As every child raised in our Orwellian age can see, his statement promises the Iranian people little hope for a bright future. It sounds like a warning of impending military action, and I sincerely resent that for two reasons.

    One is that I would much rather see Congress declare our wars, just as the Constitution demands. I would expect Congress to openly and clearly state the goals of the war. I would hope that the inevitable lengthy, open discussion of those goals would make it obvious to our enemies that we mean business, and since our enemies are evil, but not stupid, chances are that their reaction to such a discussion would make war unnecessary.

    The second reason is that if the foreigner who became the US President really meant to warn Iran of a possibility of war, then our war against Iran was lost the moment she declared that the Iranian people were not the enemy. It was lost for the same reason our “war on terror” was lost the moment President Bush declared that Islam was not the enemy. I’m sure Bush knew he was lying, but lies have the ability to acquire a life of their own. Take, for example, the lie of existence of mythical “Palestinian people”.

    The politically-correct crowd, of course, will tell you that every nation on the face of the earth is good. The Germans who started two world wars and organized the Holocaust are good. The Jews killed in the Holocaust are very good, because they weren’t Zionists and, generally, dead Jews are good Jews. The Iranians, Pakistanis, and Arabs, who hate us more than they love their own children and openly promise to take over the world, are also good. The “Palestinians” are especially good, even though (or, quite possible, precisely because) they are not a nation but a terrorist organization.

  287. ok you can listen to me
    i’m egyption
    we are about 100 million
    70 million of us not like this
    we are arab
    we are human
    we can feel
    but this people you talking about are animals
    try to translate this because i can’t speck english very well
    احنا مصرين
    الى حصل ده تخلف من بعض الناس
    لاكن اؤكدلك ان احنا شعب منذ قديم العصور
    شعب اهل الطيبة والكرم
    مش عارف اعتذرلك ازاى لان الاعتذار ملوش لزمة
    لاكن فى نسبة همجية
    واعتقد انك عارفة الهمجية دى من ايه
    معنا الى حصل ده ان مخططات الاجانب (امريكا +اسرائيل ) نجحت
    لما وضعو نظام لاكتر من 30 سنة مش قليل بردو
    بس نجحو فى تدمير الشعب علشان لما حد يجى يزرنا يحصل فيه كدة
    خلوهم حيوانات
    لاكن باذن الله ده كلو هيروح وينتهى
    هنحاول نتغير
    لان ديننا الاسلام بيأمرنا بكدة
    واعتقد اننا كلنا هنا بنرحب بالاجانب وفرحانين بيهم
    لاننا اولا بلد سياحية
    ولكننا اهل الكرم والضيافة
    وبعتذرلك مليون مرة
    لاكن الاعتذار مش هيفيد للاسف
    لاكن بكلمك باسم 50 مليون مواطن مصرى
    بجد بجد اسف
    momoamah@yahoo.com

    • ما تبطلوا بقى حكاية تلاتين سنة و خمسين سنة .. البلد خربت و فضحتونا … حضارة ٧٠٠٠سنة قضيتنا على سمعتها بالردةاللى بتقولوا عليها ثورة

  288. A few years ago, Jack Straw, then the British foreign minister said:
    “If you want to see a nuclear-free Middle East, you’ve got to remove that threat from Iran, including the rhetorical threat to wipe Israel off the face of the map… and once you’ve done that, then we can get on to work at, in respect of Israel.”

    It’s hard to see how no longer Great Britain, or anyone else for that matter, is threatened by the Israeli nukes, but that’s beside the point. The point is that Her Majesty’s government desires to see the Middle East free of nuclear arms; that, and the well known fact that one simply cannot trust the Jews. Of course, a nuclear-free Middle East will inevitably become Jew-free as well, but that’s exactly the goal Her Majesty’s government has been pursuing ever since it was entrusted with the League of Nation’s Palestinian Mandate. Some of the finest achievements of the British armed forces came immediately after World War II, when they went out of their way to prevent the remnants of European Jewry from returning home. And that was long before England was overrun by Muslims. What can we possibly expect from the UK now?

  289. “I’m not religious. But at times of desperation, we all feel compelled to appeal to some higher power to save us.”
    I like you, am not very religious, but reading your story I felt real sad and helpless and also felt compelled to pray that such incidents stop not just in my country Egypt but anywhere in the world.

    • You NAILED IT…. there is a HIGHER POWER that looks out for us all and listens most when the request is fueled with EMOTION such as a MOTHER trying to lift a car off her baby…. the EMOTION is tremendous and the PRAYER or REQUEST TO HIGHER POWER is answered fast. The problem is only when we NAME the HIGHER POWER and write books regarding the HIGHER POWER for the HIGHER POWER is beyond COMPREHENSION…. remember….it is a HIGHER POWER and beyond the intelligence of its CREATIONS…. much like a PAINTING trying to explain the PAINTER to another PAINTING…. that would be RELIGION…. beleiving in a HIGHER POWER is more commonly known as SPIRITUALITY and is evidenced once again in this BLOG.

  290. The only remaining option is to attempt to eradicate Islam without eradicating Muslims, because Islam is the motivation behind jihad. Technically, this is possible (remember World War II?), but only technically, because Islam is a religion, and all religions are equal in the eyes of the enlightened Westerners. (I myself believe that all religions are equal only to atheists.)

    So, what’s the solution? There is none, unless we decide to fight jihad in earnest. But there is no danger of that. Yesterday, the United States has found it to its political advantage to resist the calls for ceasefire in Lebanon, or Gaza. Tomorrow, as it has happened so many times in the past, it will change; Israel will be instructed to stop in the middle of a battle, and Islam will be handed yet another victory it could have never won on the battlefield.

    • I’m an atheist and I say with emphasis that all religions are obviously not equal. Islam is by far the worst and most menacing and vile religion at this time on our earth. It makes christianity, with it’s own set of ills, look positively good.

      That said, please stop your preaching. Show some respect. This is about a woman that was raped, not about islam, first and foremost.

      Don’t you have a job to go to?

  291. Let’s have a look at Islamic benevolence that rooted in the foundation of Hezbollah, Hamas, Muslim Brothers, Islamic Jihad or any other bunch of blood thirsty Arab murderers. Contrary to what you hear from our politicians, they do not have to disarm. The formidable goals of these organizations cannot be fulfilled without a prolonged armed struggle. Those goals are wholeheartedly supported by tens of millions of seemingly moderate Muslims who constitute their power base. Hezbollah and Hamas are responsible to neither Western governments nor naïve Western pacifists. They are solely responsible to those who put them in power. And those who put them in power want them armed, because Hezbollah and Hamas defend their interests.

    Therefore, if you want to take power from Hezbollah and Hamas, disarming them is not an option, because those who put them in power will eventually find a way to arm them again. Physically exterminating Hezbollah and Hamas is not an option either, because those who put them in power will find plenty of other “peace loving” Arabs willing to fill the vacancies. Physically exterminating those who put them in power is not an option either, because that would have inevitably amounted to genocide, and our civilization prefers to succumb to genocide rather than inflict one, unless, of course, the people on the receiving end of it are Jews. That’s why the UN, along with the entire peace-loving humanity, is so worried about the Lebanese and Gazans who have been suffering at the hands of the ruthless Israeli aggressors for couple weeks every time they decide to test the Israelis, but hasn’t done squat to protect Jews from the Arab aggression that’s been going on for at least 6 and a half decades.

  292. Jihad, which is the only state in which Islam can exist, is an interesting phenomenon. Modern jihad is not fought by armies, and it’s easy to see why. Iraq had the most powerful army in the entire Muslim world. During its war with Iran, it inflicted terrible devastation on its enemy. But when confronted by the United States military, it was unable to present any opposition whatsoever. That’s why modern jihad is being fought by civilians.

    Uniformed soldiers are liable to be shot on sight. Thanks to what we mistake for humanism, civilians who ambush and blow up our soldiers in Iraq and Afghanistan are subject to criminal prosecution, the so called “due process”. The reality convincingly demonstrates that the “due process” is totally senseless in the context of modern jihad. Therefore, the jihadists are fighting us unopposed.

    To prove my point, the current Iraqi prime minister is supported not only by the US military. He is also supported by Moqtada al Sadr, the most prominent Shiite warlord opposed to our “liberation” of Iraq. Al Sadr was allowed to gain his prominence while Iraq was already occupied by our forces. The very fact that he or any of his followers are still alive testifies to our inherent weakness and gives us the right to ask what exactly have we won in Iraq. The answer to that question is simple: exactly nothing.

    • I think that Natasha Smith lives in a reality of her own and stubbornly ignores the real world. What happened to her happened at least twice before, under similar circumstances, to two western female journalists. My explanation: the Sunni Islam which has now won the elections in Egypt does not like christians and jews. I think that Natasha Smith was attacked because she is a blond, christian journalist.

      • The fact that is has happened before DOES NOT excuse this horrendous crime, if anything it only emphasises the horror that it continues to happen. What a moronic comment! It angers me that people would continue to blame an obviously innocent victim. You are the ignorant one.

  293. Now would be a good time for you, Islam lovers to remind me about the Geneva Conventions. The Geneva Conventions protect the innocent from harm at the time of war. Or do they? In a hypothetical war between Switzerland and Denmark, they might. A hypothetical war between Switzerland and Denmark would be fought by properly uniformed armies, and every person who wasn’t armed or wearing uniform would be classified as an innocent civilian.

    But ask any Muslim, and they will tell you that a non-believer cannot be innocent by the definition, be he or she a member of enemy armed forces or a church choir. This is perfectly logical. Everyone can convert to Islam at any moment. All it takes is a formal announcement witnessed by Muslims. By choosing not to convert, you are persisting in your crime of unbelieving; therefore, you are not innocent; therefore, you are not a subject to the mythical benevolence that, according to Barak Hussein Obama, is found at the heart of Islam. Therefore, killing you, or your child, or your grandmother, or, better yet, all of you together, would promote jihad and, therefore, be perfectly legitimate according to Muslim laws…

  294. Me as a half Egyptian (living in California) wouldn’t even go to this area of Cairo during a time of political change!!

    These people hanging out there as vagabonds, useless scum without jobs or education. Plus, Egyptian, uneducated people love chaos and trouble. Of course, nothing of that can excuse what happened, but I would be a bit more careful as a western women to go to any of those crowded places at this time.

    Plus, non of these people have anything to do with Islam, they are like criminals in the states or the UK, claiming they are Christians…they do not practice of follow anything that has to do with Islam, they are basically only born into Islam but are nothing but outlaws.

    One of the biggest problem is still that there is ZERO system or management in Egypt at all…Where was the Police, Military, anybody?!

    To be honest, Egypt is a terrible place at the moment and a lot of Egyptians are simply dumb.

  295. There are no words to describe how I feel right now. I can’t tell if I’m angry, terrified, sad, enraged, self-satisfied with my notion of men-are-scum, absolutely disgusted, horrified or in deep grief. Maybe all, maybe none.
    It’s alright to be scared. You have persevered, you shall continue to persevere. Your writing is a very important insight to the daily occurrences of violence that the everyman and everywoman will easily dismiss and not think about it.

    I am lost for words.
    May all good things be bestowed upon you.

  296. Lol @ all those pathetic defenders of religion! religion is fucked up in general Christianity, Islam, Judaism those 3 abrahamic religions are the most fucked up things in this world.

    On topic: well this Natasha Smith seems to deal with it very well doesen’t she? as she said she was calm and aware of what was happening most of the time. And her expression of love for the country and the wonderful people of egypt (lol) actually makes me think she liked it, wouldn’t surprise me, alot of women like a good Gang-bang. 😉 go back to this wonderful (lol again) country anytime sweetheart.

    • You Barbaric Heathen slither back to HELL with the demons where you belong…because you don’t even belong on this forum. This girl has been brutally raped! and this is what you say??? Oh I am sorry… you were probably part of the crowd who raped her, you would think like that. Mark my words there is a GOD and you will get your JUSTICE WATCH what I say…God is Love but he also can’t STAND UGLY like your soul.

    • Fuck me. I have never seen a comment as disgusting as yours anywhere on the net. Telling a rape victim that she probably liked it. That is so beyond the pale of any acceptable human behavior. I’m just saying, and this is the complete thruth, if i was you (meaning i had just said what you just said) i would honestly consider putting a shotgun in my mouth, you pathetic excuse for a human being!!!

      • i have already commented before , and me and some friends ( journalists and photographers ) are actually trying to make something to support her right now
        and of course , when i commented on the part of stereotyping ppl , this doesnt mean i go with that stupid creature !!

        check my previous comment for the post ! or dont
        it doesnt matter !

    • There is a big difference between any religion and religious ppl ,
      Judging on a religion by its ppl is so lame and stupid .

      in most of the middle east countries , ppl react according to their culture which has so many wrong bases /

      Let’s just not stereotype ppl over here ,
      what happened to Natasha is a crime . whether those who did that are Muslims , Christians or Atheists .

      • So you feel more upset and thus that it is more important to comment about that stereotypes people (Whatever that means – i thought stereotype was a noun) than telling a rape victim that she probably liked it. How fucked up is that?

        The modern liberal mindset in a nutcase…

  297. God promised Abraham to bless those who bless Jews and to curse those who curse them. A few short years ago, you might need some complex reasoning and compelling historic examples if you wanted to convince the ignorant that, so far, God has kept His promise.

    On July 24, 2006 all the proof you needed could be found in a short documentary posted on CNN. It showed two Lebanese children severely burned by Israeli bombs. Even though the show might have been staged — foxy Arabs are well known for this kind of PR and Western reporters are usually happy to present their productions as documentaries — I knew that Israeli raids on Lebanon have caused civilian casualties, and some of them were children, and some of those children suffered the way no human being should suffer.

    Such is the price the Lebanese people are paying for their hatred of Jews, in general, and their support of Hezbollah, in particular. As terrible as that price is, it doesn’t look unfair or disproportionate to me. You may be a Jew-lover or Jew-hater, Republican or Democrat, Communist or Nazi, Sunni or Shiite, but as long as you stick to the facts, you must know that, in the last two thousand years, Jews have been the only people on earth who have never committed an act of aggression against anyone, including Lebanon.

    Nevertheless, CNN will not show you even a two-minute-long movie about the suffering of Jewish children who have become victims of Arab aggression against Israel, although there is a not too subtle difference between the two groups of victims: The Jews, including even infants, were targeted deliberately, and the cesspool known as the Arab street has supported the attacks enthusiastically and unanimously. Why then should they and their children be exempt from a similar fate?

    • You really believe your own preaching, don’t you? What you seem to forget is that Israel was created after WWII in the middle of Muslim countries and from then on Israeli’s did everything to get more land. What the Germans did to jews during WWII is the most ugly, but Israel today seems not very different. You are justifying an eye for an eye. Your own god wouldn’t even like you!

  298. Natasha !
    First of all , i’m deeply deeply sorry
    when i first read your post , i couldn’t read all the details i felt i wana throw up !
    no one ever on this planet deserve to experience such thing .
    i watched ” the perfect picture ” program minutes ago and i listened to the phone call you had with Lilian ,

    I can’t believe that you’re staying and you’re not giving up !

    I’m an Egyptian Muslim girl , and i know what you’re talking about , and we are trying for years to stop this shit ! but nothing changed , and for many many times we had to experience such horrible situations in the protests and even before the revolution , they were always using those pigs and animals to do those things to us to make us give up .
    this has nothing to do with any religion, those who do such things dont know a shit about god ! and even those who look like religious and cover their women ! dont know a shit ,
    Such a things is a CRIME and you have to somehow sue them

    I dont really know how can i help you , but you and many strong girls like you had inspired us and my friends to make a change now … and i would never ever be able to attack such men in the street – couple of months ago – unless i heard about strong women like you who preferred to speak up rather that just hide ,

    am deeply sorry , that i can say i may support you if you wana sue SCAF or even the Egyptian Gov. for this insult .
    such a thing should have been stopped long time ago , but they prefer to leave it alive .

    Again , im 100 times sorry , i just wish i could go back time and prevent such thing ..

  299. I’m sorry for what happened to u .. some how i feel the shame on me for what u have been through in my country … i send u my apology with a wish to get over it with God’s help .. may GOD give u strength to make this situation as a rock to step on.

    the major problem is the Islamic culture

  300. To a naïve person, this reaction on the international court decision on the Israeli defencive fence may look like most people on Earth have suddenly lost their God-given ability to tell good from evil. Such a hypothesis can be easily disproved. If the humankind had been choosing between the two randomly, then, in approximately 50% of the cases, they would have opted for good. This is not happening. The humankind has made its choice and is sticking to it.

    When Israel put Saddam out of nuclear business, the entire world, including the United States, condemned the unprovoked Israeli aggression against a sovereign country. (In the Reagan cabinet, the most enthusiastic proponent of a severe punishment for Israel was the then-Vice President George H. W. Bush.) There was no logic in that condemnation. Israel would, no doubt, become Saddam’s first target, but believing that it would have remained his only target is beyond ludicrous. In 1981, Israel literally saved the world. Years later, the West acknowledged Israel’s heroic deed in the most unofficial manner possible.

    History repeats itself. Today Israel is fighting Hezbollah, Hamas, Islamic Jihad and other bunch of Arab murderers and, as it always happens, the majority of governments, organizations, and individuals around the globe condemn Israel for defending itself. But Israel is not only defending itself. Like Saddam’s aborted nukes, Hezbollah and Hamas are not just threatening Israel. Their sleeper cells are omnipresent in Western countries. What are those countries pushing for? A ceasefire — the only way to prevent the demise of Hezbollah and Hamas at the hands of its righteous nemesis. Why do people want to save a terrorist organizations, which, at the very first opportunity, will turn their own cities into Beirut on the Thames, Beirut on the Spree, Beirut on the Seine, Beirut on the Tiber, Beirut on Moscow?

    Beats me.

  301. ‘Women were crying and telling me “this is not Egypt! This is not Islam! Please, please do not think this is what Egypt is!”’

    Okay and the rapists at the fraternity houses and the rock concerts and the Mardi Gras parades and at Penn State and the Catholic Church and in the military aren’t America or the West or Christianity, but we need to take responsibility for them. There’s only so much those Egyptian women can do though. Because Egyptian men in power, like western men in power, do everything in their power to see to it that women have no real power. It’s a zero-sum game.
    Egyptian men need to hold Egyptian men accountable, because rapists obviously aren’t going to listen to women. Men can start by advocating loudly and strongly for women’s representation in their new government. And stand with Egyptian women for their rights. And keep doing it even when the bullies get threatening and scary, like they have with Natasha here and with Lara Logan and Mona Eltahawy and countless Egyptian women.

    I’m so sorry, Natasha. I’m f*cking pissed off for you.

  302. Dear Natasha
    I’m very sorry for what happened to you in my country & please know that not all Egyptians are like this or accept what happened to you . I’m very sorry on behalf of all real eastern men in Egypt .

  303. My sincere sympathy to you, Natasha. Reading this story made me sick physically, and I cannot even begin to imagine what you are going through now. As a woman to woman, my heart is out for you.
    What struck me most in you account of this horrific nightmare was the attitude of the people in hospital and police. They are the ones who should help the victim, without any personal judgements and superstitions. And it is their attitude, not the mob’s actions that is most telling in this situation.
    The act of violence itself in this situation was an act of war. Actions of the mob spoke of war. Reactions in the hospital and police spoke of war. Reminded me the less visible side of conquests and battles when the soldiers rape enemy’s women to break the morale and humiliate their enemy. It is never about the pleasure or attractiveness of the woman (i.e, small girls and old women have been raped in Berlin by soviet soldiers; in Bosnia by Serbian fighters, etc.. ).
    Truth is, foreigners are perceived as enemy in most of Middle East. You are enemy’s woman, Through you, they attempt to hurt their invisible, abstract/imaginary enemy and lash out their helplesness and frustration. And war is not always open, with guns out in the battlefield. The most dangerous war is in people’s minds; the most damaging weapons are mistrust, hate, superstition, fanaticism.
    It is good that you spoke openly about this. However, I find the naivety of western female journalists really odd.. If you aspire to be a war journalist, or go to the war zone, understand this: you are a WOMAN in a WAR FIELD. Translation: easy and primary target. This is not a safe and dillusional bubble of western liberal democracy, human rights, political correctness and women’s rights which can be applicable to maybe 10% of the world’s societies. The rest is angry, bloodthirsty, terrified mob, fighting for the survival and completely messed up by the former 10%.
    You will heal, but you will have scars. If you want to continue your path of fighting for your ideals, you will manage. There is no soldier without scars. But you have to remember – as a woman, you have to be twice as strong and twice as smart as the strongest and smartest man if you want to survive. You are young still, but you will understand, hopefully.
    Being from Eastern Europe I observe this ‘clash of civilizations’ with a fascination.. I don’t consider us, Eastern Europeans, part of Western Europe. There is not much in common between us in terms of mentality, historical experience and world view.
    Westerners often have a stunning ability to look at everything through the pink glasses, they are blinded by their europocentric beliefs, like stereotypes too much and are genuinely naive most of the time… And I see that very often that sense of superiority is a big obstacle for them to try and understand reality, try to think from different cultural perspectives. Sad, but true.

    • Interesting analysis, and not off course. It is refreshing to read a thought-out and well written post, while wading through all the nonsense. I posted my opinion on my own blog, and was besieged by what I can only term as xenophobic psychopaths, who used so many obscenities that it is truly mind boggling; says a lot about how these people think — pretty similar to the demented thugs of Tahrir, but they can’t see their own shortcomings…

  304. Clearly many of the people who have left a comment here have lived under a rock, or just have their heads up their asses. These sort of things, more or less worse, happen every single day in islamist countries to local women. How many westerners give a crap about them? Really, really few. Same thing happens to a western woman? “Oh my god! That is so terrible!”.

    I, ofcourse feel sorry for you for having to go through all of that, but it’s the ignorance of people that really angers me. Welcome islam to the Europe. By 2050 Europe will have an islam majority.

    I can only say that we’re screwed.

  305. Not so long ago, NATO — mostly, the United States — bombed Yugoslavia out of existence for the alleged, but still unproven crime of genocide against its Muslim population. Why then the United States, along with NATO and the rest of the peace-loving world, wouldn’t even consider going to war to liberate North Koreans from the North Korean concentration camps?

    Why did a bra placed by a fool in uniform on the head of a terrorist held in Abu Ghraib attracted more attention of the humankind than the mass murder of North Koreans — or even the mass murder of Iraqis that went on at the very same Abu Ghraib for decades, while Saddam Hussein was in power?

    Why the detention center at Guantanamo Bay, where prisoners are kept in more humane conditions than in any other POW camp in history, although never in history captives deserved so little humanitarian concern, excites defenders of human rights so much more than the tortured death at the hands of North Korean “Dear Leader’s” goons of people who had done nothing wrong?

    While the Arabs – the world call “Palestinians” – murder yet another pregnant Jewish woman along with her four daughters, the institution misnamed the International Court of Justice was diligently seeking the legal basis for the condemnation of Israel for building a fence in an equally desperate (and, predictably, equally futile) attempt to prevent Arab terrorists from murdering Jews. Of the three, only the court and Arab terrorists achieved their goals. The population of this planet of ours supported the unjust decision of the unjust court with rare unanimity. Neither the Arab atrocities, nor the Korean ones have succeeded in attracting the attention of the court or its world-wide courtroom.

  306. I`m so sorry for what you have been trough.!! I hope you have good people around you that can be there for you. Lots of love fra Norway.

  307. Dear unknown friend!
    I read your story! And I am so shocked – that something like this could happen, and happen to you. It might be that your body will have to go through a grieving-process (right word?) and that you get emotional reactions after some days. But that is wuite natural! How you say and tell us about not allowing yourself to be a wictim, seems to be a really great thought! Do not let those men take away your life, love and health! May God bless you – and take care of you! May He give you all that you will need in the next days and weeks! And – May His blessing rest upon you forever!
    Take care- dear young sister!
    Greetings from Norway,
    Marianne E.

  308. I wanted to convey to Egypt’s image as real, but it is clear that you have enough pictures, and I want to say to each vessel exudes what it, and that way brought to bear on you is a feature layer petition of the Egyptian people, who hit a manic religious and atonement of desires in his beliefs. People came back about 1500 years back because of the Islamic character who defeated them and occupied their minds, but, dear this is Islam. The moderate Islam, which you said it and summits to express your knowledge of it is “in their” religion superficial “and nothing more. Have you said in your article translated into Arabic from the virtuous human rights,” Fatima Naaot “you is not religious. O sister, that Christianity is not religion, but that Christianity is a life lived by a man and enjoy his affiliation with, the, Christ died for you so that gives you that life, and to heal all your wounds and to give you the determination and perseverance to complete your determination in life. on a personal level I felt that you are a person more than wonderful enjoy recipes in finished beauty, but excuse for that to be a relationship live personal with the Lord Jesus, really do not know how much your relationship with him., but I feel that you need to log in to the rear until you discover the difference. Jesus said “I came that they may have life and have them better,” John 10:10. and you are encouraged to live the best. Sister, it was you security Mot, but your strength not due yet, and this shows that you have a message in life on you performed this task is part of the plan the Lord for your life. you seize the opportunity and accept Christ as Lord and master your life and do not forget that he is one of the saved from the clutches of Satan, who is also will use you to the glory of his name. Thanks to Natasha for your reading my comment.

  309. Natasha, I can remember only two occasions when I watched the Discovery/Times Channel for more than a few seconds in a row. The first time they were showing a documentary about Saudi Arabia. There was a room with several women seated around a table. It was difficult to figure out how many of them were there because, covered head to toe with burqas, they all looked like big, black bowling pins and were just as impossible to tell apart.

    The women were trying to outdo each other extolling their incredibly good fortune to have been born into a culture that went to such drastic extremes to protect their honor. I listened for a while how happy they were to have to ask male relatives for a written permission to leave the house every time they had to go somewhere; how beautiful it was to become a third wife to a man you had never met until he climbed into your bed to claim your virginity; how wonderful it was to live without a face that could attract unwanted attention, without a clitoris that might produce a sinful sensation, without a job that might result in a dangerous exposure to strangers, without freedom that could be so easily abused, without practically everything that makes up a normal life of a normal person in a normal world.

    Of course, normalcy is in the eye of the beholder. But while listening to them speak in Arabic and reading the translation of their halleluiahs in the subtitles, I suddenly remembered what I had read about the will left behind by Mohammad Atta, the leader of the 9/11 highjackers. In his will, Mr. Atta, the great Muslim hero, mastermind and executioner of the most spectacular mass murder of modern times, demanded that no woman, especially no pregnant woman, be allowed to desecrate his holy memory by attending his funeral or visiting his grave.

    There goes your honor, sisters, I thought. No matter what you sing while perched in your cages, your owners will always find a way to remind you that you are nothing but unclean animals…

  310. To any egyptians reading this, I want to say: SHAME ON YOU! These kind of assaults have forever tarnished the reputation of Egypt. Saying “this is not egypt” is just refusing to look the problem in the eyes and refusing to deal with it. The fact is: This is Egypt, and this will be egypt until this stops happening. THIS IS EGYPT! If you don’t want it to be, please change it.

  311. There must have been an element of contributory negligence, she didn’t bother to learn Arabic or Judo and what did a blonde and attractive female expect when she place herself in the firing line. I am not a journalist and never will be all the time I have a hole in my extremely fat arse. But if I were instead of a failed student I would have acted differently. Ched is innocent.

    • Seriously? Shame on you.
      She loves this country and the culture. She respects the islam.
      Arabic? For what? To scream: Let me go! Don’t do this! Judo? For what? To kick their asses? Hundreds of men, touching and violating her, will not listen to arabic words and they will always be stronger than a single woman. Most of them don’t respect women especially women from western countries. They wanted to violate her. And God knows, how far they would have gone.

    • You are seriously deluded if you think that learning judo would have had any effect whatsoever on the outcome in this case. You obvously know nothing of unarmed combat and the power of several people fighting one man. Stop blaming the victim. You make me sick, you people.

  312. Pingback: أدميــــن تي أن - اغتصاب صحفية بريطانية في ميدان التحرير

  313. Can we expect from our government to outlaw Islam as hateful, genocide ideology and cult of death?

    Here’s where one of the major achievements of our democracy comes into play in the international arena. I am talking about term limitations. President Obama has produced more than his fair share of major blunders during his four years in office. His desire to postpone any development that might force him to take action against Iran is palpable. He strongly prefers his successor to have to deal with that problem, along with every other problem Mitt Romney will inherit from Barak Hussein Obama.

    In the meantime, our situation becomes simpler with every passing day. We are quickly nearing the point where killing our enemies, both foreign and domestic, will no longer be one of the many options that have been historically available to us as a superpower. Beyond that point, the alternative to kill or to be killed no longer exists. It won’t be us or them. Inevitably, it will be just them…

    • Leave your Republican Bull else where…Nobody Cares. This is a Global Forum talking about a woman who has been raped. And Yes Barak a Jewish name…. Husseim a Muslim name… Obama is our president and what are you going to do about it? Get an education , get a life, and take time to learn about Global affairs, and then take several seats.

    • Neglecting – or at least minimizing – the repeated incidents of violence against women in Al tahrir is not because they do not want offending the Muslims .I am an Egyption Muslim , and i am wondering ..why this weird silence ?!…I think it is all about giving a fake image of what so call ” Arab spring ” .. but the truth that this “spring ” has nothing to do with democracy and it ended up with the fanatics taking over our country ..

      • If I may add a bit more to my response to Nouran, above — what you have written is the most important comment here.

        There is a strong tendency, including among the comments about this horrible crime, to portray such attacks as a function of Islam per se. But in fact, what we are witnessing in the Arab spring, is the rise of an Islamic form of clerical fascism, which includes the most violent misogyny, and which has much in common with the clerical fascism that took over much of Europe in the 1930s and 40s, and which is strongly supported by the Vatican. Case in point: the violent antisemitism of the Brotherhood is of WESTERN origin — hence the use of the Protocols of Zion, hardly an Islamic text. (It is repeatedly cited in the Hamas charter.) The most important thing about the clerical fascism of the Arab spring is that it has been strongly supported from the Western establishments. And it is the Western media which has led the way in repressing any negative reporting about Tahrir, for example the attacks on women, and the presence of violently anti-Jewish wall posters.

        My website Emperor’s Clothes is about to start publishing articles discussing this and we would like very much to correspond with anti-fascists from Egypt!

        Jared Israel

      • Nouran, this ‘weird silence’ is the effect of the stranglehold the cancer of political correctness holds over much of the Western world.

        Our mainstream media are absolute cowards and they would rather cover up or sanitize the truth about the Arab Spring, the treatment of women in Islamic societies, and Islam itself as to not offend Muslims in the West (who are treated as defacto holy cows and hold incredible power in places like Germany even though they’re still only a small minority) than be brutally honest.

        This is the legacy and WW2 and the Nazis and what was done to the Jews. Racism and nationalism have been replaced by political correctness and cultural relativism, which in their own way are just as dangerous and deadly because they have become the tools to suppress truth on a large scale.

        That’s how you get ‘weird silence.’

  314. Natasha…As An Egyptian I want to say We all here in Egypt sorry for that sexual assault u faced in Tahrir Square…Egyptian Girls too face same problem…And We try to do our best to end that shit and catch such bad guys…That’s Not Islam…And those peoples not Muslims anymore after that crime they did…they will burn in hell for sure…I feel sorry after I knew about ur accident And really saying sorry isn’t enough..But I think in that bad experience u met some good Egyptians too

    Egypt Say Sorry And i wish u accept our apology

  315. Or consider Iran. One of the major oil producers in the world, a country technologically backward even when compared with some other Muslim countries, Iran declared its burning desire to switch to nuclear power. I wish my government had done that. Their diplomats assure everyone that their intentions are perfectly peaceful; however, their president threatens to obliterate Israel and to share nuclear arms with every Islamic entity in the world. And their nuclear facilities are well protected by layers of rock and closeness to population center. Can we do anything to stop Iran?

    Of course, we can. Remember, arms don’t kill people. People kill people. This is equally true for an illegally purchased handgun, as well as the nuclear arsenal of a backward Muslim country. We don’t need to destroy Iranian nuclear facilities. What we need instead is to eliminate forever Iran’s capacity to threaten us. It means sending their leadership to the long awaiting heavenly virgins, turning their religious institutions into dust, confiscating their oil fields, and killing as many Iranians as it takes to render them harmless till the end of time. No democratization; no nation-building; no Marshall plan. And, most importantly, no attempts to install a friendly government, because a country whose people hate us, literally to death, cannot be our ally, no matter who is in control of its government.

    Unfortunately, we’ve been too slow to learn this simple lesson as it pertains to Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, and even Iran, as well as every other Turdistan on the planet whose kingpin doesn’t mind dealing with the infidel for the sake of promoting jihad and making a few extra billions in the process. Come to think of it, had we done this to Pakistan, there would be no problem with Iran today.

    Am I talking genocide? No, our enemies are talking genocide, openly and without shame. What I am talking about is merely necessary self-defense.

  316. Political correctness seems to be another crime against hurt humanity.
    It seems most of the mainstream news media has been told to shut up, even BBC didn’t show up any records for previous victim ,Lara Logan who was at least very high profile !
    Seems certain powers don’t want to give bad( but real) name to transition process they want to project as wonderful arab spring !

  317. Sadly your situation is a reflection of the world today. Aggression is all around us (even in the replies to your blog post)

    I am sure things like these could also happen in other so called ‘civilized countries’. So often ppl are looking away if they are afraid.

    Let’s all open our eyes and show civil courage. Let’s fight for freedom and not against each other.

    I wish you all the best natasha.

    • So true. Sexual violence against women and children (and men..yes) you can find all over the world. Most of us the are looking away. Solidarity with humanity!

    • If this could happen anywhere in the world, why hasn’t it happended in any western society (A sexual assault of this magnitude, with hundreds partaking, in a celebrating crowd, in public that is – where the rest of society treats the victim like shit and nobody seems to care – I have never heard of a rape victim having to work so hard to get basic help after an event of this magnitude)? Why have it happened at least four times in Tahir square and never anywhere in a western society? Oh, how I wonder…

  318. Pingback: 21 year old British reporter victim of vicious sex attack by hundreds of Egyptian men in Tahir square last Sunday - Stormfront

  319. Sorry for what has happened with you in Cairo? i’m so sorry ….i hope from god that the world will be a nice place for you and for every person around the world …sorry dear

  320. The so called “Palestinians” have managed to not even create a rudimentary economy. Their jurisprudence makes lynching seem humane in comparison. Their differences in political opinions are being routinely resolved by one group outgunning, rather than outvoting, the other. As soon as the West, in a hopeless attempt to save its long lost face, responded to Hamas electoral victory by withholding a part of its regular donations, the “authority” found itself unable to even pay salaries to its employees. In what twisted vocabulary have the proponents of “Palestinian” independence found their definition of the term?

    Following its age-old tradition, world opinion blames the Jews, and this time I happen to share that world opinion. This festering wound would never have existed had Israel not waived its sacred right to kill those who are trying to kill it. It is as simple as that. I can understand the reluctance of civilized people to kill enemy children, even if it means saving the lives of one’s own people. However, I refuse to understand the reluctance to kill those who dedicate their lives to turning their own children into murderers.

    • This has nothing at all to do with the story above – go vent your spleen elsewhere. Want to know why some people have a problem with your views? Maybe it’s the complete and utter lack of compassion you’re showing here – I doubt you are interested in anyone else opinion’s but your own.

    • You sir, are a complete and utter moron. Why are you posting your ultra-right wing idiotic drivel in response to the original post, about which you have made no comment whatever? The world would be far better off without mindless idiots like you.

  321. I`m so sorry to hear what happend to you Natasha! It really hurts my heart! I pray that the love of the heavenly Father would just heal your heart completly and that He would strenghten you! You will get through this! We stand here with you!

  322. Awtas on the occasion of the battle of Hunain:

    “Some of the Companions of the Apostle of Allah (may peace be upon him) were reluctant to have intercourse with the female captives in the presence of their husbands who were unbelievers. So Allah, the Exalted, sent down the Qur’anic verse: (Sura 4:24) “And all married women (are forbidden) unto you save those (captives) whom your right hands possess.” (Abu Dawud 2150, also Muslim 3433)

    O Allah’s Apostle! We get female captives as our share of booty, and we are interested in their prices, what is your opinion about coitus interruptus?” The Prophet said, “Do you really do that? It is better for you not to do it. No soul that which Allah has destined to exist, but will surely come into existence.” (Bukhari 34:432).

  323. On a wider scale, consider the terrorist organization commonly known as the “Palestinian Authority”. Imagine that Israel, instead of celebrating its 65th anniversary, miraculously disappeared overnight without a trace, along with all its Jewish population, all Jewish cities, all Jewish settlements, all Jewish hospitals, all Jewish greenhouses, all kibbutzim, all synagogues, and everything else that Jews have created on their land and heroically defended throughout six decades of incessant Arab war against them. Regardless of who runs that terrorist organization — Hamas, Fatah, Islamic Jihad, or any other bunch of Arab murderers — do you really believe they would be able to cease the opportunity and become a country?

    I think not; because the people the world calls “Palestinians”, besides being Arabs, have only one thing in common: their passionate desire to murder Jews. Let history students correct me, but the Arabs, throughout their bloody history have demonstrated no more talent for nation building that for any other kind of positive, constructive endeavor. The borders of most Arab countries you can find on the map today were drawn either by the British or by the Turks. As to their hatred of Jews, no matter what suicidal intensity it reaches, it cannot provide a foundation upon which a nation can be built.

    Since 1964, the world has poured billions of dollars into their little enterprise. How have they used the money? To kill thousands and maim tens of thousands of Jews; to make Arafat and his minions rich; to brainwash hundreds of thousands of their own children into becoming suicidal maniacs; in short, to do everything in their power to avoid the responsibilities of nation-building for themselves.

  324. “I reassured her that I knew that was the case, that I loved Egypt and its culture and people, and the innate peacefulness of moderate Islam. ”

    Innate peacefulness of moderate Islam? So the men who tried to rape you were the non-moderate ones? How do you tell the difference.?

  325. It’s sad so many posting on here chose to use this particular entry to spew hatred and misinformation and to somehow politicize what happened to you in order to convince others (and maybe themselves) that their views are right. However what I find amusing- how many on here have no idea what they are talking about but just regurgitating what they’ve heard or think they’ve read.

    Natasha – I’m sorry. I’m sorry that you were the victim of such rage and violence. I’m sorry that you were victimized again when asked if you were a virgin, married or pregnant. I’m sorry you were looked upon with indifference when seeking medical care. I’m sorry that other women turned away when your life was in danger. I’m sorry you did not receive the proper acknowledgement of how horrific an experience this was for you.

    This could be damaging to your healing, I already hear it in your post. Trying to rationalize what happened to you; somehow your past actions with friends and loved ones brought you to a place where you are deserving of violence. Your numbness is not from a place of stoicism and strength, but rather shock. You are in shock and will be in a post shock state until you seek help to work through this. If not, it will transform itself (in you) in ways that will not be healthy for you in the end. Do not ignore this. Do not talk yourself out of this by saying you need time. As much as you love Egypt and its people, do not rationalize it was but a few. It is a culture there-mistreatment of women. There were many good people that also turned a blind eye to you by ignoring you, not acknowledging what had occurred. It’s not good enough women crying over you saying “this is not Egypt.” Because it permeates their society-just as you mentioned being groped by others before attack and on other occasions. The act of violence towards you reflects a society with no morals. Violence towards women is about control, not being a spy. If you had been a man and they suspected you a spy, they would not have ripped your clothes off, but simply would have hung you in the square. What happened to you was about stripping you of your soul and dignity. Don’t hang your head low or avert your eyes, you have nothing to be shamed of, the shame weighs on the Egyptian people.

  326. Hi Natasha , I Just Dunno Wat 2 Say , i Know If I Said Im Sry Or We R Sry That’s Won’t Make U Satisfied .. I Wish I Was There 2 Try Helpin. U .. I Wish That Any Founder Organise For U 2 Come Bk Again 2 Egypt In Such a Seminar Or Something Like That N U Wont Beleive Hw Many Egyptian Boys , Girl , Men , Women And Children Gonna Be There WIth Flowers Tryin. 2 Show U Thier Sorry ,,,,God Bless U

  327. A crude awakening. All arabs are barbarians. This is exactly whats going to happen in Europe too, soon on a sqare near you.

  328. i know that saying sorry is not enough …but i’m really feel shame because of what happened to you ..we are very sorry

  329. I’m sorry for what happened to you, Natasha. I’ve been in Egypt too. Cairo is not like Hurghada or Sharm El Sheikh where locals are used with foreigners and people are very nice and polite, don’t have prejudice even if you are an unaccompanied lady. Cairo is not a safe place.

  330. Hello Natasha, I am Egyptian.. I am very sorry behalf of all Egyptians about what did happen to you in Egypt.But you you can not blame unemployed youth in a conservative society on sexual harassment, but what do you think of harassment of Muslims in the whole world? What do you think the genocide taking place for the Muslims in Burma (Arakan)? Are being extermination of ten million Muslims are the work of the signs written on it (this is the village completely free of Muslims) .. What do you think..Where is the world’s conscience, and where human rights issues and the international community what is happening now in Syria and the extermination of millions of innocent people? I think those who tried stalking you are non-Islamists (secularists) and I also save you from that which their hands are the Islamists

    • It’s quite obvious that she doesn’t “blame unemployed youth in a conservative society on sexual harassment”, but I do. As a rule, we in Western civilizations won’t even try accept or try to understand horrific crimes against women just because they’ve been committed by someone who is young and doesn’t have a job. There’s simply no excuse.

    • It must be admitted that the molesters didn’t wear beards. I feel sorry for the people who die in Syria, but this is caused by the fact that Islam isn’t clear whether the Sunnis or the Shias are right.

    • How deluded can one become? Talk about believing things just so you need not face up to inconvenient truths. “I think those who tried stalking you are non-Islamists (secularists) and I also save you from that which their hands are the Islamists” – Yeah, very very likely. Not a shred of evidence to support your claimes, which are, taken at face value, laughable, given that the day Natasha was raped people were at the square to celebrate the Islamist candidate winning the election – that means, in simple words, that it is very likely that it was muslims who filled the square and thus it was most likely muslims who raped her.

      Face up to what your co-believers are capable of instead of coming with embarrasing excuses! Until muslims get better at self-reflection nothing will change. Shame on you! A woman was raped and all youcan come up with to do is defending your backwards faith.

    • “secularists”…!! It is exactly Islam that is the main culprit here – it separates the two sexes and frustrates young males whose hormones have nowhere to go. We see it in Europe too where young Muslim males can’t access their “own” women and therefore stalk Western females – who are sluts and easy prey. Islam seriously needs to reform. One thing is certain: Europeans are getting fed up with honour culture and religious Muslim fanatics, finally.

  331. Guggi on June 27, 2010 at 9:23 am, you think this story is fake. You have some questions.

    Natasha Smith’s attack took place as she was covering the results of Eygpt’s presidential elections. She was attacked on Sunday, June 24, 2012.

    I don’t know which story you saw covered in Arabic weeks ago because there have been more than a few attacks like the one described above. You may have read about this ladiy, attacked in January, 2012:

    http://www.bikyamasr.com/55004/exclusive-woman-tells-of-having-pants-ripped-off-assaulted-and-prodded-in-egypts-tahrir-square/

    Angella Johnson’s attack was February, 2011:

    http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-1358759/Like-Lara-Logan-I-mob-sex-attack-victim-Tahrir-Square.html

    Caroline Sinz, French TV reporter on November 2011.

    Multiple alleged assaults were described on June 7, 2012. Witnesses describe “a woman in a red shirt” who was manhandled until she passed out. They don’t know what happened to her. Any of these attacks may have been what you read several weeks ago:

    http://english.ahram.org.eg/NewsContent/1/0/44121/Egypt/0/Alarming-assaults-on-women-in-Egypts-Tahrir.aspx

    A Durch tourist and some other women in January, 2012. (This is not the same person as in the above link, also in January, 2012. That was an Arab lady):

    http://www.globalpost.com/dispatches/globalpost-blogs/the-casbah/sexual-harassment-tahrir-lara-logan

    The Egyptian Center for Women’s Rights calls these attacks and others a “social cancer”.

    You may wonder how I know about so many of these crimes. It was easy; I just googled “rape” and “Tahrir Square” and got pages of links. This speaks poorly of Egyptian men!

  332. While the government removes all references to the Ten Commandments from public display, the White House openly celebrates Ramadan, and Muslim employees of our government shamelessly go on all fours during their working hours to perform the “salat”. Even though everyone knows that the next massacre on our soil will be planned, executed, and openly celebrated by observant Muslims, government-issued edicts effectively forbid subjecting them to the same regular security procedures at the airports and other points of extreme vulnerability that the rest of us, thanks to our uninvited guests, have to go through without complaining.

    The politically correct crowd keeps reminding us that this is exactly what makes the United States of America, Canada and no longer Great Britain a free countries. Unfortunately, there is a problem with their optimistic assertion. This problem stems from the obvious fact that a murderer and his intended victim cannot be equally free at the same time and place. You either restrict the freedom of the former or, eventually, you will have to bury the latter. The enemy’s ever growing presence in our land has eroded our freedom beyond anything even the most vicious, right-wing government conspiracy could ever dream up. To give you an idea of the terrible scale of that erosion: we are no longer free to kill our enemies in the time of war. But we are still free to tolerate their vile presence in our country.

    • Conservative Christians are also trying to infiltrate our government and force their beliefs on us, especially on women regarding contraception and abortion. As well as trying to display their “10 commandment” in public such as “thou shalt have no other gods”. That is not what our Deist founders would have wanted.

      • Conservative Americans are definitely not restricting your access to contraception or abortion. They just don’t want to pay for it with their tax dollars.

      • How does a requirement for insurance companies to cover this affect your tax dollars?

        And Republican attempts to pass laws labeling fertilized zygotes “people” would render several common methods of birth control as homicide.

  333. My country Egypt used to be 100% Christian, now it is full of terrorists and demon possessed people like those who attacked Natasha. My message to the west: SAVE YOUR COUNTRIES FROM ISLAM WHILE YOU STILL CAN, OR ELSE YOUR COUNTRIES WILLLLLLL BECOME LIKE EGYPT.

  334. My heart goes out to you.
    You are an amazing, strong woman. Your resilience is awe-inspiring. It gives me so much happiness and pride to see a woman so young refusing to give in after such a horrific experience.
    I won’t attempt to even understand what kind of motivation went into the act of such savages. I just hope you find the strength in you to always be the brave heart you are.
    I won’t forget you or your story.

  335. During World War II, half a dozen German agents were smuggled aboard a submarine to our shores with the purpose of committing sabotage and terrorizing the population. They were captured, tried, and soon afterwards hanged. I don’t believe they were allowed to keep their copies of Mein Kampf while they were awaiting their execution. If they were, they never complained about their jailers’ disrespect to the “sacred” book that had brought them to the gallows. Or, if they did, nobody paid attention, for those were the times before liberalism degenerated into multiculturalism, and political correctness.

    During World War III, millions of Muslims openly and, for the most part, legally, just like Mohammad Atta and his cohorts, immigrated to the United States, Canada, UK, Eurabia and Australia and settled here with the openly stated purpose of replacing the rule of the Constitution with the rule of Sharia, planning to turn this land into yet another province of the world-wide Caliphate. They are being accommodated in every way possible. They walk among us unafraid and unmolested, protected by the Constitution that, due to its novel, purposely defeatist interpretation, can no longer protect us from them…

  336. There some explains you can find in quran:
    4-24 says you can’t have a sexual act with a wife of another man save if she becomes slave in the war!
    4-34 says you can beat your woman in the case of disobedience, after three steps!

    and you can find hundreds of hatred verses in quran about non-muslims. like quran call them pig, or deaf. and you can find hundreds verses against women and against humanity.

    muhammad had murderer character who ordered to genocide 700 surrender village of bani-qurayze and made their wives and children slave. He did rape the daughter of the chief-tribe in the night ali beheaded his father and brothers. This is just one in millions of muslim’s crimes in history. And how you supposed they act better than their prophet or the thing actually written in quran.

    There is not a spring in arab world. Winter is coming. long and cold and your experience is just the chili autumn wind.

    My heart and feeling to you Natasha from Iran. From a muslim born but a human live.

    We will root up this satanic religion from the earth and it will start from Iran and Iranian who wants to wipe out their own country from the worst thing which is come to earth so far.

  337. Natasha i admire ur courage and determination u r an inspiration 4 every woman . i can’t even imagine how horrible it was what u’ve been through but coz i’m living in cairo i know how some men could be like animals sometimes motivated only by their sexual desires , have faith that jesus protected u and will protect u always as long as u ask 4 his help . may God bless u dear ….

  338. Pingback: 1 игла и 12 шпилек | Вадим Давыдов. Dixi

  339. Will we see a political leader of Einstein’s proportions who will emerge in time to remind us that there would have been no victory over Nazism if we had classified the Nazis into a minority of bad, extremist Nazis who had hijacked the perfectly benign political philosophy from the benevolent, but totally undetectable majority of “real”, “moderate” Nazis? Why do we need a genius to explain to us that there would have been no victory over Nazism had we allowed Nazis to come to our shores by the millions, settle in our cities, and change the way our children learn history of the world?

    As we know today, Emperor Manuel II Palaiologos saw things with an enviable clarity. One of his sons became the last Byzantine emperor before the empire fell, Constantinople became Istanbul, and one of the most spectacular churches ever built became Hagia Sofia, one of the most spectacular churches ever desecrated by the Muslims.

  340. What you, Natasha disregarded completely in your story was the fact that 1.2 billion people living on this planet and, in rapidly increasing numbers, among us in US, UK, Canada and Eurabia adhere to a totally different set of self-evident truths, namely, that all men are created Muslim, even if they are born to infidel parents. And if those infidel parents commit the crime of raising their inherently Muslim children in a false faith, it is both an inalienable right and a sacred duty of every properly raised Muslim to undo their crime by either converting the victim back to Islam (the Muslim term for conversion to Islam is reversion) or, if the victim is unwilling to submit (the Arabic word Islam means submission), then by killing him or her, thereby earning oneself a place in Paradise.

  341. This is the best thing you could have done with your experience Natasha. Sexual abuse happens far more often than people realise and it’s not talked about enough. You are incredibly brave and you’ve got a stellar career to look forward to, good luck. This is EXACTLY what journalism is for.

  342. Pingback: Egypt: Assault on Women in Tahrir Square · Global Voices

  343. I’m not a Muslim, nor am I Egyptian. I’m not a religious person, nor am I an atheist. After reading this I don’t want to hate. I don’t want to explain. I don’t want to judge, and I don’t want to answer any of these commenters, who are so right and so wrong. I just want to say I’m sorry, on no one’s and everyone’s behalf, about what you went through.

    • I hope you are getting counseling that helps you. I hope you are still determined to go forward and try every day to overcome the fears that this horrible event has caused you.
      I have to say, though, that all of this condemning of Islam over the acts of a few is making me sick. You people act as if this very same thing doesn’t happen multiple times a day, every day, right here in the USA. “Christian” rapists and abusers are no different from any other man who holds women in disdain. I know, unfortunately.
      So, stop acting all high and mighty about the bad people who call themselves muslims. There are millions of “christians”, “jews” and any man of any other “religion” out there committing horrific crimes against women. This is a human problem, not a “muslim” problem.
      These words come from a white as snow female atheist American of 57 years.
      Obviously, this reply is NOT to Yochai. It is addressed to those who follow hateful acts with hateful words.

      • I’m still of the opinion that this is a cultural issue (not that much of a religious one). Of course there are rapists in Western countries too, but it’s quite another thing when large crowds of men attack together and seemingly spontaneously and try to rape female journalists in a public place. That’s now happened several times in Egypt. They are not even trying to hide their crimes against women but assault them in plain sight. Unfortunately that tells me that it’s somehow more accepted behavior in their society.

  344. I’m so sorry to hear that something this awful happened to you, Natasha. I’m also amazed that you’re still trying to act all understanding towards Egyptian men. No, of course not all Muslim men do these awful crimes against women and humanity, but at the same time it is a cultural issue, it just can’t be denied. I’m a liberal thinking young woman and vote for the Green party whenever I can, but I’m still of that opinion. You’re not the first woman who’s had something like this happen to them in a large political gathering of Middle Eastern men in a public place. That’s something exceptional that just doesn’t happen in Western countries in similar situations. We have to admit that somehow public violence against women is more accepted in Egypt and its neighboring countries than it is in some other cultures.

    • Correct…..sad but true. However, there is one exception among Egypt’s neighbours and that of course is Israel….clearly, the problem is rooted in Arab culture. Sometimes the facts are just not politically correct.

      • We must remember that the modern Israel is a country of immigrants, so its inhabitants are not that firmly rooted to the Middle Eastern culture. However, once upon a time Islam as a religion was a welcome change to the extremely poor circumstances in which the Arab women were forced to live…

      • Yes, but “My thoughts on the matter,” many, if not the majority of Israelis have roots in Middle Eastern and African countries. But there is no support for this kind of madness in Israel.

      • “We must remember that the modern Israel is a country of immigrants, so its inhabitants are not that firmly rooted to the Middle Eastern culture. ”

        Actually, they are. Most Israeli Jews are Mizrahi, meaning Eastern.

      • “My Thoughts..” You make a good point about Islam once being a welcome improvement to the lives of Arab women…therein lies the answer. It is incorrect to suggest that Israeli culture (basically influenced by Jewish culture) is not rooted in the middle east… Jewish culture is completely rooted in the middle east with later influence from the diaspora of course. The issue here is that there is a problem with ARAB culture and education. This can only be changed by Arabs themselves rejecting it completely and reforming their societies. There are enough good Arabs to do that…but they will need to be very brave.

  345. Sheikh Abubukar Hassan Malin, of the recently established Somalia’s Supreme Islamic Courts Council, didn’t mention anything good or humane that came from Mohammad. Instead, he urged Muslims “…wherever you are to hunt down the Pope for his barbaric statements as you have pursued Salman Rushdie, the enemy of Allah who offended our religion. Whoever offends our Prophet Mohammed should be killed on the spot by the nearest Muslim. We call on all Islamic communities across the world to take revenge on the baseless critic called the Pope.” Inspired by his appeal, Somalis have convincingly demonstrated the goodness and humaneness of their religion by fatally shooting Sister Leonella, a 65-year-old Catholic nun, in the back. The nun died forgiving her murderers, which partially explains why I would never make a good nun.

  346. I do not think that words would ease your pain – and mine too.
    But let me tell you that I do not allow my daughters – who are I believe at the same age of you – I do not allow to go such places where those extremists nuts are gathering; because if they do; they will undergo the same painful experience you been through.
    Because if they do; they will face the same savage, inhuman, retarded, cruel, violent, brutal, undomesticated and uncivilized acts.

    To give you an example of hoe savage those people are; if this is a reconciliation to you; imagine that few days ago one of those beasts has raped a 5 ( FIVE) years old girl and imagine that he did that in a mosque!!!!!!!

    These words are coming from a Christian Egyptian.

  347. The government spokesman of Iraq, another nascent Muslim democracy, didn’t mention anything good or humane that came from Mohammad. Instead, he said that “the Pope’s remarks reflect his misunderstanding of the principles of Islam and its teachings that call for forgiveness, compassion and mercy.” Judging from the growing fervor with which Muslims in Iraq, Syria, Libya, Gaza, Yemen or any “Turdistan” you pick continue murdering each other, Islamic forgiveness, compassion and mercy must be drastically different from what the rest of the world denotes by those terms. In the generally unforgiving, compassionless and merciless Dar al-Islam, Iraq presents the most dramatic example of those exclusively Islamic qualities. Sunnis and Shiites are killing each other with such unsurpassed blood lust that I begin to suspect they mistake their own kind for the “children of apes and pigs” (the term the Muslims reserve for Jews). If so, someone should explain the difference to them. But on this joyous occasion, they took a brief respite from their daily routine and avenged the Pope’s insult by stabbing several Christians to death.

  348. It is, of course, saddening — extremely primitive and barbaric what has happened to you. The same horrific things are happening to our Ethiopian women in these satanic societies for the last three decades. The mainstream media, international ‘Humanrights’ groups are still very reluctant and unwilling to report them. In the streets of one of the most “civilized” of all Arab states, in Lebanon, African migrant workers continue to be called fahmeh (charcoal) or abed (slave). Asians can still be addressed as “Jackie Chan” or “Bruce Lee.” Arab laborers are routinely referred to as mukhabarat (informers) or as “stinkers.”

    Wishing you all the best, I would like to invite you to watch the following horrific video from Lebanon — which has recently sparked outrage and anger among many Ethiopians:

    http://addisabram.wordpress.com/tag/ethiopian-maids/

    • Yes, quite horrific, your embassy people should be ashamed of themselves and resign. One of the duties of an embassy is to protect its citizens abroad, and yours has clearly failed to do this. Domestic workers, especially women, are vulnerable (refer to the DSK episode in NY with the chambermaid) and powerless. Several governments, for example that of the Philippines, no longer allow women to accept employment in countries where there have been abuses. You (and other like-minded people) should make your outrage known to your government so that it takes action to protect these women and address the abuses with the host country.

  349. Natasha, what genius will be able to explain to us that the term Islamofascism is absurd because Islam itself, in its entirety, is a form of fascism? Islam is the ideology of jihad. Take jihad out of Islam and all that’s left will be an elaborate set of absolutely meaningless rituals. And when someone tells you that the word jihad means the internal strife of the faithful for spiritual perfection rather than genocide waged by evil savages against the rest of humanity, keep in mind that the title of the world famous classical work on humanism that enjoys ever increasing popularity among the Muslims, Meine Kampf, translates into Arabic as My Jihad.

  350. The inexplicable, stolid silence of moderate Muslims on Osama statements prompts me to ask once again: What exactly makes us think that moderate Muslims exist? If they do, they must be something akin the mysterious dark matter that no astronomer has ever observed or is seriously hoping to observe, but that is sorely needed to balance the equations that, according to the current state of cosmology, rule the universe.

    What iconoclastic breakthrough is needed for us to finally understand that the division of Muslims into moderate and extremists exists only in our imagination and only because the concept of “evil people” or “evil religion” contradicts everything we believe?

  351. Al-Qaeda, in one of its statements declared: “…you and the West are doomed as you can see from the defeat in Iraq, Afghanistan, Chechnya, and elsewhere. …We will break up the cross, spill the liquor and impose the jizya tax, then the only thing acceptable is a conversion [to Islam] or [being killed by] the sword. …God enable us to slit their throats, and make their money and descendants the bounty of the Mujahideen.”

    Kudos to Osama. To the best of my knowledge, this statement constitutes the best, most complete, most concise definition of Islam. As could be expected, this definition caused no objections from those whom it is supposed to hurt the most: the revered Islamic leaders of Mecca and Qum, the Islamic scholars of Al-Azhar University in Cairo, the residents of royal and presidential palaces in Muslim countries assisting us in our war against their terror, the American professors receiving their salaries from Riyadh, the moderate Muslims residing both in the lands that are already Muslim and those that have never been but are turning Muslim right in front of our bewildered eyes, or their Jewish and Christian enablers and appeasers.

    • I agree with all your main points about Islam (It needs to reform, it is a political ideology masquerading as a faith, it brings out the worst in people, there is almost no moderate islam, only moderate muslims, It is the worst religion today and a threat to all civilized societies and unbelievers alike, far too many muslims condone extremism and sharia in all it’s medieval barbarity etc), but please stop preaching to the extent that you do and respect that the proper thing to do here is to show some respect for the victim. Some comments about Islam related to the issue at hand is appropriate since that was touched upon in the blog post itself, endless preaching about unrelated evils of Islam seems to me rather cold and heartless. A woman was raped, goddamn it, and that is the main point! Are you no better than the muslims on this page incessantly droning about how this isn’t the fault of islam, more preoccupied with defending their faith than expressing sympathy and understanding for what this woman has been through?

  352. egyptian men as all muslim men are animals. actually they are even worse. why do the western women want these animals…makes me so sad.

    • You are a BIG liar, See what our Holy Quran says:

      Chapter/Sura 60: Verse/Ayah 8
      (Allah does not forbid you from those who do not fight you because of religion and do not expel you from your homes – from being righteous toward them and acting justly toward them. Indeed, Allah loves those who act justly.)

      Return back to Muslims history and return to your history (if you even know it) and you’ll know Who are the Muslims.

      http://mohammad.islamway.net/

      • You forgot these quotes:

        1. — Surely the vilest of animals in Allah’s sight are those who disbelieve. (8.55)
        2. — The unbelievers are your inveterate enemy. (4: 1 01)
        3. — Mohammed is God’s apostle. Those who follow him are ruthless to the unbelievers but merciful to one another. (48:29).
        4. — Make war on them until idolatry shall cease and God’s religion shall reign supreme. (8:40)
        5. — Fight against them until idolatry is no more and God’s religion reigns supreme. (2: 193)
        6. — We will put terror into the hearts of the unbelievers. (3: 151)
        7. — I shall cast terror into the hearts of the infidels. Strike off their heads, strike off the very tips of their fingers. (8: 12)
        8. — Fight against such of those to whom the Scriptures were given [i.e. Christians and Jews] … until they pay tribute out of hand and are utterly subdued. (9:29)
        9. — Prophet, make war on the unbelievers and the hypocrites and deal rigorously with them. (9:73 and 66:9)
        10. — Believers, make war on the infidels who dwell around you. Deal firmly with them. (9: 123)

        Islam is not a religion of peace. You know why? Because the koran and muhammed though the hadiths never misses a chance to scorn and dehumanize non-muslims and to say that violence towards them is ok. Hell, even the extremists themselves say so, you just have to listen to how they justify violence – by quoting from the quran and hadiths.

  353. Egyptians and muslims really seem to deserve their fate as suppressed third world citizens.

    I just decided to lift my boycott to Israeli fruits.

  354. Dear Natasha,

    I wanted to say that I find your blog text extremely brave, wise and fair, and particularly so in the circumstances. Words can’t express how sorry I am about what happened to you, but I wanted you to know that I admire your conviction not to become a victim, and to make something important out of this experience. I am sure your story will touch many people, and hopefully we will all find a way to work together to change the attitudes and social problems that have led to attacks like the one you suffered.

    You are a truly great writer, and I’m sure you will become a person strong enough to make a real difference.

  355. i’m egyptian ,i just want to tell you i’m really sorry that something like that happened to you in my country ,egyptians are really good people but ignorance , poverty and opresion had made minority this way ,but we hope that after the revolution we will fix that , i really wish that god help you get past this and you find the strength in your self to get over this

  356. You are lucky to be alive. When a gang of sand monkeys get hold of you its usually game over. Islam is a religion created by a pedophile (MooHAMmud) who married a girl at 6 and viloated her at the age of 9, who combined elements of Judaism with a pagan Moon God cult then went around spreading his “religion” by use of the sword. Women are viewed as subhuman. Calling some of them Moderate Muslims is like calling average Nazi party members in Germany Moderates in the 1930s and 1940s. Egypt is on its way to becoming a hard core Islamo-Fascist state.

  357. Sorry Natasha for what u’ve been through, I’m Egyptian & Muslim, beleive me our Religion would accept even tiny look to u, these troops have lost their humanities long before they lost their religion. I know that nothing can wipe the bad memory but at least have the faith that there r lots of respectable & honest people that r ashamed of what happened & wish to make up for what u’ve been through. again my deepst apologies to u

  358. Pingback: Egypt: "Please, God. Please make it stop"

  359. Natasha,
    Que o Senhor Jesus, esteja contigo nesta hora difícil. Só você sabe o terror e o medo que passou em uma terra estrangeira, com uma minoria de pessoas que só querem um motivo, para iniciar uma selvageria.
    Fique em paz, com saúde e não desista de sua profissão.

    Deus é grande, e foi ele quem te salvou!!!

  360. Even just by looking at these comments here, I’m amazed at how many people are blaming her for the assault. As though the sexual depravity of men in the Arab world is a sensible factor to take into account when planning a trip…
    How COMPLETELY backwards is that?
    The number of men wanting to help her were GREATLY outnumbered by those that wanted to partake in the mass rape? Statistically, for there to be more rapists than honourable men in a community is… disgusting.
    There is something clearly backwards about the Arab nations, at least through a Western lens, where rape is a BAD thing that can’t be tolerated, and not a big party for everyone to partake in. We’re not all the same happy people, living in different parts of the world, with the same priorities in life. Islam is trying to embed itself in the Western world, and, sadly, it is being allowed to do so for the time being. Just look at ANY Western European country’s statistics regarding crime and rape, and compare that with the influx of Muslim immigrants – especially Sweden and the Scandinavian countries, but hugely Germany, France, and Great Britain. Places like CNN won’t put articles like that up, but just google it. You will be totally shocked.
    I think that this is a tragic, but very clear example of what is wrong with the Muslim world.
    Natasha, by what you’ve written, you sound far more forgiving towards the people of Egypt than me, and I commend you for that. I think you’re very brave, and I’ll pray for your recovery. Please don’t go back, though. It’s not YOUR fault for being there, like so many have said, but THEIRS for having so backwards an environment where sexual assault can happen so easily, and with so much support.

    • Our heart goes out to Natasha and we hope she can recover and regain her life back.

      Oh, and all the vicious anti-Islam/Arab slurs here are seriously a joke.
      Sexual violence exists everywhere and characterizing a religion/ethnic group as more prone to that behavior is unfounded. Otherwise what are we to make of the following articles?:

      http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2111016/8-female-Marines-claim-gang-rape-sex-assault-Washington-D-C-barracks.html

      http://www.irishcentral.com/news/Gang-rape-becoming-the-norm-for-many-young-girls-in-Ireland–159403845.html

      http://articles.cnn.com/2009-10-27/justice/california.gang.rape.investigation_1_suspects-arrest-police?_s=PM:CRIME

      http://www.startribune.com/local/158515125.html

      http://www.gq.com/news-politics/big-issues/201109/texas-gang-rape-11-year-old-girl-story

      I could also post links for the gang-rapes that happened at the Occupy Movement Protests in NY, but I’m sure many of the bigoted voices here consider white middle-American anarchists to be foreign crypto-Muslims as well… just as they view President Obama. Many women can attest to a general feeling of increased safety in the Middle East, being able to walk in metropolitan areas at all hours of the night in a way they couldn’t in the United States or UK.

      We should realize that the common causes for all the abovementioned instances of sexual violence as well as Natasha’s unfortunate tragedy are a combination of the lack of education, the circumstances of poverty, the proliferation of pornography, and immorality/criminal tendencies.
      Let’s work together to fix these problems, and we will all see a great improvement worldwide.

      God Bless You All.

      • Blond. Female. Western. With camera and backpack. Approaching Tahrir square thronged with thousands of wild Egyptian men. Not blaming you for what happened but really poor judgement. A similar incident happened with female ABC News reporter, and with CNN reporter Anderson Cooper (male). I am male and olive skinned and even I would not have gone near that craziness. Be strong. and alert. Egypt will take a generation or 3 to evolve beyond medieval attitudes toward women. Not in our lifetime anyway…

    • Absolutely right! Those helping her were hugely outnumbered! In a normal society it would have been the other way around. The mentality is deeply disturbing…even one of her rescuers felt it sufficient to offer to take her to MacDonalds!!!! The Arab world needs to be honest with itself….this behaviour explains allot about what is wrong with the middle east.

      • True. I can’t fathom those that says this doesn’t say anything about the culture of egypt. How indoctrinated they are. As you say, I have never heard about the good men being outnumbered, in public, among people, in any western society. Couple this with the fact that 62 % of egyptian males admit to having sexually harassed a female and the treatment she got afterwords (I don’t know what to say – If a foreign woman said she had been raped in a western city everybody who passed by would be trying their utmost to help her) and you can see that the problem is clearly institutional and reflects deeper structures and norms of egyptian society.

        Not all cultures are the same in every aspect, and it is just naive to believe so.

    • Cultural behavior absolutely SHOULD be considered before traveling if it is an issue of safety, sad to say ESPECIALLY for women. That is why I would never go to Saudi Arabia or Iran or Afghanistan or Egypt and a growing list of other places all over the world. 20 or 30 years ago maybe was a good time to visit Egypt, but definitely not now.

  361. Hi Natasha. I wish u well and im glad that u have such gift like forgiving. Thanks for your words, love and strength. U are my hero. Listen no one. Do only what your hart told. Thanks you)

  362. i’m egyptian ,i just want to tell you i’m really sorry that something like that happened to you in my country ,egyptians are really good people but ignorance , poverty and opresion had made minority this way ,but we hope that after the revolution we will fix that , i really wish that god help you get past this and you find the strength in your self to get over this

  363. Hi Natasha,
    hope you are very well now,
    and say hi also to your parents,they are so lucky to have such a wonderful girl.
    I don’t know if I said sorry for what happend, it would change any thing, but I wish you come back in better situation which change that bad experince

  364. For those people prattling on that this is not islam / egypt, if you are so embarrassed by your deen’s true nature after what Lara Logan, other women and now poor Natasha have gone through (which has spread like wildfire across the world for all to see), then at least put your money where your mouth is by publically declaring yourself a murtad otherwise your apologies ring hollow so please STFU.

    If it is any consolation, Egypt will soon become Somalia-on-the-Nile as it is running out of money and will not be able to feed its population.

    • I agree with your first point. 84 % of egyptian muslims believes apostates (murtad) should be put to death for leaving the faith. 82 % believe that an adulterer (I guess just the females) should be stoned to death. 77 % believe that people should lose their hand for stealing. To call this medieval is simply true. To call it abhorrent and sickening is natural. Egypt, just as most islamic lands, is simply more backwards than most westeners can imagine. Moderate Islam exists only in the winds of liberal westeners.

      See this fascinating and enlighting report from esteemed opinion institute Pew for the above facts and more:
      http://www.pewglobal.org/2010/12/02/muslims-around-the-world-divided-on-hamas-and-hezbollah/

  365. Democracy in action!
    You wanted to democracy has been all over the world?
    The world thanks you!
    Take the thanks of Tunisia, Libya, Egypt, Iraq, Afghanistan …
    Welcome! You out there waiting with open arms!

    • My heart goes out to you. Now, we all know that Egypt, Lybia and other Arab countries are not safe places to visit. Let those who harassed you burn in hell!

  366. I just read this news in Indian newspaper, i really feel bad for you those are really animal…i some how agree with above comments about the Muslim community. these people really sucks…Most of the terrorist are Muslims, they never respect women even there female family member….
    Better you should work back in europe and america only……..don’t waste your life for these people,… sad for your parents and for you….take care of yourself.

  367. I just read this news newspaper, i really feel bad for you those are really animal…i some how agree with above comments about the Muslim community. these people really sucks…Most of the terrorist are Muslims, they never respect women even there female family member….
    Better you should work back in europe and america only……..don’t waste your life for these people,… sad for your parents and for you….take care of yourself.

  368. What an awful story Natasha…my heart goes out to you and I hope that you achieve a complete recovery, physically, emotionally and psychologically.

    However, I think it is high time that the truth of the depravity and backwardness that exists in many of the Middle-Eastern Arab states and especially in Egypt is exposed. The fact that hundreds of men violated you in open view of one another, that many more tried to attack you than save you…that you were sent from pillar to post when you needed help, that were asked if you were married or a virgin when you needed medical help and gentle care is clearly indicative that there IS SOMETHING MASSIVELY WRONG with Egyptian / Arab society.

    The cries of “this is not Egypt! this is not Islam!” come from a place of real embarrassment and shame….but it is time for those who feel ashamed of the behaviour that is so prevalent in their society (remember the Logan story?…just like yours) to STOP PRETENDING that its not the “real” Egypt… to STOP THE PR and STOP THE LIES and STOP THE SPIN and to start facing the issues, to confront them head on! It is time for the Arab world to BE HONEST WITH ITSELF FOR ONCE!!!!! When that process of self evaluation actually takes place… ONLY THEN will the Middle East be on track for a better tomorrow…. That should be your goal, becoming a PR agent and denying this horrific reality will do nothing to change this awful situation. The liberal knee-jerk reaction to immediately make excuses is destructive and unhelpful….its time for Egypt and teh Arab world to face up to its serious social and intellectual ills and deficiencies which are MASSIVE and stop its obsession with those they have designated as their “enemies”.

    The time for middle eastern self evaluation is long overdue….finding ways of giving Arab women (both Muslim and Christian) a voice would be a helpful starting point. The cover-up must end.

    Natasha, I wish you well, I wish you healing and I wish you success.

      • It would seem to any rational mind that the posts from Toby are an aggressive reaction deeply seated in embarrassment…. don’t blame the victim…..there is something severely wrong in Arab society….CONFRONT THE PERPETRATORS! CONFRONT THE MENTALITY THAT ALLOWS THIS TO HAPPEN! ITS NOT NORMAL!

    • Natasha,

      What happened to you was Horrific! The Middle Eastern culture is beautiful and yet so very ugly. I know from experience that most of the men have no heart and are simply barbaric; they act like cave men. And their needs to be a change but unfortunately the so called “Arab Spring” made things worse. Democracy does not work…you need a Republic with a working constitution in place…”Mob Rule” will ruin a country. At this time Western women should not go to Arab countries

      Arab men do not know how to conduct themselves. Islam will not allow them to date, they are sexually frustrated and they act like wild beast. There are no laws in place to protect women because they simply could careless about women. Most the women are over weight, and not allowed to take care of them selves or beautify themselves. It’s very sad. And if change were to come in Egypt the effects will be seen 20 years from now. Revolutions take time. And these sexual assualts on women is a systemic problem that has been in place for generations and has to be rooted out but it will take years to fix this problem.

      Again, Egypt is an AMAZING country with AMAZING people. But this is the truth the problems in that country are Amazingly ugly, and they are taught from a very young age to blame the West for ALL of their problems, instead of looking in the mirror and taking responsibility for their on country. (Dear Middle East, The West is not responsible for the ills in YOUR society). Be responsible for your own country, and stop Hating the West. Hate gets you know where.

      date,

  369. Pingback: Moonbattery » British Journalist Invited to Join in Egypt’s Arab Spring Celebrations

  370. I am so sorry this happend to you!
    I am sure you’ll come back stronger from this horrible experience, but I also hope you’ll give it time and accept help from the people around you.

    You are so brave and I wish you the best for your future.

    • ““Please God. Please make it stop .. make stop idiot American and UK female reporters travel to places they should not even think about going to and then complain about …

      • Ah yes, completely her fault, not the fault of the savages who raped and violated her?

        You very clearly personify a high level of ignorance and idiocy.

    • She’s a slut? You’re an asshat, Buddy. And you don’t even speak English… too stupid because you’re… what? Egyptian? Arab? Whatever you are, you are a knuckle-dragging cretin. Do you call your mother and your sisters these names? Obviously, your were raised by wolves and your mother taught you nothing. This is the kind of thing people in the West come to expect from men in Islamic countries. Disrespect and violence. And you wonder why we don’t trust you? Don’t like you? THIS is why. You suck donkey dick.

      • I’ll tellyou this. Self reflection unfortunately isn’t valued highly in the islamic world. That’s a big part of the problem. It’s always somebody elses fault. The jews, the west, the infidels, mean regimes etc. But dare to question their faith and a shitstorm will brew.

  371. Well what happened is not acceptable everywhere and people that are talking about Egypt and woman rights don’t know anything about what they are talking about…. tahrir square at the moment doesn’t represent Egyptians or the real Egypt, I read many racist comments towards Muslims Which i cannot accept at all and most are unreal , the last thing I want to apologize to the poor girl and hope she forgives us one-day and visit Egypt one day again and also I want to advise her to try to be a professional in doing her job and ask people to help her specially in places she doesn’t know anything about

    • its not about muslim, its abt being who she is at the wrong time, at the wrong place…white woman in the middle of arab angry mob…

      fucken idiot.. all i can call the author… next time please report from Mt St. Helens national park instead of places like that

      • did you read what i said ! , and obviously you are the fucking idiot here

    • Unfortunately, what happened to this woman IS very representative of behavior by Egyptian men. They have NO respect for women. Did you know that 83% of Egyptian women in Cairo and 98% of foreign female visitors in Cairo have reported sexual harrassment and sexual assault on the streets?

      Egyptians have to smarten up and correct this. Not only is it a grotesque violation of human and civil rights – unacceptable behavior in a supposedly civilized society, it’s economic suicide. Tourism is or was one of the biggest money-makers in the Egyptian economy. People in your country are desperate for jobs and income. So do they roll out the red carpet to foreign visitors? Make things pleasant, show off the best aspects of your country? Try to entice those dollars back? No. Your stupid Egyptian men now have given your country a worldwide reputation as a place NOT to go. Certainly not someplace I would care to visit and take my family.

      Egypt was once high on my list of places to spend a long vacation. I wouldn’t go there now if YOU paid me. Why would I? Between your disgusting men and the terrorists blowing up or shooting tourists, one would have to be stupid or insane to go there. It’s really too bad.

      Egyptian women and any decent Egyptian men need to address these issues or Egypt is going to just sink further and further into the squallor we already see on the television.

      • Jennifer I said I apologize for the girl and that is the least thing I could do, why are you talking in a plural way I am sure you never meet an Egyptian man in your entire life , I really think people who did that should be executed in a public place this is so disgusting behavior and unacceptable anywhere and about the percentage you are talking about of female visitors in Cairo have reported sexual harrassment I do not know really about it

  372. There’s nothing I can ever say about it and would make you feel better, these brutal accidents happen to female Egyptians from time to time, Community is collapsing, I’m so sorry that happened to you.. please forgive Egyptians.. who ever made this to you is just an animal, Not all Egyptians are animals, please accept my apology.

    • author (natasha) of this Article is an idiot… dont go to places like, that in a country like that..she asked for it….

      • How on Earth can someone ask to be raped? Something is inherently wrong with a community that has so many men wishing to partake in that kind of barbarism. Did hundreds of ‘rapists’ get together in a body to find her? I highly doubt it; a whole bunch of like-minded individuals just got excited at having their disgusting wishes become possible by taking it out on this girl.
        “She asked for it,” is the most pathetic and low-minded excuse for something like this, and makes me feel like you would have partook in this barbarity yourself.

  373. Pingback: Egypt: Another Disgraceful Attack on a Woman in Tahrir Square :: Responsible for Equality And Liberty (R.E.A.L.)

  374. I cant believe this honestly..I’m a foreigner in Egypt too and I always feel intimidated in the street just by the disgusting look of some men or young guys, like desire look really creepy..I am terribly sorry this occurred to you and is something happening in Egypt from long time and nobody seems to dare to talk about it, at least you are now taking the first step, If in anything I can help you I offer you my help, I assume you are American, my husband works in the American Embassy If that is of any use for you, please feel free to let me know If you need anything…I’m truly sorry for all…

  375. Pingback: British Female Journalist, 21, Describes Horrific Sexual Assault in Egypt’s Tahrir Square After Election Result | wolfslair88

  376. I apologize as an Arab for what you had to go through..
    This is a serious issue in Egypt and its been for the past years..
    Unfortunately the corrupted government never toke serious steps either invested real effort in limiting such a type of crimes.. Probably, they kept on doing it in purpose!

    I wish you all the best, it was very interesting reading your post. Thank you for having the courage to share with us.

    Bechir

    • no need to apologize… she should fucken apologize for being a retard to go to the square… who said it is safe to be there?!

  377. Hi Natasha, could you please contact me, I have been covering Egyptian election for BBC, and one of our story is the harassment of women, it would be helpful if you could tell your story, may help women over here. I am coming back to London Friday. jiyar.go.@bbc.co.uk

  378. Were you unaware that this has happened multiple times before in Egypt? Or that Egyptian men at large are sexually repressed and unduly empowered by their faith and culture when it comes to interacting with foreign females?

    I’m sorry for what has happened to you, but you should have known better then to place yourself in such an environment, large crowds of Egyptian men have shown time and time again that they can be no better then rabid dogs. That a only a handful were decent enough to help you is an indictment on Egyptian society, now matter how you try and portray it.

    Get better, stay strong and don’t let this stop you from your career in Journalism, but use some common sense next time.

      • Why should we accept it, George? “I speak my mind” is not a talisman which protects you from expressions of disgust at your utter lack of compassion.

      • Alec, my comment was in reference to abrahamhicksloa telling me to ‘STFU’.

        Your disgust means little to me, as this seems to be an alien concept to you, but I can have compassion for her and still criticize her actions. I’m sorry this happened, but I am not surprised by it given the situation she placed herself in.

        No man deserves to lose a leg, but if they walk through a minefield, the chances increase dramatically.

        Is that clear enough?

      • Yes, it clear, George. You are a repellent individual who is doing little more than turning-up at a rape clinic and jeering at the victims.

        It’s all par for the course in the Internet for no-nothings to splatter threads with their punk rockerish attempts to offend, but yours are so unspeakable inhumane and devoid of any compassion than I do think it’s helps make a case for Internet users to post by their full names and locations.

        You wouldn’t say this to Natasha’s face, I suspect, because it quickly would generate into a situation in which you were arrested for breach of the peace.

      • “unspeakable inhumane and devoid of any compassion”

        I think you’re being overly dramatic and not very lucid. You’re taking offence at the mere suggestion of an alternate opinion, one that was not even directed at you.

        Absolutely, if I were to meet Natasha, I would tell her in the same polite tone that I hold in all my comments, that she should not have been in that place at that time and the sexual assault could have been avoided.

      • D’you have a problem with other people “speaking [their] mind”, George?

        My comments towards you have been clearly expressed and unambiguous, which is the lucid bit dealt with. And, coming from someone who’s immediately responded to a blood-curdling description of serious sexual assault with a pre-written script about sexual violence in Egypt – which, given that Natasha was there to research a piece about women’s rights in Egypt, and went with male companions and didn’t even enter Tahrir Square (instead, trying to depart at the first hint of danger), Natasha clearly was aware of – accusations of being overly dramatic ring hollow.

        Your first thought was to tell someone still bearing the bruises and scars from a rape-pack that she’d brought on herself, and then you start squealing about being bullied. What an honest debater you are.

        Politeness and decency are so very much more than not using terms like “STFU”. Objecting to that whilst taunting sexual assault victims is the sign of, at best, a marvellous sense of disconnect.

        I would tell her in the same polite tone that I hold in all my comments, that she should not have been in that place at that time and the sexual assault could have been avoided.

        And I’m the Queen of Sheba. You are a passive aggressive. The aggressives in this thread are, at least, more honest than you. This doesn’t mean your unpleasantness is any more agreeable than their toxicity, it just means that they don’t try to hide behind sweet-talk.

        You, on the other hand, wish to be thought of as a nice person whilst taunting a rape victim. Sorry, mate, you cannot do that. You only can taunt a rape victim and be a hypocrite.

        ~alec

    • The faith does nothing of the sort about “foreign” females . . . the faith knows no borders and actually in Quran, respects a woman’s sanctity and modesty. Men are not even supposed to raise their gaze to women to respect this (and women are to do the same). This is a base culture issue – and not an EGYPTIAN culture issue – these situations happen in other countries. I’d be careful generalizing about faith or culture when Islam doesn’t speak ill of women at all and the culture here is multifaceted.

      • The problem with ‘holy’ books Abigail is that they are written in such a way that they mean everything to everyone. If I were to follow the Quran, I would stone my Jewish neighbour one day, and bow at his feet the next. And avoid you completely while you are menstruating.

        The Quran bids a man to respect his wife in the way you would respect a brand new car.

        You think we should treat a religion as the sum of its parts, which is incorrect. Muslims are not what make Islam, Islam makes the Muslim. They can only ever be as good as the whole.

        This doesn’t apply only to Islam and Egypt. All religions are the same. A ‘god’ is a shackle they have placed around your neck.

    • Well said George.

      Natasha, firstly I am sorry for what happened to you, I can relate to your experience only too well. But you are not the only victim in this. And people don’t simply ‘let’ themselves fall victim. The problem we are really faced with here is much bigger than I think you realise. A particularly poignant comment of yours was that you had never felt so powerless and you had no control…this was just one night in your life. Think what 30 years of this would possess you to do.

      Feel free to contact me if you are interested in more stories.

    • Will c’mon thats harsh. How many muslims have you met in your entire life? 10? 100? theres millions! and u judge by less than 1% of them? The men that did this to her are animals, but dont go insulting an entire faith based on a random act.

      • Actually, 62 % of egyptian men admit to having sexually harassed a women. So that is more like 62 % than 1 %.

    • My husband is a Muslim as are many of my friends and they treat women with respect and kindness (and doing such a thing is even outlined in Quran). You don’t even get into heaven unless you treat your mother with respect and kindness no matter what other good deeds you do. And you are forgetting there are also Christians and non-believers in Egypt . . . this is a ridiculous comment.

      • Abigial, all you’re doing is repeating tired phrases. Stating something exists in the Quran does not make it true.

        Neither you, your husband and his well respected mother, or any one else on this planet will ‘enter heaven’.

      • “they treat women with respect and kindness (and doing such a thing is even outlined in Quran).”

        Tell that to my wife, who gets hassled all the time by Muslim men while walking through the Little Egypt section of Queens NY. If these lowlives want to keep their own nations in the dark ages, fine. But please don’t think for a second that they can get away with that behavior here in America.

        My heart goes out to you Natasha. Thank you for exposiing the atrocities committed in the name of religion.

    • You are a BIG liar. Lets see what Holy Quran says:

      Chapter/Sura 60: Verse/Ayah 8
      (Allah does not forbid you from those who do not fight you because of religion and do not expel you from your homes – from being righteous toward them and acting justly toward them. Indeed, Allah loves those who act justly.)

  379. People…. try to REMEMBER it was ANGRY MEN fueled by propoganda and other stimuli responding to their lower human Nature. Primal instincts if you would, and every man under the same stimuli and circumstance is capable of the same thing…. lets look at WWII for a small example folks…… NEVER BLAME ISLAM (peaceful) but only men who wear that label but do not practice the philiosphy. PEOPLE…. IT WAS MEN and ONLY MEN….. not RELIGION that groped the girl….. and MEN around the world have groped women and will when they react to their LOWER insticts through whatever means. May you all stop CONDEMNING religions and faiths and see that all men are men and capable of doing what men can do in situations under certain stimuli. IN other words, open you F&###g eyes and shut your F*##*#g judgemental mouths. AMen!

    • Repeating the lie that Islam equates to Peace won’t convince anyone, sorry. It a lie both in scripture and in practice. Islam means Submission.

      ‘Primal instincts’ is the wrong phrase to use, it applies on a biological level only. What we have here is men who grew up in a culture that cultivates this very behavior.

      If anything, these men are the model of a good Muslim. You’re the one being a false Muslim by denying the very nature of your religion.

      Your god, like all gods, is a lie.

      • What are you an IDIOT too…. Is this IDIOT day on BLOGGING…. A good Muslim does NOT GROPE WOMAN….. IT does not say in any HOLY BOOK to GROPE WOMEN you f*#*#*#n mor**#(#(#n GO BACK AND READ YOUR HOLY BOOK and send me the parts that say GROPE WOMEN you f#*$&&$g di#*#*weed

      • And Islam is in reference to Submission to Allah . . . the Quran is very clear about the proper rights and treatment of women. And a Muslim is a person who believes in One God.

  380. I am appalled why the religious figures in EGypt do not condemn this violence in their Friday prayers??!!! if one person in any ways criticises a cleric, the entire religious communities cry our religion is in danger and we have been attacked, simply like the renown Egyptian actor, Adel Imam, there4 is a court case against him for depicting clerics in “not a pleasant way” .
    What Natasha has gone through must have been horrifying moment, since I have been attacked as a man in Tahrir during covering the election.

      • If the religious authorithies saw this as a problem they could do so much to lessen gender-hate in egypt. As, you say, tell that it is haram every prayer. So, why don’t they? Probably because they agree with it.

  381. Everything happens for a reason and can ultimately used for Good. Your BLOG will serve GOOD and save many the future pains, In essence you are a HERO. What does not kill you once again makes your stronger and wiser. I hope you understand you were chosen for this great deed and it will expand you and others you touch as a greater human being, in time you will see it for its value and expereince,
    All the best my love!!!!!

  382. Sorry to read this, but… I am not surprised at all. Raping non-muslim women is very common for islam. Also is the Muslim Brotherhood encouraging this behavior, since they want no women in the public space, unless they wear the hijab and are accompanied by male relatives. Muslim arabs worse than animals? I know of no animals that behave so barbaric.

  383. natasha smith we by my self and by all christian people who are living in Egypt are So sorry to what you suffering from and the ugly faces of Egyptian people ,,,but I must tell you as a journalist to tell all the world what we suffering from as a christian people in egypt, all these happens by blessing of USA and England governments and you investigate of my words.
    May God Bless us and you

      • The source of this evil is repression and a lack of education. Women are raped in every country and the last time I checked many of those people aren’t Muslims. Actually this is so opposite from the preachings of Islam.

    • I am an atheist myself, but the continuing lack of media interest in the west regarding the persecution of christians is one of the most shameful things the media has done as of late. I feel so sorry for all atheists, christians, secularists (Be they leftists or liberals or whatever) and people of other faiths that suffer persecution in egypt under islam. And now it will only become worse with Mursi and the massive support for the brotherhood and salafists in the parliament. I understand if you long for the days of Mubaraks old regime, even if it was cruel, At least you werent hunted like dogs.

      And what is our, the wests, response. Nothing – silence or explicit support of the brotherhood. Shameful!!! We, the west, are a sick culture, but in a wholly different way than Islamic culture is sick. We are probably among the most naive cultures in all of history, if I had to take a guess.

      Take care, sister!

  384. Lessons learned:

    Rule 1: Don’t vote for people in government who sponsor aid bills giving Egypt western tax money.

    Rule 2: Don’t travel to Egypt.

    No more problems with Egyptian mobs.

    • but thats like having a bad relationship and never talking to girls ever! (assuming you’re a guy)

      Egypt has just emerged (and poorly) from a civil outbreak overturning the government and nearly facing civil war. Wait for it to get back on its feet, and I’m sure you would love most of the culture and history it has to offer

    • The egyptian females would still suffer, so that solves only a very small part of the problem. I can’t imagine what it must be like to be a christian or secular girl in egypt these days. No support from the authorities, constant fear of being sexually harassed or worse, raped and unwillingly converted to Islam to marry a muslim man. Terrible. Shame on Egypt and it’s menfolk.

  385. I am a muslim Egyptian living in western countries. I am really very sad to what happened to you, Please accept my apology in behalf of all real muslim Egyptians, who can’t accept something like this at all. I appreciate and admire your courage and your ambition, and I hope that you will recover very soon from this terrible incident. With my best wishes.

  386. Fuck women rights over there. That country is lost, you cannot do anything to help. They must help themselves.

    Fight for your country instead. Stop immigration from these countries. Keep the filth and scum out!

    • My wife is a nide human being from that country and I am glad she was allowed into my home country through immigration. The filth and scum I presume you are referrnig to are a pocket of people that represent the few and not the many peaceful beauful humans around the world. Shanne on you Robert… one wonders who is the filth Robert, and who is the scum Robert. Shame on you Robert, hand your head low and rexamine your life today Robert. 😦

    • I’m an American woman living in Egypt – by choice – who’s married to an amazing Egyptian man, living a nice life with wonderful friends (expat and Egyptian) and family. Just like any society there are assholes. Gang rapes happen all over the world and are horrible.

      • “Gang rapes happen all over the world”

        REALLY?! In broad day light? In a crowded square? Stop making excuses and speak up for justice.

        Did you miss the part about how Natasha was treated at the hospital? This goes beyond “every society has assholes,” and shows much deeper cultural problems.

  387. Dear Natasha, I extend my sincerest sympathy to you about the attack, and what a horrible reason to leave a project and country that you loved.
    If you are looking for a silver lining or at the very least a positive consequence to eventually come out of the events, perhaps you could let it be a greater understanding of the feminist fight accross the planet. We are so far from any resolution, in some countries more than others.
    I cannot guess whether or not you want to forgive these men as you try to move on, but please do not forgive the religion and rules that primarily influenced their actions.
    It is an understandable Western trait to avoid blaming a country or religion as we are constantly taught against racism. Whilst generalisations about a people can never be true, this over sensitivity to cultral terms is putting many women at risk abroad and in England as we avoid facing the true facts of why these assaults on women are happening.
    I hope you recover soon and that this awful event that was not your fault does not burden your life too heavily.
    J
    (FGM Activist)

  388. Pingback: back-handing the casbah — Tremble the Devil

  389. I’m sorry for what happened for you but this happened too much from Muslim’s to girls or woman special Christian people on Egypt and Muslim’s look to west people as enemy

  390. I read every word and to be honest i’m shocket, i dunno how to react to this monstrosity… i can only hope that you’re safe now and people will take care of your scars so you’ll get to be the same beautiful girl you once was, both inside and out.

  391. Pingback: Une journaliste britannique violée en Egypte. | Toute-lactu.com

  392. I am a moroccan producer and filmmaker. I am sorry for your bad experience. I am searching for a director for making a film about rape and illegal abortions in my country. Your statement make me think that we could work togheter for this project. What do you think? You can reach me on: m.qrayim@gmail.com

  393. Dear Natasha,

    i’m really sorry for what happen to you and i’m sorry that you’ll have to read all the disgusting messages. You’ve done nothing wrong and there’s nothing you have to be ashamed of.

    Hope you’ll get well soon, i wish you all the best in your life.

    I’m pleased that you’ll continue your fighting for women

    thank u and may god bless you

  394. Pingback: Wishful thinking in Tahrir Square: ‘This is not Egypt! This is not Islam!’ « turcanin. cu ţ.

  395. Pingback: Datechguy's Blog » Host of DaTechGuy on DaRadio on WCRN, still Catholic and Still with Fedora (also featuring Roxeanne De Luca!)

  396. اسف لما حدث لكي , احنا المصريين حيوانات مفترسة , لا رحمة لا دين لا سلام ,هذة هي مصر don’t come again

  397. while I sympathise with you on a personal level, I can’t help but wonder, WHY? why after suffering such a horrible experience in the crowd and then later in the hospital do you still insist that your experience doesn’t represent Egypt, islam or muslims? what kind of mental block you western “journalists” suffer from in order to stay completely blind to the obvious?

    islam is built on top of sexual repression. its basic principles are that women have no rights compared to men, their sexuality (or multiple sexualities) belong to a single men. that all over the muslim world girls and boys grow up brainwashed by their well-wishing parents that uncovering a female body will cause riots, mass rapes and end order. they are taught that men being blood-thirsty and sex-crazed is a natural given constant.

    read Ayaan Hirsi Ali’s “Infidel” for an insight into this, and how she was amazed by Europe, where women walked around virtually naked and no mass rape or riots were happening.

    current muslim majority can only live under a repressive rule, no matter what the country is. the muslim mass culture is so medieval, twisted and backward, that they do need a ruthless fuhrer to repress them to keep them in check.
    “arab spring” is bollocks, despite well-educated and liberal “muslims'” (actually non-muslims at all) hopes. they will be swept away by a blood-thirsty mob that will again call for a ruthless dictator or just stay like an Afghanistan-like shitehole. why don’t you learn from Iran’s 1979? there were socialilsts, communists, liberal pro-westerners, who supported revolution. what happened to them?

    islam needs a reform. it can only co-exist with the civilised world if it becomes a benign religion like all others. otherwise it will keep muslim countries in the middle ages as it had been for the last centuries.

    if you want to help “good muslims”, especially women, start talking about what’s wrong with islam. criticise and ridicule it, support those who do.
    islam in the shape of MB, salafites or even modern Turkey has no future.

    and before you start accusing me of racism: this has nothing to do with race. race you cannot change. what you believe in — you can. it’s all about beliefs and culture. and not all beliefs/cultures are equally good and acceptable.

    I wish you quick recovery, not just physically and emotionally, but intellectually too.

      • while i stand on the opposite side of the fence with your argument, you have made some very valid points and i respect your point of view.

        however, if i may portray and example. Imagine a 10 year old kid that cusses at his parents, and brings girls home for sex. His parents would find that he has strayed from the norm and will try to get him to act better. His opinion would be “why the hell are my parents so outdated and old? they should get on with it and accept my freedom and my acts.”

        Islam is in a sense old fashioned when it comes to the “openness” of the world, and they would take extreme measures in trying to protect their beliefs. But they would never and i stress Never ask this of outsiders. It is only adhered to amongst themselves. and Please do not take the acts of random groups as the acts of Islam. I am not in agreement with the Islam way of life, but its their choice. I do not agree to homosexuality either, but its their life.

        i am not a muslim, but have lived in muslim counties for more than half my life. What you see and hear on the media is 5% true in real life when you meet and interact with them. I’ve also been to Egypt and seen the beautiful side of it. I’m not crazy or stupid enough to visit now, and that was her mistake, but i definitely will not judge thousand years of culture on a few “animals” actions that caused harm.

        cheers

    • Have you read the Quran? There’s a difference between the Quran and the practice. And then on the other hand – have you read the Bible? Women have clear rights – even to the point of keeping our own last names such that we aren’t “property” of our husbands . . . This gets to components of culture and repression. And no, you can’t generalize to a country of 80 MILLION what happened in Tahrir Square. It’s like saying all NYers represent the US or something to that effect. Give me a break.

    • Add to it you can exist and live in Egypt just fine right now – this is one awful incidence in a major crowd . . . and the Islam you’re talking about is twisted Islam . . . not the pure version of it.

  398. To all those lamenting on the causes:
    Does religion have to do with incidents like this? Specifically, no, but in more general terms, any crowd agitated enough will turn on those around it that do not comply with their moral and cultural norms – in the case of islam, it can very often be women not perceived humble and covered enough..
    Could she have avoided becoming a victim? Specifically that night, no, but in more general terms you always have to be extra careful and focused when entering near-revolution or war zones, especially so if you stick out from the crowd and if you are a woman – to put it differently, can she be blamed? of course, not, would I want my daughter to report from near Tahrir square? (or late night from South Central? or about Russian troops recapturing Chechnya?) probably not ..
    Could the police or other authorities react better? Specifically yes, but in more general terms you have to note that there is a revolutionary transition going on, where everyone associated with the authorities (of the establishment compromised under pres. Mubarak) feels they might be next, they have little professional supervision, much less political backing – lawlessness on one hand is a consequence (see also collateral damage) of the seismic societal shifts, while it can also play into the hands of the Muslim Brotherhood (who preach for more accountability on moral and ethics grounds)..
    Could similar incidents reoccur in Egypt? Specifically, nobody knows, probably yes. In more general terms, news like this will reinforce the negative perception over xenophobic and disillusioned young Egyptian men, more generally over muslims and Egyptians. Guess who the biggest loser then will become: Egyptian tourism industry (contributing cca. 40 % to the GDP) heavily intertwined and controlled by the military establishment..

  399. Natasha, I am inclined to think, that you just lie. All this story is fictional. You invent this, just to increase your reputation and to traduce Egypt people.

    • Show some respect to this obvious victim of your beloved egypt.

      And there, ladies and gentlemen, we have illustrated what’s wrong with the middle eastern mind set of today. No self-reflection, an absurd willingness to believe in conspiracy theories, just to not having to engage with the fact that your culture is a heap of backwardness and medieval superstition.

      • “No self-reflection, an absurd willingness to believe in conspiracy theories, just to not having to engage with the fact that your culture is a heap of backwardness and medieval superstition.”

        I think this sort of backwards thinking extends far beyond the Middle East and to all religious zealots.

  400. So sorry to read this. You have great character may God bless you, heal you, bring you joy and happiness and make you stronger.

  401. Hello Natasha !

    Just an advice for your future : let’s contact Sonnet Ehlers, a doctor who invented a female condom to avoid rape.

    This is the product of the century !

    • I have heard of a FB group of young European students, who – besides other things – are mapping out ways to counter violent radicalism in the name of any religion.
      These guys are known to collectively urinate on copies of Qurans after every time there was an Al-Qaida attack on non-muslims, westerners. I do not know if the news even reached those that were meant to be reached, or if they are still doing it..
      What I do know is that this would be the time for some bravery, maybe even vigilantism on the part of Western civilizations. If we had the will, if we had a couple of young, blond European martyrs willing to die while really show them, it could work.. I am talking of a hidden hand grenade or an explosive-laden belt deep inside the same type of crowd.. it may need to be done once for all to learn and remember..

      • What? Why does this keep on becoming a religious issue – there are more than Muslims here in Egypt! And violating a holy book? What the hell does that do but insult devout peaceful people and anger the crazy ones?

      • It _IS_ a religious issue. Please do not make the mistake of totally divorcing a Muslim from the ideology s/he has been raised (brainwashed) with, since childhood. The religion is preached using the scripture that is said to be the perfect word of Lord (..right!). And that very book has violent verses, verses that prescribe death, verses that qualify a woman, EVERY woman as a lower being. Your apologist like stance is not excusable here, please educate yourself – a Muslim will quote the peaceful verses from Qur’an to tell you how it is a matter of ‘interpretation’ and how the violent fringe does not represent Islam – but they will NOT mention to you how these peaceful verses are abrogated by later verses in the Qur’an.. this is the magic of Taqiyya, a tactic prescribed in the Qur’an, by which a Muslim is told to lie about Islam in order to ensure its spread.

        If a Muslim person does not follow the violence prescribed in Islam – only “THEY” become a good person, Islam does not automatically escape blame or scrutiny, it remains bad because it IS intrinsically bad.

  402. dear Natasha
    I am Egyptian and I am so sorry about what happened to you but I have something to say as a girl these stuff happens every day to me and to many girls but as a matter of truth not all Egyptian men are like that so any of them are really gentlemen and I am sorry that you had to face those men but Tahrir square became dangerous lately so you can come to Egypt when it is safe enough for you and you will se the real Egypt

    • “but I have something to say as a girl these stuff happens every day to me and to many girls”

      This is WRONG, your country is WRONG

    • Not “the real Egypt”. lol, good one. The ‘it wasn’t me’ argument! Hilarious.
      People raping and murdering in the name of Allah every single day, but of course it never has anything to do with Islam. Not “the real Islam” at least. And i guess Germany in 1945 wasn’t “the real Germany” then as well, huh? It wasn’t “the real Nazis”. No one is responsible, right? Don’t change a thing, it’s all just coincidental….

      Keep telling yourself that and negate the fact that this is obviously the result of a failed culture, and in this case culture almost equals religion. People like you will always lie to yourself and others just to avoid acknowledging some bitter truths. It’s because of apologists like you nothing in the muslim world will ever change for the better.

      Great idea: let’s just blame the Copts for all this! That way Natasha can keep her heartwarming, naive illusions about muslim Egypt and you guys can keep rampaging against modernity/infidels/the evil west/the jews/whatever.

      • NDB: So true – this is the result of what the culture is based on: a religious ideology.. and this “It wasn’t me!” response bugs me to no end – because it is often accepted..! Sad. People will even scream Godwin’s Law when you state this, as has happened down in the stream of comments.. but they’ll fail to realize that the ideology is not exculpated by the acts of those who Do NOT abide by it.

  403. What happened is absolutely awful no words are strong enough to describe what I feel about those who committed this hideous crime. Please Natasha, don’t go back to Egypt your much better off here. Take care and hope you recover.

  404. Your article just made me shiver. I’m from France, and I’m reading you with such anger inside of myself. I’ve almost been a victim of such this horrible crime.
    The thing that amazes me is how you wrote this horrible fact, you’re so brave, I don’t think I would’ve been myself that brave. Keep being strong, keep being a fighter, this makes you be who you are.
    I might not know you but I feel the same than you and this just makes me feel somehow less lonely and more helped.

    Good luck for everything girl.

  405. Another incidence of sexual assault in the islamic world, even in the same spot as last time it came to attention is that a coincidence? I bet some cultural relativists will tell themselves and the rest of the world that the perpetrators culture or religion had nothing to do with it. Well then, how often have hundreds of western men collectively abused a young woman in the streets of London, Paris or Berlin..?

    • dont throw stones at glass houses…. might wanna read some history on the so-called “1st world” countries. this has happened more times than you’d think.

  406. No woman should have to go through this terrible ordeal and violence. Women are our sisters, daughters and mothers and what those evil people did to Natasha is grossly shameful. God bless you Natasha and hope you are ok.

  407. It has been prophesied that all the good, kind, decent Jews and gays will unite under the banner of their Moshiach, and do glorious battle to the last Jew and gay against the bad, evil, loathsome Jews and gays.

  408. the very DEAR Natasha ,
    i don’t know what to say actually .. i was just speechless after reading your post .. i found myself can do nothing to correct this situation for you or for any girl or woman those who suffer from the SH everyday and all the time .. it’s too bad .. i will not pretend that i know how u feel .. but i’m just wanna have the same spirit that u have Natasha ..
    you r VERY BRAVE Natasha and you got a very strong will .
    1000000 sorry cannot express what i feel .. and also won’t change what happened !
    please keep your spirit always up and go on ..our hearts _all of us_ with u .
    god bless you Natasha
    Arsany Mashreky

    • There are a sect of people in every religion-these people can be serial killers, rapists, drugdealers…
      You should be careful in generalizing one label for a particular group. Again every religion will have deviant people.
      I am a girl and I feel sorry for Natasha, I am against violence every where

      • Sorry, I have not gone through the liberal PC brainwash. Mohammedans are animals and the enemy of Western civilization.

  409. Brave like a light’s daughter, Natasha.
    I had informations about what happens in Egypt, but reading your post is so… I have no words, and it’s not because i’m writing in english. I actually work with Medwomens’Fund, and this organization supports Harrassmap, a young association that struggles for egyptian women’s rights and safety.
    Thinking about you, sincerely. Karine – near Montpellier, France

  410. I am so sorry Natasha for what happened to you to many girls from all nationalities ,,when I just read about any sexual abuse I really get scarred to death that it could happen to me or to anyone of my familly ,, sorry for the death of humanity in human being.. The Egyptian men used to be gentle and can not bear that any one insult a girl I front of them but for so sorry not all offcourse became non caring and abusing them selves,, it is now a matter of low dignity ,, the men did this to you are not men and they do not deserve even to be called men they are turned to be furious and hungry wild animals every where in the streets!!!!! God heals you, protects and bless you. And pray also for us .

  411. Egypt is a horrible country with horrible people I wouldn’t suggest anyone to go there, especially for women, they don’t treat women as human beings..

    • Please ask the people who actually visited Egypt before making Judgments. Not to undermine what happened to Natacha, but I am sure sexual harassment happens everywhere. please bear in mind that the country is still unstable and has been in a state of lawlessness for quite some time now.

    • WHAT DO YOU KNOW ABOUT ISLAMIC MENTALITY !!!
      HOW MANY BOOKS YOU HAVE RED ABOUT ISLAM !!!
      HOW MANY ISLAMIC COUNTRIES YOU’VE VISITED ???
      PLEASE

      • Well the rapists certainly were not driven by atheism now were they? Anyone with half a brain knows that in islam women are 2nd to men. “How dare an attractive female westerner join our celebrations???” etc

    • In true Islam women are equal and complementary to men. The cultural transition of Islam has made women unequal . . . but then again women aren’t always treated equally in other societies . . . we are always fighting for our rights. Actually the Bible does less justice for a woman than the Quran – women have plenty of rights – people just don’t READ their BOOKS and then pretend to know what it preaches. Lack of education is the root of all of this.

      • > In true Islam women are equal and complementary to men.

        You must be joking… their holy prophet did himself have numerous female sex slaves. Read up on Maria the Copt, for instance — traded to Muhammed as common cattle, of which he happily accepted her to his harem of slaves.

        Or Safiyya, a 17 y/o girl taken as war booty by Muhammed, raped shortly by the 60 y/o Muhammed after he had ordered her husband tortured and decapitated. It’s all available in the first biography of Muhammed, written by Ibn Ishaq, in the story about the battle of Khaibar.

        Or Aisha — habitually raped by Muhammed from when she was 9 y/o.

        This is the man that Islam holds up as The Most Perfect Human Ever.

        So… how can you possibly say something so delusional about Islam that women are equal there? It’s ridiculous.

  412. Dear Sarah,
    I am sorry you had to go through such an experience and i am glad to year that you do not let yourself be driven into submission.
    There is a crater between the western and the arabic civilization and one should always be aware of that. Egypt is not sharm el sheikh.
    I could continue with resentiments against this country its culture or their religion. This is not what i want to say. I hope you can encourage the right people and that someday there are more people that will help you in such a situation than there are people who want to do you harm.
    For going back after this event and keeping an open mind you have my admiration.
    Be carefull

  413. we are so sorry & ashamed of that mess, and that all that had happened in the country u loved, u went down there to celebrate with ppl peacefully and it turned out like that, again we apologize on the behalf of all egyptians and plz this is too way away of islam or arab`s nature, those are cruel chaotic men with no principles or humanity,,, be safe ((الله معك))

    • > we apologize on the behalf of all egyptians

      No, you certainly don’t:

      A survey in 2008 among Egyptian men found that 62% (!!!) admits to sexually harassing women, and 53% of Egyptian men believes it’s the women’s own fault that they get harassed — ie, they deserve it.

      The survey was done by the Egyptian Center for Women’s Rights, and was reported by Reuters, among many others:

      http://www.reuters.com/article/2008/07/17/us-egypt-harassment-idUSL1732581120080717

      So you pretending to speak on behalf of all Egyptians is certainly pure, grade A bullshit. Fact is that your country is a shithole destroyed by Islam, as Islam tend to do, and your smartest course of action would be to get the hell out of there as soon as you possibly can, if you’re female.

    • Disgusting comment. This is like me saying all Muslims are rapists because of these events. Get a grip and comment something relevant on such a serious and emotive blog post.

      • No I did not mean that, but if asked I am sure 99% of them are. I am also convinced that under the rule of law the catholic church should be branded a criminal organisation. The difference though is that if there is evidence that a priest raped a boy, we consider the boy the victim and the priest the perpetrator whereas in many middle eastern countries if e.g. a young Filipina girl gets gangraped, they lock up the girl for prostitution whereas the guys go free: http://www.realcourage.org/2010/06/uae-girl-prison-for-rape-victim/

      • I wanted to say that all of us have an animal side inside, but there are many that show it more often, and in a very unpleasant way….and whose animal side is much more evolved, in the negative sense of it…very sad what happened

  414. sorry is a meaningless word now… i know.. but i must say sorry … and i want you to understand that they doing this here to the foreigners to make them not come back to Egypt.. they want to isolate us ( Christians in Egypt) they don’t want us to be contact with you ( other Christians ) ..so please accept my apologize and stay contact with us .

    • why dont u think zat some animals that harresed her may be cristians !!! a very narrow point of view ! or u see that cristian guys dont abuse even muslim girls !! cristians like YOU who give bad idea about egypt , ISLAM and also about christianity !!!!!!!

      • 100% RIGHT …. WHO TOLD US THAT THESE MEN ARE MUSLIMS MAYBE THEY ARE QOUBT (CHRISTIANS) !!! PLEASE STOP ATTACKING ISLAM BEFORE KNOW IT VERY WELL !!!

  415. Why people making out this is a problem only with the middle east and Arab World.
    This has nothing to do with religion or do people think the hundreds and thousands of priests that abused boys and girls in churches all over the world did so because they were instructed by God.

    There is rape and violence all over africa yet no one says or does anything. There is a huge problem within the UN which Coffee Annan has admitted to with soldiers raping young girls and women they are charged with protecting is this because of their religion?

    you have pedophiles in every facet of western society and most rapes and sexual violence is committed by family members within white communities.

    So before pointing the finger at Islam and muslims take a long hard look at yourselves.

  416. My heart is broken for you Ms. Smith. I can’t even begin to describe the rage I feel…. and I know that’s not the right way to feel, if there is a right way, but I can’t help but wish this kind of thing would come to an end by whatever means. Not just in Egypt, but everywhere, amongst any and all cultures. A hateful, vengeful fire burns within me whenever I read about this… about any kind of oppression, anywhere, and I despise myself for it. But at the same time, I can feel the world’s hunger for vengeance, and the worst part is that I can’t do a damn thing about it.

  417. Natasha , Really Sorry for what happened there I\’m Egyptian and i know how Tahrir square is , lately it was so dangerous to go even for me , policemen from the last regime are still there disguised just to spread chaos all over by any mean necessary , to ruin what is Tahrir square Actually is being a symbol of freedom for all Egyptians , from your Story i can see your a tough girl & you will get over it , Emad hello Im Salem Egyptian living in Qatar , I will Not try to convince you what islam is , ill talk to you as Egyptian , My wife , sisters in law even my Mother are harassed on a daily basis although they are wearing hejab\” except my wife \” from other guys i dont know what their religion is but they are Egyptians , it was never about religion , in Islam it says Don\’t look , so they are not doing what Islam said although his having a beard and he looks like islamists but he is not educated enough to just mentally think properly , It\’s All About Egypt , the country is just fixing up alot of view , opinions and fights will continue but hope is just there and it will never go , been for more 30 years in darkness poverty sickness and what i call social corruptness , for sure it will take time to heal .
    It\’s going to be weird to say that but thank you natasha for telling your story to world , your news are in every channel around the globe , Egyptian men will think of that , the guys who did it , will feel guilt , guys who didn\’t did it , will make sure it never happen again , awareness about the case is being thought about it , men will think , why we did that , how we did that and how we let it happen , they will think , they will act , Natasha Thank you for letting Egyptian people think , You Love this wonderful country and you proved it , you just participated in the process of making our country as we dream of , we will be there , we will make it happen , I\’m SORRY on behalf of all Real Egyptian Men with Manners for what happened To you Natasha and thank you

    • Stop spreading lies ..the police ..the old regime …it is only what you call revolution , your revolution ruined our country …and now you are trying to put responsibility on the police …and you know what ?..at the end of all this damage and those sacrifices our country has been handed to the fanatic group of MB.. Thanks for the Obama administration …and thanks for what you call revolution .. Thank you our country is ruined..
      once and for ever ….

      • Let’s be fair. Egypt was always a shit-hole. You’ve just replaced one tyranny with another. Your false religion has created too many sicko perverts, too much poverty and you basically haven’t invented anything or created any wealth for 1000 years. You could not even beat the Jews in 1967, because basically your culture is shit and you are a disorganised bunch of primitives.

  418. I am so sorry for your pain.. you are one brave lady
    I think it’s so good that you write about this, not all women dare to do that..
    You are an inspiration

  419. dear ms.natasha :
    i’m victor from egypt i want to till u ( sorry ) god brotect you and we ask that protects us here

      • Neither Betty Mahmoudy was a fake story nor is this one, and every Egyptian knows this is one of millions of stories that happen on a daily basis in Egypt. Give me one good reason why we shouldn’t believe her and believe you instead when we SEE these thngs happening…

  420. feel sorry for reading such story, please accept our apology, and those men are just outliers and don’t express our behaviors, morals, or ethics, not as muslims but as Egyptians. um not here to defend for Islam nor to attack any other religion/country and I hope this discourse stop right now!
    just hope u accept our apology….
    hope to c u in Egypt very soon…
    so sorry!

  421. This thread has taken a nasty twist, I understand reading Natasha’s account on her horrific experience sparks emotions which many of us find difficult to handle.

    Please people, learn from the way she dealt with this..

    “I reassured her that I knew that was the case, that I loved Egypt and its culture and people, and the innate peacefulness of moderate Islam”

    Unfortunately every religion, colour and creed has it’s share of desperately perverse and disturbed individuals. In some places it common knowledge and more intense, and in others it’s concealed… but it is there whether we choose to ignore it or not. Like some comments on here… claiming to be from a civilised western countries, yet all that is written is spite, bitterness and anger.

    This is NOT the solution.

    *Natasha – I hope your strength and compassion infects us all.

  422. But don’t let yourself become a victim. Don’t let bad experiences ruin your life and determine your future. One of the worst things two nights ago was that I had never felt so powerless. I had no control and I was violated. But now I can take control and rebuild my confidence, and learn from my experience.
    Nothing, and nobody, will hold me back. When I’m ready, I’ll finish this. The show must go on.

    You are a brave heroine Natacha; you are so strong to end your above blog with these bright words.

    Yes, The Show Must Go On.

    Keep UP your high Spirit !!!!!

  423. But don’t let yourself become a victim. Don’t let bad experiences ruin your life and determine your future. One of the worst things two nights ago was that I had never felt so powerless. I had no control and I was violated. But now I can take control and rebuild my confidence, and learn from my experience.
    Nothing, and nobody, will hold me back. When I’m ready, I’ll finish this. The show must go on.”

    You are a brave heroine Natacha; you are so strong to end your above blog with these bright words. Yes, The Show Must Go On.

    Keep Up Your High Spirit !!!!!

  424. No words are enough. I just wanted to say you are not alone. Not long ago similar incident happened to an Egyptian veiled college girl snatched from amongst her male and female friends. Even police couldn’t help her. Only few men were later able to take her on a motorcycle naked and bruised and drive her away then to a police station. The group of criminal men followed them and they hid in a gas station till they were able to take her again to the police station. I am sure these are not single incidents. I am sure you were attacked mainly for being a woman. Even if you recall the march of women around a month ago against sexual assault by some women in Tahrir was attacked by over 100 men pulling their clothes touching and molesting them. Thank you for being so courageuous to bring this to the open and I hope many more women expose the reality of the sexual violence against women in Egypt after the revolution. A revolution which brought us -some more than others- face to face with the ugliest face of crime. I salute you, your courage, your faith and everything you stand for as a woman and as a reporter. God bless your heart and may you heal soon to continue the work that was entrusted to you.

  425. Pingback: “Det var rena gerillakriget” « Snaphanen

  426. So, you got raped, everyone refused to help you, probably they thought you deserved it, in the hospital nobody wanted to help you either… and this has nothing to do with the wonderful egyptian culture nor Islam? I think your love for that country is poisoning your judgement. No doctor in the western world would refuse to attend a woman because she was raped! And almost every time I read something about a mass of people raping or killing someone, oh surprise, it’s in the islamic world! Sure, there is bad people everywhere, but we have a social conciousness of what’s right and what’s wrong which strongly differs from theirs. And it costed hundreds of years to develop. We could loose all that if we keep looking away from the root of the problem. Of course there are many nice things in Egypt, as they were in England in the 17th century… but we don’t want to go back there, do we?

    • Natasha… you asked for it. So give me a f*#en break… and be smarter next time to do some reporting from Yellowstone instead of places of risk…and you were wearing a skirt in the Arab country… are you out of your f*#en mind?!

      • No. You are wrong. Absolutely NOTHING she did meant she was “asking for it.” Absolutely NOTHING permits sexual assault you complete and total idiot of a human being. It is the fault of men who attacked her. It is the fault of the people who did not give her help when she needed medical attention. The abuse she suffered is NOT her fault.
        The men and women who helped her escape? The men and women who tried to shield her? Her friends? You will never be as courageous as those people. They are what Egypt and Islam is really about, what being human is really about.
        How dare you, you mindless, disgusting troll. You aren’t helping anything or anyone.
        Natasha, I know you must deal with these ^ people all the time. But I hope you read this and I hope you understand that your reporting really is helping. Thank you. And you are so, so, so brave.

    • point made… there is an inherent problem of morality and disrespect for other religions/cultures in the islamic world. we call it radicalism. their moral conciousness stood still a couple of centuries ago. my sister has seen most of the world by travelling and working, never had any problem with the people or its culture, nice memories and great experiences, but its only in Islamic states/countries where she encountered stressful situations differing from men trying to convince her male companion to sell my sister for camels and goats, to men in Tunis who literally spat on her face the moment they got out of the airport, men that started to jerk off in public (!!) by the sight of a western woman without any form of law-enforcement trying to stop them. The law-enforcement being males of the same culture and religion, not even seeing the problem. Of course we tend to generalize, but people must understand that some cultures and religions are just impossible to coexist in harmony with other, more liberal, less radical cultures and religions.

    • you’re right Queck,
      and Natash, do not be naive, and do not defend the arab mob of men, who are not taught that men and WOMEN are world family,
      do not cover by smoke the brains of other women who would then come in similar situations.

    • Yet, in the Western world we think it’s right to have TV shows about completely narcissistic, materialitic and sex-crazed people. Every culture has it’s own virtues and vices. It doesn’t help that regime after regime has kept the majority of people in the “Islamic” world poor and uneducated. If you can’t read the Quran, you won’t learn what it actually preaches and listen to others (sounds familiar from medieval times). A good lot of people in Egypt are wonderful, educated, kind and Christian or Muslim (or non believers).

  427. Pingback: Egypt: ‘Please God, make it stop!’ » Savoir ou se faire avoir

    • Natasha… you asked for it. So give me a f*#en break… and be smarter next time to do some reporting from Yellowstone instead of places of risk…and you were wearing a skirt in the Arab country… are you out of your f*#en mind?!

      • “you asked for it”–typical male response to rape victims worldwide. MEN ARE THE PROBLEM.

  428. I know this might sound strange, but when I was reading this with my wife I was not surprised with what those men did to you! I know this isn’t the right time. But unfortunately this is a HUGE part of what Islam is all about (SEX) I’m a Christan Egyptian living in Egypt, and because my wife (sisters, mother) are not wearing the veil they are harassed on a daily basis. Those people in Tahrir who did this to you were the most fundamentalist Islamists. The MB didn’t allow any thug to get in the square that day at all. So to claim that those are thugs is ridicules. Religion for them is everything in the outside, the Hejab, beard, prayer and all shallow stuff, but when it comes to behaviors its all sinful, like animals (just like what happened to you) I have seen this so often in Cairo. I’m not trying to use this incident to show my hate toward Muslims, but I do hate ISLAM as a fascist religion. Truly Sorry for all what happened to you. I do ask you to take your time to heal and don’t try to get back to normal quickly. Will pray for you.

    • Too bad the muslims are in a majority, pray hard for liberty, maybe one day Israel can rescue you from the satanic muslim pigs. Support Israel and show solidarity with the jews is the only way to solve your problem.

      • @Stand Up: So realy; you claim by supporting the Jews “her problem” will be solved? No doubt she’ll just forget about this traumatic experience by supporting Israel and the jews?! you’re just as dumb as those mass-rapists (no matter what religion they have) you call them pigs but you are none the less an ignorant fool yourself, thinking you are better than “them” you just show the same lack of respect and intelligence.

      • @ Stand up : First of all, We ALL Have THE SAME GOD!!
        How can you Juge something you just DONT KNOW ANYTHING about ??
        Less of inteligence, that’s SUR, but I realy want to know Are you realy Reflecting that by yourself or stupid People told you stupid things?

        Have you ever took time to read the coran?? Of course NOT!! You wouldn’t say all that stupidities.
        I am Muslim, I live in belgium ( I’m sur you don’t know this contry anyway), I’v’e read the Bible, Because for Us ; Muslims ; Coran is the continuation of the Tohra and the Bible, The name of “JESUS Christ” is written 500x More that Muhamed ( salahou eeleh yasalam) in the Coran.

        Please I ask God to help you, Of being so Hatefull and SO IGNORANT , Poor you .realy.

        By the way , what happens to Ms.Smith is Horrible, I guess she realy was in the wrong place at the wrong time.
        Arabian, Belgian,Spanish,American, African, Mexican and alll the rest of nationalities Rapist Are all, going to reach the Flames of Satan.
        And trust me, Muslim’ rapist are in a WORST position, because our god told them, they already know about our book, they already know everything about what god Make to Rapist, Liar, Stiler and HATERS.

        Inform Yourself if you have time instead of throwing Bad energies on not concerned people.
        I wanted to excuse for my english ,I am a french talker so I tried to do my best to explain you How you comment’s make me feel bad, >Because I am a simple and great person, I love everyone ( even they are red, blue, black,yellow, muslim,jew,christians,boudhist ) except those who make the bad around them.
        And I have to NOTHING DO WITH all this .

    • Natasha , Really Sorry for what happened there I’m Egyptian and i know how Tahrir square is , lately it was so dangerous to go even for me , policemen from the last regime are still there disguised just to spread chaos all over by any mean necessary , to ruin what is Tahrir square Actually is being a symbol of freedom for all Egyptians , from your Story i can see your a tough girl & you will get over it , Emad hello Im Salem Egyptian living in Qatar , I will Not try to convince you what islam is , ill talk to you as Egyptian , My wife , sisters in law even my Mother are harassed on a daily basis although they are wearing hejab” except my wife ” from other guys i dont know what their religion is but they are Egyptians , it was never about religion , in Islam it says Don’t look , so they are not doing what Islam said although his having a beard and he looks like islamists but he is not educated enough to just mentally think properly , It’s All About Egypt , the country is just fixing up alot of view , opinions and fights will continue but hope is just there and it will never go , been for more 30 years in darkness poverty sickness and what i call social corruptness , for sure it will take time to heal .
      It’s going to be weird to say that but thank you natasha for telling your story to world , your news are in every channel around the globe , Egyptian men will think of that , the guys who did it , will feel guilt , guys who didn’t did it , will make sure it never happen again , awareness about the case is being thought about it , men will think , why we did that , how we did that and how we let it happen , they will think , they will act , Natasha Thank you for letting Egyptian people think , You Love this wonderful country and you proved it , you just participated in the process of making our country as we dream of , we will be there , we will make it happen , I’m SORRY on behalf of all Real Egyptian Men with Manners for what happened To you Natasha and thank you

  429. Today we hear about this horrible violations because they happened – no offence meant – to a blonde, western woman. Guess what, shit like this happenes every day to muslim women. Nobody ever hears about it. Especially not if the mauled body is disposed in one of the quickly dug graves that you see all over Egypt these days.

  430. Dear Ms. Natasha ,
    what had happened to you is wound on our hearts and scratch our conscious . the worst thing is to find such animals in your country, i cannot describe them even as human being . Please accept my deep apologize , i wish i could help as much as i can to erase that from your mind as it never happen. For my country , i ask by the name of law , our pres dint to get a hard reaction about these crimes .

  431. Pingback: Rasistiska sexuella övergrepp igen. « Varjager's Weblog

  432. Mrs\ Natasha
    as an Egyptian, many apologizes not enough to be sent to you .. i’m really very sad to hear this bad news specially when it’s in Egypt. i’m so sorry Natasha. i want to do any this that can help you. please don’t hesitate to tell me how to help you. hope to everything going better.

  433. Natasha,

    I have broken down into tears. Literally, i am feeling ashamed to be a man. True — I mean it. I am really really sorry for your ordeal.

    Wish, i had power to turn back time. As someone mentioned before, i also wish to be one of those; who had tried to protect you.

    These words can not console you. These can not erase those worst memories, but my true wishes and prayers are always going to be with you, for rest of your life. Truly wish that you can have all the happiness of the world.

    :-///

    — A Man, A Pakistani, and A Muslim.

    • If you feel ashamed, then do something in any arab countries,
      Go out on the street and shout the injustice of what muslim men do to women.
      The problem of Natasha and other women is that the muslim men are disrespectful to women.
      Do something, but you have fear, you remain silent, look away and you like to write flowery texts as that on top. Fight against your muslim machos, if only because of all your women, even in Pakistan.

  434. Everyone remember this next time you start to defend islamofascist and blame the jews. This is what Israel deals with on a daily basis. Islamofascism does not give you a break! Their hatred pushes them beyond the limits! Support Israel STOP ISLAMOFASCIST AND ARABFASCIST!

    • Hahahah!
      So much of hatred only makes me think one thing- why are you threatened about Islam? Maybe just maybe if you got your head out of you as$.. Oh wait you’re already a brainwashed dimwit so nothing I say will make a difference! Anyhow,I’ll pray for you cause you’re in dire need of it.

  435. Respect your courage .. as an Egyptian I am really ashame you had to go through this in my country !
    وياريت لو تقرا الكلام .. بس لأخر مره هحاول اقولكو ان الموضوع دا لازم يخلينا ندور على حل لأنو حصل بسبب جهل وأعلام يفسد الفساد .. بأكتر من اظهار التعاطف والتنكر من هويتك العربيه الاسلاميه او المسيحيه .. احنا عارفين يعنى ايه رجل مسلم وعارفين يعنى ايه راجل مسيحى .. حاول تبقى انت الراجل دا وحاول تفتكر ان دى ممكن تكون امك او اختك .. حاولو نحط ايدينا فأيدين بعض ضد فساد الاعلام ضد التحرش ضد الحاكم الظالم ضد الظابط الفاسد ضد الموظف المرتشى ضد الحيوان الغريزى اللى جوا ناس كتير واسمو المتحرش .. انا قريت الموضوع وقريت كومنتات التدوينه الاصليه .. البنت دى شجاعه فعلاً لكن سواء شائت ام ابيت فسمعة مصر كل ماحد بيقرا التدوينه دى بتنزل اكتر .. مصر بلد الامن والامان .. انا اسف بجد ليكى .. بس انا واثق انى هساعد فالوعى لحد ماموت وانا بدافع عن واحده زيك لو دا حصل قدامى تانى .. يمكن اكون عبره ليهم
    كنت أتمنى انهم زى ماهيقرو بس اللى حصل معاها ياخدو بالهم انها راجعه البلد دى تانى لكن للأسف كل ماظهر من التدوينه هو شهوه حيوانيه تسيطر على كل الرجال المصريين .. لكنى متفائل هنغير وهنتغير ثقتى فالله وفالعقلاء لا حدود لها .. مش أحلام .. ولا نوع من انواع المثاليه الافلاطونيه .. لكن ماباليد حيله انا مصرى فخور عايز اغير بلدى واوجه المستحيل اعمل ايه تاريخ اجدادى علمنى كدا ! وهنقدر نعمل كدا
    وأخيراً .. انا اسف جداً

    • دا رد لكل العرب اللى بيدخلو يكتبو على التدوينه دى .. انتو خير أمه اخرجت للناس مسلمين ومسيحيين

    • If you feel ashamed, then do something in Egypten,
      Go out on the street and shout do the injustice of what muslim men do to women.
      The problem of Natasha and other women is that the muslim men are disrespectful to women.
      Do something, but you have fear, and you remain silent and look away. Fight against your muslim machos, if only because of your egyptian women.

  436. This is incredibly shocking and disgusting!

    I can’t even begin to fathom what must have gone through your mind when it all peaked.
    On something less relevant, “brave” isn’t the word I’d use, rather strong to have been able to summarize this. We’re all angry and disgusted by what has happened, this story will be spread!

    When it comes to immigrants and fugitives, Western nations are extremely naive, ignoring these facts ( http://www.theatlanticwire.com/global/2012/06/egypt-still-horrifyingly-dangerous-place-women/53976/ ) believing such behavior is lost during the move.

    Kind regards and best of recovery from Sweden

  437. Natasha,
    Even though I’m a Pakistani, you won’t be able to distinguish between me and an arab/egyptian guy if you saw me.

    I don’t have any words to say except that I hope I would’ve been part of that minority who tried to save you. I think an important lesson to get from your story is that a minority can make a difference.

    I’m used to being stereotyped as various things when other people see me, and now I know more than ever that unfortunately there is good reason for it. We as middle eastern men need to change our ways if we want the world to respect us.

    • I’m sorry to hear you are being stereotyped as you say. That is not the right way. But unfortunately how muslim men behave are a big part of the problem, as you say. I hope one day you will not suffer from stereotyping any more. Take care!

  438. In addition my previous reply, I hope you get well soon.

    Again, I want to tell you that what happened to you is not accepted by the Islam. And this is not the islam.

      • Actually he is right.
        If you took time to study and learn about proper Islam,not just the islam portrated by the media and hateful people like you,you would know better. Quit being so ignorant.

      • he is right Islam has nothing to do with that, real islam actually gurantees the rights of women before men, real islam protects women from things like that. the problem is not in islam the problem is in the people the way they behave and theit illiteracy
        before judging go read Quran to know what Islam is first

  439. I am very sorry for the horrific events you faced. You give strength to the woman all around the world who face such torturing harassment. I’d kindly like to say please don’t judge people by their race; but by an individuals act- beastly acts where religion is forgotten. I am a Muslim and have lived in the Middle east most of my life and have experienced woman are highly respected , but not men are men , savages to their desires.
    A man is a sexual animal who if loses control once is hard to put down, and rapists exist in every race or country and no religion supports such acts. We as woman all around the world be it Muslim, Christian Hindu etc need to stand up to such animals and fight for our protection, as our creator created us as a beauty in this world, and beautiful beings need to be protected and cared for and not treated in an ill mannered way, it is not acceptable by anyone at any cost.

    • women need not be beautiful, they are half the human race, which must be respected as the men.
      And do not defend the islam, because muslim men disproportionately behave like animals.

  440. You asked the God (Allah) to protect you, and he did. Don’t you think you need to re-evaluate your life and thinking again Oh God (Allah) how can I reach the right way?

    • Abu, i am pretty sure the hundreds of men that assaultet her were in a mayority also muslims and believers (there wouldnt be such a huge pile of nonbelievers in this particular place and this particular city). her religion, and the religion of the assaulters had nothing to to with the incident, those men where criminal assholes, and you claiming it was allah who protectet her and not the small group of people who stood up for her and endangered themselfes makes you a religious asshole.

    • EXCUSE YOU. She was just attacked and traumatized, now is not the time to try and convert her, you insensitive twit. God, men.

    • Or just a few of the people in that frenzied mob had some shred of human dignity and honour, muslim or not. You should be ashamed of yourself Abu Abdullah.

      To Natasha: My heart goes out to you, not in your sorrow only, but in your strenght and passion that drives you to go on, you are an inspiration!

    • Keep allah out of this. The violators were guided by their belief in that “god”.

      It might have been Buddah, Krishna, norse supreme god Odin or the Mayan god Xaman Ek for all that we know.

    • Abu, let Gog out of the play, you muslim men have to learn deal respectfully with the other half of humanity, the women.

  441. From Egypt I send you my sincere apologizes about what happened to you and I assure you as many many must have already that this is NOT Egypt. I live in it for 23 years and I have never been in such a situation nor do I know anyone that has been in one. You were a victim of some malicious scheme planned by some snakes that would do anything to protect their own self-interest and not the public interest. I hope you come back here, consider it your second home we (at least many of us) know of you now and would welcome you with open hands and if needed, protect you as well. I assure you the tension has lessened a lot now and things are back to normal again. Hope you have made a full recovery and your career is going well. Looking forward to have you here again and when you do, have a great time.

    Best regards,
    Aya A.R

    • > this is NOT Egypt

      REALLY? lets test your claim:
      1. if you are a muslim woman, tell your friends and family that you are marrying a christian man;
      2. if you are a muslim woman, tell your friends and family that you are leaving islam;
      3. declare publicly that islam and its prophet should not be protected from criticism and ridicule and proclaim support for the freedom of speech by, say, displaying a caricature of the prophet in a public place;

      I would be very interested to hear about your experiences, unless you are, of course, an extremely rare egyptian liberal living in a bubble somewhere.

      • At least with #1, in Quran a Muslim woman shouldn’t marry a non-Muslim man. A Muslim man can marry only Jews, Christians or Muslims. This is not an Egyptian thing. There is reasoning behind this from a religious perspective (some of it is around the treatment of women and rights women have on Quran that is protected when a woman marries a Muslim man – vs what the Bible and Torah state about women’s equality or rights). Many Muslim’s may practice #3 but then again – why is it okay to start insulting a religion to prove something? That makes no sense to me at all. And if #2 – why should a Muslim woman do that – there are many women who love and live the faith . . .

  442. People should mobilize and put strategy from the west. The people – NOT the leaders! Never visit these ape-countries, if you have a muslim ape-family in your neighbourhood make sure you freeze them out, never talk and try to get them deported. Dont buy in terrorist arab-shops! Provoke them and let the world see their true animal nature. Lets pray they starve to death in their countries, everyone of them! The ones that came here and infected us with their terror we must find a final solution for. Gosh I want to kick a muslim in the face! One da it will be legal!

      • Ha ha ha! Funny that you call ME a nazi, go to the islamofascist countries and get some reality in your face. Arabs and muslims are degenerated animals. The only thing they offer this world is rape, terror and islamofascism. STAND UP AGAINST ARABS AND MUSLIM COCKROACHES! You need to WAKE THE F UP!

  443. You’re an inspiration. To have something so traumatic happen to you and use it as a way to protect others. As feminist who is deeply unnerved by how commonplace sexual assault is in many countries, I am glad to see you are promoting awareness.

  444. Thanks for sharing this. I am going through a hard time where things happened beyond my control but reading what you said gave me strength to face my future. You are just so strong and brave. Thank you again and all the best to you 🙂

  445. 27 The Lord is my light and my salvation;
    Whom shall I fear?
    The Lord is the strength of my life;
    Of whom shall I be afraid?
    2 When the wicked came against me
    To eat up my flesh,
    My enemies and foes,
    They stumbled and fell.
    3 Though an army may encamp against me,
    My heart shall not fear;
    Though war may rise against me,
    In this I will be confident. Psalm 27
    May God heal your wounds dear.. Sorry for the bad news

  446. All muslims from Europe and the U.S should be deported back to the desert! Support Israel with weapons, nuclears and ammo so we can help them in fighting these animals. What are they doing on planet earth anyway? They don’t deserve life and will be out in hell. The people of the world must unite against these barbarians and finish them, They dont deserve to breathe air. We must take out everysingle virus in order to stop the symptoms. ARABS ARE AIDS

    • Whoah now. You HAVE to be trolling. I will quote Danielle from a comment above(June 28, 2012 at 6:28am) “You sound like a Nazi. I hope one day you realize how horribly hateful and ignorant you sound.”

      This is blatant/blanket hatred.

      • Yes I hate arabs and muslims because they hate everything I stand for. Arabs are cockroaches walking on a peaceful planet. Muslims are an upgrade of the barbarian arab, in a worse case.

  447. “These men, hundreds of them, had turned from humans to animals.”

    Animals don’t act like that
    These scums are HUMANS that’s the problem
    Welcome to the real world

  448. I wish all of these people who say “This is not what our country is” would just STFU. Their detachment and unwillingness to face this as VERY FRIGGIN MUCH PART OF THIS COUNTRY and to combat it, is what enables this torture.
    THIS IS EGYPT. It’s one part of it. And for women a big one at that.
    So stop making this about YOU. It’s not. It’s not about your patriotic bruised male ego.
    DO SOMETHING AGAINST IT. Speak up.

    • thumbs up!

      to reply to your call: they can’t. they’re scared shitless. they know that the moment they start speaking up, a bearded guy (probably a nephew) will come over with a knife and slit their throat. that’s how it was, that’s how it is, and that’s how it will be.

      Geert Wilders, Kurt Westergaard and Ayaan Hirsi Ali have to live under police protection for a reason. and they are living in western countries!

  449. dear, precious sister, With all my heart I send you love and all the healing intention I can hold. Thank you for telling all of us what happened to you. You don’t suffer alone an there are so many who are too burdened by shame to speak of it. I am so sorry for your trauma and loss and at the same time I am empowered by your story. I feel moved by compassion but also some kind of fervor fills me and I want to stand up, shoulder to shoulder with you and every other woman who has suffered sexual assault. thank you for speaking up and stirring up places deep inside.

  450. Pingback: ‘Please God, make it stop!’ Journalist, 22, describes horrific moment she was stripped naked and sexually assaulted by crazed mob in Egypt’s Tahrir Square « InvestmentWatch

  451. لا اعلم ماذا اقول انى اكتب اليك ليس مجاملة او مجرد رسالة ابعثها لكى اقضى بها وقت فراغى ولكنى حزين على ما جرى
    حزين لانى تخيلت ان تكون اختى او امى بدل منك وحصل لها هذا الجرم بجد اتمنى اتمنى من قلبى ان ربنا يطيب جرحك
    ناتاشا اعلمى جيدا ان الرب يدافع عنكم وانتم صامتون …..وان من يمسكم يمس حدقة عيناى
    انا اسف

  452. I’m thankful that the God you called out to was ready and willing to save you from that horrible situation. Religious or not, we’ll all in desperate need of a savior.

    • sorry, but that is a ridiculous statement. Does that mean that if she had not called out, god wld have just let her be raped and killed? if there wld be a god why you have to call out for protection? I protect my children even before they call out. Something bad happened to this woman and fortunately it did not get worse and you see that as act of god? What about all those women that did get raped, killed. Is that just their punishment because they forgotto ‘call out’. God has nothing to do with it cos there is no such thing as god

    • Okay, I’m thinking it would have been nicer of God just to let her not be attacked and molested at all, but what do I know about basic morality. The ways that some are willing to go to not have to face up to that there is no god…

  453. Pingback: What If I Was A Refugee? The UN Has An App For That | Maria R. Andersen

  454. I felt about every word that you written here.. I felt ashamed about my country, I think now if this happen with any one of my family..!!
    No one can hold you back you should to finish your documentary movie.. the show must go on..!!
    I wanna to apologize to you about this horrific crime.. We should to make a REVOLUTION against the ignorance in our culture.. specially the Respect of woman, Respect the Religion of others & Respect the human kind..etc
    I’m Sorry Natasha..

      • Obama has had the Muslim Brotherhood to the White House many times. Hillary Clinton’s secretary is very close to the brotherhood.

        We are in grave danger in America. Ronald Reagan we need you – we need you to call Islam the Evil Empire and set a course to defeat them.

      • You are propagating hate and ignorance. I hope you realize how wrong you are soon.

  455. Especially nowadays, whole humanbeing needs the REAL INDEPENDENT JURISTS, courageous intellectuals and non-corrupted NGOs! I am calling all kind jurists/lawyers, it’s the time act for justice! Exactly, once Blaise Pascal pointed well; “Justice without force is powerless, force without justice is tyrannical.” Egypt, Libya and nowadays poor Syria in the same risk going into the same mousetrap of NWO Imperialism; like a kind Bloody Festival Areas of Tyrants!

  456. 100% of western tourists get sexuall attacks in Egypt and 95% of Egypt Woman-Burqua or not.

    95% of the Truck Drivers in Pakistan had sex with young boys.
    ANy questions?
    WHy the f…you go to this barbaric countries?

  457. I am sorry about the harm suffered by him in Egypt, I offer you my apologies on behalf of 8000000 million Egyptians with the knowledge that this is enough because I was a I do not have to offer something more to this and I hope to be in this position with you to defend you I’m sorry … ………………….. Magdy Kamal an Egyptian citizen

    • It’s people like you that remind me that not everyone overseas is a terrible person. I’ve read stories about Chicago where a woman was grabbed inappropriately and when she protested, the man punched her and knocked her out. There is evil everywhere in the world, but it’s good that there are genuine people like yourself and the person below that express their sorrows. Its shames me to see these people say “every Muslim should be killed!” I believe that among the bad, are the good.

  458. please accept my appologies, I m Egyptian and I feel ashame of what you said….I swear if I saw that situation I ll die just to your rescue or anyone on that situation, but believe me that is not Islam, I m really upset of what I ve read, again please accept my appologies

  459. Dear Natasha smith,
    The sad news i heard today about the very shocking experience you had in Tahrir square really brought tears in my eyes, no words ever on earth would describe that awful nightmare you saw.
    I know that few words of apology wont be enough to bring your dignity back or restore your lost peace of mind.
    but i`m really sorry, and i mean it. I`m sorry on behalf of a lot of Egyptian young men who heard about your story who could`t be able to contact you as they are not capable of speaking or writing in English.
    we are ashamed and disgraced by this shameful and diss-respectable action committed by that cruel aggressive inhuman crowd controlled by the most inhuman and aggressive religion on earth called ISLAM ( THE RELIGION OF PEACE !!!!!!!)
    stay safe dear

    • Stop hiding behind that saying. Islam is anything but the religion of peace. Coming here and saying such things is like pouring salt in wounds. Your belief system caused this. Islam is the problem.

      • Christianity is no better so back off! She views her religion is a peaceful way. Be glad that she does not use her religion to justify violence like those men did in Natasha’s post.

  460. ma’am,
    as an Egyptian i ashamed,apologize,i feel inspired and Bend hat to what happened.it wasn’t humanity,but you are Courage and strong to say what happened and reveal the truth.you are strong and you can Beyond that.really i’m so sorry.i wish from god to fit our Ethics,and God bless all human being.

  461. http://edition.cnn.com/2012/06/27/world/meast/egypt-journalist-assaulted/index.html

    For the deniers out there:

    Witnesses – check.
    British Embassy and doctors’ corroboration – check.
    Video footage – check
    Enough evidence for one of the world’s biggest news organisations – check

    Even without all that, the traumatised look in Callum’s eyes is just so sad.

    You all owe Natasha the biggest apology ever. While your at it, could you please include the many Egyptians who risked their lives to save her.

  462. we are soo sorry for you my sister . pleas dont be angry .this people dont know any thing about egypt and the egyption the egyption we are very soory for you and we are wait you here again but this once you will know the real egyption

  463. Am terribly sorry for what happen to you.please accept my apologize on behalf of all real men in Egypt.i do apologize that i couldn’t be there to protect you.non of my words will take what happen back.wish that u will recover soon

  464. So sorry this happened. It’s about time we realize that this DOES represent Egypt. An islamic terror zone that will just get worse with an Islamic president. Egyptians please stop saying this isn’t the real Egypt. It is. I’ve been there and intolerance is widespread. It’s the truth..now examine your society..don’t blame the western world, the cia or anybody else. You are what you believe and your beliefs are outdated. Let’s see if this post gets posted and the person that runs this site believes in real free speech, even if it’s uncomfortable too read.

    • You think this is something significant to say? It has no facts and no philosophical points….you’re basically saying, “Egypt is bad”.

      You obviously havent taken the time to read the comments Egyptians have left here, which are much kinder, more enlightened, and most importantly, more focused on Natasha’s pain than what most of the rest of the world has had to say here.

      • The men who attacked her would not be bothered by this story at all to even read it. Let alone post. The Egyptians that have made comments seem to be very wonderful, kind people which I’m sure represent a significant percentage of the population, but they weren’t the men inflicting harm. I don’t %100 agree with pat’s view on Islam, but there is something that should be expanded upon. No country is a perfect Utopian society and some Egyptians (from all of the accounts of harassment I have read about from travelers especially Blonde women on reddit http://www.reddit.com/r/TrueReddit/comments/vmtr7/another_female_journalist_violated_on_tahrir/c55wngo) seem to treat others like a piece of meat/second class citizens/and so on, but this happens all around us. Idealistically, this shouldn’t be tolerated anywhere, but it happens everywhere including Egypt, including the US, the UK, Australia, France, the WHOLE FREAKING WORLD. I’m upset that this had to happen to Natasha, but the world will be grateful that she shared her story and to get people talking/debating. And hopefully some day some people might get on the same page and accept each other as human beings for what we truly are, animals who developed a society because we cannot live without each other. Just my 2 cents.

  465. اعتذر بالنيابة عن نفسى و انا حزين جدا لما حدث لكى فى بلدى مصر و انا خائف مثلك تماما اطلب من يسوع ان يشقيكى من جراحك النفسية و الجسدية

  466. i’m very sorry my lady for what happen … those animals don’t represent us ,, please forgive us .. i feel so much ashamed … may peace be with you , senora

  467. I’m so sorry for what happened to you, just please make sure this is not us, this is not Egypt or Islam, those are animals, even animals don’t do that.
    I can imagine this happens to my sister or my mother because simply it’s not only becase you are not Egyptian or you are blonde, No, this happens every single day to Egyptians even wearing Hijab!!
    Please continue your work and do your documentary and you must tell the world what happened and you must show the truth to all the people all over the world and reveal the shadow. best of luck.
    As an Egyptian, i’m ashamed of being that. I don’t know what to say just we are sorry, we are very sorry.

    • This is the current state of islam, sadly.

      Just 50 years ago, women in Egypt wore western clothes and no hijab. The last 20 years have seen radicalization and islam countries being taken over by fundamentalists who hate everything that goes against the quran.

      • Yes, Islam wasn’t always like this. Most people doesn’t understand that Islam as of today is very much more radical than Islam of the seventies and earlier. It is to some extent true that islamists have hijacked the religion. Even in supposedly liberal countries like Indonesia a substantial amount of the population expresses confidence in bin laden or supports suicide bombing against civilians in at least some cases when they feel that islam is under attack. Same story in Jordan, Egypt. Nigeria etc.

  468. I’m sorry for what happened to u .. some how i feel the shame on me for what u have been through in my country … i send u my apology with a wish to get over it with God’s help .. may GOD give u strength to make this situation as a rock to step on.

  469. Muslims are wery keen on raping white women since they are nothing more than filth in their eyes. So what shall we do about this then!? is there any sane reason to import these people and letting them go on with their sick and incestous culture?

    • I am very sorry for what happened toNatasha’s Smith, I am Egyptian Muslim women, i truly feel her pain. things will get very bad before they get better.
      To you Marathon man, i wan you to know how surprised i am at your ignorance, i do not know where you live, i am sure you know that men, women and children are raped all over the world, this is a power game not sex. I am sure you know about Jeffery Dahmer,Ted Bundy and others, white men from USA rapping white American women. Rapists come from all countries background and religions. This sort of aggression should be stopped and punished. Do your homework before you open your mouth and say wrong and stupid things about people and culture that you have no idea about. Get educated before you embarrass yourself next time.

      • Isolated incidents in most countries become common(in the form of crowds) in Egypt and other Islamic countries because the religion simply doesn’t respect women. You females that defend any country dominated by Islam are part of the problem. Archaic beliefs that are a thousand years behind. I am not ignorant. I spent much time there in college. Your society is male dominated chaos

      • Sure, rape and murder happen in any country, but I do not see huge gangs of white men (u r the one that brought up skin color) gather on piccadilly circus or the washington monument to single out arab tourists to gang rape

      • @ Mikkel, you might not see people in Piccadilly circus, but you do see gangs of blacks and whites who are non muslims, in brixton, hackney, McDonalds, Croydon gang raping girls

      • Well, I am not in Brighton, but a quick check learned me that these gangs are predominatly black (muslim or not) and eastern european. Recent figures about rape all over England published abt 2 weeks ago however speak of perpetrators predominantly pakistani and victims white girls, so yeah, I stand by what I say: I dont see gangs of white men raping arab tourists in piccadilly circus or Times Square

      • Marathon Man, there are plenty of reports of gang rape that occurs on college campuses in the US. Gay men are regularly attacked by gangs of straight men for no reason in the US and the UK. Women still do not feel safe walking alone at night in many inner cities and college campuses in the US. Mobs engage in violence and property damage after sporting matches in the US and the UK. And these are not archaic societies, so what is their excuse? Are they all secretly followers of islam, too? Stop posting here, your stupidity is showing.

  470. Hello,
    I’m Armia, I’m an Egyptian artist and i really feel every word of what you have said, i can say that i’m feeling ashamed since i read your story, i want to say that we are sorry but it’s not the right word here. i wanna say that not all Egyptians are like this but you were in a bad situation that says the contrary of this.. i wanna say that we have kind hearts and our families taught us how to treat our guest, i wanna say that there are more than 6000000 people here who are working in tourism and our concern is to put a smile on our guests faces but all this amount of millions is nothing beside what you’ve tried with these hundreds, I’m really ashamed that our beautiful Egypt became so ugly and cruel like this, i’m so ashamed that our ethics is going to the bottom.. I want to ask you to go over it even if it will be hard for you.. please forgive us not these people who did this but us the Egyptians who couldn’t help or save you… please be strong and don’t give up that we can be better.. please accept my apologize for this stupidity of these sick people they are nasty and have no human side in there selves… please be sure that next time you will come here make sure that you will not face such situation any more, we are gonna give our lives to protect you… I’m a man and i’m an artist and i really feel deeply sorry for you my dear.. we all owe you apologize… and if you are coming back again please let us know and i have a painting for you as a kind of apologize for what happened on our land… I don’t know what else to say because words is not helping to express what i’m feeling after reading your story here… please forgive us
    all love and peace for you our dear friend
    yours
    Armia

    • and one more thing to tell that in our Christianity we have a good phrases in the holly Bible that we always read and do it ” to make peace is the greatest power so as much as you can make peace with all people “

  471. For about 2 years our egyptian media has been picturing foreign people to us as evil spies whose countries can’t wait to invade us.. It is so silly and yet a LOT of people are believing this kind of crap.. So this is a small result of that brain washing.. You actually have been touched by an angel for getting out of there alive! ..
    Peace be upon you..

  472. hi Natasha
    i like to say iam so sorry for what happened to you , i read it with tears in my eyes because it reminds me of what all of us Egyptian girls feel in the streets every day now especially after the 25th revolution , i hate to admit it but its a constant fight for a girl like me ( a christian Egyptian girl ) to walk the streets , i have to be on alert every second and never let my guard down , its very hard when you have to live every minute expecting to get attacked and harassed either verbally or physically for just being a girl and for not wearing hejab and being christian
    i know its great bravery of you to handle the situation the way you did and i pray to God that you heal soon but PLEASE if you ever come to Egypt again please be very careful and i wish you luck for you documentary waiting to see it soon , thank you for being brave enough to tell your story and try to help us Arabic women
    M M M

    • Finally a sensible reply from someone in egypt, who describes how it really is, rather than the ubiquitous ‘this is not egypt, this is not islam’ quotes. Kudo’s for you. Natasha had a choice going where she went and going back or not. You dont

    • Keep up the fight, Mary! I deeply hope that you and those like you can maintain your rights and freedoms under the Muslim Brotherhood. How I wish the West would allow women under regimes such as this and the Taliban to automatically be eligible for refugee status.

  473. Natasha , really we are very sorry about what had happened to you but tahrir square is not all Egypt .
    In Egypt there is a lot of good people

    you are welcome any time at Egypt , also at my home with my wife
    01001180787 this is my no. don’t hesitate to call me any time

  474. I am really sorry you had to go through it. I have had my house broken into 10 months ago and I got raped by a man police will never get to, so I can relate to some feelings you have described. It is okay not to want to be touched for some time. The closest people to you may seem awkward or even distant at first, but most of that happens because they don’t really know how to react to it. I spent months sleeping with the TV on, and that is also fine. I have also felt that the man who hurt me could be anywhere, looking at me and recalling that night, and it was really unfair that I could never know who he was. Just like the man who hurt me, those who have hurt you will remain anonymous, and it just seems wrong to me.
    The doctors and nurses may not be the most idiotic people about this whole situation: many will come close to tell you stories of other people who “have had it worse than you have and keep on living” and, at least to me, that feels heartless. But they will do so and tell you to just get on with your life and stop acting weird.
    I hope you do’t get any panic or anxiety crisis. I hope your family hangs in there ad stays there for you. I hope you can sleep well, trsut people and be around them with no problems. And I also hope that you can carry o with your project and help bring life to the cruelty going on against women everywhere.
    Brazilian greetings.

  475. i am sorry for what had happened here in Egypt , i know that isn’t enough and i am ready to work with you on this case

  476. Sorry Natasha.. this is not Egypt, we used to know!!
    forgive us! we are sorry and awfully ashamed..
    Guys actually what had happen to Natash, could be done to Egyptian veiled women, it’s ignorance and dirty suppressed minds.
    maybe we Egyptian Women we know the language of these animals we can defend ourselves.. and yes I feel afraid to go alone to any crowded places.
    It’s not Egypt it’s a black Egypt.. hope we can clean our country.. help us tell your governess not to help “The brotherhood” I can’t blame all on them.. but yes they have a big share, for a long time, in building this ideas of covered vs. uncovered woman.. they are racists.

  477. I am Egyptian …. I can not explain any word on the show unfortunately I was hoping that the end of this visit to be the end of my happy and not miserable like we are very sorry 😥

  478. Really sorry about what those Egyptian men did to you Natasha, and what they do to women in general. Hope you someday completely heal from this. Really hope that one day, soon, the oppression and abuse of women the world over will end. May the Lord bless you. Peace be with you.

  479. Sorry to Nat, but does you know you could be a bait of conspiracy to show cruelty of protesters of Tahirir. Which are all pro-president and pro-islamist..just a thought.

    • Faiz. Are u kidding me. It;s this sort of crazy logic that keeps the middle east in the dark ages. These men were animals…no conspiracy..just animals. This mindset is sadly pretty common in the middle east. Women mean nothing there. Archaic civilization!

      • This happens far to often to be a one-off. An American journalist had the same experience a few months ago. Any western woman who has spent time in Morocco, Egypt, Algeria etc without an armed bodyguard has been verbally and mostly likely physically attacked. The response of doctors and hospitals shows how institutionalised these ideas are. And with the new regime things will get much worse.

  480. Dear Natasha , I really can’t describe how I feel as being Egyptian & knowing we did this .
    All what I can do is apologize from my heart though I know that my apology won’t suffice ur humanity & help in recovering it but this is all what I have to offer ,
    Sexual harassment is growing in a very rapid rate in Egypt that Egypt is in 3rd place in sexual harassment around the whole world ,
    It wasn’t an act of patriotism , it was pure assault so actually I admit it poverty and depression causes such effects but even though , that’s not an excuse for what happened , after reading that article we totally deserve to be described as barbarians …..
    As I said earlier all what I have to offer is my apology though knowing it won’t help at all.
    anyway u r welcome anytime in Egypt we are really full of hospitality ..

    • Natasha , really we are very sorry about what had happened to you but tahrir square is not all Egypt .
      In Egypt there is a lot of good people

      you are welcome any time at Egypt , also at my home with my wife
      01001180787 this is my no. don’t hesitate to call me any time

  481. we are very sorry Sarah, Sorry to hear that many Egyptians live in a male society, I know it’s a difficult experience. Here in Egypt there is no importance to women only for sex. I hope your work to be completed
    God protect you

  482. although being proud of being Egyptian, but at the same time I feel ashamed of being Egyptian because of what I read now and what I see always.
    no doubts that there’s no excuse for doing such brutal and disgusting thing
    I am sorry for every woman has faced this situation ” Egyptians & Foreigners “

  483. hey natasha first i wanna say sorry for what happened to you i know how it hurts believe me i do iam an egyptian girl and please don’t return back to egypt before one or two years from now , everything is bad right here i really say that just because i don’t wanna you to feel this pain again the conditions here is not stable yet! security in not self-sustaining !
    please don’t be sad believe me this is not the egyptian people anymore !!

    • The new regime will make things worse and worse. If I was a woman I’d be leaving the country while it was still possible.

  484. All what Muslims cares about in your case is the reputation of Islam and Muslims, this is why the women said “this is not Islam” and “this is not egypt” and this is why a lot of Muslims here telling they hate what happened…

    • And all you seem to care about is making people look bad. So here’s some guys who apologize and feel sorry, show compassion, and all you got to offer is hate. It’s just ridiculous and frankly you should be ashamed using a post like this for your opinion. Please wikipede what respect means.

  485. I’m so sorry for not being there to protect you as a citizen
    I’m so sorry that you suffered at my country
    please if there is any thing i can do for you don’t hesitant to ask

  486. You are dealing with hypocrites,not with Muslims.This hypocrites(So called muslims) are the biggest enemy of Islam.
    The Qur’an says:
    “Among human beings are those who say ‘We believe in Allah and the Last day;’ but they are not among the Momins.” (2:8)
    Those born in Muslim families cannot claim to be Momins unless Iman has entered their hearts.The Prophet of Islam (s), in one of his treasured speeches, introduced the hypocrites as Islam’s most dangerous enemy. “I warn you about the hypocrites. They are misguided and they misguide as well. They have appeared in society in different colors and with different faces. Their speech is eloquent, profitable and is even a cure for pain. But their actions are like incurable diseases.”
    Quran says that Holy Prophet (PBUH) will complain to Allah:
    “And the Prophet (PBUH) will say: “O my Lord! Truly my people took the Quran for just foolish nonsense (i.e., they left the message of the Quran).” (25:30)
    “What is the benefit if you claim with your tongue in oneness of God? You have made your emotion an idol and taken it as your god.” Iqbal a Philosopher.
    How many of these hypocrites are willing to go deep down in their hearts and honestly admit that they follow their emotions more often than they follow Allah (i.e. Book of Allah)? Allah demands total and complete surrender of their wills:
    “O you who believe! Enter in Islam completely.” (2:208) Holy Quran
    Therefore, the problems which these hypocrites are facing today are the outward symptoms of the root cause, i.e., the internal friction in their hearts between obedience to Allah and obedience to their own emotions and egos. And it is this internal conflict that is referred to as the disease of the heart by the Qur’an.
    Therefore, as long as these Muslims keep compromising the TRUTH contained in the Quran, there is no hope for a cure of their collective mental, psychological, and emotional ills.

    How to Define a True Muslim!

    A true Muslim is God-fearing. He fears none but Almighty Allah. The fear of God guides him and helps him stay away from evils and empowers him to resist satanic temptations. He holds the commandments of his Lord most dear to him and obediently fulfills them with great pleasure. He performs five times prayers regularly and punctually with immense pleasure and proper concentration.

    A true Muslim takes every care not to neglect the rights of people. The rights of people are equally important for him. He tries his best not to hurt anyone and do full justice with everyone who comes into his contact. He is polite, courteous, kind, generous, forgiving and honest in his attitude towards the people he meets in his day-to-day life. Once he promises, he never breaks it or back out of it. He takes utmost care to fulfill all his commitments with people. A true Muslim is indeed a man of words.

    Islam connotes Peace. It is indeed a religion of peace. Its true followers are all peace-loving people. A true Muslims hates violence and extremism.

    A heart of a good and true Muslim is free from hatred, bias, prejudice, rancor, grudge and ill-will. He loves all irrespective of his caste, color, creed or religion. He is not narrow-minded. He wants love and peace to rule supreme in the entire world. He believes in equality, brotherhood, unity and love for all.

    To conclude, a good Muslim always seeks salvation from His God. The worldly failures or success is immaterial for him. He aims at ultimate success— to win the pleasure of Allah

    Stop dealing with this hypocrites or else be ready to repent.Fact is no Islamic country is truly Islamic and today’s most of the Muslims are nothing but Hypocrites.

    • Dude, you’re kind of missing the point on this one. This woman was subjugated to the worst possible thing imaginable and all you can do is talk about and defend islam? Perhaps a “I’m so sorry for you” is in order at some point in your speech.

      • Sorry for what? Is he responsible? Are you crazy? You are the one missing the point!

      • @ contractor:
        saying you feel sorry for someone does not mean you are confessing guilt to the deed. It is just an expression of empathy. U r missng the point yrself

      • Yes i’m defending Islam because the incident occurs in a Islamic country.Just like any believing Christian will defend Christianity whenever the incident of Jews Holocaust in Germany will be remembered.Hitler was a believing christian,who murdered innocent Jews.So does it means all the Christians are murderer,rapist,evil.No! not at all,There is Good and Bad in every society,every religion,And it is a duty of faithful to show the world that the good people are good and bad people are bad,That’s what i did.All the Hypocrites commits the crimes and the faithful are left to defend their faith .
        And indeed it is very sad to know what she went through.I feel sorry for her.
        The people who have committed this crime must be punish severely.

    • Most of the countries where women are oppressed are Muslim: Egypt, Afghanistan, Saudi Arabia, etc. I think there are many problems inherent in Islam. “Islam” means “submission”, and women suffer from this terribly.
      Please stop writing here about true Islam, and go criticize the Muslim world.

      • Islamic countries are full of hypocrties muslims!
        Muslim man duty is to protect women,not to harm her,not to hurt her.But as i told before if you are dealing with hypocrites you cannot expect from them any goodness and kindness.They may appear as a muslim in front of you but in fact they submit to their emotions,ego and bad desires rather then to God.Please stop writing here about true Islam-Remember the single underlying cause of prejudice is ignorance.I hope the educated people will behave differently.Sorry if my words hurts anybody.

    • WELL SAID!!!!
      I wish I could love and favourite this a million times!
      Pity though-you’l still find hateful and ignorant people that fail to comprehend this point!

  487. Dear Sarah,
    I am Remon from Egypt, I am really so sorry to read this horrible accident which happened to you, hope you could really forgive us as egyptian ppl for what happened to you, I know it’s not an easy thing to overcome, but i pray to God to heal you from inside, and hope also you could forgive those ppl who did that for you, as you’ll not gain anything but bitterness if you didn’t forgive them. You are such a great n brave woman. Thank you for coming Egypt, n hope we could see you again in Cairo , you are most welcome at anytime and please let me know if i can help by anyway. God bless you so much and be with you always dear Sarah!

    Sincerely,
    Remon Zarief

  488. i can`t say anything i know that any apology can make u happy but i must say to u sorry for that and u r welcome any time in Egypt u know Egypt had bad time hope it end soon

  489. in the name of the remain honourd egyptians ……….. i can`t say how much i feel sry for u … we lost our safety , ,, we coudn`t make u feel it … wish one day u will recurse from ur hurts we caus for u ….. one day egypt will be homourd to welcome u again natasha… but now we don`t deserve your presence …
    pray for us … i pray for ur pain …
    god heals u ..

  490. no words can discripe what i`m feeling right now .. shame on us
    truly very sorry 4 u

    I am Egyptian
    and I am so sorry
    Believe me, many of us were ready to protect you, even if this cost him his life and whom I

    I’m sorry

  491. [i] I have so much to say, and I will say it, in time.[/i]
    I hope you do. Don’t let fear overcome you.

    I also hope you don’t read or don’t get bothered with all the harsh comments around.

    Cheers

  492. I do not know what to write cause the right words are missing totaly. What a horrible, horrible experience. At this moment I can only wish you all the best and hope that you will find a way to deal with this. I even don’t know how to call it what happened to you. I feel so sorry. First and foremost for you but also a bit for the egyptian society, which is in such a devastating condition that something like this could happen in the bright light of day under the eyes of so many people. I’m missing the right words…

  493. Those people who said, “This is not Egypt” are delusional. Of course this is what Egypt– or any country taken over by a mob– has allowed itself to become.

    The lesson of our day is simple– democracy is a disaster. Anything short of a constitutional republic, with guarantees for minority rights, will never succeed.

    I love Egypt, having traveled there a number of times. But it saddens me how a dreamy euphoria has overtaken common sense.

    I hope you are well, and hope some day to see your documentary.

    • Democracy works if the broad values of the people in general are honorable. Islamic values are doomed. No matter the political system…the archaic male dominated values prominent in the middle east will ruin any political system. Violent regimes seem to be the best option as the populace in general behave like animals because their beliefs are so ignorant. Don’t blame a system…blame the people as a whole. Evolve please…it’s about time

      • In honesty, i think most arab countries need a Khadaffi, a Saddam Hussein or a Mubarak to keep the countries from mob rule.
        Look at Iraq. Anybody dare say that the country is better off after being ‘liberated’

  494. Natasha,
    I guess there cannot be enough comments on how brave you are, so here’s another one.
    I really hope you can overcome this tragedy and continue doing your amazing work.

    Love,
    Alexa

  495. “I reassured her that I knew that was the case, that I loved Egypt and its culture and people, and the innate peacefulness of moderate Islam.”

    HAHAHA. I can’t feel sorry for a moron such as yourself. You will probably get raped again lol.

    • First I wanna do the proper thing and say how sorry i am for you, Natasha. Second, you sir, are the complete moron. I have no excuses for Islam and all the savagery it brings with it werever it goes, but you are surely no better than the filth of islam.

      • I think that rape is terrible, but this woman has put herself in that position. Furthermore, from her comment, it is obvious that she will continue to make the same mistake.

        I’m sorry but I can’t feel pity for such an idiot. Everyone knows that muslims rape, its a part of their religion. She has only herself to blame for this situation.

      • Show some respect, you come off as a morally retarded person with your laughing and “lol” comment. As somebody who is completely uncapable of empathy, thus not much better than the scum that did this to Natasha. Rape is not something to laugh about in a conversation with somebody who has just been sexually assaulted!

        Yes, she acted somewhat reckless, she admitted as much in her text, so i can agree with you about that, but to justify what happened because of that is just so low. There are some people in this that deserve to be raped and that is the perpetrators, not Natasha. She is completely devoid of responsibility for what happened and should thus not be blamed.

      • Egypt is an islamic country, they might as well have signs everywhere saying that foreign girls will be raped if they go there. I refuse to show respect for someone like Natasha. She has made it clear that she supports this abrahamic filth. These retards like her who go around constantly preaching about islam being the beautiful religion of peace are responsible for importing the mohomadian animals to Europe.


        What about all the women who are raped because these shits have been brought to Europe? I’m afraid for their well being and their future. As for Natasha, she is a fucking dhimmi and I don’t give a shit what happens to the muslim loving bitch. Of course I don’t show empathy to an enemy who wants me dead.

  496. you are really Brave !! But your article impressed and saddened me 😦
    Welcome To Egypt again ..
    Hello from an Egyptian young man 🙂

  497. Truly Sorry Natasha .. Don`t know what 2 say .. From Egypt and i can`t discripe what im feeling right now!
    like a volcano inside me .. no words would b enough to say sorry 4 u 😦
    Pray 4 u to pass these day

  498. Dear Natasha,
    The only reason to go to a muslim country is to make war upon them. If they do not renounce their genocidal ideologies – what women, gays etc.. suffer under Sharia law – the only solution is to contain them indefinately and should they show aggression, eradicate them.

    • Stefan, I couldn´t agree more.

      I am an arab woman. If there is something I learned while living in and extensively travelling the arab world, it is how the arab men cannot contain their pack animal impulses. At best they are entertaining drama queens, at their worst raging hyena packs, like in this case.

      I was also sceptical to the so called arab spring. You want freedom? Freedom for whom? I know it is not for us women. Furthermore, you can´t handle freedom. You simply would not know what it means. I was proven right. When you vote, the only candidates you bring forward are soldiers and religious nut cases.

      WIthout your dictators and police you lose that last bastion of impulse control and turn into howling rapist degenerate mobs.

      Shame on the arab man. You are indeed the scum of the earth.

      • Shaia

        I enjoyed reading your post. You seem to have really seen the situation for what it is. No political system will work if those men don’t evolve. I just fear there is no way to move them into the current century with their beliefs.

        I worry for you women. The women of the middle east seem so much smarter and aware of the problems of an evil male populace that hides behind religion.

        good luck….

  499. I am so sorry Natasha, I am just apologizing really out of respect to your courage, being Egyptian, I know exactly how is it here, faced rape trials, harassed daily in the streets, work, public transportations, even from my friends .. so I really and deeply know how is it.

    Yet, I am so proud of you, so proud of your support and presistence, we have been launching plenty of campaigns, but we only focused of defnding onself, but, here, reading what happened, all things I have done and wrote about, seems useless when they are “hundreds” .. I really wish for this to end, and would always do my best to stop those kind of people ..

    I translated your article into Arabic .. all respect!

  500. Pingback: Order in the Food Court Edition of WoW |

  501. Pingback: Egípto: Una nueva periodista blanca y britanica violada en la la plaza Tahrir, cuando cubría una nota sobre la democracia islamica « NUEVA EUROPA- Nueva Eurabia

  502. I am so very sorry for you Natasha. I will pray for emotional healing for you. What happened to you was shameful and wrong. There is no excuse for this type of behavior. Religion is supposed to unite people, not divide. I pray that each of those men suffers personally for participating in a shameful act. Take good care and be blessed.

  503. I am a young blonde female who has spent a lot of time in Middle Eastern countries alone. I have to say that it has not been my experience that I have ever been harassed by Arabic men in any way shape or form. In fact my experience has been the opposite…. the people have been so warm and friendly and the men totally respectful. Some people are quick to blame Islam as a violent religion but I think in this situation it was more about mob mentality just like in the US after Hurricane Katrina.

    http://source.southuniversity.edu/examining-the-mob-mentality-31395.aspx

    Natasha, lots of love to you and I hope you recover quickly.

    • Ive lived in three middle eastern countries as a european man and only seen kind and loving people. The ones commenting here blaming all arabs and their religion have a hidden zionist agenda!

      • And you are a male, so of course you couldn’t be bothered about the situation of women in the arab world. Everything is just fuckin dandy in the arab world, of course. For men.

        Also, you are the one calling jews scum. That means your opionion doesn’t count.

    • there still some honest women saying the truth not like others that keep talking and they dont know what they are talking about thank you so much that u said the truth

  504. You are a brave woman for telling your story, but please stay away, I am a woman just like you and I really care about you, I am an 18 year old girl and I am stuck in a muslim country, stuck in a muslim family, I once thought that I am strong enough to change the world but I guess I am not, I thought I can say NO to my father, I believed in “my body my choice”, I thought that I can live my life as I wish but again I was wrong… its not safe to come back to egypt again, at least not now, most of muslim women are brainwashed, you can do nothing to help them. We are trying our best here to make them aware of their bad situation, we are not too many, but we believe we can make a difference, we will keep fighting the damn religion. religions are invented by men for men to controle women… I wish you the best dear…

  505. Dear Natasha,
    i wish you much strength and support from your loved ones and people all over the globe to process this horrific experience and keep on fighting for women’s rights! The way in and speed with which you have told us your story has impressed me deeply and i (we all, i assume) admire your determination to overcome this offence, get back in control and finish your documentary, which i hope to see in due time.
    Bon courage with warm greetings from Amsterdam, NL
    Mr. Joost Huijs

  506. Dear friend
    I am so terribly sorry that you had to go through this awful, horrible experience, and I commend you for being determined to not stay the victim. I was molested twice as a child, the second time by someone I trusted, someone in religious authority. An assault like that is a terrible thing and the memory can rear up unexpectedly and tear a new hole in your heart. I remember being so angry for a long time, lashing out at loved ones and God. As cliched as it might sound, though, time heals. I hope you will always know in your heart, in your darkest moments, that you are not alone. You are precious and worthwhile, and you can get through this. I will be praying for you.

  507. How terrible! I was abused myself in a hotelroom by the manager of the hotel I stayed in. I was only 15 years old, but they don’t seem to care. Police handled it pretty good, they said he was fired and arrested. I couldn’t handle Egyptian men anymore, but I went back a year ago to another city and there people were great. So let’s hope that the bastards will be punished so that this doesn’t happen again! As you say, there are also good egyptian men.

  508. Pingback: Egyptians Celebrate Muslim Brotherhood Victory By Raping Another Journalist | Wizbang

  509. Natasha I was very impressed, I translated your post, please feel free to Publlish it, post it so that your experience will be broadly circulated, we DO need awareness.

    ناتاشا سميث

    “أرجوك إلهي. فلتوقف هذا..”

    نشر 26 يونيو
    لقد أرغمت على ترك القاهرة قبل الأوان، بعد إعتداء جنسي، وجسدي جسيم في ميدان التحرير.
    كان الجو العام مبهجاً، مثيراً وسعيداً بينما كنت أتمشى على جسر قصر النيل، في صحبة رجلين لدواعي الأمان. كان يومي فظيعاً، لمشاكل في علاقاتي الشخصية، لذلك كنت سعيدة أن أكون في ذلك الجو الاحتفالي الرائع في نهاية ذلك اليوم، وكذلك أن أحصل على صور فوتوغرافية مدهشة. ابتسمت السيدات، والأطفال، والآباء، ولوح الجميع بأياديهم وهم يطلقون الكلمة الشهيرة: “مرحباً بك في مصر، مرحباً” وأطلقت ليلتها الألعاب النارية احتفاءً. كانت تجربة مؤثرة وآسرة.
    وفي اللحظة التي أدركت فيها أنني وصلت لنهاية الجسر، لاحظت أن كثافة الجماهير قد زادت، وقررت من فوري أن أنعطف بعيداً عن ميدان التحرير كي أتجنبه. وحاولت بصحبة أصدقائي الخروج. حاولت أن أضع كاميرتي الخاصة في حقيبة الظهر.
    وفي لحظة خاطفة، تغير كل شئ. كان هناك رجال يتتبعونني لفترة، ولكن فجأة تزحزح الزحام، ووجدت نفسي أستدرج من بين الرجلين الذين كانا بصحبتي، بعنف وعداء متصاعد. صرخت. كنت أرى ما يحدث، وكنت أرى أنني عاجزة عن أن أوقفه. ولم أصدق أنني بصدد الوقوع في موقف كهذا.
    لقد حاول الصديق الذي برفقتي أن يمسك بي قدر استطاعته. ولكن مئات من الرجال كانوا ينتزعونني منه إلى المجهول، وكانوا يضربونني ويصرخون. ثم رفعوني على منصة واضطررت للإنحناء، وقررت أن أحمي الكاميرا بكل ما أوتيت من قوة، ولكن ذلك كان دون جدوى. انتزعوا الكاميرا. وانتزعوا حقيبة ظهري، وكانت الضوضاء عالية لدرجة أنني لم أحس بذلك. وتعثر الغوغاء من على المنصة، والتوى كاحلي. ثم بدأ الرجال في تمزيق ملابسي حتى أصبحت عارية. وبذلك استعرت رغبتهم النهمة في إيذائي. أولئك الرجال، مئات الرجال، تحولوا في تلك اللحظة من رجال إلى حيوانات.
    أمسك مئات الرجال بأطرافي وتقاذفوني. ثم أمسكوا بصدري وخدشوني وأدخلوا أصابعهم داخلي بكل شكل ممكن. رجال كثيرون، وكل ما كنت أتمكن من رؤيته هي وجوه شبقة، عدد أكبر وأكبر من الوجوه التي تهيني وتحتقرني وتسبني، وكأنني قطعة من لحم طازج ألقيت لأسود جائعة.
    صرخت: “سلام! سلام! الله! الله!”. في حالتي اليائسة لم أجد أمامي سوى أن أصرخ أيضاً: “مع السلامة!” بالعربية وهي تقريباً أسوأ ما يمكن أن تقوله لحشد من الرجال يودون تحطيمك. لعلي أيضاً صرخت وقتها: “مع السلامة أيها العالم، ها أنا أسقط!”
    كانت هناك قلة من الرجال، إثنان في البداية، حاولوا الدفاع عني، وأرشدوني إلى خيمة. كانت الخيمة مهدومة، وكانت محتوياتها متناثرة الشظايا على الأرض. كنت حافية لأنهم سرقوا حذائي الجديد الجميل. ثم ألقى بي الحشد مرة أخرى، وكان أحداً ما يعتدي علي في كل لحظة. كانوا يجرونني عارية على الأرض القذرة. كان الرجال يشدون شعري الأصفر – دليل هويتي الأجنبية.
    حاول الرجال الذين يدافعون عني أن يرشدونني إلى خيمة أخرى. كنت قادرة على أن أزحف على الأرض، وألقيت ظهري إلى ظهر أحد المقاعد، وأحصيت الغوغاء الذين يلتفون فوقي. ومع أن قليل من الرجال حاولوا تكوين درع بشري من حولي، وعرضوا علي كل أنواع الخرق كي أغطي جسدي الملئ بالكدمات، كان الرجال الآخرون قادرين على أن يلمسونني، كان عددهم كبيراً.
    أحسست للحظة بهدوء غريب. تفهمت أنني أتحول في هذه اللحظة إلى حالة ذهنية منفصلة. تابعت الأسنان الحادة والأعين المتنمرة. وبدأت الخيمة في الانهيار، وأصبحت ملتحفة بقطعة قماش كبيرة. كنت أصارع كي أتمكن من التنفس. أحدهم انتزع قائماً من قوائم الخيمة وحاول أن يضربني به.
    وهنا قلت لنفسي بصوت عال مرات ومرات: “أرجوك إلهي، أوقف هذا…أرجوك إلهي أوقف هذا”
    لست متدينة. ولكن في حالات اليأس، نحس أننا بحاجة إلى أن نبتهل لقوة مطلقة لتنقذنا. إنها طبيعة بشرية. فالحاجة إلى الأمان والحب هي ما يدفع الكثيرين إلى الدين في المقام الأول.
    دخلت سيارة إسعاف إلى الحشد. وفتحت أبوابها، وغزتها عشرات من الرجال ثم أغلقت بابها وهرعت من المكان. بدأت في التفكير: “أعتقد أنها النهاية. لعلها الطريقة التي سأرحل بها، عن هذا العالم. لقد كانت حياتي جيدة. بصرف النظر عما إذا كنت سأعيش أو سأموت، سوف ينتهي ذلك الأمر قريباً. قد يكون ما يحدث عقاباً لما سببته من ألم عاطفي للآخرين من خلال بعض الأخطاء الغبية وسوء التقدير مؤخراً. أتمنى أن أموت قبل أن يغتصبونني.”
    نظرت لأعلى فرأيت امرأتين ترتديان النقاب المنتشر في أنحاء كثيرة. نظروا إلى ببلادة، ثم نظروا في اتجاه آخر. بعد 5-10 دقائق، استطاع صديقي أن يقنع بعضاً ممن كانوا في الخيمة الطبية كي يصنعوا ممراً بين الزحام يمكنهم من خلاله أن ينقلونني للخيمة. وأثناء الانتقال تم أيضاً نهشي واقتحامي. وصلت إلى الخيمة ورأيت صديقي كالوم. أحاطتني النساء المسلمات وحاولن بكل حمية أن يغطين جسدي العاري. وقعت على الأرض، وفقدت الوعي بشكل مؤقت على ما يبدو.
    قالت النساء لي أن الهجوم علي كان بسبب إشاعات من قبل البلطجية أنني جاسوسة أجنبية، بعد حملة قومية تحذر من خطر الأجانب. ولكن إذا كان ذلك هو الدافع، فقد تم استغلاله كغطاء، كعذر للتحرش والتعدي على فتاة أجنبية شقراء.
    كان الرجال في الخارج لا يزالون عطشى للدماء، ففريستهم انتزعت من بين أيديهم بوحشية. حاولوا اقتحام الخيمة، لذلك كان علي أن أنبطح وأختبأ. حاولوا الهجوم على الخيمة، وأقام من بداخل الخيمة المقاعد كحواجز. كانوا يريدون دمي.
    كانت النساء تخبرني وتصرخ: “هذه ليست مصر، هذا ليس الإسلام! أرجوكي أرجوكي لا تظني أن تلك هي مصر” أكدت لهم أنني أعلم ذلك، وأنني أحب مصر وثقافتها وشعبها، وسماحة ووسطية الإسلام. كانت مذهولة هي الأخرى، ولكنني لست شخصاً قلبه أسود، وأعلم أن ذلك العمل الوحشي لا يمثل المكان الذي أعرفه وأحبه. بعد جدل حامي الوطيس، قررنا أن نخرج فرادى أنا وكالوم حتى لا نجذب الاهتمام. تخفيت في برقع وملابس رجالي واضطررت أن أمسك بيد مصري لا أعرفه سيصطنع أنه زوجي. كنت مرعوبة، ولكنني رأيت أنها الطريقة الوحيدة، لذلك وثقت فيه.
    جذبني وسط الزحام إلى المخرج الخلفي للخيمة، وقال لي: “لا تبكي، لا تبكي..حاولي أن تبدي طبيعية”
    كنت حافية، ونظارتي مكسورة، وجسدي منغمس في التراب والطين. ولكن احتياط الطاقة الداخلي كان كافياً لكي أتماسك وألا أبكي، كنت أفكر داخلي: “ابقي هادئة، واستمري” كانت الملابس واسعة وكانت تسقط من لعى خصري.
    كنت أظن أنهم يرشدونني إلى سيارة إسعاف، أو إلى مستشفى. جلس الرجل إلى جانبي على قارعة الطريق، وكان لا يزال يأمرني بعدم البكاء. ثم جاء صديقه بصحبة كالوم. شرحوا لنا أنهم لا يستطيعون أخذنا إلى المستشفى حيث أنه من الممكن أن يقبض عليهم لو شوهدنا معهم. وعرض أحد الرجال: “هل تحبون أن نذهب إلى ماكدونالدز؟ أتريدون بعض الطعام؟” رفضت هذا العرض السخي لقضاء السهرة. لم يكن مزاجي في تلك اللحظة يسمح بوجبة “بيج ماك”.
    ذهبت أنا وكالوم إلى طريقنا. وأوقفنا تاكسي. وبينما وصلنا إلى مستشفى حكومي في وسط البلد، حاولنا أن نشرح الموقف. كان الناس ينظرون إلينا ببلادة، ويتناوبون في الطرقات، ثم يستديرون، ويخبروننا أن نذهب إلى مستشفى آخر. لم يكن أحد يريد أن يقبلنا.
    عند الوصول كان السؤال المعتاد الذي يوجه إلي على إنفراد: “هل أنت حامل؟ متزوجة؟ عذراء؟” وفي العادة كانت الإجابة بلا لا ترضيهم.
    أخرجوننا وكالوم لنجلس في الخارج. لقد رفضوا أن يفحصونني أو يعالجوني. قررت نهاية أن افحص الخسائر بنفسي. ذهبت إلى دورة المياه، ولم أصدق ما رأته عيناي. كنت قذرة، مجروحة، وشعري يشبه المتشردين، واتسعت عيناي من الذهول والصدمة.
    لساعتين أو ثلاث، تغير الناس ومروا علينا. وحاول اثنان منهما الاتصال بالسفارة. وحاول كالوم في كل مرحلة أن يسرع وتيرة الأحداث قدر إستطاعته، وحاول الحديث مع الجميع. فقد كان إنقاذي من قبل الخيمة الطبية بفضل مجهوداته. أي أنه أنقذ حياتي.
    بشكل ما انتهى الوضع على أن السفارة ظنت أننا في قسم الشرطة، والعاملين في المستشفى لم يعد يعرف إذا ما كنا غادرنا المستشفى إلى قسم الشرطة أم لا، بينما يظن قسم الشرطة أننا في مكان لا يعلمه سوى الله.
    أجلسوني في غرفة مليئة بالرجال. أحدهم كان يلتقط صوراً فوتوغرافية لي على ما يبدو. لم أكن متأكدة من السبب، ولم أكن في تلك اللحظة في أبهى حالاتي بطبيعة الحال. كانت نبضات قلبي تتسارع.
    مرة أخرى كانت مكالمات كالوم هي السبب، كان علينا أن نستخدم تليفونات أشخاص آخرين، فقد سرقت تليفوناتنا. وأخيراً توصلنا لسيدة من السفارة. تم بعدها اصطحابي لمستشفى خاص، وكان السؤال الأول الذي سأله الطبيب لي: “هل أنت متزوجة؟” وهو بالتأكيد السؤال الأهم الذي يجب على الطبيب أن يسأله لضحية الاعتداء الجنسي الجماعي.
    قام الطبيب بمصاحبة ممرضة كانت تغطيني في خمول بفحص الإصابات، ودار حولي قائلاً أنه بسبب عدم وجود أي نزيف داخلي، فليس هناك ما يستطيعون عمله. وكان ذلك هو الهدف الأساسي من تلك الرحلة الطويلة.
    بعد ذلك أخذني أصدقائي ووضعوني في الفراش. لم أرغب في أن أخبر عائلتي على الفور، لأنني كنت أعلم أن الخبر سوف يدمرهم.
    بالأمس، تم فحصي بشكل سليم، وبدأت في ترتيب أوراقي، وضيعت وقتاً طائلاً في تحرير محضر بالشرطة. كان الناس المصاحبين لي يذرفون الدموع، ولكن لم تكن لدي الرغبة في البكاء. كان الناس يخبرونني: “كم أنت شجاعة”، ولكنني كنت أحس أن كل ما هنالك أنني أحاول التأقلم مع الوضع الجديد. لعلني سأفهم بعد بضعة أيام. لا أعلم.
    بعض الأشياء التي حدثت بالأمس جعلتني أدرك التأثير الذي تركته تلك الحادثة علي. أثناء الفحص الذي كانت تقوم به إمرأة، كنت أبكي وأرتجف. لأن لمسة أي شخص كانت تعيد في لحظة كل بشاعة الحادثة الوحشية.
    مؤخراً لم أعد أستطيع التواجد بين أي مجموعات من الرجال المصريين. وحينما يهبط الليل، أحس بالفزع، ولا أستطيع أن أنظر لأي رجل. كنت أقول لكالوم طوال اليوم بينما كنا نطوف بالسيارة في القاهرة، أنني لا أستطيع أن أمنع نفسي في التفكير أن ضمن كل الناس الذين رأيناهم اليوم أثناء جولتنا هناك واحد منهم على الأقل كان موجوداً في تلك الليلة المشئومة… واحد فقط
    إنني مصرة على استكمال الفيلم الوثائقي بشكل من الأشكال. لم يعد لدي معدات ولا حتى مادة فيلمية، أحس بالتوتر لعدم إمكاني الحصول على مبلغ التأمين لتغطية كل المعدات التي سرقت مني، وإمكانية ألا تكون هناك موارد لاستكمال الفيلم. ولكنني سأصل. لابد أن أجد غطاء فضياً لتلك التجربة. لابد من نشر الوعي، إنه من واجبنا أن نفعل ذلك. لابد علي أن أفعل ذلك. لن أرغم على الرضوخ. سوف أتخطى كل هذا وسوف أعود أقوى وأحكم من البداية. سوف يمتلئ فيلمي الوثائقي بالرغبة في جعل الناس أكثر وعياً بأهمية تلك القضية، وأن تلك القضية ليست خبراً عابراً يتوقف عنده الناس برهة ثم ينسونه. إنها قضية حيوية ومستمرة، ولابد أن تتوقف. المرأة العربية – المرأة الغربية.. هناك العديد من الضحايا.
    إن كلي عزيمة في أن أعود لتلك البلد الرائعة والمدينة التي أحب، وأقابل الناس مرة أخرى. إنني مصرة على أن أتحدى الأنماط المقولبة والأفكار المسبقة التي يعتقد فيها الناس عن المرأة العربية في المملكة المتحدة والولايات المتحدة الأمريكية. وعندي الكثير مما أود أن أقوله، وسوف أقوله، في الوقت المناسب.
    لذا فرسالتي لك من يركب المخاطر، في المملكة المتحدة أو في العالم، كونوا حذرين، ولا تقعوا في الأخطاء نفسها، ولا تنجرفوا في حالات النشوة. لا تدعوا أي شئ يغطي على تقديركم للأمور. لقد خانني التركيز لأنني كنت منفعلة بالجو العام الرائع الذي منحني راحة من عناء يومي الصعب.
    لا تدعوا أنفسكم تقعون ضحايا. لا تدعوا الخبرة السيئة تحطم حياتكم وتقرر مستقبلكم. إن أسوأ الأشياء هو أنني منذ ليلتين كان لدي شعور بالعجز. لم يكن لدي أي قدرة على السيطرة، وكنت منتهكة. ولكني الآن أستطيع أن أمسك بزمام نفسي، وأعود لبناء ثقتي بنفسي، وأتعلم من خبرتي.
    ولا شيء، ولا أحد سوف يمنعني عن ذلك. وعندما أكون مستعدة سوف أنتهي من ذلك، فالحفل لابد وأن يستمر.
    أشكركم شكراً جزيلاً للقراءة

  510. I’m so sorry this happened to you – you are a strong person! It is hard sometimes to feel strong and independent after being violated. I understand, though luckily my experience was not so violent. Thank you SO MUCH for sharing this hard experience so that others may learn from it.

    • I expect nothing less than such a response from a non human which is even beyond the reach of the animal kingdom in his/her argument/

  511. dear sarah
    i’m so sad about what happend to youplease next time be so care full next time specially in egypet and the other arabic countries,in this countrie poeple are so poor and Deprived of many things necessary to life, which makes them more brutal and push them to do such heinous acts following,i’m moroccan living in belgium and i’m so sorry for this act

  512. Items such as this (yes, there is more than one, unfortunately) lead me to paraphrase Frank Zappa:

    I’m not a woman, but there’s times that I wish I could say I’m not a man.

  513. As an Egyptian middle aged female myself .. i truly respect you .. and what happened was disgraceful and revolting ! Im glad you do understand this isnt what the majority of Egyptian men are .. tragically we dont have strong enough laws to scare sex offenders .. but we’ll get there sometime soon i hope ..

    It’s weird though to read some of the comments .. I’ve been to a few western countries and heard of sexual harrasments/rape/kidnap and was warned against being in certain places by myself .. are muslims responsible for these crimes in these countries too ? The mental status of offenders regardless their religion/race is the same everywhere.. compare stories of sex crimes from different countries you’ll be amazed with the similarities ..

    Natasha .. Ill be waiting for your documentary.

      • That is absolute, pure and utter nonsense! :o() Step away from the drugs, dude…

      • In Oslo in Norway 100 % of the “outdoor” rapes were committed by foreign men, mostly from Pakistan and Middle East. That is a fact.

      • If you can’t provide us the stats (and you can’t), that’s BS. And hateful BS from a man at that. I have many friends who’ve been raped… mostly by their White family members and White exboyfriends and exhusbands in revenge.

      • @ Anna: That is BS. Here the truth:
        The Norway Ministry of Justice report on rapes in Oslo featured only five (5 !) rapes perpetrated by people not related or known to the victim. All of these were perpetrated by men of foreign (meaning: non-Norwegian) origin. The report did not feature their religion in any way. Two of the five (again: 5) were teenagers. Here:
        http://www.loonwatch.com/2011/12/gil-ronens-fabricated-statistics-about-oslo-rapists-being-all-muslim/
        The majority of rapes overall were perpetrated by White Norwegian men against women they already knew.

      • Andrew, that statement is fucking retarded. Most Muslims in the US are too scared to even confess their own religion. What a fuckwit of a comment.

    • I think it was last year, or maybe 2010, rape-statistics from Olso were published showing that 100% of all reported rapes were commited by forginers. I do agree with you though – I have a lot of muslim friends, and I know not all muslims behave like this. It is all about how you are thaught to treat women.

      • I don’t know if you understand Norwegian, but this police officer states that no ethnic norwegian man during this period has committed this kind of violent “surprise sex” in Oslo. All have been men from cultures with “an other view on women”.

        I read an article about women in Cairo, and 80 % said that they get sexually harassed (verbally and physicaly) everyday.

      • ANNA can you frigging COUNT or READ?!? Pretty please! Those were 5, yes FIVE, cases! And to be honest Christian men from Nigeria have a very different view on women in society too. As do many Hindu men. Or even Italians! All you know is that these FIVE (friggin FIVE!) men were non-Norwegian. It says everything about YOU and your hatred and nothing about Muslims that from “non-Norwegian” and “five”, you come to “hordes” and “Muslim”.
        Here AGAIN the truth:
        The Norway Ministry of Justice report on rapes in Oslo featured only five (5 !) rapes perpetrated by people not related or known to the victim. All of these were perpetrated by men of foreign (meaning: non-Norwegian) origin. The report did not feature their religion in any way. Two of the five (again: 5) were teenagers. Here:
        http://www.loonwatch.com/2011/12/gil-ronens-fabricated-statistics-about-oslo-rapists-being-all-muslim/
        The majority of rapes overall were perpetrated by White Norwegian men against women they already knew.

      • Take a deep breath, Kat. I have not mentioned “muslims” and “hordes”. And I appreciate that you don’t understand norwegian, but that does not make me a liar.
        All over the world the most frequent violence is domestic, but we in the Nordic countries have been exposed to an increasing violence from men with roots in Asia, North Africa and the Middle East. Sweden is world leeding in rapes – and the swedish men have not suddenlig transformed.

      • You did not address my point: That those were FIVE rapes. FIVE. And you decided to ignore that and single out all others. And yes, you did say Muslim: You said ‘Middle East and Pakistanis”. Unless you are talking about Zoroastrians, Jewish Israelis or Jewish Iranians or Christians from Palestine or Syria… Which I doubt you are. So stop being obtuse.
        Stop being obtuse and own up to your BS: FIVE is completely and utterly negligible.
        And Sweden is in no way “leading in rape”- that would be South Africa.

      • Actually, correction: The Democratic Republic of the Congo is leading in rapes. What you are mixing up is that Sweden has the highest REPORT rate of rapes IN THE EU. Meaning due to exceptionally good support systems and exceptionally little rape apologetics and victim shaming MORE women have the confidence to report it.
        In the UK e.g. which has 5.6 % of any form of sentence for reported rapes I would NEVER EVER report if I was raped myself. The chances that anything would happen to my rapist are negligible, but I still need to go through all that extra trauma.

  514. Ladies and Gentlemean, do not be deluded by the so-called “Arab Spring”. Once the imams and ayatollahs established that Western voting rituals, although meaningless, do not contradict Sharia, the Muslims in Afghanistan, Iraq, and the Arab-occupied territories of Israel went to the voting booths. In Afghanistan, the election was as meaningless as it used to be in the Soviet Union, where people were forced to cast their votes for the only candidate on the list. In Iraq, it brought to power people openly hostile to us and our goals, but that was inevitable since everyone in Iraq is hostile to us and our goals. In Israel, the Arabs cheerfully used the occasion to shamelessly demonstrate that they are not a “people”, but a terrorist organization.

    Nevertheless, we continue treating the nobody called Hamid Karzai as an ally. We continue pretending that the death of our soldiers in Iraq does something good to this country. And we are holding our breath waiting to see if Hamas will accepts Israel’s right to exist. Why isn’t Hamas worried whether Israel will accept its right to exist?

    These are not signs of our defeat. These are signs of our disintegration.

  515. Really when i read this words i feel more sadness for what happened for you before and i’m one of egyptian people i tell you sorry for that and i’m one of egyptian people i tell you sorry for that and egypt will be the second country for you same you feel before really any egyptian love egypt not love any poeple from world hate egypt and i need you Accept apology as Egyptian

  516. Dear Sarah,
    What you went through is utterly outraging in so many levels. I felt disgusted and shocked while reading about your assault. You are so brave for surviving and also for talking openly about it, allowing many people to be aware of this repugnant situation happening in Egypt. My thoughts are with you and I wish you the very best from now on, you deserve it.

  517. Natasha, remember Pope Benedict XIV recklessly quoted a dead Byzantine emperor Manuel II Palaiologos (1350-1425)?
    “Show me just what Muhammad brought that was new and there you will find things only evil and inhuman, such as his command to spread by the sword the faith he preached”.

    What should have been the appropriate response to the Pop?

    Should it have come from Tony Blair, who, in the wake of 7/7, announced how proud he was of the Islamic community of Great Britain; don’t we all deserve to finally learn exactly what he was so proud of?

    Should it have come from Jacques Chirac whose country, under the gentle, deeply enlightening influence of its ever growing population of Muslim settlers, has become even more sophisticatedly cultured than it used to be when the French still owned it?

    The appropriate response should have been very simple. It should have listed all those things that are unique to Islam; things that set it apart from Judaism and Christianity, but are neither evil, nor inhumane. And if Islam really is “just another religion”, then the list of those things, accumulated since the inception of that “Abrahamic faith” 14 centuries ago, must be long and widely known to both Muslims and us,the infidels. We would all look through the list of all good things that only Islam could have brought into the world, and rejoice at the marvelous achievements of our turbaned brothers and hermetically veiled sisters.

    The burning question must be answered: Why hasn’t anyone — I mean literally any one — come up with a list of at least some good things Islamic? Why has none of the 1.4 billion Muslims and none of the uncounted millions of their learned appeasers in the West offered us at least a tiny sample of something good and humane brought into the world by Mohammad and his followers in the course of the 14 centuries of incessant genocide that have elapsed since the inception of Islam?

    There can be only one answer: Because no such thing exists. During all the centuries of its existence, Islam has miserably failed to produce anything of value to humanity.

      • What was hateful and ignorant, Gala? Use your powers of logic and persuasion to refute what Infidel claims. Of course, you cannot, because Islam and Muslims haven’t contributed anything of value to the world in the last several hundred years. What they have contributed is violence, glory in ignorance, murder, genocide, and innumerable other crimes against humanity. *That* is the legacy of the pedophile Mohammed. *That* is the real Islam.

      • you guys are kidding me right?

        have you forgotten the two world wars that were fought by people who were not muslim where millions died. or the massacres in africa again at the hand of non-muslims while the free world stood by and did nothing because there is not oil in these countries. or how hundreds of thousands of blacks were left to die in New Orleans and the Superdome because their own government sees them as second class citizens.

        You western Hypocrites make me sick, it was the British, spanish, French, Portuguese empires that spread via the sword wiping out entire civilizations.

    • The Americans invented the Aeroplane
      The British invented the Jet Engine.
      The Muslims invented how to crash it into a building and kill 3000 people.

  518. Natasha you are incredibly brave.

    To everyone saying that it is a fact of life that women cannot have the freedoms enjoyed by men, remember that this has been said for CENTURIES yet we have fought for, and won, the rights to own property, to have an education, to vote, to have control over our bodies. The fight is not won. But it will NEVER be won by submitting to a life lived in fear and restricted by the rules of ‘common sense’ we’re told are for the best.

    The internet is a horrible place. The vast majority of the views written above would not be shared if those people did not have their anonymity, and in all likelihood the people sharing them have no real social interaction which is why they’re driven to spouting hate speech on the web.

    Please ignore those people, they represent nothing but a tiny, deranged, but vocal minority.

    Thank you for sharing your story.

    • Dear Laura,
      As long as plain physical power and man sexuality play a big role in human life (and I don’t see a change of this in foreseeable future), women either take this into consideration or they will suffer for their stupidity (and with them all people emotionally related to them). This is a plain fact, not a voice of a tiny minority.
      Trust me, if I could make this world safe for every single woman, I would do it immediately. However, I know it is not possible, and I kindly ask all women: please respect the status quo and STAY AWAY FROM OBVIOUS DANGER. If you don’t think about you, think about the people which love you

    • women have just as much rights to be and do anything they please within reason as men do.
      but as it stands islamic and other religions violate those rights as they would their targets.

      • You missed the point. Women have the same rights ordained by the universe as men. The right to die. That’s all humans really have. And yes, a blond woman in a skin tight dress should be able to walk down the streets anywhere she wants (not saying Natasha did this, just an extreme example). But if she does it might not end well. Just like I don’t go walking in the park at 3 am humming show tunes counting hundreds. You have the right, but reality also has to play a role in your decision making. She did not deserve this by any means, but as humans (man or woman) you have to make decisions to stay away from dangerous places. I vacation in Hawaii and not Somalia for a reason. If you’re a western woman, you probably shouldn’t be in Egypt at this time.

  519. When Natasha Smith posted this story yesterday on the horrific sexual assault she faced during the celebrations on the presidential election outcome in Tahrir, the social media world was shocked. Soon after however – as so often – not few started to openly discuss and doubt the credibility of this account and its author. Why?

    Read my new post that I dedicate to Natasha Smith
    Words & Swords:
    Denying sexual assault on women assaults them once more
    http://bit.ly/MUwiG4

    • True. The last part of the assault on a women is often commited by the community who refuses to believe in her. Truly sad that we couldn’t unite and condemn this violence, united.

      • Truly sad that none else has noticed and responded to this important comment. We in the west have something to learn about how to treat rape victims too, let’s not forget that (It bears pointing out that we are still infinitely better than Islamic culture, fortunately. You’ll get no cultural relativistic liberal bullshit from me).

  520. Almost every single one of these comments is full of hate.
    You all want to know what’s wrong with the world? What makes some men in Egypt disregard a person just because of her gender, her nationality, her looks? I think it’s the same thing that makes some people in the UK say horrible things about a religious group, or a nation as a whole.
    I’m truly sorry for what you went through, Natasha. You are amazing.

    • I think it’s the same thing that makes some people in the UK say horrible things about a religious group, or a nation as a whole.

      Exactly! Gang rape and name-calling: same thing.

    • Isn’t disgust and anger the proper response towards a culture that allows this to happen. Can you imagine a women being raped by hundreds in a western society without thousands coming to help her? (or at least the police to rescue her with whatever forced deemed necessary). The truth is this could not have happened in New York or any western city. The response would have overwhelmed the offenders or the police would have shot the assailants to rescue the woman.

  521. My whole heart and soul goes out to you and your experience. No on should ever have to to through that. And those people either Muslims or non Muslim should burn! And many of you have probably not aware that not all people in Egypt are Muslims! There are many Christians as well and there is no proof those were all Muslims. Also during the revolution many criminals were let out of jail! Many of the awful things that are being done are by those people.

    NONE OF THESE COMMENTERS GIVE A SHIT ABOUT THIS GIRL. THEY ARE JUST REDNECK ASSHOLES WHO WANT TO PROVE HOW WRONG ISLAM IS. IF SHE WAS RAPED OR SEXUALLY HARASSED BY A GROUP OF WHITE MEN! NO ON WOULD DARE SAY WHITE MAN IS THE EVIL MAN OR CHRISTIANITY IS EVIL. BECAUSE YOU ARE ALWAYS WILLING TO HATE SOMETHING YOU DO NOT UNDERSTAND. YOU DON’T JUDGE BY PEOPLE. YOU JUDGE THE TRUE RELIGION. AND AS A MUSLIM I FIND EVERY RELIGION TO BE BEAUTIFUL AND WOULD NEVER JUDGE THEM. BUT I FIND HUMANS AND THEIR WAY OF LIVING IS THE TRUE EVIL WE HAVE TO DEAL WITH EVERYDAY!

    • NONE OF THESE COMMENTERS GIVE A SHIT ABOUT THIS GIRL.

      And we’re supposed to believe you do? None of us know her and it’s not about you or me or her, it’s about how women are treated in Egypt.

    • “NONE OF THESE COMMENTERS GIVE A SHIT ABOUT THIS GIRL”.

      What a truly insulting thing to say. How narrowminded you must be in your liberal leftist dogmatism to believe that noone who is critical of islam can be genuinely touched by natashas experience and story. I guess it makes everything a whole lot easier to just regard all islam-critical people as evil. Then you don’t have to listen to arguments or learn any facts about islam.

      But, know this: Your insular reasoning is not to the benefit of our sisters who suffer. It only makes it harder for the necessary reform of islam to take place and thus makes women suffer for a longer time than necessary. Shame on you, to let political correctness go before robust and frank criticism of islam, criticism that is so obviously needed to save so many people – gays, women, atheists, secularists, christians etc.

  522. Want to say how sorry I am this happened to you. I can only imagine the terror. I just do not understand why so many woman want to go to Egypt, or anywhere else for that matter, where Muslims are the majority. Just look at Shariah and you see it is all justified evil behavior. The way you were violated should never happen to ANY human being!

    • you too have been threatend by fearing propaganda.
      sorry for beeing so up front…
      ever lived in a muslim country…if not you shouldn’t talk about thing u don’t know.

      peace

  523. Pingback: British female journalist, 21, describes horrific sexual assault in Egypt's Tahrir Square after election result - Stormfront

  524. Natasha, You cannot be free if you are not safe. You cannot be safe in your own country when its Muslim population is growing. You cannot be safe in this world when Islam is spreading like metastasized cancer, and Western governments, including our own, instead of doing anything at all to oppose it, compete with each other in their expressions of abject “dhimmitude”.

    The truth is that our enemies do not need to commit another atrocity right now. The mass migration of Muslims to the United States, Canada, UK, Australia and Eurabia continues. In a couple of generations, there will be enough of them to vote the Constitution out and Sharia in. When our policies begin threatening the success of their venture, there will be another terrorist act, and our leaders will obediently make the necessary adjustments.

    What can we do?

    We can do a lot. We are perfectly capable of stopping jihad forever by next Wednesday. Instead, we will do nothing, because taking Babylon’s little ones and dashing them against the rock takes the courage we no longer possess – therefore we are silently, passively watching the unfolding of a new holocaust.

    • this comment came out of the darkest shithole i’ve ever seen. you must be filled up with hatred and fear, developped by your own demons and ignorance.

      religion shouldn’t be any part of politics (and it isn’t in crucial cases because these things are caused by social illeteracy, and in 99.9 per cent provoked by western society) , wether its happening or your just an postpuberty imagination of yourself. shut down your tv and mass news and meet people…muslims jews christians that shouldn’t matter to anyone, cause we’re all one.
      grow up and learn love solidarity diversity and humanity

      before u answer check history.
      and to the young woman: i salute you and keep your mind open as it is

  525. I this shld not have happened to you, but the world and certainly egypt is not a safe place. One sentence struck me:

    “Women were crying and telling me “this is not Egypt! This is not Islam! Please, please do not think this is what Egypt is!” I reassured her that I knew that was the case, that I loved Egypt and its culture and people, and the innate peacefulness of moderate Islam.”

    Sorry to say, but it IS egypt and it IS islam.
    The innate peacefulness of moderate islam???? Well I guess that the men that assaulted you were all hardcore fundamentalist Al Quida and Taliban members? No They are the average ‘moderate islam’

  526. Natasha – if you have a site set up somewhere for donations to help you finish your project I’m sure many people would love to donate. I found the story you told to be one of the most mature I’ve ever read relating to something so personal and awful. I applaud you for being there, and for not letting this break you. As women, if we agree that certain places are out of bound to us, we can never help make things better, anyone who calls you stupid for being there as a limited understanding of the complexity of these situations.

  527. “I am determined to return to this wonderful country and city that I love, and meet its people once again.” You don’t even understand why it happened to you, do you?

    • And right after you have ” Don’t let anything cloud your judgement “. it’s fantastic.
      Seems to be a very professionnal objective journalist.

      Yes it’s horrible what happened, but this pathetic ideology of blindness end xenophilia based just on good feeling and historic cultural vacuum is exasperating.

  528. You write as if you are surprised. This is what the people of the deep south has been doing for thousands of years, it’s in their nature. It’s genetic. I’m deeply sorry for what happened to you, and I’m glad you expose Arabic men for what they are. This might inspire more women to stop the immigration of animalistic Middle Easteners to Europe and the rest of the white world.

  529. A Muslim’s ancient urge for jihad is so great, so unquenchable, so uncompromising that whenever he is deprived of his sacred right to murder the infidels, he will inevitably begin killing his own brothers, using obscure tribal or sectarian distinction as the cause of war. Just look what’s going on in Iraq, Syria, Egypt, Lebanon, Gaza or any “Turdistan” of your choice, where Muslims successfully resist the infidel influence by murdering each other.

    The history of Islam is the history of jihad. The purpose of jihad is expansion. Muslims don’t send out missionaries. They send out warriors. They give us, infidels, a fair choice to accept Allah and His Messenger or die. That’s the extent of Allah’s boundless mercy to the infidel. That’s the extent of benevolence the former female US Secretary of State so lavishly praised.

    And if we don’t destroy Islam at least as thoroughly as we destroyed Nazism, Islam will destroy us as thoroughly, as it has destroyed everything and everybody in its way during the 14 centuries of unending jihad.

  530. All this talk about ‘this is not Islam’. So please explain why rape victims in Saudi Arabia and other Islamic places are arrested, imprisoned and lashed within an inch of their lives.

  531. Dear Natasha, after reading about what happened to you, I initially wanted to post a comment as a fellow journalist and a woman to thank you for your courage in re-telling this horrific incident. I cannot begin to imagine what you must have gone through.
    Then when I saw the cruel and misogynistic comments posted by others here, I feel I have to write to encourage you, and to tell you that *far* more people consider you brave and an inspiration, than the other way around.
    Shame on those who can be so low, so inhuman and so ignorant as to blame a woman for her own rape. Shame on those who would call a journalist “stupid” for going to cover a dangerous event. How do you think that the world is finding out about Syria, and about all the other atrocities happening around the globe, if it isn’t for people like Natasha.

    • [Shame on those who can be so low, so inhuman and so ignorant as to blame a woman for her own rape.]
      islam not only blames women for their own rape, they execute the rape victim woman as well.

  532. This is not normal anymore. The people are asking for a democracy over there but raping women is just normal for them. Egypt, nothing more than people acting like animals!

  533. Yes I know we have a lot of problems to fix in my country. Egypt is the land of paradox, the good and the ugly are always side by side.

    Wish you well.

    • Used to love the country. But it seems the balance has tilted towards the ugly side. Comments blaming the last 60 years are just dead wrong. It will only get worse. Personally I will not go back to Egypt. Despite its beauty. And I hope all foreigners will do the same. Don’t let our money being used for their prosperity. Hope they all live a poor life and die of starvation.

  534. It is extremely dangerous for Western women to be anywhere in the Islamic world – period. They may feel safe and protected, as all the men seem to be smiling and peaceful. But all that can change in a minute. The Muslim male regards Western Infidel woman as fair game, to do with as they please.

    In addition, women should realise that in many parts of the world, women are not regarded equal to men. They are seen as weak, and if alone, as women who are asking for it. The idea that women can go anywhere and do anything a man does, just does not hold outside the West.

    I do feel for this journalist, but as a journalist, she should know better.

    • I sympathise with Natasha Smith and I hope she gets well soon and heed this good advice from ‘DP111’.
      I will also add that “the idea that women can go anywhere and do anything a man does” does not hold anywhere.
      .

    • Did you miss the part about her being with friends and that at least one of them was male?

      Oh, you didn’t read the blogpost at all. Sorry.

    • “Anti-Western sentiment”? No, I missed that part. Was it before or after the part where she writes that the atmosphere was one of jubilation, excitement, and happiness.?

  535. What would be the appropriate American response to the accusation of mistreatment of the Koran at the Guantanamo Bay? The immediate confiscation of every single copy of the Koran from the prisoners. Is there any danger of that? Of course not. It is far more important for us to remain politically correct than to win the war unleashed on us by the Muslims.

  536. it is extremely dangerous for western people to mill around cairo at the moment especially for women. there are lots of unscrupulous people who right or wrong have been unshackled and feel a sense of freedom when it comes to molesting westerners especially as they think they now think they can act with impunity. stay away from crowds and crowded areas (which is really hard in cairo). in other words stay away!!!

  537. Hi Natasha,

    I am very sorry for what happened to you and think you are infinitely brave for sharing you story.

  538. Pingback: This is what Egyptian democracy looks like! Female British Journalist Natasha Smith sexually assaulted in Tahrir Square after Morsi victory : Fire Andrea Mitchell!

  539. Hi Natasha, I am really sorry for what happened to you and think you are infinitely brave for sharing your story.

  540. I just cannot believe the stupidity of a white woman going to a very similar situation like the US reporter not long before! And then writing “I couldn’t believe I had got into this situation.”!!
    Do you think you are invincible? Untouchable? Or are you plainly stupid, fame-seeking girl, trying to “save the world”?
    Every simple country woman would give you a very good advice: STAY AWAY FROM CROWDS OF PRIMITIVES! Had the above things to happen to you, so that you were able to understand such a simple fact? Do you really think that your presence in unstable countries will make these countries more stable? More happy?
    Your Egypt experience is pretty logical. Please avoid your “heroic” fighting back against Egypt crowds and don’t try to show them that you have the right to walk in them! Please accept the fact that you were unbelievably stupid, and tell it to the world. Please do the only reasonable thing – tell to other such women how stupid you were going in an unstable country without adequate protection and joining crowd of primitives. THIS IS THE SIMPLE AND MOST IMPORTANT TRUTH ABOUT YOUR STORY.

      • but they are primitives….it’s a fact. Blood sicking, motivated by hate and religion, harassing women, and etc.

    • Was Rosa parks stupid to refuse to give her seat?
      Yes, those men are the worst example of arab men on earth but that does not mean that people should cease to make a difference and fight for change.

      just like slavery was abolished in USA, and now you have a black president, change can come to any part of the world.

      Natasha might not be able to change egypt herself, but it is the sum of all those small efforts that brings change…

      • I assure you, no sum of crowd-violated women will change the country. Such stories will only deepen the animosity between our and their world, nothing more. Such victims are not only senseless, but in fact harmful.

  541. Natasha, generally, I believe that people — individually or collectively — never deserve more respect than they show towards others. When was the last time observant Muslims demonstrated any respect for anything or anyone outside their death cult? The answer is, never. But then, the question itself is tricky, since, in the Muslim world, respect is synonymous with fear and submission. It gets even trickier if you recall that the so-called Muslim world — every square inch of it — was taken by them from its rightful owners by ways of jihad, the Islamic war of conquest and genocide continuing non-stop for 14 centuries.

    • You are Stareotyping everybody that lives in an Arabic culture by saying this. It’s like me saying all americans are fat and stupid that doesn’t do the people justice. Also your perciption of jihad is flawed, jihad is when a person fights in a war for the Islam. What Osama bin Ladin did is not considered jihad. Do your research kid.

      • actually, tou are wrong. there are 2 meanings of Jihad, and the one that Bin laden did, is THE jihad. Do your homework, Frank, or at least try and read some arabic.

  542. i lived for 7yrs in cairo, until 2009 and i can tell you now do not go to cairo at the moment.
    it is extremely dangerous for western people to mill around cairo at the moment especially for women. there are lots of unscrupulous people who right or wrong have been unshackled and feel a sense of freedom when it comes to molesting westerners especially as they think they now think they can act with impunity. stay away from crowds and crowded areas (which is really hard in cairo). in other words stay away!!!
    mubarak held a tight strangle hold on the country and had plain clothed policemen on every street corner. whilst im sure this wasnt great to some egyptians, for others it was a feeling of security and who is going to now pay all these secret police, who were so hated by some??! some people want to cause big instability now in egypt, and who knows who will be causing the trouble………….

  543. I feel bad for you Natasha. I give you credit for telling your story. Unfortunately most Egyptian men are animals. They treat their own women like this also.

  544. I’m happy to know that you could make it.
    I’m apologizing for my genre; a man that does this kind of things shouldn’t be called man.

  545. Natasha, what an inspiration you are. Your bravery in the face of horrible violence and your determination not to let the criminal acts of those who attacked you colour your view of Egypt and its people speak volumes about your stregnth of character and compassion for others. Thank you for sharing your story with the world in such an eloquent way and for not letting your attackers rob you of your dignity. I look forward to your film if you decide finish it – but even if you don’t, know that by telling your story you are helping destigmatizing sexual assualt and violence against women and that, in and of itself, is an enormous gift to the women worldwide.

    • Here is the color I see the Muslim Arabs:
      Do you remember how, in 2002, a group of Arab terrorists escaping capture by the IDF barricaded themselves inside the Church of the Nativity and took hostage the priests who happened to be inside? The Arabs did not hesitate to urinate and defecate inside the church. Imagine the reaction of the Muslim world if “infidels” had done something similar to the most insignificant mosque on earth.

      Although the Church of the Nativity constitutes one of the most important Christian holy places, not a single Muslim objected to its desecration. Christians did not demand any apology from that particular group of Muslims, or their leaders, or Islamic authorities in general. There was no anti-Muslim backlash in any Christian country.

      • Where in the quran does Muhammed say something like “turn the other cheek”?

  546. We delude ourselves into thinking that Muslims will never come to our door. They most certainly will, just as they have come to Natasha, and as they have come to the door of Denmark. The Christian response was as cowardly as the Israeli response to the Arab atrocities on its territory. Take the boycott of Danish goods, for example. What would be the appropriate response of the civilized world? Any response as long as it is meaningful. But not a single Western country, not a single Western manufacturer has taken its goods off the shelves in the Muslim world out of solidarity with Denmark’s stand for the freedom of expression. Was there ever any danger of such a response? Of course,not. We are doing everything in our power to fulfill Lenin’s prophecy about selling to our enemies the rope on which they will hang us.

    What would be the appropriate American response to the accusation of mistreatment of the Koran at the Guantanamo Bay? The immediate confiscation of every single copy of the Koran from the prisoners. Is there any danger of that? Of course not. It is far more important for us to remain politically correct than to win the war unleashed on us by the Muslims.

  547. It’s not a first rape on Tahrir Sq. so You were stupid enough to try it yourself.
    It’s just like sending a sheep journalist to a HungryWolf State.
    Russian joke says:” Every time you put your finger into wolf’s mouths – it bites”

  548. Dear Natasha, I thought it was very brave of you to share your story, and I am so so saddened that this happened to you. I can empathise with your pain, and I know how much time and how difficult it will be to get through this: but you will, you have the courage and strength and heart to heal one day, and to move on. I am so sorry to read the mad mess of comments that have just turned into a mud-slinging contest .. I am sorry I bothered to reply to some of those comments, because it feels like the Comments section is where we are supposed to connect with the writer, and instead we might as well just be a bunch of people standing around fighting each other and totally ignoring the rape survivor whose story we just heard. I think that must feel hurtful and insulting and belittling and I’m sorry for that. Please forgive me if my words have added to your pain in any way. Wishing you healing, comfort and support at this time ..

  549. Dear Natasha, I am Egyptian & I AM DEEPLY SORRY for what happened to you! I can imagine the suffering you went through & I am very proud to see you that BRAVE sharing your story! and m sure that what doesn’t kill you makes you stronger. I apologize on the behalf of every ignorant out there, I just wanted to tell you that this is not EGYPT and it really hope that this is not just the beginning of CRUELTY in Egypt, I am also sure that is not Islam, however I am christian. God Bless you

    • Let us stick to Islamic doctrine as enshrined in the Koran and in the words of the prophet. You will say that they are taken out of context, but that is a lie because there is no context which will make those verses mean the opposite of what they so clearly say. And, remember that Allah in the Koran says that His words are clear and understandable Here are just a few of of them:
      KORAN
      1. — Surely the vilest of animals in Allah’s sight are those who disbelieve. (8.55)
      2. — The unbelievers are your inveterate enemy. (4: 1 01)
      3. — Mohammed is God’s apostle. Those who follow him are ruthless to the unbelievers but merciful to one another. (48:29).
      4. — Make war on them until idolatry shall cease and God’s religion shall reign supreme. (8:40)
      5. — Fight against them until idolatry is no more and God’s religion reigns supreme. (2: 193)
      6. — We will put terror into the hearts of the unbelievers. (3: 151)
      7. — I shall cast terror into the hearts of the infidels. Strike off their heads, strike off the very tips of their fingers. (8: 12)
      8. — Fight against such of those to whom the Scriptures were given [i.e. Christians and Jews] … until they pay tribute out of hand and are utterly subdued. (9:29)
      9. — Prophet, make war on the unbelievers and the hypocrites and deal rigorously with them. (9:73 and 66:9)
      10. — Believers, make war on the infidels who dwell around you. Deal firmly with them. (9: 123)

      MUHAMMAD
      1. — Mohammed said, “I have been ordered to fight with the people till they say, “None has the right to be worshipped but Allah,
      2. — Muhammad said: “Fight in the name of Allah and in the way of Allah. Fight against those who disbelieve in Allah. Make a holy war, … ”
      3. — Allah’s Apostle said, “You (i.e. Muslims) will fight with the Jews till some of them will hide behind stones. The stones will (betray them) saying, ‘0 ‘Abdullah (i.e. slave of Allah)! There is a Jew hiding behind me; so kill him.’ ”
      SHARIA ISLAMIC SACRED LAW
      From one of the most popular manuals of Sharia Law, Reliance of the Traveler: A Classic Manual of Islamic Sacred Law, approved by the highest Islamic religious authorities of Saudi Arabia, Jordan, Syria, Egypt and America.

      1. “JIHAD means to (make) war on non-Muslims”
      2. ”The Caliph makes war upon Jews, Christians and Zoroastrians … ”
      3. “The Caliph fights all other peoples until they become Muslims”

      • Here comes the Answers.
        1. — Surely the vilest of animals in Allah’s sight are those who disbelieve. (8.55) ok so who are the disbelievers? Those who didn’t follow the Holy Quran,Right! And those who didn’t follow the Holy Quran will certainly not shy away from raping women,committing crimes,murdering innocent. Completely true!Because if they believe in Holy Quran they will know that if they commit this crime they will face harsh punishments.So what you will call them a Iron men or Animals?
        2. — The unbelievers are your inveterate enemy. (4: 1 01)
        Yes they are! A believer means a good human being and he knows what is good and what is bad,He will restrain himself from all the evil deeds and temptations and is always looking for a chance to do good things and on the other hand a disbelievers is hell bent to stop a believer in doing good deeds.
        3. — Mohammed is God’s apostle. Those who follow him are ruthless to the unbelievers but merciful to one another. (48:29).
        I hope now you will understand the meaning of unbelievers.Anyway those unbelievers are not like you! Ok i will give you a example. Al qaeda hell bent to destroy america and israel.Now no american or israeli or even you will show mercy towards member of al qaeda when you openly knew they are your enemy.Will you? Similarly those unbelievers were hell bent to destroy Islam and Muslims.So God order those Muslims to be ruthless to those unbelievers,just like america oders it drones to attack terrorists.
        4. — Make war on them until idolatry shall cease and God’s religion shall reign supreme. (8:40)
        Before Islam most of the Arabs were idolaters,they drink whole day and night,bury girls alive,and they do many evil things.So make war on them! Do you remember the golden calf event in the Bible.The golden calf was an idol made by Aaron to satisfy the Israelites during Moses’ absence, when he went up to Mount Sinai. The calf was intended to be a physical representation of the God of Israel, and therefore was doubly wrong for involving Israel in idolatry and for ascribing physicality to God.The Lord told Moses that his people had corrupted themselves, and he planned to eliminate them and start a new people from Moses himself. However, Moses argued and pleaded that they should be spared (Exodus 32:11), and the Lord relented. And when Joshua heard the noise of the people as they shouted, he told Moses. Moses went down from the mountain, but upon seeing the calf, he too became angry. He threw down the tablets upon which God’s law had been written, breaking them. Moses burnt the golden
        calf in a fire,That’s Why Make war on them until idolatry shall cease and God’s religion shall reign supreme. (8:40)
        5. — Fight against them until idolatry is no more and God’s religion reigns supreme. (2: 193)
        Refer from above.
        6. — We will put terror into the hearts of the unbelievers. (3: 151)
        Yes indeed the murderer,rapist and drunkards should be terrorized so that they will never commit evil crimes.
        7. — I shall cast terror into the hearts of the infidels. Strike off their heads, strike off the very tips of their fingers. (8: 12)
        Those infidels were same like al qaeda! So strike off their heads ,because if you will not do,they will most probably do it with you.
        8. — Fight against such of those to whom the Scriptures were given [i.e. Christians and Jews] … until they pay tribute out of hand and are utterly subdued. (9:29)
        Allah Almighty commanded the Muslims to be kind and just with non-Muslims: “Allah forbids you not, With regard to those who Fight you not for (your) Faith Nor drive you out Of your homes, From dealing kindly and justly With them: For Allah loveth Those who are just. (The Noble Quran, 60:8)”
        Certain ayahs (verses) from the Qur’an have been a subject of controversy by many critics of Islam over the years, and so has been Islam on the whole.Verse number 29 of Surah At-Tawba is often used on websites with an Islamophobic view, the verse itself is often falsely translated (with the adding of words in the wrong context, I.e. Jihad, Infidels, etc.), used out of context,or has been concluded upon that verse 9:29 commands Muslims to attack non-Muslims, until they pay money.
        Translations
        Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued.
        Commentary by The western historian Will Durant explains the historical context of the verse:
        The people of dhimma: Christians, Zaradishts, Jews and Sabi’a’; enjoyed a degree of tolerance during the Umayyad rule which can never be assimilated to Christian countries nowadays. They were free to practise their rituals. They maintained their churches and synagogues and the only obligation was that they should wear a special color and pay tax for every person pro rata his income. This sum ranged between two and four dinars at most. This tax was exclusively levied on non-Muslims who can go to war. However priests, women, children, slaves, elderly men, the disabled, the blind and the destitute were exempted from the tax. Dhimmis were exempted from military service in return. They were also exemptped from Zakāt which is 2.5% of the annual income and the government was bound to protect them.”
        9. — Prophet, make war on the unbelievers and the hypocrites and deal rigorously with them. (9:73 and 66:9)
        10. — Believers, make war on the infidels who dwell around you. Deal firmly with them. (9: 123)
        9&10 What will you do,when your enemy have only one goal and that is to wipe out your existence from the earth.Will you make and bake pan cake for them,will you take them to watch a movie,Nah most likely you will defend yourself or even plan pre-emptive strike against your enemy in order to protect yourself and your loved ones.Just like Israel attack egypt in a Arab-Israel war.when it was clear to it that egypt was determined to attack it.
        Islam is indeed a peaceful religion,just as you have taken some words out of context similarly the people who follow Bin laden have taken the words out of context and they think it is allowed in islam to kill non muslims.They too are ignorant,All the bad words are used are against those unbelievers(Who were very bad people) and was present at the time of Holy Prophet(pbuh).Islam as areligion always try to bring unity among Muslims,Jews and Christians.But the people does not understand this.
        Prophet Muhammad (pbuh): A mercy to all creation!

        There was one old jewish woman made a habit of throwing rubbish on Prophet Mohammed (saw) whenever he passed from her house. Prophet Mohammed (saw) had to pass that house daily on the way to the mosque. Even when the old woman threw rubbish on him, he would pass silently without showing any anger or annoyance. This was a regular, daily event.
        One day when Prophet Mohammed (saw) was passing by the woman was not there to throw the rubbish. Prophet Mohammed (saw) stopped and asked the neighbor about her well-being. The neighbor informed Prophet Mohammed (saw) that the woman was sick and laying on the bed. Prophet Mohammed (saw) politely asked permission to visit the old woman. When allowed he entered the house, the old woman thought that he had come there to take his revenge when she was unable to defend herself because of her sickness. But Prophet Mohammed (saw) assured her that he had come to her, not to take any revenge, but to see her and to look after her needs, as it was the command of Allah (SWT) that if any one is sick, a Muslim should visit him and should help him if his help is needed.
        The old woman was greatly moved by this love and kindness of Prophet Mohammed (saw).
        MUHAMMAD(pbuh)
        1. — Mohammed(pbuh) said, “I have been ordered to fight with the people till they say, “None has the right to be worshipped but Allah,

        The Hadith referred is reported in Sahih Bukhari and Muslim. The Prophet (Sallallahu Alaihi wa Sallam) said: “I have been ordered to fight against the people until they testify that there is no one worthy of worship but Allah and that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah and until they perform the Prayers and pay the Zakah, and if they do so they will have gained protection from me for their lives and property, unless [they do acts that are punishable] in accordance with Islam, and their reckoning will be with Allah Most High. [Bukhari,Muslim].
        The purpose of fighting is to take Jizyah(Tax),(Jizyah is the tax levied from the people of scriptures who are under the protection of a Muslim government). “When the messenger (Peace be upon him) of Allah appointed anyone as leader of an army or detachment he would especially exhort him and say: “When you meet ‘enemies’ who are polytheists, invite them to three courses of action. If they respond to any one of these, you also accept it and restrain yourself from doing them any harm Invite them to (accept) Islam; if they respond to you, accept it from them and desist from fighting against them. If they refuse to accept Islam, demand from them the Jizyah. If they agree to pay, accept it from them and hold your hand. If they refuse to pay the tax, seek Allah’s help and fight them”.
        ( If they respond to any one of these, you also accept it and restrain yourself from doing them any harm) see clearly the first order was to restrain from bloodshed,killing,fighting.And what America or Israel does with militant they just attack without warning,So will you called them aggressors or defenders/protectors.
        If they refuse to pay the tax fight them.Now the enemy who is refusing the tax was not sitting on bench eating Subway sandwiches,the enemy was in the battle field awaiting the Muslims to come and fight,And in the battle field the appointed muslim leader gave the enemy three choices,now it is upto to him to choose if the enemy choose to fight,fight them with the help of Allah.That’s call a honesty.
        I think you just pick the lines,go and study the reason behinds these words.
        2 — Muhammad said: “Fight in the name of Allah and in the way of Allah. Fight against those who disbelieve in Allah. Make a holy war, … ”
        3. — Allah’s Apostle said, “You (i.e. Muslims) will fight with the Jews till some of them will hide behind stones. The stones will (betray them) saying, ’0 ‘Abdullah (i.e. slave of Allah)! There is a Jew hiding behind me; so kill him.’ ”
        SHARIA ISLAMIC SACRED LAW
        From one of the most popular manuals of Sharia Law, Reliance of the Traveler: A Classic Manual of Islamic Sacred Law, approved by the highest Islamic religious authorities of Saudi Arabia, Jordan, Syria, Egypt and America.

        1. “JIHAD means to (make) war on non-Muslims”
        2. ”The Caliph makes war upon Jews, Christians and Zoroastrians … ”
        3. “The Caliph fights all other peoples until they become Muslims”

        There are a lot of sayings of the Prophet PBUH but not all are authenticated.A lot of them are not and you have to research and make sure they don’t contradict the Quran. Killing disbelievers is only allowed when they suppress your faith and attack you (in wars), then you must fight for your freedom.Look up these verse numbers in Quran and you will see it says, fight them only if they fight you first, but stop if they stop fighting and live with them in peace.

        Myth: Islam teaches suicide bombing and terrorism
        Fact: Islam prohibits killing others and suicide 4:29

        Myth: Kill all disbelievers
        Fact: Kill disbelievers only if you are attacked by them, but if they stop, you must stop 2:190 2:191 2:192
        Fact: Islam teaches to live with the disbelievers in peace 8:61 43:88 43:89
        Fact: You cannot force a woman into marriage in Islam
        4:19
        Fact: Islam teaches to be kind to your enemies, unless you are attacked by them, then fight them 41:34
        Fact: You cannot force the religion on anyone 2:256
        You see the “violent” verses are only the verses of self defence, The self-defence was the law.
        ISLAM -I Shall Love Always Mankind. Islam-Salaam-Shalom-Peace on you,Peace in the world,Peace with everyone but not with evil!

      • Honeybunny Johan, you clueless prick, how this different from the Bible?! The Bible states that a woman who is raped has to marry her rapist (Deuteronomy 22:28-29) and that a woman who ‘does not defend herself enough’ against rape should be stoned (Deuteronomy 22:23-24).
        Here you go:
        http://www.evilbible.com/Rape.htm

  550. I’m a Muslim Egyptian, and I am sorry, there is no excuse for what happened to u, and u have every right to hate Egypt and Egyptians, I know I would… this is the result of a rotten regime that took over Egypt for 60 years… I’m sure it wouldn’t make much difference but I really am sorry, for u and for Egypt.

    • Everybody knows it’s not the Egyptians nor Egypt and his rich and fascinating culture. Nobody blames the country or the Egyptians. I guess we can all agree it’s all about a sick and corrupt belief system, which will probably take another 60 yrs to wipe out. And it’s not up to you or any other civil Egyptian to apologize for those sick motherfuckers.It’s up to those predators to do so. And then for all fundamentalists, politicians and your previous leaders to do so, for giving these savages a playground.

      • I think as a civilian I should apologize, because we never tried to change that hard enough in the past. u would’ve never gone through that if we did. Educated Egyptians are just as responsible, and I do apologize again and again…
        I was wondering if you don’t mind me using your story for a short movie as an effort for change. I’m an Egyptian filmmaker living in Canada

      • “Everybody knows it’s not the Egyptians nor Egypt and his rich and fascinating culture.”

        Who says so?

        Every culture is many-sided, and Egyptian culture has it rich and fascinating aspects, and Egyptian people can be wonderful. Nevertheless. this is not the first public rape (or something as bad as rape) of a foreign woman in Tahrir Square in past year. Nothing like this happens in political protests in the West. Yes, there were some rapes at Occupy camps, but those were furtive acts by individuals, nothing like this: dozens of men crowding around the naked victim to get their hooks into her. A culture where this sort of thing happens has serious problems.

    • @Mansour. Forget the regime, look at your people and what they have been learned from their religion. Their behavior is totally consistent with it, although they are probably illiterate.

      Let us stick to Islamic doctrine as enshrined in your Koran and in the words of your prophet. You will say that they are taken out of context, but that is a lie because there is no context which will make those verses mean the opposite of what they so clearly say. And, remember that Allah in the Koran says that His words are clear and understandable Here are just a few of of them:
      KORAN
      1. — Surely the vilest of animals in Allah’s sight are those who disbelieve. (8.55)
      2. — The unbelievers are your inveterate enemy. (4: 1 01)
      3. — Mohammed is God’s apostle. Those who follow him are ruthless to the unbelievers but merciful to one another. (48:29).
      4. — Make war on them until idolatry shall cease and God’s religion shall reign supreme. (8:40)
      5. — Fight against them until idolatry is no more and God’s religion reigns supreme. (2: 193)
      6. — We will put terror into the hearts of the unbelievers. (3: 151)
      7. — I shall cast terror into the hearts of the infidels. Strike off their heads, strike off the very tips of their fingers. (8: 12)
      8. — Fight against such of those to whom the Scriptures were given [i.e. Christians and Jews] … until they pay tribute out of hand and are utterly subdued. (9:29)
      9. — Prophet, make war on the unbelievers and the hypocrites and deal rigorously with them. (9:73 and 66:9)
      10. — Believers, make war on the infidels who dwell around you. Deal firmly with them. (9: 123)

      MUHAMMAD
      1. — Mohammed said, “I have been ordered to fight with the people till they say, “None has the right to be worshipped but Allah,
      2. — Muhammad said: “Fight in the name of Allah and in the way of Allah. Fight against those who disbelieve in Allah. Make a holy war, … ”
      3. — Allah’s Apostle said, “You (i.e. Muslims) will fight with the Jews till some of them will hide behind stones. The stones will (betray them) saying, ‘0 ‘Abdullah (i.e. slave of Allah)! There is a Jew hiding behind me; so kill him.’ ”
      SHARIA ISLAMIC SACRED LAW
      From one of the most popular manuals of Sharia Law, Reliance of the Traveler: A Classic Manual of Islamic Sacred Law, approved by the highest Islamic religious authorities of Saudi Arabia, Jordan, Syria, Egypt and America.

      1. “JIHAD means to (make) war on non-Muslims”
      2. ”The Caliph makes war upon Jews, Christians and Zoroastrians … ”
      3. “The Caliph fights all other peoples until they become Muslims”

      See the relation to what has happened to Natasha?

      • Dear Johan, I am in no place to discuss religion with u, I keep religion to myself. If u need advice from an expert, I would happily direct u to one. All what I can tell u about my experience with this religion is what my parents taught me, treat others how u want to be treated. 1 of my best friends in Cairo is Christians, and 1 of my best friends in Canada is Jewish.
        Cheers

    • Credit to you for being a truly moderate muslim. I really really really hope you soon have the power to change islam into being a religion of peace. Otherwise we shall have war. It surely isn’t something i hope for. But credit where it’sdue. It’s people like you that gives me hope.

  551. Obviously spam, western people cant go to islamic country as so called people in there cant behave and have no respect for others, great culture and religion of yours that shows us this behaviour! You should be locked in cages than if you cant controll yourself!!

  552. Pingback: British Journalist Natasha Smith Details Tahrir Square Sexual Assault After Muslim Brotherhood Mohammed Morsi’s Victory | TheBlaze.com

  553. When I was reading Natasha story I recalled of completely inconsequential episode when I saw a photograph showing a group of Muslims burning a Danish flag. They looked just as mobile and as solemnly satisfied as those Arabs in their attempt to rape the blond English girl. The resemblance was not accidental. In both cases, the Muslims, cruelly deprived of the real thing, found comfort in whatever substitution was available…

    The Arabs, in accordance with Muslim laws and traditions were deprived of a normal sex life to such a degree that I don’t think they knew such a thing existed. Everything about sex that we consider normal constitutes the most depraved debauchery to the Muslims; we, on the other hand, gently disapprove of their zoo- and pedophilia.

    The flag-burners, on the other hand, were deprived by cruel circumstances of an immediate opportunity to wash their hands in the blood of the infidel, which, under the same Muslim laws and customs, is both their sacred right and sacred duty. In both cases, the substitution was precious and, at the same time, lacking.

    The major similarity between the two groups is that the Arabs on Tahrir Square had their dreams — whatever they might be — fully realized by raping western girls as was reported many times before. Like them, the flag burners had a pretty fair chance to realize theirs.

  554. Your determination is inspiring not just to victims of abuse, but to women everywhere who will benefit from your investigative work. I hope you make a speedy recovery from this, both physically and emotionally, and that some good will come from shedding light on your horrific ordeal.

  555. Pingback: Watchers Council Nominations – Order In The Court Edition | askmarion

  556. Pingback: Another female journalist assaulted in Tahrir Square – sailor-boy - My Telegraph

  557. When presented with a choice between imposing our religious beliefs on others and productive coexistence with each other, we, infidels, wisely opted for coexistence and turned our faiths into an intimately personal matter. As a result, tolerance has become our way of life. Thank God for that!

    If, instead of an infidel, I were a muslim, my view would be entirely different. My faith is Islam, but my way of life is jihad. For 14 centuries, never letting up for even a minute, Islam has demanded of me that I continue jihad until the last infidel stops breathing. How can you counter my upbringing? By reeducating me? You won’t succeed even if you keep at it for the next 14 centuries, but, considering your staying power (or, rather, lack thereof), your effort is not likely to last 14 months.

    Your peace-mongers may sing sweet songs about Islam’s benevolence, but the truth is: Islam and jihad are as inseparable as the two poles of a magnet. A smart demagogue may describe them as two opposites, but you know as well as I do that the two cannot exist without each other. Jihad is the only state in which Islam has ever existed since the day when the infidel fools exiled the Prophet from Mecca. Jihad is the only state in which Islam can exist.

  558. Meanwhile in the ret of the world such thing is not only impossible but unimaginable. Thank god for borders for it provides liberty. Dogs do not make cats.

  559. You are juste an idiot. You think you can go everywhere like in your home, that everyone thinks about equality and rights. Do do not know them, this country and uses but you think you know all about it because your ignorance tells you to look only the bright side.
    Even when they rape you you seak their language, you called their god like it will have any effect. You thought they considered you. Stupid you are.
    You are not religious, ahah you’re juste a shame for western countries. Religion was everything in the past for us and ervrything now for them. You used god as a tool, hoping he will save you, so this country you did not nothered to understand used you like a tool.

    • So you’re condoning what these men did by saying she deserved it by saying something about their God (during the rape, might I add, not before) ? I think you’re the idiot. Maybe she should have had extra protection but I’m sure an experienced and intelligent journalist like her is aware of the fact that she doesn’t have the same rights and equality everywhere in the world. Your comment may be a result of nationalist pride, but you’re not being fair. And try working on your spelling, please. The world could do with more literate human beings.

      • Of course I do not think she deserve that but that’s not what she think and she wrote it by herself. ” we must learn for our experiences “. She did not read Candide of Voltaire.
        That’s the only thing you have to tell me ? about the spelling ? Maybe english is not my natural language..

      • Maybe but I do not rape people and I have the minimum respect for others to learn at first where I’m traveling.

      • It’s funny how all you politically correct internet heroes consort to violent remarks when facing an opinion different than yours.
        Kelb might hit a soft spot here and there, but he’s just as entitled to breathe as any one of you.

      • Kelb, you might not rape people…but you have assaulted and hurt someone who has already been hurt and assaulted with your unnecessary words here. Shame one you! 😦

    • What is wrong with you??? How can you read a rape victim’s story and then call her an idiot? Have you no humanity? No compassion? No understanding of what Islam truly means? Shame on YOU.

      • Hum. But you get the message.
        Keep looking at the finger when I show you the moon. I thnink spelling is the most important in this case.

  560. Hi Natasha, I am very sorry that something so awfull happend to you and even more so for some of the disrespectfull comments made on your story. I bless your heart for still being able to praise Egypt and it’s people after not only being attacked but also initially denied proper care at several hospitals. It must have been the worst of fates that men with only hurtfull intents came across your path on Sunday. I hope you will find the strength to recover from this attack and that of all the bad things that you’ve experienced, there is at least one good thing to come out of this, which is to raise awareness for you documentairy, as shown by described events, something that needs to be adressed. Best of luck!

  561. The reports have prompted press freedom group Reporters Without Borders to issue a safety warning to journalists covering the events in Tahrir Square:

    “It is more dangerous for a woman than a man to cover the demonstrations in Tahrir Square. That is the reality and the media must face it. It is the first time that there have been repeated sexual assaults against women reporters in the same place. The media must keep this in mind when sending staff there and must take special safety measures.

    “We are not saying the international media should pull out and stop covering events in Egypt. But they need to adapt to the threats that currently exist.”

    The group initially urged media organisations to stop sending female journalists to Egypt, but changed its advice after a storm of complaints from reporters, the Guardian said.

    DON’T GO BACK THERE NATASHA!!!

    • No, go back Nathasha !! it’s heaven ! go fight ” stereotypes and preconceptions” ! ( they raped you and WE are the bad guys ! Oo )
      Let’s start buy the stereotypes and preconceptions of Egyptian people.
      As you said ” learn from my experience. ” ahah ! ridiculous. Are we europeans so miserables ? Rape is an ” experience ” ?
      Do no forget, this is not Egypt. :rolling eyes:

      • Ok, I accept there’s probably not much point engaging in debate with someone happy to air such foul opinions, but here we go…

        Whatever the “reasoning” behind the abuse of women, this still never makes it acceptable.

        Of course it’s an experience – life is an ongoing experience. Some of it can be extemely unpleasant.

        I hope you can evolve and learn, certainly before you come into contact with any women in a personal capacity.

        Sexual abuse raises it’s ugly head across all cultures and should be shamed for what it is.

        Grow a soul, find some compassion.

        Natasha, live well and grow, don’t, as I’m sure you will not, let these stunted individuals add to your burden.

    • I know, right!? She gets raped by hundreds of people, the best she gets offered after is a chesseburger at Mcd’s(and degrading medical treatment) and she still has the nerve to say that this event was unusual, that this “is not Egypt,” and she won’t be cowed into submission. Seems like she is asking for another bad experience.
      -If it walks, acts, eats like a duck…..it’s a DUCK

  562. Pingback: Another Journalist gets “enriched” by the religion of peace #egypt #edl #laralogan « Casuals United Blog

    • No, muslims are NOT animals as real animals are much better than you or anyone else on this Planet!!! So colling those bastards animals is an insult for nimals!!!

      • When it comes to “being an animal”, religion has nothing to do with it. Gender has something to do with it (the majority of sexual assaults are committed by heterosexual males). When it comes to being a “bastard”, I kind of thought racists also fell into that category, not just rapists, so I’m confused ..

  563. Hi Natasha,

    I know you probably won’t see this…kind of hope your won’t since there are many harsh words on here from people who should know better…but if you do I want you to know that I respect you very much. As a very young journalist its hard to hear stories like this and keep going, but your courage reminds me that this is what is right and there’s a reason we do what we do. Thanks for your fearless admission of the truth, even when it must be terribly difficult to talk about.

    • And this is an appropriate how?

      Sorry – but you can not just generalize an entire population or faith of people like that. Completely unfair. I’m from Northern Ireland, am I a terrorist? My mother is Irish, is she a dumb drunk? American, fat? Did you even read Natasha’s entire blog? Even she, with so many reasons to, has not condemned all Muslims, nor all Egyptians for the crime committed.

      Women are raped and murdered in the ‘developed’, ‘ predominantly Christian’ West everyday in their thousands!

      What if I were to challenge with: “Men….f*cking animals.” ?

      • Your just being evasive – she was attacked by muslims because she was the lowest form on human amongst them – a none muslim women. There is a link between this women’s experience and the huge rise in violent sexual attacks on women – and girls – in Europe – the majority of which are committed by muslims.

        You may prefer to deny this as a fact, but even so I would suggest that you read the koran and learn something of Islam so that you understand why it is so repugnant to liberal free thinking people. faithfreedom.org

      • I know plenty thank you. I have spent a huge amount of time in the Middle East as a young, blonde, western woman and have never suffered even an inclination of abuse or assault, being treated with nothing but respect. I also have a significant number of Muslim friends, none of whom support or condone this behavior. As with all subsets of the population, you will have extremists who interpret above and beyond, or take an ultra-conservative or orthodox view.

      • Certainly not a fraud Johan. And if I have just been lucky, then may it continue.

    • For fuck sake, stop offending animals!!! They do not rape or abuse anyone on purpose, we should take example from them!!!

      • rape is actually quite common, just like abuse. Ducks seem very cute but the male ducks are quite the evil rapist motherduckers.

    • Guy I would certainly “deny this as a fact” .. so do provide the source for your claim that the majority of sexual assaults in Europe are by Muslims. I think you will find it easier to discover that the majority of sexual assaults are by family members.

  564. Truely a horrific experience, but sadly not surprising.
    Time and time again in European society alone we witness how muslim men do not respect, or do not know how to deal with western women. Nearly on a weekly basis I hear women complain about being verbally assaulted by women, for no apparent reason other than looking and dressing western.
    I’m hoping it has to do with something physical like a lack of masturbation, which in many muslim communities is looked down upon, or even pure taboo. This could account for the general sexual frustration in many muslim men. If not that, then it’s a cause for general concern if such distaste for free women would be a cultural thing.

  565. God, how stupid are you Natasha! You really thought muslims were cool and friendly people ?!?
    You really thought it was a joke, when people say these people treat women worse than animals??
    Your credulity is gigantic.

    • Wow, your comment is so stupid. First you come on a site to read abt what happened to her, then you think somewhere in that not so bright head of yours, that it’s entirely okay to make this comment. Talk abt stupid.

    • No, he’s kidding. This is just an incident. Muslims ( in general) treat their women like their equals. Encourage them to be educated, let them wear and look the way they desire and most of them even marry above 18 and are totally monogamous. There are minor incidents known involving groping, honor killing, pedophilia and stoning, but that’s so rare it isn’t even worth mentioning.

  566. My sympathy for you Natasha! My heart goes out to you. What had happened, is not your fault- which I am certain you know.. It must have been so difficult to narrate the unfortunate event. I commend you for being very brave and strong to articulately pen down the entire situation.

    As for the rest of us who reads this; please be considerate and be careful with your words. Your bitterness reflects your character, not the person you’re referring to.

  567. Après la journaliste américaine violée place tahrir, après la journaliste française violée place tahrir, voici l’anglaise !
    Et non les civilisations ne se valent pas, envoyer une femme chez ces abrutis ne pouvait que finir de cette façon… Fallait envoyer un bulldog anglais pour parler avec ces gens…
    Les journalistes sont incultes et vivent dans un monde fantastique aux merveilles, avant de partir pour le monde musulman faut étudier un minimum se qu’est ce monde musulman…

  568. People like you are why the world is the way it is… Disgusting… All my support with Safka and Catriona. Spam.

  569. You are an absolutely vile piece of crud. Tash is an absolutely fantastic girl for fighting through this horrendous experience and is selflessly trying to raise awareness and I am so proud that I know her. Why the hell should she have to be terrified or avoid going somewhere just because other ‘things’ in this world wish to live a disgusting, violent and selfish existence? To wish death on anyone, let alone someone you do not know and has done nothing to harm you or your feelings is incomprehensible. I despair that there are beings like you in society. No doubt you were there that night or wish you were. I will not wish anything upon you, but I do believe in karma and boy, you have a shit load of bad karma coming your way. I really hope this whole thread gets deleted before Tash sees it. Words fail me for how this post makes me feel.

  570. This is a very brave piece to have written. Know that the horrendous comments made on this page are from a minority of unthinking and unkind people, and that there are many more who can only thank you for your bravery in reporting such an incident and wish you a speedy and strong recovery.

  571. Hi Natasha!

    After reading just a handful of comments, I felt like I needed to just leave a note because of all the horrible, unnecessary and rude comments.

    I’m glad you wrote out your story, things like this do need to be heard, whether or not they will ever be fixed in any lifetime, as humans are flawed creatures.

    You will go back and visit Egypt, again and again, and you will have a great time, visiting the country you love so much.

    I’m so sorry that so many people felt it necessary to write their opinions on whether your story was real, what they believed really happened, about religion, and what their definitions about things are.

    I hope you keep your chin up, and keep doing what you love doing best.
    Do it for you, tell your story. I’ll be listening 🙂

    Zack

  572. I am an Egyptian girl and I’m deeply sorry for what you had gone through. I hope you recover from this soon, I will pray for you.

  573. Has there ever been a Muslim Newton? Or a Muslim Shakespeare? Or a Muslim Mozart? Or a Muslim Mother Teresa? A few Muslim names that I can name, like al-Khwarimi, could shine only in the darkness of the Dark Ages. As soon as Dar el-Harb moved forward, Dar el-Islam found itself unable to produce even a single person of any global significance, except for an enormous variety of Qaddafis, Saddams, bin Ladens, Arafats, and other animals-Hitlers every imaginable magnitude.

    • There are many many kind people whose kind acts are not even known. Muslims are generally very kind and large-hearted people. I am from a Christian family in India and have seen many Muslims in the Arab World who are more ready to help the needy, part with large sums of money expecting no return than are people from many other nations. This is the case even when the one in need is not a Muslim and merely happens to be a friend of their’s. That does not mean that there arent kind people in other countries, sure there are. However, the point is that there are millions of kind people who do a world of good but who aren’t famour or known to the media. You will be touched only when they have touched your lives.

    • hahaha,that is just plain ignorance.
      if you know what you are talking about you would’ve known that when it was the dark ages in Europe it was the golden era in the middle east.
      Arabs invented the basis of almost every science you are learning today,astronomy,medicine,mathematics, chemistry,and many other.
      only an example,arabs put the basis of an important little field that you might know as Algebra.there is some medical instruments that were invented at the time that are still used to uptil that day.to help you google some info ,arab scholars were like,Al-Zarqali,Ibn Firnas,Muhammad and Hasan Banu Musa and many many many others.
      you are talking about sth that you are completely clueless off.
      what happened to natsha was awful and people should be punished and yes sometimes arab tend to use Islam in a bad way or interpret it according to their messed up conceptions,but what you just said is just stupid .

      o yeah ,btw,who started the first and 2nd world war?Arabs?
      food for thought.

      • The difference is western society have evolved. Of egyprian muslims, more than80 percent favor strict sharia punishments for petty crimes. And I hear muslims have gotten all of four nobel prices. And that more books are translated into spanish each year than have been translated into arabic in a hundred years. Unfortunately islamic culture is insular, retrograde and a general menace to liberty and well being everywhere it is found. Show me an Islamic society and i will show you an abundance of extremism and gender-hate.

      • 1. Arabs picked up different things, such as proto-algebra from the Greeks and Babylonians, astronomy and medicine from China and India, and refined them.

        2. Much of this was done early on when the religion of islam had just been created. So it can be seen as it was done DESPITE islam rather than thanks to it.

        The past inventiveness, creativity and civility of the arabs has been suffocated by the slave-religion of islam.

    • Infidel, what animals have to do with Hitler? Do you think they are as horrible and cruel as Hitler was? Yes, animals like us- humans, but not any other breed so dont offend them!!!!

      • Read Dr. Barbara Oakley’s book, Natasha: “Evil Genes__Why Rome Fell, Hitler Rose, Enron Failed, and My Sister Stole My Sisters Boyfriend,” then buy and read a Koran.

  574. In order to understand Islam, one doesn’t need to read the Koran. One only needs to take a careful, unprejudiced look at life in Islamic countries. Or, even better, at the purest, least corrupted by Western influence implementation of Islam in modern times. I think you would agree with me that the Taliban regime in Afghanistan was exactly such an implementation of Islam. Would you like to live in Afghanistan under the Taliban? Would you like to deprive the women in your family of all opportunities to go to school, to pursue a career, to walk in the streets, to be able to see a doctor when they become ill? Would you enjoy attending public executions? Would you like to take part in the stoning of an adulteress? Would you like to be told what clothes to wear, what length beard? Would you like the government to deprive you of the last vestiges of your privacy by insinuating itself into every aspect of your personal life?
    As a Muslim, you probably would. But as a reasonable person you shouldn’t expect people from other cultures to wish that upon themselves.

  575. Natasha, I just wanted to say how sorry I am that those men did this to you, and to add my voice to those saying that your assault is entirely on them, not you. Thanks for speaking out.

    • I agree wholeheartedly. If I could donate to help you Natasha out of this terrible accident and to help you finish your project, I surely would.

  576. When someone wakes you up in the middle of the coldest, darkest night of the winter and complains how unbearable the heat of the sun has become, he is either calling you from halfway across the world or he is blind and sitting dangerously close to a blazing furnace.

    When someone tells you in the year 2012 that Islam is all about peace, he can be one of many things. He can be a Jewish liberal looking at the world and the approaching Holocaust through the pink glasses of political correctness. He can be someone as ignorant and unwilling to learn as President Obama. He can be an unapologetic liar like Bill Clinton. He can be a ridiculously apologetic coward like Tony Blair. He can be a schizophrenic, because schizophrenics live in an alternate reality. And, last but not least, he can be a Muslim, because Dar el-Islam is an alternate reality.

    Maybe, Islam is all about love? I don’t think so, because Islam is the only religion in the world whose followers routinely practice “honor killings” of members of their own families. It is also the only religion in the world that does not promise family members a reunion in the afterlife. Instead, it guarantees good Muslim men a free brothel for all eternity. It does not spell out the reward for virtuous women, but does specify that dead Muslims will be segregated by gender in their X-rated heaven. Wouldn’t a loving husband prefer to spend eternity surrounded by his family rather than fornicating like a priapic rabbit? He would, unless, of course, the loving husband in question is Muslim.

    Maybe, Islam is about high moral standards? Not really. Even if you decide to disregard the overwhelming corruption reigning in all Islamic countries, without a single exception, as a perversion of the true faith, you must know that wine, sexual pleasures, and everything else Islam declares taboo in this life, is promised in abundance in the next one. But if something is evil here, on our sinful earth, it must be even more evil in the pristine purity of heaven. Therefore, the wrongness of the act is not the reason for the prohibitions. What is then? Here’s my guess. If you forever prevent perfectly normal people from having fun, from enjoying their lives, they will be easier to control, easier to turn into “martyrs”. As you must know, this works wonderfully well.
    You must also know that in Muslim countries mullahs run prostitution rings by officiating temporary “marriages” between their customers and the hookers in full compliance with Sharia. You must have heard about Ayatollah Khomeini’s fatwas detailing what a man should do to an infant he raped or to domestic animals subjected to a similar treatment.
    Besides, even Mohammad himself didn’t rely on the high moral standards of his followers. He is quoted as saying, “When a man and a woman are in the same room together, the third person in that room is the devil.” I do not guarantee the accuracy of the quote (to the best of my knowledge, it is not found in either the Koran or Hadith), but I do know that it reflects the customary Muslim attitude: a person who has an opportunity to do wrong is not expected to resist the temptation. Don’t you think that such an attitude alone makes the average Muslim enormously more immoral than the average Western teenager who manages to spend a day of fun at the beach surrounded by half (or, rather, nine-tenth) naked females without ever being tempted to rape anyone?

    • Wow, look – I women was attacked by those who take on no responsibility for their actions. You turn it in to a book on a page that should be abt her.

      • So true. How distasteful and cheap to make this only about islam. Let’s remeber that this is first and foremost about a woman that was sexually molested because of no fault of her own.

    • Didi,
      I have lived, worked with, and befriended a number of Muslims in my life. Let me say that what Infidel said is correct in almost every point. While moderate Muslims exist, many of them are complicit in the actions of radicals and are next on the list to be attacked after extremism is done with Westerners. Even with Westernized Muslims, there is an attitude of disassociation with extremism that is unacceptable. As a society, we must plan our lives based on worst-case scenarios; this is the reason for the judicial system. What you are asking is that we ignore the radical Muslims and focus on the good ones. In happy-unicorn land, that approach is fine. In the real world, most of the Middle Eastern Islamic regimes are controlled by religious zealots that should not be trusted to take care of their people in a fair and honest fashion. All religions have their extremists and zealots, but the Islamic ones are the people who are actively engaging in violent attacks against other people. We cannot ignore the violence and oppression inherent in the practical application of Islam just because we want to be politically correct. Until Islam has reached the point where it no longer condones murdering people as an acceptable part of the faith, self-preservation dictates that we must be wary of anyone claiming the Muslim faith. Remember, Islam is judged by its adherents: earlier this year, a man in Saudi Arabia was put to death for “witchcraft and sorcery”. This is 2012. Saudi Arabia is one of the most powerful and wealthy Muslim nations in the world. If any Islamic country should be more modern, it should be Saudi Arabia but they are still following the old ways. People who judge Islam as a violent and extreme religion have plenty of factual evidence to support their claims. Just because you don’t agree doesn’t refute the facts.

      Natasha: I am so sorry for what happened to you. No one should ever have to go through what happened to you. You are very brave to have written about it and I wish you a speedy recovery.

    • Indeed, Infidel, the truth hurts. But political correct people look away from the truth, and the raped journalist is one of them. Sad but true!

  577. Fuerza, ser Periodista es una tarea muy dificil … realmente eres un ejemplo a seguir lamento de todo corazón lo que te ha sudedido, siento un dolor e impotencia pero gracias por compartir tu historia, en lo personal haces que tenga la suficiente valentia.

    Bendiciones

  578. This is just terrible and very sad to read. I hope you find peace and recover. I just wonder why you made these excuses to try and protect Egypt and Islam in your reporting. Would you have done the same if it happened in France, Japan, or Israel? The fact is it is just a flea bitten, third world country where the people are animals. Sorry, but been there and that is the truth.

    • Well because Vlad, some people understand people in other countries, and the nuance thinking and interacting it requires. Some just paint everyone with the same brush, and add to the insanity – just like those who attacked her. Get it?

      • Yes, very true!! First day in London, robbed and even had some racist throw a lighted matchstick at me simply because I wasn’t one of them and we had parked in an unknown area thinking it was safe, we were new there. Are all people from the UK this way? I don’t think so.

      • @Mary/Just

        What about her reporting about the countless and relentless mobs didn’t you get. This isn’t some football match, but rather in their main square for their elections. What culture these Egyptian Islamist have and how lucky thet are to have apologists like you!

    • I do not believe Egypt, Islam or the Middle East has the copyright on immorality. Who created the Atomic Bomb? Holocaust anyone? The IRA/UVF? Open any British or American newspaper any day of the week and you will find stories that will leave you questioning what has happened to the world?

      I am not defending their actions, I am taking issue with your vile and ill-informed opinion.

    • ‘Vlad’ You are quite frankly an idiot. Thousands of rapes happen all over every country in the world by men of all race and religious faith but one doesn’t find themselves slating the country and the whole population of people. How can the whole country be held accountable? What you’re saying is countries like England or France where horrific crimes go on regularly contain only animals.
      I pity your stupidity.

      • Oh sure. Mass mob rapes that seem common. They just happen all the time all over the world. if you are so certain make this choice: where would you send a beloved femle (and attractive) relative to take a mid-da, city-centre stroll: Cairo, London, Atlanta, Beijing or Mexico City….I rest my case!

      • I really am not sure where you went with that. She took a risk for her job out of her own choice like many people would do in all circumstances, it just so happened it ended up so unfortunate. However I shan’t waste my time arguing with such a poorly opinionated character, as is yourself. Though I will leave you with a tip; perhaps get educated to rid you of your ignorance.

    • Sounds like you can’t read. He said she put herself in danger by going to a place filled with misogynistic assholes.

    • Sounds lke you’re an imbecile, as he said he has no sympathy for her getting violently assaulted.

      Although to be fair, you sound like birds of a feather; I shouldn’t expect you to exceed your abilities.

    • I’m sure your parents are very proud to have raised someone without empathy.

      Being a decent human, how does it fucking work.

  579. @Spam909 lets just pray you get hit by a bus or something soon, you’re waisting the rest of the worlds oxygen, your nothing but a cock, infact cock is too nicer word for you, you are pure scum, the lowest of the low…go get a life retard!!

  580. What a stupid comment.
    People like you are spam, just like the name you are using.
    Natasha, Please accept my apology and the apologies of all Egyptians.

  581. Hy Natasha

    First of all the things that happened to you were terrible. That shouldn’t happen to ANYONE , blonde or black equally.

    Now to my second point, why have you written this turn of events so graphically? Do you want sympathy or publicity. I read some where that another journalist from USA was also molested in a similar fashion in the square. After she came back to US, she wrote about it, her colleagues wrote even more and finally her pictures were all over and then she was invited to some political campaign and she went smiling with her husband in a back less dress. She might even write a book for couple of million of dollar about the event.

    I find it very confusing, where the dignity ends and where commercial interest takes over !!

    You blog seems like a chapter from the soft porn book “50 shades of Grey” only that it happened to you in real. If it did happen, blog it in a sensible dignified way.

    Look at your words from your blog ..I copied it below :

    “”Men pulled my blonde hair – a beacon of my alien identity.

    But if that was the cause, it was only really used as a pretext, an excuse, to molest and violate a blonde young Western girl.””

    What if you were black, what if you were ugly and fat and had a nose like Charles Bukowski .. and what if those men did the same thing to you then .. would this column be still that Juice ?

    Joe

    • Joe, your comments are disgusting. A “survivor” of sexual assault has every right to tell her story, whether you want to hear/read it or not. People heal in different ways. It is not for you to determine how a victim of sexual assault should react. As for Lara Logan raised awareness, this survivor is coping as best she can and has decided to remove the victim stigma and move into survivor mode.

    • Your comments make me sick, frankly. To question the motive of a woman who has made it her cause to liberate women from the evils of backward men and who is, by chance, exploited by that same violence, is disgusting.

  582. My heart goes out to you, I have been a victim of assault and the fear and powerlessness still haunts me. Having lived in the Middle East, my experience is that foreign women are “fair game” and regarded as worthless, if not more so, than a convict or rabid dog. I feared for not only myself but my PRIMARY SCHOOL aged children who would be leered at on the beach by men stroking their crotches at the sight of a four year old girl in shorts. It was horrifying and frightening, I applaud any attempt to improve the situation for women and girls. Sadly the changes need to come from within these misogynist communities ……I doubt this will happen within my life time

    • Spam, how about you all fuck off and take your nasty asses from our western world!!! No one wants you in Europe or USA, so get lost with your so called culture where you can just assult anyone and rapeing children or animals is normal, and take your vile religion with you!!!! Why are you coming to live in UK and push your dirtiness on us? Fuck off!!!!

      • Is this your culture to talk like this? No, just like you there are always some bad people in every society!

      • This for you Sandra:
        Is this your culture to talk like this? No, just like you there are always some bad people in every society!

      • “A Muslim woman” is right. There are “good” and “bad” people in every country and every society – it is deeply disturbing to read so much hate on this thread. Is hate “good” or “bad”? How we treat others is a reflection of ourselves and that includes how we communicate with one another – right here on this blog.

      • I am verey sorry for you Natasha , please accept my support .
        dont hear frome the unti Islam people , the hate moving them .
        what happend there is not by the Islam name , you are jurnalist and sure you heared about alot of same crimes in all the socities
        in palestine alot of foregners came daily sleeping , eating , talking with us , nothing happend .
        hoped if shoot them by your camera to judge them soon
        my support for ever to you

      • Islam = respect
        If you experience true Islam; you would just love it. believe me.
        TC

      • Excuse me , Please let me tell you something .
        As a Muslim know my religion i would like to reply to your comment .
        Islam has no relation for what happened in this story !!
        There’re many women who’re raped by christians , jews , unbelievers men .
        The problem is on persons not on Islam .
        Islam forbid rape and violation and even to touch a woman .

        ” Be gentle when you deal with bottles”
        This statement was said to men to recommend them to deal gently and respectively with (bottles) that means ( Women ) in this recommend .
        The relation between women and bottles here is that both are fine and need a nice treatment .

        Another quote says :
        ” Be kind with women , The Woman is created from a rib , and the most crooked part of the *rib* is the top of it , So if you tried to make *it* straight instead of being crooked you’ll cause it to be broken , and if you let it be as normal as it was created it’ll stay crooked , So be kind with women ”
        This statement recommend men to be kind with women as the woman is created from the ((crooked)) rib near the heart and this indicates that she’s ((fine and nice)) and need a special nice treatment , not a tough treatment that causes her to be hurt and also indicates that she protects the heart of the man and if you tried to make this ( crooked part of the rib ) straight and break it you’ll cause the protected heart to be unprotected .

        Both of the 2 quotes are recommended by Prophet Muhamed PBUH to Muslim men who must obey them .

        Thank you dear and really i hope you study Islam truly to know the truth .
        Greets ,
        Shrouk 🙂

        Peace .

      • What’s marvelous about your reply is that you Do NOT even Realize how sexist you are being, with the bottles, rib, etc – of course Islam is a pig-sty of ideas, it is violent and misogynistic. The prophet was an illiterate jerk who married a 7yr. old and consummated that marriage when the girl was 9yrs old.. what ideology drives this religion if anybody’s guess.

      • I am created from the most crooked part of a rib??? Yes, now I know! Islam respects me!!! And men have to treat me nicely because I am sort of handicapped? By God in the heavens, this is worse than national socialism in discriminating a group of people.

      • Islam also forbids the killing of virgins; what ‘s the solution in Iran? They first rape them, then they kill them! If Islam doesn’t allow this, why is no-one doing anything about this practice by the Red Guard (or whatever their name is)???

  583. Wow. All it was were fingers? I think you overblown the term rape… this has happened before, yet you were smart enough to go into the fire yet again.

    Why did you make a choice that you knew what the result was going to be, and yet you act surprised and angered over the result? Admit the fault of going there in the first place. That’s like stepping into a firefight and getting mad because you got shot.

    • Ladies and gentlemen, here we have it: it was HER fault an entire mob of men tried to fucking kill her. Bravo! You’re officially the Worst Man Alive, please collect your prize (a .45 to the temple) and leave this plane of existence!

      • Big ups! THis man is clearly not much better than the rapists themselves. Stand up to violence against women and Islam!

    • People like you should be jailed just for comments like that…A.S.S.H.O.L.E., I hope you dont have sister or daughters…I really feel sorry for your mother to have giving birth to such a low, worthless, or evil person like you.

      • NOONE deservs to go to jail because of what he/she has said. But the idiot John Joe does deserve a big punch in the face. Free of charge!

    • “All it was were fingers?”

      Are you seriously trying to say that the act carried out on this poor woman would’ve been easier to accept it it was a male penis instead of fingers forcing into her? Does it make a difference whether it was fingers, a male penis or even something like a feather. Rape is rape, forced entry of sexual nature without permission. You cannot categorize fingers as a lesser of a case then a penis, its purely idiotic and vile.

      Like ‘pedrevans’ said what if it was your sister/moth er/friend/wife/girlfriend/daughter, would you be treating it as if it was THEIR fault that some archaic monster thought they had the right to force themselves upon a woman whilst other men basically held her down unable to fight back and to throw her around as though she was prize? No, you’d be blood-thirsty at the thought of someone touching someone you care about in such a sickening way.

      Maybe you need to think about THAT before you go brandishing around phrases like ‘Admit the fault of going in there in the first place’ She was doing her job which she is entitled to do, regardless of her nationality, race or hair colour.

      She’s the victim in all of this, those who committed the crime are not even worth a single breath of oxygen.

    • She did nothing wrong. She was doing what normal people think they should do, and had people with her as well. You, on the other hand sound just like the crazies who attacked her. Perhaps you are? This is exactly how they think.

  584. Having read your post through three times, I have come to the conclusion that this alleged event was all in your mind and that you made the whole thing up. Your description of the events sounds more like some male pervert fantasising with his hand in his pocket than the genuine recollections of a female sexual assault victim..

    • This just in: white (judging by the name) man calls woman out for fabricating rape story.

      The implication that such accounts of sexual assault only exist for male sexual gratification is disgusting and abhorrent. You know NOTHING of the assault and abuse that women face in Egypt on a daily basis.

      You sexist, chauvanist pig. YOU are the disgusting pervert.

      • So true. As a man I am disgusted to be of the same sex as the above commenter.

    • I TOTALLY AGREE !

      THIS IS A FAKE BLOG !!

      THESE THINGS NEVER HAPPENED. The way the blog has been made juicy , I agree its written by some pervert ….

      • I think your name is fake and you are not Joe, but some Mohammed trying to cover up the filth you believe in.
        Eat shit , ‘ Joe ‘

      • @bozo, now here is a “Mohammed” replying to you,
        we do not believe in filth, we do not believe that women’s bodies are “free for all” , we actually believe that it is forbidden to have premarital sex or even touch another woman’s body, hell, it is even forbidden to look at another woman’s body of even face unless it is a must (read: a doctor ).
        But not all of us are believers, rapists are found all over the world and Egypt and other muslim majority countries are no exception .

      • True, rape is everywhere. Yet the statistics show higher rates in Muslim countries. How come?
        Stoning, disfiguring privates, honor killing and groping is something not so common in non islamic countries. How come?
        And you know what really fascinates me? how come Muslims living in the Western world keep up with this kind of immoral behaviour?
        ( statistics here: http://wikiislam.net/wiki/Muslim_Statistics_%28One_Page_View%29 )

        Let’s be clear, not all muslims are to be judged, but why not take a good
        look at the facts and ask yourselves, why islam is feared and hated in
        western society? because we need a scapegoat? or because the majority
        of people in muslim countries have a belief system that conflicts with our
        morals? I’m not islamophobic btw; I despise religion in general and Islam
        the most since it is still keeping entire continents in medieval times. People
        , all people deserve more than that.

      • @Bozo,
        Again, Islam itself forbids these action, but the lack of religious morals in addition to ignorance forced by bureaucratic regimes aided by western governments are the cause of these actions, keep in mind that most of these regimes actually benefit from keeping the people in this state as opposed to more morally aware because only then they will have the ability to resist their oppression, and this also explains the very aggressive islamophobic movements carried out from these regimes inside and outside their countries

      • Forbidden? polygamy, oppression of women, jihad, pedophilia, harassment forbidden, stoning? by what law? In what book? Please help me out with quotes from the noble Qur’an cause I think you are talking about a different Islam and as far as I know there’s only one;)

        ( and yes, I know there are Muslims that despise all of the above, but they
        are either educated, wealthy or not practising religion very seriously. )

  585. ‘Chapeau’, Natasha, for your bravery, integrity and sheer decency. And for your moral and physical bravery.
    Wishing you all the best in your recovery from this vile ordeal (which won’t, can’t be, easy) and for your future career (which starts now, camera or no!).
    The world needs reporters like you, now more than ever.
    ‘Bon courage’ – and a big hug.

  586. I am an Egyptian woman, I cant believe your comment, this is disgraceful. Calling her a liar like that. Honestly, think before you type, whether there are cameras in Tahrir or not, whether we heard about it from the media or not. This is an experience, an experience of terror, of humiliation, of pain, and of oh, so much disrespect by Egyptian men. She also stated that this isn’t Egypt at all, she doesn’t think that all Egyptians are like that. Not only are you confirming and contributing to that image those men gave her, you are also making it worse. Have some empathy!! If you don’t think its true, then just don’t comment. This isn’t a trial here, some one wanted to share an awful experience. Let her be!

    • Natasha, I’m so sorry about what you had to go through in Tahrir square, I really respect the fact that you still manage to see the good side of Egypt and the Egyptians, if it were me, I don’t think I could do that. And again, I am so so sorry. I am apologizing on behalf of all Egyptians. Lets just hope that after this revolution that is a call to a change to everything, everything does change.

  587. Women were crying and telling me “this is not Egypt! This is not Islam! Please, please do not think this is what Egypt is!”

    And yet, this is not the first, nor will it be the last incident of this type there. Something is terribly wrong when women need to cover every inch of their bodies covered AND have male protection just to move around safely.

  588. Natasha,
    You have been Muslimmed.
    This could not be a surprise for you since I am sure you read about Lara Logan’s recent Muslimization which sounds identical to yours.
    Those brave Egyptian men were merely helping you understand the teachings of that murdering pedophile Mohammed (may Jesus shit in his mouth) who raped his second “wife” Aisha when she was only nine years old.
    You would be using your time more profitably if you stayed in England and fought the Muslimization of our beautiful country as witnessed in Bradford and Luton. It is only a matter of time before lovely white English girls suffer the same horror in the streets of England as you did in Egypt.

    • Susan, I’m so so sorry for your ignorance and arrogance, you cant say you’ve been Muslimed… you have no idea of Islam if you think that this is how they behave, people from all religions do mistakes, this kind of behavior doesn’t show Muslims, this behavior is a production of Mubaraks regime. Honestly, you too… Think before you type…

      • So we’ve heard poverty, we’ve heard SCAF-paid, we’ve heard lack of education and now it’s Mubaraks regime that makes men behave like pigs.
        Rather typical to accuse this woman of ignorance when you just added another poor excuse for the fact that sexual intimidation , rape and sexism is predominant in ALL Muslim countries.
        Why does none of you loving Muslims have the courage to acknowledge the wide spread issues of child abuse, sexual abuse, rape and sexism in your religion? Covering up something that is clearly a mess, is just as evil as making the mess.

      • What you are describing is no different to what the Hutus did to the Tutsis, what the Serbs did to the Bosnians or what UN soldiers did to the African women and Girls they were charged with protecting. This has nothing to do with religion but men, most of whom are sexually repressed taking advantage of vulnerable women. The problem of pedophilia is not something confined to the muslim countries Western prison, in the US and Europe are full of predominantly Anglo American or Caucasian men. Churches all over the world have paid out Billions of dollars in compensation to adults who were molested by priests when they were younger. You need to take a long hard look at the society you live in and the monsters you create before you can are so quick to judge others.

      • Are you kidding? Middle eastern culture supports the rape and abuse of woman on a regular basis. I don’t care what muslims have to say about the merits of their religion. The key tenants of the religion do nothing to stop and may even encourage this behavior. Religion in general is dangerous, Islam is just the worst offender. I don’t think Muslims deserve to call themselves human, but thats just the hate talking.

      • @Bob, what kind of middle eastern culture are you talking about exactly? the middle east was doing fine before it got bombarded with Western Culture

        and have you forgotten the over sexualisation of almost everything in western countries turning children into sexual predators, who spend so much time watching porn on the internet that they are now acting out these fantasies on innocent girls.

      • Yes, teens watching porn is haram for you, we know. Porn is haram.
        Yet groping, raping , stoning and killing your wives and other’s is totally acceptable.
        Yes middle east was doing fine, because we never heard the cries of your
        women and children. You know, the little girls that are forced into
        marriage. We never heard of Sharia and never heard of your dictators.
        See no evil, hear no evil. But then we decided to a. rob your oil and b. try to impose our beliefs on you. And shit hit the fan. We should have send you tons of porn instead; would have saved us loads of tax money and the women your sexual harrassments.

      • Karma, we have nothing against wonderful Islam, only against Muslim behavior. (There must be going something wrong in the implementation). When ignorance and savagery are the results, it seems better to stop practicing that religion. During European history it turned out that people started behaving better after basing morals on the common good of the people rather than on religion. At first, nobody could believe it, but it turned out to be true after all 🙂

      • All of you have no idea whatsoever about Mubarak’s regime. Neither did I until I turned 17, and took a community psychology course at university. You have no idea what Islam is about either. Stop relating Islam to anything bad that happens, it has nothing to do with it, it is against all of it. The association you have of culture and religion is exactly like what illiterate people do here. So please open your mind a teeeennyyyy tiny bit and do some research about islam first before you type.

      • Susan,I would agree with Karma and also feel so sorry for your ignorance. May you please read more about Islam and about Profit Mohammed (peace be upon him) before you decide to make extremely false and offending statements like these. If you have a problem finding readings about that topic please let us know and we are willing to help you check some unbiased sources so you can make a wise judgement.

        Karma, chapeaux, I agree with what you said!

      • Charlotte, you have to think a bit more, poverty led to people not being able to get what they want. If you have nothing at all. Poverty leads to illiteracy, therefore very little thinking, it leads to unawareness, little knowledge about everything, leads to disgusting impulsive actions. They are all very horny men, and were not getting laid because of Mubarak’s regime, and the poverty it led to. Don’t even think for a second that Islam supports this shit behavior. I am and always have been against the way men act around here,
        1) its their fault – they are disgusting and give themselves the rights to do shit actions and then blame it on whatever
        2) their parents fault – for not being able to teach them the ABC morals and values of life
        3) Mubaraks fault – his regime led to extreme poverty
        4) the environments fault – to accept this behavior as being OK
        5) the governments fault – for not putting rules to punish this kind of behavior.
        Dont blame it on Islam, and being Muslim, this is where your arrogance and ignorance kills me. Do some research.

    • Susan, you are 100% right. It is just such as shame that by the time the majority of the UK realise it, it will be too late and our country will be ruined beyond repair. Maybe when all those do-good liberals witness their daughters attacked in this way on a daily basis and are powerless to do anything about it (as non-muslims will be in the minority) they will wish they had listened to us.

      • You are all talking about a society that has been in extreme poverty, extreme oppression, extreme illiteracy and all that is due to fucking Mubarak. It has nothing at all to do with Islam. I personally know a girl that was a virgin who was raped by an Egyptian who’s Christian, I never even thought that it was his religion that pushed him to do that. These are all actions that were a result of the old regime. Think before you type people, its a very easy request.

      • Karma, there is no financial gain from raping someone, so how is poverty the justification? I think it is you that you should think before you type.

        You state you are an Egyptian woman, so I can only assume that your ridiculous reasoning links back to what a commenter has said above “Infidel on June 27, 2012 at 6:02 pm said: Has there ever been a Muslim Newton? Or a Muslim Shakespeare? Or a Muslim Mozart? Or a Muslim Mother Teresa? A few Muslim names that I can name, like al-Khwarimi, could shine only in the darkness of the Dark Ages”.

        It seems clear to most educated people in the West that muslims are simply not capable of thinking at all, so your comment to me suggesting that I think before I type is quite ironic.

      • On just judges a tree by its fruits, in this case a savage gang-rape, good intentions are not worth very much. BTW prosperity is build on trust, civility and honesty, poverty is the result of corruption and savagery. If you think Islam is a noble religion, you just don’t understand Western civilization.

  589. Natasha,

    Tell me what you need? What can the documentary community in New York City do to help you? You must finish your film. People, resources, time?

    • Actually, god did bless her, and this is what your god allowed to happen to her. Please don’t invoke the name of a deity responsible for creating rapists and sexual assaulters. Duh.

  590. ACTION CAMPAIGN:

    1) On Friday 6th July, let’s all meet at Midan Talaat Harb at 1.30pm, bringing as many of our relatives and friends as we can possibly gather., to go into Tahrir Square. [It was originally planned for this Friday, but we need more time to join together with other groups and get the word out: we need a large, strong presence for this to work]

    2) Advertise and share the event through all our Facebook pages, spread Natasha’s report in Arabic and English.

    3) Paint or print 10 flags, with the “woman” symbol, saying “Safe Point” in English and Arabic.

    4) We need at least one Safe Point to be set up under the flags, with lots of guards to protect women protestors and journalists. Guards should be armed with pepper spray if possible, and certainly with bright neon pink spray paint, and handcuffs. Anyone who attacks the Safe Point will be ideally put out of action ready for arrest; failing that, marked and his clothes ruined with spray paint.

    5) Let’s get some cheap flyers in Arabic, explaining that we are trying to protect women protestors, and asking people to please detain any man marked with pink spray paint for questioning.

    6) If we get enough volunteers, let’s give some phone numbers for women to call (or a Twitter account), to be escorted in and out of Tahrir to the Safe Point.

    7) We also need some volunteer observers to mingle with the crowd and look for any suspicious groups or behaviour, please.

    We have a budget of 900LE, donated by two other women and myself. Does anyone have a printer friend who would do the flyers at cost price, please?

    We need someone to write a flyer text in Arabic, and/or people to paint flags.

    MOST IMPORTANT: we need a good event text in Arabic calling for volunteers, which everyone can post to their Facebook status/Twitter and ask everyone to spread the word.

    I have one friend in the Police…anyone have any contacts for trustworthy police who can wait in a van nearby Tahrir ready to arrest any assaulting criminals we catch? There may be SCAF-paid rape gangs, and the police in general are unsympathetic, so we don’t want to call on random police.

    Anyone, anywhere in the world can help by spreading news of the event via Twitter and Facebook. Those who have used Natasha’s blog to promote one religion or another are particularly welcome to do this, to support her and other women, and prove there’s more to being religious than simply criticising the religions of others.

    Yalla, let’s go: please join this Facebook group…but only if you will take an ACTIVE part in some way. THANK YOU! 🙂
    https://www.facebook.com/groups/129672763810060/

    • Nice initiative Amanda , but don’t discredit all which has been said as narrow minded empty criticism.
      ” Those who have used Natasha’s blog to promote one religion or another are particularly welcome to do this, to support her and other women, and prove there’s more to being religious than simply criticising the religions of others.”

      What doctors and nurses and other people behaved with the assaulted woman is a representative of the cultural/society dominant beliefs ( harmful or helpful to humanity is something for you to decide for yourself) , Mention of SCAFs and Rogue POLICE only diverts the larger issue in the land.

      • Thank you. Assaults like this have been happening for ages in Egypt. Don’t make it a SCAF thing. It’s an issue of society.
        And nobody promoted other religions; people simply responded to the ignorant comments stating this behaviour has nothing to do with Muslim beliefs since Christians rape too, when all the facts are stating otherwise.
        That’s not promoting Christianity. It’s argumentation for the poor excuses you made.

        It’s not poverty
        It’s not SCAF
        It’s not worldwide

        It ‘s ISLAM providing a great set of rules to attack, hurt and degrade women.
        You can’t fight the cause if you ignore the source.
        Happy spraypainting…

      • I mention SCAF and the police, because they are relevant and important practical issues here…as you would know, if you knew anything at all about Egypt.

        Egypt has a terrible and widespread problem with sexual harassment…which I’ve created a group to combat. What are YOU doing to help address the problem? Victim-bashing and religious debate are the opposite of helpful, in case you were wondering.

    • I dont agree with you about the role of Islam in all of this, but I would be willing to donate hard cash to your extremely worthy cause. I am in Sweden,so it’s the only way i can help. Is there somewhere I can donate? This madness makes me sad, so sad. To think of all the egyptian women we never hear about… Truly horrible.

      • That’s very kind, thank you Libertarian. 🙂

        The protest is over now. It went really well…we had the support of the Tahrir crowd, who chanted with us, tons of local and international press (front page of Le Monde, Foreign Policy, papers in Canada, India, Jordan, Lebanon, Indonesia and articles coming out soon in Sweden and Spain, too).

        Our next initiative is called WhistleStop: we want to sell rape whistles with an anti-harassment message at cost price to raise awareness. We don’t currently have any mechanism to raise money (I used to work for Save the Children Fund to stringent regulations which makes me nervous of just calling for donations). Besides, we only need a small amount to buy the first batch, then the rest should be self-financing after that.

        What would be great would be to spare 10 minutes once or twice a week to lending support and raising awareness about the issue. If you can spare the time, please join this group: https://www.facebook.com/groups/shagegypt/

        Thank you again, it’s a very lovely and generous offer. 🙂

  591. I could not finish your story till the end, i did not make it i am sorry it’s too horrible.
    But please accept my mean-less apology to you as an Egyptian man. And my advise to you never come to this jungle again, it’s my country but it’s an impossible place to live in. I am sorry again.

  592. um really sorry :((((((((((((
    I know that its not enough!!!!!!! :((((((((
    we are sorry for you!!!! :((((((((

    • Dear Natasha, I am so sorry to hear what you have had to endure at the hands of those disgusting men. You sound such a strong, courageous young woman, I am sure you will make a good recovery but it will take time.

      I am so disheartened to read the derogatory comments on here. It does make me wonder how people can stoop so low. Don’t let them get to you as they believe they are safe and anonymous on the internet but there have been cases now where such vile people have been traced and brought to justice. May they get what they deserve.

      Sam, I read your blog and it makes me sad to realise everything you have said is true. I have had plenty of bad experiences, mistreatment by men. Despite us supposedly living in a modern society, they still have animal instincts and urges that they don’t always try to control. I don’t think the media helps at all in this respect.

  593. regardless of the intellectual smack down going on in the comments above, i think you are incredibly brave. and if and when it catches up to you, i hope you would remember that despite the violation that happened to you, they did not take anything from the beauty of your soul or your self-respect and motivation. but they gave you strength and determination. as an egyptian woman forced daily to deal with sexual harassment and the more painful, the little consideration society pays to this, i understand. please stay strong, God bless u.

  594. Dear Natasha,

    All my support and sympathy.

    Thank you for sharing this story which I guess it hasn’t been easy at all for you to write.

    I hope you finish you documentary and it becomes a great success.

    Oscar (from Barcelona)

  595. Why are you hanging out in that fucked up part of the world anyway? That whole area is full of animals and monsters and this proves it. That whole section of the world should be turned to glass.

  596. i am really sorry, no apologize would cover a fraction of what you face, i am glad you know what is the true Egypt, there is no excuse for what happened to you and there is no justification i could tell you reasons..this is the accumulation of decays of ignorance and poverty…people without hope and ambition, a generation raised to follow and only to follow, and suddenly their slayer is gone.. they don’t know what to do anymore, a wild dog in a city than wants to bite every walking creature. but we are to blame. we didn’t do much efforts with people in need, and the need are not always in material. majorly its no morals i am so sorry.

      • I wonder how much poverty you’ve lived with? It’s shameful to me that safe, middle-class Westerners are saying that living circumstances which they have never had to face could not possibly cause this behaviour but a religion that they also know nothing about could. Utterly shameful.

    • You feel safe to assume I know nothing about Islam? I wonder what arguments you have for that rapid conclusion.
      I also would like to hear your arguments for the conclusion that poverty is the cause for decades of sexism and sexual abuse in Muslim countries.
      It’s funny how rather rich Muslim countries display the exact same figures and such behaviour is not seen in poor parts of this world that are not muslim.

      Please do bestow me with your intelligence.
      Cleopatra would turn over in her sarcophagus…

      • Bozo, I would not even bother arguing with this ignorant liberal idiots. The statistics speak for themselves – it is an insult to animals to even call muslims animals in my opinion – they are the lowest of the low and have no worth to any society, least of all Britain. Let’s face it, what has been produced by any muslim society other than hate? Have they contributed towards advancements in technology or medicine? No, the only education they know is in their shitty little book. I would not waste my time even conversing with them, or the liberal blind idiots who support them and their sick way of life.

      • Charlotte, i couldnt agree with you more!!! More and more of them in Britain, why do we let them in?

      • I can’t agree more with Charlotte.

        There is a book sitting on my desk, “The Legacy
        of Jihad” by Dr. Andrew Bostom. Its cover is adorned with a depiction of the massacre of the Jews of Medina. Presiding over the massacre is the non-prophet himself, along with his (if I am not mistaken) cousin, Ali, and their faceless wives. You don’t need to be an art expert to realize that it is a Muslim painting. Produced in the 19th century, it betrays its author’s complete ignorance of the laws of perspective and other basic techniques used by European artists for many centuries. Flames in that painting look like a plywood model of a cactus, and it takes an effort to figure out which of the victims are already down and which are still standing.

        In short, this Islamic masterpiece does not quite reach the level of sophistication achieved by Cro-Magnon artists some 30,000 years earlier. Nevertheless, it provides an accurate, even if artless, depiction of one of the many genocidal episodes comprising the entire history of Islam and the genocidal blood thirst that constitutes its essence. I have never heard that Muslims objected to that picture, even though their beloved fuehrer, if you look closely, appears to be severely constipated…

    • Before prosperity comes civilization, after savagery and corruption comes poverty. This is exactly what happens now in the Arab world. Next year Egypt will be pleading for food help from the West it so dispises.

      Conversely, prosperity does not necessarily make you a decent citizen, as can be observed by the stunning number of African Muslims that now make the streets of Europe unsafe.

  597. I am really sorry Natasha ……….
    I turned crazy after reading the article and i am really sorry…….
    but plz dont think all egyptians are like those animals but iam sorry and i wish to come back to egypt and i will be so happy to see u really ……

    and again i am so sorry ….

  598. Natasha,
    I’m so sorry that happened to you. I hope that once home, you can access the resources you would like, whether they be legal, medical, counseling, or just some good friends to listen.

    Moreover, I am so sorry for the vitriolic and hurtful things many people have said on this page, from attacks at you to unfair and uninformed statements about Egyptians, Muslims and Arabs. I am impressed by your ability to see the negative actions of some Egyptians as belonging to those specific Egyptians, and not to all–that is impressive, especially so soon after the trauma.

    Finally, while there are certainly ways for women and journalists to protect themselves in large crowd situations, I hope you do not blame yourself for the many attacks, as some of your closing words suggest. While perhaps you could have been more cautious, no one ever has the right or the excuse to do what was done to you. Contrary to what often feels the case, it is not your responsibility to not be attacked–it is everyone’s responsibility not to hurt each other. That sounds simplistic, but sometimes we all forget that everyone has agency, and the people who hurt you are the ones to blame for their decisions to hurt you.

    I hope you get some rest and support back home.

    delia

  599. Dear Natasha,
    I am so sorry to hear that this happenend and was deeply distressed by your story.
    My wife and I are UK cits living in Cairo and whilst we too find this a generally friendly and welcoming city, the attitudes towards women are often sickening.
    Just wanted to say that our thoughts are with you and your family.

    Andrew

    *To those who have posted some pretty disgusting comments about this story, and made wild accusations, shame on you.

  600. Terrible event. Terrible for all. I’m glad you got out of it alive and in one piece but the shock of your experience will begin to settle in over time and it won’t be easy.

    A couple of thoughts regarding the comments here.

    Not sure why anyone would doubt this story. It is unfortunately all too familiar.

    Rape is worldwide, but to say that large mob sexual attacks erupting at the snap of finger in public daylight happen everywhere is untrue. It only happens with frequency in certain places, like Egypt for instance as we’ve seen in cases before.

    It is unfair to smear an entire people for this evil crime. But dear Egyptians, please you must ask yourself why is it so easy? What promotes this in your selves? Your sons? Your brothers? And yes, your husbands.

    The world would love a good outcome of your elections but the hard line of the person Morsi who won just set Egypt back about 1,000 years.

  601. Your story has left me breathless, I wish you healing and courage to carry on. I haven’t read all the comments, some of them are outrageous and are not written by human beings; focus only on those who will give you strength and stand with you, not those you must fight. You are being strong now, there will be days when you don’t feel so strong, when you don’t want to be so strong, when you can’t be so strong – that’s ok. We all heal in different ways, to different timescales, and sometimes we go backwards to go forwards. Every day is a win.

    At the end of your blog, you seem to blame yourself. You say “to anyone taking risks, whether in the UK or worldwide, please, take care, and don’t make the same mistakes. Don’t be swept up in a wave of euphoria. Don’t let anything cloud your judgement. I was not focused enough …” I say, rubbish! You did NOTHING to cause this to happen to you, other people did this to you. Don’t let rape apologists make you feel any blame, it wasn’t you.

    Big hugs, in solidarity. x

  602. What an appalling and stomach-churning experience you have survived. Thank you for bravely sharing your story- one that an unfortunately huge number of women have in some way experienced. I hope that you never ever think that you were in some way to blame for the violence that was acted upon you, and I wish you all the strength in the world as you navigate through the aftermath of your attack. You are not alone.

  603. Pingback: Sexual Harassment- Take III « The Irish Alexandrian Speaks Up And Out from Egypt

    • hello every one there. AM faith, I found a great spell caster on line who helped me to get back my husband who has left me for pass 3 years. we where married for 5 years without a child and my friend introduce me to a real spell caster named Dr.stone which I never believe it exist but after the meeting of this spell caster my problem where solved and now I am with my husband who left me for pass three years my life and my entire family are now happy now I have two kids with the help of this great spell caster. thanks to doctor cooland I will advice anyone in need of help to contact him with this email:shamuspiritualtemple@gmail.com.

  604. Let’s assume that the story is true and verifiable (which we don’t know,but let’s assume it is).

    Can we blame Egyptian society for what happened? Let’s assume that yes, Egypt is in many aspects a very patriarchal and sexist society.

    Can we blame the current state of affairs in Egypt? Well indeed, mobs of out-of-control folks going postal on an alleged female-alien (possibly half naked to their standards in case she wasn’t adequately covered) for what they perceive to be a provocation can be blamed, although in a state of communal frenzy, where the collective state of mind is so unstable, anything really can go as a provocation for a mob to consummate such cathartic violence. Everything else is poor excuses, there is just an animal desire for retaliation , sexual empowerment and the weakest victim available shall be the chosen

    Can we blame the Western support of a regime that has squeezed its own people so badly to leave them in such a collective mental state? I guess western interventionism always answers to western interests , so , even if the intention wasn’t to provoque this situation, the west is accountable to a extent for many of their foreign policies (and to the full extent for some of them too). But again, international relationships are not exactly motivated for the common good of the international community. Is a rat race, that is.

    But ultimately, can we blame the self-depicted blonde western non religious journalist female for getting into such trouble? Well, if it wasn’t because we are ourselves in a collective state of blindness and political correction we should assume that westerners are incredibly naive, arrogant and plainly stupid for pretending that their moral standards and points of view should be hold accountable in every single scenario. I am sorry, but I can not feel pity for the victim. I can feel proud of her (or alternatively think of her as incredibly stupid ) , for having the balls (or the desire of attention and recognition) to try to do her job in an environment that any first grader would see as decidedly hostile and extremely dangerous (such as a convulse, revolution-fresh , male dominated mass society of sexist and savage religious nuts) It would be the equivalent of feeling proud for a journalist that got caught in the middle of a violent mob in any single scenario. Being physically and sexually abused is the least of the things that could happen to you in such scenario. Being severely mutilated or even killed in a horrific way could have equally easily happened to anyone. Don’t even need to be sexually or racially profiled (but being sexually and racially profile only adds up more to the story)

    So please, blonde western female journalists, stay the hell out of post-revolutionary mobs in Islamic republics if you want to avoid being assaulted. That I need to explain this, somehow doesn’t speak much of this lady’s intelligence.

    I find particularly funny how many ethnocentric clichés she writes in her description. I feel sorry for Egyptian society, as I feel sorry for any society that is crumbling apart.

    I feel sorry for Egyptian women as I feel sorry for every women that are victims of established social violence against them.

    And Natasha, I hope my comments did not offend you. What was done to you can not be justified or forgiven, but can be explained and prevented to happen again. Journalists must be much more aware of the risks of their (our) profession.

    I am not saying that you should stop being involved in delicate and perilous scenarios, only that you should try to minimize the risks where possible.

    • And Natasha, I hope my comments did not offend you.

      No, I’m sure she’s grateful that you’d donate such an insightful contribution to her website, just as I’m sure Egyptian women will be grateful that you are sorry for them.

      I figure she’s now duly chastised and has taken note on your expert advise on Middle Eastern sartorial conventions and the inconveniences connected with being a woman in Egypt. Maybe she could hire you as an advisor on the documentary of abuse of women in Egypt that she’s making?

    • Louis, your comment is disgusting. Look in the mirror, change your attitudes towards women and towards other human beings. No one asked you for that comment…why would you volunteer something so unsympathetic, pointless and empty?

      • And who asked for yours?
        Look in the same mirror you suggested him. I finally understand why you get all wound up about Islam critics, you are either just that stupid or you simply live by Sharia, telling others repeatedly what they can or cannot say.

    • Yesterday , after reading this horrifying story I put a comment ..and I have bee seeing it is inappropriate to go in politics …but as you did Louis ..so I think something must be discussed about what ‘s going on in Egypt …I agree ..we have a cultural crisis ..but we used – before 1/25/11 to live in a very safe country ..with decent people generally ..during the revolution ,what happened is that 75 ٪ of the police power had been destroyed .. Can you imagine a country of 90 million ..almost without a police ?!..what happened to Natasha is part of the cauos that hits Egypt since last year , when she went to Al Tahrir it was the celebration of the MB because their nominee was elected president , and you know what …the Obama administration and Clinton made pressure to declare him president ..which is very strange !! I used to be opposition to Mubarak’s regime but the worst scenario to me and to all the Egyptian liberals is to replace the old regime with the MB …I ask all Americans to oppose the Obama ‘s policy in the Midle east , especially Egypt ,and urge him to stop backing the Mb under the name of democracy ..and i am sorry Natasha again and again.

      • Another apologist. No sir, when I was in Cairo in the early eighties of the last century, women could not go through through the city without being harassed too.

    • Harsh but true Louis! Natasha thanks for sharing your story I hate what happened to you and you have my full sympathy but as Louis said stay away from a post-revolutionary male-dominated society like Egypt. If you insist on finishing this documentary then for heavens sake be smarter, cover up completely and don’t mingle in crowds! From a muslim Egyptian female who thankfully immigrated to Canada!!

    • You don’t feel bad for someone who was horrifically assaulted? And you think this was an appropriate thing to tell her on her very brave and stomach-churning account of the event? You rape apologising cunt go the fuck away.

  605. Dear Natasha , I am an Egyptian women who sufferred alot from sexual harrasment and abuse when I was in my country therefore I totally understand exactly how u feel,it is an existing problem that most of the women of my country sufferrd from it has nothing to do with being muslim or Egyptian , it’s the result of poor neglected naive people who were manipulated by others , I AM Sorry if that counts for anything but from what I read you are a brave strong smart woman who will turn this to a milestone in her life .
    Please watch an Egyptian movie called 678 and u will know exactly what women suffer on a daily basis in Egypt

  606. Ms. Smith,

    Thank you for sharing your horrific experience. I hope and pray that your courage will encourage and strengthen other women who have been assalted as well, regardless of where, who, when, and how.

    God bless,
    Adrian A. Bernal

  607. This is an absolutely horrifying post – its terrifying to think how prevalent sexual assault and rape are in all of our societies (regardless of gender, race, religion). It is so sad to think that any human being can treat another with such violence, and that others find ways to justify their actions. My love and thoughts with you Natasha.

  608. The people on this thread exploiting this horrific assault on Natasha to express their hatred & bigotry against Muslims are utterly revolting ignorant hypocrites. You don’t give a damn about Natasha or any women on the receiving end of any assault or other oppression. You just love puffing out your chests indulging in fake moral outrage and self-righteous blowhard bullshit against a billion people on the planet, your fellow human beings.

    You conveniently ignore the Muslim men who tried to help Natasha, protect her and save her. You conveniently ignore the CENTURIES of Muslims living normal lives in the US, UK, and other western democratic countries who don’t go around in gangs attacking and raping women.

    You conveniently ignore the HUGE numbers of daily rape statistics in countries like South Africa which is NOT a Muslim-dominated country.

    The notion that rape is some kind of Muslim invention–that Muslims are INNATE rapists by virtue of their religious beliefs whereas the rest of humanity are civilized and anti-rape is juge BULLSHIT.

    Do you hear of Muslim men attacking women in gange in crowds like this in other Muslim countries? What about the CHRISTIAN men in Egypt who also behave this way?

    I lived as a student in Egypt in the late 80s for a year – I am not Muslim. I experienced sexual harrassment just as I experienced it in Latin America (I’m originally from Brazil). But I never was assulted or threatened. Tho I did feel quite threatened more than once while in college in the USA.

    Just STOP this disgusting opportunistic use of Natasha’s suffering for your own ideological ends. Your response to her ordeal has NOTHING at all to do with any “concern” over what she endured or any other women endures in Muslim countries. Since you despise Islam and Muslims, you despise Muslim women too, so you certainly don’t give a damn about any oppression they suffer.

    You just enjoy the feeling of hatred and consigning millions of people to subhuman animals so you can feel superior to them. Well this isn’t all about you.

    • You just love puffing out your chests indulging in fake moral outrage.

      “Fake”? That would even suggest that is revealing of your mindset. And this is not about Ms Smith, it’s about Egypt. There has been several incidents like this and if you keep it up, Tahrir Square will be associated with gang rape, not liberation.

      You conveniently ignore the CENTURIES of Muslims living normal lives in the US, UK, and other western democratic countries who don’t go around in gangs attacking and raping women.

      Muslims have not lived in the US and the UK for centuries and the DO go around raping women. In Oslo, the capitol of Norway, in the period 2007-2010, every single ‘assault rape’ – meaning a someone assaulting a stranger in the street – was a non-Western immigrant and 70% of the victims were ethnic Norwegian. The latter number is almost the most alarming because all criminological experience says that crimes are committed within communities, strongly suggesting that the perpetrators had sought out their victims for their ethnicity.

      And at the moment, somewhere around seventy Muslim men are undergoing trial in a spine-chilling case about systematic grooming and rape of under-age girls. Most of them ethnic British.

      And yes, such facts DO attract islamophobes, what did you expect? Should we all shut up about it?

      • Eric. What you said about Oslo can also be said for Sweden and the UK and the Netherlands: the victims are the same as in oslo and the perpetrators are the same as in Oslo. When the muslims attacked Vienna, they brought weapons and we could shoot them. Now they come with suitcases and apparently there is nothing we can do

      • The report featured only five (5 !) rapes perpetrated by people not related or known to the victim.

        No. The blog you refer to mentions five unique perpetrators in 2010 alone, not 2006-2009. (I gave the wrong interval above)

        That said, there are lots of problem with that blog, amongst other things the liberal use of the words ‘nazi’ and ‘zionist’ and the fact that just about the only thing it doesn’t link to, is the report it purports to be evidence of the lower number.

        According to the Oslo police department, the number for all three years are 41 rapes, mostly by Kurds or Somalis and since then the pattern has not changed and as Mikkel says, the picture is pretty much the same in Sweden. Wouldn’t know about the UK.

      • Recent report says that victims and perpetrators of rapen in UK are ‘from all ethnic groups’ but if you read the report itself, it becomes clear that the victims are predominantly from one ethnic group (guess which?) and the perpetrators from another (guess which?)

    • “You just enjoy the feeling of hatred and consigning millions of people to subhuman animals so you can feel superior to them. Well this isn’t all about you.”

      It’s not about you and your rather revolting and uninformed trolling tirade either.

    • Yes, what about all those crowds of Christian men doing this? Or Jewish men? Hmm?? Oh, right, there AREN’T any!
      Are you that totally clueless?? Misled by the dhimmi media, including the author, who is still largely in denial of the true evil embodied by this religion of hatred, abuse, and killing?
      This story *IS* exactly what Islam is all about!
      Try reading the Koran; the alleged writings of Muhammad also. This is exactly what they lived and taught as ideal Muslim behavior. This is exactly what Islam teaches today, promises to bring to the world, to the west. Their own Imams say there is NO such thing as “moderate Islam”, the treatment of women described here and in other horror stories of rape & so-called “honor killing” are too numerous to mention, and growing every day as Islam spreads its barbaric hatred of women and fear of free thought around the globe.
      They have sworn to kill all who disagree with their vile faith, killl all who will not convert and become animals like them. There is only one place such evil can come from: they serve Satan himself, and call him Allah because they are willfully blinded by the darkness they have come to love.
      YOU are what they call a ‘useful idiot’, Jaelle, being used & abused by them and yet too blind to see these animals destroying civilization. What a pathetic waste.

      • Wow. What a horrifyingly prejudiced tirade. You cannot condemn Islam because some interpretations are vile. The same can be said of Christianity, and there ARE Christian groups who treat women as second-class citizens, think homosexuals should be murdered and are an abomination, and more. The Abrahamic relgions have a lot of hatred in their old texts. But that doesn’t mean that all people who follow that religion hold on to that hatred. Modern interpretations of Christianity are about love and peace, and the same is true of Islam. The anti-Islamic attitude of Westerners is brought on by fear-mongering politicians and media spin-doctoring. Yes, those men may well have used Islam as the cover for their dispicable behaviour. But we “intelligent’ westerners should know better, shouldn’t we?

      • Chris can you stop offending animals and comparing muslims to animals? WTF is wrong with you? Are animals killing , raping, dropping bombs? No, so stop your stoopid comparison!!!! Animals do not deserve to be compared to anyone let alone to those assholes!!!

  609. Not only was that a vile, horrible way to be treated, but I can’t believe your struggle to find help or treatment after the fact. That’s not just disgusting but outrageous. I commend your dedication in hoping to continue your documentary, and I strongly suggest you start taking donations somewhere! Regardless of whether your insurance covers your equipment or not, I’d like the opportunity to make a financial contribution towards recouping your loss, and I know I can’t be the only one. Do you have a PayPal or anything like that?

  610. So sorry for this awful experience. Admire your courage and balanced reaction, such cruel incidents were reported before, masses of angry, deprived youth can be worst than animals.

  611. Have YOU lived in Egypt, Mostafa? Coz you obviously clueless about Egypt and how much women get harassed and groped inside and outside Tahrir on daily basis. Whether Natasha’s account is true or not, you have absolutely no right to think even for a split second that you know what is it like to be a woman in Egypt. This is coming from a woman who lived her entire life in Egypt. You just don’t know shit! You pretend to have had spent long time and know Tahrir pretty well, did you also know that Tahrir was manly about people tried of burying their head in the sand? So get yours out of your ass as Mona sad and don’t give your opinion on something you ain’t the least bit qualified to have an opinion on, not that anyone asked for your ass-backwards opinion anyway. Get a life dude, or you know, a brain at least!

    • When Muslims are a minority, they only attack uncovered women, in order to get them to cover themselves. But as soon as most women are covered, they start attacking covered women as well, proving their hypocrisy when they say they attack women because they are uncovered.

  612. Another Western apologist for Islam. I would think that this kind of awful experience would convince you that Islam is not a peaceful religion,that it is stuck in the 6th cent, and it is not suited for the modern world. Instead you detail this awful experience and make excuses for it. A fool is someone who can’t learn for experience. Good luck on your return trip.

    • this is because u r an illetrate dude who do not read about other religions and get all ur knowledge from ur sick and misleading media and build ur concepts upon watching childish hollywood movies . READ then talk .. Media is not everything douchebag ! …. sorry for u natasha once again , u r a charismatic person and i wish u best of luck

      • Yes, it’s all media.

        Or is it scientific research? cold hard numbers? facts ‘n figures?
        You READ and then shut up.
        It turns my stomach to still see people defending a religion that is inexplicably related to oppression and hatred.
        http://wikiislam.net/wiki/Muslim_Statistics_%28One_Page_View%29

        Islam is not peace. It’s mutilating women, degrading women, abusive to children and racist. Against Jews, against gays and against anything and anyone not Muslim.
        Those muslims ( BLESS THEM ALL ) that don’t fit the profile are a vast minority. But if they had any humanity in them, they would stand up for the sick mess their ‘brothers’ are making. But I haven’t seen a Jihad for that cause yet…
        And I’m not the one hating on Islam; I despise all religions, because only bad things have been done in the name of some God. I’m Glad Christianity has lost great popularity in my country. I hope the trend kicks in worldwide.
        You go tell a girl that her future is about as hopeful as a stray dog’ s because some Prophet promotes it’s. You make me sick and so does your God.

      • Mostafa, the fact alone that you are muslim disqualifies you. Now fuck off.

  613. Wow, you are an amazing woman. No one should ever have to experience what you have. Your entry is quite amazing, to be so understanding is incredible. I wish you all the very best on your road to recovery

  614. Sorry to hear this natasha ….. but this has nothing to do with the place ….Arab women are also being harrassed both in physical and verbal ways in USA and the West but unfortunately u people do not realise this and u call it freedom , we call it racism ! This is the ugly truth that westerners fail to comprehend. I’m not trying to justify what happened to u and i really feel sorry coz these kind of people neither represent Islam nor Egypt by any means.

  615. A very courageous blog entry.

    Unfortunately, the author’s experience is far from unique. According to studies conducted by the Egyptian Center for Women’s Right (ECWR) in 2008, 98 percent of foreign women and 83 percent of Egyptian women surveyed had experienced sexual harassment in Egypt. 62 percent of Egyptian men confessed to harassing women and 53 percent of Egyptian men faulted women for “bringing it on.”

    The people that helped the author and those that helped Lara Logan and the other victims from Tahrir Square, deserve the utmost praise exactly because they were a minority, they are true heroes. We should remember them next time we see something disturbing in the streets and hurry on, hoping it was nothing serious. And to those brave and decent Egyptians fighting to make Egypt a more open and tolerant society I wish you faith, courage and fortitude.

    But the apologists should be ashamed of themselves. The level of ignorance your childish stories of a Mubarak conspiracy requires on the part of us, say a lot about where you are coming from. Social media and mobiles gave Egypt revolution and social media and mobiles put a spotlight on Egypt’s shameful treatment of women and will bring you another revolution soon. The world is watching you and the world is revolted.

    • The irony is heartbreaking. Ms. Smith’s ordeal will probably do more to raise awareness of the problem than her planned documentary would ever have done. This post has been on-line for little more than a day, and already the thread runs to at least a thousand comments with dozens of feedback pings from other bloggers linking to this blog.

    • @Natasha I am sorry for what you’ve gone through and hoep that you would never experience such a terrible situation again during your stay
      @Nicolas I am sure that you’ve read the part about “Women were crying and telling me “this is not Egypt! This is not Islam! Please, please do not think this is what Egypt is!” I reassured her that I knew that was the case, that I loved Egypt and its culture and people, and the innate peacefulness of moderate Islam”. If you still think otherwise, then this goes back to your bad understanding of Islam. Misbehaving of a person does not reflect his belief, specially if he is very weakly connected to his religion.

      • The Jihad is an inherent term to Islam. It means to wage war on all infidels, basically kill all those who are different than us. Intolerance is built in into Islam and sexually repressed misogynist men are the norm not the except.
        Saying that everyone that disagrees with you ‘doesn’t get it’ is useless. The region is lost and that religion is sick.

    • This position far away from Islam, our Islam distorts with these stories, I admit that these monsters in my country I have nothing in common with Islam … I Must defend our religion and if you read about the religion of Islam will know that our religion disown these acts of brutal

  616. Wow… the woman describes a horrible incident that happened to her, hoping to make a difference and reach out, shows strength and forgiveness, shows determination to help while she is in a state that could use all the help she can; and you bozos turn it into a religious debate, questioning God’s existence, trying to find someone to blame while she herself did not, sharing your unwanted philosophical perspectives, self absorbent, egotistical, mother f… seriously, if there is a shred of humanity in any of you, you’d simply stand up for her and support her in any way she needs.

    Natasha… you are nothing short of a hero in my eyes dear. God bless you…

      • I’m not denying anything. I’m telling you this is about HER, not what you think of Islam or God!!! the people suck no matter what religious or non religious faith they have!!! Christianity does not promote violence but hey, Christians kill and rape ANYWAYS! People are bad… if a religion supports violence then its just as good as as an excuse as “I just feel like killing and raping” people will find their excuse in religion or anywhere else…

        support her or shut up!

      • Don’t tell me what I can or cannot say.

        It IS about religion. If you had made an effort to look into the facts, you’d realise how ignorant your comment is.
        It’s not about Natascha at all. It’s about hundreds and thousands of women being abused like that and in more severe ways by muslims.
        There are no such figures for any other religion since medieval times, so why do you refuse the truth? It’s not an exception, it’s common.
        Why is it common? Why is it common only in certain regions?

        Nobody said all muslims are evil. Nobody. People are just stating the obvious.
        Ignorance is bliss.

      • I’m distressed by this story and what happened to someone so innocently in ore of the country – but I’m so much more distressed by some of the comments! Some people live in a world of complete ignorance and dont understand the meaning of humanity… you wouldnt treat an animal this way!

    • We are not Bozo’s that turn it into a religious debate. Natasha brought up ‘peaceful islam’ herself and I reacted to that. Furthermore I do not need to questions gods existence coz there is no god. no question about it.

      What happened to Natasha shld not have happened, shld not happen to any woman, but it does. Maybe it is courageous of her to write this article. But dont call people that react to it bozo’s.

      Wether Natasha is a hero I dont know and it does not matter, she is a victim and wether going back to egypt is heroic or stupid is in the eye of the beholder.
      Yes every woman shld have the right to walk on Tahir sq -or anywhere else for that matter- without being molested. But the world is not a perfect place and any western woman going to Tahir square could at least be called careless

  617. Pingback: Animalidade primaveril « O Insurgente

    • Sorry, this was a response to an ignorant reply that must have been deleted while I read the entry and made me feel indignant.

      I just wanted to express you my honest sympathy.

      Besides, I’d recommend you not going back at this time. Sometimes it’s really dangerous even to a male going anywhere where you’re obviously a foreigner. I have really pale skin but my hair and my eyes are dark (I’m a Mediterranean guy, though in England nobody really notices that). When I visited Norway (twice) two female clerks (blondes) harassed my just for my looks at two different times. It was so obvious that the owner of one of the shops gave me free stuff as an apology! (I didn’t really wanted or needed that). Everyone else treated me normally, kindly and always with a smile in their faces, so I decided that this wouldn’t ruin an overall excellent experience. Anyway, I decided that the night wasn’t safe for me because there’s drunk people that can get mad (even after I had a casual pub conversation with a big drunk male guy that looked quite dangerous but was so nice after he learned I was from Spain, where he always rode his motorbike during the summer). You’ll never really know where the danger is, but being “marked” is not what you’d want in a currently agitated country.

  618. This is absolutely awful but then again what’s new? What was most shocking to me was that really nothing changed! When I was raped in Egypt 20 years ago, the same reaction of hospital personell, police, people like what was described in that article. Only because I live in a country where things like that are not as easily possible as in such a patriarchal society, I dare to talk about this openly – or even think about it – without wanting to puke or hit either myself or somebody else. I recommend to you to leave Egypt as soon as possible, find a psychologist you feel comfortable with & leave Egypt behind you if you want to stay sane & work things out for yourself! Unfortunately me as a half Egyptian have to say that & I urge you to take my advice. I did that much too late & still have major problems / aggressions / fear with / against / of men.

    It is “not only” the actual abuse but also very much how the society reacts to this. If I read some of the above comments, I feel I am put back in time – those comments that this is your own fault because you were not dressed properly, put me back in a time machine where I feel helpless & angry, so angry that I can’t do anything but numb myself with drugs (of course another problem that does not exist in Egypt). Once again, please get out of there as long as you can still think straight!

    • Your comment is saddening but enlightening. Glad to hear you did the right thing and got out while you could. Take care.

  619. You’re a great journalist you described everything in details as if it happened to the reader although you were in a difficult situation. I’m surprised there were hundreds that have the idea of foreign spies. I thought only ex-regime loyalists follow Egyptian media. I’m Egyptian and I’m also surprised with the people entering here and talking about this being a fake story.

    I believe it because it happened number of times before and million of Females are abused and harassed annually. I don’t think a professional journalist would write a fake story unless you’re from Egyptian media :D:D:D

    The one question remains Does the world rape and harassment index represents the situation in Egypt? or it is true developed countries may have high rates of sexual harassment?

    Get well soon

  620. I’m sorry this happened to you, I’m sorry you were victimized. Stay strong, remember this was not your fault in anyway, no matter what some of these assholes are saying. It’s a sad world we live in, one that women has to walk around with male friends for protection in foreign countries, and even that isn’t enough protection. One where, instead of getting treatment for sexual abuse as soon as you walk into a hospital they question you and they don’t believe you for whatever reason, refusing to give out rape kits because of personal beliefs (That happened in the U.S.) We live in a sad world indeed. I am glad you survived this terrible ordeal, I hope your story helps other women reveal their stories, and I hope it helps to bring awareness/resolution to this ever growing problem.

  621. This is very unfair of you Jouja!! You live in Egypt.. I am EGYPTIAN!! and I can tell you, I have heard plenty of similar stories, some of them happened to very close people. We are molested and harassed everyday in the streets of Egypt. Instead of attacking her, we’d better think of solutions about how to improve the situation for women and foreigners in Egypt!

    • Christine, this is true, but the majority do not agree with you as Egyptians. thus the reason why the brotherhood was voted in.

  622. Since my original posting with the specific questions has been deleted I will now ask the British embassy in Cairo directly and provide the story for fact checking to AI, HRW and “reporters without borders”.

  623. I’m so sorry for what happened to you, this is horrible.
    Let me say something not so political correct. Things like these are always happening outside UK or Europe or some other developed countries. In many other countries that may look peaceful from the distance you’ve to be really careful of what you do or where you walk. You’ll think yes, in some neighborhoods of UK I’ve to be careful too, but I’m talking about losing your life for an empty wallet i.e.
    For some reason many tourists forget about these precautions and just get in an ecstasy of “omg it’s so cool to be with third world people celebrating life” and suddenly they’re involved in a horrible situation. I’m sorry to say this but be careful and don’t try to proof yourself you’re brave and you can do whatever you imagine or see in a movie. In real life shit gets real, you know it better than me.

  624. Natasha,

    As a woman living in this country, and a victim of countless harassment incidents, including one somewhat similar to yours, I hope that one day you will overcome the terror and shock of it all. Be patient with yourself, it is hard and painful, and it takes a long time to heal. But heal you shall.

    I really cannot commend your bravery in speaking out about this, enough! It’s been some 15 years since I encountered such violence, and I still choke up attempting to discuss it.

    And, bizarre as this sounds, I love you! And I am truly sorry.

  625. Thank you for writing and sharing what happened to you at Tahir.
    I hope you will recover soon from your wounds and reappear strong. Even stronger!

    Elements who are dangerous for our integrity in our societies have to remain kept away. Especially if the rage directed against an individual or societies comes from men that has its origins in a feeling of inferiority as they see women expressing their proposals and points of view right beneath them. And especially if they find courage and expression in a group. There are (too) many dangerous groups with that same structure holding on to power and humiliating all they find on their “way” just to hold or make growing their power. It could be in their nature. I mean the nature of human males…? I hope not. It would be difficult to keep them all away and not desirable. Forgive me this little sarcasm ; )

    The fact that you could not find attention in a public hospital is very sad. It seems that they (not)treated you as a especial case, because of what happened to you. Violation no, broken leg, yes? I will talk about tied legs, not broken ones, even if they tried through ages to do so. Women’s legs (so loved by photographers all over the world…) and our limping societies. Is it fear or conviction of something they believe in that makes people (in a hospital!) act in such a way? If it is fear, from what? If it is belief, in what?

    The action of sexual humiliation of the big group of men on Tahir goes against those they recognize as evidently weaker than them. The action of sexual humiliation, is it done with the aim to empower themselves? Or to impose punishment stating an example to avoid future participations by people they do not like to participate? Or are all of them not controlling their sexuality? In all cases, again, they suppose a danger for society, especially for women and children and should remain kept away from public participation.

    People like Natasha and her friends, who through their acts break up with these structures represent the future. A future where we stop limping on one leg having forgotten to use the other valorous one. That is my belief.

    And by the way I express what I feel looking at the reunions of political and/or religious organizations which contribute with interesting but very dangerous stories for us in their interpretation. It is remarkable how many funny dressed men are still pretending to represent the rest of human beings and beings in general who life here, on this planet. No one can, but with a pistol on my head, pretend to direct my loved spirit, and never can do so an organization that presents itself as Administration of Spirituality connected in a privileged way to an “upper being” (mostly the figure of a man..father, son and so on) who as they affirm inspires them and in whose name some of them loudly and publicly announce to act, terrible terrifying acting, in many cases. It is remarkable too, how often sexual humiliation is used to enforce the power, to weaken the “enemy”.

    Women have their points of view and feelings and are more and more involved in decisive positions in our societies. This is a fact, a reality packed with hope for many and with fear for others who see their personal sense of being merged in its power. It makes them dangerous and blind.

    So please, you and all Tahir have done a lot for all of us to reanimate our other, tied leg. Your writing gives me hope and the power to use my brilliant brain to think, evaluate, open my eyes and encourage my mind to progress towards a life in dignity with all our capacities. Women and girls, men and boys together. With my best wishes for you and your friends, you are hope for many!
    Tahir is not only a place in Cairo. It is a place in our heads, abroad many actual rigid borders still gripped on the “traditional power” and “they” can´t move it away from there that easily. – I deeply wish you can soon laugh again and enjoy a good life!

  626. I´m very sorry for you.
    The rape and the broken reality of the sorroundings which you believe as pacific.

    Maybe you need to know why you were attacked.
    You were because you didn´t have the right clothing at that spot.

    In islam is haram that women show all their skin to the open.
    In the koran is detailed how to deal with “uncovered meat”.
    Sadly you had the example live.

    Partially was your fault of not adressing the reality of the place and believing that it was still the peaceful kind imported at home.

    • her fault !! .. are yo serious !

      in Islam sexual Harassment is blanket for all women
      even if she is no a Muslim

      you should not force her how to wear or what to wear
      Remember “Your freedom stop at the freedom of others”

      your reply is a shame

      • Also, as a kuffar at the umma, did the same as the other raped reporter.
        The same. And still she don´t get it.

        The ikhwan is honest about it means. You westerners are too arrogant, and prefer being deaf to islam.

        It was her fault.

      • firstly i’m a Muslim Egyptian

        and i know that a lot of women in my country suffer from sexual harassment.
        some of them are veiled

        it’s not her fault , it’s the fault of our society

        Islam is the religion of all people and to save all not only Muslims

        finally , ikhwan is not the Islam .

    • It is not her fault by any means. Sorry, but your point of view is retarded. Women in Hijab and even Burka are sexually abused everyday in Egypt, so you better not try to blame the females. The sexual harassment will always be the abusers fault, never the victims.

      • What an IDIOTIC IGNORANT YOU ARE BISCUT!!!!! YOU ARE A SHAME TO HUMAN KIND
        YOUR KIND THAT IS ALLOWING THOSE ASSHOLES TO ENJOY THESE HARASSMENT AND GET AWAY WITH IT WITHOUT ANY PUNISHMENT
        I WISH FROM GOD TO PUT YOU IN THE SAME SITUATION IF YOU ARE A GIRL AND TO HAVE A DEAR YOU KNOW GO THROUGH THE SAME IF YOU ARE A GUY THAN YOU WILL REALISE WHOSE FAULT WAS IT
        MAY GOD SAVE US FROM THOSE THINGS LIVING AMONG US AND THINK THEY ARE ACTUALLY HUMANS

      • I agree, and for this Biscuit, he should have his nuts and dick cut off and fed to the nasty fish in the Nil.

    • Fuck you.

      This is NOT her fault. The only people at fault are the bastards that raped her because they view women as less than human, because they think they have a right to her body, because they are sick violent little cunts who don’t deserve to be called human.

      No wait, someone else is at fault. You, and people like you. Because as long as there are imbeciles like you blaming victims/survivors and making apologies for rapists this kind of crime will never be punished properly, the survivors will never be looked after properly, rape will never be taken seriously.

      I hope you’re proud of yourself, coming on here and being so vile to someone so incredibly brave and strong.

    • In western countries it is seen as degrading to women to be covered up in sheets. So this means that westerners have the right to pull the sheets of those women?

      • in the west we don’t have the quran to tell us this kind of sick behaviour is justified, so the answer is no.

    • PEOPLE READ THIS GUYS POST!! This is what a Majority of Egyptians believe. Now go and book your flights to see this lovely country and please bring your daughter from the west. They would love to touch them as well. Seriously, I lived in Egypt for 2 years, it is a messed up society and in reality, the people voted for what they want. AN ISLAMIC, NON Tourist country, let this country rot in hell.

    • so, islam is to blame. Muslims see ‘uncovered meat’ and will rape the uncovered meat for it, for that is what the quran says. Well… ain’t that a sick truth… Let’s not be deaf to islam anymore and view it as the sickness it is… Let’s hope this sickness will be cured soon.

  627. It reads real to me. Not only that, but we’re not reading this story in the New York Times or Reuters or the BBC News, it’s on her personal website. Does anyone else out there use a fact checker when writing personal accounts of events? Where is the proof of your own claims?

    • i don’t know if you are questioning her claims or not but i did see this happen before so it is no fictional if that what you mean

  628. The datum is pretty much described in the first sentences. Or did you miss the part describing the fireworks and happy people? It wouldn’t hurt to just keep your useless opinion to yourself. Especially in a case like this. And as for you working with abused women..I think THAT is an untrue story. It must be, because you obviously don’t bother to notice details and you are clearly paranoid.

  629. To those who appear to be turning a horrific personal drama into an islamophobic hate-fest, please remind us that women and children are never raped or abused in christian and/or other non-muslim countries, not even by priests. And there are no serial killers either, or sex offenders, I suppose, in christian countries…

    A childhood friend of mine from the Netherlands, was raped and clubbed to death by her German husband, who left her to die in a pool of blood. The (supposedly very clever and efficient) German (supposedly also christian, not muslim) police could not find evidence to convict him, so he was never even arrested or tried. Perhaps being christian had something to do with this totally disgusting murder???

    Stop blaming religion for the vile behavior of people. Evil exists everywhere. And if you cannot be compassionate over Natasha’s trauma, then shut up.

    • Lo uno no justifica lo otro, lamento ambos casos. Pero no me parece acertado tu comentario, y la religión si tiene que ver. O ¿acaso piensas que eso lo hubiera hecho una masa de mujeres a un hombre extranjero en el mismo escenario?.

      • (translation for Nileblues. David, I hope you do not mind if I translate your post. /espero que no te moleste que le traduzca tu post a Nileblues. Saludos : )

        One thing does not justify the other, I lament both of the cases. But your comment does not seem appropriate to me, and the religion in my opinion has to do with it. Or do you think that this act could have been done by a mass of women to a stranger man in the same scenario?

      • Thanks for the translation!

        Would a man in a mob of women be sexually assaulted by the women? Hmm. Interesting question. I don’t know really, are there any documented cases to this effect?

        As for religion being the cause of Natasha’s horrible ordeal; I really cannot agree. Women are subjected to attacks and assaults all over the world; not just young blond foreigners in crowds of Arab Muslim Egyptians — old grannies, small kids… Rape is an act of violence against a weaker person. The rapists do this because they can get away with it. They don’t do it because their religion tells them to do it.

    • Yes, evil is everywhere. And there’s a little more of it in Tahrir. How can you defend a religion that considers a muslim woman to be nothing but property and a non muslim as prey. Or do you truly believe this story is an incident and not related to the insane foundations of this ‘religion’ ?
      It’s time people leave this retarded religion, just like many Christians turned atheists when stories of children being abused by priests came out.
      There no such thing as an almighty God, we are all Gods. We can create and terminate lives. Create hell and create heaven. If you need to fear anything, it’s mankind, not some mythical figure that supposedly wants the best for us, but let’s his soldiers fuck up regularly.
      This is your life.

      • Joanna; I do not defend or condemn any religion. People commit crimes, not ideas. The priests who abused little boys cannot claim that religion made them do it. And those men in Tahrir cannot place the blame for their acts on Islam either.

      • Joanna, you are an intolerant self-righteous know-it-all. People like you are the ones who spew hatred and feed extremists of all kinds. It does not bother you in the slightest that you are insulting millions of people with your flippant comments that have nothing to do with what Natasha had to endure. Read her account and her comments.
        I am a non-observant Christian woman from a non-observant Christian family married to a non-observant Muslim man from a very observant Muslim family. I deeply resent you insulting my husband’s mother, aunts and cousins, as well as their husbands, brothers and fathers the way you do. Your ignorance, as well as your close-mindedness, are patent.

    • You do see the difference between a crime and a religion that is a way of life?
      Islam is not a loving religion. It requires vileness to be true to the beliefs of a murdering pedophile warlord it worships as a god.

      • And the Christian and Catholic Priests who deliver the word of their God and then molest young boys and girls in Western countries?

        Many people claim that they are people of religion, but religion cannot be used as an excuse or justification of any vile activity like rape and paedophilia, and neither can it be blamed solely for any act.

        The fact is, the men in this case believe that they have a right to do whatever they wish to a woman, like certain Catholic priests believed they had a right to abuse and rape young boys and girls in their care.

        These men are evil and would be evil whether they were Muslim, Christian, Buddhists or any other religion.

        The question is; who is teaching them that this behaviour is ok, and how can we stop the cycle?

    • @Nileblues: ‘police could not find evidence to convict him, so he was never even arrested or tried’ When there is no evidence, everyone could have done it in this case. And believe me, they defenitily tried to arrest him! (I’m from the Netherlands) And the whole thing around he was ‘supposedly also christian’ doesn’t makes sense. The important thing is that there is less (or sometimes) no respect for women in Islamic countries. Unfortunately…

      • Frank: Kiki was killed in Germany, not in the Netherlands. Why are you so quick to place the fault for what happened to Natasha on the religion of the Egyptians? Why don’t you equally blame Christianity for Kiki’s husband’s criminality? And besides, you don’t have to believe a word I said about the ineptitude of the German police — perhaps I’m also another mythomaniac like Natasha — as some commentators seem to believe, and am just writing this to become famous and sell lots of books, make loads of cash and buy a ton of shoes..

    • Girls in the Netherlands are not assaulted in public by crowds of strangers and rapists are universally despised. I challenge you to find a comparable incident in Europe or the United States. And the author is not the first to be sexually assaulted by a crowd in Tahrir Square either, so don’t compare this to ‘ordinary’ rape.

      The (supposedly very clever and efficient) German (supposedly also christian, not muslim) police could not find evidence to convict him, so he was never even arrested.

      Do you even realise how implausible that sounds? A simple DNA test and off he goes to prison.

      • Perhaps the most chilling aspects of these Egyptian crowd assaults is that they are not even technically rapes, because that would sully the rapists. The only motive seems to be the humiliation and the punishment of the victim.

      • Sorry if Kiki’s murder — which is not the object of this discussion — offends your European trust in the ‘infallibility’ of your systems, Erik. A simple DNA test cannot prove that a husband raped his wife, as his DNA is all over the house, the woman, the kids, everything… Kiki’s family — who are all Dutch — believe that she was killed by this man. They are still in shock, ten years after the murder. As I did not personally witness this murder, I cannot swear that she was killed by her husband; I believe her parents’ version of the events.

        In developing countries, we don’t trust the police, or the army, or any men in groups. We don’t naively believe that the police are there to protect us, or that the judicial system will uphold our rights. Women do not go out into crowds in Africa or Asia. This may be hard for westerners to understand, but it is a fact of life in many countries. We don’t like it. We wish we could go out alone at night, take public transport, drive our cars in safety. But we can’t, because we live in very poor countries where it is easy to attack a woman to steal her purse or her car, and bribe the police to turn a blind eye.

        South Africa has the highest rate of rape in the world, and it is not a Muslim country. Even men fear for their lives at night in South Africa, not just women. Kenya is another place where it is extremely unsafe to go out after dark.

        Egypt, on the other hand, used to be a very safe country. I lived there for many years, and never felt unsafe. The recent events, and decline in security, have contributed to the heinous crimes against women, and men, that we are seeing now. It is not linked to Islam or whatever Islam has to say about the status of women.

      • A simple DNA test cannot prove that a husband raped his wife, as his DNA is all over the house, the woman, the kids, everything.

        Point taken. That was a silly comment of mine.

        But still, there’s a difference between killing your wife and what has now happened four or five times in Tahrir Square. I’m not saying that the latter is worse, simply that it doesn’t compare. Something like this would be inconceivable in a Western country.

    • thanks for your reply nileblues! i don’t know why they people insist on deforming my hometown in a time everything is going inverse to the reality of my people ! isn’t it enough planning to destroy my culture and my religion they have nothing else in their lives to show accept hate what surprise me ( after all what she explained from suffering and torture like there is no humans living in cairo even in hospitals ! she say women have to be strong and fight etc …) its really not a time to go there now i advice you those people are not with real Egyptian attitude im not defending i don’t care even what you will think of it your morals and culture is totally different than us i don’t expect understanding or respecting religion like islam your culture show us as terrorists and our women are not free and repressed this is your point of view and its untrue !

    • Well said, Nileblues! This is Natasha’s blog…please respect her by having inter-religious debates elsewhere.

    • I totally agree with your points and this is an issue across the globe. This can not be pin pointed on a religion, it’s uneducated thugs who are a disgrace to the human race as a whole.
      I wonder how they would feel should the victim had been their daughter or their loved one?
      I am certainly not an expert in religions as a whole, but I have a question to you, from what I read I believe you have a better understanding then me on this subject…. So, do you think that there is anything in Islamic beliefs which could lead people to view females as a lesser race or second class citizens and more specifically, ‘western women’?
      I hope you do not mind my naivety, this is something which I find very intriguing.
      Many thanks.

  630. Thanks for being brave enough to tell your story for the sake of other women. The assaulting Tahrir flash mob is far too common to be attributed to a commercial. Ask the Egyptian women protesting in Tahrir against sexual haraassment who were then assaulted and sexually harassed by hundreds of men, who, although less than the lowest form of life, consider themselves superior to women.

  631. I can’t believe people like you exist. And I’m more sorry for the women you worked with. Dealing with a biased ass like you after trauma doesn’t really sound like something you’d need after being traumatised.

  632. I sincerely hope you thought this out. You have just tries to shift this into some kind of bigotted attack upon the victim of a terrible crime. Please think about the kind of accusations you make.

  633. Thank you, Irene. I totally agree with you and I’m well aware that the Egypt society is full with abuse of children and women and sexual violance. But this story is a fake if I’ve ever read one.

    I got the impression that the story happened during the last days but as someone posted a link the story was translated into Arabic weeks ago. So when did this allegedly sexual assault happen? Why doesn’t Natasha give a proper datum?

  634. Natasha, thank you. Thank you for sharing this with us. Thank you for not giving into the many doubts that will have plagued you about sharing this. This isn’t lies, it isn’t attention-seeking, and it isn’t fishing for sympathy. This is your story.
    I wish more of the beautiful people who tried to stop what was happening were around that day and less of the people who pretended it never happened, or that it was okay.
    This was assault. This was abduction. This was an unprovoked attack on you and your body. I don’t care how common may be, it isn’t. right. It happened to you, and you matter.
    Sharing your story may be all the therapy you need, but I hope once you’re in a place you feel safe, that there will be someone ready to listen if you need to share more. Maybe your friends and family, or maybe someone unconnected to you that can hear what you have to say without judgement. I never took this opportunity myself. It’s so easy to bury what happened in another country and move on. What you’ve experienced may affect you in some unexpected ways, but as you’ve already discovered, there’s more to you than meets the eye.
    You said nobody would hold you back. I don’t doubt you for a second! Write on, travel on!

  635. it does not matter if it is a bad novel. have you ever live in Egypt? you have no idea how true her story is , for me and others. keep your insensitive opinion to your self prick!

  636. Natasha, I can’t tell you how shocked and saddened I was to read this; I also lived in Egypt for many years and love the country and its people, their rich history and quirky humor… Perhaps as someone from the region (I am Sudanese), I am always wary of crowds, and of men in general. It could be that our parents endlessly drummed into us as girls the terror of being a lone woman in a world of men… and the need to be cautious, to avoid having to deal with the police or public offices where there are only men.

    You were very brave indeed to confront this horrifying episode and hopefully overcome it by writing about it. I can only imagine how painful it must have been to relive the experience, but it could be a good way to heal. I would like to send you a gift of my novel “Nile Blues”. It’s about Sudanese women, and there’s a description of it if on amazon.com,. I can be contacted through my blog. Wishing you safety and serenity, Maha

  637. ..I was actually pointing my questions to Bill Fisher and E.Eliveld
    and you have just proven my point, people who actually experience Islam can judge it to be the message of peace…

    ===

    Islam is the message of peace “except for …

    * Women
    * gay men
    * other religions
    * non-believers
    * apostates
    * supporters of democracy
    * opponents of democracy

    Hmm…wait…

    • that’s not true, Islam, is religion of love and peace. the last words of our prophet Mohamed before he died were to take great care of woman, he repeated that 3 times. concerning other religions also we were ordered by god to treat them well. and Islam is the base of democracy, as Muslims in the past, can face their rulers and say you are wrong and he accepted and correct, you have to read more about Islam, before you talk about what you don’t know 🙂

      • Islam is not a religion of love and peace – just look at any predominantly muslim country. It is a religion of hate, war, and flying airplanes into buildings.

        Also, claming that muslims take good care of their women is ludicrous. Forcing women to cover themselves, allowing their husbands to beat them, not giving them any social rights, and killing them for adultery if they are raped – you must have a pretty warped view of “good care”.

  638. This has nothing to do with Egypt. It happens all over the Middle-East and it is not just something which started now. I was already harrassed by a group of men in about the same way 30 years ago in Turkey. I am long and blonde. The average Muslim men sees all woman except his mother as sexual prey and is society lets him acts upon it. It’s all about education and all muslim mothers play a great part in this. Sad but true.

    • You are right. I want to add that women have been seen like dirt in other religions too. In fact a rape is not a fact coming from sexual arousal but looking to feel powerful. We, women should educate our sons in dealing their frustration in other ways but violence and rape. If a man cannot control himself, he should be send to a zoo.

  639. Natasha, deeply sorry for this despicable incident. As an Egyptian male, this is beyond belief and acceptance. I know that no words can comfort you, but it is the best I can offer.
    Just a note to the ongoing debate regarding the role of religion (Islam) in this and its teachings, etc, etc. I would like to remind you of the European “dark” middle ages when “witches” were burnt at the stakes, or dunked into rivers, when dissidents were hung, drawn and quartered, or when the king or prince of the land had the right to sleep with any woman in the land prior to her wedding night. I fully understand that this was a long time ago, but it does not erradicate my point: was any of this the teachings of Christianity? Or the genocides in many Christian black African countries in the past few decades (eg the massacres in Rwanda & Burundi in the mid 90s where a million people died). Again, was this Christianity’s teachings? Or were all these extremely negative and appalling incidents due to ignorance and poverty?
    Egypt has been plagued with poverty, mis-management, political abuse, severly degraded education, increase in un-employment, people living in filth, spread of disease, etc, etc, etc for the past few decades (between 30 to 60 years). These negative actions are directly a result of these factors. These people didn’t even have proper Islamic education in the first place for you to blame religion for their actions.
    Look back in history to all societies across the world and you will see a clear trend: whenever there is severe poverty coupled with a crap education system and lack of basic human sustinance, you will find people becoming more like animals (Maslow’s hierarchy of needs).
    Judge religion by the actions of the people who can afford a proper education, and not by the masses who can not even afford a meal.

    • Thank you for writing this comment Sharif. When a woman is violated and degraded, and the first response of a man hearing the story is sorrow and a rejection of that behaviour, it brings real comfort and consolation.

    • Sharif , the teachings of Jesus, ie. the New Testament, do not justify or encourage anyone to hurt or kill someone. In contrast, it preaches peace and forgiveness. In contrast, the koran commands muslims to abuse and kill non-muslims, gays, apostates, promotes slavery, rape, oppression and many other crimes. It is typical that a muslim like you has to come up with things the Church did hundreds of years ago. Is that all you got? Pretty lame I have to say. It is time people like you see how violent and hateful your koran and prophet are. I doubt that mohammed is God’s prophet and that the koran is god’s word. God wouldn’t want people to kill God’s own creatures. Also, to make things worse, the koran is full of mistakes; it does not only state the earth is flat and the sun turns around it, it also claims mountains were built to prevent earthquakes and that semen comes from behind the ribs. More proof the koran and mohammed are nothing but frauds. You muslims leave with the illusion that islam is peaceful. But why aren’t you honest to yourself and admit that it is not peaceful or tolerant? Did you actually ever read the koran and hadiths? Do you even know what abrogation means?
      You should come clean and leave islam. You are worshiping the wrong god; you know what the koran says about people who worship an idol.

  640. Dear Natasha,
    Like many others who have commented here, I must say you have been very brave in handling the after effects of the situation. And, by narrating it in your blog for all of us to read! I cannot imagine the pain it must have caused in recollecting that day, that moment. But I do know what it feels, being violated and the feeling of helplessness at the time. Healing from what you went through will take time but I am glad that you are determined to see your documentary project through. All the best and be safe.

  641. Dear Natasha,

    I saw the link to your blog on twitter. Like many others who have commented here, I must say you have been very brave in handling the after effects of the situation. And, by narrating it in your blog for all of us to read! I cannot imagine the pain it must have caused in recollecting that day, that moment. But I do know what it feels, being violated and the feeling of helplessness at the time. Healing from what you went through will take time but I am glad that you are determined to see your documentary project through. All the best and be safe.

  642. I just want to say, I am very sorry for what happened and I think it is shameful that people are bringing their political conclusions to your blog. I read this post last night, and when I thought about it again today I realized that these comments really are a shame– just know that most of the people who are reading this are totally sympathetic and would not interrupt you with such accusations and ignorant conclusions at this time.

  643. Sexual mores in Egypt are ultimately governed by islamic law – not by the golden rule, or natural law or simple empathy – but by sharia. Under islamic law, a man may have four wives and as many concubines as his “Right Hand Possesses.” A “Right Hand Possession” is essentially a female sex slave taken from an infidel population that refuses to submit to islam. The rape of such women is completely halal under islamic law. Mohammad did it, as well as all of his companions. Furthermore, the failure of a woman to act in accordance with islamic norms of gender aparteid and veiling is typically a good defense to a charge of rape (or harassment). Of course, since this type of mentality typically results in men seeing every woman in a predatory fashion, at least if she is outside and sufficiently accessible, all women end up suffering harassment and assault, muslim or not and covered or not. For islamic authorities, the solution for this rampant criminality is to simply make sure that all women stay inside and fully covered unless under the direct control, escort and guardianship of a related male (i.e. strict purdah – see the brotherhood’s flies/uncovered lollipop billboard for confirmation). In this way, the harassment feeds islamisation, and islamisation in turns feeds the harassment (since the more fully islamised the society becomes, the more visible and readily identifiable are the western “sluts” who refuse to submit to islamic norms).

    Welcome to Dar Al Harb, Ms. Smith. Unfortuneately, YOU are the war booty.

    • You Said That Sexual mores ultimately governed by Islamic Law as that man can has up tp four wives….
      Yes he can,but in specific cases as If His wife unable to give birth or such things…and in return …he must lower his gaze and never touch any other woman…so Sexual Mores nit Governed By Islamic law…And It’s Not Dar Al Harb BTW

      • Egypt is Dar al Islam. Ms. Smith and her western ways represent dar al harb – and that’s how she was treated.

      • Very rightly said reality for all such lands ;This was indirectly expressed in behavior of doctors,nurses and other people who came across after violent assault, all non believers should simply be governed by one word,’Beware!’
        Those who go and come out safe have only one thing in their favor , ‘their stars’ not culture,not society,not religious customs,not laws of land.

    • Luckily, the vast majority of muslims know a lot more about Islam than you do Lin…and are much kinder to victims of crime.

  644. “This is not Islam..this is not Egypt..” Suuuuurrrre, it isn’t. And Christian demonstrators weren’t pelted with rocks and bottles by the lovable muslims in Michigan last month either. Who am I to trust my eyes and ears?

    • …and no Christian has ever blown up a building killing hundreds, or pelted women with model foetuses covered in red paint, or killed gay people, or started wars based on their religion.

      You probably shouldn’t use your eyes and ears unless you also plan to engage your brain.

  645. Dear Natasha,

    The world needs more people as strong as you are. You are making a difference, and you have my support. I hope that you can achieve your dreams. Peace and understanding are possible. Thank you for sharing your story, and stay strong.

  646. Natasha, I’m really sorry this happened to you. I apologize on behalf of every civilized person in Egypt, and, believe me, there are many.

  647. It is a double shame, Mostafa, that you assault this woman here. I understand that rapists are compelled to their acts of shame due to the incredibly small sizes of their equipment. Would this explain your verbal tirade as well.

  648. Why did you go to Egypt at the first place. Did you think that you were witnessing another cuban revolution ?? That this spring revolution (Revolution, the word as western media tries to depict) is a rosy revolution and people have stood up and arab world will be free and soon this revolution will way all the way into China and a Democratic revolution will happen in China and Communist party will be over thrown and Western World would once again trump ??

    This wasn’t a revolution !! It was a “mini” anarchist over thrown of a bad regime .. thats all..nothing more..nothing less.

    So yea next time you are elated at the sight of revolution some where outside Anglo-Saxon sphere, think twice ! I think its time to go to Greece to see its own revolution .. which so unfortunately western media depicts as riots ….

    Cheers

    lenin from the moon.

    • I totally understand where you’re coming from, but it is extremely insensitive to ask a victim “why did you go there in the first place?”. That’s called victim shaming and there is obviously nothing that can be done now, so why even pose the question?

      • That wasn’t my point. When ever you read any “Lonely Planet” or any other travel books there are guidelines for women traveller. If you have to Saudi Arabia, be sensitive to the culture, if you are going to India be careful if you smoke or drink in public and bla bla bla. If Egypt was in the middle of some kinds of riots, Natasha’s home country would had given no-travel warning. But the turn of events in Egypt was viewed not as riots, not as anarchism, not a de-stabilising situation but was portrayed by western media as a REVOLUTION which it wasn’t !!

        If Egypt had a real revolution going on at that time, I bet (from Moon) that even surrounded by 10,000 Muslim men, no one would have dared to touch her because the energy of revolution is extremely extremely positive !

        I don’t want to deny the importance of events @ tahrir square. Mubarak is gone, his regime is partially dead, people stood up, the inertia that was holding the masses has been broken but it wasn’t a Revolution.

        So the mistake Natasha made was that she thought that some thing really good and positive was going on at that moment and it was safe to venture into highly crowded space with hundreds of young men shouting and screaming. She thought she was witnessing some kind of a world event (because Natasha listen to CNN and Fox News too much) which it wasn’t !!

        Now lets say Natasha is in a similar situation surrounded by hundreds of men in a vast square, and making documentary …. let assume it was a Cuban revolution, American revolution, Russian revolution or Indian struggle for independence in 1947 , I bet the people around her will have any inclination for sexual desire at that moment.

        So moral of story – Don’t watch too much CNN or BBC. Do think for yourself and your actions.

        Red Salute for the Moon ….. Ah I see few Chinese near the Moon …

      • Typo in my post below …

        Last Paragraph should read as :

        I bet the people around her will NOT have any inclination for sexual desire at that moment.

        PS: I do feel sorry for Natasha and the things that happened to her but i again emphasis, the turn of events would have happened any where in third world where there are demonstrations, anarchy, riots etc. People just crowd in a space and young men (of all characters) come along, they scream shout , they are not disciplined and if they see a victim ( in this case it was Natasha) bad things are supposed to happen. So lets not ask WHY DID THEY DO THIS … we should think logically and our security is in our hands.

    • lenin from the moon, I wish you were on the moon. Blame the victim (as long as it’s not you, right? You sound like a very sheltered individual who probably would end up in the same situation, God forbid!!!!!

    • Why did you go to Egypt at the first place. Did you think that you were witnessing another cuban revolution ?

      She went there to make a documentary on the abuse of women in Egypt.

      Moron.

    • Make your political point at the expense of another person’s suffering…insensitive doesn’t cover it. I in Cuba for several years…no decent Cuban would speak to you after what you just said.

  649. When are we just going to admit that Islam is a misogynistic ideology, and breeds likewise cultures? A dumb set of beliefs is a dumb set of beliefs, there’s no reason to apologize for it just because someone calls it their faith.

    • So if a girl gets harassed in a concert in the UK, should we blame christianity? How about getting real and saying the truth. The truth is there are many sleazy disgusting people who have no respect for other human beings and who will never be stopped except by law and order. The problem is sometimes in situations like this and many others, there isn’t enough security, or there are too many distractions, etc.. These situations are opportunities for the dreadful people I am talking about which have attacked Natasha and many others. But the existence of these disgusting people doesn’t justify blaming a country’s religeon or its culture because they are present everywhere in the world. So if you will, then you can blame all religeons, cultures, governments because as far as I know, there isn’t a place in the world where there isn’t at least one victim of rape or sexual harassement. As far as I am concerned, you should be above that, you should be aware that making such accusations about other countries and their cultures or religeons may only promote bad relations between people of different cultures. What are we promoting, peace and understanding, or bad relations which may eventually result in more wars? Think before you arrogantly write your ignorant opinions for others to read.

      • Well, if a girl gets sexually harassed by a mob of 40-50 men at a rock concert we can blame rock music?

        It’s not very common in the west that mobs of men sexually harass women. At least in Scandinavia, sexual harassment is seen as very shameful and gang rapes by ethnic Scandinavians are very uncommon.

        This is purely a question of moral and of who is seen as part of the group and not okay to harass and not seen as part of the group and okay to harass.

    • I invite you -being male or female- to enter with your gringo baby-face into my neighborhood in a catholic country. If you survive please tell me if it’s about religion or if it’s just violence.

  650. Dear Natasha,

    I think that to write about your experience has shown everybody the human quality you have and has indeed risen awareness regarding the vulnerable position of women in general and how abusive men can become under certain circumstances. Speaking out is a tribute to suffering women around the world.

    A warm hug from Spain.

  651. Gosh , i think i was there , Iam syrian and we have a tent in the Tahrir Square and few months ago , a foreinger run into our tent , we wrere about sixty syrians , we gather around this girl who was without trouser and many sick people trying to rape her , we did our best to defend her with a help of Egyptians patriots who were defending this girl , and i think they pulled her to out tent , trying to hide her from those sick people , i was shocked , and iam still , since that day , i declared to my wife no more going to Tahrir Square, i think these sick people are hired from the Ex-regime to say to people when we left , the mess came

    • Please stop blaming others or circumstances’ for the behaviour of people. This is typically Egyptian excuses. For everything bad happens. It starts in childhood. If a child makes a mistake, it is rarely punished, because it is always the fold of others. With one exception, if women get raped, it’s her own fold.
      That’s the mind of the majority men and women in this country. Please open our eyes. That’s Egypt. And I personally do not believe that any institution finance things like this. This are misguided young men. They are misguided by their upbringing, by their education. I bed most of them did not even see the naked upper-arm of the mothers or sisters. But they have the Satellite Televisions at home and see in films female bodies and flesh. So, what you expect??? When they are in a crowd where nobody can stop them? This is also a part of the “Freedom” as they understand the revolution. Democracy is like “I am free to do what I want… Mubarak is gone, nobody will stop me…” I am more shocked from the behaviours and treatment in the hospitals, the doctors, the nurses, this worries me more. What is the different, by being married or virgin?

      • Mazin, I think that was another incident…Natasha was attacked on 26th June. There have been several of these incidents. I agree with you: I think they’re state-sponsored paid gangs of thugs.

        There is huge problem with sexual assault and harassment in Egypt generally, and a lot of denial about it…but this is something else altogether.

  652. I can’t believe the ignorant one sided Islamophobic comments people posted here, specially those claiming to live in Muslim countries. Making a connection between Islam and such behaviours not only ignores the fact that non-Muslims in Muslim nations share the same behaviours but also claim that these behaviours are limited to Muslim societies!!
    Please, go back and check how many women are raped or beaten by husbands/boyfriends in the U.S alone. Instead of blaming Islam, you should face the fact that these kind of behaviours are a product of poverty and low education and are spread everywhere in the world depending on how high poverty/low education exist!

    • Typical male moslem behavior. Really though, females should expect such actions in insane moslem crowds. She put herself in mortal danger and was lucky to survive. The sad part is liberal western women will defend islam although this is not all that unusual. Not Egypt?, in light of the muslim brotherhood victory in Egypt’s election, this most clearly IS Egypt and islam.

      • Have you experienced Islam to judge it in that way?! look if you don’t like Islam we have absolutely no problem, but you as a civilized person should respect Islam, and Muslims, no, you MUST respect Islam and Muslims, and so what you are saying right now, and please correct me if I’m wrong, is that when a Christian man, for example, kills a guy we would automatically say it is because of Christianity?! i mean if that is what you mean, then I’m happy to tell you that you are completely wrong, it is not because of Christianity, it is because he has some serious issues, be realistic please !!

      • Yes “Really?!” you are wrong in what you are saying.
        When a christian kills another man or assaults woman in animalistic manner and doctors,nurses and all common people in the christian society around behave in the way Cairo society around behaved with traumatized human beings and specially women , Yes we automatically say that the society has some dominant anti human set of behavior patterns which are promoted by certain dominant culture.
        Does this sounds more realistic ?.

      • Dear Anudeep,
        Yes you might say that the society has some dominant anti human set of behavior patterns, but it is not promoted by a certain religion it is promoted by a certain environment, because i will admit this to you, Egypt has a lack of education and money… etc, and that is why there is a growing population of those who abuse women Muslims or non-Muslims, but you have to put in mind that there is a large amount of Christians there as well, and no it is still not realistic to me, i mean if a message is coming from a higher power from perfection as a matter of fact, then this message is perfect, and there is absolutely nothing wrong with it, because it was made by God (Allah) at least to me and to many Muslims Islam is perfect, just as I’m sure you think your religion is perfect too, but we the people we are nothing near perfection, we do mistakes, and some of us are good, and some of us are bad, and some of us are mentally sick just like those people she just mentioned.

    • Please, go back and check how many women are raped or beaten by husbands/boyfriends in the U.S alone.

      And please check how may women are sexually assaulted and beaten by mobs in public places in the US or Europe. If something like that happened in a crowded square in any Western country, the assailants would be ripped apart.

      • There is no causal link between believing their is no god other than Allah, and Mohammed is his prophet, and sexual assault. If a Christian robs a house, you don’t blame his religion, you blame his criminality.

        Painting Muslims as “insane” is just plain Islamophobic: just as bad as Anti-Semitism or racism. The person hurting a woman now is you, Mike go look in the mirror.

      • For fuck’s sake. It’s not a contest. Wrong is wrong. It’s not a pissing contest.

  653. Your insults and language don’t exactly reflect well on your character. Can you disagree without making yourself look like a total jerk?

  654. Mostafa, your mother regrets the day she pushed you out of her womb. If any woman woud have known in advance she would deliver such a hateful human being, she would abort the damn foetus herself. I spit on your life and the people that are in it.

    As for Natascha; keep calm and carry on with your duty. You are brave and this too can be turned into something positive.
    You have all the tools to do so.
    I’m sorry this happened to you and you are in my thoughts.

    As for the incredibly stupid religion discussion. In the name of all Gods, not just Allah, chidren and women have been raped and damaged.
    If there is one thing I wish for mankind, it’s atheism. People are too damn evil to handle the essence of religion.

  655. By the way, this:
    http://www.google.com.eg/imgres?q=tahrir+square+26+june+images&hl=ar&client=firefox-a&hs=wCj&sa=X&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&tbm=isch&prmd=imvns&tbnid=DENZWwwutR7tKM:&imgrefurl=http://www.abc.net.au/news/2012-06-25/tahrir-square-celebrates-mursi-victory/4089604&docid=zt7D6yV-ov6LtM&imgurl=http://www.abc.net.au/news/image/4089604-3×2-940×627.jpg&w=940&h=627&ei=9m_qT_rpCcLd8APDx-DsBQ&zoom=1&iact=hc&vpx=387&vpy=153&dur=1080&hovh=183&hovw=275&tx=163&ty=126&sig=117836346234915859492&page=1&tbnh=131&tbnw=174&start=0&ndsp=18&ved=1t:429,r:3,s:0,i:81&biw=1366&bih=626
    is a picture of the “small” space on the day of the attack, where those in denial are claiming they would have witnessed what happened to Natasha.

    As anyone who’se actually been in Tahrir knows, when it gets like that, it can take an hour to shuffle from one side of the square to the other…all you can see are the 100 or so people directly around you. Severely injured people have been carried past me covered in blood, and I wasn’t able to see them until they were within touching distance…and that’s in an emptier square than Tahrir was on 26th.

  656. Natasha’s report, kindly translated into colloquial Arabic by Nana Elhariry (thank you!):

    مشيت من القاهرة مجبرة بعد تعدى حنسى و حسدى فظيع فى ميدان التحرير. اليوم ده كنت ماشية مع اتنين اصدقائى كحماية على كوبرى قصر النيل. الدنيا كلها مبسوطة و فى حماس و فرحة, مع انه يوم غريب بالنسبة لى كله مشاكل فى العلاقات الشخصية, يمكن عشان كده كنت مبسوطة بجو الفرحة ده! بصور ابتسامة ستات و أطفال و رجالة بيشاوروا للكاميرا و بيقولوا “Welcome, Welcome to Egypt!”
    السما منورة بالألعاب النارية. إحساس و تجربة محركة للمشاعر.
    لما وصلنا لتهاية الكوبرى, لاحظت ان الدنيا ادزحمت, ة عشان كده قررنا انا و أصدقائى نبعد عن الميدان, أنا و صحابى حاولنا نمشى و حاولت برضه احط الكاميرا فى شنطة ضهرى بس السيناريو اتغير فجأة, لما مجموعة رجالة بدأو يلمسونى لفترة من الوقت و فجأة جرونى من صديقى و لمسوا كل حتة فيا. العنف و العدوانية زادت, صرخت, أنا كنت شايفة اللى بيحصل و ما كنتش قادرة اعمل حاجة!
    مش مصدقة انى اتحطيت فى موقف زى ده.
    صديقى حاول بكل الطرق ينتشلنى لكن مئات الرجال سحبونى بعيد. ضرب و صريخ. اتزقيت على رصيف و العدد زاد. كنت مواطية بحاول احمى الكاميرا لكن مفيش فايدة! الكاميرا اتشديش من ايدى و شنطة ضهرى اتقطعت من ورا. ما كنتش حاسة بحاجة من الزحمة الفظيعة و بأرتباك مجموعة الغوغاء قدام الرصيف, التوت رجلى.
    جردونى من هدومى كلها, و زاد اندفاعهم الشهوانى لأذيتى مئات البشر تتحول لحيوانات قدام عينى.
    أصابعهم فى كل حتة’ المئات تشد اطرافى وتمسك صدرى, يخدشونى بكل طريقة ممكنة. رجالة كتير بس كل اللى شايفاه وشوش تلعنى باحتقار و بيرمينى من ايد للتانية كأنى حتة لحمة طازة فى وسط أسود.
    صرخت ” سلام سلام! الله! الله!” و بكل يأس ازعق طب “مع السلامة!” اقل حاجة اقولها لقطيع من الرجال بيحطمونى, يمكن كنت اعنى الكلام ده لدنيا لا تعرفه!

    كام واحد حاول يحمنى بقوا مجموعة صغيرة بتحاول توصلنى لخيمة. كنت حافية بعد ما اخدوا جزمتى الجديدة! بحاول اوصل لخيمة مهدومة, سحلونى تانى على ارض قذرة و انا عريانة بتهان فى كل لحظة بيشدوا فيها شعرى الاصفر, اللى هو جزء من هويتى الفضائية.
    نفس الرجالة اللى كانت بتحول تساعدنى حاولوا يودونى خيمة تانية. سندت ضهرى على كرسى ببص على الحشد الهمجى. و رغم ان العدد القليل ده حاول يغطينى بحتت قماش لكن كان فى لسه ناس بتلمسنى, نناس كتير قوى.
    كنت حاسة بهدوء غريب, انا فهمت اللى كان بيحصل, وصلت لحالة من الأنفصال العقلانى. ببص بتمعن فى اسنان مكشوفة و عيون مسعورة. بدأت الخيمة تنهار و كنت ملفوفة بقماشة كبيرة…مش عارفة اتنفس, لما حاول راجل رفع راس الخيمة و حاول يضربنى بيها!
    فى اللحظة دى قلت للنفسى بصوت عالى”يا رب كفاية!” انا مش متدينة, بس فى لحظان اليأس كلنا بنفضل اللجوء لقوة اعلى لحمايتنا. دى طبيعة الانسان, الحاجة للاحساس بالأمان و انه محبوب من الاسباب الاساسية اللى بيلجأ عشانها البعض للدين.
    وصلت عربية إسعاف وسط الجموع, فتحت بابها, هجم عليها عشرات الرجال, قفلت بابها و مشيت.
    بدأت افكر”يمكن كده خلاص! شكلى هاموت كده. حياتى كويسة. عشت و لا مت الوضع ده هينتهى قريب. يمكن ده عقاب لالم انا سببته لحد عشان حبة غلطات غبية مؤخرا! بتمنى يخلص بسرعة! بتمنى اموت قبل ما يغتصبونى!”
    بصيت فوق لقيت كام واحدة منقبة بصوا لى بأستغراب و مشيوا.
    بعد 5-10 دقايق, قدر صديقى يقنع الناس فى خيمة طبية يعملوا زى ممر وسط الجموع اعدى منه. عديت بس بعد ما إتلمست!
    وصلت للخيمة و شفت صديقى كالوم. حواليا سيدات مسلمات حاولوا بسرعة يغطوا جسمى العريان. وقعت و لوقت قصير فقدت الوعى.
    الستات قالوا لى ان الهجوم ده سببه كام بلطجى بتوع مشاكل نشروا إشاعات إنى جاسوسة أجنبية, على أساس إعلان التليفزيون المصرى اللى بيحذر من خطورة الأجانب. بس لو هو ده السبب فهو تم إستخدامه كذريعة و عذر لأنتهاك فتاة غربية شقراء.

    لمدة ساعتين تلاتة, ناس رايحة جاية بيحاولوا يكلموا السفارة. كالوم حاول يشرح اللى حصل بكذا طريقة لكذا حد. أنقذ حياتى…بفضله وصلت للخيمة الطبية.
    بشكل ما, السفارة ظنت اننا فى قسم البوليس لعدم إدراك العاملين بالمستشفى إننا مازلنا بها و البوليس كان فاكر إننا فى…الله أعلم!
    قعدنا فى أوضة كلها رجالة. واحد منهم كان شكله بيخاول يصورنى, مش متأكدة ليه, شكلى ماكنش فظيع! قلبى بيدق بسرعة.
    كالوم اضطر يستخدم تليفونات ناس تانية, احنا الأتنين إتسرقنا, و ده اللى سرع الامر. أخيرا حد من صحابنا جيه مع سيدة من السفارة. ودونى مستشفى خاصة, و كان أول سؤال من الدكتور “انتى متجوزة؟” اللى هو اكيد اهم سؤال لضحية تحرش جماعى جنسى!
    هو و الممرضة تفحصانى(بكل هدومى فى مكانها) بسرعة و فضلوا رايحين جايين و طبعا عشان ماكنش عندى نزيف داخلى, مش هيقدروا يعملوا حاجة!!
    أخيرا, روححت البيت بمساعدة أصدقائى, مقدرتش أقول لعيلتى فى ساعتها, كنت متأكدة أن ده هيحطمهم.
    إمبارح, عملت فحص دقيق و خلصت تحقيق الشرطة. كانوا حواليا بيعيطوا بس انا لأ…قالوا لى إنى شجاعة قوى, لكن انا بس قررت إنى أتعايش مع الموقف…يمكن الوضع يتغير كمان كام يوم, مش عارفة!
    أدركت كذا حاجة من تأثير الموقف. كنت بعيط و ارتعش و الدكتورة بتفحصنى. إن حد يلمسنى بعد اللى حصل ده شيء مرعب!
    بعدها ماقدرتش اكون وسط مجموعة رجالة مصريين. مابقتش أعرف أبص لراجل فى عينه و بأصيب بحالة ذعر لما الدنيا تضلم.

    كنت بس مع كالوم و فى تجولنا بالقاهرة, ماقدرتش ابعد فكرة انه اكيد فى واحد من الوجوه الذكورية دى كان وسط الجموع المتحرشة, اكيد كان فيه!
    رغم إنى لا أمتلك المعدات و لا حتى صورة واحدة, صورة واحدة, إلا إنى مصرة على إستكمال الفيلم التسجيلى. قلقى كله إن التأمين ما يغطيش كل المعدات, لو مش كده مش هعرف أكمل, مش معايا فلوس. بس أنا لازم أكمل لأنه من جانب مضيء فى اللى حصل. يبقى انا دورى انشر الوعى و هنجح فى انى ارج أقوى و اكثر حكمة. هاشتغل على الفيلم الوثائقى بكل ما فى من شغف عشان اعرف الناس مدى جدية و خطورة الموقف و انها مش مجرد قصة جديدة الناس تهتم بيها شوية و بعدين تنساها, ده إتجاه ثابت و لازم نوقفوا. المرأة العبية و المرأة الغربية و كل من يعانون منه.
    فأنا عازمة على الرجوع للبلد الرائعة دى اللى بحبها و اتعرف على شعبها مرة تانية. وسأتحدى الصورة و الافكار النمطية عن المرأة العربية فى المملكة المتحدة و الولايات المتحدة. عندى كتير اقوله, بس لأ هاقوله فى الوقت المناسب!
    ورسالتى لمن هم فى اوضاع خطيرة مشابهة, سواء فى المملكة المتحدة أو أى مكان فى العالم, من فضلك ماتغلطش نفس الغلطات و ما تخاليش حاجة تأثر على حلمك أو حماسك. انا ماكنتش مركزة لأنشغالى بالروح الرائعة فى الجو بعد يوم صعب.
    ما تعملش من نفسك ضحية. و ماتخليش التجارب السيئة تفسد عليك حياتك و لا تحدد مستقبلك. كان من أسوأ الحاجات اللى حاستها فى ليلتين فاتوا إنى عاجزة, ماكنش عندى القدرة لكن دلوقتى عندى القدرة لإعادة بناء الثقة و الإستفادة من تجربتى.
    ولا حاجة و لا حد هيوقفنى, انا هعمل كده و العرض لازم يستمر.
    شكرا لقرأتكم!

    كانوا الرجالة واقفين بره عايزين ضخيتهم اللى اتخدت منهم. بيدوروا عليا, وطيت و إستخابيت, حاولوا يهجموا على الخيمة لكن تاناس اللى جواها عملوا حاجز بالكراسى.
    الستات بتعيط و قالوا لى” دى مش مصر! ده مش الإسلام! أوعى تفتكرى ان دى مصر!” أكدت لهم إنى عارفة كده كويس. انا بحب مصر و حضارتها و ناسها و السكينة الفطرية للإسلام المعتدل. كانت مذهولة! اصل انا قادرة اشوف الوضع كويس و ان الهجوم المتوحش ده لا يمثل المكان اللى حابيته و جيت له.
    قرر كالوم, بعد مناقشات ساخنة, ان يمشى منفصل عنى عشان ما نلفتش الإنتباه, تنكرت فى نقاب و ملابس رجالى و قالوا لى امسك ايد راجل مصرى ما عرفوش على انه جوزى. كنت مرعوبة بس ماكنش فيه حل تانى قدامى, فقررت اثق فيه!
    مشى بيا من بين الجموع من ورا الخيمة, فضل يقول لى “ما تعيطيش! خليكى طبيعية!”
    ماشية حافية وسط إزاز متكسر على طين. ادركت اللى فاضل فيا من قوة و بطلت عياط…لازم ابقى هاادية و أكمل. البنطلون كان واسع و كل شوية يقع منى.
    كنت فاكرة إنى رايحة لعربية إسعاف و لا مستشفى. الراجل قعد على الرصيف و لسه بيطلب منى مأعيطش. فى الأخر اصدقاائى ظهروا و معاهم كالوم. قالوا لى إنه ما ينفعش يروحوا معايا المستشفى عشان ما يتقبضش عليهم.
    واحد منهم إقترح بطيب خاطر نروح ماكدونالد ناكل, بس انا رفضت الرض الكريم ده, أصلى ماكنتش حاسة إنى ف موود “بيج ماك”!!
    مشيت انا و كالوم, ركبنا تاكسى. لما وصلنا مستشفى حكومى فى وسط البلد و حاولنا نشرح لهم…بصو لنا قوى و قالوا لنا نروح مستشفى تانية قريبة أحسن.
    وصلنا مستشفى تانية, أول ما وصلنا سألونى “انتى حامل؟متجوزة؟عذراء؟” ماكنوش مبسوطين قوى بردى “لا ”
    رفضوا الفحص و رجعت لكالوم تانى بره. كان اللى يهمنى اتأكد فى ضرر بنفسى, رحت الحمام مش مصدقة اللى شايفاه فى المراية, قذرة و مجروحة وشعرى متبهدل وعيون مصدومة.

  657. Did you even read the story? How are you going to lecture her on journalism when you didn’t even bother to read it? She states very clearly that this happened “TWO DAYS AGO”!!! The opening is in the present progressive tense. It’s shameless enough to turn this into an opportunity to bestow your (garbage) advice from upon high, but you don’t even bother to read the story you’re criticizing. You need to ask yourself how you became such a gigantic asshole. It’s really quite astounding.

  658. Our Cairo anti-sexual harassment group has gained 25% more members over the past few hours, thanks to Natasha’s bravery in speaking out. We’re planning a campaign to protect women journalists and protestors in Tahrir on Friday.

    If anyone harasses the campaign, we’re going to catch them, spray paint them and their clothes neon pink and handcuff them to the nearest lamp post ready to be arrested.

    If anyone would like to join, please see here: https://www.facebook.com/groups/129672763810060/ We particularly need men and women who are wiling to come and protect the Safe Point we will set up, or those willing to mingle with the crowds and keep an eye out for suspicious behaviour.

    Thank you.

    PS: For the trolls here, who are getting their kicks from verbally abusing Egyptians, please just carry out the following exercise. READ the responses to Natasha’s blog, and do some counting.

    Most of the comments are from Egyptians…and the overwhelming number of those comments are apologetic and supportive, 99% plus.

    Of the none-Egyptians who have commented, the majority of the comments are ignoring Natasha’s human suffering in favour of Muslim-bashing, racism or other hatefulness. I’m not going to conclude from these stats that non-Egyptians, “are all animals and have no souls”. Kindly return the favour, please.

    For the people who are casting doubt on Natasha’s story: you are WRONG. Just plain WRONG. Let’s imagine you’re 99% sure this never happened…what about the “1%” chance that you are adding your disgusting verbal abuse to the heap of physical abuse this kind, brave woman has already suffered. Here’s a suggestion: why not keep your doubts to yourself, “just in case”?

    • Not so long ago, I met Dr. Nawal el Saadawi and saw her give a keynote address at a conference. She discussed remaining in Egypt and working to free women from oppression there. She told the audience that she believes the Muslim Brotherhood is not truly a faith-based group–they are not holy people, they are not true believers–but rather that they are misogynists who fear and hate women and who will stop at nothing to preserve male privilege and indeed to prevent all kinds of change in Egypt. If you can get Dr. el Saadawi involved on your side, with your group, I believe she would be a powerful ally for you. I wish you the best in your endeavors to protect women.

      Let us never allow ourselves to be fooled by people who claim to be true believers, but who simply use the sanctity of faith to disguise their greed for power.

    • As a Non-Egyptian born in the Netherlands, immigrated with my parents in 1955 to Canada, I believe Natasha is telling the truth. My father, before he was married more than 60+ years ago, worked in various Meditteranean ports (I don’t know if he was in Egypt per se) when he worked on a freight ship which delivered various goods to that area as well as Western Africa, and was familiar with that area and often told us of his many experiences (e.g. being accosted in one country by several homosexuals from whom he ran quickly away, although being a walled city it wasn’t exactly easy to find his way out through the maze). P.S. Is it possible to put in an edit option in case we make a typing mistake and notice it too late?

    • We need to talk about it, and act against it. There are laws in the Netherlands against his kind of hate crime…four of my friends there have already reported him to the authorities. Please report him too, the vile creature. 😦

    • What made you so vile and hateful? Were you not loved much as a child? Is life that uneventful you have to throw in a few extremist views to get the juices flowing? Do you really believe whites are pure and sin free? What are your views on paedophilia in the catholic church? Why do you pretend to give a crap about how brown people treat women when it is plain for all to see you have a dislike for women? Were you rejected? Was it too much to bear that you must masquerade behind a computer screen, angry at the world for owing you and not delivering you your perfect prize, a white woman for your eyes only? Did she run off with a black man?

      To be quite honest, I don’t care. People like you exist because of pain and fear. Some people take responsibility for themselves and own these emotions, others make it everyone elses problem. I pity you, bet no one has even acknowledged you till last night. Sad.

    • What Sam said. 🙂

      E.Eliveld can be reported to the Dutch authorities in the Netherlands. I’ll get the online link one of my friends used for you. Hopefully, they’ll get him the psychiatric help he obviously needs.

  659. What in the world would you expect from Muslims, especially Muslims being that you meant no more to them than a dog? Do you understand that these people rape their own daughters and then tun right around and kill them because they were to alluring to resist? Has anyone here seen or tried to understand that this happens quite frequently and yet, woman are given a false sense of security because you cannot bring yourself to report the truth that it is very very dangerous in any of these Arab countries for woman? Instead of warning woman of this very large threat you just cannot tell woman that it is a real possibility that by going to these places will almost certainly result in rape and even worse death? It is not going to change. Muburak insured that woman would be safe and enforced that, but he was wrongly removed by lies and deceit and you have facilitated that lie. Welcome to the den of the Muslim Brotherhood….

    • I’m an Egyptian Muslim, I’m not veiled and I look just as foreign as any European tourist. I live the harrassment on the streets, and I totally understand all the previous comments and what they went through. But blaming Islam for this is ABSURD!! Who rapes their own daughters and kill them?!!! That is one FAKEEEEE statement. You think this is what Islam preaches… I feel bad for my religion to be defamed by the acts of idiots and all I can tell u is that the true essence of Islam is not what these terrorists do.

  660. I applaud you for refraining from associating the whole of Egypt with the brutal treatment you received from such a horrible mob. I also am amazed that you had the clarity to write about it, which will do wonders to help other women who may find themselves without a voice after such an attack. I wish you the best with your documentary and hope that you are always able to find help when you need it.

  661. She did not have to say a word your!! Your letter speaks volumes about yourself and how YOU view Females.
    If this is how you and Country men feel about Females the U.S.A should stop sending Billions of our hard earned U.S dollars to your Country and instead offer all of the Females of your Country a free trip to anywhere but there. then you would be free to have all of the MAN on Camel sex you dream of.
    I would like to Thank those who helped for those who participated in this cruel act .Your time will come and a special place in Hell will be waiting for you until then please pick a Camel and have fun you bunch of Motherless sons of Dogs.

  662. Well, this is pretty goddamn horrid, and I am extremely saddened to read about it. I am glad you are safer and okay. And I also feel remarkably angry about this happening to you. Not just because I am Egyptian and a woman, but because I am a human being and that this shit happened to you makes me feel awful.

    But I am I think also angry not just at the terrible men who did this, but the women who looked the other way. This is a problem in Egypt … men have been allowed to get away with bad behaviour for a long time. Women just take it and learn to walk a path around it to avoid it, learn to ‘adapt’ and accept it as somehow normal. It’s not fucking normal. But when you’ve lived within that framework for a long time, you become used to it and accept it as home, and you stop trying to change it because the work of doing so is so goddamn exhausting. However, it is every woman’s responsibility to keep men in check for this behaviour, to fight back, to make these idiotic men realize that their barbaric behaviour is not acceptable. I am not saying it’s women’s FAULT btw – I am saying we are responsible for standing our ground to keep doing so until sense is drilled into the heads of these sad excuses for human beings.

    • Also: Per the whole religious argument, I will say this: This is not a problem of religion, it is a problem of society. Yes, Egypt is mostly Muslim (now) but I have seen such things happen from oh-so- Christian males in Egypt too. Let’s take the religion out of it because you can’t change what religion people are born into (unless you are okay with eliminating it through genocide, obviously), but you can address their behaviour. You cannot blame it on religion, when there are a greater number of people NOT committing atrocities than there are doing so.

      • well maybe that mob was just Copts celebrating Morsi’s victory, who knows, but surely you can blame the religion for not speakign out against such atrocities? No religion is woman’s friend, you have orthodox Jews making women sit at the back of a bus, you got Christian zealots denying them contraception, you have Muslim ones making them a black mass. I mean, it’s normal that something opressed for decades will have a revival, but extreme or moderate, it’s still inspired by religion, because to keep religion in check, you need Ali, Mubarak, or something similar. Until religion becomes a private matter, this will not go away.

      • Um, the Copts I am speaking of were not from that specific event, Mr. J lol.

        I am not a fan of religion, either . I just think eliminating is not the answer…and also the tribal wear which you’re talking about for Muslims is not religious wear, it’s from the tribal wear of long ago. They just keep insisting on making it religious wear, which is fucking retarded. Nowhere in the Koran does it fucking say women should be wearing a black Hefty bag, but when you have a lot of illiterate folk, they will be so easy to manipulate…. as well as people who just are hellbent on seeing ONE thing, they will look for ways to tweak the words as they can (which of course is easy to do in religion since so much of it is metaphorical in nature).

        There are people of a religious nature (imams and such), leaders and so forth who have spoken out against it. But there are also a lot of people who give no fucks and do as they please. And of course there are other so-called leaders of the poor and ignorant who use their influence to keep on condoning asshole-ian behaviour.
        This is why you just need some basic laws that are against this kind of thing, where no one turning their head and looking the other way.

      • Religion has EVERYTHING to do with it. Even moderate Muslims believe that the Quran is the inerrant word of God, taken literally. Do you know what the Quran says regarding privileged nonmuslim people like Natasha?
        Taken from the Quran…

        They (the infidels) will be “rewarded with disgrace in this world and with grievous punishment on the Day of Resurrection” (2:85).
        God’s curse be upon the infidels! (2:89).
        They (the infidels) have incurred God’s most inexorable wrath.(2:90).
        We shall let them live awhile, and then shall drag them to the scourge of the Fire. Evil shall be their fate” (2:126).
        But the infidels who die unbelievers shall incur the curse of God, the angels, and all men. Under it they shall remain for ever; their punishment shall not be lightened, nor shall they be reprieved” (2:162).
        The Unborn are like beasts which, call out to them as one may, can hear nothing but a shout and a cry. Deaf, dumb, and blind, they understand nothing” (2:172).
        Theirs shall be a woeful punishment (2:175).
        Slay them wherever you find them. Drive them out of the places from which they drove you. (2-190).
        The evil-doers shall have none to help them (2:270).
        As for the unbelievers, neither their riches nor their children will in the least save them from God’s judgment. They shall become fule for the Fire (3-10).
        Let the believers not make friends with infidels in preference to the faithful (3-28).
        Do not be deceived by the fortunes of the unbelievers in the land. Their prosperity is brief. Hell shall be their home, a dismal resting place (3:196).
        Believers, do not seek the friendship of the infidels and those who were given the Book before you, who have made your religion a jest and a pastime.(5:57).
        They deny the truth when it is declared to them: but they shall learn the consequences of their scorn (6:5)

        It goes on and on. Do you think those men that attacked her felt it was morally wrong? NO. She isn’t Muslim, and her presence was inherently an insult to their beliefs. The few men that did protect her did not do so because of religious morals, but rather they knew it was the right thing to do, regardless of religion.

        Perhaps if Islamic tenants didn’t call for complete sexual repression from both genders incidents of rape and violence would be much less frequent and severe. Although it isn’t well publicized, Muslim men rape young boys ALL over the middle east, their go around to handle their sexual urges without violating the tenants of God dealing with women.

        Christianity or Judaism isn’t immune from their crimes either. The difference is that those religions evolved so that people may live in modern times, no longer taking the Old Testament literally. Hence we can now shave our temples, allow women to teach, and wear two different types of fabric (all expressly forbidden in the Old Testament).

        Natasha Smith was a victim, but a naive one to think that there is some sort of peaceful Islamic moderate state. Their entire culture is stuck in an anti-intellectual, racist, and backwards 14th century mindset. Despite what politicians argue, we are at war with Islam. Their believes, human rights violations, and sheer incompatibility with the modern world must be rectified to match modern society. Just as Communism couldn’t survive without adopting Capitalist principles, Islam and modern society cannot coexist without some change in Islam itself.

      • Seriously though, you’re right. I just look at people who do this and don’t see religion, I see a mob mentality, and I see something less than human.

  663. I’m so sorry about your awful attack and violation. There is no excuse for the repeated attacks, no, sexual assaults, of women by mobs of hundreds of men in Cairo in the last year. I visited shortly before the uprising and found the atmosphere to be one of mass disrespect of women and acceptance of aggressive behavior, even assault, even by young teenage boys. I hate to say it, but this story and those like it, show what we can expect from the rule of the Muslim Brotherhood. They have no respect for women, and no fear of any reprisals for their repeated attacks of women. The frightening thing is that for every publicized attack there are likely 100 more that are unknown.

    • And yet so much of this shit has been going on during Mubarek’s reign. I think this is more of a societal problem.

  664. You sound a little guilty about something? you were there eh? and just the fact that you speak like that to someone…you disgust me.

  665. I’m so sorry that happened. It’s horrifying. I admire your telling the story immediately and being resolute to keep covering the story and doing your work. Right on!!!!!! And I just want to say that rape should never be part of a real revolution.

  666. I don’t know what i can say to comment on that article or what you experienced in my hometown. i just know that i have to tell you how i felt about what you went through, at least as a sort of respect to your bravery in writing about these horrifying acts. words will keep to escape me only tears help in times like these. but one thing i tell you, your bravery in writing about it, in trying to overcome what you went through, will probably be what keeps you (and others like you/us) together. every egyptian woman faces sexual harassment on our streets however old, young, veiled or not veiled. still my experience with these harassment doesn’t come near what you went through, i have an imagination and multiplying my pain, my anger, my bitter resentment like a thousand times more may be i come close!
    i have to tell you, YOU DID NOTHING WRONG, tired or not at the time, focused or not focused, it was not your fault, it was not your fault, you don’t have to be on the look out for animals among humans! no, it’s not your fault.
    and for us egyptian women, some will keep fighting this and some will keep hiding it! and some day maybe we’ll wake up and find that things are starting to change, not by themselves, but with the help of people like you and me and every person that refuses to see women as pieces of meat 😦
    be well, get over this, however hard i’m sure it must be, but i have faith in the inner strength of women, and i’m pretty certain that you have plenty of that.

  667. oh there we go, there is no violence against women in Egypt. Mostafa said so, therefore it’s TRUE. Do you hover above Tahrir Sq, monitoring everyone’s movement? go have a wank mate, seriously.

    • O Great Mostafa, you are right. No such thing would ever happen in Egypt. It is all propaganda to make us all look like evil people. I am sorry I ever doubted you, there is no such thing as sexual harassment or assault or rape in Egypt.
      It is a perfect land of purity where no bad things happen. Ever. There is fresh milk flowing through the Nile and when the sun rises, the milk turns to cheese and we all have it for breakfast with a little bit of bread which grows out of donkey’s ears.

    • Oh dear, who told you about the mikl that magically turns into cheese? It’s the best thing we have here. Even better than french cheese (but shh, don’t tell). But I hate to break it to you, bread doesn’t grow out of a donkey’s ears. You were probably high if you ever saw that happen. Magic mushrooms do that to you sometimes. Just be careful, they can be dangerous.

      Donkey’s ears, that’s disgusting.

    • Sarah, I think you must be high yourself if you don’t see the intent of my post. lol.
      What is the problem? That you think nothing bad ever happens in Egypt? Oh lala let’s all deny it so that means it’s not happening?
      It’s not even about whether this story written up there is true or not, it’s about the fact that it still happens.

      Also, don’t knock donkey’s ears until you try them.

  668. Don’t say this happened because you were not focused enough. You are blaming yourself. Victim blame is still victim blame even if it’s yourself. This was NOT your fault. You are brave and strong. Love from the other side of the world.

    • I do think she is blaming herself…rather than taking a good hard look at the system of oppression that exists in Egypt that could make what happened to her not only possible but likely. How can we end the abuse of women if we pretend that radical Islam has nothing to do with it?

      • I don’t think religion has anything to do with it at all. People choose how they act. I know vile and wonderful people of every religion.

  669. As an Egyptian young man I’m so ashamed… So sorry for this… But promise all this will end soon, very soon.
    Thank you for being that understanding Natasha…

    • Mostafa, what the fuck? Don’t act like shit like this doesn’t happen in Cairo/Egypt, it does, you know it does. I’ve seen it happen and I have seen it happen and I have had it happen, and I was born in Cairo. Seriously, get your head out of your own ass, man.

  670. “But at times of desperation, we all feel compelled to appeal to some higher power to save us. It’s human nature.”

    No. Some of us absolutely do not believe in a higher power ever. If there was a higher power than this would not have happened. Or that higher power is pure evil.

  671. Typical Muslim comment here; “I am Arab Muslim, and I have Jewish friends, some of which are Israeli(NOT playing Israel card), ”

    What does he want? A medal. It says something of the Arab/Muslim mentality that he annouces he’s friends with Jews as some sort of anomaly from usual behaviour.

    However it is good to see some Egyptians taking responsibility without making excuses;

    “I don’t think I could apologize enough or that my apology would do anything to help. Sexual Harassment is a massive problem in Egypt and its roots are deep in our culture. I could only hope that we will be able to fix it one day.”

    Islam teaches women have LESS rights than men eg to inheritance. No woman can have 4 husbands but men can have 4 wives. In most Islamic schools women can’t be judges. In many schools of Islam women can’t be educated, leave the house unaccompanied etc WHAT DO YOU EXPECT? Its a seventh century belief system that was already violent then. It’s the equivalent of we in the west living by viking law.

    • It’s not about religion, it’s about being allowed to get away with bad behaviour, which is a purely patriarchal thing.

      Also, what woman in her right mind would want 4 husbands? 1 is bad enough.

    • I am Muslim Egyptian girl and obviously you know nothing about Islam. Islam makes perfect sense to girls , it protects us and keeps us safe. I ve been raised to choose whatever I want and take all decisions myself , and I chose to wear Hejab myself because I believe it protects me. I have no idea what your religion is even if your Muslim , but i would surely tell you that you know nothing about Islam. Talk about whatever you like it’s your right.But dont talk about Islam unless you have fully knowledge about it. Thank you and have a good day

      • Excuse me? How EXACTLY does Islam make perfect sense to “girls”?You don’t even know your own religion, either brainwashed or living in denial. This so-called religion advocates beating you if you don’t comply to your husband and then leaving you to rot if you “disobey” him. You are called “nashiz” if you go against cruel punishment imposed by your husband. He is allowed to marry 4 wives and unlimited concubines (we ma melekt yaminakum), and if you even DARE to look outside your window you can be flogged legally under the Islamic Sharia law. Which rock you are living under? Where are women presidents and leaders in the Islamic world? You are even forced to wear hijab, burqa or face what Natasha faced if you walk among such animals. Everything in you Islam calls shame “awra” , Islam insists that women are inferior to men, are deficient in their brains and in their religion, and you call this “perfect sense to girls”?If you were/are not offended by the fact that one man’s testimony is taken over 2 women testimonies, then you deserve what you get. You are typical Muslim woman, blinded by her own ignorance and fears. You think others don’t know about Islam? Think again. Most of us lived/still live among Muslims and in Islamic countries, and in this information age, you have to be reality challenged to think that only Muslims would know what Islam is.

      • Nada, get off it. Not all muslims wear the Hejab. It does not protect you. Men will rip it off and they do. I was born Muslim and would NEVER wear a Hejab. Of course I have also prayed in churches as well, among Christians. And I have also denounced all forms of rules and religion. However, do not say Islam makes sense to girls. Religion does not make sense unless someone drills it into your head. You make a choice. Whatever reasons you tell yourself you are wearing that veil, do not tell me it is protection. Because you cannot hide from the way things become.

      • I know for a fact that veiled Egyptian women are also harassed. That piece of cloth is not really going to protect you. Do you understand that your culture is also telling men that it is ok for them to attack women? The whole culture needs to change.

      • A chastity belt would protect you even more. Would you want to wear one every day?

        You are a slave of islam. Hopefully one day you will wake up and realize that the power of your mind and thoughts is bigger than religious fairytale books.

  672. I can’t say anything more than the woman in the tent said .. this is not Egypt this is not islam
    on behalf of every egyptian men how have dignity ..I’M SO SORRY

    • Please leave that disgusting place. It’s very likely it could happen to you again. This does not happen anywhere else – but Tahrir square.

      • I think Natasha’s point is that it actually does happen everywhere, Tahrir just one of the places. It’s a sad and scary reality, but it isn’t Natasha’s fault it happened. No woman ever wants for this kind of horror to happen to them. I don’t think any rational person would believe those monsters were in any way, shape, or form what Egypt or Islam are all about. Natasha, really amazed by and admire your strength, grace, and dignity.

      • Unfortunately, this can happen to any woman in Egypt within a large crowd of men (ex: celebrating a soccer game, protesting). It’s a very big problem that is finally being discussed.

    • as an egyptian young man shame on you for believing this bullshit you ignorant idiot. i don’t believe you know the first thing about egypt and i doubt you even live here. you clearly have no idea about tahrir or anything that goes on there and just believe anything you read

      • You make me sick. It’s because of people like you that Egypt is such a fucked up place.

  673. No words of sense or comfort have come to me while I’ve been contemplating this story. All I’ve managed is to wish that the universe sees fit to protect you from here on in.

  674. Am an Egyptian , Deeply sorry and ashamed for what happen to you :-((. I wish we became civilised as we used to be 7000 years ago or to die all if we ll turn to animals , soo sorry again and forever :-((((

    • Please leave that disgusting place. It’s very likely it could happen to you again. This does not happen anywhere else but Tahrir square. There is no record of attacks like this on women anywhere else. How many women have to be savaged by these men in Tahrir square before something is done. It’s time people started acknowledging that and stop making excuses for the weird unique behaviour that keeps happening – in Tahrir square only – over and over again!

      • Hello again, Mr. “Journalist”, stop leaving the same pathetic ethnocentric reply on every single post. Makes you seem so much less credible. Just saying.

        BY THE WAY, there is a record of these kind of attacks happening EVERYWHERE IN THE WORLD. So cut the monotonous crap, please. (I asked nicely.)

    • So “Sarah Abdelhalim” who is apparently living in a different world says:
      ” pathetic ethnocentric reply”
      Have you looked at responses from nutcases like “Mustafa”?I see you defending his woman hating post, hating everyone who is not Egyptian or Muslim, call others names, and even justify his juvenile style, yet you are “offended” by someone saying truth that you don’t like. Seeing your writing style, I am convinced that you are either a troll/a sockpuppet of “Mustafa” or just another ignorant Muslim Woman. You even showing disturbing sign of ignorance claiming Islam means peace while it meas submission. You are yet another Muslim woman who simply does not understand her own religion.

      “Makes you seem so much less credible.”
      Obsess much?
      You probably don’t see how ironic is this statement, given the crap that you spew so far.

      ” there is a record of these kind of attacks happening EVERYWHERE IN THE WORLD”

      Which makes it alright to happen in Egypt too, right?
      So you people call Egypt “the mother of the world” (Um El-Donya), and claim Islamic societies do not have such behavior, Islamic countries have no problems, there are no problems, women are treated equally, “Islam makes sense for girls”, …etc and here you are, making up excuses for a mob of animals violating and sexually assaulting a woman, someone you should be the first to stand by and condemn such attacks, and go even shamelessly dug deeper to attack anyone who sympathized with her and offered support.

      Yet you chose to be the devil’s advocate. Are you a woman hater? Yes, once you come out from under that rock, do some research, there are thousands of women out there who hate women.

      “. So cut the monotonous crap, please. (I asked nicely.)”
      Please do yourself a favor and look up the meaning of the word “nicely” in any dictionary, and then read what you spew again, see if it fits the definition.

      You also claim that Koran is against rape. Really?Have you even read the Koran without your Islamic glasses?What would you call Koran’s forcing women to submit to their husbands’ call for sex? Even your prophet says if a woman would not obey her husbands’ call to bed the “angels” would curse her till morning comes.

      So basically you have no idea about your own religion that you are defending. Yet another Muslim woman who has no idea about Islam, so what else is new?

      Any woman who defends rapists and sexual predators that attacked anther woman, needs to be locked in mental care and under heavy medication, yourself included you shameless rapist supporter.

  675. You’ll forgive me if I am frank. I am almost incredulous at your rather stubborn refusal to admit even to yourself that your attack was not an aberration but part of a pattern of behavior that has been inculcated into an entire culture and religion through the practice of a perverse and false religion. You bravely(foolishly) seem to insist that your” show must go on”. I sincerely hope you change your mind, and soon, else we will be reading about your demise, not your attack. May God, and yes He exists and His name is not allah, make Himself known to you and be gracious to you, and save you , even from yourself.

    • Based on your pompous and high-and-mighty response (which completely misses the point of this article), I have to say it’s people like you that make me want nothing to do with your “God.” You sure know how to make “Him” and his followers look bad.

      • ND, you may be correct about nunya’s tone, but it’s perhaps wrong to discount his or her opinion so quickly. Systematized misogyny is real, and it exists in many places. I think it exists in Egypt. Unquestionably, it exists there very strongly.

      • He’s not “his” God, he’s our God. That includes you. He created you as well. All monolithic religions pray to the same God. So yeah, he created you as well. So don’t belittle Him.

      • my comment was for ms smith and none else, I will respond this once and only, I am not God nor do I speak for Him. I will however Quote Him” the fool says in his heart there is no God”.

    • Oh really, Nunya, so does that word God exclude the spanish one Dios, which is Christian? You realize this is a retarded comment because you’re talking about THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE don’t you, you fucking nitwit?

  676. Natasha,
    On behalf of all honorable Egyptians, we are truly sorry that you had to go through all of that in Egypt. I hope you will accept our apology and maybe one day will be able to show you how wonderful this country and its people really are. I can only blame the Egyptian media for messing with people’s heads only to protect the bastards who rule. I AM SO SORRY
    Ahmed Ghoneim
    News reporter

    • Please leave that disgusting place. It’s very likely it could happen to you again. This does not happen anywhere else but Tahrir square. There is no record of attacks like this on women anywhere else. How many women have to be savaged by these men in Tahrir square before something is done. It’s time people started acknowledging that and stop making excuses for the weird unique behaviour that keeps happening – in Tahrir square only – over and over again!

      • Journalist….you are clearly a man. You haven’t been attacked by men…..I have.
        Not hundreds, but several at a time…….I have fought back and have experienced no where NEAR the vicious attacks that have been reported here…..
        But it sure aS GODDAMN FUCK HAPPENS ELSEWHERE…..!
        Lets see…..um….in the USA…..in Italy….and in France…….how do I know??
        BECAUSE I WAS ATTACKED BY MEN IN THOSE COUNTRIES YOU SANCTIMONIOUS ASSHOLE.

  677. there’s no excuses for this crime & no words could explain how sorry am i…
    please accept my apology…me many more are ashamed of this so again we’re sorry & hope one day u know this is not us 😦

  678. I don’t think I could apologize enough or that my apology would do anything to help. Sexual Harassment is a massive problem in Egypt and its roots are deep in our culture. I could only hope that we will be able to fix it one day.

  679. I read your story, and I found it profoundly disturbing. As man, I am appalled by this total lack of respect, this objectification, this savage, misogynist attack on your identity, your body, and your private sphere of intimacy.
    I pray for you in these hours. May your friends and family give you the strength, trust and love to overcome this tragedy, and to eventually carry your important work.

  680. First, as an Egyptian I beg you to accept my apology for what happened.
    hope you don’t get the wrong idea about Egyptian men.
    please, I’m an Egyptian man who participated in the revolution. I went to Tahrir almost every important event their. I can be quit sure that all the sexual harrasement happened in Tahrir were managed by the remaining men of the old regime. this is the plan of the old regime to ruin the reputation of Tahrir square and the people who fill it during every protest.
    this plan is also to terrify the Egyptian girls who effectively participated in the revolution and the demonstrations and prevent them from anymore protest. also to terrify the western women especially journalists to give the bad reputation in their country and destroy the symbol of Tahrir square.
    please put this points in your mind, and accept my deep apology.

    • Start taking responsibility for the actions of these men and stop blaming the old regime or any regime or some plot. It’s the behaviour of these men in Tahrir square who all join in because they want to. No one is telling them to behave like this. It’s sick – and it doesn’t happen anywhere else. And female journalists work all over the world without it happening on this scale. Nowhere near the scale of Tahrir Square. Why is that?

      • According to studies conducted by the Egyptian Center for Women’s Right (ECWR) in 2008, 98 percent of foreign women and 83 percent of Egyptian women surveyed had experienced sexual harassment in Egypt.

        Meanwhile, 62 percent of Egyptian men confessed to harassing women and 53 percent of Egyptian men faulted women for “bringing it on.”

    • First, as an Egyptian I beg you to accept my apology for what happened.
      hope you don’t get the wrong idea about Egyptian men. I can be quit sure that all the sexual harrasement happened in Tahrir were managed by the remaining men of the old regime.

      Oh, please! While her case is on the extreme end, Egyptians’ attitude towards women foreigners are well known, especially if they’re blondes. Stray away from your male companion or tourist guide in any crowded quarters and you risk being gang-groped and women walking alone are routinely spat upon. It’s been like that for decades.

      Look at some of the videos: these dozens of men, pushing and shoving for the chance to give the infidel prostitute a taste of Allahs justice, they are all Mubarak agents?

  681. i really don’t know what to say to you
    unfortunately obsession over women’s body is increasing in Egypt especially this decade i assure to you its not only that you are a foreigner
    girls here are raped and harassed sexually everyday even if they are covered from head to toe i am not going to try to make us appear like angels and our men are so pure because lately they are not it is something that needs to change and we are doing our best to change it
    i am so sorry and i hope you recover soon you are indeed strong God bless you and since you love Egypt pray for us to be able to change that soon

  682. This is horrific. Have strength. Your writing here is wonderfully beautiful and powerful.

    This sounds stupid and trite, I know, but it’s amazing. You are so wonderfully strong.

  683. Thank you for sharing your story. I believe your words could possibly save another woman’s life in the future.

    Thank you.

  684. Natasha,
    I am sorry for your experience. You have my deepest respects.
    All others,
    I don’t know why this turned into a country specific case. It is simply human nature. All humans could go monstrous with enough mischief on their side. Come on people for fuck’s sake. Manson was American. Hitler was German, Mussilini wasn Italian, Stalin Russian… Seriously! Idiots are world wide in all shapes and sizes. Humans eat, fuck, drink,and discriminate… grow the fuck up.
    Yeah i know Muslims look scary with their beards, but so do sun burnt fat ladies. Scary people are not necessarily bad. Sirens are good looking..

    Again, sorry Nat.

  685. I am Egyptian man, and I really cant express the sadness that I feel for you and those sick twisted people that did this. How low can these people be!

  686. i cant find anything to tell you,i only wanted to show to you that i hear you,i hear your sorrows,i feel your pain,i am so sorry ,so sorry that you had to go through such a horrible experience.but stay positive,you impressed me with your attitude,you are so strong,and i am terribly sorry that that happened to you ,and especially in my country,i feel guilty somehow,if i as a woman in egypt had put up a fight about the sexual harassment that happens daily to every single girl,maybe you wouldnt have to go through what you just gone through.
    .the civil society is trying to do sth about it,and i am trying to change it one man at a time.
    i am so sorry i wasnt strong enough to prevent that.
    my heart goes out to you my dear dear friend.

  687. I know right? I mean who would joke about them being raped? “…I might as well have yelled ‘goodbye cruel world! Down I go!'”. Along with that, if I ever got brutally raped like that I would’ve fainted straight away, this hoe remember everything in detail…Shakespeare can’t even be as detailed as that.

    • Are you effing kidding me?You are the people of the world who deserve to be locked away from other humans. She’s a journalist, she’s been taught how to tell a story. This story was widely reported in the news and the fact you are going to say it is made up is so unbelievably shameful, I can’t even begin to describe. I hope I never meet you in my life.

  688. Pingback: This & That - The Daily What

  689. Pingback: Journalist Recounts Horrifying Sexual Assault In Cairo’s Tahrir Square | Le monde de l'information

  690. I think I’m calling BS on you. Did you read the article? Where does the author say she was “surprised”? What she said was “I couldn’t believe I had got into this situation.” What surprised her was her own absence of caution. She knew something like this could happen. She tried to be careful. But she let her guard down momentarily and this happened. You invented her “surprise” and then beat her down with it, calling her “howl-at-the-moon stupid”. So congratulations. You just denigrated a victim of sexual assault.

  691. I know that my words of sorrow are not enough for you but unfortunately, that is all I can offer. Thank God you are still safe after all the hard time. What doesn’t break you makes you stronger
    God bless you.

  692. i cant imaging what you have been through, its a horrible thing to even just read it, i just wanted to tell you that most girls in egypt experience sexual harassment on daily basis weather she is covered from head to toe or not, i mean if you don’t have a car or not with a guy friend its not gonna be pretty thats the shameful reality, and this was never in egypt before we used to be good people, some of us still are, what you’ve experienced was a result of ignorance that Mubarak’s regime have plagued Egypt with, over the last 30 years, imagine that all they cared about during this period is just how they can get rich, not thinking about a proper education or medical treatment for egyptian people, but since we have revoked we certainly can change all this outrageous disgusting manners, we can raise awareness and thats the right thing to do, thank you for your understanding and courage and am really happy you want to continue what you are doing and not giving up, am proud of you as a woman.

  693. this is all very well for yuppies with perfect english and internet access to postulate how Islam means peace and how these savages were only few in all of Egypt, but this is not the first such crime, crime committed in public for that matter, during what was supposed to be a celebration. I’m not going to discount it to felool conspiracy, because this is something far more profound. Do you have debates on violence against women? on TV? in Mosques? in public? was this even picked up by Egyptian media? Imagine a woman gang raped during Olympics in any western country, it would make headlines the world over, and here, do you need ‘time’? a lot of denial hiding behind this ‘peace’ narrative, granted, women in the west didn’t gain their rights overnight, they fought hard, but they fought. as long as half the population accepts that they have the rules set for them, that they must hide in public because some tribal custom dictated so hundreds of years ago, because they have to accept that at any moment a mob can appear and go wild at a sight of an ankle, that they can have their clitoris cut off, that they can be married off in their teens, that they must bear as many children as their horny bigoted men proscribe them to, and so on, nothing will change. this is about control, and by projecting their insecurities onto a woman, and her body more specifically, Muslim men just prove how infantile they are, afraid of vagina dentata. I’m not religious, and there is enough to raise your hair in Christian attitudes towards women, but to my western eyes, I can only feel sorry for the situation in the Arab countries. And it has a lot to do with religion being the base of almost everything – politics, social, cultural spheres. you can talk all you like about how all kinds of evils flourished since religion was relegated to a second plan in Europe, but that’s how I prefer it, for a man has a brain for a reason, namely to use it, and what you have here is religious indoctrination taking over reason. I’m not saying they did this because they were religious, it’s not the point, but the environment defined by religion leaves little room for reason, I think I just got tired.

    • spot on! the cult forms the culture, perennially claiming a sense of victimhood and it’s always someone else’s fault, right now it must be Mubarak, but above all it is always the ‘joos’, and that permeates throughout.

  694. Pingback: Natasha Smith: "Por favor, Dios. Por favor, haz que paren." [INGLÉS]

  695. Hello Natasha. This hasn’t happened to you because you are a ‘western’ woman. It has happeend to you because you are a ‘woman’. I had the same experience in Tahrir square, and I don’t look the least bit western, every one knew I’m Egyptian, it has happened to me and 5 others of my female friends, eve though we all covered our hairs like typical Muslim girls do in Egypt, we also had male friends accompanying us, but they were being beaten up and stabbed while we were being sexually harrassed and almost rapped, thankfully some people were able to shield and protect us, and some of the area residents took us into their homes because whenever we go to a tent it would collapse as well. I know exactly how you feel. My camera was stolen as well. A stranger took me by the hand and was running so fast among the crowd so that I can reach his home and be safe with his family. I am very sorry you had to go through this. I bet it is not just you and me, I bet there are hundreds of women who have been through this.. one of my friends had to be hospitalized because of the emotional trauma, her physical state was also pretty bad, her arm was broken. I don’t understand what kind of pleasure they get out of this.. what can be going on in their heads! The people that were trying to protect us were much less than the ones attacking us… It was also very touching that very simple people were the ones trying to protect us. I owe those strangers my life. Again, you are not alone, and it’s not because you look western. It is because the people who have done this turned from humans into animals like you said.. animals are even better than them.

    • Please keep on speaking out about this. Please – because maybe sometime someone will listen and it will stop. But it just keeps happening in Tahrir Square.

    • She’s not a liar. If you went to Tahrir then tthis would have happened to you as well! Ask some girl you know that goes there! It has happened to me personally as well. Believe her or not, but just don’t go there.

    • I doubt you are telling me the truth. Referring to her as a “bitch” raises my suspicion already and your poor attitude towards her. It reminds me of a fellow I once worked with, who believed his own flesh and blood children to be better than his wife who he said could be “replaced”.

    • Oh good job being objective, mr journalist. Ever heard of propaganda? Learn to analyze everything you read, please. Journalists like to exaggerate sometimes. Other times, they even like to make up crap. I’m not saying this doesn’t happen. just never to this extent. She shud’ve just kept it to the facts, no exaggerations necessary. That’s what makes me suspicious.

      • YEah Sara Same here She is totally exaggerating and really i cant imagine people are buying this crap! really she is suh a bastard for making this story up! no single person at tahrir square saw what she is talking about!!

      • there is no evidence that this story is true im so sorry……

    • Bullshit. You were there Shaymaa? Did you cop any good feels? Are you one of the perverts who assaulted this woman? Is that why you are so defensive? Or is it guilt from all the women you have called “bitch” for trying to speak their minds? Your position is absolutely indefensible. What are you, the omniscient all-seeing eye of Tahrir? All kinds of shit has happened to women in that square. Most of it is denied by “men” like you unless there is a perfect camera angle on it from some evil foreign journalist hiding out in a nearby high-rise. The movie 678 captures quite well the culture of abuse men force upon women in Egypt on a daily basis. You can’t hide anymore, pervert.

  696. please accept my deepest apologies for what happened to you…ialmost cried just by reading this and i cant imagine how horrible this was for real.. i beg you not to let this affect you in any way even your work..i swear to god this is not my country Egypt or my religion Islam .. Egypt former rulers are intentionally spreading this just to stop our reveloution from getting the support of the crowds..to make us say that their era was way better than ny reveloution…be yourself coz you are already the strongest person i’ve ever seen in my life.. please spread the awareness ..god bless u dear

    • This is Egypt. Let’s face it. I live here. I am part Egyptian. It IS what Egypt has become. Let’s own up to it, admit it and take responsibility by educating the youth properly (I am a teacher to Egyptian kids, so am doing my part) and – as an Egyptian man – you could possibly join forces with other Egyptian men to spread awareness on this type of thing and to help alter rigid and backward mindsets into more progressive ones. Teaching messages such as ‘respect all women’, ‘never harass them, physically or verbally’, ‘women are human too and have feelings,’ and ‘do not rape women – ever’ would be a good start.

      • You are right. When I was being sexually abused in Tahrir square, the people trying to protect me were saying all the time ‘this is not how Tahrir is about.. not everyone here is like that’, that was true because there were some people trying to protect me, but the vast majority were attacking me!

      • No one with a brain can possibly believe that GODs will is served by beating and raping a woman. No one with a conscience can look the other way while this goes on; sadly, the American government is doing just that. Obama turned his back on the good people of Iran, now he is abandoning Egypt to the forces of darkness

  697. Ahmed El Sadek and Anita: As a western woman in Cairo i have seen stories just like hers (a large mob hiding within a bigger group, stripping a woman completely naked and throwing her around between them like a piece of meat) and I know for a fact that there aren’t any blogs about it or articles or police-reports as the woman i know broke down and had to be escorted home. How many you-tube videos do we need to see? How many incidents and reports at nazra, at harassmap? How close to home does it have to hit? Yourself? Your sister? Get your heads out of the sand! And i hope for gods sake you’re not the same Ahmed Sedik that tours foreigners around for a living! I don’t know Natasha, but sadly, I know of stories like hers, from reliable sources. i don’t think she’s exhaggerating.

  698. Anita, there both young men and women who refused to have insight into problems, and think theirs are the only one worth anything believing. Then there are those who know things like this happen, and lie about because that’s what they do to cover it up. Some have been victims themselves, and refuse to acknowledge others who have been victimized, while others are like those people who have a mindset that if something doesn’t happen they way they think, it couldn’t have happened. You are naive, and your comments are obtrusive no matter the reason.

    • Specially when they are Muslims … Am against ignorant people no matter what their religion .. arrogant ,selfish, fool people never comprehend any teaching ! easy to manipulate and drove . they have narrow perception and hard life , and many psychological disasters within .. Am Muslim trying to implement my religion and the most important teaching of Islam is good Ethics , these behaviors dont reflect Islam and whomever do this will be judged in life and beyond … As Person i am against sexual harassment and violence , and will defend anyone no matter what his believes his race his color to Death , thats my obligation as a Muslim . and thats what i have been taught .

  699. Wow…aren’t “you” the pathetic one? Such sophisticated language: bitch/retard…sex with a camel?!!! What’s the matter, can’t make your
    argument without using words that negate all of your credibility as a
    thoughtful and ethical human being? Ever notice how everyone is a
    tough guy while hiding behind a computer screen. That’s you…
    pathetic.

  700. A woman is writing a story on her blog about how she was horribly assulted and you make it into a journalism-class? Are you for real? You both seem completely bonkers. This story sounds like other peoples stories because it’s happened to many people!! It’s happened to many people when the masses get big enough for a mob to hide within it and thats also how it goes unnoticed.

    I think you’re immensly brave for sharing this and moving on so un-judgemental, Natasha. You have my deepest sympathy and fullest support.

  701. You were there at the moment it happened? Some men, unfortunately, treat women worse than their own flesh and blood.

  702. Sexual attacks upon women have taken place in Tahrir Square on several dates. Some of the victims were veiled Muslim ladies. Blaming the victim for immodest dress or European appearance is just another form of denial.

    There is no excuse for these crimes. They are the shame of Egyptian men.

    It would help prove these are not typical of Islam or Egypt if men told OTHER EGYPTIAN MUSLIM MEN this is a sin. Don’t tell us. Doing this in a mob of others doesn’t make you invisible, guys!

    If you don’t want Islam to be seen this way, tell the other Muslim Arab men to stop doing it.

  703. And natasha please don’t go back there. Arabs cannot be trusted. Thery would do it again if they get the chance. Don’t spread the awareness, leave them for what they are. Just try to forget the horrible things that happened. I repeat, ARABS CANNOT BE TRUSTED.

    • My Arab male friend was hospitalised because he was beat up trying to defend me and my other female friends from being harrassed in Tahrir square. This one Arab can be trusted and I am sure there are a lot like him.

    • Very, very stupid of you. This is probably the first interaction you have had with an Arab, even if you knew half the Arabs in the world, you do not know them all, therefore can NOT say something like this. P.S. had it not been for the Arabs, America would no longer be a world power, the world runs on oil, and the Arabs are rich in it. They are scared of saying no to selling oil to America for an increasingly cheap price, for fear that they will do to them what they did to Iraq – absolutely destroy the country with a fake motive.

      • One day, Americans will wake up and develop our own energy resources. When we do, the price of oil will drop like a stone.

      • One day ManassasGrandma, one day, but for now, the world runs on oil, which is why some think its’ worth is more than that of hundreds of thousands of lives. Quite sad really.

      • Oh, how big and pretty words you use and you still can’t understand irony. Well, I’ll say what you thought he said plain and simple for you: Islam is part of the problem.

        Keep up the good work; Natasha!

  704. “… the innate peacefulness of moderate Islam….”

    I’m truly sorry you had this horrible experience and respect and admire the courage it took to write about it. I hope for your sake you drop the gullible naivete. And leave the ranks of those stupid enough to buy into the “Arab Spring” nonsense — that would include the US President & SecState.

  705. I accualy had great admiration for the people standing up agains Mubarrak. Since I’ve read your story and others like it, I feel like the country will never be good since the people arnt good. I hope you are doing better now, I wish you all the happyniss that is still to come.

    • Most of the people in Tahrir are the noblest I have ever seen or heard of in my life…literally risking their lives for a principle.

      • Which is exactly how we got democracy in the west. The problem is to create and maintain an open and fertile soil for the roots of democracy to grow strong. It has worked in the west with some exceptions. Besides Israel, there are still no functional democratic states in the middle east and north Africa.

    • That ought to shut everybody up.
      Chilling, horrifying. This is one of the most animalistic, non-human things I have ever heard of. What a stark contrast; An internet video of humans that are not human.

  706. What do you expect from hordes of mohammedan Arabs? White women are like a lump of sugar to a swarm of flies where they are concerned. You should have had a much larger and preferably armed escort as a white woman moving amongst a barbarian rabble of that nature, especially in Egypt in her current woeful state, in the grip of idiot liberal “revolutionaries” on one side and extremest mohammedan zealots on the other, they probably thought violating you would render some sort of worship to their monstrous “god” and his “prophet”. The Arab is always prone to violent spasms of bestial savagery, it’s the heat or the water or something God alone knows.
    I must say you do yourself no favours in relaying this information in prose that smacks more of Mills & Boon than a traumatized rape report but that is not to say I do not believe that, minus certain exaggerated elements, this event took place. White women should never stray among natives unless unaccompanied by several non-native men , it never ends well.

    • dude, she herself just mentioned that she knows that not all Egyptians are violent, and she herself just mentioned that she knows that not all Muslims are violent, look it is true there are violent Muslims and Egyptians and Arabs, but that doesn’t mean that all Muslims, Egyptians and Arabs are awful like those animals she just mentioned ,look if you don’t agree with the message of Islam it is okay really you have your own believes, and i don’t mind but you have to at least respect it, because not all Christians for example are perfect some are awful, and some are very friendly and amazing, and that is what it is called to be PEOPLE, that is us dude, some are evil and some good, SURPRISE !

    • I wasn’t sure if this was just really ill-judged sarcasm, as it’s so mental. Where are these people coming from…? Scary! 😦

  707. I read your story and i really felt shameful, angry, disappointed, disgusted and shocked from what my people did to you, saying sorry is not enough and it won’t erase these bad memories, but we are sorry, i am sorry, i cherish you for what you have done and how you reacted, and thank you so much for being a better human being.

  708. You calling her story unbelievable because you didn’t see it? I think you have a problem and it has less to do with what happened to her and more to do with your ideas of how people should be respected. Are you all and knowing? You are not, and people should be thankful for that. You come on here and rant against a victim of something horrible. Mindful people, the kind who don’t do these types of attacks, they know better then accuse someone of being a liar even if they are not sure. I would suggest you think about why it is so difficult for you to understand how this could happen. Camera’s are not everywhere, and you certainly could not be. There is a true history of men doing this. What you are doing coming here making such an accusation? Are you one of those feeling guilty, or shameful for taking part in such an act? Her’s was not the only one? Mindful and respectful people don’t react as you do, so perhaps you were one of those involved in one of the assaults? Do you realize how you look? Think about it.

    • Stop being so fucking biased. Look who’s accusing whom now.. (You look pretty bad right now, just sayin’.)

  709. If you read the rest of her blog you will see that she went to Cairo to start a career in journalism. That she was in Tahrir square during a protest shouldn’t seem surprising.

    What you are doing is blaming her for being abused rather than the morally repulsive abusers and would-be rapists and murderers.

  710. Sad and sorry this happened to you… You got caught by one of the feet of the statue of Daniel’s Prophecy… the other being the Vatican… To explain why this happens, and yet there are so many who want a peaceful form of it in the same area… let me refer you to this: http://archive.frontpagemag.com/readArticle.aspx?ARTID=30675
    Your friends there are caught up in a system that will either sweep them along, or go after them as well if they keep trying to be sensible…

  711. Thank you for your courage and sharing your experience of going from being a victim to a survivor 🙂 keep believing and giving people strength to do the same.

  712. Rot op, Eliveld.

    Seriously, we’ve heard you insulting this woman a few times already. For such an “educated” European man, you really enjoy calling women misogynistic names.

  713. If this has happened to you, I am sure Tash would offer understanding and condolences. I have heard more stories from Tash than I could possibly hope to recount, but I have never known her to exaggerate, lie or deceive. She always behaves with great integrity and optimism which only makes this story all the more saddening. I do however agree that she would make a great fiction writer, although for reasons different from yours.

  714. Lovely. I have been to Egypt, under Mubarak. Not a bad place on the whole..NOW? it’s a bucket of shit and I have no doubt that before long, they’ll do something stupid and threaten Israel. When that happens, I won’t mind seeing them destroyed.
    This may sound heartless but it is not.
    You can say “people are good” all you like. 2 things negate this fact in Egypt as it is now. Islam and crowds.
    I feel badly for you . NO woman should have to endure that kind of treatment.
    It’s not your fault but you need to pull your head out of your 4th point of contact and wise up!
    Dye your hair. blend in. If you want to stand out, you will. Often, in tumultuous countries, this will NOT garner the results you want.
    Egypt is in control of islamists now. It is no longer a friendly country. act accordingly.
    You have endured a harsh but survivable lesson. I hope you learn from it and adjust your actions accordingly.
    Frankly, I’m surprised you’re not dead.
    I wish you success with your documentary and I hope you never have to endure that treatment again.

    • 1. Egypt is not run by by “islamists”. far from it in fact, that is one of the reasons the people of Egypt revolted. It is still under the control of the military, just a different leader. 2. She acknowledges herself that she knows not all Arabs/ Egyptians are like this. 3. The people who did this know what they did was wrong, and know they will be judged accordingly in the future. I don’t think you realise this already, but Israel is a terrorist state. More Israelis die from peanut allergies than at the hand of a fellow human (or things set off by humans – bombs etc.). Anybody who against Israel is known as an Anti-Semite, stupidly may I add, considering that Arabs are Semitic also. And to dwell on your statement of a Muslim country being a non-friendly country, what were the native Indians thinking when the white man marched in and stole America, or the aborigine, when the white man also stole Australia, or the Tasmanians, who were wiped out by the white man, not the mention the two nukes dropped by america on Japan, affecting them to this day. Somehow, Americans seem to forget this fact when condemning Muslims, and speaking about 9/11. Also, when the Jews came from Europe and took Palestine, the Americans watched, and when something pops up in UN meetings, America vetoes most things. When the Jews oppress the Palestinians it’s okay, but when an Arab oppresses Israel, it’s the end of the world. Be careful what you say, for it will mostly end up you being contradicted.

      • What a joke this response is. The islamists are only animals and hide the truth to protect their own sensitivities. What occurred is common and not an isolated incident. Not all Arabs are like that, but far too many are. The fact that the hospitals turned her away speaks as much about the animals as the men who tormented her. This is a backwards society and the people without souls.

      • Not at all Bill, you do not know all Muslims, therefore you can not generalise them in that way, can I also say that the are much, much more Christian, atheist and people of other religions/beliefs who are rapists, child groomer’s, and all-round law-breakers than those who are Muslim. However, I agree with you to an extent, I also think there are far too many Arabs like that. And I also agree that many Arab countries are in a backward society (despite being Arab myself) but this is all due to the corruption of the countries who look up to America too much (even though not really relevant). Also, when someone in the crowd screams that someone is Israeli and Jewish, and with all the hype surrounding the area, many people will retaliate brutally, as they know that Israel has been oppressing there Islamic brothers and sisters in Palestine. I am not justifying what they did. I am just saying that this is not a true reflection on the people of Arabia. 1 is too many for people who do things like that. There is no guarantee that all these aggressors were Muslim, as there is a large Christian population in Egypt, and any real Muslim would not dare do anything like that, and those who do are just Muslim by name.

      • Dear Mo,
        I wanted to help you in this argument, but apparently you don’t need any help, so i will just say this one thing:

        I don’t understand how can you guys out of all the people be so superficial and judgmental? have you experienced Islam to talk of it in this way? have you met all the billion Muslims is the world to talk of them like that? just think before you speak please !

      • Yes of course I have experienced Islam, I am Muslim, I have visited many Muslim countries, I have experienced many cultures, and none of these have promoted oppression of women. Islam is about co-existence, there would be no existence had there not been a woman. However, never once did I say anyone would get along perfectly fine together, I just simply stated that it was a possibility. I have met many Muslims, and rarely have I met a bad one. The prophet Muhammad (PBUH) preached a message of tolerance of women, especially as whenever you disrespect a woman, you disrespect someone’s mother/wife/sister/daughter/aunt etc.. This makes you think “what if she was my …”. The people who sexually harass women are doing so through there own will, and not that of the Quran, therefore, Islam can NOT be held responsible.

      • And once again, Journalist, I am not justifying what they have done, but I am condemning.

      • Dear Mo,
        I was actually pointing my questions to Bill Fisher and E.Eliveld 😀
        and you have just proven my point, people who actually experience Islam can judge it to be the message of peace.
        and i’m a Muslim too.

      • Oh, we Egyptians have no souls? Oh….kay then.

        Anyone have a really large butterfly net, please?

      • That’s just plain laugable. You can apologize for Islam all you want, but the fact is that this couldn’t have happened in a western society. If this type of thing had been underway in london, there would have been thousands trying to help her and to stop the attack, police to take care of her, doctors with some empathy etc. This type of thing, mob-rape in broad daylight, could only have happened in a country so influenced by islam as egypt. But you don’t seem to interested in stopping mob rape, only in white washing Islam.

      • Dear Libertarian,
        First of all, this awful thing that happened to her wasn’t promoted by Islam it was promoted by the environment, I will admit this to you Egypt has a lack of education, money, and in addition to the large population size… etc.
        Second of all, don’t forget that there is large population of Christians there as well.
        Finally, by the ignorant way you are judging religion with, then there would be no right religion, i mean lets say this country is destroyed by Islam, and this country is destroyed by Christianity, and this country is destroyed by Judaism… etc, then there would be no right religion wouldn’t it?! people are the ones who are ruining there own countries, not their religion, no matter what their religion is !

    • It is very sad you think this happened to her because she’s or looks western. It happened to Egyptian women in Tahrir every day. I know you feel bad for her, I do as well because I felt exactly the same as her when I was abused in Tahrir, I feel the way she does, you can’t be more sorry for her than me.. but when you say those things about us, Egyptian women included that went through the same horrible experience, you hurt us more..

      • It’s amazing how tens of thousands of men can turn up in Tahrir squate to protest all sorts of things – but not these attacks on women in Tahrir square – because only a few people will protest these rapes. What’s even more amazing is how many women have been attacked in Tahrir square. Egytian girl – you’re so brave. Talk about it – all the time – everywhere.

      • Egyptiangirl, keep fighting for your rights. I knew it was bad for women in Egypt, but now i understand the hate towards women is infinitely deep. I will donate money if i can find somebody who works for womens rights in Egypt.

      • Oh, yes. Cut the crap Sarah. Until Egypt is more secular women will never have peace.

  715. Or you could try not to type in caps lock and not to be this rude. Tahrir Square may have lots of live camera’s, but A LOT of people too. Everywhere there’s noise and stuff, and hundred men aren’t really much in that huge crowd. And maybe it just looked like 100, maybe it was even less. I think it was overlooked, somehow. You are the pathetic one here and you are embarassing your whole country even more. Goodbye.

    • He wasn’t using caps lock to be rude. In this case, caps lock is used to signify anger. If there’s one thing I know about Egyptians, it’s that (unlike most western countries I’ve lived in) they are not bystanders. They would never stand there and watch something like this happen, let alone not even prevent the woman from ahving a check-up. There’s been all this propaganda in Egypt lately. Too many rumours, most of them exaggerated even. So all I’m saying is, don’t believe everything you read.

      • Oh the Sarahs and Anitas of this world, you have no idea, do you? It is people like you who refuse to recognise facts as they are and have a blinkered view of society who, by their blindness, help perpetuate the crimes committed. It is people with your attitude who enable rapists to continue raping – turning a blind eye is so much easier, isn’t it? Shame on you.

      • We’ve seen the videos, so don’t give us the pathetic propaganda-BS. Indeed there are few bystanders, most people are shoving and pushing to get a chance to punish the infidel prostitutes.

    • Sarah, leave your ego behind. You don’t always have to have the last word. You can also let things go once in a while. As for your writing, your messages are way too emotionally charged for someone who thinks they know what good journalism or professional writing is all about. “You ungrateful bitch” is extremely insulting and rude by most standards.

  716. Anita, I’m not sure if you will read this but I hope you will.

    What you have done is callously, and with no grounding whatsoever, called a sexually abused girl a liar and a fraud. Unless you were there or know someone who was, you have no right or reason to challenge her account of the story.

    It doesn’t seem much of a stretch to say that your motivation for these accusations is an attempt to bridge the gap between Egyptian society how it is and Egyptian society how you think it is. What you should be doing is offering comfort and condolences and informing your worldview with evidence. Instead you level unfounded and disgusting allegations, which makes your behaviour both morally and intellectually repugnant.

  717. Excuse me Mostafa. I am assuming you’re a man? You have absolutely no idea what it is like to be a woman in this country my friend. I can tell you that I have been sexually assaulted on many occasions in Cairo just by walking from AUC’s old campus, where I was a student, to my car 100 metres away, WITH a male friend. And that’s only one example. I have many, many more. Open your eyes. There is a huge problem in this country and we need men to help us spread this word. Men need to learn how to respect women and realise that we have feelings and minds just like you. And if you don’t believe this story, or my own accounts, why don’t you just google ‘harassment in egypt’ – or read this http://www.forbes.com/sites/daviddisalvo/2012/06/14/testimonies-of-sexual-assaults-in-egypt-reveal-the-predatory-nature-of-crowds/ – or google LARA LOGAN – or read this article, published by state media about an ad that was recently aired on TV advising Egyptians not to speak to foreigners because they are spies: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/africa/egypts-onair-warning-dont-talk-to-foreigners–theyre-all-spies-7831813.html And if you’d like to see the ad itself, just look for it on You Tube. It’s disgusting. If you don’t want Egypt to have a bad name, then start taking responsibility for the atrocities in it. Start owning up to them, start defending your women and sisters, not pointing fingers at a victim of sexual assault.

    • Excuse me Mostafa. I am assuming you’re a man? You have absolutely no idea what it is like to be a woman in this country my friend. I can tell you that I have been sexually assaulted on many occasions in Cairo just by walking from AUC’s old campus, where I was a student, to my car 100 metres away, WITH a male friend. And that’s only one example. I have many, many more. Open your eyes. There is a huge problem in this country and we need men to help us spread this word. Men need to learn how to respect women and realise that we have feelings and minds just like you. And if you don’t believe this story, or my own accounts, why don’t you just google ‘harassment in egypt’ – or read this http://www.forbes.com/sites/daviddisalvo/2012/06/14/testimonies-of-sexual-assaults-in-egypt-reveal-the-predatory-nature-of-crowds/ – or google LARA LOGAN – or read this article, published by state media about an ad that was recently aired on TV advising Egyptians not to speak to foreigners because they are spies: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/africa/egypts-onair-warning-dont-talk-to-foreigners–theyre-all-spies-7831813.html And if you’d like to see the ad itself, just look for it on You Tube. It’s disgusting. If you don’t want Egypt to have a bad name, then start taking responsibility for the atrocities in it. Start owning up to them, start defending your women and sisters, not pointing fingers at a victim of sexual assault.

  718. 😦 i dunnu what to do or say… i believe that typing some digital letters saying sorry is not enough… but i have no power but to do so at the moment… so here it is… “as an egyptian.. as a human being… i am sorry.. i am really sorry”

  719. One of the molesters makes the scene. “In my country, we dont rape women!” Yeah, i believe you cocksucker, you muslims are wonderful, i know because i live in a muslim country.

    • Don’t insult muslims. Islam means peace. And if you read the Koraan or know anything about Islam, you would know that rape is punishable by death in Islam. You can’t blame all christians because a few stole a bank, and you can’t blame all jews, buddhists or the people of any religion for something one person did. Basically, you can’t make a general statement about a whole religion because of one person that disobeyed that religion’s laws. This is how stereotypes start. Yes, rape is an issue in Egypt, not because of Islam, but because of poverty, corruption, lack of education, etc. etc. This is a problem with a specific mentality in a certain society. Not all muslims are rapists. Not all Egyptians are rapists. Not all men hate women. And yes, surprisingly, not all muslim Egyptian men are terrorists (shocker!)

      • Dear Sarah,
        as a muslim woman, living in the Middle East, I can say that you are wrong. Our religion need to go through reinnovation, otherwise.. you know. The story wasnt about 1 person, it was a group of blood-thirsty and sex-thirsty men, this is a common thing in the Middle East, just read the arabic media (in arabic of course). We are, muslim women, harrased on a daily basis, and whenever I go to Europe-even to the smallest villages, with poor people-no croowd harrasing me. It can be a single man, but never a thirsty crowd.

      • Much honesty! So you understand Islam is the problem, and Muslim men will burn in hell! Islam destroys itself in Syria.

      • Wrong…. Islam is NOT the problem. Religion does not Grope Women…. Men who grope women…. grope women. Whatever brings a man to the point where this very human actions (since it was an action done by a human, it is a human action, duh) there is something that happened before in their mass conciousness saying “This is ok to do today”. Nothing more and nothing less. Please do not try to explain the obvious, THEY DID WHAT THEY DID BECAUSE AT THAT MOMENT THIER MINDS SAID THIS IS OK TO DO” keep it simple folks… humans can only do actions that their minds first indicate is the next action to take in life…. what brings the mind to this point is FEARS and ANGERS…. end of story!

      • Islam is a satanic cult. I hope all bad comes upon you. You deserve it and your satanic brothers and sisters. F off muslim scumpag.

      • There is no god, and no satan, not for muslims, christians or jews. It’s all a big lie. So get over yourself, idiot.

      • Thank you. our religion “Islam” tough us not to respond to an insult by similar although we can.

    • Are you people serious? This kind of tragic display of WHAT ISLAM ACTUALLY IS happens DAILY. Read the Koran in Arabic and see the kind of crap that comes out of that religion. Did I just say religion? Sorry, I meant group of horny sexist pigs that use the word religion as a way to mask their idiocy. Even if this story isn’t entirely factual, which I think it is anyway, it displays THE TRUTH. Get the hell over yourself and learn something about the muslim world.

    • Sarah, i know all muslims are not rapists, but i know they are POTENTIALLY rapists. Why? As i said, i live in a muslim country, and i have been harassed again and again. and when i went to Paris, i harassed again (and he is muslim). I get pissed off. Quran insults women repeatedly, i read it. I read it: this is because why i am an atheist 🙂

    • Rape punished by islam? Unless you marry the rapist, right?
      Instead getting angry with somebody who makes such a statement about a religion (which I don´t agree by the way), you should get angrier with the animals who did that to this girl instead atacking the stereotype of muslim-terrorist-bad which we all know is not true.

      Not all men are rapist, not all muslim are rapist, not all Egyptian are rapist and not all Egyptias are muslim..right. But what about the hundreds of people seeing such a scene and doing nothing!? Many of them were not rapist, but are they free of guilt for doing nothing?

      I hate those animals, don’t care if muslim, christians or atheist. But especially I’m disgusted for the witnesses. Probably you are right and it’s a matter of ineducation and poverty. But when people rise the voice to defend a religion rather than to defend a human being.. I see not only one problem here..

      • Have to agree with you all the religious and political debates God what about the humane part the empathy part the human being in question puzzling how an attack on a religion or a country moves you more than the tragedy itself. I wish you well Natasha and I hope people work to find measures to stop this from reoccurring actively seek change with the same courage you presented your story.

    • Egyptian Naive,
      I would just like to thank you for your politeness -.-
      First of all, there are truly good people, why do you keep looking on the negative side that would show Muslims as a heartless people? what about the people who tried to help her while she was in the crowd? now what you are saying is a big evidence that you have been blinded by the media just as everyone else is. EXPERIENCE ISLAM THEN JUDGE IT. no matter how many books you read, and no matter how many information you get, you don’t know Islam as much as we do, if some people were acting like a total animals, then those people are a total animals not all Muslims or all Egyptian !! be realistic for a second !!, and more important if someone made an awful mistake you blame it on this person not on its religion, because by what you are saying, basically if a christian man for example raped a girl, or killed a man, or whatever we just automatically say it is because of Christianity? i mean if that is what you mean, then I’m happy to tell you that you are completely wrong, because this dude has some serious issues, not because of his religion. stop being ignorant, and racist.

  720. I am 100% Egyptian… To all Egyptians out there that cant believe the story… assure you that this mass sexual assault happened more then three times before in Tahrir Square! One accident was even caught on tape and shoen on CBC Channel ( alocal channel in Egypt)!!! i was mortifed to see it happen with my own eyes during one of the million demonstrations… the number of men harassing this foregin blonde women were over hundred and other people couldnt fight back… she were lifted and her pants almost got off!!!!!

    Natasha, i am very very sorry for what you have been through… Even as an Egyptian woman, i am afraid to go to Tahrir again!!! I want you to be rest assured that i will help you tell you story and spread it as much as i can so we can raise awarness on this horrific issue and stop it from ever happening again!!!

    I will start first by translating your narrative in Arabic (if you allow me to) and try to publish it in one of the popular Egyptian news papers to make it readable by the majority of Egyptian population, who dont read in English….

    I will do all what i can to help you recover from this accident and make you feel better…

    • Your people are animals. Accept it. If they were truly a good people, after the attack the hospitals woujld at least have helped. They did not. Why? Because they too hate anyone not Muslim. I hope the world wakes up and exterminates this abomination on Earth or that the Arab people themselves wake up and realize what a virus on the planet they have become and change their ways. I really hate having to feel this way but over and over again the world sees Islam destroying thed worlds peace. How can anyone deny it when looking at the places in the world where wars rage.

      • I agree with everything you said, I have a small modification. They hate ‘women’ all ‘women’, not just non-Muslim ones.. I am Muslim and the same happened to mr too

      • There are truly good people, why do you keep looking on the negative side that would show Muslims as a heartless people? what about the people who tried to help her while she was in the crowd? now what you are saying is a big evidence that you have been blinded by the media just as everyone else is. EXPERIENCE ISLAM THEN JUDGE IT. no matter how many books you read, and no matter how many information you get, you don’t know Islam as much as we do, if some people were acting like a total animals, then those people are a total animals not all Muslims or all Egyptian !! be realistic for a second !!

      • Don’t call me an animal please…that hardly reinforces your argument, which is presumably based on the assumption that I, as an Egyptian am an animal, whereas you are somehow more ‘civilised’…?

      • the hatred in your speech Bill truly amazes me! don’t u think that you’re being “more than just a little bit” racist? condemning a whole nation to be animals! where are you from really? tell me, creatures who commit crimes at your homeland are only animals as well?

    • Well, I’ve been to Tahrir for several hours at a time, over 60 times…I guess the whole area is a mile square. Tahrir was *packed* the day Natasha was there…that means there were hundreds of thousands of people there.

      Anyone who really *has* been there would know that when Tahrir is really full, you can’t see further than a few metres in front of you, unless you get to some higher ground, which there isn’t much of at all.

      Even when Tahrir is relatively empty, it’s a still a large area and impossible to take in what’s happening everywhere…walking a circuit of the space takes at least 20 minutes.

      The tents in the centre of Tahrir usually have one of the highest concentrations of people…and of course the tents themselves block the view.

      There’s no point lying, just because you wrongly believe someone else is. 😦 Iyeb w iyeb taani. 😦

  721. Tahrir is not a small area, you could not know everything that went on at all times, stop being a fucking tool.

  722. “I reassured her that I knew that was the case, that I loved Egypt and its culture and people, and the innate peacefulness of moderate Islam.”

    Right there’s the problem. You believe that bull. Eygpt is a “moderate” islamist country? Yeah, they treated you just like “moderate” muslims treat women the world over. The just elected a “moderate” muslim president who recently proclaimed: “The Koran is our constitution, the Prophet is our leader, jihad is our path and death in the name of Allah is our goal . . .” You’re lucky to be alive.

    So, when are you going back?

    You’re lucky to be alive. Quit making apologies for monsters.

    • I am not sure where you get your info from, but it is lacking. This is not done because of religion, it was done because of men thinking they can do what they want and blaming it on whatever they want to blame it on.

      • When a law is not made to protect rights and obligations of people but to protect those who made the law in the name of a god.. this is the result.

        You are right, they thought they can do whatever they want. Why? Maybe because they know that in a country with Sharia law it does not really matter if you rape a blonde girl, but don’t you dare saying anything about the Islam or drawing a funny picture of Mahoma, you could be in trouble then.

        Christianity is not better by the way. But at least in some other places we choose to make the society laws to protect the society and its people, not to hail a god.

        Damn religions.. damn stupid followers..

      • Hey Just, your comment is a load of crap. Did you not read the part that the hospitals would not help her? What do you blame that on? I blame Islamic hate. Your ancient, ignorant religion is a scourge on the world. There is way too much evidence to support my claim than to deny it.

      • All the comments are full of so much hatred and lack of manners.
        u totaly missed the point of the article natasha wrote everyone, this is not about religion or ethnic, this is about culture and brain wash, do not tell me that sexual harassement and rape does not happen in the ” civilized” countries. coz they do happen and in a wide range,
        this is about the way men think of women as sexual object not as a respected human beings,
        stop this racist speech and focus on the goal from the article, which is spreading the awareness against sexual harassement ..
        if u cant do any of that, then either say you are sorry for her, or say nothing at all, cause these side conversations that are going on are not of any use at all !

  723. I live in a Muslim country, Turkey, and i know that all Muslim men hate women. This is true. They think that women do not have to right to live as free or equal citizens, that women are reptile creatures. I am sorry what happened to you but it is a daily routine in our fucking countries.

      • Yes, ever since the Islamist party, Akp, has come to power, sexual and physical assaults to women has increased. I live in a so-called modern city, İstanbul, but i know if i go to a bigoted, conservative muslim neighbourhood of the city, i will absolutely be harassed.

      • What do u think the reason for this is? I know harassment is not exclusive to Islam, but then why is there such a high correlation between Islamic nations and the harassment and abusive treatment of women?

      • The reason is the logic behind of Islam, In Quran, Allah insults women repeatedly. I am an atheist but i dare to say that islam must be reformed.

    • I’m guessing, seeing you last name, that you’re a armenian. Which doesn’t me bother don’t get the wrong idea. I’m feeling very sorry for you if you endure this kind of problem everyday. So my question is, why are you still in Istanbul, why dont you go back to your own country. That’s what i would do, if the “conservative” turkey is becoming to hard to live in. But you wouldn’t live as good as in Turkey, back in armenia. Would you?

    • Sorry if you live in the anti Muslim country, you do not know men’s right to know because it is not Islam, or manners, and I hope this thing to differentiate in order to force the charge and Hua’s not fair that.

    • At least i’m not whining about the political issues in my “miserable cove” :D. But isn’t istanbul a CITY in TURKEY? Correct me if i am wrong, but isn’t Istanbul the CITY and TURKEY the country? But yeah, i think i should go back to my cove, since i don’t understand the difference between a city and a country. After you learn the difference, please take some time to answer my question, which is: why don’t you leave the country if you’re displeased with the current situation? just curious.

    • Ah, some1, you are totally idiot. we dont accept your fascist state as OUR country, our country is Constantinople, or Istanbul, choose one. And no, we aint intend to go to another place; because it is our home. CAN YOU BELIEVE IT? 🙂 I think you all must go back your coves or wilderness in which your parents were born 🙂

    • Ah my bad sorry, its your country.
      But istanbul isn’t a country :S. Sheeesh and i’m the stupid one in this conversation 😀 😀 :D. Well maybe for you it’s a country since you are so narrow minded :D. Good luck living in “your” country 😀 XD. I haven’t laughed this much in a long time, god bless you milady and have a good life :D,

      Cheers

      • Shame on you for being so callous and judgemental towards a girl who has endured the harassment that is part of the gender-hate in many Islamic countries. I guess you would rather she shut up and got back to being a good girl, taking it, eh? Shame on you!!!

    • Interesting. I’ve been to Istanbul dozens of times, and travelled all over Turkey, and found people there extremely polite and welcoming. Granted I’m not blonde or blue-eyed, but I saw plenty of European-looking Turkish girls in skimpy dress, in cafes and restaurants, smoking and drinking alcohol openly, who did not appear in the least nonplussed about being surrounded by those “woman-hating” Turkish Muslim men you mention. Perhaps you are referring to remote villages cut off from the news that Turkey is a secular country…

  724. Pingback: “Please God, please make it stop” « Arun with a View

  725. I believe you. It’s extremely horrible what has happened to you. I hope you will recover soon.

    Your message is very important and needs to be read by many people, but especially men who don’t realise or admit to themselves the horrific extent to which misogyny and rape culture hurts women.

    To the commenters: As Sam Ambreen correctly points out, the problem is patriarchy and misogyny (which exists and is a massive problem everywhere on Earth), not the colour/nationality of the rapist.

    To men: Don’t rape or sexually assault anyone ever. ALWAYS believe the victim of sexual assault. NEVER defend the perpetrator. Understand that the problem always stems from systematic misogyny and rape culture, and that these are huge problems everywhere, so stop being racist!

    Smash patriarchy, smash male privilege and smash racism (borrowing Sam Ambreen’s wise words)

    Toivo

  726. For those who want to understand society of Egypt and its foundations, please note the following before coming to any conclusion.
    1. Natasha choose to work on “on women’s rights and abuses against women in Egypt since the revolution.”

    2. Behavior of people after she had suffered the trauma, the Questions asking if she is married, ,pregnant or virgin ? They seemed displeased by my response of “no”. So , whenever any women is assaulted sexually , this is the treatment which she should expect.

    3 Upon reaching a government hospital downtown, we tried to explain the situation. People stared at us blankly, sloping around the corridors. We were turned away and told to go to a nearby hospital instead. Nobody would take us; we just had to walk there.

    4 I was refused examination and treatment. Eventually I decided I’d just have to check for damage myself.

    5 For 2-3 hours, people strolled past us,
    I was sat in a room full of men. One of them seemed to be taking a photo of me. I’m not sure why, as I wasn’t exactly looking glamorous.

    6 I was taken to a private hospital where a doctor’s first question was “are you married?”, which is of course the most important question to be asking a victim of mass sexual abuse.

    7 He and a female nurse (who only reluctantly kept me covered up) looked briefly at the damage and just wandered off, saying that because I didn’t have internal bleeding, they couldn’t do anything.

    Which society, its doctors behaves like this with needy woman in urgent need of medical and other support, for answer is not too far , a simple google will do fine.
    For with Mubarak , there was someone to blame but now in the name of people’s revolution ,democracy …! god save civilization in Egypt.
    Once again Natasha , Your courage is awesome.

    • The behavior of the doctors is equally as egregious as the crowds. Is there not a kind soul in that entire country?

  727. This is terrible, I’m sorry you had to go through such a thing… I hope that this story raises more awareness for people in or around similar situations. If you need any assistance with your documentary I would love to help, I’m in school for Peace and Conflict studies at the moment and It would great to help if you need any writing done. All the best, Anton

  728. There are no words to describe how horrible I feel about your experience; you are truly a hero and an inspiration for women everywhere. Thank you for showing such grace and positivity and for setting an example for us all. On behalf of all egyptians, I am truly sorry.

  729. Pingback: “Please God. Please make it stop.” « Public Secrets

  730. Dear Natasha, although we are strangers, I will always stand by your side, woman to woman, human being to human being. I wish you well on your journey, your recovery, and your future. Blessings.

  731. Natasha,
    Allow me to be perfectly frank: I’m a male Egyptian who got fed up with the ‘macho’ mentality governing almost all older male Egyptians’ mentality surrounding me back home. I left in hopes of meeting new people around the people, different people, different mentalities, but unfortunately it didn’t work out and all my attempts at getting a visa ended with failure.

    You can go ahead and call me a total hypocrite for telling you that I may know how it feels. But I’ve experienced that helplessness for an entire week when a person I loved and cherished for years left me for someone else, without ever letting me know why once. But over here, it’s immediately assumed that when something like that happens, you’re an ‘impotent’, both physiologically and personality-wise. People (including family) verbally assault you with these claims, thinking they’re somehow getting you back on your feet, but it only serves to pleasure them and them alone.

    I want to assure you that Egyptians my age, my generation, are not the depraved animals you dealt with. When I read about the people crying to tell you that this isn’t Egypt or the religion we follow, I cried as well. I cried because I know that, just as I experienced before, nobody will listen, and the stereotyping will only amplify further and further, and more people will avoid us because of what a certain faction/demographic did to you (and others, no doubt). You have a right to tell the world, and nobody should ever deny you that. But you also have the right to know why this happened, from someone who understands these minds.

    We still have TV channels (such as El Faraeen) spreading propaganda about foreigners visiting Egypt always turning out to be spies (even when 99% of them aren’t). These channels instruct people to harm innocents like you in various ways, directly and indirectly. Since Morsi’s election, this particular channel remained silent (it did everything it could to fight him, along with most other state- and pseudo-state run channels) and ‘went in hiding’. But I saw the ads instructing people to ‘expose’ any foreigners as spies on sight. And I assure you, the crimes these soulless bastards spread on a daily basis, along with those that follow them, will be exposed and held against them all in court, and you and I and millions of others suffering from this depraved mindset will finally know peace in this strange nation called Egypt.

    I beseech anybody reading this: give them time. Give them a chance, and look for the people who want to protect you. I would gladly lay down my life if it meant protecting someone facing this, or convincing you that this is never going to be who we are.

    May God have mercy on us all.
    – Q

    • Please go and help those doctors and hospital staff to be more sensitive to human beings in need and be respectful to women,Try to help those people who ask questions regarding virginity or married or pregnancy to hurt women!

      • The only people I’ve literally seen do that were SCAF’s forces, and they got away with it.

        As for the questioning, like I said: mentality. El Faraeen LOVES to discuss virginity and sexuality as if it’s a trend or something to bring up around anybody, including rape victims. Worst of all, after an Egyptian woman was stripped by SCAF’s forces in public and caught on tape, El Faraeen was the first to attack her for ‘being there’ and ‘exposing herself’.

        Welcome to Mubarak’s Egypt, ladies and gentlemen. Please hold on to the rail tightly as we attempt to remove his influence on this sad nation for years to follow.

  732. Thank you so much for posting this. I believe every word of this, but the one thing I have hope in is the fact that several Egyptians did try to come to your rescue. Many brave women and men tried to protect you and were embarassed by their own cruel countrymen. I have lived in Egypt off and on and each time I have been sexually harassed, touched etc. I know that most Egyptan people are not like that so I will always go back. Once I was in a crowd of men and I was arguing with a taxi driver. He cheated me and physically tried to take my tall blonde friend and me to the police. A hoard of men came towards us and I thought that was it. The group of men then collected enough money to pay the driver off and then quickly found us another taxi to whisk us away from the situation. I know there are worse stories, but I truely believe there is so much kindness in the hearts of true Egyptians.

    Peace to you Natasha as you continue your important work wherever it will take you.

    • 62 % of egyptian males admit to having sexually assaulted a female. How is that not most egyptian males? 62 % percent means that almost everybody knows a couple of males who have harassed a woman. Speak up!

  733. I can’t imagine what you must’ve gone through. Such a terrible experience, and I’m so sorry to hear that this happened to you. But you were such a brave woman, and I hope that Egyptian woman will have the same courage you had facing the situation. And know that karma is a bitch; those men WILL pay for what they did to you, and it’ll be very pricey.

  734. ….and “the Left” claims Muslims are just like “us”. Muslims are savages just like the Black beasts in Haiti that raped aid workers after the earthquake. In one case a female Libtard aid worker blamed Whitey’s supposed oppression of Caribbean Coloreds for her rooftop rape.

  735. im sorry for what happened to you and i hope you’re ok now. but again as many people here said..this happens everywhere and you dont judge a whole country,race,or religion according to your experience with a few of them , i admit we have this harassment problem here , it only seemed to increase recently and i can’t really identify the cause, its not that the woman wears tight or anything its something else i dont really know..if you see egyptian movies from the 70’s for example you will see actually egyptian women wore mini-skirts and bikini’s and this sexual harassment problem have never been mentioned and we never heard of it at this time , i dont know what happened to people and we should know the cause because its obviously getting worse, i hope you just don’t judge egyptian people upon those idiots you met, you’ll always find those everywhere , i won’t judge germans upon hitler and won’t judge USA upon george bosh , i can’t blame a mass of people coz of somebody’s mistake, as if we did this the whole planet is gonna hate each other
    i wish you the best in your life and i hope this terrible experience will make you a stronger person and not just traumatized
    regards from Cairo

  736. Natasha smith
    I am really really sorry for what happened to you > I am an Egyptian and for me that is a shame for such accident to occur in our country I knew that sexual harassment and violation has great impact on the personality and your psychology but you are great woman who resist hating and stereotyping people in a country actually doing that primary because you are a foreigner and they are seeing every foreigner as a spy and secondary because you are a woman the people in crowds turn to animal no thinking >> Natasha you are a great woman
    Abdrahman
    an Egyptian

  737. Natasha! I’m so so sorry you went through this, and i’m inspired that you are still determined to carry on with the documentary. I’m 15 and want to be a journalist but now i am not so sure, I don’t want to get raped when all i want to do is snap a few photos of a celebration D:

  738. This is awful thing to happen. I was with a female friend in Cairo and we managed to narrowly escape from a very similar situation following celebrations after Egypt beat Algeia in the football in 2010. This is not to say that sexual attacks only happen in Egypt or the Arab world. Those of you who have decided this article is falsified, you are free to believe that but to see it is an attempt to smear the good name of Egypt is misguided. There is no attempt to make Egypt look bad, this happened to take place in Egypt. I believe Natasha has been very brave to share this story so soon after it happened and I am disgusted at the attempt to make the comments section a political debate regarding Israel or Palestine or the revolution or the elections. Not everything is written with a political motive, not everything is about the revolution, believe it or not there is more going on in the world. Thank you for sharing your story Natasha, hopefully it will raise awareness for other HUMANS about keeping safe wherever they are.

  739. How does one contact you about using this story? can you please email me at marwan.i.imam@gmail.com, I’m a comic writer/artist working on a journalistic episodic graphic novel documenting events of the revolution and post revolution recounting personal stories of people who are there. I would love to use your story and spread more awareness for it. please contact me whenever possible.

  740. I just wanna say that we say ” Allah” to express a feeling of pleasure ..Don’t know what to say ..We suffer from this too. ..good luck & Take care

  741. Im very sorry that this happened to you; over the past few months I heard of many similar attacks and one happened to a really close friend of mine with her husband being with her and not able to help her because they were to many (she is Egyptian BTW not a foreigner). But I have to say that it is not smart to go to Tahrir Sq. especially in the times we are currently in (not an excuse for what happened to u) but it is the plain and honest truth, we, Egyptian girls/women, are trying to avoid being put in positions that may cause us harm and so you will find a large percentage of females trying to avoid to go to places like that because we never know what the crazy men over there would do to us. If you look at the news, nowadays tahrir sq. is filled with poor, hungry people who have nothing better to do with their time than go their. As a foreigner living in Egypt, you to should avoid being put in that position.

    • This is exactly the wrong attitude to have. The solution is MORE women in Tahrir, MORE women in politics, civil society and every aspect of public life. Don’t wait for anyone to grant you your rights, just grab them by any means possible. Right now Egypt is the theater of great upheavals, but it isn’t a war zone, and anyone going to a demonstration shouldn’t be subjected to such horror in broad daylight with onlookers passively ignoring the ordeal of a helpless woman. These people are as guilty as the assailants. As are the doctors who failed to provide adequate care and comforting. We as Egyptians are all guilty for allowing our values as humans to get so screwed up. Comments like these are so depressing.

      • I agree with Ashraf. We (women and men, Egyptians and foreigners) need to reclaim Tahrir as a safe space for women. We can’t let the abusers win.

  742. Natasha, there are no words that could express how I feel what happened to you. You are most likely still in some kind of shock, and there are many stages of emotions and numbness that you most certainly will encounter after such an attack. Not everyone reacts the same. I can tell you that when something like this happens, you need to be around those who can be a strong foundation for you. Those who understand. There is a part of you that will want to make this not such a big deal and another part of you that will revolt against that denial.

    My apologies for any unwanted advice.

    You went with the clear intention of doing something important. Something you felt you had to do. That’s the honesty in it. You did not set yourself up for what happened to you, you only were thinking about what you had to do, and those people who have made you love Egypt. That is what caring, mindful and respectful people do. People who are not mindful of themselves or others did this to you. People who do this do not habitually take responsibility for their behavior, or for what they think. They usually use something or someone to blame it on instead of taking responsibility for themselves or their actions and they allow the actions of others to sway them as well. It is the thrill that they seek, no matter awful that thrill is, or how it is gotten.

    I am keeping you and your friends in my warm thoughts of everything good because that is exactly where you belong.

  743. i am so sorry about what happened to you and i want to say to you
    this action is not the behavior of the Egyptian people
    this action is the behavior some thugs belongs to the national party seek to spread the chaos and i promise you as the Egyptian this action will not happen again
    and i hope to come Egypt again

  744. Natasha, I am so sorry to hear of your terrible ordeal. Thank you very much for writing about it so that others can learn from this, so that change may be possible, and so that women and the men who love them can take precautions for their protection. Reading the comments here, I fear there is an overall descent of decency which may make this type of behavior, in all its forms, an increasingly common occurrence. Brave women like yourself who have the courage to speak out will help reverse the tide.

  745. Tash, I am so shocked that this has happened to you. I always seem to take it for granted that everyone I know is always safe and okay. I believe bad things happen for a reason. Not because you deserve them or you’ve made mistakes but to teach you how sweet the good things are; how lucky we are; how much we really love the people in our lives; to teach you the unending limits to your inner strength and resilience; to give you perspective. Whilst i am so sorry this happened to you, I in awe of you for standing up and speaking out about it. To take something horrific and make it into a positive, to spread awareness and promote change is an amazing thing and you should be really proud of yourself. Sending all my love for a full recovery.

  746. This is as depressing as it gets, I hope you pull through, but I can’t wish you to ‘forget’, or ‘get over’ it, or keep re-living it, just as I cannot find any justification for actions of that savage mob, and hypocrite medical staff, and to all those who say this is not a muslim thing, pray do tell where in the Christian, or Western country a crowd last brutalised a passer by. I doubt this would even be reported in Arabic-speaking press, and for this grave story to make headlines is sadly impossible. Will there be women marching in solidarity? Judging by post ‘blue bra’ incident, when just a few thousand turned up, it is too much of a taboo. A woman can run a house and a family and all that, but all freedoms stay at home. once out, every day is a victory. something very very rotten remains at heart of such society, and by the look of it it will remain so for a time to come, because there are no indications that even a dscussion is on the way.

    • I don’t know of many places where this kind of thing happens out of doors, but gang-rapes happen all the time among the criminal gangs in UK inner cities, in Eastern Europe & various other locations. That this should happen outdoors & in public is shocking, but rape is a product of patriarchy & rape culture – Egypt seems to have a growing problem with this, and people who subscribe to this mindset will use things like Islam to justify their actions, just as they used Christianity to justify witch-burnings & torture in medieval Europe and 17th century America. It’s about bullying & terrorising women, bottom line, and it needs to stop.

      • well the point is that we’re not in ‘medieval Europe and 17th century America.’ anymore, but in Egypt 2012, where mentality as if stuck in the times aforementioned seems to be the norm. They used Islam to justify their vote for a party that gave them the President, so what is your point exactly? and I’m not saying this is MB or felool, it’s a cross-affiliated phenomena, where men can relaps to their primal alpha mode at a sight of blonde hair, they should be castrated in public.

  747. Your account of this traumatic experience has left me in tears. Your strength and patience is so admirable. We all experience An intrusion on our personal space daily and with words like yours I hope one day enough people will make it stop. Good luck

  748. as a Egyptian i’m very sorry for what happened to you , really Awful and that’s all going to change …we can and we will
    i admire your courage and wish to have young people like you around the world

  749. I am a man. But even me cannot imagine one single situation where you find the nerves to do something horrible to a woman. Even if you can hide behind beastly group behaviour this seems so unreal. I cannot understand what drives men like this to do this to a woman. Beasts indeed. I hope you will get better soon and it will not scar you mentally or physicly. Best regards, Sebastiaan.

  750. So sorry for you. Hope you recover soon
    trust me that could happened any where ,,,, I am sure you will become more stronger
    You didn’t visited EGYPT you visited bad view of it ,,, try to visit EGYPT again as you can see how much muslem s and christens are friendly , kind and very human, I have married to Egyptian man who is excellent in deal with women more than any Europaian ,,, he respect me and help me always and feel of me more than himself ,,thanks gad,,,, he is muslem

      • Scale doesn’t matter when someone violates your body without your permission. The fact is that sexual assault can and does happen in Europe and people *everywhere* need to take this more seriously as a social epidemic.

  751. I will not tell you that this is not what is Egypt is like. But I will tell you one thing that your article has made me willing to stop this “phenomena” whenever I see it in my country. Thanks Natasha.

  752. Dont fool yourself! There are NO real men in Egypt. They are all either pussies (created by their mothers fawning all over them) or pussy-whipped by their wives. They all dream of having real sex with a real woman. It is for this reason they go in search of other women to violate, humiliate, rape and torture! They hate women actually, but then again, the women here hate men….except in one case. Egyptian mothers are in love with their sons, and Egyptian sons are in love with their mothers! It is a garbage can of a country. It isnt worth yours or anyone else’s suffering to make a documentary.

    • This is so clearly demented that no-one’s even bothered to reply to it…let’s leave it that way.

      We can just ignore the Egyptian men who’ve volunteered their time to the anti-sexual-harassment action groups, and been injured protecting strangers in the street.

  753. Hey , I’m Egyptian woman & I believe every word in this post , Now I’m crying , not for you , you are such beautiful and strong person , and you will be OK , I’m sure , I’m crying for Egypt and the Egyptian women who face kinds of sexual harassment almost everyday , I’m crying for a country was a source of civilisation

    • Wow, really? This is your advice? Let’s pretend this wasn’t someone “else” and it was you instead for a moment. You would never deserve this no matter what you were doing. You like to call other women “dumb and bitch” do you? My guess is that you think you are either to high and mighty, or you really don’t think much of yourself at all. Someone did something to you? Or are you one of those who do something to others and find ways to excuse yourself from your behavior?

    • E.Eliveld is a man, a racist and an Islamophobe, with a blog dedicated to that. Who is now under police investigation for breaking the laws of his country, and will hopefully be carted off to jail very soon.

  754. “Putting her in her place” and what happened to her was way too elaborate? I have seen ppl in this mob type madness. I have seen how ppl respond when they have been attacked. YOU apparently choose to think it can be only in “your idea” of how one would respond in any way. You are a fool, and I am putting YOU in YOUR place. Get it? If I had you in front of me at this moment, you would be on the floor. Disrespectful, and condescending does not make far past me. If you are suspicious of this happening, then may I suggest you just keep your comments to yourself. I would rather be in support of her and be duped later then take the chance of not doing what is right. YOU need a head check. It is you that needs putting in place!

  755. I was touched by your experience and felt sick after reading. I hope you will manage and are able to overcome this “anonymous” attack. It will be hard because there is no individual to focus on. Please don’t let it ruin your self-esteem. Writing it down is a very big step.

  756. Muslim are the cancer of this earth, i’m not a racist, but this is really the truth. I’m so glad i’ll be moving to South America, where there are no fucking Muslim. And never will be. Thank GOD. HATE ALLAH and his child molesting followers, man and woman. FUCK YOU ALL

  757. I am so sorry. I am glad that you are sharing what happened with everybody though. And, I am glad that you are going on with your life. I don’t know what else to say 😦 Just so sorry…

  758. Unfortunately, this blog has now attracted various kinds of “surprisingly” committed trolls, trying to whip up some anti-foreigner feeling…either by directly blaming foreigners or by blaming Islam or Egyptians, in the hope that Egyptians will react defensively. Nice try.

    What’s actually happened is that Egyptians are showing an outpouring of sympathy, apology and regret, as seen in the comments above.

    Our Cairo anti-sexual harassment group has gained 10% more members in the past 2 hours, thanks to Natasha’s bravery in speaking out. We’re planning a campaign to protect women journalists and protestors in Tahrir on Friday. If anyone harasses the campaign, we’re going to catch them, spray paint them and their clothes neon pink and handcuff them to the nearest lamp post ready to be arrested.

    If anyone would like to join, please see here: https://www.facebook.com/groups/129672763810060/

    We would particularly be grateful if someone can kindly translate Natasha’s blog into Arabic? Also for men and women who are wiling to come and protect the Safe Point we will set up, or those willing to mingle with the crowds and keep an eye out for suspicious behaviour.

    Thank you.

    (And yes, I am Egyptian, and proud of it….and so what if I wasn’t? Sexual assault is not Egyptian, hospitality is: if we cannot at least protect our guests from harm (never mind our own selves) what kind of hosts are we…?)

    • I think it’s amazing that you’re able and willing to try to prevent more of the same. Solidarity sister, keep safe come friday.

    • Your post is ‘charming’. You wield a big brush and paint all critical comments to be either trolling or racist. very very weak. In essence you reverse your accusation, you generalize Egyptians by claiming a shared sympthatic and apologetic attitude for all.
      You can’t just deny everything that’s bad and accept only the good, that’s not the way this world works.

      • Quote one “critical” post on this blog that isn’t trolling, or racist, or misogynistic, or xenophobic, or hateful, insensitive, lacking in compassion, lacking in empathy or downright nasty.

        There isn’t one. A truly lovely person bravely suffered a truly horrific experience…whose human response to a terrible tragedy is to “criticise” the victim? No-one decent.

      • I beg to differ. Read anyone of my posts. Critical of Islam? Yes? Hateful? No. Full of compassion? Yes.

        I offered to donate money to your cause. It’s very cheap and cliched to paint every dissenting opionon as hateful rhetoric. You are just so wrong, but I think you will never see why.

        Anyway, tell me were i can donate, please? It’s the only thing I can do. Good luck to your good cause!

  759. I disagree, to say that poverty turns men into rapists is an insult to those who have little, and a gross generalisation. Rapists are in all strata of the society – what makes a rapist what he is is a sick mind, nothing else. Out of interest, how much time have you spent in Egypt to give all this advice?

    • actually, Islam allows the rape of women. In a country where people have no control over the government, rape is pretty high..simply because some men need to feel in control and that’s what rape is. a way for helpless idiots to feel like they’re in control.
      and yeah, I’ve been to Egypt, both during my time in the military and afterwards.

      • You need four witnesses to prove rape. However, if the defendant is a non-Muslim or someone impopular, that rule is waived.

      • I demand protection for the identity of men accused of rapes and indecent assaults on women. Why should women’s identities be protected but not in the case of men?

    • Go away, you sad little man. No one wants to know your thoughts, except maybe your psychiatrist. Have you really got nothing better to do than insult victims of rape?

    • And for a big loser that you are it’s no surprise that you would say that! and for that I’ll make you a wish that I hope will haunt you for the rest of your life. I wish you, a member of your family or your friends gets raped by a gang of men so you know how it feels.. Creep!

    • Yep, so when you are walking to the store anywhere and someone attacks you, do we all get to blame you? Yeah, I would think about it. I wouldn’t do it because before would open my mouth, or type on a keyboard I would use mindfulness and respect for the victim, even after he did it to someone else before. However, since you decided to not use good judgement in your comments on this particular post, I will simply tell you how foolish you are being.

  760. …but this story is so well written, feels like fake to me.

    Natasha is a journalist. Writing, and preferably writing well, is one of the things a lot of journalists do for a living.
    It’s amazing and admirable that she can write so well over such a horrific ordeal that she went through.

  761. As a woman living in the UK who has been ignorant to these goings-on I thank you for writing this, especially so soon after the event; I hope it has been of some therapeutic use and not a traumatic one.

    I am sickened by the assault you suffered, the lack of basic care by the hospitals you visited, and the ignorant comments left here.

    Natasha has done a very brave and also professional thing, posting this so soon. Many more people need to know that this happens: to protect themselves and their loved ones, and so there can be change.

    I echo what others have said to those who doubt the story – unless you have not only experienced this, but also unless you are Natasha herself, you have no right to make claims on how she should have felt, what she should have been thinking, and how long she should have left before talking about this horrific event.

    To James, I think your replies on the comments here are commendable. Not only have you been traumatised also, but having to read such nonsense posted by some people here and still keep your head must be so difficult (an understatement I’m sure). I hope you both find whatever counsel you need to get you through this time.

    I would like to do whatever I can to educate people on these sickening abuses, the world is not shouting “NO” loud enough. Please let me know what I can do to get involved.

    My thoughts are with you.

  762. And how about this little fact? Seems like most Egyptians (and neighbours) still have no clue whatsoever about what constitutes a civilized society. Does this occurence seem out of odds by any chance? think not.
    From the reputable Pew Research center:
    http://pewresearch.org/databank/dailynumber/?NumberID=1184

    82% – Stoning Adulterers
    About eight-in-ten Muslims in Egypt and Pakistan (82% each) endorse the stoning of people who commit adultery;
    Muslims in Pakistan and Egypt are also the most supportive of whippings and cutting off of hands for crimes like theft and robbery.
    When asked about the death penalty for those who leave the Muslim religion, at least three-quarters of Muslims in Jordan (86%), Egypt (84%) and Pakistan (76%) say they would favor making it the law.

    • which country did you spoke about ???? EGYPT ???? its not true as I lived there 10 years and never saw crime or rape for women as I see now in CANADA????

      • Unfortunately it’s true. Follow the link. It’s to the website of one of the most trusted polling institutes in the US. His numbers are correct, wheter you like it or not – that is a fact.

  763. TO ALL THE IDIOTS MAKING THIS A MUSLIM PROBLEM, OR A BROWN PEOPLE PROBLEM.. GET A LIFE. RAPISTS COME IN ALL COLOURS, IT JUST SO HAPPENS THAT RAPE IS BEING USED AS A WEAPON IN EGYPT RIGHT NOW. ACCEPT IT.

    AND PLEASE DON’T USE MY COMMENTS TO GET AT EACH OTHERS NATIONALITIES OR RELIGIONS, YOU’RE ALL FUCKWITS.

    SMASH PATRIARCHY, SMASH MALE PRIVILEGE, SMASH BULLSHIT WE’RE BETTER THAN YOU PROPAGANDA. FUCK THE APOLOGIST, FUCK THE RACISTS AND THE RAPISTS.

    SOLIDARITY WITH MY SISTERS, BROWN, WHITE, BLACK AND BLUE. WE BELIEVE YOU

    • This. Exactly. What can we do, to stop this kind of thing happening though? These men need to learn some fucking respect. So sorry this kind of shit still happens. 😦

    • Dud, WHAT IS YOUR PROBLEM? I KNOW LIFE IN HOLLAND MUST BE FUCKING BORING BUT IT IS YOUR PROBLEM NOT OURS! GO VOMIT ELSEWHERE.. SERIOUSLY, IF YOU HAVE ISSUES WITH YOUR MUSLIM POPULATION IN THE NETHERLANDS DON’T DISGUISE IT BY POSTING ‘SOME’ INSENSITIVE COMMENTS IN SOMEONE’S TRAUMATIC EXPERIENCE, JUST GO DEAL WITH IT. PATHETIC. SPEAKING OF PASSIVE AGGRESSIVE

    • Oh my goodness…what a bigoted idiot you are. Rape is not a ‘muslim’ problem. It’s a patriarchy problem. It’s pervasive in all communities including muslim ones, and to suggest otherwise is just evidence that you’re an ignorant islamophobe who has no idea about rape culture and patriarchy and clouds this painful and murky topic with vile racist crap. Kindly shut up.

  764. Dear Natasha,
    THANK YOU!
    Because no apologies will help in taking away the impact this must have left on you. So you writing down this for thousands to read will only help us (Egyptian women), speed up the process of cleaning such animals from here. If this happened to me, I would definitely never step foot in Egypt again. And woul have more shit to write out of anger, fear, depression and hurt. You, on the other hand, put more reason and gave excuses (more or less right) into your article.
    I am an egyptian woman, blonde and white, living in Cairo. I do understand the circumstances that led to such outrageous acts, but this must stop.

  765. I wish you strength and good friends to get over this as soon as possible. Probably the best thing to start with was writing about it, although it must have been terribly painful.

    Greetings

  766. [throws up in mouth].

    We have your IP address, E.Eliveld. With an IP address, it’s possible to locate the exact location a post was made from.

    “Remember, people get what they deserve”.

  767. Whatever the reasons.were ..civilized country or civilized people would not do that to foreigner….indeed, it was a very shameful act…you ruin the credibility of your country….the beloved Egypt..:(((

  768. Am utterly speechless, shocked, revolted and saddened by what has been done to you, and sadly to other western women, in my country of origin. Am at the same time amazedand touched that you still express love for Egypt and its people. being an egyptian myself I don’t know if I had had this strength for forgiveness and am very very grateful and humbled that you do! I wish you all the best and hope you will one day overcome the pain of what has been done to you – and I pray that nobody in Egypt will have to go through such horror again.

  769. You will soon get what you deserve you stupid fucking cunt! Have some respect you ill-mannered, ill-cultured piece of shit..

  770. I don’t know what to say to explain that is not the real Egypt and it’s not the real Islam and I’m so sorry that you faced something of ignorance that the country has been filled of for over 60 years I’m sorry again ana plz visit egypt again and we shall you the real egypt

  771. So sorry to hear your story. There is no excuse for such violence and the ignorance and apathy you were shown after the attacks. I feel sick after reading this. May you heal in peace, and may Egyptian men — all men — confront this problem.

  772. Speechless …. sorry for you really sorry i s awful. Try to forget and recover soon, you are a very strong person and keep it up please.

  773. Anyone thinking that sexual frustration and hostility to outgroup-blonde women is not at the very least accentuated by Islam is fooling him or herself. The fact that her virginity and marital status were the first questions asked from her says more than enough. And how about those women in burqa that were not assaulted and probably afraid to help?
    She was totally dehumanised by her attackers, how could such a thing possibly come about? This needs an ideological push by religion and societal ‘norms’; the evidence is more than abundant.

    This horrific account of unheard of rape ofshows that ignorance is not always bliss.

    • Clearly you are speaking out of ignorance. although I agree with you that the attitude of hospital staff was horrific, their questions were asked because of the legal nature of the situation. if she was a virgin or married she will need to proof rape medically so that in court it can be presented as evidence.. again, I stress that I’m not trying to justify their attitude but I also don’t want to blame everyone in a moment of rape. and yes, I do agree that there is a need of an ideological push by religion and societal ‘norms’. it is just sad that there are people who confuse sexualized violence, which is used as a weapon of war, and societal norms.

  774. I’m very sorry for what happened to you.. I apologize on the behalf of any human who lives in this country. Yet I may not represent any street animal who thinks his desire and sexual oppression allows him to attack any woman as if she’s just a sexual piece of thing that has no feelings. Some men here may go around harassing girls and women under the pretext that she’s “Not dressed appropriately” as if this means it’s a woman’s fault if she’s not dressed decently but it’s not a man’s fault if he turns into a sex animal, or if he behaves like he’s a creature without a brain and without the ability of resisting his desires. We, Egyptian women have to live with that every day and if we try to talk about it or resist it, it’s a shame on us.

  775. Egyptians, please stop saying this isn’t Egypt. It is. It happened in Egypt. The men were Egyptian. No single act can characterize an entire country, but these mob-like sexual assaults (especially against foreign women) are recurring incidents. And nothing has been done about it. They go unmentioned. No one really wants to deal with it. No one knows how. No one seems to care. And Egyptian women, like myself, suffer too.

    Natasha, I am sorry that you went through this. I am not exactly sure how I would have handled it or if I could have picked myself up so quickly and provided a detailed account for those who lack awareness. I was in Tahrir (shooting video) on the same day but I tried to be vigilant and I moved cautiously around the square. In the end, there is no recipe to avert this type of disaster. At many points I would walk in one direction, then turn and walk away because I did not feel safe. It is hard to tell and hard to know who to trust. Sorry. Good luck with your documentary. Make it personal and put it out there.

    • I agree with you. This IS Egypt. And we Egyptian women face the animosity and cruelty and egoism and sickness of Egyptian men daily. And it’s even our fault if we try to capture the harasser and put him to a penalty. We have to stop lying to ourselves and start facing the reality of our society.

      • Your post makes me so sad. I wonder oftentimes why not more feminists are willing to see the truth.

        As have been said, this was not the first time. I have never heard of such mob rapes, in broad daylight, surrounded by people, of which most does not help, anywhere else. It seems that in egypt sexual assault is something normal. Two thirds of men admit to doing it. I feel sorry and powerless for you. How you must feel. Terrible?

    • i was stuck in traffic in front of the gezira club one afternoon when the futbol match let out and hundreds of men marched by all psyched up about it. it was hot and my window was down. a man reached into my car and grabbed my breast– his companion knocked his hand away and told me to roll up the window, that the fans were dangerous. this was back in 1992 or so, i’m not blonde and i was over 40 at the time, also i’m not voluptuous by a long shot! another time a girlfriend and i got mixed up in a crowd of men leaving the mosque after friday prayer in istanbul– never been so rudely grabbed in my life, they tried to get their fingers inside. we were dressed conservatively and neither of us is blonde and we were both over 40. men in mobs. imagine getting mixed up in an ashura parade! what a horror that would be!

    • I am mystified by the standard reaction that this is not Muslim or Arab, whereas all statistics point in that direction. Since Muslim North-Africans came to live in my city, their crime figures of are staggering. Is this denial part of tribal shame culture? The usual reaction to these sober facts is mostly of the “Fuck You!” type.

  776. It sounds almost like a woman needs armed guards to protect from these crazy lechers! I hope she recovers from her ordeal. (My father was once accosted by several homosexuals 60+ years ago when he worked as a commercial seaman bringing goods to several Meditteranean countries. He said he had to run like the dickens to get away from them.)

  777. Its shame to humanity !!
    Democracy is what quality of numbers ( people) are made up of. I really don’t know what difference it makes to civilized world that democracy of such type of people for world.
    I respect the hope author has even after such a horrible move she believes it is not representative of cultures and religions,but this is fact that the ‘act’ was representative of the dominant beliefs of majority of males of the particular society and there is no shred of doubt as to what they believe about ‘white woman’
    Fine ,everybody in the world is entitled to have their beliefs about things and people,but when it threatens the existence and safety of unrelated innocent human being it should be kept under control by self or by outside forces( read dictatorship). Reading deeply about prevailing situation in certain regions of the world and by virtue of lived very close to such societies, I have no doubts that this social system ignores and indirectly promotes such behavior with non affiliated( read non- believers ) human beings and more cruelly non affiliated women.As they consider them sinful creatures with whom all excesses can be done and yet it would be less !
    Few of such crimes could be but not limited to.
    Keeping your hair and body uncovered.
    Talking freely and mixing with male who is not your husband or family member.
    Making bad impressions for their women folk by doing things which are prohibited by godly commands.
    To make an example before their own women so that they always remember what happens to the one who dares!
    As if it was not enough already,with new wave of emergence of democracy of men like these , god save humanity,god save human and more importantly freedom of women.
    Thanks Ms. Smith , thanks so much for not keeping quiet. Emerge stronger.

  778. Firstly, I do not believe you are a woman. Secondly, your life is so shite, you get your kicks out of trying to control and intimidate the vulnerable.

    SHAME ON YOU.

    • This is the attitude that continues this kind of violence. Because it happens everywhere else in the world is exactly why people need to hear Natasha’s story and stop it. No matter where this happened or who it happened to, this is horrifying and something needs to change.

  779. Goddh… Poor you, as if the events you underwent were not enough. But to read some of these comments… I don’t know much but I know how quickly a crowd can turn; I know how invisible a crowd turning on someone can seem to people but yards away; I know how capturing the odd details (losing new shoes; hamburger) can serve a literary purpose and/or simultaneously reveal our capacity to go out-of-body when horrors are occuring; and I know that people who are assaulted behave during and after it in ways which non-experiencers can not understand. V best of luck with unreported world it’s a great university. Your task and a v hard one is somehow to make something positive out of this. Go easy on yourself, you have a right to be here, and keep ‘Desiderata’ near by.

  780. Thanks Natasha for having the courage of sharing this unimaginable event. No comments can explain how we feel for you and how we also feel for Egypt being exposed in the worst form ever…after all; this is why a revolution began, after that Egypt had low security, thugs (thousands) fled freely in the street of Egypt…etc, then just add the already existing issue of harassment to the equation and a bit of the high level of poverty, illiteracy, frustration and you have a mess.
    A big shame indeed for Egypt, amazing courage from you to share your story, another big shame for a few comments that added a pinch of religious racism to the story although you were saved by the same people…who could have been local Muslims or Christians.
    Around 48% elected a liberal party but lost due to the majority that erupted as an outcome of the old regime corruption which infected the people’s core manners…hope you recover soon and get back to work even stronger than before!

  781. Hey there! So sorry to hear about that awful experience! You’re not alone and this is not something new in Egypt. I was groped once too in Maadi (supposedly the safest place back then in Cairo) I was 16 and someone grabbed my breast but I beat the crap out of him this mofo. Anyway, keep your head high these men deserve to die all of them and what ever happens to them they deserve it and I hope to God one day they will get raped in their ears, noses, mouths and butt holes.
    My advice is that you don’t set foot back into that country, I know I never will.
    Take care

  782. I cant tell u how much sorry am I .. I am sorry with name of every egyptian man and women who have any honor … words cant describe how brave u r and how coward and lowness and animals are they who attackted u

  783. What you went through is horrendous and it’s redundant to say that I am sorry it happened to you. I want to say- in light of some of the rape culture and apologism affirming comments here- I believe you. I wish it weren’t so believable that this could happen to a woman in our world. Your message of strength and hope, and defiance of enforced victimhood inspires me, and I hope will resonate with every survivor of sexual assault and oppression who can face reading your deeply personal account. You may not feel brave but you are, and you help me to feel braver. Thank you so much and take care,

    Ellen xxx

  784. natasha, i want to say i wish i was there to help you, but i would have probably been harrassed for doing so.
    i’m an egyptian girl, and yes there is sexual harrassement issue here in egypt, and it has spreaded widely lately after revolution, by men who are invious of women who contributed in the revolution, and the fact that the success of the revolution means freedom to each and every egyptian, maybe and for all other reasons i can tell you about later.
    i don’t want to repeat the sentence: this is not the real egypt or the real islam, as u already know it, but this is not a problem produced by the poverty or animalistic nature, this is a problem we have been facing for the lack of morals, and spreaded lately because the troubles in the country and absence of law, as the regime punishes the society for uprising againt it.
    i have faced many harassements in Tahrir Square, not as nearly as what happened to you coz i’m not blonde maybe, or just coz i’m lucky, but i do remember being saved by true egyptian men there.
    wish you a quick recovery, hope you come back to egypt real soon 🙂

  785. So sorry for what happened to you, you are first of all brave for even writing this. Brave enough to re account all the gruesome details behind what happened. What I find shocking amongst many thing s is how these hundreds of men amongst a square full of people got away with this and nobody stopped them? That shit is mental. Allahu a3lam….

    • I witnessed a similar attack in the midan a few weeks ago.

      When the square is crowded it is hard to even know what is happening a few people away. Getting through when the attackers are 20 men deep is hard. It takes a very large amount of ‘good guys’ to do it. This cycle of realizing what is happening and organizing a group of strangers in a crowd takes minutes. During another attack that week 100 men dispersed 300 attackers by throwing water on them.

      I get ill about each and every attack I hear or read about. Egyptians must decide if this is how they really want to treat women.

  786. Mena, you must live in a little bubble. WAKE UP. This shit happens all the time and I can testify I have been sexually assaulted more than a handful of times in the 18 years I’ve lived in Cairo.

    • Agree, there is a ridiculous amount of sexual hunger between the youth of Egypt.

      I can only blame the stupid media which has left the youth with no social, cultural or religious identity, and most people are so poor, so what do you expect ?

      You have to admit that the same stuff happens every where in the world, but maybe in a less percent, but it happens.

  787. Firstly, so sorry for what happened to you and proud of you for speaking out. I am glad you can still see the good in that country and its people. Without in any way wanting to excuse what happened, so much of this is attributed to mob mentality. When the London riots happened, nobody could believe it when some middle-class educated people got embroiled in the looting and arsons that happened. In Egypt, it’s men’s sexual frustration that comes out in these situations. And like I commented to a racist Islamophobe commenting below, we shouldn’t judge an entire country by the worst things that happen there – otherwise, we will not leave the house. This is not to undermine your horrific experience of course. I wish you all the best and hope you recover soon and resume your work.

    • Believe me, Johan, it was infitesimally small in the Egypt that I grew up in (and I’m in my 30s), so I’m hopeful that things can still change back for the better. Your “primitive” comment has hints of white supremacy (inadvertent, probably), but I’m not getting any more into that.

  788. On behalf of Egyptians i’d like to apologize for this terrible ordeal and the disgusting comments on this page. i cant believe people are more interested in the writing than on the details of the attack i cant believe they are looking for proof! less than a week ago i was walking to my car and just as i was unlocking it someone attacked me from behind and slamed me against the car. luckily i wasn’t raped but he did just about everything else. wanna call me a liar too?! or was that too “exaggerated” for everyone? would you like a scene by scene play?! how long do people here plan on staying in denial?! how many more people have to go through this and bravely speak up till we acknowledge this as a problem?!

    • Yes, stuff like this happens, women get raped every where and all the time, by people from every place on the planet, its your duty as a woman to pay attention to that, its nothing new or exclusive in Egypt or Tahrir, and may happen to anybody.

      However, this story still seems a bit beyond the limits of imagination for me, but it may be true.

      • It’s not our “duty as women” to “pay attention”: it’s the duty of criminals not to commit disgusting crimes.

        You’re not sure whether the story is true…but you’re happy to take the risk of further hurting the person these terrible events happened to? If a woman was raped in your house, as your guest, you would say, “Oh well, of course it could happen in my neighbour’s house too”? La2a. Haram keda. 😦

      • Gang raped by a hundred men? Everywhere? You must be kidding!
        Just look at the savage responses by some Egyptians on this site to get the flavour.

  789. Hi Natasha,

    Sorry to hear that. I am sure that you are a strong woman. I am sure that you will survive this intact.

    Keep the faith.

  790. really i can’t express my sorrow and i’m trying to put words together to express how sorry i am …. speaking of the Egyptian people we are terribly sorry and i just wanna to say that this is not Egypt , i know that was a horrible experience u had and u are very strong to recover and to assure in your article that u know that this is not Egypt …..again we are sorry not only because u had this experience but also because as an Egyptian man i could not protect u in my country …. i’m sorry 😦

  791. I’m so sorry this happened to you and commend you for speaking out. I hope you are able to heal.

    Please know that this wasn’t your fault – you didn’t “make mistakes” or take risks – no one is to blame other than the men who attacked you.

  792. As an Egyptian I must say i’m sorry,,,as a woman i can say that sorry won’t do anything for you,,Natasha that’s not Egypt from the beginning it’s Egypt after 30 years of blindness,,I can promise you that won’t happen again in new Egypt !!

    Be strong and u r welcomed in new Egypt anytime

    • Comforting someone with self-serving denial does not seem to be the appropriate reaction. Apologizing is an art not mastered by many. It’s not about you or your country, it’s about the other human being that’s being hurt.

  793. Natasha … im sorry you had to go through this … and to all of the egyptians and “westerners living in egypt” … this shit happens ALL THE FUCKING TIME WAKE UP AND SMELL THE COFFEE!!! Dont u remember what happened in mohandiseen a few years ago when egypt won the african cup, and about 30 cops had to interfere to save 3 girls from the mad crowds that raped them in the middle of the fuckin street????

    Unfortunately, i had a link to a video of something similar that happened in down town cairo before the revolution, but i cant find it … but will continue to search until i do and will post it here.

    Again i apologize to u on behalf of all the egyptian people

  794. Ms natasha smith
    No words can be of use in this situation
    but i assure you that all egyptians don’t approve those filthy acts of those animals
    Islam can/t approve it alsi
    Humanity don’t approve it
    Iam sorry to you , i can’t believe people of my country did this .
    we , youth are trying our best to make people know , and make them don’t beleive rumors
    sorry again – god be with you.

  795. Assuming what you said is true, if you had the courage to write all the details here in such a wonderful and suspenseful way, I expect that you will be able to recover “emotionally” SO fast.

    As a matter of fact, I believe that a maximum of 20-30 guys may be surrounding & touching you, not hundreds, and according to similar accidents, there will be at least 30% of them trying to get you out.

    I believe this is a campaign to ruin Egypt’s reputation after the new president.

    • this shit is happening all the time and don’t try to justify it. this is the same shitty mentality that denies the Holocaust because there were “only” hundreds of thousands of Jews killed, not millions. as if this makes it less of a crime!

    • Ah, great, so there was only 30 guys raping her! That makes it all better! And she’s recovering really quick, so everything is actually perfectly fine. Fool…

    • And so what if it was “just” 20-30 guys and not hundreds?? Do you think she had the mental presence to stand there and count the guys that were invading her body??

    • Having 20 out of 30 men would make it alright, wouldn’t it? I can’t see how anyone would think it was more when you have 60 hands grabbing at you and pulling you this way and that unless it was a fabrication. I mean, for goodness sake, didn’t she count them? After all, if you’re *only* being violently assaulted by 20 people, what on earth could you have to complain about? And how could anyone be so calculating as to use the journalistic skills they’ve trained for years to acquire to express their emotions in relation to any incident that’s affected them when other people, including some of those “innocent bystanders” in the crowd could possibly be upset? It would be very callous of anyone to even contemplate hurting someone who simply stood by and did nothing by saying how a situation had affected them. Honestly, some people make me sick.

      I wonder what part of “I am determined to return to this wonderful country and city that I love” made you think that this post was motivated by a desire to ruin Egypt’s reputation? Think about how you would feel if the person was telling this story was your daughter, your sister, your mother. Would you castigate her and tell her to stop risking ruining the reputation of good men by complaining when there were *only* 20-30 of them?

    • Eshta – what a disgusting, insensitive and ignorant post.

      Are you kidding? Do you live in Egypt? Do you not know any female who has walked on the streets of Cairo?

      This is not a campaign to ruin Egypt’s reputation – it is Egypt’s reputation.

      Don’t kid yourself. Regardless of the number of people who were involved, that it happened after the announcement of Morsi’s win, or that this was written by a foreigner, your comment is flippant, and lacks any insight or understanding of the gravity of this issue in Egypt. Incidents have occurred like this over and over again, to both foreigners and Egyptians alike. Lara Logan, Mona Eltahawy, the girl in the blue bra, the dozens of women marching against harassment earlier this month in Cairo, the women sexually assaulted during Eid in 2008… I can continue with more examples if you need it spelled out to you. Incidents like this have little-to-nothing to do with Egypt’s new president, baltageya, or islam. It is the culture of Egypt, the acceptance of sexual harassment as the norm.

      Your excuse that this is somehow outside or beyond Egyptians control smacks of ignorance and disconnect.

      Are you aware that this sort of incident happens to Egyptian and foreign women of all ages and religions everyday in every governorate of Egypt? Regardless of what they wear or look like? Are you aware that the majority of Egyptian women fear for their safety in the streets of their own neighbourhood?

      Ask your Egyptian female friends, family or even a stranger in the street if they have experienced sexual harassment in Egypt. Don’t sit behind your computer screen judging and discrediting someone who has spent time in the streets talking to women about this problem, and has had first hand experience of it.

      Egypt needs to stop blaming ‘foreign hands’ and external forces and own the fact that this is a problem with Egyptian culture.

    • Then how do you explain the similar incidents which have been happening for almost a year now?

      Take a look in the mirror: it is this nasty, insensitive, brutal comment of yours which is bringing shame on Egypt. Iyeb aleky! 😦

    • Don’t think of this as a campaign to hurt egypts reputation, think of it as an opportunity to improve egypt\s reputation going forward. What are you doing to improve egypt’s reputation?

  796. The amount of rage and sadness that I am feeling while reading your words can’t be really described. Ignorance caused this….the stupid judgments and rules of my society caused this; and I don’t want to apologize to you, because the apology is not enough. I promise you that I will work on awareness for the people, that I will do as much as I can to spread awareness and to make the people get some education. I am very sad for my country and for my people but we will change this, we will eventually…

    Thank you for being so brave, thank you for being such a strong person…..and finally thank you for still loving Egypt despite what happened. I hope a day will come when you tell this story and people won’t believe that this happened in Egypt…

    • I hope so too. We have to persevere, and prove everyone wrong who is attributing such horrific incidents to the Egyptian or Moslem personality. And I too salute Natasha for her fairness, despite all she endured.

  797. If somehow a nuclear strike were launched by someone on these Islamic savages, it would be theoretically wrong, but after reading this, it would not bother me. Kill them all and let Allah sort this garbage out.

  798. I am a person from Egypt, and I apologize to you on behalf of all the Egyptians.
    It was difficult for you, I know that, but as you said, the Egyptians are not as well, these are few and rare people.
    God bless you, and again … We apologize a lot for what happened to you. : (

    • people, you have to understand that this may be a complete lie, this stuff happens in Egypt AND in EVERY where on the planet, but this story is so well written, feels like fake to me.

      How to delete my comment ?

  799. Sorry sister but the bloody Military Dictators messed up (brain washed) the mentality of most of the ordinary Egyptians 😦
    The Egyptians are very nice & peaceful people but those were the offspring of MUBARK’s Ideology over the past 32 years.
    sister, I would like to invite you again with my wife, my son & I to Egypt again & I would promise you as long as you are not wearing anything reveling I would protect you with my life and no one will touch you.

    • “as long as you are not wearing anything reveling”. Please explain why it is that a man in Egypt can wear shorts and a tank top without anything happening to him and that a woman that is “reveling herself” gets assaulted?

  800. Am so sorry to what happened there but thanx to God that you made it.You are a brave lady kudos madam.Your documentary will be superb.May you be more careful next time.May God bless u

  801. So you admit you don’t know and provide examples of evidence that will help you ‘know’ but at the same time you ‘know’ it’s a smear campaign. Your attack on her credibility does not add to your own. Thanks for the internet lesson though. *rolls eyes*

  802. Your ordeal was horrific….and only someone who has been in such a situation would understand your story…the little details that others question or deny….those are the things that keep it real… I have lived in Egypt for 30 years…. I am blond….thus not Egyptian…. I have seen how people of Egypt have changed from happy go lucky hospitable people to this new angry group of people who want to place blame for everything on anyone who isn’t Egyptian. Just last week I too was harassed (but nothing like what you went through) while trying to save a horse in one of the canals…. way far away from the square…I was glad my Egyptian husband was with me….As I see it your story needs to be told as there are so many small things that are adding up to give the OK for such things to happen… No person (or animal) should have to be treated with such disrespect.
    May God bless you and James….. Keep telling your story! Hugs Yasmin

  803. This is totally offensive!! I urge you to delete this hurtful insensitive comment if you have the tiniest bit of compassion in you.

  804. I have to confess, I was so shocked by your story that didn’t want to not think about it, do something else, whatever, but eventually here I am commenting on your story still kind of shocked and wondering if anything could be said to help you feel better and move on. I am praying for you, Natasha… your physical wounds will heal and only God can heal your inner emotional and mental thought life as well as the memories of this horrific event in your life. I am a Christian and will be praying for you. Take the time to heal, Natasha… our culture will drive you to move on without doing the hard, introspective work to get whole…. there is happiness and purpose on the other end of this experience for you…. my heart goes out to you… thank you for being so brave as to write your story in such a public forum…. blessings to you….

  805. I know sorry wont make things better, all the time i am reading this all what is think of i really would gladly die to protect you form such awful experience. as a woman you represent my daughter, wife, sisters and mother who i wouldn’t ever allow such behavior toward them. I wish only I could promise you that the day will come when you come back to Tahrir not afraid of being sexually harrased and even have the ability to look to Egyptian men as humans not just animals

  806. I am sure that if some one is telling lies , this will be you …you deny what happened to Lara Logan …?.And what about Vivian Abdou the Egyptian journalist and the French journalist and hundreds of cases ..if any one checked YouTube he will find many videos of women harassment in Al tahrir ..it is a terrifying phenomena which looks like a strange poisoning came into our society

  807. Strange how you are still blind to reality even after your horrific experience… this *is* Egypt, and this *is* Islam. Reports of women assaulted and raped on Tahrir sqare are manyfold, and non-muslem women are a “treat” for muslem man. Please take my advice and never go back there (or to any islamic country).

    Lastly: there is no moderate islam.

    • I don’t think it makes sense to argue with people like you, but please stop pretending you have a clue about anything. It’s a horrific experience, but if we start stereotyping every country by the most horrible things that happen there, then good luck finding any place to go to in the world. And if you don’t want to set foot in Egypt (or any Islamic country), it’s up to you.

    • peter, this havent anything to do with religion my friend, this is a result of lack of proper punishment and disrespect for sexual harrasments against women in Egypt. So dont attack religions as no religion is telling people to act like animals. I hope you change your mind as generlizing the problem into a religious one will not help.

    • Religious moderates are just intellectually dishonest with themselves. This is dangerous and morally compromising. Fundamentalist dogma is just as dangerous as religious moderates. I understand respecting culture, but only so far as it is progressive. Appreciate but do not help give them excuses.

      • If you know anything about sociology people who commit such acts are usually ones that are generally frustrated from life due to poverty and hopelessness. religion is not the cause; it might be a result of the frustration ( An opium to help things pass). Culture in this particular situation is irrelevant.

    • You do not know ethics of Islam to speak,
      Harassment happens everywhere, not only at the hands of Muslims
      The face of harassment, not religion

  808. Natasha’s story is completely believable. Several reports of mass assaults that night and deliberate attacks by thugs on female demo against harassment a few days later. This is Egypt. But not all of it. I was attacked by a group of youths on 26 July bridge. A wonderful Egyptian man helped me and gave the youths a mouthful. I feel for you Natasha – this should never have happened and this is in no way your fault. The medical response you received was appalling but until a government takes this on as a cultural change program then it will continue to happen. And I cant see these men doing that any time soon. You look after you, girl and stay strong against these disgusting creatures.

  809. I am so sorry that this happened to you. I can’t imagine how you must feel. I hope you realize that you are a strong woman and you’re very brave. I admire your perseverance. On behalf of Egyptians I’d like to apologize. I’m so sorry. What goes around comes around, and I hope each and every one of those men pays.

    Stay Strong.

  810. This is horrific. I’d like to think that if I experienced something like this I would be as brave as you are being in making this known to more people. Don’t let any of the inevitable troll misogynists get to you – if anything, they’re making even more clear the kinds of attitudes that exist towards women in the supposedly modern and civilized world.

  811. Dear Natasha
    I am a 40 years old Egyptian who raised and lived in this country. Sexual harrament is reality in Egypt.
    Many Egyptian are taught and forced to have a kind of duplicate lives, example a policemen who tortures every day and returns back home to his family and plays the nice religous person without feeling guilty, or a state employee who looks religious and only finishes work with bribe money. People in Egypt were pushed and forced to have this duplicate lives throughout the last decades. This is not an excuse, but a justification. And the best start for a new Egypt is to admit the we have gained an evil attitude and habbits and we must get rid of it immediately. Lack of laws and punishments for such behaviors helped a lot an was a systimatic tactic played by former regimes to turn people here into stupid and evil human beings. I am sorry for all what happened to you and I believe you.

    • The best solution for this mob would have been 20 minutes of uninterrupted machinegun fire. Egyptian men seem to savages deserving only to be killed like dogs. Where are the drones?

      • Lettlander, with all respect, let us not forget that human beings are the same everywhere, you cannot just put all together in one corner. I have been all over in the world and people are almost the same. We as human beings can have two visions, the one who criticizes people and blame all the time, and the other and the better from my point of view is to try to help people to find the right path for their lives. Humans by nature are not evil, it is the circumstances around them who helps them to be good or evil. Thanks for your comment anyway.

      • Well, these particular “humanoids” deserve to be summarily executed by automatic gunfire. Journalists should be able to work, women should be free from violence (death penalty for rape doesn’t bother me), and maybe (even though it is impossible), the so called “Arab World” should be recolonized, put under Western martial law and its men “reeducated” with as many rifle-butt strikes to their head as it takes to get the point across.

  812. i apologize to you with the name of all real men here in Egypt and i will not tell you this is because of the poor life the people live but i just want you to forgive us and here in Egypt some people can save you with there life 😦 i don’t know what to say more !!

  813. I am really sorry…
    I cannot believe this is Egypt, but yet it is. The mob has a mind of it’s own, the adrenaline, the crowds, the stress and the absent law and strings.
    Nothing is justifiable, you have this experience reserved in the darkest corner of your memories, and all what I can do about it is say that am terribly sorry again

  814. Hi Natasha …… I can’t begin to tell you how angry I am at hearing this …… we had the same experience with a girl that was with us in Tahrir Square last week. If you would like to contact me on my email …. please do.

  815. What you call “Howl at the Moon Stupid”, most people would call noble. How is a journalist supposed to do her job without going near the events she’s documenting?

    How are those of us who want to protest the terrible injustices and murders being carried out by this regime meant to do so, without leaving the house so we don’t “get ourselves raped”.

    I’ve spent over 200 hours in Tahrir, looking foreign, without incident. Don’t blame Natasha for being the victim of a horrific crime.

    Your comments disgust me to the core. 😦

  816. No you’re not a woman living in Cairo, or you’d never say such a thing. There’s only one person here who sounds like they’re commenting for money, and that’s you.

    You’re so keen on evidence? Until I see your Facebook page, I’ll assume you’re the one being paid to sow disinformation.

    • يا بنتي اسالي صاحبة المدون عن ip بتاعتي انا عايزت تعرفي انا فين. بنسة لجنسي مش محم انا ست او راجل الدليل واجب

    • Because I know you probably can’t read Arabic, let me repeat you can ask Natasha to look at my ip address and see if I am in Cairo. And why does my gender matter? How sexist it is of you to assume it makes a difference in my comments. I am not denying these things happen, I know women AND men who have been assaulted here. I am not accusing her of lying either, but I am under no obligation to accept her word without evidence. In any civilized society, you cannot convict someone of a crime without evidence or witnesses. We have not fought during the revolution over the past year and a half in order to allow mob mentality to rule, whether the mob be men attacking women on the street or a mob of commenters on a blog condemning people without evidence. I will stand up to foreigners such as yourself who don’t believe in due process for Egyptians.

    • ana masreyya….w “enti” magnoon. i read and write arabic nicely – and with better grammar, thank you for your kind concern. on an english blog, i think it’s only courteous to speak in the language everyone here understands.

      this is a personal blog you chose to visit and comment on, not a court of law! no-one’s accused “Egyptians” of anything, much less Natasha who still loves our country despite her horrible experiences here.

      it’s clear to me exactly who and what you are: i won’t debate with paid felool. have a happy life….though i expect you wont.

  817. Reblogged this on yasmineelrafie and commented:
    Sexual harassment in Egypt is sadly a known and well documented phenomenon. Recently the reports have increased from colleagues and others in a deliberate targeting of anyone who could be labelled a foreign spy. Let’s not forget though, that this mob mentality has been a known thing during eid al-fitr and after football games for example. And let’s not forget all the men and women in Egypt who disapprove of this as well. The most sad part is the comments refusing to believe, or blaming the victim. Recommended viewing: the movie Cairo 678.

  818. As a cameraperson and journalist, the instinct to protect your camera is completely understandable – it’s your work, your livelyhood and a symbol of what your are fighting for.

    Natasha, I’m sorry you have to hear such brainless and heartless criticism. Your courage is inspirational. I believe you.

  819. Your self-description via Twitter: ‘I’m not a total bastard. Under my exterior there’s a nice guy, but yes – under him there’s another bastard. Let’s just say I’m two thirds bastard.’ You’ve definitely proven, and perhaps under-estimated, your self-description.
    FYI, “the show must go on,” likely refers to her documentary … a “show.” (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_show_must_go_on)
    Be glad you’re not a “blonde young Western girl” who went through such a situation. Gender has its privileges.

    • If you bothered to check twitter, you should’ve read my last tweet – If you doubt God, you’re an intellectual, but if you doubt people, ah – well .. then – you are one big f*ck of an a-hole.

      And whether or not it refers to a documentary, that just goes further to my doubts, certainly doesn’t alleviate them in any way. Gender? I refer to ‘blonde young Western girl’ – and the only word you saw there was ‘girl’? Xenophobic much? Sorry, but in my view, this is either an exaggerated account, or the writing is poor enough to give that impression.

    • AND – It has nothing to do with ‘gender’ – sad that people like you, who ARE gender-obsessed will take any doubts shed on any single individual as an attack on all women, grow up. Unless you’re suggesting that all men should believe anything said by any woman. In that case, I’d certainly have to reconsider my views on say, Condaleeza Rice.

  820. I’m sorry all this happened to you Natasha. I really wish i was there to die defending you . But I wish more that all who participated in this filth are shot to death with out any trial

  821. I am not able to find the proper words! I am sorry Natasha.. Really, this is not Egypt! and this awful experience you went through is an absolute shame on our foreheads! As an Egyptian, I apologize for you again, and again!

  822. Dear: M so sorry for this you are so brave to take it. please finish this documentary for the world to know how Egyptian men are uninhibited and harassing and this is an increasing phenomenon, please add a review on trip adviser, people can’t live in denial.

    • Not all Egyptian men are like this Asmaa. I know how many of them are bastards. But I know that there is still good in some of them. A few white spots on a very dark black dress

  823. I reached your link through the ‘The Uprising of Women in the Arab World’ Facebook page. I am from India, a male, and cannot in this life fully understand the suffering you went through.

    I wish you all the best to recover and get back to work though this does make me feel concerned about the future of Egypt under the new Islamist regime.

  824. So sorry for your experience ~ stay strong! Thank you for bringing awareness of situations such as yours. I hope writing this post helps you heal. Tweeted it @onlyintheozarks.

  825. even reading this is a Terrible experience i can’t imagine how horrifying to live it and writing about it i am speechless and i can’t express how sorry i am . i admire your courage . i hope that you will be able to get over it and i hope you the best .

  826. Sad thing these lowlife animals did this to you. Then again, how naieve to go to a country like this with such a low moral and low respect for women, and thinking you can make a decent reports as journalisms without being in a dangerous place. We all saw how it worked out last year when CNN, BBC and Al Jazeera MEN journalists try to report from Thahir Square. It’s a place where deep core hatred, frustration and despair is being outletted by men who have no future and have no life, and every woman in their path can be a victum. When u think u can roam freely around there as a western reporter u don’t know shit about this country and culture. I have been there several times, also in Cairo, and know from my visits that these people are desperate when the going gets tough. Especially when they operate in groups. That is no excuse for their behaviour, I wish they would have saved you from their beastility, but it’s about the same as walking into a lion’s park: u know what u are asking for of u do it. Next time bring more security and guns. That will protect you.

    • you and the likes of you are exactly why people like Natasha must keep doing what they`re doing, You`re a stereotyped sheep, that`s what you are…….and speaking about countries with low morals; why don`t you take a look at the crime statistics in your country before you make a goddamn fool of yourself, but again who am I talking to, a sheep that doesn`t have the vaguest notion of what he`s talking about, Natasha`s talking about preconceptions and stereotypes and here you are like a completely retarded doofus proving every word she said to be right ..God!! people like you make me siiiick…Fuck off you mindless creature.

  827. Pingback: This week in misogyny: “I don’t believe you” « Another angry woman

  828. On behalf of all egyptians i am vey sorry for what you’ve been through. Unfortunately i do believe you. less than a week ago i was walking to my car and just when i was about to put my key in and unlock it someone grabbed me from behind and slammed me against the car. i wasnt raped but he did almost everything else. i’m truly disgusted and i cant believe this is what my country has become. this is not the egypt i grew up in and i truly hope we have the power to change things and make our streets safer for women.

  829. Pingback: Women BE CAREFUL in Egypt « Doug's Archaeology

  830. This is truly heartbreaking. Thank you for sharing your experience to bring much needed attention to these problems in our global society. My thoughts and prayers are with you as you try to recover from this awful event. God bless.

  831. To all those who say your story sounds exaggerated or made up, I’d just like to say this:
    It is bad enough that it’s even possible to THINK of something as bad as mass sexual assault or rape in general.
    I would much rather like to be able to teach my children ‘don’t rape’ instead of ‘don’t get raped’. This world needs people like Natasha to raise awareness!

  832. Brave girl, keep spreading awareness. I can tell that this is happening from my own experience but i was more lucky than you and saved by strangers Egyptians during last year salafist demonstration. One man starts harrassing you and soon there are tens of them, in your case even more. Harrassing in a smaller scale is very common everywhere in Egypt and it concerns also Egyptian women. It is shameful

  833. Dear Natasha,
    I just want to say three things:
    1) I believe you
    2) This was not your fault
    3) Thank you for writing this
    Much love @Brixtonite x

  834. There are no words…. but thanks for sharing. This will take a while to sink in I’m sure, but hopefully writing this helped you to regain some power and begin to deal with it. What a shocking thing to happen to you, but you survived and I’m pleased to see that it hasn’t broken your spirit. The feeling that they’ve taken power away from you, leaving you vulnerable, is awful, but this piece proves your strength and resolve. I admire you and wish you all the best in finishing this project. Keep strong.

  835. Hi Natasha,

    Thank you for writing about your dreadful experience, I expect the impact won’t have fully sunk in yet but I hope that when it does you manage to stay strong and continue working. Never forget that you are doing essential work – it’s important that the whole world hears about how women are treated in Egypt- indeed in all countries. Most importantly- and I say this with reference to your penultimate paragraph- do not EVER blame yourself. It’s a trap that so many survivors fall into, and a very tempting one, but this was in no way your fault. I wish you all the best in your physical and mental recovery- I’m you will get there and come back stronger than ever.

    I know I am a complete stranger but I just had to comment as your story is so upsetting. I wish you all the best.

    Charlotte

  836. It’s not clear to me who is more vile and worthy of castration — the animals who did this to you (uneducated, sexually messed up men who were probably raised in abusive households where beating was a regular part of growing up), or the scoundrels leaving comments here who don’t believe your story (presumably educated people who can write in English and have access to the internet and information).

    To my mind, I hope neither the animals nor the scoundrels ever have any kids so their rotten genes might stop with their own rotten lives.

    Either way, I commend you for not wanting to purchase a bazooka and blow this town down. That’s certainly what I’d want to do.

  837. NOBODY deserves this kind of treatment and the fact that you have no sympathy for it whatsover, Justine, is what is so disturbing. It almost sounds as if you think she deserves it. Do you? There is absolutely NO justification at all for this horrific act. Instead of telling women they should TRY NOT TO GET RAPED, when are we going to start teaching men NOT TO RAPE?!

    I live in Cairo and have for 18 years. I am half Egyptian. I DO NOT put it past so many crazy, angry, desperate, oppressed and frustrated Egyptian men to commit such acts. I have been a victim of sexual assault myself since I went to AUC. IT IS UNACCEPTABLE and it’s time EGYPTIAN MEN STAND UP FOR US AND STOP BEING SILENT. Speak up and tell your brothers to RESPECT women as human beings.

      • Natasha Smith ………
        If what you mention about what happened in the editing, this is a true product of your civilization; because Islam is the finest and highest of which happened to you in the field.
        It calls for the virtue and morals
        It is forbidden to touch women or mixing with men in any place

      • Why don’t you tell this to the actual perpetrators, instead of the victim? What use is a belief if people don’t follow its rules? Why mention islam if islam has nothing to do with it? Islam didn’t stop these savages and islam didn’t make the doctors and nurses treat her in a human manner. It’s so easy to always deny things by saying ‘this is not islam’, but the people who do these horrible things call themselves muslims. I’m beginning to wonder how many muslims live islam the way it’s portrayed to be.

  838. Seriously? You want a fucking photograph of the injuries sustained in a serious and violent sexual assault? I know we live in an age if ‘pics or it didn’t happen’ but what the fuck is wrong with you? This is a vile, irredeemable comment and you should be fucking ashamed of yourself you piece of shit.

    • In a court of law, sure. But as she isn’t in one, and furthermore hasn’t accused anyone (see the names of any of her attackers up there? Didn’t think so), she is under no obligation to produce ‘proof’ to anyone, least of all an anonymous stranger. Asking for proof of a traumatising experience just hours after it took place is /at best/ insensitive and thoughtless, and at worst the vicious and cruel action of a shitstain on the sole of humanity.

  839. This is such a horrifying thing to read. You are so, so brave to write about and post this, particularly so soon after the attack.

    Your last few lines made my heart ache. This is not your fault, in any way shape or form. I hope you can heal in peace. Look after yourself.

  840. Dear Natasha, thank you so much for writing this piece. I believe you. You are an inspiration in your openness and honesty. I wish you all the best in fighting the good fight and recovering from this horrific thing x

  841. As i’ve witnessed one of the mass sexual assaults months ago, i can understand and expect how huge the “Hundreds of men” was! This was on of the most terrible things i’ve EVER seen in my life, i took my belt off swinging right and left trying to hold the mob back and could have been dying right now as i stumbled off the platform and the crowd ran over me, i was thinking of the bad things i’ve done in my life. I’m still having nightmares of this awful night and even can’t forget the scared look on her face.

    • Thank you for risking your life trying to help, I really admire your bravery. I think it’s important to remember, despite the vile criminals, the very many Egyptian men who are absolutely decent and noble, beyond what you’d expect to find in most parts of the world. 🙂

  842. Shut your ugly mouth. You know nothing and to deny someone’s experience because YOU haven’t seen evidence is why these animals continue to get away with it.

  843. I’m amazed and impressed that you shared this so quickly but I totally agree that it is so important to do so. Wish you a speedy recovery. I also want to reiterate what Neta said above: NOTHING you did was a “mistake.” One of the ways we keep perpetrators in power is to tell victims to avoid rape or assault. It’s not *your* job to avoid that; it’s *their* job to quit raping and assaulting. Stay strong. You did nothing wrong.

  844. Anita: what a stupid answer. Sometimes the mind uses its own safeguards to lower the impact of devastating, horrible experience; the person focusing on some detail not directly related to the tragedy (here, fact of losing camera) is one of these tricks of the mind. That is why many raped/assaulted people will be able to give a very precise description of a detail with no importance at all and be unable to explain in detail what happened or not. Most of raped people experience that moment where mind acts like “detached” from body; go and accuse all of those people of being storytellers.

    And being a “westerner living in Cairo” doesnt make of you more trustworthy than any of the ppl who replied here.

  845. People ‘not believing’ this account have obviously never suffered sexual assault and your comments are making me wish you had/will in future.

    You people seriously disgust me. A woman documents (her godsdamn job!) a serious sexual attack by a mob and you’re telling her that things she focused on make her ‘less believable’? Did you not read the part about detachment? Which MOST rape victims do to protect their minds! It enables you to get through the experience without going completely insane with fear and horror.

    I generally would never wish violence of any kind upon anyone, but to come on someone’s blog, where they have shared an experience in which they truly believed they could die, and call them a liar or propagandist is as sick as the rapists/attackers themselves.

    You need to take a long, hard look at your life & attitudes.

    I hope, for their sake, that no child of yours is ever sexually attacked. You obviously would either disbelieve them or say it was their own fault.

    When are we going to stop teaching women ‘Don’t get raped’ and start teaching men ‘DON’T FUCKING RAPE!!’

  846. A very moving and powerful story. I wish you well, Natasha, with the healing process; and hope it shall be complete.

    I was last in Tahrir Square, 23 years ago. I recall sitting at an outdoor cafe (accompanying a young female journalist, as it happens) drinking a beer (Egyptian Stella) and enjoying the scenes – which included young Egyptian women dressed much as they would be on an evening out in London or any other cosmopolitan capital. The few that covered their heads did so with Hermes or Liberty scarves – all very elegant. All the people we met were great, and we never felt unsafe.

    That Cairo has descended into the sort of place where your experience is now more commonplace than mine is a source of great sadness. I cannot help but deduce that your experience, and that of many others with similar stories, is a by-product of Egypt slipping back from secularism. Whatever the cause – Egypt is broken. For a problem to be fixed, it first needs to be identified – you have done Egypt a service in highlighting a problem.

  847. I saw a friend of mine reposting this on facebook. I am so sorry for what you have gone through and you’ll be in my prayers. May God bless you. Stay strong! You can get through this!!!!
    Sending you lots of love!
    XXX

  848. Pingback: Blog Post of the week: “Please God. Please make it stop.”

  849. I believe you, I am terribly sorry for what you had to go through, and I am also very sorry for all the unkind and blind words some Egyptians used to reply to such a painful post. I’m an Egyptian woman, I know very well how uneducated and poor Egyptian men behave like, it’s a disgrace. Such crimes against human rights happen on a daily basis on Egyptian streets, not always with the same level of barbarity, but they do. Women get insulted and demeaned. But for some odd reason, most seem to deny such things. On behalf of all Egyptians I dare represent, I am terribly terribly sorry you had to go through this instead of spoiling you with the hospitality that was once common in our country. I’m sure you can use up your will power to get over this and resume your project stronger than ever. I also hope you get to see the other side of Egypt, the generous one. Stay safe.

  850. I BELIEVE YOU.

    Where my heart finally broke was when you blamed yourself at the end. This was NOT YOUR FAULT. It is never the fault of the person (let’s face it, woman) being attacked. It’s the fault of men who are so brutalised by a mix of political oppression and religious propaganda that they think of women as lower than animals. My heart goes out to you. Stay strong.

    • I agree – i cant stop crying i’m so sorry. I’m sorry too you and to us egyptians who hate to see anyone hurt in our country and “egyptian” hands. it’s so horrible and so definitely not your fault.
      I blame the egyptian media for the direct attack on you because of the fact that you were western. I dont blame you for being there. I blame myself for NOT being there.. we should be able to protect others..
      Further more i am so sorry that you were put in a position that people made you feel like because you weren’t married or a virgin that this was okay or of lesser priority.I can understand and sympathize about how horrible it is.

      • Don’t blame yourself; just focus on the perpetrators. They are obviously too depraved for any one person or small group to be able to control; until there’s a social change… which could take centuries… such garbage will continue to pollute the planet. But it does you, and all the other commentators on here who understand the reality of the situation, credit that you want to improve your society. It won’t be easy!

  851. I’m so sorry you had to go through this! I personally feel violated even though I didn’t go through the same experience, even though I get harassed every single day in a different way.

    I would just like you to remove Shafiq from your tags, this man is too decent and it’s irrelevant tagging his name. You could gladly tag Morsi if you want, for the oppression he will bring to this country will definitely make your kind of accident a daily incident.

  852. Asalamu Alaykom Natasha (and James),

    Alhumdulillah. We say this even in the worst of times and we try to see how God is with us even then. Alhumdulillah. Subhanallah, Natasha, that you called out for God. Truly God loved you and saved you. You are blessed. Alhumdulillah.

    I believe you. I am a survivor of sexual abuse and I say that plainly. I don’t say it with any feeling of dirtiness on me. I am clean because I’ve gone through counseling and I really recommened that you connect with a professional counsellor as soon as possible—someone who is well informed about issues survivors face.

    Sexual abuse is about power; to have control over someone else. Though others can find reasons that the men attacked you, basically you were attacked as a symbol; not as a person. They didn’t know you. What they did was a complete invasion, yet they never reached who you really are. Remember: your true self is intact.

    I am here in Giza and you can reach me through my blog or on Twitter. I will not make public any contact you make with me. I am most truly offering love and support. I don’t think you need one more person telling you that you are brave or strong. Honestly? You’ve earned being weak for a while. Lie low and recover from this. You don’t have to accept one label that readers put on you; positive or negative. I think you need some peace and quiet; a time to regroup. Though this information is important for the public to hear, I wonder if it might not become a re-violation. Pull back from publicizing this if that’s what you need. Do WHATEVER you need to make it through these days. It only has to make sense to you.

    James, you seem to be a main support to Natasha. Please remember that you are suffering a shock too. You will need to resupply yourself with a centered soul as well. Find whatever healthy input you can.

    The men who did this to you forgot their higher selves. No one has to wish them ill. They are already ill. They will also carry with them this memory but with their lower selves being the aggressors. Astragferallah.

    Everyone reading this could take a moment and send good thoughts to Natasha and James. Positive thoughts are powerful things. Send prayers for healing and good health. Send prayers for protection for allllll the women in Egypt and around the world. YA RAB!

  853. you’re really deluded if you think you know how people’s mind work when they’re under duress… i’m sorry but if it’s never happened to you then dont even. and if it’s happened to you and you had presence of mind then good for you but i’m sorry that’s not how everyone else’s brain operates, you are insensitive and horrible..
    i hope god spares you the experience since i sense by your tone you might not have a good support system to help you through it and then imagine how Karma would have her way with you.

    • Thanks for making my point. If this really happened, the victim has every right to be profoundly horrified and absolutely no right to be so shocked that it could.

  854. I belive there is some work of fiction in the story. No sane woman would be assulted and think about losing her “nice shoes” or that “suprisengly she is not the mood for a big mac” !!!! Those are lines from a novel.

    • people who think like you are why we are in this mess…you have no idea what it is like i have been there …it happened to a friend of mine and i saw what those men could do…sadly i was in a mess and could not help her….

    • Iyeb! :(((

      I’m very happy for you that nothing bad has ever happened to you in your life, so you’ve never needed to learn the strange things the mind focuses on when your body is flooded with adrenaline. I’m sad for you, that you’ve never managed to learn empathy, sensitivity or compassion, though. 😦

    • Shame on you Bothaina ..you know well that it’s a true story , we have been watching hundreds of similar stories over the last year and the hall world saw what happened to Lara Logan the correspondent of ABC news in 2/11/2011 and the Egyptian journalist Vivian Abdou …in Al tahrir…as an Egyptian I apologize to Natasha , I will pray for her to over come this terrifying experience and I thank her for her braveness ..by publishing her story many women will be saved from going through such an experience .

    • If you are EVER put in a traumatic situation you will realize that the shock will let your mind drift to irrelevant things. When I was attacked by thugs once before I was focused on how I’d lost one of my earrings. You do not know anything about trauma and therefore are NOT allowed to judge! I hope something like this never happens to you, but SHAME ON YOU. SHAME ON YOU A MILLION TIMES. 3eeb kda!

  855. Yes of course…a figment of her imagination. Women just LOVE to imagine the prospect of having their clothes ripped off by a mob of dirty Egyptian men and being dragged naked and sexually violated in the street – especially blonde foreign women who would crave the attentions of dark manly men in Egypt. Ahmed El-Sadek, what kind of delusional world do you live in? This could have happened to your sister, or your wife, or your daughter. Would you then tell them that this was in their imagination? Or perhaps you might blame them for what they were wearing. I feel sorry for every woman you know. Again, Natasha, I apologize for people like Ahmed, who also do not represent the majority of Egyptians.

    • I am sorry Dina, but people like Ahmed do represent the majority of Egyptians. when a woman is sexually assaulted in front of ppl like ahmad who occupy the streets the most. they don’t move, they observe quietly as they pass by looking amused. then they blame the woman if they’re confronted about it. I am very sorry to tell you this, but I am sure you know it already and didn’t want to accept it.

    • This sounds like a typical Egyptian conspiracy theory to me. Where do you get this information from? From my point of view seeing how often my female friends get sexually assaulted just walking in the street here, coupled with the temporary madness which seems to overtake crowds, I find no need to believe that ‘paid thugs’ were behind this. That just sounds like an excuse to avoid facing the reality of a very serious problem here. Offered respectfully, Campbell.

      • Have you already forgotten the assaults on women in downtown Cairo at Eid al fitr back in the mid 00’s? Are you unaware of how the streets are deserted of women when eid or the end of a victorious football match has taken place? Really??

      • I know what you mean Campbell…as a ‘nus w nus’ (Egyptian-English) the denial you’re talking about drives me crazy!

        However, in this case I personally agree with this particular conspiracy theory, based on my own observations over more than 60 days/nights spent in Tahrir. I look like a foreigner. All women in Egypt get harassed on every street, every day: foreigners often get it worse, because it’s assumed they are more “loose-moraled”, or won’t speak enough Arabic to defend themselves.

        However, my time in Tahrir, and that of my female friends (Egyptian and foreign), was a blessed respite from the constant outpouring of sexual harassment in the streets. I’d walk the twenty minutes into Tahrir accompanied by catcalls, whistles and leers. Then I’d join the crowds thronging into the square and it would just….stop. Bliss. Lots of guys would talk to me, flirt with me in a respectful way, take pictures with me…but in about 200 hours spent in Tahrir, no-one as much as leered at me.

        There was one incident, when I was taking photos with my IPhone, when the leader of what I can only describe as a “gang” looked me up and down in a way I can only describe as “casing me”…with more reference to the camera in my hand, than anything else about me. We made eye contact, he noted I wasn’t a journalist (or a foreigner, as I seem at first glance) and that I was paying sharp attention to them, then he moved on…with his organised gang. This wasn’t a normal group of friends, laughing and talking together. It was a silent group of men moving purposefully through the crowds. Every hair on my body stood up in reaction to that group.

        I know other women have had less fortunate experiences, and suffered the general groping and verbal harassment. But these attacks are on a much bigger, more frightening scale and seem organised and concerted. In many of these reports the women were attacked *simultaneously*, by a *group*. It seems to me that a natural mob attack would begin with one or two men, then spread. The other common factors in these attacks which make me suspicious are, 1) female foreign journalist targets. The camera or voice recorder in a woman’s hand should make her no more attractive to random violence. 2) The persistence and viciousness of all of these attacks – a random attack should disperse in the face of resistance or counter-violence. In every case, passersby and the women’s own male companions tried to stop the violence and were attacked. The normal pattern is for harassers, who are bullies, to show their cowardice – grope and run. 3) There is far less harassment in Tahrir, then in any other part of Egypt…yet we’ve never heard of any attacks on this scale in any other part of Egypt.

        I completely understand why Egyptian conspiracy theories seem a bit mental to outsiders. However, I’m afraid when faced with the brutal and strange regime that we have here, many of the theories turn out to be true. To give one example, the Parliamentary Investigative Commission did in fact find out that the Port Said Football Massacre was organised (with an accompanying organised attempt to cover up the evidence). This regime has a well-documented history of using both paid thugs and systematic sexual assault to squash protests.

        To Natasha and other victims, in one sense it’s irrelevant whether or not this violence was organised: except in so far as we are going to attempt to catch these disgusting criminals and have them shamed and punished, no matter who they are. 😦

  856. Pingback: Please God. Make it stop. « Gin & Thomas

  857. This happens in Egypt, in Libya, in Syria, maybe even Bahrain, Yemen, but with all your criticism of Israel, The Jews would NEVER do this to a woman. Arabs will and do, but not Jews. Remember that when you are praising Arabs and criticizing the Israelis.

      • You’re right…The Israelis don’t waste time on that sort of thing. They just go raze down the homes of the Palestinians and shoot them down. It’s really a much more efficient process.

      • Seconded. Plus of course: the fuck they don’t. I’m Israeli, and reports of activists and arrestees being sexually menaced & assaulted by right wing activists, the army and even their own “side” are a dime a dozen. They get suppressed for the same reason that men in Egypt are able to get away with this beastly, gut-churning perversion of human behaviour: because women are seen as second class and “their” problems are seen as secondary to the “struggle” (whatever that happens to be that day).

        The truth, of course, is that “women’s” problems like abuse, violence and rape are central to the social failure of the middle east. Until violence against women is not front and centre of the struggle in both Israel and the Arab states, none of these “spring” revolutions will achieve anything other than a new and more horrific flavour of oppression for the people unfortunate enough to live there.

      • Well, actually they do. They even take special care to see that it is children they are slaughteering, which the Israelis do not. See: Mohammed Merah.

    • Are you Serious ? ignorant mobs will do anything no matter what their race or background is, if you think Israelis are either Culturally or Genetically superior, well.. then that explains your reaction to such a brave story. I am glad not all Israelis think the same way as you do.

    • Oh really? what about all that violence done to Palestinians by the Israelis, they even do that to not only women, but also children!
      I believe neither a good Jew nor a good Muslim would do that..

    • A rabbi in my neighbourhood raped a 10 year old boy. We had an anti-racism demo after that since many nazis started to spread propaganda. Its really disturbing to see jews (not all) do the same kind of propaganda against muslims and arabs. Get a grip!

      • That is because Jews are victimized by Muslims on a daily basis. Anti-Semitism and Islamophobia cannot be compared for this very reason.

  858. For all the people who doubt this story: please read these other testimonies gathered by Nazra, from an attack on June 2nd, in Tahrir: http://nazra.org/2012/06/%D8%B4%D9%87%D8%A7%D8%AF%D8%A7%D8%AA-%D8%AD%D9%88%D9%84-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%A7%D8%B9%D8%AA%D8%AF%D8%A7%D8%A1%D8%A7%D8%AA-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AC%D9%86%D8%B3%D9%8A%D8%A9-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AA%D9%8A-%D9%88%D9%82%D8%B9%D8%AA-%D9%85%D8%A4%D8%AE%D8%B1%D8%A7-%D9%81%D9%8A-%D9%85%D8%AD%D9%8A%D8%B7-%D9%85%D9%8A%D8%AF%D8%A7%D9%86-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AA%D8%AD%D8%B1%D9%8A%D8%B1
    PDF in Arabic: http://nazra.org/sites/nazra/files/attachments/nazra_sexual_harassment_testimonies_june2012_ar.pdf
    PDF in English: http://nazra.org/sites/nazra/files/attachments/nazra_sexual_harassment_testimonies_june2012_en.pdf

    2 of the victims are personal friends and I can assure you it is all true.
    They also went on live TV (“bi taw2eet al qahera” with 7afez al mirazy on Dream2 channel) and gave their testimony of what happened to them. For Egyptian commenters who cannot believe the story in the above blog post, you can watch this short extract from the show on Dream 2 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=13szCqHbuIQ&feature=youtu.be

    Some attacks in Tahrir seemed to have been coordinated or planned, possibly in order to weaken or discredit the protest movement. But it is difficult to be sure about this. In any case there is no hard evidence of the attacks were planned.
    By the way, the attacks do not seem connected to Ikhwan (Muslim Brotherhood) at all. In fact, my 2 friends happened to be saved by supporters of Mohammad Morsi on June 2nd.

  859. hi,next time please be careful with yourself in whatever you set out to do there in Cairo i might not know you personally but as a global citizen i want you to know care for you very much.It must have been an awful experience for that night which you perhaps will not want to remember or it be done again.Take Care sweetheart!

  860. Why would she make it up? To be famous? Who wants to be famous for being sexually assaulted ?!. Let us not change the facts so we can sleep better at night! The poor girl just got sexually assaulted. Let her recover in peace instead of bombarding her with insensitive comments

    • If she wants to recover in peace and change stereotypes about Arabs as she claims elsewhere in this site, then she would have not written this post now and instead taken time to reflect on the situation before posting about it. If it happened, she was under no obligation to blog about it immediately.

  861. Dear Ahmed, please do not deny something you didn’t witness yourself, and I assure you as an Egyptian female who is frequently at Tahrir this happens and increasingly since the 25th of Jan 2012 to females of all ages including a mother in her 50’s local and foreign females. This is a horrible experience that takes women years to recover if they do. Before saying anymore please do some fact finding. Speaking of a violations spreading awareness is they key to resolving such issues having strength and bravery to tell is worth a lot of respect.

  862. I am a man, and I went once to Cairo. After few days thereI said fuck it. I ain’t coming back to this shithole. I wasn’t harassed or molested, but I didn’t like the bad vibe in all of the city. God bless you and give you the courage. But if you want any advice, don’t go to Cairo, and if you can, don’t even go to Egypt. It’s a fuckedup place, believe me.

  863. Anita, you may be a female Westerner living in Cairo, but that does not mean you are an oracle on what women go through here. The author is a documentary film maker, I’m willing to bet her camera cost a lot of money and had precios work on it. (and she speaks about that only at the start of her ordeal) I doubt she thought about it again once they had ripped her clothes off etc.

    Contrary to your thoughts that women say this to get attention as a journalist – this kind of stuff actually hamper women in their careers – editors sometimes think they are weak or troublemakers and won’t send them places.

    Honestly – you are a piece of work Anita.

    • Agreed. Most Egyptian men are far more likely to come to the aid of a woman who is being assaulted in the street than most Western men, in my experience. My Egyptian male friends are also far more politically active against sexual harassment and assault than my Western ones.

      • You are right. Amanda is truly delusional. Any woman who has been to Egypt has seen some form of this behavior. The happenings in Tahrir are an enhancemet by a male population who no longer fear any reprisals.

  864. Do not listen to those who want to hurt you.
    A big hug. I hope you are able to get over this terrible experience soon and get on with your life.
    Jane, Italy.

  865. The shame of Egypt. These men do not deserve sympathy or understanding. Your love for Egypt is amazing and clouds your reactions. It was brutal attack that is becoming too common. The Egyptian culture is stained. Go on, go public, please.

  866. That is just about the most insensitive response I’ve ever seen. Who in their right mind would exaggerate an issue like this? Seems like people don’t want to believe that this can happen. Shame on you.

  867. Reading your story has made me feel ashamed of being Egyptian… almost ashamed of being a man.
    I am proud of strong brave women like you who have the courage to speak out. And I’m so very sorry.

  868. @Samar – perhaps the story is exaggerated based on the fear, pain, and panic Natasha was experiencing at the time of the assault, but perhaps it isn’t. Even if it was 5 men or 10 men who ripped off her clothes, dragged her through the dirty streets in the middle of a mob, chased her, and raped her with their hands – Does it really make a difference how many people were involved in the incident? Put yourself in her situation where you are in the middle of a mob of crazy men and unrecognizable faces and they are doing it to you…wouldn’t it feel like a thousand men? Shame on you for not expressing your sorrow and sympathy at her experience, and throwing the blame on her for exaggerating the story. The pain and humiliation she has endured as clearly beyond anything you could ever begin to comprehend. This woman has had the courage to share the worst possible nightmare that could happen to a woman, and has done it not to say how bad Egypt is, but to alert all men and women of the dangers they can face, and you want video evidence? Seriously? To Natasha, I’m sorry, but Samar also does not represent most Egyptians, and if she does, we have a lot of work to do.

    • I agree with you. and Natasha and James, please don’t mind those people who doubt her credibility. When we (egyptian women) are talking about sexual harassment we get more aggressive responses than this. and we get almost no sympathy from either men or women for that matter. its indeed a very very sad reality that makes the most sensible ones and the ones who can afford it to leave the whole country. It’s very hard to be an egyptian woman and mostly harder to address issues like this without being attacked. Heal well Natasha.

      • the best punishment for Egyptian sexual harasser men is for all the women to simply leave Egypt. China has a female deficit. Anywhere is better than Egypt, land of sadists and rapists.

      • lol,, have you seen of all egypt’s Men !?! don’t make a judgement because of a sick group it’s not all of us like that ,,things like that are everywhere even where you live ,, and by the way the sexual Sites that we see these days came from the USA and all of the foreign countries not from Egypt so you’re the most Disgusting people on the entire planet you produce SEX MOVIES for living and who did that to Natasha was just a sick group of people you can find some of them in your country as well.

      • wait. You don’t want Egyptians to be judged by the vile acts of some, but you are okay judging all Americans because some Americans make sex movies which you obviously enjoy… What is worse, a gang rape or a sex movie? Maybe you should think again and face reality (if that is somehow possible).

    • And the garbage who carried out the assault don’t represent most Egyptians. There are civilized men in Egypt… and elsewhere… who try to counter the bestiality of the kind who carry out such atrocities:

  869. If anyone, male or female, is interested in setting up Safe Points for female journalists and protestors in Tahrir Square, forming part of a defensive guard to protect the safe points, and/or forming protective groups to escort women to the Safe Points, please join this Facebook group:

    https://www.facebook.com/groups/129672763810060/251787051598630/?notif_t=group_activity

    We want to start a mass Facebook campaign to co-ordinate protective volunteers. We also want observers to mingle with the crowd and photogroup suspicious behaviour or groups.

    Khallas, and la2a: enough. We can’t let this happen to anyone else. 😦

  870. To answer your question, how did so many in the crowd fail to notice this? Probably from many men refusing to recognize reality, as you are doing now.

    • I’m a Tahrir regular. There are often hundreds of thousands of people in the square. Unless you are flying overhead, one can only see the couple of hundred people next to oneself. When a woman is completely surrounded by men and attacked, all the people around would see is a group of men surrounding some kind of scuffle or activity in the middle. The only people who would actually see a woman stripped on the ground are the 50 or 100 people nearest her…in other words, the criminals themselves.

      The woman the army stripped was videoed because they did it right in the open, where there were no people around to block the view. Even so, there were only a couple of videos and photos of that incident. Bleeding bodies were carried past me countless times, and I never managed to get one photo: it all happened so fast.

      This is not the only account of these mass sexual harassments happening. Walk into the street right now, wait 5 minutes, and you’ll see some kind of SH (even if it’s shouting). There is no reason whatsoever to question Natasha’s account of what happened.

      She is a guest in our country: iyeb aleky! She deserves all our full sympathy and support. 😦

    • Also Samar, I have been to Tahrir many times, but I am seriously wondering if you have. There are areas in Tahrir where the people are packed so tightly, that it is almost impossible to move without fighting through. If you remember the photo of the blue bra girl, it was in an area where people were extremely scattered. Here is the link to photograph. Just in that photo, there are 3 officers simultaneously assaulting her, and 5 others visible in the picture who most likely had a go at her next. http://www.npr.org/blogs/pictureshow/2011/12/21/144098384/the-girl-in-the-blue-bra
      I suppose, oftentimes, ignorance is bliss.

  871. We’re in Egypt and I think we were on the same bridge at possibly the same time. Can you email me so we can talk?

  872. I’m reading this in total shock,, not that i didn’t know of it happening, but i had not read an account, except for Mona Eltahawys, and i mean no disrepect to her terrible ordeal, but I have to say this is much harder to read, of course. I do admire your strength, and wish you Gods speed on recovering, both physically and mentally/emotionally. Thank you for your bravery and openness, I do hope that many women find the strength from your experience tocome forward.

    • Wasn’t Mona Eltahawy’s arm broken in the assault on her? All the accounts I’ve read of any of the many similar assaults are harrowing; anyone who talks of invention or exaggeration obviously doesn’t get out much. Some of these comments are almost as appalling to read as the account of the actual assault…

  873. I’m really sorry for your pain.
    I was exposed to something similar on the night of celebrating Mubarak’s stepping down. I was in Tahrir with a group of foreign journalists/photographers, and we were harassed by young Egyptian men who were suspicious of our presence there. We were saved first by a group of young Egyptian men who made a circle around me and the other woman being harassed, then by the military police who took us in an army car out of the square into the Museum. Otherwise, it could have turned much much uglier.
    I can relate to what you mentioned about one’s inability to understand how people can behave so viciously, how one feels completely powerless..and I was also thankful for those who decided in a split second that this was wrong and that they had to do something about it. I owe them my eternal gratitude.
    I was shaken for a while, and eventually it made me stronger. I no more tolerate any of this shit.
    You too are very strong.

    • Dear Gehan,
      I’m a graduate of political science and psychology, permanently living in Cairo and trying to do research on the issue of sexual harassment. Would you maybe be willing to talk about this topic with me? If yes, or if you would like to have more information first, please get in touch.
      Best regards,
      Sina

  874. Hey Natasha,
    I really hope you read this,
    I apologize, I\’m not only sorry for what you\’ve experienced, but I do apologize, this was completely wrong, shouldn\’t happen and doesn\’t commonly happen
    While I was reading everysingle word and imagining everymoment – i was trying to think \”why\”??
    It\’s not a just a harassment accident. we both agree this was not normal by anymean, but you said it \”they wanted my blood\”. Iam not defending the hell they\’ve done, but If you want an explanation, and we owe you one, just add the weak education system to the misleading media campaign against foreigners that consider them all spies, to the regome many thugs in Tahrir who like spreading rumors about anything and anyone to make the Square unstable / insecure place.
    Iam sure you\’re very wise to findout that every action has a reason, they didn\’t attack you and only you out of other foreigners in the Square, just like that
    I know how those things start, and Iam sure that a man, most probably a thug, shouted in arabic that may heard but didnt understand \”watchout this women is an israeili/american spy\”,, add to that this silly ad about spies in TV,, and the weak education that graduate majority with weak logical thinking,, It would then be very easy to have all those men in the crowd very sure that they are facing an enemy. That\’s how it all started

    Square security should be more,, you had the right to have more of square security guys besides you all the way untill you finish your job, at least they could effective reply any rumor that you\’re a spy or smth,,
    I second you, foreigners shouldn\’t forget their extra precautions, shouldn\’t get in the middle of a crowd, you even have every right to call police before you go in and ask for getting support from tourism police so they could secure you till you finish your job
    last thing to say,, there is a new president now. It\’s honestly getting better now

    Thanks God you\’re safe and sound now

    I was just trying to help you find an answer for the valid questions\” why\”, \” why me\”, and \” how could i have that not started from the beginning\”

    Iam sorry and apologize

  875. Sorry Ahmed, this is not the only story I heard about this! I am from Egypt and I know that some of the thugs were trying on purpose to scare the girls away from Tahrir square and this is why we saw the circle of young men surrounding their girls (friends or relatives) to protect them from harassment! This is a painful truth, but as the women told her, this is not Egypt!

  876. Dear Natasha,

    Thank you for sharing your heart-wrenching story. I wish I could say I am surprised. I am an Egyptian who was also a victim of severe sexual assault, but nothing near to the experience you had. It is truly shameful that we live amongst ‘people’ – if they can be called that – who are so brutal. They cannot even be called ‘animals’ because ‘animals’ would never treat their own kind the same way. I am truly sorry that you had to experience this, and ashamed that these crimes were committed by my countrymen. Being sexually harassed is almost a part of a daily routine as a woman in Egypt, and the crimes ALWAYS go unpunished. We are hearing more and more stories similar to yours, and sadly, I don’t think it is because sexual harassment/assault is more rampant now, but because women are finally gaining the courage to speak up about their experiences. I hope that all women who experience any form of sexual violation have as much courage as you to share their stories so that we can FINALLY give these criminals the punishment they deserve, and eventually eradicate this problem completely.

    Dina

  877. Reading this just brought me back to the looks, the cold eyes with no fear and no hope of hundreds pushing and pushing on Jan 25th 2012, since today it’s a Day of prayers, God, i reiterate my prayers for those guys for all who don’t see any hope and have not seen love, I pray for 2 very brave persons specialy, and i pray for all the victims and pray for all the attackers …. and thank you Natasha for describing so bravely what we could never describe and explain, May God be with you and Bless you, Thank you for being who you are:)

  878. Fuck them, fuck anybody who dared put his hand on you. This happened due to the recession in morals that our country has been going through in the last few years. You can’t imagine how much people have changed in the last 10 years. I am talking about every aspect in our life. The old regime, in its fear of the islamists, did its best to weaken the best morale-building thing and that is religion. Plus the new slums, where people are so poor, ignorant, and piled 10 in a room. Adding all this up leads to what you experienced today. I am so angry, and every day I see this I curse those bastards more and more.
    Please hold on and keep going, I can’t imagine what you’ve been through but I know that it is too much. Raise your eyes in every fucking bastard you see. And please make sure that if there were hundreds of these fucking molesters, there are millions who would kill them if they had the chance and power to do so. Let’s hope they reap what they did one day.

  879. I am so sorry for you and am amazed by the strength that you show in your post. I just would like to say one thing and that is that please do not think for a second that you should have done anything different. It is ridicilous to constantly have to be aware of your surroundings in order not to get raped. There is nothing you did, said or wore that could possibly make you “deserve” this treatment.
    Living in Cairo, I know how women are treated as I experience this myself every day. It sucks!
    Still I love this country/city and most of the people in it.
    I hope you are somewhere where you can feel safe and take time to recover. You sound amazingly strong but give yourself time to process, to grieve, to become madder than hell and then feel stronger. Wish you all the best!

  880. it was so heart breaking hearing about your attack last year , devastating … reading it in details now is even more heart breaking , you are one brave woman ,,I know that you have heared those words a lot , but it is the truth .. more than that , you have a free and clean soul
    God bless you … and God punish those who have hurt you or any woman any where in the world … as Egyptian I want to see justice done to those animals more than any thing

  881. this is not lie, for her sake i hope nobody has video of what happened and sexual harassment is never an accident!

  882. you dont believe what happend to her! i am her boyfriend, believe me when i say this happened, she is a dedicated student and you have no idea what would be going through your mind in that situation, how dare you criticise her!!

  883. you dont believe what happend to her! i am her boyfriend, believe me when i say this happened, she is a dedicated student and you have no idea what would be going through your mind in that situation, how dare you criticise her!

  884. I’m so sorry this happened to you, how awful. 😦

    It’s a brave blog, which will make a big difference in helping to fight sexual harassment and assault in Egypt. More and more people are aware of the issue, and many grass roots level groups have formed to combat it (I’m part of a Cairo action group, SHAG, whose Facebook link I can’t post due to some technical problem).

    I’d like to say something about this: “…don’t make the same mistakes. Don’t be swept up in a wave of euphoria. Don’t let anything cloud your judgement. I was not focused enough because I was distracted by the wonderful atmosphere…”. It was not up to you to be on constant full alert against any possibility of danger. It was up to the criminals who attacked you not to pounce on you like a pack of wild dogs. 😦

    It’s my personal opinion, having followed the various incidents of severe sexual abuse in Tahrir, and spent over 60 days/nights there myself as an apparent foreigner, that there are organised “rape gangs” operating in Tahrir, aiming to half the numbers of protesters by making women feel unsafe to go there, and to block independent first-hand media accounts. Male foreign journalists have reported police/military beatings and arrests. That makes no difference to your first-hand horrific experience, and in no way excuses the general terrible levels of sexual harassement and assault all over Egypt. However, I hope it means that the group I’m working with will have some success in catching and unmasking some of the criminals who hurt you.

    So sorry again. 😦

    With all love and best wishes.

    • I wonder how many of these random responses are coming from people who are paid to write them. I’m sorry, but it is soooooo easy these days for anyone to say anything online! The internet is better at spreading lies than the truth. I could write anything here too if I wanted to. It doesn’t need to be true. You are all a mob yourselves.

      • Thanks for the this commentary on critical thinking and reading comprehension that I’m sure no one ever thinks about when using the internet. You’re so helpful. Not. You’re insensitivity is disgusting. Your mob of apathy is shameful.

      • This reeks of someone desperately trying to find a reason for why everyone seems to disagree with him… that the reason is simply that he is wrong still somehow eludes him…

      • Well, with creatures of such insensitivity & ignorance as you around, it makes it very to understand why atrocities are allowed to go on happening! No wonder decent people are afraid to speak out… they’ll be silenced either by the likes of you or your charming accomplices in the streets…

      • for every reported story such as Natasha’s, there are at least 500 that don’t get reported, so stop pretending millions of sick Egyptian men don’t wake every morning with the hope of raping women – they are no different than the repressed Catholic priests who raped children because in both cases these men repressed themselves sexually which creates unnatural and immoral urges. Ironically, these men’s religions instruct them to behave this way in order to control their urges. What a farce. And what baseless and intellectual dishonesty, to pretend this account is false and that it doesn’t happen as often as it does. You are part of the problem, and I wouldn’t be surprised if you were part of the mob.

  885. This was an Ikwan fileld Tahrir. Their lack of respect for women is disgusting, this is what America is backing

    • Oh come on; there’s no proof which political party was behind the atrocity, or indeed, even that it had an ideological element. Even if it had, as others have commented, such issues were used as an excuse for subhuman behaviour. The garbage who could behave like this will use any excuse to justify their lack of humanity…

    • All the sycophants who support ‘power’, however perverted, write like that! Do you follow any of the expat trash who support the regime in Bahrain? That’s exactly the way they write… they try to whitewash the disgusting behaviour of those they support, and denigrate the valid experience of the victims of the oppressors. Nice folk….

  886. As an Egyptian man, I am horrified and ashamed to read this. I am deeply sorry for what you went through, and thank you for sharing the story. This shit has to stop.

    • No he is being realistic. I am a female in Cairo and Westerner and do not for a second believe this work of fiction!
      This is another Lara Logan trying to get attention.

      • John, or who ever you are, you are the very example of the problem. How many times has this happened? Plenty. You are probably one of them.

    • It genuinely hadn’t crossed my mind that, even in the recesses of the internet, someone could be as cruel as this. This is clearly a groundless attempt to dismiss what is without doubt a horrific and life-shattering ordeal. I am appalled at your callousness and intellectual laziness.

  887. I’m so sorry this happened to you, how awful. 😦

    It’s a brave blog, which will make a big difference in helping to fight sexual harassment and assault in Egypt. More and more people are aware of the issue, and many grass roots level groups have formed to combat it (I’m part of a Cairo action group, SHAG, whose Facebook link I can’t post due to some technical problem).

    I’d like to say something about this: “…don’t make the same mistakes. Don’t be swept up in a wave of euphoria. Don’t let anything cloud your judgement. I was not focused enough because I was distracted by the wonderful atmosphere…”. It was not up to you to be on constant full alert against any possibility of danger. It was up to the criminals who attacked you not to pounce on you like a pack of wild dogs. 😦

    With all best wishes.

  888. I’m very very sorry that you had being a victim for our Awful Media , which kept telling people that most of the foreigners in Egy are sort of ” Spies ” :s & the worst that we have many people who believed that it true ! Im sorry again & I hope You can come back some day to complete your Doc 🙂 , You are so Brave to hold on after that (F)

    next time if you need any help You Got a good friend over here !

    My Best Wishes in Your life .

  889. Reblogged this on chloeghv and commented:
    An unspeakably brave account of the experience of a student at my University whilst in Cairo. Please take the time to read this truly heart-breaking account, and send her your best wishes and thoughts.

  890. I’m so sorry you had to go through this horrific experience. Just reading about it makes my stomach hurt. I can’t begin to imagine how it must have felt for you.

    I admire and salute your strength to write this, and to be determined to document sexual harassment in Egypt.

    The problem, ignored for so long, has grown to insane proportions and now I really have no idea where we can start to address it. But one thing I’m sure of is that we really need a unified front to tackle this, to attack it and erode it one little bit at a time, but make SOME kind of progress.

  891. I hope you feel better very soon horrid experience, I really respect your strength and will to recover and continue living. People commenting don’t try to prove a point or prove that not all Egyptians are the same it makes no difference. Just spread awareness violations to foreign and local females. Natasha I just wish there was anything we could do, don’t rush yourself wait and I sincerely wish you a complete recovery.

  892. I am so sorry for your experience. Good on You for writing about it to the world, good on you : )
    I have spent some time in Egypt and lived and worked in Cairo and I am sorry to say but I can’t say I was totally surprised by the story. Horrified, heart broken and saddened but surprised…There is something about the men on the streets there that I haven’t experienced anywhere else in the world. I don’t have a word for them because well animals are nice. I adore Egypt and I absolutely love Cairo and the Egyptian people and I absolutely treasure my time there but I had so many experiences there where I either witnessed or was victim to sexual harassment that I accordingly grew extremely vigilant psychic armour to deal with it. This constant vigilance is unpleasant to say the least, not to mention draining and de-moralising. Anyway, something Absolutely needs to be done about the men on the streets of Cairo. The way they treated you was barbaric and there is no excuse. And again I regret to say but they do this kind of thing to a greater or lesser extent, every day.

  893. I am really sorry that this happened to you, same thing happened to a friend of mine while i was with her…i wasnt able to help and dragged away and groped as well my hijab was pulled off…..its horrible i am reading your post with my heart breaking as i recall everything that has happened so i really know what you have gone through….Thank YOU for writing this and for finding the courage to face it.

    do u remember the date and the time? where exactly on tahrir, we are compiling information to see how we can fight it. also i am working with some men who are working on securing the square and making sure this doesnt happen again.

    again i am really sorry and stay strong..sending you a Hug

    Nihal

  894. I can not say unless you are very brave … And we have to know that the mobs are located in any place, regardless of religion or culture .. And that this does not reflect the behavior of an entire people .. And that any person who does this is not considered humane about anything .. Even if you are a spy and I do not think so … there is no human being deserves to happen to him that … I am so sorry for what happened .. And I’m sure that you have learned a lot from this bad experience ..

  895. First of all, I’m terribly sorry for what happened with you. My country has always been and MUST stay a welcoming country for foreigners, disregarding where they come from or how they look, rather than being a repulsive country where people (especially females) can’t feel safe walking around the streets

    I hope you’re on the right track to recover, and I like your attitude of seeing a silver lining to all this, and also still cherishing the good memories in Egypt and/or Cairo.

    To be honest, I was shocked while reading your post; shocked that this whole thing happened, and that more people were actually participating in such a crime more than trying to stop it from happening..!

    As an Egyptian male (I assure you I wasn’t there during the incident, since I’ve been out of Egypt for some years) I declare this as a disgraceful crime that cannot pass unpunished. I realize it would be impossible to pinpoint all hundreds of men you mentioned above, but something has to be done

    At the end, you’re more than welcome to return any time you wish, hoping that by your next visit, those type of Egyptians won’t still be thinking the same towards foreign females..

    Take Care 🙂

  896. An incredible and brave blog, I was shocked but am not sure how much of an exception this behaviour is. I have lived in Egypt, but when I took my two young blonde daughters to Cairo for what I thought would be a fun history-filled holiday there they had a simply miserable time after being groped and fondled whenever a man thought he could get away with it. Young girls that nobody could have any “misconceptions” about. Anyway that’s a small point after what you’ve been through. Congratulations on keeping your cool, that must have saved your life as much as anything. And I hope Egyptians will confront their men with compelling evidence like yours. My very best wishes for a speedy recovery.

    • I apologize on behalf of every Egyptian man, for your daughters as well as Natasha….we’re are observing an increased rate of this bizzare behavior.

      I think the cause behind all of that is the fact that egyptians have lost a huge part of their dignity, we are missing the most basic concepts of human rights and dignity..

      an egyptian child gets yelled at and beaten almost everyday by his parents or by playmates or teachers, he then grows up to be crushed by the unjust society and inequity of chances, the lack of respect by the government comes in many aspects, mutating the psychology of a typical egyptian citizen from respect to others and public properties, to a constant challenge in breaking all rules and causing harm to people and vandalism to properties,

      behavior like writing on walls or metro seats or breaking street lamps has finally evolved to violate other members of the society when possible, and as a male would fight back, violation is now directed towards women and it became a routine more than a try to satisfy certain needs as some people say…..

      again, my apologizes in behalf of the many respectable men in this society to all victims, Egyptian or not…

  897. Natasha, You can’t imagine my feelings right now! I stopped reading more than twice, i wanted to stop because i didn’t want to believe. And if I said I’m really, truly sorry, it’ll NEVER express how really I’m! And i agree with Shaymaa,This article needs to be translated and published in Arabic. The new president as too much to do about this and he should work on this and removeeee these ads on the national TV and be able to replace the idiots at the top of the State media. I know it’s not the main reason but it helped a lot of ppls to make this as “unreal” reason to attack foreigners because we all knew that we’ve a big problem in sexual and physical attack here 😦 I’m really sorry again 😦 I hope you can be OK soon.

  898. As an Egyptian I am really ashame you had to go through this in my country. Not all Egyptians are like this but let’s face it, it is a very serious issue in Egypt and as long as we’ll continue to treat it like a minor issue, it’ll never change. Nowadays we still put too easily the fault on women: she was dressed like this, she was out late, etc.

    East, West, Arabic, African or European, all women are my sisters and we should all unite to overcome this.

  899. this was not your fault. Not your mistake. As helpless as it makes you feel, you 100% did every thing right. Getting swept in euphoria and all. There is something sick that needs to be challenged and it is not you.

  900. Natasha, Thank you for your post. I really think that there is a cultural “psychosis” about this issue. Women face this type of situation EVERYDAY in Egypt. I am a male foreigner here, and have seen this type of situation up close and personally with my English wife (at the time). It was truly terrifying as a male, I obviously cannot imagine what it must have been like for you. But as the previous comment said, it can happen anywhere, at any time here. What is fascinating AND horrifying is that Egyptian men that I know seem to think that this isn’t happening often, nor is it as bad as its made out to be. It is because they weren’t dressed “properly”, or they were in the “wrong area of town”

    Its tragic that there is this sort of Jekyl and Hyde type of perspective. Ask any Egyptian woman, and she will tell you that this happens all the time, to ALL women. The men seem to want to wish it away.

    I love Egypt, I have lived here for almost 7 years. I have friends here, I have my home here and I have a deep respect for the heart of the Egyptian people. But…. This issue is unacceptable in all facets. It cannot continue. Women cannot be treated as animals, or chattel to be used as men see fit. I cannot see it changing any time soon. its just sad, all the way around.

    So, I hope you use the experience to let others know about this. I hope you push through it and come out the other side, quickly. I hope that it makes you stronger and a better reporter. Most of all, I hope it never happens to you or any other women – Anywhere, ever again.

  901. I am so awfully sorry for what happened to you. as I was reading through, I kept hoping it will be my imagination. I still can’t process this!!! what happened to you is a daily possibility of what could happen to me everyday as I walk down the streets of downtown. I am truly sorry and sad and shaking .. This article needs to be translated and published in Arabic. Do you know that we are still blamed for being sexually harassed in this society? Do you know that fractions of this happen everyday to women and nobody interferes or cares to, and the men who witness that just observe as they walk by being amused? Nothing I will say will make it better or make it stop to any of us here in Cairo. May you heal in peace.. sorry

  902. So sorry. Hope you recover asap!! This will change and thanks for sharing the experience, can’t imagine how hard must have been …. you are strong.

    • It won’t change but for the worse. The world was lied too about Mubarak and was deposed of, and now there is a new monster in charged and he is even more dangerous. This Muslim Brotherhood will strip woman of their rights, it’s coming and they are bringing hell with them?

Leave a reply to Mona S Cancel reply